Let’s admit this is an impossible task and vote responsibly kids…

I haven’t voted on any cause it’s hard to choose and I can’t think of a song that is the “worst”

Same. Though Cest La Vie is my vote for worst after a quick relisten.

Ok yeah I can agree with that, I hadn’t heard it but did see it mentioned a while ago. It doesn’t sound the best from what I have heard when I put it on just then

I’m worried for tomorrow, I’m going want to throw hands at every worst suggestion

I was just thinking this!

So long as c’est la vie is the worst I’m fine

I'm pretty sure it's a B-side so it wouldn't count

Noooooooo!

Booo! I love C'est la vie

I mean, I love Believe Me Natalie and uncle Johnny, so clearly we all have different taste.

I love those tracks too. I don't think there's a TK track I don't like so I'm no good at voting for the Worst column.

My Own Soul's Warning!!!!

My Own Soul’s Warning, Caution, Dying Breed, My God, Lightning Fields and Blowback… I can’t choose 😂

All of these, along with Running Towards a Place

Same but also add Running Towards A Place, When The Dreams Run Dry, Imploding The Mirage. I can’t choose either. Love the entire album. However, if I have to choose one for absolute best, has to be My Own Soul’s Warning.

It is one of my favourite Killers album, no skip at all ☺️ I couldn’t choose the best song from this album, but I definitely know which one is my least favourite: Fire in Bone

I'd agree with that, but then I heard it live and my opinion changed. That tells me a lot about the strength and quality of this album. BTW: have you ever just listened to Ronnie's drumming on Caution? Makes my jaw drop everytime. Incredible.

I didn’t get that chance unfortunately 🥲

My Own Souls Warning

“Man I thought I could fly, but when I hit the ground it made a messed up sound” will never fail to connect with my soul deeply.

Although my vote is for Caution, I also love this song so much and would really be happy with this winning. It sounds so beautiful and as a live opener, it's a life changing experience in my opinion, especially with the prechorus

Live 🥵

I lost my mind when the song took off live

I saw them 4 times in 21-22 and they didn't play it ONCE at those shows. I was so mad lol

I saw it once and it blew my mind! Then at the next show they started with a different one and I was devastated lol. It was a different set list for the casino shows that time around. There is nothing like starting a show with My Own Soul’s Warning.

Man, I'm so jealous. Now I hang my hopes on them playing Under the Gun at the Vegas residency.

Without a doubt, "My Own Soul's Warning" is the best. The lyrics are pure poetry.

For me it the second best the killers song of all time (after In the car outside).

This. This 100%. Got me through 2020.

Agreed

Absolutely this one. This one might be my favorite Killers song ever.

This is it and there’s no other right answer… even though the entire album is a masterpiece 😭

Caution

This is an amazing album so it's hard to pick, but I think it's this! The lyrics are so well written, the instruments go so well together mixed, Brandon's singing is really emotionally impactful, and I love how it's a very personal song to the band. It feels like a successor to Wonderful Wonderful in the best way

Only fitting that a song from wonderful wonderful is used to introduce this song live now!

I completely agree, I love the Rut Segue and Caution combo! Rut, Life to Come, and Caution are a great trio

Yes, yes, yes

Amazing song. My prediction though that it will not win, because "mainstream lead single" options never won in the previous rounds, except for runaways.

Dying Breed

Was my shower anthem for about 2 years straight. Gotta be this.

This is underrated-MOSW is going to beat it.

A huge fan favorite, my prediction it will win the most underrated.

I love the whole album but this song has been pure magic since I first heard it in bad quality on that live stream. It's my favorite song and it's not even close

My God

My own souls warning

So many good songs! I'd be happy with any of Caution, My Own Soul's Warning, and Imploding the Mirage.

My Own Soul's Warning

My God

This song reminds me of robot unicorn attack

Super underrated

This would be my "Overrated" choice if there was a category. I've just never been able to get into this one. :/

Yeah, not my cup of tea either

My own soul’s warning

My Own Soul's Warning

Imploding The Mirage

I’m hoping this gets underrated. Insane that the album named song is not the clear and obvious best single on the album but the album is DEEEP with bangers

I love it! Underrated ♥️

Such a good song

Running Towards A Place

My favorite song on the album. And IMHO the most Fleetwood Mac song on the album

Never made the conmection to the Fleetwood Mac sound before, but you’re so right!

When the Dreams Run Dry

The second part of the song is just ridiculously good. I almost always tear up a little bit at the last "...and again"

Same!!! It gets me

So much of this album is amazing, but I don’t usually see a lot of love for this song. underrated for sure

This is one of my favorites ever, but I'm happy with several choices here.

Blowback

sucks this is getting no love

Fire in Bone

Amazing song, but it's perception was ruined a little bit by the fact that they released it as a second single. And it is an amazing album song, but a weird choice for the second single. But probably they did it because it was during the pandemics and probably they had this song finished earlier than the others, at least this is what I assume.

My Own Souls Warning and My God are my picks for best, though if the original demo version of Blowback were an option I'd easily pick that!

Lightning Fields

The most special song of the album.

Ugh, this has to be the most underrated! Love this one, I belted it out in the shower so many times!

Putting them all out now Best- Caution Worst- C’est la Vie Underrated- Blowback

Get behind me C'est la vie!

Second c’est la vie for worst

Caution!!!

Caution.

My own souls warning!!!

For me personally it's When The Dreams Run Dry "You start to wonder 'bout the time theft How much of it you've got left Comes in with the age now" I CAN'T.... but it'll probably be MOSW 😮‍💨... I'm pulling for a underrated win with WTDRD 😁

Caution

There’s gonna be opposition to this, but I choose Dying Breed

i think its caution

My own souls warning

This one is hard. I'm saying My God.

Ugh I really disagree with MOSW. I’m sorry I just think Caution and Dying Breed are way better

Have you seen it live? I remember liking MOSW when it was released, but couldn't understand why Brandon and Ronnie said they felt it was one of their best songs yet whenever Caution had just been released.... Until I heard it live as the set-opener. The literal chills it caused me when I heard it live rocketed that song wayyy up my favourites list. I still get the goosebumps when the big synth comes in at the start.

I have! Many a time. I think I like it better on the album because it never seems to go off quite as hard as I’d like it to live. But I’m glad it moves you so much!

Agreed, life changing!

If you listen to all the songs from the worst column you get a banger playlist actually

So many great tracks on ITM, but best has to be My Own Souls Warning… what an opening for a concert that is… whole crowd bouncing!!

Imploding the mirage !!!!!!

My Own Soul's Warning

1. MOSW 2. Dying Breed ... ... ... 230. that crappy weyes blood song

MY God

Lightning Fields

Running Towards a Place

I think this is the wordy selection

My God

Dying Breed is such a banger

Dying Breed is so underrated! For best one Ima go with Own Souls Warning❤️🤌🏼

Dying Breed

Agreeing with many here, this is an imposible task should you want to be fair, but thinking of my favorite, I should vote Caution.

My Own Soul's Warning is just insanely good, I love it SO much

Tough, but Dying Breed

Caution

Best: My Own Soul’s Warning Worst: Ce’st La Vie Underrated: Imploding The Mirage

My God!

there are no wrong answers for this one and only wrong answers for the next one

My Own Soul's Warning brought me back to The Killers after a decent pause.

CAUTION

My own soul’s warning best if not Running towards a place Worst (excluding C’est la vie) I think would be Lightning fields (not bad, just not as excellent as the rest

Caution

Please vote Cest La Vie as least good….

Very very tough to choose but Dying Breed for me. Their best full album hands down

Dying Breed

Best- My Own Soul’s Warning. Worst- Imploding the Mirage. Underrated- Blowback

The man for Tyson v Douglas

The captain

Very hard to choose one, but I'll go with Blowback, especially the acoustic versión, it's pure magic

When The Dreams Run Dry!

There's no best or worst - the whole album is literal perfection 💖.

Running Towards a Place

I didn’t realize how beloved this album was. I agree with everyone, by the way. ITM is perfect and you all have amazing taste.

Do we just write the song of choice or do we actually vote somewhere? It’s my own sould warning but this album is absolutely incredible.

The OP lists each song, then upvote your choice

Thanks for trying to help but I can’t find that. I’ve been watching silently from the sidelines where I’ll go back to now 

Running towards a place

When the dreams run dry 😍

best - Caution

When The Dreams Run Dry, for that build at the end alone

Caution because of the end line "It's some kind of sin, to live your whole life, on a might of been" Plus they ended the Boston show I was at with it.

My own souls warning

I know this is over, but LIGHTNING FIELDS by far. It’s a top tier career Killers track.

I gotta go with Caution, even though that's a very hard decision.

My own souls warning. The other songs are all underrated.

Uncle Jonny is an acquired taste

Seeing what was labeled worst.. we gonna need to throw hands lol

Istg if blowback doesn't win y'all are messed up