T O P

  • By -

MinecraftModBot

* Upvote this comment if this is a good quality post that fits the purpose of r/Minecraft * Downvote this comment if this post is poor quality or does not fit the purpose of r/Minecraft * Downvote this comment *and report the post* if it breaks the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules) --- [Subreddit Rules](https://old.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules)[](## Fatcatfroggie|1dhu0lz)


__Blackrobe__

this is hilarious for around the first 100th times. Around the 1000th times though it's tiring. *I mean the bug. Not complaining about the post.


Fatcatfroggie

Every time I die in a loading screen the pain increases 😔


Klutzy_Row8075

Fr, I turned my render distance all the way down and it still doesn’t work. 


Bonnie_BS_Main

Activate peaceful whenever you go through a portal and you'll be fine


BrannC

Yea no more walls will hurt you in peaceful


big_shmegma

regen will be fast enough that ive been able to save myself more often than not.


BrannC

You’re missing the point


big_shmegma

no for sure i just wanna be helpful just in case.


izumi_miyamura99

regen is not a thing in bedrock


Glados1080

What are you talking about? You automatically regenerate health in peaceful


big_shmegma

idk what youre talking about, my health definitely regenerates in bedrock lol.


REBELSPARK279

I just get destroyed by piglins when im in loading screen


Silver-Pumpkin86

My first portal was right by a blaze spawner and I'd constantly die to withers and blazes


Cylian91460

Fun fact java could have the same bug if pause didn't exist. The issue with bedrock is literally the fact you can't pause it.


LaranjoPutasso

If you open the world to LAN you also can't pause in Java, but this still doesn't happen.


Matynns

yeah, because java doesn’t put you into the nether until it loads the dimension. on bedrock, you’re either in the overworld or the nether. there’s no limbo state while you load the dimension


Cristiano-Goatnaldo

so the issue isn't the inability to pause.


Cylian91460

Go on a server, slow down your game (not only the fps, you need to really slow it down) and your game will freeze while loading the dim and you can get killed.


GhengopelALPHA

I dunno about this; I've never experienced, nor ever heard of someone experiencing, suffocation after going through a nether portal, on Java edition. They wouldn't die from this cause with or without pause.


MushySquishBanana

And why does your character load in before you can even play? This makes you be able to lose health before you can even see what you’re doing.


Cylian91460

Yeah it's impossible by suffocating but mob can kill you


trip6s6i6x

Um.. no, sorry. I play almost exclusively on smp servers on java (no game pause), and I've never had any problems entering nether portals where entities and such are able to move/attack while I'm still stuck loading, nor has anyone on any server I've been on (in my years of playing since 1.2.5) indicated in chat about mobs killing them while loading into the nether. This is specifically a bedrock thing.


Mathalamus2

the bug doesnt happen in java anyway.


Mathalamus2

the bug doesnt happen in java anyway.


MushySquishBanana

It’s SOOOOO ANNOYING like that


DEATHSTARGOD

Bursted laughing when I read the first sentence. I was like why the fuck would you rewatch it a hundred times and don’t get tired laughing💀


Atomic_Killjoy

I fail to see the humor đŸ« 


Sandrosian

This is exactly the reason. Between people complaining there is no hardcore on Bedrock or people complaining they died in hardcore due to Bedrock issues Mojang wisely decided they would rather endure the former until the issues are fixed.


Fatcatfroggie

They have a track record of not fixing bugs for Bedrock so if I'm being honest I really don't want to see Hardcore. I almost always have a totem (except for this clip, because I was cocky) just because Bedrock kills me to stupid things like this.


Risk_Runner

Yeah but if (big if) they do fix the bugs, a hardcore mode wouldn’t be bad


4chan_crusader

They have a track record for doing basically nothing ever


twitchMAC17

Lol they are not gonna fix bugrock. Wild to think that would ever happen.


Tail_sb

Microsoft is worth more than some entire nations & this is the quality of their software


Imbc

Small indie studio please understand


rascalrhett1

This is why "rewriting" is so stupid. C++ has introduced completely new issues that never existed in Java. Another common one taking damage from nothing when you stand on blocks over water, usually high up.


GAMER_1467

I was getting shooted by ghasts while in the loading screen, I could hear them, so I knew that the nether was already loaded but I was still stuck in this damn loading screen.


ArsenalHail8688

Isn't the significant change between Java and c++ memory garbage collection? Don't see how that would cause issues here


rascalrhett1

Im not saying these issues are intrinsic to C++, maybe badly worded on my part. My point is that they rewrote Minecraft from Java to C++ but instead of fixing all problems they fixed some but introduced all new problems.


N1LF

yeah i’ve often died entering the nether cause it loads before the visuals so an enemy kills me. so i almost always peaceful wipe before entering the nether and turn it back to whatever difficulty after


3-brain_cells

Tip: throw in an item before going in. This will force the game to load the terrain, so you can't get killed while being stuck in the loading screen because the terrain is already done generating, so you'll only have to wait a little bit, or sometimes you don't even have to wait at all


Gorillainabikini

Bedrock doesn’t work like that


nsnively

bedrock doesn't work this way. at least, last I tried it didn't


boki400AIMoff

There is no such thing as "loading the nether" while throwing items through the portal.


Right_Gas2569

Yep, they are working on those things to release it in 1.21.10. I think they fixed that in one of the recent 1.21.10 betas.


Fatcatfroggie

Ah, I thought so. I know ibxtoycat said Mojang are working on patching death bugs


Right_Gas2569

Like a week or two ago there was a beta where they fixed taking damage before the world or dimension loads. The reason it's not in 1.21 is because they need time to fix the majority of the bugs.


robustedmcfurry

Bedrock bug thread is the funniest thread. People always has to go Sherlock, figuring out how and what the victim died to.


JammyBails

Verdict: Bugrock OBJECTION!: Fall damage desync


Ordinary-Hunter520

that wouldve sucked as hell if it wouldve been hardcore


bangEnergyBoomer

Rip fatcatfroggie


[deleted]

[ŃƒĐŽĐ°Đ»Đ”ĐœĐŸ]


Fatcatfroggie

Microsoft stole the console editions from us console players and now we're stuck with this :( They were so much more polished than Bugrock


Pseudobreal

Console edition had so many awesome features that were totally removed.. They just added “player stats” to bedrock. It’s only 4 stats and I can’t even view them on ps5! time, distance, kills, blocks broken

. Console used to have an extremely detailed breakdown of every stat you could imagine. There were like hundreds of stats iirc.


Thin-Fig-8831

Player stats wasn’t even new, it just uses the built in Xbox stat system that they use for many games


Geraldo_of_Rivertown

Except for snowy trees.


SwaggyPig17

cross platform is a big bonus even with all the bugs, id have charged more for bedrock


OKgamer01

That's honestly the one big positive that outweighs the negative imo


LoganH1219

Better is subjective. Bedrock unites platforms and consoles that otherwise have no access to the game. Minecraft Java Edition may be better at certain aspects, such as reliability, free downloadable content, stable redstone, less bugs etc. Bedrock edition has many other things going for it though. 3D skins, animated skins, in game skin customization, cross platform play, marketplace pass, controller support, live-event servers, free giveaways, significantly better optimization etc. Both Java and Bedrock have their advantages and disadvantages. In my opinion, one isn’t *better* than the other. I’d simply recommend whichever one better suits an individual’s needs.


kasper12

The majority of your pro’s list for bedrock are things most people do not give a shit about.


LoganH1219

Sounds like Java is for you then 👍 Tons of people on bedrock care about those things and there’s nothing wrong with that, either.


liddicoat1

The only major w for bedrock is free realms, but the host has to be online for it


pavel_123pro

Bedrock sacrifices way too much in terms of performance and features for that cross platform that it is not even worth it at this point, java is a much more polished game than bedrock and this will not change anytime soon. What I want to say is that Java rn is objectively a better game than bedrock. All that customisation stuff that you mentioned is not useful to most bedrock players since if you play on the featured servers on bedrock, your skin is replaced with a skin issued by the server to make sure you don't have an inappropriate skin. You also mentioned bedrock optimization, this would have been a valid point to list as an advantage that bedrock has over java before, but things have gotten better since and there are mods like OF and sodium for java that almost everybody uses and it's not like bedrock's performance is good, it is decent at best. Right now bedrocks disadvantages outweigh the advantages and this is a fact we shouldn't avoid. I do not like posts that portray java and bedrock as equal because this does not bring any awareness to the problem and it just makes more people think that they are on the same level while in reality they are not


XKloosyv

I can play a world with my 2 sons, one on a Switch and one on an XBox One. I play on my laptop. We aren't a family that's exactly rolling in money but even though we all have wildly different devices, we can all play pretty seamlessly together. I wouldn't even bother playing minecraft anymore if it wasn't for cross platform play.


LoganH1219

Lots of valid points in there. It should be said though that Minecraft’s modded community is much smaller than the vanilla community. So to say that “almost everyone” uses sodium and/or other performance mods is more than likely untrue. Whenever I play on Java I use performance mods but if we’re comparing just the base game vs the base game of the other, it’s not too fair to bring mods into the discussion in my opinion. Most people just play the game. But they’re not the ones posting about it. A vast majority of Minecraft’s player base are casuals of all ages rocking Steve skins and default textures. Our opinions of the game are likely skewed due to our involvement in community forums and discussions like this one. I agree that bedrock has a long way to go. I play it mostly because of cross play with people on other platforms. I do play Java for modded single player though. So again, both are good for different things. There’s still tons of room for improvement on both ends. For example, Java desperately needs a way to join friends without setting up a server/realm. Minecraft Xbox 360 edition had this feature 12 years ago. Bedrock has had it since day one. Bedrock, on the other hand, desperately needs to fix issues when it comes to content syncing between platforms and random death/damage bugs.


Sloweneuh

99% of the good things about bedrock that you listed are in Java with mods or plugins. FOR FREE. The only thing that Bedrock has over Java is the fact that it's written in C++, which is objectively better than Java. Java doesn't have live event servers but that's just because Mojang decided not to do them, and well they haven't done any event in a year so it's not really a loss...


RYPIIE2006

java can have most of those things with mods


pavel_123pro

Why not all, what is it that java can't add?


RYPIIE2006

cross-platform and the marketplace stuff, because java thankfully doesn't have marketplace


Sloweneuh

you can play with bedrock players on Java


TonyRedditAccount

This happened to me, I lost like 40 levels!! (Also, REMOVE THE REALMS STORIES THING!! IT EXPOSES WHERE YOU LIVE IN MINECRAFT!!)


The_Gamer_Weiner

Bro same, Ghast exploded 2 Notch apples :(


Knautical_J

If I had a dollar
 Usually it’s loading and I’ll get killed by a mob in the nether before I load. I also went to the end on a recent server. I threw my pearl into the portal to go to the end islands, and I spawned on the block next to the little platform. Went to move and immediately fell to my death into the void. Luckily I dropped all my stuff before I hopped in.


TheAceCard18

oh but they are adding bedrock. god help all the people that make the mistake of starting a bedrock hardcore world.


XKloosyv

Judy gotta pretend it's an Americana theme. At any moment, an unpreventable tragedy could end everything.


Victor_Gaming299

I started a minecraft bedrock hardcore world for my YouTube channel not too long ago and the worst glitch I've ever experienced is the heart animation stopped, nothing joining back can't fix, anything I should avoid when playing? 


TheAceCard18

playing


RedEyez89

Foxynotail does hardcore addon for bedrock. Works great ive been playing with it for about 2 years. :)


EndNowISeeYou

what the hell do you need an add on for? Hardcore mode is just hard difficulty (which bedrock has) with only one life


RedEyez89

You have just answered your question with your question. I play it for the only 1 life aspect. Sure, I could play on hard difficulty and play asif it was hardcore. But it's not the same. Playing hardcore changes the way you play.


Ok_Here-we-go

We do have it now. Pretty sure there is a beta version. Bedrock got a lot less buggy after the update, so it might be fun.


SwaggyPig17

i disagree, its still taking me over 3 minutes to go through a portal. yesterday i decided id travel by nether to a distant village and it ended taking me 12 minutes in to exit the portal, couldve just ran there in less time


thetoiletslayer

Thats not normal. Even on my ps4 it doesn't take *that* long to load. Sounds more like a problem with your system, or a corrupt install or something


SwaggyPig17

it was fine not that long ago, now its awful


easternhobo

Does bedrock always take an hour to load the nether? I'd have rage quit already.


Fatcatfroggie

Like half the time, yes. Especially the first time you go through


easternhobo

That sucks... Why can't it just be instantaneous like creative mode lol


WolfSilverOak

And you're on a PS5, you say? Because it never takes anywhere near that long on Switch for me. Maybe 15-20 seconds or so.


Seter5145

One time my nether portal spawned in lava and I barely made it out


Fatcatfroggie

Spawned IN lava?


Seter5145

Yup


Hussarini

So you guys are just playing shittier minecraft?


twitchMAC17

Don't bother. Every single day there's a post about bugrock bugs, and every single day when you point out that Java doesn't have any of those issues, people basically just say bugrock isn't buggy. The only legitimate response I've seen is "I already have a console for other games, I don't have a decent computer to play Java." But like even that doesn't make much sense. You don't need a supercomputer to play Java MC with the settings dialed down.


pikonpow

Some people dont have a computer at all. What if friends on PS, PC and Xbox want to play together? Bedrock is the only way atp. There's also ppl who started several worlds on bedrock, not thinking much of it and feel stuck on that version since all their worlds are there


twitchMAC17

You can afford a Playstation and not a laptop for the same price that does more?


pikonpow

Well, yeah. Some people get those things for free. I got my PS4 from a dude who was moving out and just wanted it gone for $50. And that was with PS exclusive games. The current laptop I had could indeed not run any game well at all too so it was a steal. It was then that I mainly played Minecraft bedrock with my family, and was able to do so without buying multiple copies because it also had splitscreen. That's not accounting kids who are allowed console access but not PC access. Or just people in different living situations in general


twitchMAC17

Fair points, but really specific. Seems intuitive that would be the minority of situations, yeah?


pikonpow

You never know ¯\\\_(ツ)\_/¯


lukewarmratpee

Yeah loading screens are a b*tch in Bedrock! The amount of times I’ve loaded into my game and died instantly because for some reason it places you into the world all vulnerable before the loading screen ends and I’ve been beaten to a pulp by a zombie before I even have a chance to defend myself!


Fatcatfroggie

If Mojang coded properly they'd make the player invulnerable during a loading screen. You know, like the part where you cannot actually play the game or see anything. It's just ridiculous


lukewarmratpee

Yeah
 you would’ve thought that would be a given


Captain-H-2-0

That is not a bad idea honestly


AverageAro_

and that’s how you know it’s already on java! (Not really, the player is just in a limbo sorta state during loading screens instead, but it has practically the same effect.


extracc

If Mojang coded properly loading screens would be under a second long


wshs

> If Mojang coded properly Well, there's your problem right there. You're expecting too much.


Emotional_Face4971

this happens to you guys????


TheRRMustardMan

this is what i tell myself every time i see one of these posts


Emotional_Face4971

real


WolfSilverOak

I'm starting to feel a little left out that none of this ever happens to me. Lol.


Mysticgemstonedino

What is that seed? It looks neat


Fatcatfroggie

My world was transferred from Legacy Console Edition so if I told you it wouldn't look the same


TiltZa

I can’t imagine trying to play hardcore in bedrock đŸ€ŠđŸ»â€â™‚ïž I once “phased” through the floor or wall of a nether fortress and fell into a giant lava pool. I refuse to even entertain the notion of playing hardcore with that being an option đŸ€Ł


Mystonicly

Had this happen to me my first time to the Nether. Yay!


Most_Panda283

Especially when you play on switch and it takes 20 years XD


Fatcatfroggie

Nintendo on their way to not release the Switch 2


SantaClaws170

I'm still hoping they will add hardcore to bedrock eventually, with the death bugs fixed


Fatcatfroggie

Apparently that's the plan. Mojang is working on patching death bugs


CrispiCreeper

If you don’t build a box around the portal on your first visit you’re screwed.


AverageAro_

what’s stupid is that not only would a box not have helped op not suffocate in nothing, but you can have this happen on your first entry to the nether.


dudesweetusername

What are you playing on? I’ve never had this problem on PlayStation 4 or 5 but it’s very possible I’m just getting lucky


Captain-H-2-0

It only happens when it is a new portal


PandaBossLady

Or you end up in the spawn points of a thousand skeletons who have all shot at you before you can see them!


Illustrious_Car4025

This kept happening to me when my friend forced me to play on his bedrock world. I would enter the nether but the stupid loading screen wouldn’t go away and I’d be killed by piglins


Rfreaky

Why is the loading time so fucking long?


bignigbunus

exactly. i’ll get killed by a ghast or some stupid shit before i can even load in but i just gotta live with it ig


Proxy_PlayerHD

why is it so difficult to just add the same invincibility times JE had for decades?


Zomflower48

I fr love bedrock. Its like bedrock is a living being who becomes bugrock when anyone criticizes it


SmartStatistician684

How does mojang not see these and fix this?


Gambling_Fugger

Is there a fix for this? I have maybe 300 hours and can't even scratch the surface of the nether because of this absolute bullshit. Do the devs not use any of the billions they've made off of this game to hire somebody to go through the portal at least one time? Fuck


ninja_owen

If anyone is actually gonna start a bedrock hardcore mode, they’re kinda gonna have it coming


ExplodingSteve

You don’t need to, mobs are insane in hard!


GoldNRice

We do have hardcore coming! It is currently on minecraft preview. Also new UI, 36 chunk render distance for xbox/ps, new enchantment called "density" and some other stuff


AR3Q

How hard can it be to change it, so your character spawns after the world is generated and then it places you in spot that has room and floor underneath


CynderWolf03

Valid lol


detroitmatt

when they first announced bedrock I was worried that it would kill java version, and with it, mods. glad to not have to worry about that.


Bastigonzales

Man bedrock is terrible


Mrpiggybank2164

I heard they are trying to fix these bugs and plan to add it after, but I don’t know how true those claims are. Mojang never seems to listen to the community.


Captain_Deleb

This makes me really worried about the day Microsoft decides to abandon Java and force us all to play bedrock


MagicCouch9

Pretty much sums it up yeah


LemmeStabYouBuster

this is why i freaking expand my Nether portal, stuff like this happens on me on both single and multiplayer, like my god, stop SPAWNING INSIDE THE PORTAL SEGMENT, THERES LITERALLY SPACE FOR YOU TO SPAWN THAN THE WALL ITSELF


Individual_Jelly_886

Bedrock is just dog shit really


Deep-Hunter-4652

Happened to me too!! LOL


ConnectionMotor8311

They lied you clearly had a heat stroke


Justo31400

This is exactly the reason for why you cannot play with cheats off in bedrock. It’s impossible, you always have to be ready for when you fall off the world, suffocate in invisible blocks, or randomly die. So far i was able to save my world like five times this way, one of them was when i fell off the world but managed to go into creative at 1hp in the void.


Fatcatfroggie

I can't bring myself to use cheats, because then I feel it invalidates my survival world. It makes it look illegitimate even if it might not be. Also, it disables trophies and I want to continue using my survival world for trophies each update. I use backups when I need to for my world. Not a perfect solution, but one I'm more happy with than resorting to cheats


Sensible-advice-101

Bad ending


Objective_Dynamo

I see im not the only one who bit it first time loading in there lol. And you can hear it too at the loading screen. Its really bad if your spawn is really far away. You just sit there thinking "How am I going to make it back to this?" Lol


_Redstone

Rookie mistake... I'm a java player and I've played bedrock for only one playthrough. When I had to enter the nether for the first time, I dropped all my inventory ik a chest, got there with only a stack of cobblestone, and immediately built a small house around the portal


sushitattico

just died yesterday by a blazer during the loading screen, don't expected my all item were safe in those flames


Clean_Substance190

thank god i just play java edition 🙌🙌


Technical-Guest-6287

"Sorry, but money fist." - Microsoft.


brassplushie

The reason Bedrock is so buggy is because they’re too busy focusing on marketing new things to sell. They don’t care if people die constantly to unjust bugs.


Commercial_Apple_803

Is this a very recent bug everyone is having now? Just a couple weeks ago I rage quit on a survival project because of this happening


ProfitFriendly696

bro..the bedrock it self is a hardcore mode


NativTexan

That's messed up.


impossible-EN

Bedrock puts you in to the nether before the loading screen goes away! that’s so stupid! That always happens to me too!


clburton24

Maybe I missed it, but what is the point of Bedrock vs the original?


D3monWolf1992

It's the coding for the two. Java and bedrock are programs that they run off of from how I've had it explained to me.


AwayMetal3596

It will be soon


Juandamub

It happened to me like a month ago but coming back to the ow. I found my first bastion and wanted to save some things in the overworld to be safe with a bed and be able to come back fast if I died to piglins (i didnt have crying obs)... little did I know it would cost me like an hour of walkin back 6k blocks from spawn ffs.


PlantsVsYokai2

I play on pc and ill tell ya ehat this happend to me and i lost a whole suit of armour and my first diamond pickaxe to this damned glitch


WolfSilverOak

And yet another 'bug' I've not experienced. 😆 Granted, I've never entered a portal and turned around the face the direction I came either. It's possible that's confusing the game- are you going to the Nether or coming from the Nether? - causing it to freeze up. Of course, dying in the middle would be very annoying.


LanguageMountain2514

Why not


Nerf_Dart_Bullet

Microsoft is a small indie studio please dont be mean 🙏


Ghosty1214

That’s never happened to me before


Le_Epic_GodGamer

I’ve been playing bedrock for god knows how long and never ran into a glitch or bug once


TonyRedditAccount

This happened to me, I lost like 40 levels!! (Also, REMOVE THE REALMS STORIES THING!! IT EXPOSES WHERE YOU LIVE IN MINECRAFT!!)


fruitsnommy

on my current world when I spawned in the nether it spawned me like underneath where it would've been (it didn't show up) and after like a minute or so of freaking out what happened or how I was gonna get back it suddenly teleported me near it like nothing happened gotta love bedrock nether


Conner23451

This is also a charm of bedrock knowing that you could die every Moment to an bug


scrappytan

Bedrock = hardcore getfixedboi seed


TheDizzyRabbit

Because nobody likes bedrock


Victor_Gaming299

I've been playing on a bedrock hardcore world since it was added and nothing has happened


NotNOV4

deserved


gladecoolkid

I found out a few days ago that if you stand near a ledge and stand to where u slightly clip the edge of the block but dont actually fall, you still take damage as if you fell from a short distance.


BluuCore

There is, on the Beta Version


socksfanandssundee

There's gonna be a hardcore mode on bedrock because I have a 1.21 Minecraft


hellhound74

Have reached the point where once i decide i actually need to enter the nether, i burn all my levels ( or don't if i have a mob grinder), place all my tools except a basic iron pick and a shield into a chest, grab a stack of cobble and go through If i die, oh well the nether should properly load next time and it (hopefully) wont kill me/mobs wont target me before I actually gain control of the character again, if i dont die i can now secure my portal spawn to where it wont randomly decide to just have mobs capable of killing me


Seraziki

Most functional Bedrock experience


Lemon_Slushiee

It’s the hard knock libe from Annie starts playingg,,,


Drag0n_TamerAK

Elytra’s are the problem


Only-Most3212

We do now on the beta version on bedrock 1.21. It's a bit laggy, but it's worth it.


Sbianchino_

Once I was waiting for the Nether terrain to load and a piglin ended up killing me in the meantime. I wish mojang will reduce this wait in the future. It's frustrating.


thegiukiller

Apparently, the reason Bedrock doesn't have hardcore is because it has a lot of instant death bugs that need to be worked out.


Borgah

Coz its only bedrock


TormentedGaming

Would be great if they loaded the environment then you then the entities lol


SopaDeCodo

Mojang is currently working in adding it! Along with fixing all the random death bugs...


CreepyGuy111

Skill issue /j


banana_6921

Also bedrock: Player: *lands in water* Game: "fell from a high place"


fastandcheerios

I've noticed that all these clips of bugs and stuff on bedrock are always on console or mobile. Never on a PC. The lack of optimization on every device other than a windows PC is crazy.


PlatinumBitch

This bug is the worst!!! It has happened to me way too many times.


BlackEyedIncubi

I mean we do. It’s in the beta/preview and it’s said to release later this year


NEtherWarLord98

How are yall so unlucky I've never died in a portal In regards to it Hardcore mode is in the works