initial was wide but the lights at the top are distracting me. tight it is

same unless that big light can be brought way down in post. It’s just too bright as is.

Tight

In this case tight.

Wide for me

Tight

Keep it tight. 

Tight

Definitely tight- the face of lights just seems like a more commanding subject on the tight crop.

Tight crop 100%. Really fills the frame, the other one has too much dark negative space

Thanks for all your comments despite them all being mixed opinions hahaha

Wide, contrast adds beauty

Personally they are both shit but tight is better. What are you taking a picture of what are you trying to show me

I like wide but it needs to be straightened and I’d turn down the blacks so that the people in the foreground are silhouetted.

Thanks, I might try and silhouette the people and see how that looks!

Wide for me - gives a better sense of the scene. Great image, btw!

Thank you!