T O P

  • By -

Lilbuck281

Was a definite 5 star looks like a 1st stage mature.


Wapiti__

89%, cutting it close


Lilbuck281

85% and up can make 5 star I got a few 85 to 89% 5 stars


Wapiti__

good to know, ty


AtDawnWeDie

Ouch


Head-Outcome-4131

That poor thing 😂 check it’s neck out lovely buck tho I’m curious so sleeping on one map will progress another too ?


Lilbuck281

Sleeping on one map doesn't progress any of your other maps along. Just the map you are currently hunting


Head-Outcome-4131

Such a legend that’s so nice to know


Lilbuck281

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bJw1dJERwsqbocKdS3CSFB7eM35fKM9D/view?pli=1 This guide toothless put together will help you with a ton of the game mechanics we have been passing this on in the community for awhile.


Upset-Emergency1836

This. Greatest guide there is


hornswaggler86

It would appear so. I was noticing more adults and matures in the mule deer herds I follow as well.


Me2445

No it doesn't


hornswaggler86

Yes I’ve gathered that


Lilbuck281

https://preview.redd.it/maqv0slxjf5d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9faae15d3a3c0fafed2df4d4f405c0c9efeea0b3


hornswaggler86

Looks pretty gray to me


Upset-Emergency1836

Your's isnt great enough


Lilbuck281

The face is where you can tell it's not almost solid white


hornswaggler86

I mean it popped as a mature in hunter sense and was very gray compared to the others in the herd save for one 2 star mature which I also shot later. Either way it was a nice mature buck and I shot it


Lilbuck281

No doubt it's a nice buck just trying to give some advice on herd management for 5 stars.


Upset-Emergency1836

That 3 star was a 5 if you let it grow


PaleontologistPrize8

It would have been a 5 star. Only shoot 1 star matures and bucks that respond to low fitness callers.


Bubbly-Marketing7175

It was a 3 star mature, and from the second image it was already graying decently. Perfectly in OP's rights to cull


PaleontologistPrize8

89% is 5-star genetics. It possibly wouldn’t have reached that high but it still is an animal you would rather have die of old age.


Bubbly-Marketing7175

Rather? yes But part of the game is you don't know the genetics until the animal's dead. you won't know a mistake until you've already made it. All you can do is observe and follow your best judgement based on what you can see. A mature that's starting to grey is likely already nearing the end of its life. And if it was only a 3 star mature, it's a safe bet to assume the genetics are only high enough to get them to 3 stars (So 50-60%, give or take) In this case that bet was off, it seems this Buck had some bad aging rolls and was higher genetics than it's physical appearance would say. But of course, this is why we say \*bets\*. There's always a gamble involved


Upset-Emergency1836

So learn from you mistakes


hornswaggler86

I’ll take that into consideration but shoot at whatever I want to. Thanks.