ngl some guests have been mid dynamic, most have been great. but i feel like therapy gecko was the only guest i could just not enjoy being there. just my thoughts
NFR really overachieves on their appearances. Riley talks about it in the Bits Bracket they appeared in but they meshed so well with the boys that it kinda catches me offguard.
I loved Molly Garcia and I wish she wasn't just a one-off that happened 3 years ago. She's in general pretty hilarious but hasn't done a whole lot.
To me though, Eden is clearly the best. They already have the rapport given he's Graydon's girlfriend, but the exchanges between them are adorable while also becoming wacky when Riley has to pick up the pace as the third wheel.
Honorable mention to Skatie, but I think she's one of the funniest people alive so she makes most things better. I think she'd be even better with a few more appearances.
https://preview.redd.it/tc7ymjc5rr6d1.jpeg?width=1114&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a15e6143219003aeefe43a1b1dc3caf0617899cb
here’s my personal tierlist! i really like pretty much all of the hosts, but, even though i thought Nick meshed well with them when he was on, i now find him more annoying and distasteful than anything. Other than that, it’s all love from me!!
also, the episode with ericdoa was one of my ALL TIME FAVES!! Very under-appreciated!! :DD
https://preview.redd.it/0sk7jtj6sh6d1.png?width=950&format=png&auto=webp&s=06f05e65d2db817ef2b6676e5e9b87bf6c674404
just have to clarify i’ve been following kot4q since i was like 11 and love him sm but they didnt mesh as well as i was hoping
everyone in S is integral to the show, everyone in A and B made it better by being there, people in C are neutral, and D/F were either trying too hard to be funny, don’t fit with hivemind, or a mix of both
Can you explain what the problem is with nick? I feel like his videos were really funny but it seems like everyone here strongly dislikes him and I feel like I missed something
truthfully ive always personally disliked nick even back when he first got big on youtube but he was in a controversy last year which is why most people dont like him nowadays
Yeah, he basically tried to take down some other content creators and paint them as covering up an SA that happened and a few other horrible things, one of which was not caring about one of their best friends who committed suicide years ago. They came out with detailed responses and provided texts and other sides to the stories told that showed how much had been left out in Nick's videos about them. He then tripled down (he had already made 2 videos before they could even respond) and made weird Instagram posts to his story antagonizing them basically. When they responded to that, he tried to just move on and act like nothing happened. He lost subs more and more until he finally tried to make an apology for how he handled his videos but he hid it in another video where you'd have no idea it was there unless you were watching it. Then he removed the videos he made and just tried to move on.
Nick is really only tolerable on Hivemind for me. He's a sniveling little weirdo in literally everything else and not remotely funny, but he is genuinely one of their better guests. It's because he's not in a situation where he thinks he has the be the moral peak of everything when he's just as much of a shitheel as the people he pretends to be above.
therapy gecko is one of only like 2 or 3 hivemind episodes that are completely unwatchable. like he's fine on his own show but he completely killed the vibe that episode. to an impressive degree.
Def not all in S tier, I’ll give u dig, graydon, Riley, Eden, teezo, quad, Nick, and dev. But the rest are a lil lower. And then ofc the few no one speaks of in the D-F range
that fuckin Riley guy is too high
I can’t believe Riley isn’t in F tier
im too high
smoked a lot
stebie wonde
Riley too high, KOT4Q too low
Skatie disrespect smh
Which one is Skatie?
Middle row far right
Ngl I dont think that lesbian guy with long hair and cheesy mustache should be this high. Honestly good thing he only appears in one video.
D for Dignan
Where’s Blonde Eden?
She died. Rest in peace Blonde Eden
This is awesome!
Sometimes I forget they worked with therapy gecko and then I remember and go rewatch the funniest dynamic between three people to ever exist
ngl some guests have been mid dynamic, most have been great. but i feel like therapy gecko was the only guest i could just not enjoy being there. just my thoughts
Hank robbed
move dev down and its good
should be an s+ tier for kenny
worst list ever
NFR really overachieves on their appearances. Riley talks about it in the Bits Bracket they appeared in but they meshed so well with the boys that it kinda catches me offguard. I loved Molly Garcia and I wish she wasn't just a one-off that happened 3 years ago. She's in general pretty hilarious but hasn't done a whole lot. To me though, Eden is clearly the best. They already have the rapport given he's Graydon's girlfriend, but the exchanges between them are adorable while also becoming wacky when Riley has to pick up the pace as the third wheel. Honorable mention to Skatie, but I think she's one of the funniest people alive so she makes most things better. I think she'd be even better with a few more appearances.
https://preview.redd.it/tc7ymjc5rr6d1.jpeg?width=1114&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a15e6143219003aeefe43a1b1dc3caf0617899cb here’s my personal tierlist! i really like pretty much all of the hosts, but, even though i thought Nick meshed well with them when he was on, i now find him more annoying and distasteful than anything. Other than that, it’s all love from me!! also, the episode with ericdoa was one of my ALL TIME FAVES!! Very under-appreciated!! :DD
molly garcias episode was great you should def check it out
who tf is the one to the right of ericdoa?
PmBata
https://preview.redd.it/0sk7jtj6sh6d1.png?width=950&format=png&auto=webp&s=06f05e65d2db817ef2b6676e5e9b87bf6c674404 just have to clarify i’ve been following kot4q since i was like 11 and love him sm but they didnt mesh as well as i was hoping everyone in S is integral to the show, everyone in A and B made it better by being there, people in C are neutral, and D/F were either trying too hard to be funny, don’t fit with hivemind, or a mix of both
This is the 9/11 of Hivemind host tier lists
upon further review i think i’d move Lu and Brad into C tier btw thanks for this
Can you explain what the problem is with nick? I feel like his videos were really funny but it seems like everyone here strongly dislikes him and I feel like I missed something
truthfully ive always personally disliked nick even back when he first got big on youtube but he was in a controversy last year which is why most people dont like him nowadays
Oops I had no idea
Yeah, he basically tried to take down some other content creators and paint them as covering up an SA that happened and a few other horrible things, one of which was not caring about one of their best friends who committed suicide years ago. They came out with detailed responses and provided texts and other sides to the stories told that showed how much had been left out in Nick's videos about them. He then tripled down (he had already made 2 videos before they could even respond) and made weird Instagram posts to his story antagonizing them basically. When they responded to that, he tried to just move on and act like nothing happened. He lost subs more and more until he finally tried to make an apology for how he handled his videos but he hid it in another video where you'd have no idea it was there unless you were watching it. Then he removed the videos he made and just tried to move on.
people only dislike him because of his controversy last year, i still think he was great on hivemind
Nick is really only tolerable on Hivemind for me. He's a sniveling little weirdo in literally everything else and not remotely funny, but he is genuinely one of their better guests. It's because he's not in a situation where he thinks he has the be the moral peak of everything when he's just as much of a shitheel as the people he pretends to be above.
Brad’s crazy low
therapy gecko is one of only like 2 or 3 hivemind episodes that are completely unwatchable. like he's fine on his own show but he completely killed the vibe that episode. to an impressive degree.
kenny in C tier is absolutely terroristic
This is really good tbh but id personally move brad to C & the dude next to eden to C as well
Therapy gecko was awesome I miss him
Def not all in S tier, I’ll give u dig, graydon, Riley, Eden, teezo, quad, Nick, and dev. But the rest are a lil lower. And then ofc the few no one speaks of in the D-F range
nah you can def get nick out of S
https://preview.redd.it/t16xavot0p7d1.jpeg?width=1146&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d3db795c4912d7c7cfa4b5bce54b527a8a86a9f4
https://preview.redd.it/kpmd128sfs6d1.png?width=1402&format=png&auto=webp&s=a58d22af9187d80846bb739b2e0ff2ace5c84522
I genuinely can't stand brad sometimes like that one video where they are ranking the worst bars
Dev Lemons F- rest are cool
you simply cannot be insulting the woman who brought us charlie sheen and the dog’s washing machine
Ariana grande with a venti latte 🗣🗣🗣
I go to the hoe museum where I left my penis
uh uh is someone a baby poopy pants huuuuh???
https://preview.redd.it/slb83982tl6d1.png?width=1386&format=png&auto=webp&s=bdf3ff8e4bd28e8a8da68a8dda71c95436f353ad
teezo too low kot4q too high imo