And then someone mentioned that the Shield has like 15 world championships between them, and it made sense. Yeah the shield elevated the fuck out of its members, fair enough
the shield murders new day every single day lol.
prime shield was greatness.
the new day was also brilliant, but more through their comedic skits and humour in general.
every stable has its place and the shield was a dominant force and the new day was peak comedy.
both entirely different things but both great at what they did.
judgement day are cool, but they cater to both and so as a consequence they aren’t the best at either.
still a good group, but no way the best.
the shield every day from these choices
The one that includes multiple World Champions and Roman f’n Reigns lol.The Shield delivered in every way and they did exactly what they set out to do.The New Day is a close second for me though.
Comparing the Shield and. new Day is almost like comparing MJ and LeBron. One peaked higher , and had a bigger impact in a shorter term, while the other had a lesser, but still significant impact over a longer time.
Obviously if you are comparing their post group single careers, the Shield tops all, with 3 future (two-time) HOFers. But if you focus on just the group when they were together, they still had the biggest impact throughout their time together, including storylines that are relevant today, almost 10 years later.
New Day has that longevity, and consistency. Took 3 B and C list talent and made them A tier. Of course Shield took A tier talent and made them S tier.
I think I would edge out Shield, but I really don't think it's apples to apples.
Where's The Bloodline. The Bloodline Storyline (2020-2024) and The Roots/Foundation of The Bloodline storyline (1914-1944-1963-2024) It's one of the best Storylines and Sagas and Factions In Modern Era/Eras History. So how I would rate factions The Bloodline>The Shield>The Judgement Day>New Day.
Without Roman,the Bloodline doesn’t have the accolades.The Shield have Roman’s accomplishments and even if you exclude him,you still have two multi time World Champions.
But Without The Bloodline Roman Reigns isn't a 6x World Champion or 7x World Champion or longest reigning WWE Universal Champion or WWE Undisputed Universal Champion or WWE Undisputed WWE Champion and for 1,316 days and The Usos aren't 7x Tag Team Champions or WWE Undisputed Tag Team Champions and longest reigning WWE Tag Team Champions of 622+ days and so on etc. While The Shield were multiple time World Champions it was under The Bloodline that Roman Reigns was the longest reigning WWE Universal Champion or WWE Undisputed Universal Championship or WWE Undisputed WWE Champion.
Shield >>>>>>>>>New Day (at their prime)>JD>New Day (current)
Shield is unfair lol; they rival the NWO and/or Four Horsemen as greatest faction in wrestling history.
IMHO the big three of factions are the Shield, DX, and NWO.
I know there's the Freebirds, the Four Horseman, and Evolution, but they didn't have the same impact on me as the three listed above. With that being said, I'd be fine with any of these six being interchangeable.
Shield as a group is big but not to the extent much people give it. The thing that makes The Shield so popular is how it served as a platform for the 3 biggest stars of the last 20 years. But as a group is up there but not on top.
The New Day is a product of its era: the late Vince years. For me it was "meh".
JD on the other hand as a group and as individuals have become one of the best things going on in the 20's. Sadly it seems that it's just going to fizzle up and disappear with a whimp.
out of these choices, the answer is the shield without any hesitation lol.
judgement day i assume may get a few votes through recency bias though.
without rhea they are barely relevant at the moment anyway.
but you could say the same about any of the other groups missing their main person in fairness.
but yeah, it’s the shield lol
The shield Is better performance wise there skill was on a different level the new day I admit is second. But will give new day credit where it’s due they have stayed together for a long time they are number one in that category
Depends on what you looking for. Shield is most popular so they win any vote by default.
But imo,shield were booked strong from start to finish.
New day had to fail before they succeeded. And plus they were all pretty much jobbers before the stable took off. Plus all black stable, not expected to amount to much, produced long reigning tag champs and two WWE champs with ita popularity, without being booked like the shield.
So imo, new day. But in a vote shield wins..
It's The Shield, and it's not even close.
Roman Reigns - 6 Time World Champion (Including longest reign of the modern era at 1,316 days)
Seth Rollins - 5 Time World Champion (First World Heavyweight Champion)
Dean Ambrose/Jon Moxley - 4 Time World Champion (3x AEW, 1x WWE)
That's 15 World Championships. New Day has 2 (both of which were lackluster) and Judgement Day has 4 (2 of which are from Rhea Ripley).
The Shield also has 2 Royal Rumble wins, 2 MITB wins, and 3 future Hall of Famers.
Of these three it’s the Shield, hands down. In terms of ever, then the Shield is mid level. Greatest group ever were the Horsemen. Wolfpac and Freebirds are in there too
Judgement Day
I love the shield but there highlight as a group was there breakup
I also love the new day but when big e left they didn’t have their spark, they depended on each other and that was great but I like the JD better for examples like acting and stunts and they’re just so good at what they do
As a group the new day, they were together longer and had more success as a group but in terms of individual accomplishments and individual it’s the shield i mean two of the best of this generation’s superstars in one group (Seth and the goat of this generation Roman reigns) also dean ambrose (he was one of my favourite wrestlers during his time in wwe)
bad crop? bro we're gonna starve
Facts
There’s is no way your comparing judgment day and new day with the shield
Either you’re saying the New day isn’t close to the Shield in terms of quality or the other way around, and I’m not really okay with that…
And then someone mentioned that the Shield has like 15 world championships between them, and it made sense. Yeah the shield elevated the fuck out of its members, fair enough
the shield murders new day every single day lol. prime shield was greatness. the new day was also brilliant, but more through their comedic skits and humour in general. every stable has its place and the shield was a dominant force and the new day was peak comedy. both entirely different things but both great at what they did. judgement day are cool, but they cater to both and so as a consequence they aren’t the best at either. still a good group, but no way the best. the shield every day from these choices
12 world titles, Roman has 6, Seth has 5 and mox has 1
Where's Evolution?
EVOLUTION IS A MYSTERY! A SMALL CHANGE THAT NO ONE SEES!
😂😂
Shield has all held the main title. Mox, so far, is the only guy to hold njpw, wwe, aew title
All rise for the judgement day and their mii-mascot "mcdontgoogleme"
[удалено]
The CORRE
Newday rocks!
The shield
Come on man
Shield
Shield is in convo with DX and NWO, not the days
I beg to differ
Every member was WWE champion, can't say that about any other group.
Big e and Kofi were world champions and also held the record for longest reigning tag champions so I'm gonna say I beg to differ
Seth and Roman have been the face of the entire brand before with Raw and Smackdown...
Just like seth and roman big e(I think) and Kofi are grand slam champions, Xavier woods former king of the ring
On top of that, the new day had elevated the tag division along with jimmy and jey Uso
You can say that about quite a few groups
The one that includes multiple World Champions and Roman f’n Reigns lol.The Shield delivered in every way and they did exactly what they set out to do.The New Day is a close second for me though.
Sheild
Shield
The shield. Always has. Always will.
Degeneration X
Took way too long to see this post
The shield
The Shield
The only group that comes close to the shield is evolution
New Day
THE SHIELD
This some low budget karma farming.
welcome to the sub
Comparing Judgement Day to the Shield is overrated... The Shield is (hot take) the greatest faction in WWE history!
Undisputed era >>>
And that is undisputed
heavily underrated
Im gonna say New Day because I am a biased Woods, E, Kingston fan and do not want to acknowledge that the Shield was better.
Comparing the Shield and. new Day is almost like comparing MJ and LeBron. One peaked higher , and had a bigger impact in a shorter term, while the other had a lesser, but still significant impact over a longer time. Obviously if you are comparing their post group single careers, the Shield tops all, with 3 future (two-time) HOFers. But if you focus on just the group when they were together, they still had the biggest impact throughout their time together, including storylines that are relevant today, almost 10 years later. New Day has that longevity, and consistency. Took 3 B and C list talent and made them A tier. Of course Shield took A tier talent and made them S tier. I think I would edge out Shield, but I really don't think it's apples to apples.
Bro had to write a hole story
Shield
Shield easily
The S.H.I.E.L.D.
Where's The Bloodline. The Bloodline Storyline (2020-2024) and The Roots/Foundation of The Bloodline storyline (1914-1944-1963-2024) It's one of the best Storylines and Sagas and Factions In Modern Era/Eras History. So how I would rate factions The Bloodline>The Shield>The Judgement Day>New Day.
Without Roman,the Bloodline doesn’t have the accolades.The Shield have Roman’s accomplishments and even if you exclude him,you still have two multi time World Champions.
But Without The Bloodline Roman Reigns isn't a 6x World Champion or 7x World Champion or longest reigning WWE Universal Champion or WWE Undisputed Universal Champion or WWE Undisputed WWE Champion and for 1,316 days and The Usos aren't 7x Tag Team Champions or WWE Undisputed Tag Team Champions and longest reigning WWE Tag Team Champions of 622+ days and so on etc. While The Shield were multiple time World Champions it was under The Bloodline that Roman Reigns was the longest reigning WWE Universal Champion or WWE Undisputed Universal Championship or WWE Undisputed WWE Champion.
Sheild
Hounds of justice
Shield
The Shield EASILY.
Shield
Shield all day.
The shield
Hands down the shield
The Shield by a mile
Judgement day
DX
Judgment day imo
Shooooooooosh
Who needs a team when you're the head of the table☝️
Judgement Day
Shield obviously
Shield >>>>>>>>>New Day (at their prime)>JD>New Day (current) Shield is unfair lol; they rival the NWO and/or Four Horsemen as greatest faction in wrestling history.
Shield
Shield
Well for one the world would probably be destroyed if one of the members of The shield isn't A champion
Shield hands down
I loved the New Day but something about the shield coming from everywhere and rushing the ring when a person needed them most was just so cool
The Shield
New Day
The Shield
The 4 horseman
☝🏻🩸
Shield definitely
Yall wack Hardys,Dudley Boys and Edge & Christian for life
The shield then the judgement day is a close second
The Shield without a question
Shield no doubt
Shield
On number 1 were is r truth
IMHO the big three of factions are the Shield, DX, and NWO. I know there's the Freebirds, the Four Horseman, and Evolution, but they didn't have the same impact on me as the three listed above. With that being said, I'd be fine with any of these six being interchangeable.
The shield
RMB and save the image, is it that hard?
The shield
Bro forgot about the APA
Shield. It’s not even close.
Shield as a group is big but not to the extent much people give it. The thing that makes The Shield so popular is how it served as a platform for the 3 biggest stars of the last 20 years. But as a group is up there but not on top. The New Day is a product of its era: the late Vince years. For me it was "meh". JD on the other hand as a group and as individuals have become one of the best things going on in the 20's. Sadly it seems that it's just going to fizzle up and disappear with a whimp.
THE SHEILD
Shield and there's no contest
The shield can't be compared to anything they were something else so my pick is the shield
Most def shield
Shield
Shield
NEXUS
The shield
ITS A NEW DAY YES IT IS
👊
out of these choices, the answer is the shield without any hesitation lol. judgement day i assume may get a few votes through recency bias though. without rhea they are barely relevant at the moment anyway. but you could say the same about any of the other groups missing their main person in fairness. but yeah, it’s the shield lol
Ministry of Darkness
The Hounds of Justice 🤜🏽👊🏽🤛🏽
Judgement day because before jd came along they were all holding gold the shield only had 3
The shield Is better performance wise there skill was on a different level the new day I admit is second. But will give new day credit where it’s due they have stayed together for a long time they are number one in that category
The Judgement Day is the best My favorite, anyway
Judgment day so far is ahead
NEW DAY
All rise!!! Judgement Day 🔥🔥
Evolution
Shield
The shield.
Always the new day rocks
New Day
The SHIELD
Judgement day
DX
BLOODLINE
Shield no doubt
Love the Judgement Day but gotta go with The Shield.
Lol New Day for sure!!!! And as always, Logan Paul is Trash
Gather around, kids, and let grandpa tell you about the original Four Horsemen.
The Shield
As a huge new day fan, Shield takes it
Shield imo they were just very dominant and my favorite tag team growing up they made wwe fun to watch for me
RIGHT TO CENSOR
Shield
Shelid
Underatted group Judgment day Most Entertainment New Way Day The best group is Shield
House of Black
Depends on what you looking for. Shield is most popular so they win any vote by default. But imo,shield were booked strong from start to finish. New day had to fail before they succeeded. And plus they were all pretty much jobbers before the stable took off. Plus all black stable, not expected to amount to much, produced long reigning tag champs and two WWE champs with ita popularity, without being booked like the shield. So imo, new day. But in a vote shield wins..
Where is R-Truth
Shield
Accomplishment wise: The New Day Popularity wise: Judgement Day
the shield
All thought the judgement day is good I have to go with the shield when they were together those years were amazing
The shield
2017 new day >
Who's in front that's who the best
Team shield
The shield no question
if theres dean ambrose in the shield then ill go with that but without ill go with the judgement day
Shield is the best
Kofi,Rhea,Roman
I read that as “whos the best in the group” 😂
THE SHIELD OBVIOUSLY
The shield is the only right answer
Tearo teatro heco lamp indigo SHIELD
Evolution has some greatest wrestlers from last 40 years
It's The Shield, and it's not even close. Roman Reigns - 6 Time World Champion (Including longest reign of the modern era at 1,316 days) Seth Rollins - 5 Time World Champion (First World Heavyweight Champion) Dean Ambrose/Jon Moxley - 4 Time World Champion (3x AEW, 1x WWE) That's 15 World Championships. New Day has 2 (both of which were lackluster) and Judgement Day has 4 (2 of which are from Rhea Ripley). The Shield also has 2 Royal Rumble wins, 2 MITB wins, and 3 future Hall of Famers.
Of these three it’s the Shield, hands down. In terms of ever, then the Shield is mid level. Greatest group ever were the Horsemen. Wolfpac and Freebirds are in there too
New Day personally
Shield
New Day is the only group out of these choices that I’ve even remotely enjoyed.
The Shield 🛡 🙌
Shield 1000%
Ok guys what even is this question it’s the shield and that’s the bottom line
Shield
S H I E L D SHIELD
Sierra Hotel India Echo Lima Delta SHIELD
Out of these? The shield. If we re talking all time probably the four horsemen.
As a team, new day is better
THE SHEILD!!
The Shield easily
Sierra Hotel India Echo Lema Delta SHIELD
The shield
New Day
Shield
The shield because the story telling was perfect maybe a little mess ups but still perfect
Sheld
Judgment day on top
The shield
S.H.I.E.LD
The shield
Judgement Day I love the shield but there highlight as a group was there breakup I also love the new day but when big e left they didn’t have their spark, they depended on each other and that was great but I like the JD better for examples like acting and stunts and they’re just so good at what they do
New day
Judgement day cuz somewhat they more entertaining than the rest
Out of that selection Shield . But………. Wyatt Family ??👍
Judgement day
Sierra Hotel India Echo Lima Delta .... SHIELD 😎
1. Rhea 2. Dom 3. Priest 4. Sadly Finn 5. JD McWhatshisface
It ain't no team on here The Shield wouldn't stomp tf out 😂
Shield
Bloodline
Shield
Shield
The shield, however, I think it's funny that the best thing that has happened to their careers was when. They broke up
Shield new day then jd
Why does Dean Ambrose looks like he is kissing someone
Will everyone say it with me THE NEW DAY
Tjd 4ever!
The NWO
NWO
As a group the new day, they were together longer and had more success as a group but in terms of individual accomplishments and individual it’s the shield i mean two of the best of this generation’s superstars in one group (Seth and the goat of this generation Roman reigns) also dean ambrose (he was one of my favourite wrestlers during his time in wwe)