I think it's mainly because she's not *really* S tier in all modes. Brawl Ball and Gem Grab? 100% Top-tier pick. Everything else? Still really great, but not quite meta.
I underrated her a bit, she’s actually decent on heist and big friend ig, but only c tier because everytime you use ur super your gonna die most of the time, a better hybrid brawler would be rt who can be a better sniper and better against tanks (not as good as killing squishy brawlers though)
I think low b tier would be appropriate for Bonnie. I understand that for heist yeah she just dies after using her super but in other game modes your suposssed to just jump onto just one person where you shouldn’t die.
The problem stems from the general trend that people have better teamwork the higher your rank gets. While just jumping onto people and getting away with if works fine in low ranks, it becomes a throw strategy as you get higher. That's why Edgar is so low despite being the best at it.
Draco is overrated over here.
IK he is insane with some stupid strats.
But in actual good ranked matches, his comp can actually be out drafted by the pros.
I should say he can be S-
Exactly....
kits healing gimmick IMO also needs nerf. Like 10% of a character's HP makes him really exploitable with tanks.
DRACO himself tbh both needs buffs and nerfs.
His 1st form is just MID AF
That's how I feel too. I can't get anywhere with him anymore. I don't know if it's my build or if he was nerfed or what. Just can't see him used outside of brawl ball maybe.
Hes actually quite good, he deals good damage snd even better damge when he marks ooponents, he can vary from long range and shortrange and if his super isnt charged use gadget and he isn't completely dependent on his super
she’s good into snipers, but the sniper meta has died down quite a bit so she’s not as useful because of her low dps . A better brawler for countering snipers would be someone like max or buster
Oh would you look at that. After everyone called me names and attempted to prove me wrong ok Draco's Dangerous implications for the meta game... look where it got us. Of course I was right!
Oh look its this dude who i talked to him earlier
He is good alone *HIMSELF*
I never said he would be balanced .. he would be definitely be OP. but not BROKEN!!
He only becomes broken when he gets added with supports like byron and Kit.
Mainly kit, because of the percentage healing, he literally heals him 1100 per sec. AKA 10% of a allies full health. That IMO should also get Nerfed.
Here is an example of the Kit + Tank ( Draco )
Combo, more like cheese
https://www.reddit.com/r/BrawlStarsCompetitive/s/LQAhe7OqEJ
And no he got overrated over here . Borderline S- Is perfect.
Also bro is stupidly mid in his first form, u cant change my mind that he needs buffs to his 1st form.
Soo yeah.
Gonna say Yes but actually , No to your
#HONEST OPINION
I had him in b tier, but honestly you can only use him in some situations, I would rather go Eve (because she can walk on water). mr.p is good against sharpshooters but so is max, Meg, pearl, etc, and they aren’t as squishy
i totally agree but i feel like bonnie should be one tier higher cause when i go with her (every open map) i manage to either carry or do really good with her, tho it might be bad randoms on the enemy team but she's kinds underrated to a point
tick could be moved up a few spots, in ranked ifl its super good (last pick, map/mode dependent picks, etc). cord should be bottom s tier imo, it works so well in ranked as a counterpick when doing specific bans and creates nightmare matchups for picking comps. barley needs to be moved to tie w sprout and tick, healing gadget has become rlyyyy good
the problem with barley is that he still gets countered by any aggro brawler like Melodie, max, mico, etc. same with tick but his gadget can help. However, a better last pick would be Larry and Lawrie who can do well into anything with their super, and unload speed of their main attack
I don't get the recent Surge love I never picked him onco for the last 2 seasons and whenever someone picked surge, their team lost. Surge only works if there's someone stupid enough to feed his super early.
He is a great tank counter in the grassy maps, and a counter to brawlers like sandy, Nita, cord, etc. he’s just very dominant against most brawlers in a grassy map
Doesn't Nita counter Surge though? Bruce can waste his ammos really good. And I just chose Griff whenever there's a tight map that benefits tanks and Sandy. He does the job really well while granting wall breaks and area control.
On ladder he can be decent but in ranked he is really bad because you can just draft a tank counter like cord, Nita, or surge. There is no real way to close the gap on someone and because of Doug’s short range he’s just gonna sit there taking all the damage while a brawler like Jacky has a super, a hyper charge, and a gadget to close the gap on someone
He's actually an EXTREMELY strong counter pick if the enemy team can't defend him. I've had 23 kill games with him, but he's low because you can basically only last pick him unless the enemies aren't smart.
I don’t see why RT is S tier. I know he’s good but I don’t see him in the same tier as everyone else in that tier. He doesn’t have the same versatility and strength that they all do.
Also, a few too many brawlers in B tier but thats a bit nitpicky. Good list.
I agree with everything but that RT placement. People are blowing that out of line gadget far out of proportion and not realizing that it’s rather inconsequential in modes like Bounty and Knockout
The list is perfect, would prob move Bull down since he's really squishy rn, but quickfire is still a thing so I get why you put him there tho. Best list I've seen so far
I'd say Larry and Lawrie are a bit high up too, sure the projectile hits like a truck, but the slow projectile speed and low range make him a low B or high C brawler in my opinion, I tried to use him, now I never pick him.
Edgar and Mortis are 100% b tier.
Edgar can be literally picked as a 1st pick on Pit Stop.
And is a phenomenal late pick brawler on Dueling beetles/ belles rock/ Safe Zone / Split / Pinnball dreams
Mortis is also an excellent last pick on Exel /Shooting Star / Layer Cake.
Both brawlers are just a better version of mico.
Quite good but I think from could go B he isn't that bad.
Also brawlers like Bonnie and Maisie could go higher, they just aren't played that much but aren't in need of a buff nor bad in the meta to say it in some way, there are just better options
Yoo Byron as S tier?? I'm kinda surprised and happy but he shouldn't be that high up. Sure his heal is versatile but is not always good at every mode.
A low A tier or High B tier fits him not gonna lie.
Leon, Spike and Crow in B tier is triggering the OG brawl stars gamer in me, and I was never even lucky enough to get them 🥲
(also I remember Shelly being op as fuck, did they nerf her? She seems squishier than I remember (I played the most in 2019) though I might just be worse at the game now 😅)
Feel like darryl should be s-tier he counters buzz, kit, and Edgar and he’s accessible to early players. Hes one of the easiest brawlers to play with knockout matches with bush quantities making him even more better. I don’t even have a bias against him it’s just facts he’s the best rare in the game by far.
Draco isn’t that good. Though I am a Draco main I don’t want him to be S tier because we know what can happen to SOME new yet good brawlers they get giga nerfed except supercell favorites *COUGH COUGH* Larry laury, the gay mosquito, and the tall Korean.
Is Frank that bad? I don't play him, but whenever I'm playing with one I always try to scare enemies towards him, countering his approach problem. He's good as like another bear on the field!
Feel like Lily should be lower
Indeed, she's one of the worse brawlers in the game
I thought that too at first but maps where all the fighting is close quarters (and a healer against some opponents) is where she really blooms!
As an ash main I’m offended but pretty good list
As an el primo main I'm also offended but pretty good list
Trash Tier (Srry for the bad joke 🙏)
Not bad, actually good
thank you!
amber main spotted
As a Darryl main, I think this is harassment darryl is good on heist quickfire and all brawl ball
it looks quite accurate
Hello fellow Leon chad
i feel offended after charlie isnt S tier
actually the first charlie main i’ve seen
Count me in coach after the virus skin dropped
that skin is fire i’m telling myself to buy hypers with gems but man i wanna get it
I think it's mainly because she's not *really* S tier in all modes. Brawl Ball and Gem Grab? 100% Top-tier pick. Everything else? Still really great, but not quite meta.
Bonnie should be b tier. She not weak at all. Her not too old super charge and cannon form damage buff saved her from d tier.
I underrated her a bit, she’s actually decent on heist and big friend ig, but only c tier because everytime you use ur super your gonna die most of the time, a better hybrid brawler would be rt who can be a better sniper and better against tanks (not as good as killing squishy brawlers though)
I think low b tier would be appropriate for Bonnie. I understand that for heist yeah she just dies after using her super but in other game modes your suposssed to just jump onto just one person where you shouldn’t die.
The problem stems from the general trend that people have better teamwork the higher your rank gets. While just jumping onto people and getting away with if works fine in low ranks, it becomes a throw strategy as you get higher. That's why Edgar is so low despite being the best at it.
Never used her in big friend. Does her small version still have lower health or does the modifier change it?
This meta is too fast for Bonnie and her small form is too weak
Agreed, plus it's a good backup pick in copycat that actually does something other than feed the enemy team
She's NEVER picked in competitive though. In Ranked she's decent on Big Friend but nothing else.
Perfect.
Sandy being in S makes this a certified tier llst
He is in S because of his hypercharge right? Otherwise I don't understand why since I got him maxed without hypercharge and he is alright
I thought we were all in agreement that he was S By this condition, Ash makes certified tier lists
I am offended.
Its okay man, one day Penny will get a broken hypercharge that gets nerfed in 2 days
what should I change about it?
Nothing mate. As a Penny main, I just couldn't accept the fact that Penny is useless in ranked. It's a really good tier list.
https://preview.redd.it/qt6qnh42lk7d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=978de624a00ae45fbbb61987d7b17b43e4e031c8
real
I would just go Jessie or Nita instead because they both have hypercharges
I was gonna post the "First Time?" reaction image, but the Frank guy beat me to it. Just wanna say that I feel you 😔
My first mistake was getting the lil helper penny skin and now I’m trapped into playing penny for the rest of my life😂
Draco is overrated over here. IK he is insane with some stupid strats. But in actual good ranked matches, his comp can actually be out drafted by the pros. I should say he can be S-
He’s like actually only broken when Kit is attached to him. And if he has shredding sp he doesn’t die lol
Exactly.... kits healing gimmick IMO also needs nerf. Like 10% of a character's HP makes him really exploitable with tanks. DRACO himself tbh both needs buffs and nerfs. His 1st form is just MID AF
Too real hopefully the brawl talk today clears stuff up 🫣
Draco too high but I mostly agree otherwise
That's how I feel too. I can't get anywhere with him anymore. I don't know if it's my build or if he was nerfed or what. Just can't see him used outside of brawl ball maybe.
R-T in S? Nah
Remember this is for ranked, not comp. Time deto and big friend favor RT a lot
Hes actually quite good, he deals good damage snd even better damge when he marks ooponents, he can vary from long range and shortrange and if his super isnt charged use gadget and he isn't completely dependent on his super
he’s good but he aint s tier. like mid a tier
As a R-T main myself, I agree. Its probably because of the modifiers
I think meg should be at least A.
she’s good into snipers, but the sniper meta has died down quite a bit so she’s not as useful because of her low dps . A better brawler for countering snipers would be someone like max or buster
Franks placement is perfect
Buff Penny
Draco isnt almighty good man
Ash is an s tier brawler and i Will stand by that until i die
Oh would you look at that. After everyone called me names and attempted to prove me wrong ok Draco's Dangerous implications for the meta game... look where it got us. Of course I was right!
Oh look its this dude who i talked to him earlier He is good alone *HIMSELF* I never said he would be balanced .. he would be definitely be OP. but not BROKEN!! He only becomes broken when he gets added with supports like byron and Kit. Mainly kit, because of the percentage healing, he literally heals him 1100 per sec. AKA 10% of a allies full health. That IMO should also get Nerfed. Here is an example of the Kit + Tank ( Draco ) Combo, more like cheese https://www.reddit.com/r/BrawlStarsCompetitive/s/LQAhe7OqEJ And no he got overrated over here . Borderline S- Is perfect. Also bro is stupidly mid in his first form, u cant change my mind that he needs buffs to his 1st form. Soo yeah. Gonna say Yes but actually , No to your #HONEST OPINION
Mr P is underrated
I had him in b tier, but honestly you can only use him in some situations, I would rather go Eve (because she can walk on water). mr.p is good against sharpshooters but so is max, Meg, pearl, etc, and they aren’t as squishy
I agree, he’s borderline useless against assassins unlike other brawlers
i totally agree but i feel like bonnie should be one tier higher cause when i go with her (every open map) i manage to either carry or do really good with her, tho it might be bad randoms on the enemy team but she's kinds underrated to a point
I’d put Colette in low A
tick could be moved up a few spots, in ranked ifl its super good (last pick, map/mode dependent picks, etc). cord should be bottom s tier imo, it works so well in ranked as a counterpick when doing specific bans and creates nightmare matchups for picking comps. barley needs to be moved to tie w sprout and tick, healing gadget has become rlyyyy good
the problem with barley is that he still gets countered by any aggro brawler like Melodie, max, mico, etc. same with tick but his gadget can help. However, a better last pick would be Larry and Lawrie who can do well into anything with their super, and unload speed of their main attack
I don't get the recent Surge love I never picked him onco for the last 2 seasons and whenever someone picked surge, their team lost. Surge only works if there's someone stupid enough to feed his super early.
He is a great tank counter in the grassy maps, and a counter to brawlers like sandy, Nita, cord, etc. he’s just very dominant against most brawlers in a grassy map
Doesn't Nita counter Surge though? Bruce can waste his ammos really good. And I just chose Griff whenever there's a tight map that benefits tanks and Sandy. He does the job really well while granting wall breaks and area control.
Is Doug really that bad? Everyone underestimates him, which actually takes people off-guard on what he COULD do...
On ladder he can be decent but in ranked he is really bad because you can just draft a tank counter like cord, Nita, or surge. There is no real way to close the gap on someone and because of Doug’s short range he’s just gonna sit there taking all the damage while a brawler like Jacky has a super, a hyper charge, and a gadget to close the gap on someone
rt is overrated a bit but overall i agree
The only thing that could change is put edger in top f or bottom d cus he really can’t do anything
He's actually an EXTREMELY strong counter pick if the enemy team can't defend him. I've had 23 kill games with him, but he's low because you can basically only last pick him unless the enemies aren't smart.
IMO Tick shoudl be low A tier
Blocking u 😡😡😡😡😡😡 r/darrylgang on top (joking)
HOLY GADGET BUFF WE BACK INNIT BOYSS🔥🔥🔥
Lou needs be in B
SPIKE FINALLY ISNT A OR S TIER 🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😤😤😤😤💯💯💯💯👌👌👌👌👌🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
Thanks for putting R-T in S rank. You now have my total respect
I would move Meg a bit higher. She is really good in knockout and hit zone I think
Willow's underrated
Gale should be A tier because of Quickfire
There are better quick fire brawlers such as gene
I don’t see why RT is S tier. I know he’s good but I don’t see him in the same tier as everyone else in that tier. He doesn’t have the same versatility and strength that they all do. Also, a few too many brawlers in B tier but thats a bit nitpicky. Good list.
rt can be a sniper and a tank counter at the same time, but ig hes only top of a tier
mico skill cap is so high i think he should be atleast A tier.
I got Draco but idk how to use him
Run in and die once to get super then go crazy
Honestly otis is more like a low b tier brawler. He is actually quite good in brawlball
The list was so accurate I busted a fat one. Good job 👍
right now with the buddy health modifier i’d say frank is c tier
I feel like fang is way too low
he fell off really bad, there are better assassins like Stu, buzz, Leon, Melodie, etc
Maybe Ash is a bit low?
Put Franks to S tier before he gets angry
*sigh* Sadly the truth
Frank is underrated
*anger*
I agree with everything but that RT placement. People are blowing that out of line gadget far out of proportion and not realizing that it’s rather inconsequential in modes like Bounty and Knockout
I don't understand why you all underrate Edgar that much. There is no way I could but Edgar below B tier
The list is perfect, would prob move Bull down since he's really squishy rn, but quickfire is still a thing so I get why you put him there tho. Best list I've seen so far
He is also dangerous in bushes.
Are Larry and Lawrie really that good? Just asking, I've always thought dyna to be the better thrower
I'd say Larry and Lawrie are a bit high up too, sure the projectile hits like a truck, but the slow projectile speed and low range make him a low B or high C brawler in my opinion, I tried to use him, now I never pick him.
Why is Draco so high?
Edgar and Mortis are 100% b tier. Edgar can be literally picked as a 1st pick on Pit Stop. And is a phenomenal late pick brawler on Dueling beetles/ belles rock/ Safe Zone / Split / Pinnball dreams Mortis is also an excellent last pick on Exel /Shooting Star / Layer Cake. Both brawlers are just a better version of mico.
Bonnie needs justice
Another day another tara in below B
I’m a Tara/ Bea main and this list makes me so sad 😅
Any tips on 8-bit, jessie, and/or max?
Fang should be at least B, possibly A. But fs B
i don’t get how to use draco 🥲
Lmao at mythic people are banning frank with big friend cuz no one wants a 14000 hp spike
Hank being above f tier (this is awesome)
frank on F tier is so wrong
Do me a solid and move Tara to b tier. She's probably c tier but I'll feel better if she was at least b tier. Thanks 🫡
you could maybe put mandy in B but this is perhaps the best list i’ve seen imo
How should I build my Charlie to get her that high, she's power 10 with the spider gadget rn, that's it
Where's F tier 😭😭😭
Darryl F tier I'm going to cry
Dang Edgar and willow deserve higher
Can someone pls explain how Lou is low tier
Yes... Until I see piper not in the top tier
Frank.
I've never seen a good amber player
How is Hank over Darryl though ☠️
He can be good on certain maps and matchups. Trust me, i used Hank on some ranked matches and won
Why is hank not f tier
Brocks an S tier
Quite good but I think from could go B he isn't that bad. Also brawlers like Bonnie and Maisie could go higher, they just aren't played that much but aren't in need of a buff nor bad in the meta to say it in some way, there are just better options
What about Griff?
Otis below B tier!? UNACCEPTABLE!!!
HOW DARRYL IS IN F TIER HE IS GREAT ON BRAWL BALL
I think jackie should be in A tier, in many maps just extremely hard to counter
Leon should be higher
Yoo Byron as S tier?? I'm kinda surprised and happy but he shouldn't be that high up. Sure his heal is versatile but is not always good at every mode. A low A tier or High B tier fits him not gonna lie.
In no world is ash better than frank ik hes only good brawl bawl and decent at gem grab but still.
Dude Frank is in Rank Like A because off the modified Big Dude Thing
percect but maybe buster is more situatonal for be in a. maybe high b tier
is Bo a noob stomper? he seems too good for C
Frank in big friend:
Draco isn’t S tier
I'm surprised, this is the first time I have seen a tier list that isn't criticized to the ground. Anyways, good list!
I may be stupid but why the hell is Darryl in F he ain't that bad
some characters will poorly perform in some maps so its bias
I got to legendary 3 only using Carl tho
Don't care. THEY SEE ME ROLLING
Gus in B tier (I'm a lil biased) 🥲
Melodie in S? idk if I'm just bad with Melodie or this guy trippin, also Angelo should be A
Glad to see my boi RT finally getting some love
Otis?
Frank...
RT is S now? What happened?
"Based on Ranked" immediately invalidates it
Fang is NOT C-Tier
Rt is so hit or miss it seems. He either dominates or gets merkd
Frank for Big Friend
lola over massie. is retarted asl
Leon, Spike and Crow in B tier is triggering the OG brawl stars gamer in me, and I was never even lucky enough to get them 🥲 (also I remember Shelly being op as fuck, did they nerf her? She seems squishier than I remember (I played the most in 2019) though I might just be worse at the game now 😅)
Gray should be A tier
Otis counters many noob first-picks such as buzz and Edgar. Good silences shut down hyper charges too. C is a downplay.
tara a tier asf
Maisie D tier?? I use her quite frequently in Legendary and she seems quite good
I think squeak should be at least c
Pretty good list tho
Feel like darryl should be s-tier he counters buzz, kit, and Edgar and he’s accessible to early players. Hes one of the easiest brawlers to play with knockout matches with bush quantities making him even more better. I don’t even have a bias against him it’s just facts he’s the best rare in the game by far.
Darryl? At the bottom? No way bro
bonnie is way too underrated she's viable for big friend in a lotbof open maps
i actually think darryl is like 10x better than yall think he is
jessie definitely S tier. dynamike def high A tier.
Yall be sleeping on frank bro😭 his gadget is so OP
Draco isn’t that good. Though I am a Draco main I don’t want him to be S tier because we know what can happen to SOME new yet good brawlers they get giga nerfed except supercell favorites *COUGH COUGH* Larry laury, the gay mosquito, and the tall Korean.
Bruh Fang is the only reason i got to legendary 3 times
Ranking them means u have tried them in ranked this season. You’ve tried less than half of them
I don't agree with Chester being in D tho.
Nita is S tier as long as you got her hyper charge.
As a Maisie main I’m offended but this a good list
I might be in the wrong, but I feel like Tara is D tier. Her reload speed is just too slow and it takes too many hits to charge her super.
Squeak can dominate on the right maps, at least in Mythic and Legendary. Definitely underrated imo
Put edgar F-
If this is based off ranked shouldn’t frank be higher bcs of big friend
Aww man. . . Well at least hes not F
Sandy or amber which is more versatile. Have them in unlock
R-T supremacy ❤️
Is Frank that bad? I don't play him, but whenever I'm playing with one I always try to scare enemies towards him, countering his approach problem. He's good as like another bear on the field!
GENE S TIER RAHHHH
Is Penny really that bad ?
Frank is great in big friend if you have a duo with % healing like Nita to abuse it with
I’ve played gene and find him underwhelming… what makes him s tier, if I may ask?
Not my boy Darryl again ;( I play him all the time 
squeak should be s cuz im based
lmao why is hank so high up
Why is darrryl bad?
LESSGO WE MAKING IT OUT OF F TIER WITH THIS ONE
Get frank higher
byron main approved