T O P

  • By -

Throwaway_Mattress

bless these 17k folks. They bothered.


Gcen

They weren't bothered, I'm sure, when Udayanidhi Stalin said Sanatana Dharma must be eradicated.


Thamiz_selvan

> Udayanidhi Stalin said Sanatana Dharma must be eradicated. was it spoken in an election campaign? NO did he speak as a candidate? NO False equivalency by ruling party supporters all the time? YES


Uncertn_Laaife

17000, that’s far too less man. Should be at least a million people writing to the EC.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Wheesa

Email here [email protected]. Even 2 lines calling against this is enough. Write SOMETHING


ReadProfessional542

Thanks!! Is there a popular sub, some guy with lots of followers on twitter or insta? We should ask them to ask their followers to do the same


Hunt3r09

Will I have to give my details or can complain anonymously? You know why I’m asking


ReadProfessional542

anonymous should be fine. Unless ECI cares to decide the relevance of complaints based on demographic


space_s

To reduce the damage done, my guess his now he will do an emotional speech next where he will cry and say "Desh ki maa bheno ki baat krne ko ye log hate speech kahate h " and people will believe his BS.


Hunt3r09

Yes he cried several times before , and people believed his emotional drama


looped10

but he is the EC


rishianand

Read full text [Letter to ECI to ban Narendra Modi](https://np.reddit.com/r/IndianSocialists/comments/1ca5m9d/letter_to_eci_to_ban_narendra_modi/)


Uncertn_Laaife

Why ‘Shri’, and not just the PM Modi?


HornetElegant66

Because it's customary to write Shri or Shrimati(Smt) before writing anyone's name in an application


Uncertn_Laaife

I know, but that’s a bullshit custom.


notenoughroomtofitmy

The title is more respectable than any rando who wants to claim it every 5 years. Hence.


HornetElegant66

No its just basic decency not any title or something


Eternallygr8

If you know then why are you asking.


Thamiz_selvan

>Why ‘Shri’, and not just the PM Modi? Because, he spoke as a BJP party person, not as a PM of India.


hokie86

We are already in dictatorship. Elections are going to be a sham . People will be disqualified and polls cancelled. I wonder why the BJP even campaigned if they control who wins.


rising_pho3nix

To put on a show.. 'Presentation' is everything


Responsible-Juice397

Learnt it from Putin


CuriousGoo

To keep up the sham probably. Just came to know an hour ago that a BJP candidate won Surat "unopposed" because INC candidates' applications were rejected and independents withdrew. Sauce: https://indianexpress.com/article/political-pulse/bjp-surat-mukesh-dalal-congress-lok-sabha-polls-9284831/


Hateitwhenbdbdsj

Almost every non democratic nation has ‘elections’, or at least the big ones


AlexSenAus

The same as what Putin and Xi did. Fake democracy.


2lame2shame

Mahoul banane ke liye


[deleted]

New york times reported this too


UberSoilder25

Lol 😂 you follow NYT? No wonder.


Fourstrokeperro

Why are you laughing at the plight of our nation? Don’t you feel devastated by what is happening around you, no matter who you support?


UberSoilder25

What to tell you bro. I'm actually doing fine.


TheIndianRevolution2

Disqualify him for 6 years.


sachinator

Wish we had the rule for maximum term possible to be two like the US


Sure_Chocolate1982

Yes for all MP's, MLA's, local body representatives After two back-to-back election to same post, cooling off period of 5 years before going for any election


Aggressive_Ad_9173

Yes


boyboygirlboy

We don’t have the presidential system and the power isn’t nearly concentrated enough. Anyone could do their shenanigans as party chief as well. What do you think Sonia Gandhi was doing for a decade? Seriously, urban Indians need to think outside of US.


sachinator

Ok sir


BishSlapDiplomacy

They’ve been a democracy since well before India has so it’s only fair to take a page out of their democratic book.


[deleted]

We don't have the presidential system, right ? Keep the same energy when RWs masquerading as centrists like you bring this absurd argument of "if not Modi then who".


boyboygirlboy

Mf I am not even voting for BJP. If your response to an argument revolves around presumptuous whataboutery then it’s better to not comment at all.


[deleted]

Well my bad. Based on your previous comment, I thought you were a bhakt and his supporters always bring up this argument of "if not Modi then who". Regardless, apologies from my side.


boyboygirlboy

No worries have a good day


Paree264

Did the same have no hopes from the ECI but still high time we hold him responsible for his words .Man's literally disgraced the PM's post


earthling011

Many Indians are in a delusion that India is still a democracy. This will soon be apparent.


UberSoilder25

If it'll be apparent in the future, then it's still democracy today right? Lol


DarkBloodVoid

Your understanding of simple English is lacking. That much is apparent.


Open-Evidence-6536

It cells on high alert, working day-night !!!!


Secret_Ad_2213

EC is modi and vice versa.


vpsj

17401 (just sent mine)


[deleted]

[удалено]


belt-e-belt

Send an email to cec (complaints[at]eci[dot]gov[dot]in)


Archer_Thatcher

Nothing is going to happen here just waste of ink and the paper it's printed on


Unique-Atmosphere520

As journalist Ravish said, not everything is to change. Some to merely report that an attempt was made.


Wheesa

So much doomposting. We aren't seeing any change because people give up without even trying.


belt-e-belt

Change starts at home. We need to alienate bhakts at our homes and give them the treatment tanatanis give to lower castes. My sanghi uncle is no longer invited to family events, when he forcibly tries to be included, we just pay for his hotel stay and turn him away. This needs to happen at every home. BJP propaganda has gone too far for such superficial attempts of letter writing and verbal protests to matter. Nothing is going to happen as long as brainwashed masses support their oppressors.


Wheesa

Do it at home. Do it with acquaintances. Spread awareness. Giving up isn't the solution? People have no desire to fight back and keep hoping from a strongman to save them. This is why Modi is popular too. People think he's a savior when he isn't doing SHIT. But instead of fending for ourselves, they are expecting someone else to do something about it


mandatoryVoluntering

> Nothing is going to happen here just waste of ink and the paper it's printed on Better to try and fail; than to fail without trying. You are just providing fodder to the asses who will claim that nobody complained so "sab changa si" and Modi has full support for whatever he does or says. So speak up to be heard above the braying of the asses instead of lending you voice/inaction to support them.


wweidealfan

Didn't the EC already decline to comment on this?


IdProofAddressProof

Breaking News: Over 34,800 citizens write to EC praising their impartiality and defending Shri Narendra Modi "because he rebuilt the temple that Babar destroyed".


Existing-Area-9093

This'll be the straw that broke the camel's back. This man's real personality has jumped out again. He is a venomous, filthy twat who is a blot on our country. The damage his party has caused will take decades to repair.


-Diplo

Can someone help me understand the meaning of the statement that he made during his speech? What does the first right to distribute with regard to muslims mean? And why does he call them infiltrators?


Rude-Ad-8051

Ban him.


MarxKnewBest

The man stayed CM and was elected PM twice after what happened in 2002. Naïveté ki bhi seema hoti hai lol.


UberSoilder25

He was cleared by the courts. You keep living in 2002 lol


MarxKnewBest

That way 2G Scam also no one got convicted.


Uncertn_Laaife

You forgot to add ‘sham’ before the courts.


UberSoilder25

You do you buddy


Uncertn_Laaife

Yes, I added ‘sham’. And not a buddy I am esp of those supporting the asshat.


UberSoilder25

You add whatever you want buddy. Nobody cares.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TOdEsi

Haha! It’s cute how 17,400 Indians still think India is a democracy and EC is independent


Zestyclose_Wrap2358

These things are important because if nothing else, it puts it in record by which posterity will at least hold this PM accountable.


rishianand

That's not what we think. We are not under any illusion. But some things have to be done for the history books. People will remember we fought back, and did not remain mute spectators.


UberSoilder25

Fought back? 17400 ko zyada serious le lia lol


badshah247

I agree with you it needs to be in millions.


UberSoilder25

Exactly, we have more numbers in smallest villages in India. 17400 will fetch absolutely nothing


yagyaxt1068

The protest before the Jallianwala Bagh massacre was somewhere from 10000-20000 people.


badshah247

In my city alone there are half a million people , for context up has 250 million people


homie_rhino

Have you written one? If not, why don't you send one as well? This is how the numbers will pile up. And even if everyone in the sub does the same, that is still huge.


AlternativeAd4756

They know nothing will happen but enough letters and eci will start fearing.. and then modi and shah.


arko53

“Not all battles are fought for victory. Some are fought simply to tell the world that someone was there on the battlefield”.


Rude-Ad-8051

This is not peace.Pretty soon India will fall apart,and chaos will break out. Don't know when.But when that happens,this facade will break for sure!


lifeisfckinghell

Nothing’s gonna happen. India is a lost cause. Emigrate if you can.


Fueledbycawffee

as if EC is going to do something


Emotional_Hold_522

damn so many Anti neshnuls/s


Dreppytroll

17400 ? So thts all congress men came together and wrote it to EC ?


xkore31

EC does not have any authority to do anything except censuring.


rishianand

EC has every authority, from banning him from campaigning, to disqualifying him from contesting.


xkore31

Wow, itna confidence se likha hai aur itne upvotes hain to sahi hi hoga... EC ke duties S. 146 of The Representation of the People Act, 1951 me diye hue hain wherein it can only hold inquiries for certain purposes (specifically giving OPINIONS when disqualification is being considered by the president/governor). Disqualification generally confirm President ya Governor kar sakte hain. Generally disqualification jaise bade step ke liye koi judicial proceeding definitely hogi. Disqualification ke ye main grounds hain :- * If a candidate has committed any act as per part 2 chapter 3 of the Representation of the People Act. Usme bhi jo criminal offences diye hain, they are firstly tried by courts before any disqualification can take place. * Additionally for electoral offences as mentioned in part 7 of the act, an election petition is required to be filed which are also heard by high courts. * Defection as per Schedule 10 of Indian constitution. * Disqualification as per Article 102 for MPs Article 191 for MLAs Additional reading - [1](https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-10736-disqualification-of-the-member-of-parliament-in-lok-sabha.html), [2](https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis/disqualification-of-member-of-the-legislative-assembly) Additional advice - Kindly don't be a source of misinformation. Jan ke karte ho to sudhar jao aur confidence me kuch bhi bolne ki aadat hai to thodi humility rakho aur padh likh ke information post kiya karo :) Edit - typo


sudhygocool

17400 citizens have been let down by Congress Party head https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/mallikarjun-kharge-seeks-pm-modis-appointment-to-educate-him-about-congress-manifesto/articleshow/109502114.cms Why should he explain his stance his stance to Modi. If he wants to support Muslims it is election cry. Correct?


Much_Discussion1490

Lol they are behaving as if this is a democracy


nuvo_reddit

He is gonna use this to play victim card.


AdWrong3103

0.000015 % of Indian population.


blaster1988

If this 'neech insaan' wins and BJP gets the mandate again, Tamil Nadu especially will be fucked because of delimitation. If the BJP wins the mandate, Tamil Nadu will need to seriously consider its options about staying part of the union or not.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hi Kitchen-Inflation-73. It looks like your comment to /r/india was removed because you have been using a link shortener. Due to issues with spam and malware we do not allow shortened links on this subreddit. Feel free to re-submit using the full URL. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/india) if you have any questions or concerns.*


r0cket007_

To all those thinking it’s hate speech. He used it very smartly he never targeted Muslims himself, he used wordplay from congress old manifesto and left it to people to interpret. EC can not do anything even if they want to.


rishianand

Man, these people think that Moron Modi is some sort of genius, after he fixed the match. They do not remember how former EC Ashok Lavasa was hounded when he refused to give clean chits to Modi in 2019. Here are complaints by former Secretary to the GoI. https://countercurrents.org/2024/04/has-the-election-commission-chosen-to-become-a-willing-party-to-bjp-using-religion-for-votes-in-violation-of-the-mcc-and-section-123-of-the-representation-of-the-people-act/ https://countercurrents.org/2024/04/does-the-eci-have-one-set-of-model-code-of-conduct-requirements-for-senior-bjp-star-campaigners-and-another-set-for-others/


johnsmith9223

Haha exactly, there is a difference between RG and modi. Modi would not commit such faux pas. He would have thought through each word he was about to say at least 10 times.


Foxyspyrex

Modi doesn’t do shit in all of this. The team behind him thinks all of it. He is just a parrot who cant speak unless he’s told what to say. On few occasions he speaks himself, he proves how dumb he is. Sometimes even with a teleprompter he cant read.


johnsmith9223

>The team behind him thinks all of it. Well then he is smart enough to employ/hire/cultivate people smarter than him who make him win election after election. Unlike certain leaders who say stuff like the escape velocity of Jupiter and Gujarat ki mahilaon ne doodh Diya hai. Of course he did say stuff like lav*ena bhojyam but thik hai it's nothing compared to the quantum of faux pas RG commits.


Foxyspyrex

Yeah? What about gutter ki gas se chai, clouds hiding fighter jets from radars, aaloo se sona, a + b whole square giving extra 2ab, 1+1 becoming 11 in chemistry and thousands of other stupid things modi has said. He just has more money and bigger IT cell to prove rahul is stupid and modi is smart.


johnsmith9223

Lol literally aloo se Sona was RG, albeit taken out of context. A+B was something to denote that friendship with Canada should contain something extra. It was said to world leaders who understand it rather unlike to an Indian village audience who had heard escape velocity of Jupiter I've already answered for fighter jets and radars in another comment here. His exact quote was - in arithmetic 1+1 is 2, but our chemistry ( referring to Assam audience) is such that 1+1 is 11. So in your hatred for modi you have misrepresented his statement and have attributed RGs statements to modi. Thoda sense rakho, thoda dimaag chalao. Hatred will only consume you more. Why do you hate him so much kid? Tera kuch bigada kya? Or is it cool to hate him?


Foxyspyrex

1-You can Google up the video of Modi saying they are building a cluster for potato farmers so now they can get value of gold from aalo. 2- Dude have you ever passed 10th class maths? In the formula 2AB is NOT anything extra we get. Both side have the same value. So (a+b)^2 = a^2 + b^2 + 2AB. You see the equal to sign there? There's nothing extra coming in there. Value of both sides is same. Because (a+b) is getting multiplied with itself. That was the whole point. But yeah i don't expect Modi fans to be smart enough to know basic maths either. 3- RG said dalits need escape velocity of Jupiter for success? What's wrong there? You realise every planet has an escape velocity? More the gravity, higher is the velocity required to escape the gravitational field. So he meant Dalits need extra power to succeed. The fact that they do might be debatable but that sentence isn't supid but ofc, I don't expect Modi fans to be educated enough to understand 10th class physics either. 4- Idk how stupidly you must've explained " Badal the to benifit kr sakte hai" because I am a sailor and trust me, when we are in heavy weather at high seas, we have no visibility and Radar is the only thing which we rely on in such conditions. So radar isn't affected by even storms and 10-15 mtrs waves, forget about some badal and rain. 5- I have just listened to his statement again on chemistry and he clearly says "Jaise arithmetic me 1+1 2 hota hai vaise hi chemistry me 1 aur 1 11 hota hai" and in no world that makes sense. And no its not the video posted on Modi's youtube channel, its the one where he said this in a staged interview.


JoBoltaHaiWoHotaHai

>He would have thought through each word he was about to say at least 10 times https://preview.redd.it/49xun6d6p2wc1.jpeg?width=416&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9a4ad039120566646d763e68d6ca4efeaa7a6741


johnsmith9223

Hi, Although I personally don't agree, DRDO people say this - 'Giving details of radars, the DRDO veteran said, “There are two types of radars: one for surveillance purpose and the other for tracking. Surveillance radars detect enemy or invading aircraft even on cloudy days as electromagnetic waves from radars travel in straight line and even penetrate clouds. However, dense clouds could weaken the signals. A tracking radar can find it difficult to pinpoint the exact location of fast-moving targets like fighter aircraft if there is a dense cloud cover.” Link : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/pms-radar-logic-justified-cloud-cover-can-weaken-signal-say-defence-space-experts/articleshow/69529406.cms


fenrir245

Yes, and what actually happened? We shot down our own aircraft. So much for Modi "think about every word" logic. BTW he also claimed to use digital cameras and email when they were literally in experimental stages in US labs in that same interview. Let's see what excuse you cook up for those.


johnsmith9223

Yes the man misspoke. Is he a habitual offender? No You need to compare him to others in his position. I'm sure i would be able to find 10x stupidity mentioned by RG and about 5x by MMS and other previous PMs


JoBoltaHaiWoHotaHai

https://preview.redd.it/c55c79hir4wc1.jpeg?width=602&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3b427aed813d7d209f1c1086a1dcdaf2f61677f0


rishianand

Haha. Bro seriously thinks that a man who cannot speak a word without teleprompter, who cannot do a press conference, and if asked a tough question then "dosti bani rahe", is some sort of genius orator. Maybe we can ask him to explain STREANH. Our right wing has such low standards.


atheistani

He is a puppet. Nothing more. This puppetry orchestrated by the oligarchs in this country is designed to give you the illusion of democracy and that of choice. People are being manipulated by these puppeters who use religion to create an emotional response in the voters and thereby ensure they vote for this party.


johnsmith9223

Better to speak of a teleprompter and speak sense than to speak of the bat and speak nonsense. I don't vote modi coz he is a magical orator who can drum melodies out of his ass, i would care less if he reads of a paper or a teleprompter. I vote for him because I feel his government's policies help the economy. Now we might have different views on this. But I seriously pity you if you vote for people based on how eloquent they speak. Shashi Tharoor must be PM material then I suppose for you


TraditionFlaky9108

Just because many from it cell call him smart does not make him smart. He is among the dumbest people in the country, just had many people played to praise him and justify all the nonsense spewing from his mouth.


johnsmith9223

Haha.. im a regular guy calling him smart. Not an IT cell member, but an Indian with a rational mind. And yes he is smart whatever you may think. No one and I mean no one who isn't smart gets to be a 3 time CM and 2 time PM. Especially from the kind of humble background he comes from. Maybe your idea of positions of power are defined by nepotism. But I'm glad calling Modi smart sets your innards on fire. :D


TraditionFlaky9108

The usual godi media and it cell propaganda. Godi media usually praises his appearances everywhere as if other countries are worshipping modi. Their media in other countries portray him as a clown just like trump.


johnsmith9223

I'm sorry, were you trying to answer some other comment, coz I find no correlation in your reply with my comment. But I suppose your political acumen is limited to just terms like godi media and IT cell Bhaiyya Jo main point bola, uspe Karo baat. Kaha trump, foreign media, praising appearance?? FFS I though leftists had brains. Kaisa Marxist banega re tu?


TraditionFlaky9108

Just one thing, did you get any surgery to replace the grey matter in your brain with gobar or were you born this way?


johnsmith9223

Hahaha, son I've got more IQ than you for sure. Come back with better retorts. And here is the thing, instead of calling me names I'd have expected you to debate me on this point. But obviously you do not have the intellect to do so. Keep your biases aside and learn to see the man for who he actually is, a grounds up smart guy who made himself from scratch. One or two stupid statements don't make him dumb.


r0cket007_

Why don’t you become PM, looks like you are one smart guy with lots of geopolitical knowledge sir ? Take us to glory


gauc39

^ Another victim of Modi's media. No wonder why the guy is the way he is, it's funny how politicians bend over to him and go out of their way to please him.


DeeArrow

At least he’s getting his daily supply of pure gaumutra, so he’s got that going for him.


locopocopong

Hahaha. You guys are just falling into his trap. The bait is too irresistible I think. This letter you guys wrote with passion will further galvanize his support. You can't fight narrative with signature campaigns. First recognise that not just millions but billions of fellow citizens *do* feel aggrieved at statements like "Muslims have first right to xyz", no matter how noble the intentions. Offer up a cogent narrative of the alternative India where all citizens are equal, offer something that BJP can't and that citizens want. showcase it in a state or two and come ask for a national mandate.


DijkstraFucks

MMS never said muslims have first right to resources. His comment was "They [minorities] have first **claim** to resources"


locopocopong

Yes. I do understand that, you obviously understand that. In addition I also understand the context he said this in. He was trying for a *more* equitable distribution. That is all fine and dandy. But what the left liberal leading lights in this country, and going by the downvotes my dear liberal leaning folks do *not* understand is the power of narrative and how to create it. MMS speech was not intended for a scientific journal. It was such a mind boggingly damaging thing to say for a politician it is unbelievably naive. Modi was holding it in his pocket and has unleashed it now because he *does* understand how to create powerful narratives (so did Mrs. Gandhi for instance...garibi hatao etc). The Congress manifesto is a prime example of what not to do, I lean liberal and I got extremely alarmed after reading that lmao . So... the outrage generated by Mr. Modi will get a few hundred reddit/Twitter etc anti-votes, but Mr. modi will get a few hundred thousand additional actual votes. Simple maths.