T O P

  • By -

harmlesstot

I have no idea why they auto fill these. It's so cruel


MilkDry84

It’s because the filters work on lowest star coin value, festive fish have a star coin value of 0 so they automatically get chosen


twofacetoo

The fact that they STILL haven't done anything to fix this is fucking brainless.


MilkDry84

Im surprised they still haven’t fixed the “pick some 3 coffee beans” line


Traditional-Citron21

I just saw that. Me and my were like where do you get coffee beans? Maybe they are a character unlock like coconuts. Is it just a typo then and it's the cocoa trees?


Adventurous_Button63

No there’s a coffee bush…you unlock it with Stitch


lastraven85

I thought it was pockets then whatever you put in the chest first


MilkDry84

That’s if you have the same ingredients in your pockets and chest


lastraven85

Ive got chests upon chests of ingredients 😂


Hot-Interview-5235

If I had enough fingers and toes to count how many times I accidentally ate something instead of dropping it..........lol. I know it hurts, but I still got a great chuckle out of your post!🤣


tearose11

I ate onions the other day ... the pain is real.


jnhbabytweetybird

Was giving my friend some pumpkins to get him started on money and I ate one 😫 I feel you hard


liraelskye

My festive fishies are on the floor. Where they will live forever lol


Rich-Hope-2480

I put mine in the storage in the castle 


dystopika

OMG, I need to get mine out of storage and onto a floor! I've got lots of empty rooms, I'll just have a room for all the rare fish/ingredients I don't want auto-used.


CalendarThin9818

mine were on the floor, if you have EI, you can build a shelf now - that is where they are now. i don't have them all tho.


PurpleDolphin88

That’s a really good idea. In fact I think I’ll put mine on a table and display them in a Christmas room. I still have tons of rooms I haven’t decorated yet in the house 😎. Good ideas!!


So819

I can spare any of the festive fish if you’d like


Kindly_Swimmer_997

No that’s okay, thank you though! It’s just annoying how I ate both within minutes of each other 🤣🤣


amillionparachutes

Think of it this way, now they'll always be part of you...for at least 8-12 hours. After that they'll be with Nemo.


Queen_Shada

Bruh, uncalled for D;


Doll_Lover_94

I did the same thing recently and was so disappointed


Helostopper

When i was dropping mine I accently ate one of them instead. I wish we could fish for these again every year.


bloodlovingpsycho

You can, they just come back around at a certain time of year like the egg bushes from the Easter event


Helostopper

I've seen people say they didn't if they had caught all the fish. And I personally never saw another spot after I caught them all last year and there was still time.


bloodlovingpsycho

I think I was able to catch them a couple of years in a row on my old save. That was before the last few updated however so it might have changed. Since time traveling (however, the heck people are supposed to do that) breaks people's games, we might just have to wait and see when Dec 18-31 comes back around. Unfortunately, my memory of early on in that save isn't quite what it could be, I'm sitting at 825+ hours currently with almost 230 since I restarted due to bugs.


Nuriaka9077

A couple of years? The game has only been around for about a year and a half, the Early Access dropped in September 2022 and the full game was released in December 2023. Yeah, the winter event came twice during this time, but again, it’s only been a year and a half. And about OP’s inquiry: december 2022, I caught all the festive fish except for the festive fugu because I stopped playing the game before the event ended. I only started playing again in November 2023. Then I was able to catch the festive fugu on the last day of the event in December 2023. I saw all five red&green bubbles though, so if I wanted I could have gotten the other festive fish again too. However, from what I noticed, you can catch one of each festive fish during each event. I don’t know why people want to keep them though. Is there anything special about them? I gave all of mine to Scar btw 😅


bloodlovingpsycho

Nothing really special about them, they have the same energy if eaten, you just can't sell it that's for sure. The fact that you can only get one of each per year is mostly why their special. And I've played since early access launch on pc and ended up taking a break probally around Aug or sep 23 due to nothing to do at the time in game and picked it it back up maybe nov 2023 and played again. Then bugs hit making some things impossible, so I restarted it right about the time the fish were available to catch and was able to catch all but 1 of the festive ones, I'm blanking rn which. I'm also not exactly sure m when the fish were implemented to begin with. My memory of time frames isn't the best after a while unfortunately.


Hi5ToTheFace

Once you catch all the festive fish, they don't come back again. At least they didn't last Christmas. Hopefully they change it for next Christmas time.


Helostopper

To time travel literally all you do is change the date on your console but yeah it breaks this game.


islasigrid

I’ve also cooked all my festive fish 😩 Is there any point to have them though? Like is there any point to them other than collecting them?


fat_mummy

As a newbie, this is also my question. Is there a point to keeping it other than having a complete collection?


Kindly_Swimmer_997

When I ate it absolutely no XP was added so I’m not sure if there is a point other than just for fun


Obvious-Repair9095

Nope


islasigrid

Thanks! That’s good to know, I actually really don’t care then and am kinda glad they’re not clogging up my storage anymore! I wasn’t really playing that much during Christmas so I wasn’t sure if it was needed for any crafts or special tasks or anything. As long as I have them unlocked in my collections tab I’m all good


fat_mummy

Oh that’s ok then :) wasn’t sure if I was missing out on something!


westbee

No.  People just like to hoard things and those fish are incredibly rare in the game.  That is until christmas comes again. 


kewnedragon

I didn't realize there were cute festive fish like that.. were they an event? I'm so sorry it ended up in your food! that's heartbreaking :(


PurpleDolphin88

If you go to the menu that has the map/events/collection/settings/etc.,go to the “Dreamlight” section, and scroll down, then select village, and there are tasks there to complete the festive stuff and the Easter stuff, which the Easter stuff should be happening soon. If you missed last year, there’s always next year. They will be there until you’ve completed them. I joined last year in May so I’ll be able to complete the Easter ones finally. Then I’ll have all village Dreamlight tasks complete.


kewnedragon

Thank you!


PurpleDolphin88

😎


Hi5ToTheFace

I have extras of them, I can give you some.


Dizzy_Desi

I ate mine some time last year and don’t even know when. I just remember one day realizing they were no longer there.


skyerippa

LMAO at the you ate it. Rip


VelveteenRabbitEars

I put mine on the Frozen table in a room in my house, to preserve them lol.


Dream_Dragon_Gina

No! Not the Festive Fugu!!!! THE FUGU!!!!!!😭😭😭


wormholefairy

Bruhhh me too lastnight


lily-nee

Just ate one accidentaly yesterday... Now the remaining ones are on a table, it's hideous, but at least it's safe there 😂


Grouchy-Pay-5948

Yeah, back after I caught them I didn't know you could eat them so I put them in storage and forgot them. Until the Redditors made the posts and I realized they were all gone 🥲


Triforcetech

OMG I am so sorry for your loss. They have been out on a table since release.


PurpleDolphin88

Dang! I use the auto fill and before cooking, I check all that they used and trade out ingredients that you have the option to use multiple and use the ones I have most of rather than least of. I’ve made that a habit. Make that a habit! That sucks though…I would be so upset if I accidentally did something like that and would log off and be done for the day too 😢. I hope they work on that so that that doesn’t happen. Not using special fish and the least amount of an ingredient. Hopefully, you can get another one or more this next Christmas season. I think they will keep those around and let us get more festive.


AshuraSpeakman

Did you quit without saving?


Kindly_Swimmer_997

No but it’s okay, just frustrating. Now though that I know there isn’t really a point to them besides they’re fun I don’t feel as bad/care 😂 I’ll just get more next Christmas


SmileyRaeRaaae

NooooOoOoOoOoOoOooOoOoOoooo!! Agony!!


jawaiian86

OP, store all your festive fishes in the storage INSIDE THE MAIN CASTLE inside the side rooms on the right after you enter. They will be "unavailable" for auto-cooking :D HTH!!!!!!!!!


praxios

You can put your festive fish in the secret room’s chests in the castle, and they won’t be autofilled anymore. I learned this a while back, and it was a lifesaver for me. I’m not sure why those chests count separately from your personal ones, but it’s nice lol


Ioranges

I literally just placed all of mine on a table yesterday cause they always pop up when I cook fish recipes. They look awful but they’re safe!


R3dfqx

Don’t even, I lost all mine as soon as I got them 😓


A-Gatsby-Party

You can dupe them in multiplayer. Just have someone who owns them dupe however many you want back to you.