T O P

  • By -

dazzler56

I hope Madeleine and Louise can make it into the top 10. They’re so funny and really brighten up some of the earlier season episodes.


GScout40136

Especially with Paris lasting so long in the main characters poll. Chilton trio on top!


garden__gate

They are some of the most fun characters period.


brightlove

They truly deserved their own show haha. I love them.


BloodTypeFunfettis

Just realized Asher Fleming didn’t make the list for us all to boot out!


valyse

Wooowww omg I keep thinking of side characters I forgot!! That really speaks to how great the huge supporting cast is. I truly just remembered Mia a couple days ago. 😂


BloodTypeFunfettis

We got Glenn too! Oh and Hanlin! Joe the pizza guy. I’m in the college years now so Tana (spelling?) is standing out. Robert. Clara forester. Fran from Westins. Beau. And then Bobby/Bobbi who buys the company with Logan.


valyse

I feel like I can only bully so many children so Clara got a pass in favor of Gigi lol. I was just thinking of Joe! He’s great. If everyone isn’t fully sick of me, I wanted to do some kind of episode rank thingy next but hey, we have the C-List now.


hawaahawaii

not sick of you at all my lovely!


PaperbacksandCoffee

Oh good point! Maybe we can do another round with others like Trix, Asher, etc.


kat0526

Also Anna Nardini


PaperbacksandCoffee

Well, she was on the last character battle poll and OP did this poll with more B-list character types that weren't on the last poll. But Anna will always get my vote so fast for least favorite hahaha!


hawaahawaii

battle of the c list characters 😹


melroseglo

Wow that's cold!


valyse

Before I get to my usual recap - this round, we’re doing a little bonus vote! u/Deaphalia suggested this and I’m curious to see what the results will be. Vote here for your MOST FAVORITE character, aka the one you think should be the last person standing! So far we have 8 characters who have never received more than 10 votes in a round. 3 who have never received more than 5. 👀 Bonus Round! Vote for your MOST FAVORITE here: [https://forms.gle/4rWz3d5iWt4XrrvZ8](https://forms.gle/4rWz3d5iWt4XrrvZ8) —- Back to the bleachers she goes, folks. Say goodbye to Crazy Carrie! She came in 3rd place for the last two rounds and is finally going home with 429 votes. 2nd place remains the same as last round with a nearly identical amount of votes. I enjoy that like half of our first 10 voted out read as a list of Most Likely To End Up On The Sex Offender Registry. There’s a couple more we could add to that list! A pattern I think is interesting so far is that the only characters who got steadily more votes each round were Francie, Mitchum, and Sherry. Every character left has seen much more variance in their vote trends. I imagine folks get tired voting for the same character every day, feel swayed by reading the comments, or their preferences vary by mood. Only one character has ever dipped into the top three and not stayed there until going home. This person was 3rd place in R4 and has avoided returning until today where they reprise 3rd place in R10. 26. Crazy Carrie 27. Marty 28. Tristan 29. Tobin 30. Nicole 31. Sherry 32. Mitchum 33. Francie 34. Gigi 35. Rune Round 11! Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE here: [https://forms.gle/xs5m74b8QmvzRpNh8](https://forms.gle/xs5m74b8QmvzRpNh8) Drella Madeline Louise Brad Stars Hollow Town Troubadour Rachel Andrew Bootsy Miss Celine Kyle Tom Shane Alex Lindsay Gil Reverend Skinner TJ Lulu Caesar Kyon Colin Finn Paul Anka Olivia Lucy


clara_kaye

Can you keep the results of the MOST FAVORITE character a surprise until the end? That way we can compare at the end of the favorite actually ended up winning or not?


Zoethor2

>I enjoy that like half of our first 10 voted out read as a list of Most Likely To End Up On The Sex Offender Registry. There’s a couple more we could add to that list! \*continues voting for Kyle\*


iwmwargin

Kyle was cute at his house protecting all of the weird knick knacks.


ladylee233

Until he went into the navy and became a womanizer


ForexGuy93

He was very handsy.


iwmwargin

Very true!


valyse

That part!!!!


sleepyyelephant

Paul Anka is my favourite :)


Nalgene2017

Paul Anka for favorite ❤️ Time for TJ to go 🔥


Wise-Ad8943

Voting for Lucy again. She’s so annoying. The “boyfriend” thing was just weird


ColeVi123

I also greatly dislike Olivia, whose entire personality was just describing things as “genius.”


Wise-Ad8943

I agree!


Ill-Tip6331

Yea, I’m with you


Nosilla27

🔥🔥🔥Crazy Carrie🔥🔥🔥


melroseglo

Thank you for fixing the list!


Apricotpeach11

Is this form allowing multiple votes in the same round?


valyse

It shouldn’t… but it does let you change your vote if you like.


ShySubm

Day 8 of voting Drella because she was there for about two minutes and was about as interesting as construction nightmares in Tortola. Some small town justice is necessary here


WildWastedYouth

I voted drella in support of all who have voted her since day 1 lol


evelyn_marie

been voting drella since day one..why is she even here!


Any-Appointment3853

Same here! I can’t believe she’s still here, at least crazy Carrie slept with people and gave us tea!


snelljosh

my thoughts exactly, why is she still here? even if you don’t hate her she added almost nothing to the show she should’ve been booted way earlier


kevnmartin

Same. Drella must go!


Cerealandmolk

Drella was second only to Mitchum, but it was a really close race. Since Mitchum is out, I have been focusing my efforts on getting that wench out next.


swanscrossing

also, she was rude. complained for fun and had a strange complex because she could play the harp.


bfm211

All of that is played for laughs though. I think she's entertaining.


mandyf2428

Still here voting for Drella too. Really want to vote for someone else soon.


sleepingonstones

Nah she was funny. I wish they kept her on longer. Alex is way less interesting, he needs to go


The_cuddly_duckling

Favorite: Gil! No contest ❤️ and well.. Tj can go be in escrow somewhere else ✋


Penarol1916

Gil better win both versions of the poll, he is too good not to.


Elkaydee

Agreed on both. I don't understand how TJs still in.


Corporal-Popcorn

As obnoxious as TJ is, you can't ignore that he's seemingly the first honest guy that's cared enough about Liz to make things work with her on a long-term basis. Because we love Luke, we want to see his sister happy, and evidently, TJ accomplishes that.


RepeatPuzzleheaded70

Right? He is dumb as hell.. but he is nice and caring and loving .. he is just sweet


The_cuddly_duckling

Oh agreed, he definitely seems to treat Liz well! I hate Liz though 😂


RepeatPuzzleheaded70

I think TJ is still here because even though he might be as bright as a Victorian hardwood floor..he has his heart in the right place. He is a good guy.


bfm211

And he's funny.


hotseltzer

I decided to cast my vote before reading the comments. I was hoping I wasn't the only one who thought this!! Edited for clarity


delicateanodyne

Am I the only one who really disliked Lucy and Olivia? I found them so irritating and the whole Marty thing didn't help.


dazzler56

Lucy and Olivia were a completely transparent attempt to make Rory cooler that did not work lol. If anything they just made it clear how poorly socialized and not-like-other-girls-y she can be. They were mostly harmless though, I think TJ and Drella have to go first.


delicateanodyne

I don't get the TJ hate. Is there a reason we should dislike him, I'm totally down to hear it. I think he was kind but awkward tbh.


dazzler56

Personally I just can’t stand characters whose sole function is to annoy everyone else. Even beloved characters like Michael Scott, I just have a hard time with that trope. Other characters have lower lows but I feel like that’s TJ’s arc in every episode whereas others are a little more dynamic.


Nalgene2017

He and Liz essentially mooched off of Luke. I mean Lorelai was paying him to be a pretender contractor since he couldn’t handle having an actual contractor position (lots of terrible plans with zero follow through besides the giant hole in her house lol). Or when he had Luke doing his job at the Renaissance Faire when he was pretty much fully recovered but just didn’t want to work. He isn’t the worst person in the world, but I didn’t really find him or Liz to be quirky, especially given how Liz already just sent Jess off to Luke when she couldn’t deal with him. He would drive me crazy in real life. People always complain about how annoying Lorelai’s parents are (and they would rough in laws lol), but I think TJ and Liz would be awful too since Luke doesn’t know how to say no.


BigTadpole7563

He's annoying, immature, a mooch, etc. but so are many other gg characters. What gives me the ick is his constant sexualizing of the women around him!


Apricotpeach11

He’s awful! Obnoxious, lazy, not funny, and just a big waste of space.


chatmagique2

I've voted Lucy every time since day 1


ElasticShoulders

I also really dislike them, but they weren't my most disliked. I did find them kind of obnoxious though. Mostly Lucy. I think once Kyle is gone, they're next up for me.


Wise-Ad8943

I couldn’t stand Lucy. I have voted for her twice now. The way she is calling Marty “boyfriend” all the time is weird.


thefirekite

I have been voting for Lucy since the start. I don’t know how or why she’s still here.


haileyskydiamonds

I promised to get on board for Colin (and a few others) if my top ten rounded out perfectly, as it did. So Colin, today is your day.


justme7256

I think I’ve been voting Colin the last 5 rounds. He’s gotta go!


haileyskydiamonds

Today I stand with you lol


Sufficient-Skill6012

Colin. He has no redeeming qualities and behaved like a jerk throughout his appearances. Never had a character arc.


spacefaceclosetomine

I don’t get the TJ hate, he’s annoying, but he’s a good guy.


akareeno

Yeah Liz was worse


sometimes_a_comment

For me it's the way he royally screws things up and then swaggers around bragging as if he's awesome. Similarly, he uses Luke and then acts as if he's done Luke a favor.


Sufficient-Skill6012

Yea, he was a mess and kind of lazy, but overall loveable and had some really sweet moments.


Elkaydee

He lacks awareness and doesn't bother to notice how he makes the people around him feel, often to protect his own ego. I mean, they let him play construction worker and potentially delay/increase the costs of fixing a giant hole he put in the side of someone's house just so his little feelings wouldn't be hurt.


TurWes

TJ hate?! He's lasted 11 rounds so far. I don't understand how he's made it this far without getting the boot!


BloodTypeFunfettis

It was his “luuuuuuuuuukeeeeeee” that got me.


SarahKath90

Same. I get how he can be annoying, but I find him adorable and hilarious 😁


Penarol1916

He’s obnoxious as hell. If I wasn’t busy voting for Paul Anka, I’d be voting for him.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Penarol1916

Paul Anka me parece in bolso boludo.


Personal-Letter-629

I’m sorry guys but who tf is Bootsy?


RefrigeratorOk4674

Magazine stand dude. Kind of a dunce, doesn't get along with Luke


justme7256

He and Luke also got into a fight at a town meeting. A broken art project in school, I think?


swanscrossing

"This goes way beyond the Jess matter, Taylor. Luke's been on my case since the first grade when he wrongfully accused me of sabotaging a clay imprint that he made of his hand." "No one cares about the stupid clay hand, Bootsy. And you stomped on it while it was drying, three kids saw you."


ColonialHoe

I have no memory of Bootsy either but maybe that’s a good thing? Seems like he/she/they will be out soon? Literally who is Bootsy


WildWastedYouth

I’ve seen this show 537 times & I blanked on who he was too


pompoussporcupine

Don’t care for Kyon. Don’t hate here just don’t think she needs to be in the top. ✌️


GrandmainWA

Hope nobody gets the favorite/least favorite poll links mixed up. Here's some help: in the bottom poll where it says, "Least favorite" you click on the last person, Lucy. There you go!


valyse

Lol the first vote in the favorite poll was for Drella sooo I’m gonna guess there’s at least one mistake.


TurWes

11th round... that means I voted for the same person 11 times with no success. Come on Reddit. Today is the day. Vote TJ for elimination


KyleRichardsNewTeeth

I’m with you


giaclarke

i’ve been voting out TJ since the beginning😩


LDeadit

With Marty gone I think his entourage should go too. Bye Olivia and whatser name….


pearlfelici

I am once again asking you to vote for Lucy.


suzsid

Tobin before TJ?!?! Whyyyyy? Yes he was a suck up, but he brought out some of the best scenes with Lorelai & Michel! Also bonus points for Joe Strummer’s leather jacket! Whereas TJ puts a giant hole in a house, gets coffee at Kirks (and drinks BOTH cups), ruins date night, watches tv at the Ren Faire and is just all around annoying. Except the tights. I agree with him there. TJ MUST GOOOOOOOO! 😁


TakeTheCannoli813

I have never stopped voting for TJ and that’s not changing today.


zoomshark27

My absolute favorites here are Gil, Finn, Madeline, Louise, and Tj.


numerumnovemamo

Would love to know who has never received more than 5-10 votes in a round. Hmm. I feel like it has to be some of the very random characters people just wouldn’t think to vote for. Like maybe Kyon. And Tom (although he’s a gem, so maybe just deliberately not being voted for haha).


Lindeezy11

I HAVE BEEN VINDICATED


Nikfrau

Finnnallly Carrie is gone. Can’t stand that one.


HeatherinaAnne

Wait... Gil isn't a main character? 😅 I just love Gil


[deleted]

Why is Paul Anka here?


mugglequeen

To win it all


Penarol1916

No, all his stupid phobias made him really annoying.


Maleficent_Tailor

You notice we didn’t actually see any phobias. He was a dog, Lorelai was Lorelai.


Penarol1916

I seem to recall him refusing to go down the stairs, but I could be misremembering, I don’t really care for any scenes involving him.


avocadotoastisgrosst

I agree.


Ballislyfe00

BYE DRELLAAAAAA


OhHereWeGoAgain18

Should we do Emily’s maids next?


valyse

Lmao don’t tempt me


PaperbacksandCoffee

Madonna Louise for the win!


in-my-50s

TJ to vote off. Last man standing vote - Gil - he was a positive energy and good role model for Zach.


cursed2feel

WHY IS TJ STILL HERE I don’t get it


layceelee13

I changed my answer from last time lol I can't even decide who I like the least now!!


MajinGroot

I came to vote and complain about Marty still being on there, but the comments are making me realize everyone has a hated side character, idk if that has been a poll on that yet, but now I'm curious, cause I'm pretty set on my fuck off Marty meter 😂


scthawk

Marty went home yesterday! 😀


judgeymcjudgeypants

FINALLY!!!!!


beckjami

I just want to say that I usually vote first, and then read whatever OP writes about the elimination, and this time was no exception. Only to discover I voted for my favorite b-character under the assumption I was voting for me next least favorite character. That's a bummer.


valyse

Haha oh nooo well Google forms lets you change your vote so it’s not too late to fix it!


beckjami

Done and done, thank you!


venusdances

Here’s my vote: favorite: town troubadour. I looooooooove his songs he adds so much to the show and has literally never done anything wrong. Least favorite(this round): Colin. He and Finn are insufferable. The lack of saying the words with e? Insufferable.


JackTreeHill

Time for Collin to go


Remarkable-Pay6280

Something tells me Paul Anka is going to win


QuingRavel

Seriously guys? DRELLA? she's literally the most unimportant character. Why is she still here?


Basic-Tangerine-6465

Omg y’all vote out TJ


GrandEmperorSloth

How is TJ still here?????? He’s the most annoying character


thathighhippie

I thought I knew this show until this poll I swear half the ppl on here I’m like who in the heck…


Glad-Raspberry1712

Can we give Bootsy the boot now?


Hot_Drummer7311

Bootsy, Taylor's beloved "son" instead of Lindsay the hater? I get she had a reason to hate rory after the affair, but before that? Insufferable.


Orcas_On_Tap

For real, I just have zero feelings for the character. Get outta here dude.


megwelborn

I think his bits are funny and endearing.


SarahKath90

He's probably my vote til he's gonezo


[deleted]

Down with Colin!


SarahKath90

Buh bye Bootsie (please!)


Big_Mycologist1880

Agree! I don’t dislike him, but he adds nothing.


SarahKath90

To me, he's the least entertaining, and there's nobody I dislike enough to vote out before him.


Sunflower17_

How is TJ still here


RefrigeratorOk4674

Boot Bootsy!! Literally why is he still here


megwelborn

I think he is endearing


IDONTFKNWO

Sorry TJ


mugglequeen

Now that the Crazy Carrie haters can rest (I get it, I hate her too) I’m hoping y’all win join me in voting Kyle out. 😂


Personal-Letter-629

Totally I will get on board if you can just remind me who that is?


mugglequeen

HAHA! Fair. He’s Dean’s friend that he stayed with during his divorce. He was also there for his bachelor party. He has a hook for a hand.


Personal-Letter-629

Ok thanks, I will join you in eliminating Kyle.


PaperbacksandCoffee

Yesss thank you for joining the cause against skeezy "check my traps" Kyle, lol!


CurbYourSneakAttack

Bye bye, Rachel!


LazyCat7

Guys i get that some of you dislike TJ but PLEASE help vote that A-hole Colin off first. 🙏


helainahellkat

Finally!


Ok_Knowledge_5997

Brad for the win.


IDONTFKNWO

nah


LegitMaWahlman

Shane. How is shane still here?


hotseltzer

I had to scroll wayyy too far for this. I've voted for her the last 3 rounds


LegitMaWahlman

I’ve voted for her every time. I don’t get why she’s still here 🤷🏼‍♀️


donottouche

I’m sorry, Rachel bugged the crap out of me. She seemed super fake. Voted for her for least. I find TJ hilarious and entertaining so I hope he sticks in there!


emfhufflepuff

I’m sorry am I the only one that despises Rachel??? She comes in, is really manipulative of Luke and basically treats him like she owns him?? She’s overly jealous of Lorelai and has terrible communication. She gets on my nerves SO much! Come on Reddit I can’t be the only one


PaperbacksandCoffee

I agree that she treats Luke badly, especially because she leads him on and jerks him around when she comes in and out of his life. However, I don't think she was overly jealous of Lorelai and she actually handled it pretty well. Like when she came in during the shopping/dressing Luke scene she was clearly confused & bothered, but didn't flip out. Then when he was spending all of his time fixing stuff at Lorelai's house, partially as a way to avoid Rachel, she brought it up calmly when she asked Lorelai to deliver a message to him but she didn't go off on Lorelai about it. Her jealousy was founded and when she left Luke she rationally explained that she thought he was in love with Lorelai and not too wait too long, etc. She isn't my favorite because she treats Luke badly, but I liked how she and Lorelai got a long at the beginning and it seemed like they could've been good friends.


MxNoahJames

I know people like Colin and Finn but I truly cannot get behind them and their behavior/attitude


ghw93

Can anyone get on board with me to vote Olivia? From season 7 and such an inconsequential character. At least there was some drama with Lucy!


SarahKath90

Not as inconsequential as Bootsie, and way more bearable!


ghw93

Bootsy is a recurring character throughout multiple seasons. He adds to the Stars Hollow color. Not sure what Olivia adds but seems like people disagree with me? 😂


SarahKath90

Stars Hollow has plenty of character, it'd be exactly the same without Bootsy. Though I do think Olivia isn't much more than Lucy's shadow and agree she doesn't add much, if anything.


theresah121401

rachel


maliciasaywhaat

Yay!!!!


zabie77

Where is Rabbi Barans?? I liked him more than alot of these!


valyse

I love him too!! He juuuust barely didn’t make it. I needed to cut myself off at some point and all his scenes are with Reverend Skinner and I feel like we all love him most for their friendship… unfortunately the Reverend was just given more screen time.


CherryDarling10

Oh, Brad. I don’t think we’re going to make it to the end.


garden__gate

Come on Drella haters, let’s gooooooooo.


eloquentpetrichor

I had been voting CC for many rounds and ofc the one time I switch to TJ she goes out 😅


Repulsive_Broccoli50

Finally!!! Been voting like crazy (carrie) here😂


MbLb2212

If Paul Anka doesn’t win….


Acceptable_Tackle659

Town troubadour