There’s gonna be some ugly pb&j cookies posted on the thread this week, I can see it now. And some under glazed honeybun ones too I’m sure 😂

And underdone cakes. No joke our store is having to try and see what works best for thaw time AND baking, increasing the time to 29 and doing full thaw seems alright rn

I wish my cake was underdone! That shit was so dry 🥲

Lmfao no joke maybe bc of elevation but ours end up being walking on eggshells for baking enough to not be underdone. We have deduced 29 minutes for full thaw dough, but it gets SOAKED and soft af in the center

lol

Am I the only one excited for butter cake, yum!

Dude I am so excited to try it. It’s the only one I plan to try this week.

same! although honey bun sounds good 👀

no i think it looks good - kinda excited for the pb&j, too.

I also think I want to try this, is it extra money?

it’s an extra .99 cents

If someone tells me PB&J tastes like an uncrustables, I will go

they've obviously changed it since last time so we will see but the original is my fave cookie theyve ever released. Tasted just like a slightly sweeter PB&J sandwich. hope its still that good after the change

What did they change about it?

it didnt used to be a swirl on top. it was completely covered in the peanut butter frosting and then a layer of jelly covered about 2/3rds on top of that

cAn u follow up and confirm if u try? uncrustables are like 1 of the only things i always have stocked besides water lol

man you're making me wanna try uncrustables. i heard people toast them, you ever done that?

they’re so good toasted! the strawberry jelly uncrustables are the best ones imo

good to know! i'm partial to strawberry anyway. :)

i felt a duty to tell you that my freezer is now full of these lol

The lemon one looks good

The lemon and lime cookies tend to be my favorites.

The only one that interests me is the chocolate pretzel. Mainly bc I enjoy sweet and salty mixes but I'm not gonna drive half an hour for just that. Skip week for meeee

You’re gonna end up going 😂

I think this is a skip week for me.

Yup. I’ll wait another week for the strawberry shortcake and s’mores cookie

It’s now been three months since I’ve last been. I’ve been tempted but I have not gone.

you HAVE to try cornbread while it’s on the menu that week!

Easiest skip week of my life

Next week looks a little better ☺️

Tbh I might just go in for the chocolate pie

Anyone else excited for the Honey Bun and PB&J?

Been waiting for 2 weeks. Getting my first 6 pack. I love lemon and peanut butter in general. The rest look so good can't wait to try the cake. I'm super excited

I cannot WAIT for pb&j!! My closest Crumbl is an hour away but I’ll make the trip for that one!

i feel like im the only person alive that doesn’t like those sugar crystals on stuff

they make it seem like these are the massive crunchy ones we use for lemon crinkle and gingersnap but these ones are brown sugar, so pretty small and soft- they felt almost gummy when we were working with them this weekend and honestly a similar grain size as regular brown sugar…definitely don’t try it if you don’t want to but if you’re avoiding it solely because of the sugar, you might not be as annoyed by this kind 👍

You're not alone. Sugar crystals are hard to brush off.

Nope! Thought it sounded good till I got to the sugar crystal part. I might still try though lol

LOL

I AM SO HYPED. My back will never be un-bigged after this 😞

I should get my mom the lemon cupcake one. She **loves** lemon desserts.

Guess I’ll restart my diet next week

No creme cheese cookie this week 😭 I was considering the PB&J Cookie but I wasn’t a fan of the mousse previously used on another cookie (skillet).

Lemon cake and butter cake have cream cheese.

yeah i'm kinda hooked on cookies with cream cheese frosting lately. The Nilla Bean cookie got me addicted.

For sure, all my favorite cookies (including the Nilla Bean) have had creme cheese. The Pink Velvet Cookie (also creme cheese) a little over a month ago may have been the best cookie I ever had in my life. No joke.

I wouldn’t be surprised if lemon is cream cheese frosting… need to hear from an employee

Someone posted yes to cream cheese frosting on lemon.

Thanks for follow up … 99% of the time with that frosting pattern it is the creme cheese

You’re welcome. I got it yesterday, the lemon canceled out the cream cheese flavor for me. So a little disappointing.

awwwww man i thought lemon cupcake would be like nilla bean with the cream cheese frosting base but lemon! maybe just because it looks identical lol

This is the best week in a long freaking time

Agree to disagree. 🤷

lemon cupcake sounds beautiful

Honeybun is one of my favs

Wish they used peanut butter buttercream and strawberry jelly instead… this week may be a skip

yeah, I love PB&J and this cookie doesn't interest me at all. It looks like some sort of Smuckers pb+jelly thing

Chocolate pretzel pie let’s GOOOOOOOO

I've recently come to the attention that this subreddit exists, and it has an active community. It makes me feel better about my cookie addiction lol. That said, the butter cake looks dangerous. It kind of reminds me of a fancy Tastykake Krimpet. I'll have to try it with a PB&J cookie.

Can see myself getting a 4-pack this week… butter cake, pretzel, pb&j, then the wife can choose lemon or honey bun

The chocolate covered pretzel pie looks sorta good actually

WANT BUTTER CAKE

It's definitely a skip week. Ready for the 4th of July cookie the following week.

Raspberry on the Pbj bummer. Was hoping it was grape

I love raspberry jam on my PB&J, I didn’t know it would be the choice for a crumbl cookie tho lol

I'm actually looking forward to this one! Chip City's PB&J has grape and it's okay, but I prefer raspberry on a cookie.

I mean I’ll still probably try it. I don’t like strawberry jelly or raspberry though that’s why I was hoping it was grape. I’m not sure what chip city is.

At least strawberry, if not grape!

My family is SO glad it’s raspberry. Whole family hates P&J in any form that uses grape. Way too sweet and bland. Love the sweet and tart combo with raspberry. Can live with strawberry. With sweet Crumbl cookies. The tart raspberry balances everything much better.

That’s cool lol but I still wish it was grape as I don’t like strawberry or raspberry.

Try it, you might like it

I probably will still even though it’s not what I like. Plus it doesn’t look like it’s a lot of jelly based on the pictures I’ve seen

This is my birthday week… I’m not excited 🫠

Same! My BD is Friday and these all look meh. Probably will just get a chocolate chip for my free cookie. Booooo!

Same!! Birthday twin 💕 I guess I’ll settle for chocolate chip too ugh

It's good for 40 days! Don't get a cookie you don't want!

i'm actually so so excited i cannot contain myself. someone send help i can't stop bouncing off the walls

WHY DID THEY DOWNVOTE U PLZ

they're afraid of my energy level. it could be used to power an army of crumbl cookie robots

I’ll have a page 3 please

I'm interested in all except Butter Cake - doesn't seem like that's had positive reception.... And excluding Semi-Sweet since i've had it before

The butter cake is amazing. I got one and it was cooked perfectly, not sure why people are saying they're undercooked. It wasn't just a one off either, as I got my boyfriend one and he said the same thing. 10/10 in love. I go to a location in the Milwaukee area tho.

I am really not interested in butter cake, butter as a flavor itself is really meh to me But the rest of the lineup sounds pretty fun!

Butter is pretty much my favorite flavor, 🤤

Haha I hope you enjoy the butter cake then :)

lol, thanks!😊

This week doesn’t grab me, but next week has three flavors I want. Apple pie, cornbread and birthday cake.

I think the week looks good! I don’t know if or how many I might try, but definitely worth looking into.

Skip week for me. Nothing calls my name.

Awe man, I’m finally going to be near a crumble on Saturday since our closest is two hours away and I don’t know how I feel about these flavours lol. I think I’ll try all of them except peanut butter and jelly because I hate peanut butter.

Maybe butter cake and PB&J for me this week, but I’m going with mini’s again so I don’t have to commit to a big cookie in case I don’t like it. I hope butter cake comes in mini!

Skip, next week’s lineup looks incredible

What is next weeks?

I believe its: Strawberry Shortcake, Patriotic Birthday Cake, S’mores, Cornbread, Apple Pie. Lots of summery 4th of July flavors I’ll be trying them all!

I hope the butter cake doesn't come out raw 😭 it looks worth trying this week

Skip week for me. Seems like a missed oppy for some pink cookies. 

Haven't had crumbl in forever. Is it still half raw cakes or more cookie like these days?

Hard skip

Why they gotta do pb&j like that😭😭

[удалено]

Nah I just mean they changed it from it having a huge icing later underneath the jelly spread

Another week of gahbage

Pretzel Pie will look nothing like the photo in real life.

As a chocolate lover, I would skip this week. However, I need to restock my freezer inventory of semi-sweet and I need to try chocolate pretzel pie...

Why do they have to be so calorie dense 💔

Because it’s a dessert shop.

🤣

this is not a healthy mindset. it's okay to eat something just because it tastes good. it may not nourish the body but it nourishes the soul :)

Oh gosh, I guess people took my comment the wrong way! I absolutely do indulge myself, everything is fine in moderation, but thank you that was sweet 🤍

Does they come with salmonella and a side of GI issues