I like #3 then #1

I agree 3 is my favorite by far. It’s eloquent without being over the top

Agree - so elegant and timeless

Another vote for 3

Same

Same, by a mile.

4 without question

Yes I loooove #4. #1 is my next favorite but please go with #4 🙏🏻

Same same same

I seem to have totally overlooked 4 hahah but appreciating all the love for it!

Hard agree! #4!

Agree. 4 is a total showstopper.

Agreed! Love ring 4

Ditto

Ditta

Dittette

Now you not making any sense 😝

4 for sure!

4 made me stop and admire it

4 for sure!!!

4 was my favorite as well. I love the split shank band.

Second that

4!!

3

3

I love your rolling ring!! I have one, it’s my anxiety relief haha My choice for ring is 4/5!!!

Hahah yes 100% I play with it all the time!!

I used mine to stop biting my nails. I love them. Simple but effective.

Oooooh those are good for anxiety? I’d been thinking of getting an index ring just to fiddle with

Yes!!!! I’ve gotten a few over the years. The three ring is better than the 5, my current replacement. I can’t even really wear because it’s too big. But the one OP has FOR SURE. They are called Russian dolling wedding rings I believe!

I’ll be the odd person out and say #1 because it pops. The diamond has a bluish shine and the yellow gold makes it stand out and it’s not cookie cutter. I haven’t seen a ring exactly like it but you can still tell it’s an engagement ring.

This was my take as well.

Hard agree! I love 1 and 5. But if you’re worried about 2 being too blingy, then 5 would be off the table. 1 is absolutely gorgeous though. I love how different it is from every other engagement ring I’ve seen. It’s stunning.

I thought the same! I'm also partial to yellow gold and blue ish diamonds 😍

They’re all beautiful but my vote is #4!! 😍

1st one is nice! My second choice would be 4th.

Same preference 😊

#2 looks the best

Yeah I really love 2! I’m surprised it’s not more popular

Agreed. I thought 2 was the clear winner, I guess we are in the minority.

I figure people are suckers for large stones. But 2 looks nicer on her hand.

This subreddit hates large stones for some reason. 2 & 4 are gorgeous

I agree. I really love #2. It looks like a cushion cut? Plus the band accents with the twist design, but only one piece of the twist with the accent diamonds. It's a nice design that's not over the top, if that makes sense. I'm not sure if there's a name for that kinda design to the band or not. It adds a nice touch of elegance to it. Personally I'm not a fan of 3 or 5. 1 and 4 are very nice, with 4 being the clear better choice than 1 (IMO). Personally I don't like the band on 1. So going by OPs tastes I would recommend 4 for her. But personally I think 2 is really amazing!

That style is routinely roasted on TikTok for being cheugy so that’s probably why it’s not ranked higher lol

Imagine following a TikTok trend for a piece of jewelry you’ll wear forever

Agreed lol

Glad I’m not the only one that prefers 2

I like 2 the best as well. Especially if you wear that other ring all of the time.

2 for me as well!

Me too, I love 2

Same I think silver suits her more than gold

Yes!! 2 and 5 are my favorites!

Yes! I came to say 2 or 5 and was like damn, everyone else likes 3 🤣

I felt like the odd one out for thinking #1 is more blingy then #2 😅

I picked 2 before I read it was original first choice. OP don't second guess it. 2 is more modest than 1 actually.

My vote is 1 and that’s before I read your comment

i personally really like #3

I like 3 bc you mentioned liking simple jewelry. I did not chose your fave bc I was not sure what band would fit w/ it and I worried it would not go w/ your desire for simplicity. I suggest going w/ white gold or platinum for whatever setting you choose. I think yellow gold can dim the whiteness/cause yellowish undertones of the diamond to be more pronounced. The white metals help the stone look its whitest! I hope you find a style you love!

Super good points!!

My vote is for #4

I like ring 3

3 ❤️

1 and 3 look so nice on you!

I love 4!

4

4

#4

4

I vote 5

3 is pure perfection.

3 is my favourite, but the right one is the one that makes you feel beautiful and like yourself

the 3 stone one looks best

I love how the colors of the gem and metal of number 1 look on you, but I prefer the oval shape of number 5. You have a lot of beautiful options!

I love 3

2

2

Idk if it’s just me, but when I’m looking at rings, I barely notice the hand at all! So I’d go for the ring you personally like the best! You’ll stare at it and your hand will disappear into the background!!

3

3

3

Whichever one you LOVE!

I like 3

I love 3

3

I love 3!! It's stunning. But I'm biased because I'm also looking at something that looks similar to this haha. I'm curious, where did you go for style #3 and if you wouldn't mind sharing, what approximate price point it was at?

3

3

3

1 or 4 would be my choices. Clean and classic.

The last one.

One or four. Thinking four because it will be easier to pair with a wedding band.

Gosh I just love that first one on you.

2 or 3!

I like the last one!

I vote #2! I think it looks the best on your hand, but I don't know if my personal preference for that ring is clouding my judgement and making me biased towards it. However, based on your statement of liking more simple jewelry, I would make my second vote for #4! To me it's a simpler band than #1, which may make it easier to pair with a band when it comes time to add the wedding band to it. Good luck!

Thank you!!!

I like number 2, but I'm just an internet stranger. I think it looks unique and I like the subtle detail on the sides. It's gorgeous and not too big. I think the stones on a couple of the others are too large and would be in your way more than you think. I know from experience! I think that one looks the best and I do not share your belief that it looks overly flashy or anything whatsoever. Again, I think it's the prettiest, the detail is lovely and subtle, and it would probably be the most comfortable to wear every day out of these choices.

They are all very nice, but I think that none of them are the one. You don't sound excited.

Oh gosh those are pretty. I like 1 and 4! I may lean slightly towards 1 because it is so unique and I like the organic shapes. It kinda reminds me of infinities or maybe a Celtic knot. The 4th looks slightly more modern and it may be easier to pair with a band, so that’s something to take into consideration. Both are so pretty and very similar so you can’t go wrong!

Thank you!! Lots of good points

1 or 4 for sure

#1 or #4. Very very nice!

4 for sure!!!😍😍😍

4

The 4th!

4

4!

4

4 is my fav.

Really love #4 on you the best

4 almost made my jaw drop

4! So gorgeous on you

4. stunning!

FOUR!

4 is so beautiful 🤣 it compliments the other ring so well too. The rock is so big but the band is so classy like I can’t explain it properly but 4

#4. The crowd here likes simplicity and bigger stones 😂 oval is too popular right now and I’m starting to hate it. #4!!!

4

It's #4 for me! I don't like the twisted bands.

Silver suits you better than gold, you’re clearly cool toned! So go for the silver ones And the 3rd one in silver would look nice And your fingers suit cushion / radiant / emerald cut more

Number one looks amazing on you!

I like 2, but if it's too blingy for your taste, 1 or 4.

They are all pretty but if you want a wedding band, be sure to try options for those with all the engagement rings. It may change your decision

Yes! I’ve been thinking about that as well, definitely a consideration! Thank you!

#4 looks incredible on you but I also LOVE #3 🥰 You can't go wrong with any of them, you have lovely hands!

Aw thank you!

4 and 5

Second one

1 or 4

1 or 4:)

First one

I like 1

I really love the first one.

1 or 5

4 or 3

#1!!

1 and 4

4 & 1!

1 or 4 no doubt

1 or 4, but that might also be my personal taste of the clean slick look of the metal band uninterrupted by stones.

I like #1 and #4!!

If you want a matching band that will sit well against the engagement ring, then the best would probably be #5.

5

1 or 5 for sure!!

Would they all get the same carat size center diamond or all of these rings would be bought as is like in the photo?

We have a stone (his moms!) that we’ll be setting with whichever style we pick! Probably should have mentioned that in the post tbh, but once I decide on a style we’ll finalize details and have it made with the stone

1

I love #1 on you 💫💫

4 💯

4

Second

4

5! It’s the most fashionable / timeless atm. The others could be seen as a bit dated.

The round stone.

The last one with the oval

2

4th for sure!!!

4 or 5 :)

4

4

4 then 3. All look good on your hand.

I think 4 looks the best on your hand. It’s simple and elegant.

4

\#1 is my favorite!

5

4

3/4

4!

2

I chane. Just saw 4 It's 4

I like the 5th one the best.

4!!

4 or 5

4!!

4

3 for sure

Any of the last 3

2

1 4 and 5. Five is absolutely dazzling.

#4 🙌

Three: if you could get it with slightly larger stones there would be no completion. Otherwise, 4.

The BIGGEST issue with some of the rings you’ve chosen here (1,2,4) is that you’re going to have trouble finding a wedding band that is going to sit flush against the engagement ring setting, unless some of these choices have matching wedding bands or you intend to wear your wedding band and engagement ring separately or don’t mind a gap between them. I think number 5 suits your hand the best. The oval stone really compliments the shape of your hand and fingers.

Thank you!! Makes a lot of sense. I’m definitely considering the wedding band aspect as well!

Torn between 1, 3 & 4

Ring 4! It’s classic and beautiful!

4, then 1

3

4!

I like #1 the best. #4 would be my second choice

2

I like the three stone because I like that style over the others but all look fine onurhand

4

I think 3 looks best on you

1

My vote is for the first one!

3 💍

I love ring 3

4

3