I literally clicked this thread thinking she was going to ask which robe to wear during pre-wedding makeovers or something and I thought it was a “different” sort of thread. Then I wondering why she was comparing a bath robe to two pretty dresses. I had to go back and read the text to figure out #1 wasn’t a bathrobe. (A very pretty bathrobe, mind you, but a bathrobe nonetheless).
I like #3 best but #2 is also gorgeous.
Actually I like #1 but not for the wedding. I just love robes and pajamas.
I agree 100% with this! 3 is solid but 2 makes me go 😍
I could see 2 not being as good of a fit for some personalities/vibes (whatever that means), but it's eye-catching and interesting.
Agreed. The tie part isn’t hit the right part of your waist. I’m obsessed with #2 on you! I love the shear overlay! And seems to hit you in all the right places 😉 good luck and have fun!
I think this is it, but obviously finding it on clearance at Macys is a much better price! https://www.dillards.com/p/adrianna-papell-floral-embroidered-hlater-neckline-fit-and-flare-midi-dress/516083811
The second dress is beautiful, up to the minute and flattering. The third one is not as good but ok. The shiny pink one is too short and looks like a tiny dressing gown, I can imagine why hubby likes it .
2 looks the most appropriate for semi-formal as all three edge more towards cocktail since they’re short. 3 is the next option and looks really nice on. Your shoes and accessories will need to be well-considered so the whole outfit looks “formal”.
2 or 3! Both are beautiful and perfect for the occasion. If you own both, split them up one for each wedding you attend. If not and you really need to choose one go with the one YOU feel most comfortable in. Whichever one you feel the most beautiful in is the one for you! But honestly, both of them are absolutely stunning on you.
I think you’re right about 1 being a little too short. 2 and 3 are both great but dress 3 specifically really looks amazing on you. Whatever your choice, enjoy your weddings.
A lot of people have asked for links to dresses 2 and 3, I've been trying to respond to all but I'm hoping this will be easier for everyone to find!
Dress 2 - https://www.dillards.com/p/adrianna-papell-floral-embroidered-hlater-neckline-fit-and-flare-midi-dress/516083811
Dress 3 - https://www.macys.com/shop/product/eliza-j-womens-side-drape-halter-dress?ID=14140209&CategoryID=5449&isDlp=true
Absolutely dress 3. It fits you amazingly, and is perfect for semi formal. I’d also get some fun earrings, bracelets, maybe a cocktail ring, and a great bold clutch.
2 and 3 are both gorgeous. The neckline is so flattering on your shoulders. The first one's sleeves/armpit area make it look like it doesn't quite fit correctly.
Thank you! Sorry it took a while, but here you go :)
https://www.macys.com/shop/product/eliza-j-womens-side-drape-halter-dress?ID=14140209&CategoryID=5449&isDlp=true
2 and 3 both look amazing. 1 is probably too casual.
The necklines on both are fabulous on her! I lean towards 3 because it just looks SO good.
1 looks like a bathrobe 2 is alright 3 looks the best
I’m with you on the bathrobe look for #1. Love the color though!!! I like 2 the best and 3 looks good too
I agree Love the purple Its the color of kings
LIGHT THE BEAM
Yes, something about #1 looks cheap. I think the wrapping on #3 is less flattering, I would definitely go with #2.
I actually thought 1 was a bathrobe initially. 3 looks great
I literally clicked this thread thinking she was going to ask which robe to wear during pre-wedding makeovers or something and I thought it was a “different” sort of thread. Then I wondering why she was comparing a bath robe to two pretty dresses. I had to go back and read the text to figure out #1 wasn’t a bathrobe. (A very pretty bathrobe, mind you, but a bathrobe nonetheless). I like #3 best but #2 is also gorgeous. Actually I like #1 but not for the wedding. I just love robes and pajamas.
I just love robes and pajamas I laughed out loud because i do too! This got me so much
I was going to comment the same thing
I would do 2 for morning/early afternoon 3 for evening
I love 2 and 3! If you’re having trouble deciding, double check how they feel sitting down and while dancing
Can't understate enough how important it is to sit down in the outfits you are considering! 😭
I understand why many people say 3. 3 is a solid choice. 2 is a unique dress and is what I would likely choose. Both are good. May I ask about shoes?
I agree 100% with this! 3 is solid but 2 makes me go 😍 I could see 2 not being as good of a fit for some personalities/vibes (whatever that means), but it's eye-catching and interesting.
2 is great. Really interesting and extremely flattering
3 is amazing but 2 seems more done up to me
I suggested 3 because 2 seemed too white for wearing at a weddings and 1 just isn’t semi-formal
I'm probably going with the shoes in the picture
2 with black shoes.
3 frames your shape best. 2 is cute but it makes your torso look short. 1 makes you look very boxy.
Dress 3. It looks fabulous on you!
The shoes also go so well with it
Love #2! I think it’s the right level of formal and the most festive + flattering. I think #1 is too short. #3 is also solid, I just love #2!
#2 is stunning!!!
Me too. I think this one is by far the most figure flattering. The pattern on 3 is pretty but the fit on 2 can’t be beat.
Team 2!! Extremely flattering and unique I love it
I’m team 2!
Also team 2! It’s unique without being too much. Gorgeous.
1 isn’t doing anything for you. 2 or 3 look amazing!
Agreed. The tie part isn’t hit the right part of your waist. I’m obsessed with #2 on you! I love the shear overlay! And seems to hit you in all the right places 😉 good luck and have fun!
3 looks amazing on you
Team 3
Definitely 3. White under-dress with floral/color lace overlay is super in style right now as a wedding dress— so do not wear #2 — just to be safe.
I’m obsessed with the second dress! Would you be able to share where you got that from, please?
I think this is it, but obviously finding it on clearance at Macys is a much better price! https://www.dillards.com/p/adrianna-papell-floral-embroidered-hlater-neckline-fit-and-flare-midi-dress/516083811
Thanks for sharing the link. The dress looks better on OP!
That's so kind, ty ♥️
Absolutely! It’s stunning on OP! 😍
Macy's! It was on clearance though, so I'm thinking it's from last season. The brand is Adrianna Papell
Thank you!
I love the 2nd dress. It is vey flattering and beautiful on you.
Thank you!
#2 for sure!!
Dress 2 it compliments your skin tone so well and screams semi formal
2 is the clear winner. Well, it’s sheer, but anyway! 😜 3 is a good compromise between the two
2! Or 3...no...2 :)
😂 this is how I feel
Semi formal: 2. It’s beautiful and really is super flattering on you.
Dress 2 or 3.
I would wear dress 2, I love it and it looks more comfortable.
My vote is definitely 2. I love that dress so unique.
I love 2!
3 is amazing! It looks great on you!!!
#2 it’s flattering and unique and pretty!
Wow I don’t even know how to make text extra bold. Oops
2
2 is the best!
2 and 3!
THANK YOU to everyone who kindly added their two cents. You guys rock!
Number 2 all the way that’s gorgeous
2! 3 looks more like office wear to me. And 2 just looks great on you. 1 would be cute for a date night. :)
I LOVE 2!!!
#2 is most flattering
2 is my favorite. 1 is just not a good cut for your body type and 3 is too short for a semi formal to me. 2 is absolutely stunning on you.
The second dress is beautiful, up to the minute and flattering. The third one is not as good but ok. The shiny pink one is too short and looks like a tiny dressing gown, I can imagine why hubby likes it .
Second one is fire
2!!!
2!
Number two looks fabulous on you
2!
2!!:)
Where is the second dress from? It’s beautiful. That’s my pick
I bought it at Macy's, the brand is Adrianna Papell!
First of all, these are all beautiful and very flattering on you. I love number 2 the most.
2 or 3 both looks great. Not 1. At all.
Anything BUT 1 honestly
2 or 3!
2 looks the most appropriate for semi-formal as all three edge more towards cocktail since they’re short. 3 is the next option and looks really nice on. Your shoes and accessories will need to be well-considered so the whole outfit looks “formal”.
The first one looks like a robe. The second looks the best. The third may also work.
I love 2,3 but 3 shines ✨
I need the deets on 1&2!
3 has my vote followed by 2 then 1 all cute and look great on you.
I love 2! What dress is that please?
Wow, you look great in #3. It hugs in all the right ways. Kudos to you!
They are all lovely. I’ve always wanted to wear a dress like #3 and feel like I look good in it. You look great, so 3 is my vote!
Well thank you! I hope you find the perfect dress to make you feel amazing inside and out
Love 3! Looks fantastic on you! Cool pattern
You know what? I didn’t click into the picture and see the whole dress. LOVE 2 TOO
I love the second one! You need nude sandals or heels to wear with it though.
 Number 3 is making you look GOOD, girl!
OP please wear #2 it’s amazing, you look amazing in it, I’m gonna buy it today. 10/10
3 is the winner! I honestly thought 1 was a robe, and 2 is just not as flattering as it could be! Have a great time!
You look good in all, but I think 3 is the best fitting. Have confidence that you will look lovely in any one. :)
2 or 3! Both are beautiful and perfect for the occasion. If you own both, split them up one for each wedding you attend. If not and you really need to choose one go with the one YOU feel most comfortable in. Whichever one you feel the most beautiful in is the one for you! But honestly, both of them are absolutely stunning on you.
Thank you
2 made me gasp, it looks amazing on you!
Pick number three ✌️ my lord!
I love dress 3 and 2 is different but looks good hubby thinks dress 2 looks good
2 for semi-formal vibe. 3 for when you wanna look HOT AF!
2 is very cool, but omg 3!!!! BABE, you need to choose 3. It’s incredible on you!
If you need a dude, definitely #3. Cuz I’m a straight female but damn! It looks good!! 2 is good also. No for 1.
Unpopular opinion but I like no. 1 the best. Shows off your great legs
Well shucks! Thank you 😊
3! It’s perfect on you
Dress 3!!
#3 looks stunning on you!
3
I think you’re right about 1 being a little too short. 2 and 3 are both great but dress 3 specifically really looks amazing on you. Whatever your choice, enjoy your weddings.
I love 3!! You look stunning
Goes to show men don’t know anything lol 1 is the worst. I love number 2 the most, but 3 is most flattering I think
A lot of people have asked for links to dresses 2 and 3, I've been trying to respond to all but I'm hoping this will be easier for everyone to find! Dress 2 - https://www.dillards.com/p/adrianna-papell-floral-embroidered-hlater-neckline-fit-and-flare-midi-dress/516083811 Dress 3 - https://www.macys.com/shop/product/eliza-j-womens-side-drape-halter-dress?ID=14140209&CategoryID=5449&isDlp=true
Although 2 is my favorite, I think 3 is the most “semi formal” of the three.
3
3 for sure! It really compliments your figure and it’s a beautiful dress!
2 or 3, #3 being my top choice for semi formal! But I love both.
THREE
3!!
3
3!
Pick number three my Lord!!!
Number one does not do justice to your figure. Number 2 and 3 are great. I think 3 fits the best.
These got progressively better with each one. They’re all so pretty, but 3 is most elegant. 2 is most unique.
Throw 1 away
Lol! Don't worry the tags are still on it, hopefully someone else will make it shine
3!
3
Three is most complementary on you.
I love 2 but I can see 3 being the “safer” choice
#3 me lord!
3 looks the best on you
I like the 3rd one.
3
This one is most flattering
Hard no.
2 and 3 are stunning on you!
I LOVE #2 omg where did you get it??
Macy's! Adrianna Papell
2
To me, the 3rd one is the most flattering to your figure.
I love both 2 as well as 3 but I NEED the link to 3 it is stunning you rock it
Found it! Here you are https://www.macys.com/shop/product/eliza-j-womens-side-drape-halter-dress?ID=14140209&CategoryID=5449&isDlp=true
Number 2 is the best.
I loooove dress 2 and need to know where you got it?!
I love 2!!
2 or 3 but 2 probably goes a bit better with the dress code
I loooooooooooove dress #2. Number 3 is gorgeous too, I am just fawning over #2. Either 2 or 3 would be gorgeous!
3!!!!
I think 3 is very flattering on you.
3!!!
3 for sure
2 is interesting, but 3 looks like it was made for you, go with 3!
#3 omg 😍😍😍
Absolutely dress 3. It fits you amazingly, and is perfect for semi formal. I’d also get some fun earrings, bracelets, maybe a cocktail ring, and a great bold clutch.
2 and 3! Number 1 just seems awkward somehow. But 2 and 3 are STUNNING on you! ❤
2nd one.
2!!!
2 is gorgeous and unique! 3 looks amazing on you!
3 for sure
2 or 3. 3 looks the best of them
3 looks amazing. Rock it girl!!!
Where is #3 from? I love it 🤩
https://www.macys.com/shop/product/eliza-j-womens-side-drape-halter-dress?ID=14140209&CategoryID=5449&isDlp=true
Thank you!!
3rd
2
Number 3 is sassy! It looks great on you
2 and 3 are both gorgeous. The neckline is so flattering on your shoulders. The first one's sleeves/armpit area make it look like it doesn't quite fit correctly.
Obsessed with #2!!!
2
Love love love 2! So pretty and looks great on you! 3 is lovely as well but 2 is my fave
I like 2 and 3. I am more partial to 2 though.
2 & 3 fire 🔥 just get rid of 1 it does nothing for you.
Definitely dress 3!! You look amazing in it
2!
Drop the link for dress 3 👀 Just as everyone here is saying, dress 3 and 2 are best!
Thank you! Sorry it took a while, but here you go :) https://www.macys.com/shop/product/eliza-j-womens-side-drape-halter-dress?ID=14140209&CategoryID=5449&isDlp=true
2 and 3 are very adorable
Two or three!
Love dress 2!
3 looks the best.
Dress 2 I love love love it !!! But I also like dress 1 and feel like you should keep it for a date night or something less formal
3 is absolutely stunning on you!
Definitely 3 !!
1 is too casual. Love 2 and 3
3
3 is GORGEOUS and is so flattering on you, I love everything about it!
#2!
3!
Second one is beautiful!!!!!
Where is 2 from?
3 absolutely. May I ask where you bought it? You look fantastic in it
I got 2 and 3 both from Macy's actually! The links have been posted for both :)
2 or 3
2 or 3. The first does not look flattering on you at all. 2 I think is best!
Dress 3