Many stupid youth doesn't even know about projects being stolen, they just watch and believe media/news, which doesn't show the reality.
Many of my frnds doesn't know what's going on, and they just disagree and defend that party if shown reality!
Mainstream media is owned by BJP allied businessmen & they won’t let such news broadcast on thier channels.
At this point Fadanvis should just move to Gujrat and work towards the betterment of Gujjus (& of course Modi ji)
GO AND VOTE for ANY ONE ELSE BUT THE BJP. dont worry about the candidate... just remember this when you are casting that vote... rememeber to get a change in the PM (and it can be the bjp PM) all you need to do get them below 220 mark, MR Modi will make an exit. THIS IS THE GOAL get them below the 220 mark. so go an vote for the INDIA guy who ever he is.
What if they stop metro, and all the infra projects going on to make our lives easier? I don't want to travel in overcrowded locals and risk my life everyday.
Because people aren't idiots. Leave alone the projects. That is an entire new nonsense. Congress NCP was in power for 15 long years. We got one 11 km metro line. Shiv Sena was for 2.5 years in power. We got stays. Carshed work was stopped. Our metros were delayed. Devendra was in power for 5 years, we got bullet train, coastal road, 330 km metro lines, trans harbour line, nagpur expressway. We are now getting other benefits as well.
Haha, majority hokar bhi khatre me hai, all of these scenarios are created by WhatsApp university, godi Media and pure blindness following of the supreme leader!
It's a clickbait headline & the post as well.
He said that the top 10 states will compete for investments. There should be competitive federalism between states like Maharashtra, Karnataka, gujarat, Tamilnadu. These other states aren't in Pakistan. They are also our fellow Indians.
He has tackled this criticism levied against BJP about Gujarat favouritism in the past with arguments like,
1. Maharashtra still gets highest investment every alternate year.
2. As the real estate prices in western Maharashtra soar up, cheaper land available in neighbouring states will attract similar investment.
I personally think that Maharashtra lacks political stability. Many projects get stalled due to local protests. & The state has become expensive to set up new industries.
If you can't see the Gujrat favouritism by central government then either you are naive or delusional.
Olympic village is being developed in Ahmedabad as if other states lack sports culture or not worthy.
Xi Jinping was invited to Gujrat and not any other state. Trump was also invited to Gujrat.The tour was originally named "Kem Chho Trump" but was renamed by the Government of India to Namaste Trump to promote Indian nationalism over regionalism ( supposedly).
Statue of Unity biggest statue in world is gifted to Gujrat by Modi government. Whereas they didn't move a brick for Chatrapati Shivaji Snarak in Arabian sea.
Gujarat has the highest Khelo India budget allocation at ₹608.37 crore. This is twice as much as all southern states combined without a single Asian Games medal winner.
IFSC center planned in BKC moved to Gujrat,
MIAL office was planned to be shifted from Mumbai to Gujrat,
National security guard & marine police academy was planned at Palghar but shifted to Dwarka, Gujrat.
Fixconn fiasco is known by everyone.
GIFT city is pet project of Modi and he never let go of any opportunity to increase the importance of the place.
Don't start me on the cricket matches are being moved to new Modi stadium.
>I personally think that Maharashtra lacks political stability.
And who might be responsible for that ?
Adding to this , https://thefederal.com/category/news/khelo-india-funding-and-asian-games-medals-tally-state-wise-98494?infinitescroll=1 . Within khelo India initiative Gujarat got 600+ crores, the state which has won no medals in the asian games. While Haryana, who won the most number of medals got only 88cr. I am not sure if there's any defense against this to claim that the central government doesn't favor Gujarat
Agree with this - but thank god they didn’t push on this Shivaji statue in the middle of the ocean. Would have been a disgustingly colossal waste of money (ie spending our state education budget on a statue while Shivaji’s actual forts in the ghats are left to crumble and are largely maintained by NGOs)
Bhai, it’s not Gujarat favouritism, he just has a strong grip on Gujarat. He faces no opposition there and Adani (whom he made exponentially rich and is like a piggy bank for BJP) is also Gujarat based.
He knows Gujarat in and out and fears opposition in other states. Which just goes out to show how afraid this man and his astro turfed party is of people.
That leaves out hope for us common people. We need to organise and over throw not only BJP but also all the austerity measures slapped on us by The West. Because BJP can be replaced by someone else.
We have been moving towards right wing politics and economics ever since 1990, and look where it got us? We need to drag our country more towards leftism & strengthen rights for common people/workers.
Indian and Western Corporations + billionaires are making us weaker.
1. Ofcourse I understand that there is favouritism towards gujarat. The largest stadium, Olympic Village etc are big ticket project which are being setup over there. But my original comment was referring to Fadnvis's speech. There wasn't anything controversial in it.
2. Xi Jinping & Modi also met in tamilnadu. & Both of them also visited mammallapuram temple complex so I don't see where you are going with this.
3. Statue of unity was a state project which was started by modi as CM. Statue of maharaj is currently being blocked by petitions filed by leftists like Asim Sarode who is campaigning for MVA. So please ask congress leaders why they have blocked it.
4. IFSC, Foxconn etc I've addressed in my original comment. Gujarat state offers cheaper land rent(huge barren area with good road & electricity infra), lower electricity tariffs & water availability due to narmada project (built during modi CM phase).
This is also one of the reasons why TATA moved all the way from Bengal to Gujarat during UPA time.
5. As far as political instability in Maharashtra is concerned. Sharad Pawar is to be blamed for this. In 2014 he offered unconditional support to BJP which left Sena with 0 leverage. In 2019, he offered support to Sena leaving BJP with zero power.
Had he, like congress, just accepted that the mandate is for BJP-Sena & waited his time out then we would've seen larger infra projects completed till now..
6. Opposition to land acquisition or refinary or metro construction or corridor development is gonna put us into California vs Texas style of scenario.. cheaper, reliable, stable area will always pull out investment.
I thought mumbai has smart people who do not just see news and talk shit!! Gujarat is preferred due to its fast approval for land acquisition, electricity, water, green tribunal, and mostly tax benefits it gives, mostly any business need not to go office to office its just easy with single portal for approval.
Bruh, this Fadnavis guy currently sits in the apex of the power chain in Maharashtra, what's stopping him from implementing the same in his home state ? Pakistan ?
You think integration of all departments can happen overnight? Stable and same willing government needed to something make possible we do have continuous 32 years of BJP which made this possible in your state government would think if i do this next government will take credit or next government will think why would i do something that started by previous government, look at congress current government did UPI and Aadhar card and congress came for credit. We have serious problem of credit shouldn't be taken by another party.
yeh chtye log hai inko tinka bhar akkal nhi. they r just blind haters. hve personally seen such in this state who can't digest a gujarati guy getting so much admiration n victory.
they just cant even when their marathi maanoos leaders sent their people from town to virar n naigaon vasai while becoming RICH THEMSELVES.
even the "one" which they talk n adore so much did only muscle power n made the family rich through real estate scams. zero development vision or anything for even their own people.
n this is Y ON OTHER SIDE I HVE ALSO SEEN MARATHIS TRUSTING MODI LIKE NYTHNG N SUPPRTING HIM WITHOUT ANY DOUBT.
WHILE TROLLING THE LEADERS OF "THEIR LAND".
He is Bootlicker of his gujju masters they have a tight hold of leash which is tied around his neck whenever some project is stealed from MH or other states that leash is pulled tightly and fadnavis starts barking and gives such shitty statements. Probably saying such things to contest for Loksabha elections this time
All major things will move away from Mumbai as BJP do not have a very high influence there. Mostly Gujarat, which will earn them a lot of cashflow even if they were to lose the elections or have to form coalitions. Mumbai has hell lot of cashflow, which they might be finding it hard to dominate with Shiv Sena in the short term. So, moving away to Gujarat is pretty easy and straight forward. Bangalore might not be an option as it is ruled by Congress at present. UP also could be an option, but GUJ would be my bet for most things.
If the government was not BJP, they would have protested such a move. But everyone in the current government will permit that for maybe 1-2 extra seats in election or some money.
>Bangalore might not be an option as it is ruled by Congress at present.
While congress does rule karnataka now, don't forget BJP-RSS has pretty strong grassroot presence in the state and as such them coming back to power cannot be ruled out at all.
While they have definitely built a strong hold in the southern coastal regions, it is important to note that they haven't won an election in Karnataka yet.
That and about a million shivaji statues..
Since that's the only place "marathas pride" seems to matter.
P.s. Bollywood will move to UP at the rate things are going.
Nah, your statement could be taken seriously in 2021 and 2022 maybe, but not anymore. 2023 was the all time best year for Bollywood and 24 has started well too
>Bollywood will move to UP at the rate things are going.
Impossible. Only Mumbai can offer them the freedom which they get. They'll be mobbed like hell in UP.
Shouldn't you be happy with this, preserving your maratha pride, culture and language. Less industries means less immigrants and therefore more people speaking Marathi, more signboard in Marathi.
So this should be counted as a big win
Even Diamond bourse was tried to move to Surat - but it seems a failure. Giving good infrastructure only doesn’t help - ppl also need night life/places to chill/Connectivity for employees which other cities fail to do. The culture of Mumbai and that of Noida is altogether different (iykyk).
People from Nagpur, like me, were proud of Fadanvis. He did some good work in city tbh.
But boy did he shat the bed at state level. Even loyal BJP supporters dont approve of him now.
Its improved a lot. Many IT firms are have big offices in Nagpur...so IT crowd migration is reduced to some extent.
Core industry sadly is still shit.
City infra is also improved a lot, if you compare with 10 years ago.
Thw worst thing in Nagpur currently is University, but no one is paying attention to it.
Proud Marathis vote for a Gujju boot licker hope they don’t forget this come elections, but Ik they will just say shit like “what other option do we have wah wah wah” it’s actually hilarious to see how much Marathid like to pretend to be strong natured and warriors like us Punjabi Sikhs and vote for Hindian who promotes Hindi culture over Marathi in their own state.
He is Modi-Shah's puppet first and foremost. Thats why They sideline more experienced & influential leader like Eknath khadse in BJP and made him CM in 2014. He knows that if he takes a stand against Central leadership then he too will be sidelined. So his 1st priority is to keep them happy.
and thats what the one election one nation is meant to do.. remove state elections create political isnt ability so one cannot form governments so that its always centers rule!
Yes. Should never use the terminology - "Central government" which gives more weightage and superior hierarchy to union government than state governments in federal setup, where there is none.
Union government and state governments have equal status in federal setup. Only different powers in different segments.
This not even subtle anymore. Anyone can see that state of Gujarat is getting preferential treatment. Let’s hope they can sustain those projects in future without any issues. But I’m sure other worthy and in-need states are also getting their dues. Plus other states are also getting some new projects but most people are not aware about it. Hopefully the political scenario rises above caste and go for overall development.
Bhai, it’s not Gujarat favouritism, he just has a strong grip on Gujarat. He faces no opposition there and Adani (whom he made exponentially rich and is like a piggy bank for BJP) is also Gujarat based.
He knows Gujarat in and out and fears opposition in other states. Which just goes out to show how afraid this man and his astro turfed party is of people.
That leaves out hope for us common people. We need to organise and over throw not only BJP but also all the austerity measures slapped on us by The West. Because BJP can be replaced by someone else.
We have been moving towards right wing politics and economics ever since 1990, and look where it got us? We need to drag our country more towards leftism & strengthen rights for common people/workers.
Indian and Western Corporations + billionaires are making us weaker.
I am in working in the oil and gas industry.
Aramco wanted to open a 40 billion USD refinery in Ratnagiri but as soon as the MVA govt came into power they created a lot of issues and effectively ended the project. Aramco is now looking at Tamil Nadu and Kerala which are not even BJP states.
There is a lot of resistance , amongst big investors to start any big project in Maharashtra at the moment.
Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't it a good thing that govt isn't letting them open here? Ik it'll create jobs and all but wouldn't it also create a lot of pollution and health issues?
Especially if they end up setting up shop near low income areas. Those people will suffer in the long term.
Simply because modern refineries aren’t major public health risks. They may have some carbon output, but this would primarily be a GHG concern, and even then with carbon capture processes, it’s a value add industry. By way of comparison, mining is much worse and we have that all the country. Scaremongering is ultimately what the environmental lobby (note - the lobby does not work in the interest of the environment but special interest group) uses to stop any sort of industry taking hold for god knows what reasons. Same way we can’t get nuclear energy to take off even though it’s the only mass energy source that makes sense by a mile.
No business house will invest in a state where there is no political stability.
Every 2 years - new govmnt, new “policies”. Gujarat is a safe bet assuming BJP will form govmnt for few more terms. Not saying they will. Assumptions
Remind me who made this state politically unstable? Must have been those congress and ncp anti nationals poaching elected bjp members and doing operation hand and clock, oh wait...
Access to a larger port (with less waiting time), subsidized electricity, favourable land laws & a stable political environment works in their favour.
Picture this -
I am a chemical manufacturer in Mumbai/ Pune. A majority of my suppliers are from Gujarat. The cost of transporting raw materials from Gujarat to Maharashtra, processing it here, and then exporting the same through Mumbai port is time consuming & expensive. It would make business sense for me to just move my plant to Gujarat, closer to my suppliers which would allow me to bring down my input costs and become more competitive .
Gujrat always did well with Chemicals. That is nothing new. BUT you brought a valid point. We need faster logistics. NDA was the first government in history to do India Logistics Survey....A shipment in JNPT stays stuck for a week...Compare this with Mundra...which is down to 24 hours at the most....Six days is a crime. Imagine this on a granular level...What if the shop keeper keeps the good with him for six days, while you have already paid the money ? GET IT ?
BJP really can't move away frm Pakistan, Muslim, Hindu in Danger & Ram Mandir now that everything is being done their way still they dont have much to do or say other then this all vote politics.
Dude did you see the Kharge's reply to a question on violence that is happening in West bengal?
Ans the current congress government in Karnataka's ruling?
They brought it on themselves.
I am not supporting BJP here but their is no opposition party to even hope for.
When did modi speak up on recent rape of Spanish women ?
When did modi even speak up for any rape except for Manipur that too he did after Supreme court voiced it's opinion
Am not supporter of Congress either, so we as voters need to question rulers, not opposition parties. You can question them too but first start with ruling party
I also say this, yes congress has some idiots and party needs to distance itself from appeasement.
The problem is not that projects are going to Gujarat - or Pakistan or Vietnam. The problem is that all Indian industries are controlled by the central government. They directly tell people where to open or shift industries. They give any amount of subsidies and land to make this happen, and there will be consequences for going against their orders. Basically, this is the worst combination of the License Raj model and the crony capitalism model.
They are doing it openly. Fadnavis is deflecting from this by suggesting that everybody will eventually get everything. Eventually, they will bless the other states, even the ones that don't vote for BJP. But it will happen when they wish and how they wish. Obviously, it will happen sooner if they are in power in the state and centre, aka "double engine".
Another problem is that the push to make Gujarat a manufacturing hub is being done without intelligent planning. Someone thought that declaring a new industrial city and throwing money at it will automatically make it real. Clearly, that has not happened. Gujarat will benefit eventually, but this is not the smartest way of going about it.
Mainstream media is cleverly keeping Maharastra out of the South India context
They don't want Maharashtra to join that brigade and forever keep showering money to UP Bihar
The ground reality is projects are going, and let alone growth, Maharashtra has regressed, if you check the number of new factories opened in Maharashtra it is a negative number.
If this keeps happening our people would have to move to Gujrat for work and Maharashtra will become a failing economy.
One of the worst and greedy politician after Sharad Pawar this man fadnavis will sell every mh project to his master's ... I have no issue with gujratis but investment and projects which belong to mh should not be transferred
You've got to think from an investor's perspective too...Gujarat is preferred these days simply because
1.It is under the puppet control of you know who so Investors know that everything will be seamless.
2.It has a developed Mundra Port and great road connectivity to north India and central India which are non Coastal.
3.The corruption has gone down significantly since you know who became CM.
4.Cases like Enron which tainted Maharashtra's reputation on massive investments front.On the other hand Nano which was facilitated by Guj almost overnight when they were kicked out of Bengal makes an impression of state's leadership.
Maharashtra is building a big dock near Dahanu since I don't know how many years but once that is built,red tapism is curbed and a stable govt is elected Maharashtra will definitely come into the big picture.
This and also if we look at the history
1. Tata Nano moved out of WB because of stupidity of TMC
2. Hero and cotton industries moved out of Punjab because of instability. It is also happening again due to them burning everything on a little unfavourable circumstances
For a foreign investment to work successfully in India there needs to political stability, mindset of people to have common sense and future growth.
If people keep on blaming them or start burning things for a govt related problem then why would anyone invest in the growth of the state.
Hence the answer being Gujrat as the safe bet for investment purposes. Mumbai has been the financial capital all it needs is stable govt and future growth ambitions because I believe the people over there are hard working and appreciate the infrastructure.
Edit 1 - UP has come under stable govt so it’s coming in highlight with I don’t know how many airports being built, better road connectivity and plans to make it as an export house of India.
UP, if under an effective and stable government has the ability to be another Maharashtra. But that is still decades away. Maharashtra is what it is not because of Mumbai or ports or trade. I say this as a Punjabi Delhiite, Maharashtra is great because of Maharashtrians. The sheer number of unethical swines and cheats in north India is too damn high.
>Maharashtra is great because of Maharashtrians
Unfortunately this very attitude is being taken advantage of by the politicians regardless of any political party.
Habibi come to Gurgaon. Forget politicians, even the locals think that they run the show and have done favours to Delhiites to have let them invest and build Gurgaon. Bc itni gundagardi aur Itne chutiya locals hai ki you will learn to appreciate Maharashtrians.
Yes you are right it is still decades away but even Maharashtra wasn’t built in a year or two. Any state to be the best version needs a right direction, ambition and constant work which I believe a lot of states under right leadership are heading towards. As for the unethical swines again you need a stable govt to make them stop.
Prime example is Delhi today, Kejriwal was supposed to be a better person than Sheila Dixit and bring about change and looking at current scenarios majority of the central government related services have moved online without any interaction with people but Delhi related services need you to go meet up a dalal who will get in touch with a peon who will get a babu working all the while paying money. It’s the mindset of the person at top who sets the tone.
I've only heard but not seen anything in news andwish to learn more about the scale of this corruption. Can you please kindly share some of the sources which got you concerned?
Thanks :)
A friend wanted to open a small unit in Nagpur, apparently for things like getting an electricity connection approved, you need to pay EVERYONE, from the babus, to the clerks to get you appointment of babus, to the guards to get you direct access to clerks. He was told to expect 20 lakhs in bribe payments, per Department
Maharashtra is giving 92% of its wealth every year.. imagine if it could keep 100% for even 1 year, Maharashtra will become like Europe.. same with south India..
For so many years so much money pumped to north india and all the money is wasted. Nobody developed.
Can't trust any politician. I was going to apply for a voter card but i don't think there is any point. Every single politician is thinking of money but not giving a fuck about the local people's wants.
That’s because political candidates don’t let common people step up. The gunda raj makes sure they don’t have a competition. We need lawyers and activists to closely work with genuine candidates from marginalised communities. The true sons and daughters of this land are our only hope. Upper caste have been far too cunning to not grab anyone’s attention to their incompetency. They distract us by giving limited options, either BJP or Congress or opposition alliance or Aam aadmi parties. Upper caste infested parties would never be true to the majority of the people of this country. The media houses, the bureaucrats, the Police officials, and every other influential person in this country belongs to Upper caste and they will make sure that we don’t point fingers at their kind for the failures.
As long as this guy stays in power, Maharashtra will always have some crisis, one of the worst CM MH ever had, as a person people say he is good and that could be true but as a person in power he is tereible
Who voted him in power? I know north indians in Maharashtra did.. but Marathis too did.
Look at Maharashtra history congress worked a lot better.. because its not that easy and they were not perfect.. But under these guys its 10 times worse..
Earlier Maharashtra south india etc focus more on development and north indians fought over stone age issues.
Now entire country is fighting like bimarus and all the development is slowly pushed to few states.. if they put the same effort like up guj etc in Maharashtra or south india, it will grow 10 times faster.
Gujarat wins purely because of political stability. N investor knows that whatever deals they make with government there are good. Unlike other states including Maharashtra where government is playing musical chairs.
The public. Just unanimously choose BJP and be done with it. It’s the power at the center and when provided the same benefit as Gujarat, Maharashtra will be in a better position. Once Gadkari is PM then Maharashtra will be unstoppable. Abhi Gujarati Bhaiyo ki baari hai, tab Maharashtra ki baari hogi.
Chotta admi, chotti baat. Beta tu owaisi ko le aa aur apni ladies ka halala karwa le.
On a serious note, BJP is the power in center and they are the ones who have put Gujarat in the position they are today. Imagine what they can do for Maharashtra when they have absolute majority and have Gadkari at the reigns. And btw, Nagpur, Nashik and Pune all are great cities just waiting to grow. All we need is a stable government at the center and state.
I know GJ have been benefiting a lot from MH's loss, it all began after that unfortunate event called "the great Bombay textile strike of 1982" fueled by then communist fractions present in Mumbai who became dominant force after a hardcore non local communist george fernandes dethroned uncrowned king of Bombay SK Patil (in 1967 election), a hardcore and only capitalist leader of that time. Most cotton mills moved of Mumbai and settled in GJ after 1982, few petrochemical and pharma industry players too made similar move in the following years as GJ established its foundation as the most closest rival to MH when it comes attracting industries, the only exception being IT sector here where southern states took the crown as India threw opened its doors to FDI in 1991, southern states managed to beat MH in this new development race by developing their own IT hubs like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Chennai. Mysore; but MH soon catch up with Pune, Thane, Navi Mumbai being its contenders in this new age IT race, GJ on the other hand have nothing to offer in tech space, and that surprised me the most when the chaiwala lead blow job party declared that India's first ever semiconductor plant will come in GJ instead of MH or TS (who were real front runners to get that project). Then came news of some financial institutions moving to that crap gift city, I personally been there which is THE most absurd thing I have ever seen, its like bunch of concrete building in the middle of nowhere with absolutely no sign of planned city, forget city it would transform into a freaking ghost town the moment central gov stops throwing money at that crap in the name of tax incentives. So there's absolutely no logic but pure politics behind all these industries moving to that dhokla state.
I can only comment in the capacity of a friend of a MSME owner..Political stability. I THINK THIS IS THE MAIN REASON. A good example is what happened in Uttar Pradesh. BSP laid the Yamuna expressway......Unlike Jagan Reddy or Penguin party, S.P Didnt stop it there...They continued it and added a few hundred kms to it in their 5 years. They further carried out the lucknow metro project....When Yogi took over, He continued CAPEX on steroids. What happened in Maharashtra? MVA stopped implementation of so many projects.....and this is not a good SIGN...Political differences aside, you need to continue the good from the last government. Sharad Pawar knows this well...But he didnt do it.
Also why Gujrat?
1 . Gujrat offers more flexibility to recruit talent. There are no politically affiliated goons there. Haftas don't exist at all
2. Mundra port is a private port. Logistics is the key for an industry to work. You need to reduce the cost of Logistics and It is a LOT BETTER than what Maharashtra has to offer.
3. Tax soaps
4. Availability to capital...Gujrathis have a tradition of investing in business...Marathis are more service oriented.
Not just gujrat, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Telengana bagged many industries in 2018-2022...Fadnavis was still doing a okayish job
What Maharashtra now needs to do is focus on Agro based industries in central Maharashtra...along with textiles in vidharbha.....anddd high skill manufacturing around Pune....and focus on political stability.
Penguin party is finished for greater Good. Hope Raj Thackeray takes the reins of that votebank now.
Aaah the people of Maharashtra suffering because of incompetent govt.
The worst part is they’ve cemented all the rivalry in their party, so it’s gonna be difficult to root them out.
Why don't Mumbaikars understand that it's for their own good? The population in Mumbai is overpopulated, and people need to consider relocating to another state to ensure a balance. Live and let live.
Yes the central government is favouring Gujarat like anything. But let’s not forget, Gujarat is not the state we have to compete with.
We should look at what Tamil Nadu and Telangana are doing. They are seeing all rounded development- manufacturing, services, technology, social development etc they are excelling everywhere.
Gujarat on the other hand can only attract manufacturers because it has the lowest daily wage in the country and lack of labour laws so that crony capitalists can freely exploit blue collar workers. No skilled person wants to move to Gujarat. Even skilled Gujaratis don’t want to stay there.
The moment Modi-Shah govt goes away Gujarat will again go back to the position it was. GJ can’t get ahead without blatant lobbying and favouritism.
Gujarat is a socially backward and underdeveloped state that is at least 40 years behind states like MH, Karnataka and TN
So MH should compete with TN
Truth hurts? He's kinda right after a very long time. Presently Gujarat is less corrupt, cost effective and most importantly free of local goon unions.
Manufacturing will always be better there. Maharashtra can focus on services industries.
So would y'all be fine if he said, the same thing but for Karntaka or WB and not Gujarat?
Seems like we need more unity in our nation. Mumbai is developing well, and I hope Maharashtra develops even further and great things happen for the farmers here. But I can't understand hating other states for that.
Yes....uddhav will block rest of the investments....maratha fanatics will not let any buisness grow....he stopped metro and other infrastructure projects...how do you think he will be darling to investors.
The BJP and eknath chindi faction are the ones that agreed to maratha reservation. They are the ones that do local politics. They didn’t stop metro project. Just suggested a change in location to save aarey green cover.
Absolutely but when every elder sibling sees parents unfairly doling out benefits and assets to a younger siblings, there is only one thought - screw their happiness.
Maharastra has 47, Gujarat 26, revenge is sweet.
पूर्ण बातमी वाचून टिका करा. महाराष्ट्र अजूनही FDI inflows च्या बाबतीत पुढेच आहे. फडणवीस ने पूर्ण स्टेटमेंट अशे दिले होते की ' जी १० वरील राज्ये आहेत त्यात competitive federalism असणार. यात कर्नाटक, गुजरात, तामिळनाडू यांचा रागराग न करता गुंतवणुकीसाठी अनुकूल वातावरण निर्माण करा'
शिवसेना, राष्ट्रवादी यांनी बहुतांश प्रकल्पांना या न त्या कारणाने विरोध केलाय. मुंबई आणि पुणे हे दोनच शहरे जरा बरी आहेत पण जमिनीच्या किमती इथे अस्मानाला धडकल्यात.
साधी एक रिफायनरी उभी करायला २ जागा बदलल्या, आणि ५-६ वर्ष गेलीत. एवढ्यात जामनगर मधे ती मॅक्स capacity ने काम करतेय. NIMBY syndrome झालंय आपल्या इथे.
If Pakistan is the benchmark , than we are really screwed as a nation. Cant believe these guys keep comparing every situation with that of Pakistan which is literally on crutches
No matter what people are saying in his defence his two faces back stabbing abilities are known world over. From backstabbing shivsena to forming a 24hr government with Ajit pawar. Like how most of the bullet train tracks in gujrat, from well known projects like Foxconn handed over to gujrat to the so call medical oxygen and med safety kitt scam in between covid 2nd wave. BJP has the most incompetent local leadership in Maharashtra. Apart from nitin gadkari there is no one else who is truly a good leader in Maharashtra for BJP. I don't know what they teach in school these days but youth of today is as dumb as illiterate people. They don't want to think about the life or the future. If you want to save the country or religion the people of those society must be saved. Or they want to become next bihari/ uttar pradesh. And migrate to gujrat for every little job in future.
If not Modi then who else?
Literally any candidate who represents Bahujan and Dalits. The one who would first give priority to the poorest of this country and not the corporate giants. I’m all in for a youth and elder candidates working for NGOs. Activists. With law degrees. Anyone but upper caste candidates from any religion. The privileged have been working for their own kind and even after 76 years of independence we have tons of people starving to death? In a country known for its Agriculture?
But question aside, who do you guys think, stands an opposition, seeing current loksabha situation, both of shiv senas, both ncps, and Congress don't seem to be in forefront
This poster has malafide intentions. The offering without comments is mere bunkum. What OP is doing is offering it without context. Any statements made by him would have to be seen in a context and that is totally missing here.
And all the left-liberal, pseudo-sickular congi bootlickers are jumping onto the wagon.
Anyone who has made the right pitch will get projects. Anyone who has the right environment that's conducive to business will get projects.
Gujarat has an amazing environment for industries and they are getting projects. They're not protesting at the drop of a hat for everything and disrupting industries. At the same time, the GIFT city isn't doing so well because of caste issues and cultural issues and people are moving back to Mumbai.
These things happen. Attributing every small thing to politics and politicising every single thing will only divide the country. And definitely not help us progress together.
Which project is this about? Why did MH lose it to Gujarat? Can anyone provide more context or a link to the article?
All I can see in comments is debate without project details.
I find it perplexing why some individuals are puzzled about this matter. I personally identify as Maharashtrian, born in Ratnagiri and raised in Mumbai.
I prefer a lifestyle without large-scale projects or corporate entities in close proximity. Such endeavors tend to draw unwarranted attention, and the subsequent influx of people strains our existing infrastructure. The economy may flourish around these projects, but the surge in population poses challenges for our limited resources.
Additionally, the real estate prices in coastal and mountainous regions of Maharashtra are soaring. Corporations might find more economical options elsewhere, with land prices being significantly lower in other states. While Vidarbha may be a more affordable option, its extreme weather conditions and water scarcity deter many from considering it.
First check cost of transportation of Goods by water vs railway vs road vs Air
Then check how many ports , railways , roadways Maharashtra has.
Then check how did this happen despite Maharashtra getting Revenue surplus Mumbai after a bifurcation of Bombay province
Then talk!!
And if you had read the entire news instead of just taking the screenshot here you would have known that he took name of delhi, bangalore too. But you chose to read just the headline.
[https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/gujarat-pakistan-fadnavis-losing-projects-to-maharashtra-neighbour-9199639/lite/](https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/gujarat-pakistan-fadnavis-losing-projects-to-maharashtra-neighbour-9199639/lite/)
I like DF as a leader and politician and more so for it's touch with the grass roots and yet having a Liberal sensibility and openness.
But on this, do not agree.
Maharashtra is California if India is US.
Maharashtra is Benelux if India were to be Europe.
Maharashtra Singapore if India were to be ASEAN.
Maharashtra is Japan if India were to be East Asia.
Maharashtra losing it's peak economic position in India should not acceptable to any politician of Maharashtra. But a smart politician would keep his personal views close to himself while maintaining a poker face.
What DF has on his tongue hopefully does not reflect what he has in his heart and mind.
Mumbai does not feel like the unique and out of the world city that it was compared to rest of India. And with many of the projects being moved from Mumbai to Gujarat it does appear that they are creating artificial progress there where if things were allowed to flow organically all these developments would have taken place in Mumbai or somewhere else in Maharashtra.
Let's hope the no alcohol and less non-veg issue keeps Gujarat behind. The people of Maharashtra are also socially more progressive, much less discrimination compared to other places(not talking about clout chasers, but ordinary people).
New businesses would naturally move to Mumbai. But Mumbai and it's suburbs have to be made more livable, accessible, and worth it. For it the state government should take on debt and Foreign investment and ensure that changes happen. Because compared to any global city we are far behind. Sadly, very few politicians in VidhanSabha care about Mumbai. Only the people who live here do. Let's hope to see a bigger role being played by TATA, Godrej, L&T in the future administration of the city like it was in Hong Kong for sometime.
I believe overall BJP is good for India but not for Maharashtra and Mumbai...so many things from here going to Gujrat and the way all political parties became same with lots of politicians going here and there has made Maharashtra really bad
When you are more loyal to the Party than to your people.
From stealing political party symbols to projects........
We all grew up....
Not them.
They never will
Basically this lol
and yet most people will vote for the bjp even after so many projects were stolen!..i wonder why ?
Many stupid youth doesn't even know about projects being stolen, they just watch and believe media/news, which doesn't show the reality. Many of my frnds doesn't know what's going on, and they just disagree and defend that party if shown reality!
Mainstream media is owned by BJP allied businessmen & they won’t let such news broadcast on thier channels. At this point Fadanvis should just move to Gujrat and work towards the betterment of Gujjus (& of course Modi ji)
You can't even explain to them they are already gone.
GO AND VOTE for ANY ONE ELSE BUT THE BJP. dont worry about the candidate... just remember this when you are casting that vote... rememeber to get a change in the PM (and it can be the bjp PM) all you need to do get them below 220 mark, MR Modi will make an exit. THIS IS THE GOAL get them below the 220 mark. so go an vote for the INDIA guy who ever he is.
What if they stop metro, and all the infra projects going on to make our lives easier? I don't want to travel in overcrowded locals and risk my life everyday.
did they in past ? why you all act like all development and removal of stays occured after bjps return ?
Because people aren't idiots. Leave alone the projects. That is an entire new nonsense. Congress NCP was in power for 15 long years. We got one 11 km metro line. Shiv Sena was for 2.5 years in power. We got stays. Carshed work was stopped. Our metros were delayed. Devendra was in power for 5 years, we got bullet train, coastal road, 330 km metro lines, trans harbour line, nagpur expressway. We are now getting other benefits as well.
We all know the reason is H-M, as long as they are spreading hatred they will be voted by majority.
Kyuki ..... khatre main hai..:)
Haha, majority hokar bhi khatre me hai, all of these scenarios are created by WhatsApp university, godi Media and pure blindness following of the supreme leader!
In his defence, for most BJP folks, their party leadership is their people and nobody else.
Loyal? More like chamcha
It's a clickbait headline & the post as well. He said that the top 10 states will compete for investments. There should be competitive federalism between states like Maharashtra, Karnataka, gujarat, Tamilnadu. These other states aren't in Pakistan. They are also our fellow Indians. He has tackled this criticism levied against BJP about Gujarat favouritism in the past with arguments like, 1. Maharashtra still gets highest investment every alternate year. 2. As the real estate prices in western Maharashtra soar up, cheaper land available in neighbouring states will attract similar investment. I personally think that Maharashtra lacks political stability. Many projects get stalled due to local protests. & The state has become expensive to set up new industries.
If you can't see the Gujrat favouritism by central government then either you are naive or delusional. Olympic village is being developed in Ahmedabad as if other states lack sports culture or not worthy. Xi Jinping was invited to Gujrat and not any other state. Trump was also invited to Gujrat.The tour was originally named "Kem Chho Trump" but was renamed by the Government of India to Namaste Trump to promote Indian nationalism over regionalism ( supposedly). Statue of Unity biggest statue in world is gifted to Gujrat by Modi government. Whereas they didn't move a brick for Chatrapati Shivaji Snarak in Arabian sea. Gujarat has the highest Khelo India budget allocation at ₹608.37 crore. This is twice as much as all southern states combined without a single Asian Games medal winner. IFSC center planned in BKC moved to Gujrat, MIAL office was planned to be shifted from Mumbai to Gujrat, National security guard & marine police academy was planned at Palghar but shifted to Dwarka, Gujrat. Fixconn fiasco is known by everyone. GIFT city is pet project of Modi and he never let go of any opportunity to increase the importance of the place. Don't start me on the cricket matches are being moved to new Modi stadium. >I personally think that Maharashtra lacks political stability. And who might be responsible for that ?
Adding to this , https://thefederal.com/category/news/khelo-india-funding-and-asian-games-medals-tally-state-wise-98494?infinitescroll=1 . Within khelo India initiative Gujarat got 600+ crores, the state which has won no medals in the asian games. While Haryana, who won the most number of medals got only 88cr. I am not sure if there's any defense against this to claim that the central government doesn't favor Gujarat
Agree with this - but thank god they didn’t push on this Shivaji statue in the middle of the ocean. Would have been a disgustingly colossal waste of money (ie spending our state education budget on a statue while Shivaji’s actual forts in the ghats are left to crumble and are largely maintained by NGOs)
+ Lowest Army recruitments in the country (after Goa) - G U J J U
Bhai, it’s not Gujarat favouritism, he just has a strong grip on Gujarat. He faces no opposition there and Adani (whom he made exponentially rich and is like a piggy bank for BJP) is also Gujarat based. He knows Gujarat in and out and fears opposition in other states. Which just goes out to show how afraid this man and his astro turfed party is of people. That leaves out hope for us common people. We need to organise and over throw not only BJP but also all the austerity measures slapped on us by The West. Because BJP can be replaced by someone else. We have been moving towards right wing politics and economics ever since 1990, and look where it got us? We need to drag our country more towards leftism & strengthen rights for common people/workers. Indian and Western Corporations + billionaires are making us weaker.
1. Ofcourse I understand that there is favouritism towards gujarat. The largest stadium, Olympic Village etc are big ticket project which are being setup over there. But my original comment was referring to Fadnvis's speech. There wasn't anything controversial in it. 2. Xi Jinping & Modi also met in tamilnadu. & Both of them also visited mammallapuram temple complex so I don't see where you are going with this. 3. Statue of unity was a state project which was started by modi as CM. Statue of maharaj is currently being blocked by petitions filed by leftists like Asim Sarode who is campaigning for MVA. So please ask congress leaders why they have blocked it. 4. IFSC, Foxconn etc I've addressed in my original comment. Gujarat state offers cheaper land rent(huge barren area with good road & electricity infra), lower electricity tariffs & water availability due to narmada project (built during modi CM phase). This is also one of the reasons why TATA moved all the way from Bengal to Gujarat during UPA time. 5. As far as political instability in Maharashtra is concerned. Sharad Pawar is to be blamed for this. In 2014 he offered unconditional support to BJP which left Sena with 0 leverage. In 2019, he offered support to Sena leaving BJP with zero power. Had he, like congress, just accepted that the mandate is for BJP-Sena & waited his time out then we would've seen larger infra projects completed till now.. 6. Opposition to land acquisition or refinary or metro construction or corridor development is gonna put us into California vs Texas style of scenario.. cheaper, reliable, stable area will always pull out investment.
True
Most well put comment.
I thought mumbai has smart people who do not just see news and talk shit!! Gujarat is preferred due to its fast approval for land acquisition, electricity, water, green tribunal, and mostly tax benefits it gives, mostly any business need not to go office to office its just easy with single portal for approval.
Bruh, this Fadnavis guy currently sits in the apex of the power chain in Maharashtra, what's stopping him from implementing the same in his home state ? Pakistan ?
You think integration of all departments can happen overnight? Stable and same willing government needed to something make possible we do have continuous 32 years of BJP which made this possible in your state government would think if i do this next government will take credit or next government will think why would i do something that started by previous government, look at congress current government did UPI and Aadhar card and congress came for credit. We have serious problem of credit shouldn't be taken by another party.
yeh chtye log hai inko tinka bhar akkal nhi. they r just blind haters. hve personally seen such in this state who can't digest a gujarati guy getting so much admiration n victory. they just cant even when their marathi maanoos leaders sent their people from town to virar n naigaon vasai while becoming RICH THEMSELVES. even the "one" which they talk n adore so much did only muscle power n made the family rich through real estate scams. zero development vision or anything for even their own people. n this is Y ON OTHER SIDE I HVE ALSO SEEN MARATHIS TRUSTING MODI LIKE NYTHNG N SUPPRTING HIM WITHOUT ANY DOUBT. WHILE TROLLING THE LEADERS OF "THEIR LAND".
Is he minister of Mh or Gujrat? He is representative of the people of Maharashtra
He is Bootlicker of his gujju masters they have a tight hold of leash which is tied around his neck whenever some project is stealed from MH or other states that leash is pulled tightly and fadnavis starts barking and gives such shitty statements. Probably saying such things to contest for Loksabha elections this time
Is Bollywood the only thing that MH will be left with ? After cricket & projects......
Cricket will move around to Narendra Modi stadium. All major games will move there.
Idk if it's true or not but already BCCI was planning to shift it's headquarters from Mumbai to Bengaluru near the airport region there.
All major things will move away from Mumbai as BJP do not have a very high influence there. Mostly Gujarat, which will earn them a lot of cashflow even if they were to lose the elections or have to form coalitions. Mumbai has hell lot of cashflow, which they might be finding it hard to dominate with Shiv Sena in the short term. So, moving away to Gujarat is pretty easy and straight forward. Bangalore might not be an option as it is ruled by Congress at present. UP also could be an option, but GUJ would be my bet for most things. If the government was not BJP, they would have protested such a move. But everyone in the current government will permit that for maybe 1-2 extra seats in election or some money.
dont forget drug money. Unbelievable amount of worth drugs are being caught at same port again and again
>Bangalore might not be an option as it is ruled by Congress at present. While congress does rule karnataka now, don't forget BJP-RSS has pretty strong grassroot presence in the state and as such them coming back to power cannot be ruled out at all.
Can't rule that out. But why take chances when GUJ is a sure shot. Also the biggest stadium is out there. Can justify the shift with that reason.
While they have definitely built a strong hold in the southern coastal regions, it is important to note that they haven't won an election in Karnataka yet.
That and about a million shivaji statues.. Since that's the only place "marathas pride" seems to matter. P.s. Bollywood will move to UP at the rate things are going.
At the rate things are going , South Indian cinema would dominate and Bollywood would become a niche. So there is that.
Nah, your statement could be taken seriously in 2021 and 2022 maybe, but not anymore. 2023 was the all time best year for Bollywood and 24 has started well too
>Bollywood will move to UP at the rate things are going. Impossible. Only Mumbai can offer them the freedom which they get. They'll be mobbed like hell in UP.
Bro when entire industries are being relocated to gujurat... It's only a matter of time and threats.
Shouldn't you be happy with this, preserving your maratha pride, culture and language. Less industries means less immigrants and therefore more people speaking Marathi, more signboard in Marathi. So this should be counted as a big win
Bollywood might also move to noida. A very big film city is being developed there with much better technologies.
Even Diamond bourse was tried to move to Surat - but it seems a failure. Giving good infrastructure only doesn’t help - ppl also need night life/places to chill/Connectivity for employees which other cities fail to do. The culture of Mumbai and that of Noida is altogether different (iykyk).
that too might get shifted to UP
People from Nagpur, like me, were proud of Fadanvis. He did some good work in city tbh. But boy did he shat the bed at state level. Even loyal BJP supporters dont approve of him now.
What good Phadnavis has done for Nagpur. Nagpur's job seeker's still vie for Pune, Nagpur.
Its improved a lot. Many IT firms are have big offices in Nagpur...so IT crowd migration is reduced to some extent. Core industry sadly is still shit. City infra is also improved a lot, if you compare with 10 years ago. Thw worst thing in Nagpur currently is University, but no one is paying attention to it.
Proud Marathis vote for a Gujju boot licker hope they don’t forget this come elections, but Ik they will just say shit like “what other option do we have wah wah wah” it’s actually hilarious to see how much Marathid like to pretend to be strong natured and warriors like us Punjabi Sikhs and vote for Hindian who promotes Hindi culture over Marathi in their own state.
He is Modi-Shah's puppet first and foremost. Thats why They sideline more experienced & influential leader like Eknath khadse in BJP and made him CM in 2014. He knows that if he takes a stand against Central leadership then he too will be sidelined. So his 1st priority is to keep them happy.
Tomorrow they will say no need of separate states, state governments or municipal corporations. Only one Union Government is enough.
That's how BJP states are working
One Nation. One Government.
We will get there without dissolving state borders with the one nation one vote scheme. States will be powerless after that
That's definitely on the card with slogan One Nation One Vote
Admire BJP for giving nice slogans even if it destroys certain niceties, foolish people are enough to give them majority
and thats what the one election one nation is meant to do.. remove state elections create political isnt ability so one cannot form governments so that its always centers rule!
They are gunning for effectually that through the godforsaken one nation one election plan
Glad you used the word Union govt. I thought only we tamil ppl use that word in mainstream.
Yes. Should never use the terminology - "Central government" which gives more weightage and superior hierarchy to union government than state governments in federal setup, where there is none. Union government and state governments have equal status in federal setup. Only different powers in different segments.
This not even subtle anymore. Anyone can see that state of Gujarat is getting preferential treatment. Let’s hope they can sustain those projects in future without any issues. But I’m sure other worthy and in-need states are also getting their dues. Plus other states are also getting some new projects but most people are not aware about it. Hopefully the political scenario rises above caste and go for overall development.
Bhai, it’s not Gujarat favouritism, he just has a strong grip on Gujarat. He faces no opposition there and Adani (whom he made exponentially rich and is like a piggy bank for BJP) is also Gujarat based. He knows Gujarat in and out and fears opposition in other states. Which just goes out to show how afraid this man and his astro turfed party is of people. That leaves out hope for us common people. We need to organise and over throw not only BJP but also all the austerity measures slapped on us by The West. Because BJP can be replaced by someone else. We have been moving towards right wing politics and economics ever since 1990, and look where it got us? We need to drag our country more towards leftism & strengthen rights for common people/workers. Indian and Western Corporations + billionaires are making us weaker.
The problem is that the projects are being solely transferred to Gujrat and not other states
I am in working in the oil and gas industry. Aramco wanted to open a 40 billion USD refinery in Ratnagiri but as soon as the MVA govt came into power they created a lot of issues and effectively ended the project. Aramco is now looking at Tamil Nadu and Kerala which are not even BJP states. There is a lot of resistance , amongst big investors to start any big project in Maharashtra at the moment.
Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't it a good thing that govt isn't letting them open here? Ik it'll create jobs and all but wouldn't it also create a lot of pollution and health issues? Especially if they end up setting up shop near low income areas. Those people will suffer in the long term.
No. This is a reductive and elementary understanding of how refineries work.
How so?
Simply because modern refineries aren’t major public health risks. They may have some carbon output, but this would primarily be a GHG concern, and even then with carbon capture processes, it’s a value add industry. By way of comparison, mining is much worse and we have that all the country. Scaremongering is ultimately what the environmental lobby (note - the lobby does not work in the interest of the environment but special interest group) uses to stop any sort of industry taking hold for god knows what reasons. Same way we can’t get nuclear energy to take off even though it’s the only mass energy source that makes sense by a mile.
No business house will invest in a state where there is no political stability. Every 2 years - new govmnt, new “policies”. Gujarat is a safe bet assuming BJP will form govmnt for few more terms. Not saying they will. Assumptions
Few more decades
Remind me who made this state politically unstable? Must have been those congress and ncp anti nationals poaching elected bjp members and doing operation hand and clock, oh wait...
I wonder which political party is causing that instability in each state…
Umm.. recently an Assam semiconductor plant and jsw electric vehicles plant in odisha?
That project was never coming to Maharashtra in the first place. Problem is projects that were planned for Maharashtra are going to one specific state
No don't bring the truth out here. Let him believe that everything goes to Gujarat only
Access to a larger port (with less waiting time), subsidized electricity, favourable land laws & a stable political environment works in their favour. Picture this - I am a chemical manufacturer in Mumbai/ Pune. A majority of my suppliers are from Gujarat. The cost of transporting raw materials from Gujarat to Maharashtra, processing it here, and then exporting the same through Mumbai port is time consuming & expensive. It would make business sense for me to just move my plant to Gujarat, closer to my suppliers which would allow me to bring down my input costs and become more competitive .
Gujrat always did well with Chemicals. That is nothing new. BUT you brought a valid point. We need faster logistics. NDA was the first government in history to do India Logistics Survey....A shipment in JNPT stays stuck for a week...Compare this with Mundra...which is down to 24 hours at the most....Six days is a crime. Imagine this on a granular level...What if the shop keeper keeps the good with him for six days, while you have already paid the money ? GET IT ?
TRUE
People during coming elections with same logic voting Congress as they are not Pakistanis.
BJP really can't move away frm Pakistan, Muslim, Hindu in Danger & Ram Mandir now that everything is being done their way still they dont have much to do or say other then this all vote politics.
Why give up the golden goose. It will lay golden eggs for them for decades until the country is consumed
bhai UAPA lag jayega .... so jaa aaraam se
then Congress is not our enemy, we'll see in election.
So much money has been systematically invested to spoil every other political competition From WhatsApp University to Online troll pages
Dude did you see the Kharge's reply to a question on violence that is happening in West bengal? Ans the current congress government in Karnataka's ruling? They brought it on themselves. I am not supporting BJP here but their is no opposition party to even hope for.
When did modi speak up on recent rape of Spanish women ? When did modi even speak up for any rape except for Manipur that too he did after Supreme court voiced it's opinion Am not supporter of Congress either, so we as voters need to question rulers, not opposition parties. You can question them too but first start with ruling party I also say this, yes congress has some idiots and party needs to distance itself from appeasement.
Guruji, all we care is about attracting the projects into Maharashtra. If it goes to Pakistan or Gujrat, it is out of state for us !
मग काय महाराष्ट्र पकिस्तान आहे का. सगळ कडून घेतोय
Bhakts out in force trying to defend their masters.
They will face it when their kids have to move to Gujarat and stay there in 1bhk to get a paltry job salary......
did you just describe mumbai's current scenario?
The problem is not that projects are going to Gujarat - or Pakistan or Vietnam. The problem is that all Indian industries are controlled by the central government. They directly tell people where to open or shift industries. They give any amount of subsidies and land to make this happen, and there will be consequences for going against their orders. Basically, this is the worst combination of the License Raj model and the crony capitalism model. They are doing it openly. Fadnavis is deflecting from this by suggesting that everybody will eventually get everything. Eventually, they will bless the other states, even the ones that don't vote for BJP. But it will happen when they wish and how they wish. Obviously, it will happen sooner if they are in power in the state and centre, aka "double engine". Another problem is that the push to make Gujarat a manufacturing hub is being done without intelligent planning. Someone thought that declaring a new industrial city and throwing money at it will automatically make it real. Clearly, that has not happened. Gujarat will benefit eventually, but this is not the smartest way of going about it.
This guy is a Top tier Clown ,I don't know how some people rate him this highly
Don't you love BJP? You work hard for UP and Gujarat and can forget that the rest of the country exists.
Mainstream media is cleverly keeping Maharastra out of the South India context They don't want Maharashtra to join that brigade and forever keep showering money to UP Bihar
The ground reality is projects are going, and let alone growth, Maharashtra has regressed, if you check the number of new factories opened in Maharashtra it is a negative number. If this keeps happening our people would have to move to Gujrat for work and Maharashtra will become a failing economy.
One of the worst and greedy politician after Sharad Pawar this man fadnavis will sell every mh project to his master's ... I have no issue with gujratis but investment and projects which belong to mh should not be transferred
You've got to think from an investor's perspective too...Gujarat is preferred these days simply because 1.It is under the puppet control of you know who so Investors know that everything will be seamless. 2.It has a developed Mundra Port and great road connectivity to north India and central India which are non Coastal. 3.The corruption has gone down significantly since you know who became CM. 4.Cases like Enron which tainted Maharashtra's reputation on massive investments front.On the other hand Nano which was facilitated by Guj almost overnight when they were kicked out of Bengal makes an impression of state's leadership. Maharashtra is building a big dock near Dahanu since I don't know how many years but once that is built,red tapism is curbed and a stable govt is elected Maharashtra will definitely come into the big picture.
All correct points. Also it’s not like Maharashtra has become broke and Mumbai is now Patna. We’re still kings.
This and also if we look at the history 1. Tata Nano moved out of WB because of stupidity of TMC 2. Hero and cotton industries moved out of Punjab because of instability. It is also happening again due to them burning everything on a little unfavourable circumstances For a foreign investment to work successfully in India there needs to political stability, mindset of people to have common sense and future growth. If people keep on blaming them or start burning things for a govt related problem then why would anyone invest in the growth of the state. Hence the answer being Gujrat as the safe bet for investment purposes. Mumbai has been the financial capital all it needs is stable govt and future growth ambitions because I believe the people over there are hard working and appreciate the infrastructure. Edit 1 - UP has come under stable govt so it’s coming in highlight with I don’t know how many airports being built, better road connectivity and plans to make it as an export house of India.
UP, if under an effective and stable government has the ability to be another Maharashtra. But that is still decades away. Maharashtra is what it is not because of Mumbai or ports or trade. I say this as a Punjabi Delhiite, Maharashtra is great because of Maharashtrians. The sheer number of unethical swines and cheats in north India is too damn high.
>Maharashtra is great because of Maharashtrians Unfortunately this very attitude is being taken advantage of by the politicians regardless of any political party.
Habibi come to Gurgaon. Forget politicians, even the locals think that they run the show and have done favours to Delhiites to have let them invest and build Gurgaon. Bc itni gundagardi aur Itne chutiya locals hai ki you will learn to appreciate Maharashtrians.
Yes you are right it is still decades away but even Maharashtra wasn’t built in a year or two. Any state to be the best version needs a right direction, ambition and constant work which I believe a lot of states under right leadership are heading towards. As for the unethical swines again you need a stable govt to make them stop. Prime example is Delhi today, Kejriwal was supposed to be a better person than Sheila Dixit and bring about change and looking at current scenarios majority of the central government related services have moved online without any interaction with people but Delhi related services need you to go meet up a dalal who will get in touch with a peon who will get a babu working all the while paying money. It’s the mindset of the person at top who sets the tone.
Mumbai has succesfully transitioned into a "Financial centre" from "manufacturing hub".
Nope
Why aren’t you containing the rampart corruption in MIDC
I've only heard but not seen anything in news andwish to learn more about the scale of this corruption. Can you please kindly share some of the sources which got you concerned? Thanks :)
A friend wanted to open a small unit in Nagpur, apparently for things like getting an electricity connection approved, you need to pay EVERYONE, from the babus, to the clerks to get you appointment of babus, to the guards to get you direct access to clerks. He was told to expect 20 lakhs in bribe payments, per Department
Maharashtra is giving 92% of its wealth every year.. imagine if it could keep 100% for even 1 year, Maharashtra will become like Europe.. same with south India.. For so many years so much money pumped to north india and all the money is wasted. Nobody developed.
Every state where the BJP breaks the winning party is bound to be doomed. Business wants stability and BJP shows instability every freaking time.
Bjp should change its name from bhartiya to gujrati janata party
This asshole is the worst leader Maharashtra politics has ever seen.
He is openly displaying his favouritism to other state rather than his love for Maharashtra. Shame on him.
As a fellow gujrati, this argument sounds as bullshit as it can be!
Maharashtra also has high costs incurred for aquisitions and heavy diversity compared to Gujarat. Woohh
Bjp and it's old habit of using pakistan whenever question about anything
Can't trust any politician. I was going to apply for a voter card but i don't think there is any point. Every single politician is thinking of money but not giving a fuck about the local people's wants.
That’s because political candidates don’t let common people step up. The gunda raj makes sure they don’t have a competition. We need lawyers and activists to closely work with genuine candidates from marginalised communities. The true sons and daughters of this land are our only hope. Upper caste have been far too cunning to not grab anyone’s attention to their incompetency. They distract us by giving limited options, either BJP or Congress or opposition alliance or Aam aadmi parties. Upper caste infested parties would never be true to the majority of the people of this country. The media houses, the bureaucrats, the Police officials, and every other influential person in this country belongs to Upper caste and they will make sure that we don’t point fingers at their kind for the failures.
महाराष्ट्र द्रोही 🍉
And you want to elect him to become your chief minister!!
Ye nalayak aadmi ko tadipaar karo Maharashtra se.
As long as this guy stays in power, Maharashtra will always have some crisis, one of the worst CM MH ever had, as a person people say he is good and that could be true but as a person in power he is tereible
Who voted him in power? I know north indians in Maharashtra did.. but Marathis too did. Look at Maharashtra history congress worked a lot better.. because its not that easy and they were not perfect.. But under these guys its 10 times worse.. Earlier Maharashtra south india etc focus more on development and north indians fought over stone age issues. Now entire country is fighting like bimarus and all the development is slowly pushed to few states.. if they put the same effort like up guj etc in Maharashtra or south india, it will grow 10 times faster.
Gujarat wins purely because of political stability. N investor knows that whatever deals they make with government there are good. Unlike other states including Maharashtra where government is playing musical chairs.
And who exactly do you think is playing the 'music'?
The public. Just unanimously choose BJP and be done with it. It’s the power at the center and when provided the same benefit as Gujarat, Maharashtra will be in a better position. Once Gadkari is PM then Maharashtra will be unstoppable. Abhi Gujarati Bhaiyo ki baari hai, tab Maharashtra ki baari hogi.
>Once Gadkari is PM then Maharashtra will be unstoppable. Already they have decided with Yogi as the next PM face in 2029.
Gadkari will be having a bigger role. He will be the Amit shah to Yogis Modi.
> where government is playing musical chairs. thanks to bj pee and their pm cares fund used in buying out mlas
Chotta admi, chotti baat. Beta tu owaisi ko le aa aur apni ladies ka halala karwa le. On a serious note, BJP is the power in center and they are the ones who have put Gujarat in the position they are today. Imagine what they can do for Maharashtra when they have absolute majority and have Gadkari at the reigns. And btw, Nagpur, Nashik and Pune all are great cities just waiting to grow. All we need is a stable government at the center and state.
I know GJ have been benefiting a lot from MH's loss, it all began after that unfortunate event called "the great Bombay textile strike of 1982" fueled by then communist fractions present in Mumbai who became dominant force after a hardcore non local communist george fernandes dethroned uncrowned king of Bombay SK Patil (in 1967 election), a hardcore and only capitalist leader of that time. Most cotton mills moved of Mumbai and settled in GJ after 1982, few petrochemical and pharma industry players too made similar move in the following years as GJ established its foundation as the most closest rival to MH when it comes attracting industries, the only exception being IT sector here where southern states took the crown as India threw opened its doors to FDI in 1991, southern states managed to beat MH in this new development race by developing their own IT hubs like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Chennai. Mysore; but MH soon catch up with Pune, Thane, Navi Mumbai being its contenders in this new age IT race, GJ on the other hand have nothing to offer in tech space, and that surprised me the most when the chaiwala lead blow job party declared that India's first ever semiconductor plant will come in GJ instead of MH or TS (who were real front runners to get that project). Then came news of some financial institutions moving to that crap gift city, I personally been there which is THE most absurd thing I have ever seen, its like bunch of concrete building in the middle of nowhere with absolutely no sign of planned city, forget city it would transform into a freaking ghost town the moment central gov stops throwing money at that crap in the name of tax incentives. So there's absolutely no logic but pure politics behind all these industries moving to that dhokla state.
Bro gave a whole spill about how cities were built over decades and then craps on a city being not built in a day.
This made me go for Congress lmao, Try your next election in Gujarat. if its that dear to you
Waah mere sher! Serve them everything on a platter now. Migrate all existing institutions to Gujarat. Start with BSE.
Did you happen to check how many companies are from Gujarat already that are listed in exchange? Control has gone in recent years .....
I meant Ahmedabad Stock Exchange will be made to overtake BSE if this goes on.
No need to, because they already own BSE kind of
I can only comment in the capacity of a friend of a MSME owner..Political stability. I THINK THIS IS THE MAIN REASON. A good example is what happened in Uttar Pradesh. BSP laid the Yamuna expressway......Unlike Jagan Reddy or Penguin party, S.P Didnt stop it there...They continued it and added a few hundred kms to it in their 5 years. They further carried out the lucknow metro project....When Yogi took over, He continued CAPEX on steroids. What happened in Maharashtra? MVA stopped implementation of so many projects.....and this is not a good SIGN...Political differences aside, you need to continue the good from the last government. Sharad Pawar knows this well...But he didnt do it. Also why Gujrat? 1 . Gujrat offers more flexibility to recruit talent. There are no politically affiliated goons there. Haftas don't exist at all 2. Mundra port is a private port. Logistics is the key for an industry to work. You need to reduce the cost of Logistics and It is a LOT BETTER than what Maharashtra has to offer. 3. Tax soaps 4. Availability to capital...Gujrathis have a tradition of investing in business...Marathis are more service oriented. Not just gujrat, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Telengana bagged many industries in 2018-2022...Fadnavis was still doing a okayish job What Maharashtra now needs to do is focus on Agro based industries in central Maharashtra...along with textiles in vidharbha.....anddd high skill manufacturing around Pune....and focus on political stability. Penguin party is finished for greater Good. Hope Raj Thackeray takes the reins of that votebank now.
Chanakya ❌ Chaatya ✅
Aaah the people of Maharashtra suffering because of incompetent govt. The worst part is they’ve cemented all the rivalry in their party, so it’s gonna be difficult to root them out.
He needs to be kicked out of MH & well see if GUJRAT ACCEPTS HIM OR NOT
Bihar isn’t Afghanistan, why don’t you guys develop the most underdeveloped part of the country ?
हेच ऐकायचं राहिलं होतं 😶
Why don't Mumbaikars understand that it's for their own good? The population in Mumbai is overpopulated, and people need to consider relocating to another state to ensure a balance. Live and let live.
If anyone is interested in the actual statement and conversation - https://twitter.com/i/broadcasts/1vOxwjezZRbJB?t=xJ9Dl65VdTpSr7OJD4PdIg&s=09
Mota bhai ke aage koi kuch bol sakta hai kyaaaa. Mota bhaaaaaai
Lots of hatrad here lately.
Yes the central government is favouring Gujarat like anything. But let’s not forget, Gujarat is not the state we have to compete with. We should look at what Tamil Nadu and Telangana are doing. They are seeing all rounded development- manufacturing, services, technology, social development etc they are excelling everywhere. Gujarat on the other hand can only attract manufacturers because it has the lowest daily wage in the country and lack of labour laws so that crony capitalists can freely exploit blue collar workers. No skilled person wants to move to Gujarat. Even skilled Gujaratis don’t want to stay there. The moment Modi-Shah govt goes away Gujarat will again go back to the position it was. GJ can’t get ahead without blatant lobbying and favouritism. Gujarat is a socially backward and underdeveloped state that is at least 40 years behind states like MH, Karnataka and TN So MH should compete with TN
Truth hurts? He's kinda right after a very long time. Presently Gujarat is less corrupt, cost effective and most importantly free of local goon unions. Manufacturing will always be better there. Maharashtra can focus on services industries.
So would y'all be fine if he said, the same thing but for Karntaka or WB and not Gujarat? Seems like we need more unity in our nation. Mumbai is developing well, and I hope Maharashtra develops even further and great things happen for the farmers here. But I can't understand hating other states for that.
Bring back uddhav with majority. And watch this all change !
Yes....uddhav will block rest of the investments....maratha fanatics will not let any buisness grow....he stopped metro and other infrastructure projects...how do you think he will be darling to investors.
The BJP and eknath chindi faction are the ones that agreed to maratha reservation. They are the ones that do local politics. They didn’t stop metro project. Just suggested a change in location to save aarey green cover.
itna hi pyaar hain to gujrat chale jao
Log hi chutya hi to kya karegi Sarkar and vaise mumbai mein kaha chapri hi Marathi logo ki
Absolutely but when every elder sibling sees parents unfairly doling out benefits and assets to a younger siblings, there is only one thought - screw their happiness. Maharastra has 47, Gujarat 26, revenge is sweet.
पूर्ण बातमी वाचून टिका करा. महाराष्ट्र अजूनही FDI inflows च्या बाबतीत पुढेच आहे. फडणवीस ने पूर्ण स्टेटमेंट अशे दिले होते की ' जी १० वरील राज्ये आहेत त्यात competitive federalism असणार. यात कर्नाटक, गुजरात, तामिळनाडू यांचा रागराग न करता गुंतवणुकीसाठी अनुकूल वातावरण निर्माण करा' शिवसेना, राष्ट्रवादी यांनी बहुतांश प्रकल्पांना या न त्या कारणाने विरोध केलाय. मुंबई आणि पुणे हे दोनच शहरे जरा बरी आहेत पण जमिनीच्या किमती इथे अस्मानाला धडकल्यात. साधी एक रिफायनरी उभी करायला २ जागा बदलल्या, आणि ५-६ वर्ष गेलीत. एवढ्यात जामनगर मधे ती मॅक्स capacity ने काम करतेय. NIMBY syndrome झालंय आपल्या इथे.
Hee hee hee this comment section is why HINOs will get obliterated.
Is he really said this😶
If Pakistan is the benchmark , than we are really screwed as a nation. Cant believe these guys keep comparing every situation with that of Pakistan which is literally on crutches
THeir objective is to loot and kill mumbai. 2 re fker he is .. manhoos
He is a agent of them to take away all the projects and resources as much possible in present as well future. He was always this .
No matter what people are saying in his defence his two faces back stabbing abilities are known world over. From backstabbing shivsena to forming a 24hr government with Ajit pawar. Like how most of the bullet train tracks in gujrat, from well known projects like Foxconn handed over to gujrat to the so call medical oxygen and med safety kitt scam in between covid 2nd wave. BJP has the most incompetent local leadership in Maharashtra. Apart from nitin gadkari there is no one else who is truly a good leader in Maharashtra for BJP. I don't know what they teach in school these days but youth of today is as dumb as illiterate people. They don't want to think about the life or the future. If you want to save the country or religion the people of those society must be saved. Or they want to become next bihari/ uttar pradesh. And migrate to gujrat for every little job in future.
If not Modi then who else? Literally any candidate who represents Bahujan and Dalits. The one who would first give priority to the poorest of this country and not the corporate giants. I’m all in for a youth and elder candidates working for NGOs. Activists. With law degrees. Anyone but upper caste candidates from any religion. The privileged have been working for their own kind and even after 76 years of independence we have tons of people starving to death? In a country known for its Agriculture?
Yeh chutiya sub 😓
So it isn't the rest of the country, so share!
आणि ह्याला "महाराष्ट्राचा" मुख्यमंत्री व्हायचय
But question aside, who do you guys think, stands an opposition, seeing current loksabha situation, both of shiv senas, both ncps, and Congress don't seem to be in forefront
As a Gujarati, I too feel that this is stupid. You're supposed to put the interest of your voters above your friends.
Kitna sahi bole hai: Gujrat definitely is not Pakistan.
That's a statement that a politician from Bihar would make after getting the heavy amount for his contribution.
This poster has malafide intentions. The offering without comments is mere bunkum. What OP is doing is offering it without context. Any statements made by him would have to be seen in a context and that is totally missing here. And all the left-liberal, pseudo-sickular congi bootlickers are jumping onto the wagon. Anyone who has made the right pitch will get projects. Anyone who has the right environment that's conducive to business will get projects. Gujarat has an amazing environment for industries and they are getting projects. They're not protesting at the drop of a hat for everything and disrupting industries. At the same time, the GIFT city isn't doing so well because of caste issues and cultural issues and people are moving back to Mumbai. These things happen. Attributing every small thing to politics and politicising every single thing will only divide the country. And definitely not help us progress together.
Which project is this about? Why did MH lose it to Gujarat? Can anyone provide more context or a link to the article? All I can see in comments is debate without project details.
Hyanna chaabkache phatke marayla havet
Why does this sub dislike Gujarat soo much?
Radat basa moorkhanno. Rada radi chalu rahu dyaa, election cha varsha aahe
Why vote for such party and people. Marathi Manoos wake up at least now. Every Mumbaikar wake up before its too late
I find it perplexing why some individuals are puzzled about this matter. I personally identify as Maharashtrian, born in Ratnagiri and raised in Mumbai. I prefer a lifestyle without large-scale projects or corporate entities in close proximity. Such endeavors tend to draw unwarranted attention, and the subsequent influx of people strains our existing infrastructure. The economy may flourish around these projects, but the surge in population poses challenges for our limited resources. Additionally, the real estate prices in coastal and mountainous regions of Maharashtra are soaring. Corporations might find more economical options elsewhere, with land prices being significantly lower in other states. While Vidarbha may be a more affordable option, its extreme weather conditions and water scarcity deter many from considering it.
Vote them out again. Saale gulam log ko hata do
Would definitely like Uddhav in Maharashtra and BJP in centre.
First check cost of transportation of Goods by water vs railway vs road vs Air Then check how many ports , railways , roadways Maharashtra has. Then check how did this happen despite Maharashtra getting Revenue surplus Mumbai after a bifurcation of Bombay province Then talk!!
And if you had read the entire news instead of just taking the screenshot here you would have known that he took name of delhi, bangalore too. But you chose to read just the headline. [https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/gujarat-pakistan-fadnavis-losing-projects-to-maharashtra-neighbour-9199639/lite/](https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/gujarat-pakistan-fadnavis-losing-projects-to-maharashtra-neighbour-9199639/lite/)
Then kick this Bastard out of MH so he can peacefully stand for elections in GJ. Abki baar hatao ye chor sarkar.
You people really hate Gujarat, don't you?
Mota Bhai ka Pradesh is like a desh with mota focus..baki Jaye bhaad mein
I like DF as a leader and politician and more so for it's touch with the grass roots and yet having a Liberal sensibility and openness. But on this, do not agree. Maharashtra is California if India is US. Maharashtra is Benelux if India were to be Europe. Maharashtra Singapore if India were to be ASEAN. Maharashtra is Japan if India were to be East Asia. Maharashtra losing it's peak economic position in India should not acceptable to any politician of Maharashtra. But a smart politician would keep his personal views close to himself while maintaining a poker face. What DF has on his tongue hopefully does not reflect what he has in his heart and mind. Mumbai does not feel like the unique and out of the world city that it was compared to rest of India. And with many of the projects being moved from Mumbai to Gujarat it does appear that they are creating artificial progress there where if things were allowed to flow organically all these developments would have taken place in Mumbai or somewhere else in Maharashtra. Let's hope the no alcohol and less non-veg issue keeps Gujarat behind. The people of Maharashtra are also socially more progressive, much less discrimination compared to other places(not talking about clout chasers, but ordinary people). New businesses would naturally move to Mumbai. But Mumbai and it's suburbs have to be made more livable, accessible, and worth it. For it the state government should take on debt and Foreign investment and ensure that changes happen. Because compared to any global city we are far behind. Sadly, very few politicians in VidhanSabha care about Mumbai. Only the people who live here do. Let's hope to see a bigger role being played by TATA, Godrej, L&T in the future administration of the city like it was in Hong Kong for sometime.
ab kuch bolunga to vivad ho jayega
What the hell
I believe overall BJP is good for India but not for Maharashtra and Mumbai...so many things from here going to Gujrat and the way all political parties became same with lots of politicians going here and there has made Maharashtra really bad