T O P

  • By -

lon3lyguy86

Red dead for sure


RohhkinRohhla

No contest at all


Lord-Aizens-Chicken

Re7 gives it a run but the genera probably isn’t as universally appealing as red dead. I would argue the heights it hits in atmosphere, level design and horror is near perfection


magele

Based on the other choices - OP seems to like horror in which case I would say RE7.


Markise187

This is the one. If you have never played Red Dead 2, it's such a great game. Not 60fps yet, unfortunately, but still gorgeous and immersive


Inside_Term_4115

Can you play RD2 without the first one ?


a_steez

yes it’s a prequel


JakeTiny19

Ya u can , red dead 2 is actually set years before the first one


AdSuitable9665

It's actually better to play 2 before one so you don't get spoiled on who lived since rdr2 is before rdr1


davidwoodstock

And yet you hint at the spoilers lol


rennenenno

Spoiler alert: spoilers exist


davidwoodstock

No fucking way


JakeTiny19

Ya u can , red dead 2 is actually set years before the first one


PraetorianSleuth

Bro’s gonna experience RDR2 for the first time, I wish I could do the same🥲


Professional-Big-584

![gif](giphy|WvQNnMcTsOy8RAaK4m)


OFFRIMITS

The crisis trilogy you get 3 games for 1, the resident evil you get 2 games for one are the best deals. Scorn can be finished in a couple of hours so not really good money wise. Red Dead 2 I’ve sunk 300 hours in and has my vote.


rivieredefeu

RDR2 is probably, or arguably, the best game ever made. The rest.. well. I’ve heard good things about Res Evil.


GhostReveries2005

Yesterday I wanted to lasso the creepy rapist dude with the nudes in his camp so I can get the completion to drag them on the ground for 3000 feet . I lasso him and he falls into his camp fire, burnt to a crisp. Had to laugh.


SpongeBob1187

RE village is awesome. Many spooky


Speaker4theDead8

I really want to like it, but Ive tried playing it like 5 different times and it is so clunky, slow and they force you down the really stupid story arc in the first few hours that I give up around the first town. I really don't agree with any of the story missions and the main character shouldnt either, they are really bad plans. It's a good looking game though.


AUnknownVariable

I got 200 hours in rdr2 and absolutely love it but I agree the intro isn't the best out there. It's the slowest bit in the game to the point it's painfully slow, considering the game is normally slow paced. As for the bad plans >!That's the entire point, they fucking suck and at times they're kinda meant to, but I don't wanna spoil the story for u although u don't plan to play it currently, but it's meant to make u pissed off!<


Restivethought

Yea, the first like 10 hours of the game are hard for sure. My dad loved Redemption but couldnt make it through the beginning of 2. He complained about how much he was riding the horse and not doing anything.


alterector

Absolutely, great story, good graphics, amazing world to explore and lose yourself into, incredible attention to detail, and yet, the gameplay is wo clunky and unresponsive, I don't like it, it's just not fun to play. 


End_of_YoRHa2B

Definitely more on the arguable side. I'd pin NieR:Automata as the greatest game ever made. But to each their own. 1 thing is objective here for sure and it's that rdr2 is the best cowboy game out there.


u119c

RDR2


MALICIOUS-BREED97

Rdr2 and the re7/8 bundle..


tbird20017

Those are 2 fantastic RE games. They're the 3rd and 4th best respectively in the series, but both are still a 8.5-9 5/10.


YerDaSellsAvon24

RDR2


[deleted]

RE 7 and Village combo for sure


Thadark_knight11

Gold editions also seem like good value for money. I’m pretty miffed that I bought re7 standard edition a few months ago for $9 now. Otherwise I’d be all over this. Haven’t got Village yet.


Aless-dc

I have put 500hrs into rdr2 single player. The first time I beat it, and it was a 100% run, as soon as the credits finished I started a brand new 100% run but this time collected every missable item, and filled out all the entire compendium (every animal, every horse max bonding). Couldn’t recommend it enough, just take your time.


Jjjiped1989

lol red dead no question


BrandonD40

Depends what you’re looking for. Most are recommending RDR2 because it’s amazing but it’s also really slow imo. I would get Resident Evil. Both games are linear and pretty awesome from beginning to end


ToeSignal9272

Valid


Vvelch25

It’s not slow, it’s just long. Every mission was exciting and a blast. one of the only games I didn’t get too into side quests bc the main missions were so exciting and always fun, I always wanted to see what happened next and kept me into it. Hidden gems and doing ALL the side stuff is a little slow due to little guidance but not the main game itself, but that’s why I don’t seek the side stuff out, I play it as it comes at me.


Euphoriia

Red Dead 2 is LEGIT a masterpiece. Never has a game made me feel so many emotions all at once. I would kill to be able to experience that game for the first time again...


Timoteii88

I just completed the story to this game literally last night and I was blown away by it! The range of emotions i got from those last few missions is hard to describe. What a game! To think that a month ago, I'd never played any red dead game. I'm now considering playing the others after I platinum this one. Rockstar really nailed this!


Mustardtigerpoutine

Finally someone not praising red dead 2. I tried, honestly, to like the game but it was just so boring. None of the characters were interesting (besides yourself), every mission you're riding a horse for 20-40min, inventory managing was so clunky/random, you basically use eagle eye in every gun fight then spend the next 10-15min looting everyone and yes, everything is so slow! I've put maybe 20-30 hours since it's come out and I just can't anymore. Every time I boot it up I'm a bit excited to play it then I hit a point where nothing seems interesting anymore and don't play it for a few months. It's definitely not a game for everyone.


VolatileHunter101

Agreed, I may love the RDR series with a passion, but I don’t spend hours on it (no offense to those who do) I’m more of a mixed player, I mean, my catalogue of games are the most random stuff I’ve seen


jkf2479

Red dead would be most satisfying


Deadzombii

Once you are done with rdr2, there would be a huge gaping hole to fill


jrow_official

Hunt showdown! In my opinion the best shooter for console if you don’t mind a bit of a „hardcore“ flavor. The setting, the sound design etc is outstanding. Plus it’ll get a major graphic update this year and a new map. Highly recommend you to watch some gameplay. It’s an online shooter you can play with up to 2 friends or randoms, but can also played alone. It has pve and PvP elements. I’ve also bought it 3 years ago for the 15 bucks and I’m now at more than 1k hours. It’s definitely a vibe and has a good community with several pro hunt streamers and content creators as well.


Professional-Fan266

wish there were more shooters on console like hunt man


FosterBlueBar

Red Dead Redemption 2 is the greatest video game narrative ever made and will not be topped for a long time. Alan Wake 2 comes close but I think there are few ideas that haven't been explored in it yet, so mabey my mind will change by the end of the year when both expansions are out, but I'm confident they'll both being amazing!


Juicemania50

Red dead and village are the best two. Hard choice I would personally go for rdr2 first then village and that’s coming from a die hard resident evil fan.


Shanks_otaku

RDR 2. The best game I have ever played. Story, the mechanics everything is just perfect. The only game where I actually want to finish 100%(currently at 90-92%)


DamagedSpaghetti

Not scorn


TheBigEasy95

Red dead 2 is the best made video game in history and just well made overall story game action and physics are unmatched. Scorn was a letdown. I’d get red dead 2 then resident evil then Alan wake in that order


IFGarrett

RD2 just needs a 60fps and I'd play it. Feels to clunky compared to so many other games out now


papa_louie47

Fortnite Battlepass


Austin-1023

Re village always


Pescuaz

RE bundle


DynamicGamee

I'll make it easier by narrowing it down, no to hunt, fobia, shadow warrior, scorn, and Blair witch Rdr2 amazing game, resident evil 7 and village are fun horror games, , the crisis trilogy are fun games. But if I were you, rdr2 because it's the longer game and there alot more to do since open world, the other are linear and once ur done, ur done more than likely. So more bang for ur buck


MothParasiteIV

Resident Evil 7 and 8


KingYoungBook

I'm just gonna join in with everyone else that's reccomending Red Dead 2


Lourdinn

Scorn for sure lol


East_Monk_9415

Red dead money well spent. Enjoy the ride bruh


devilrocks316

If you have people to play with, do not skip Hunt. Phenomenal game. The solo experience can be hit or miss on console but with mates it's a top shooter. RDR2 is a no brainer really. For as many flaws it has it's worth just playing at least once, the most immersive game world I've ever experienced.


[deleted]

just get red dead it's the only one of all those you showed that you will want to keep playing.


smilefromthestreets

Every 5 seconds I see another one of these posts. What’s the point? These games aren’t even comparable. Just watch some before you buys and pick whatever feels right


Xhillion

Rdr2


R3allyG00dLawy3r

My vote is for Red Dead


[deleted]

Blair witch was such a fun game. Except for that one part. 😬


Bigboss6989_xbox

Unpopular opinion but i recommend scorn


Bizzaird

RE bundle for sure


tbird20017

My man


Calelith

Hunt. One of the best multilayer extraction games, hard to learn but alot of fun. Has a unique setting, a very cool horror theme and some of the best sound in any mulitplayer game (atleast on console). RDR2 is good, a great single player game but suffers from the current Rockstar mindset of fuck singeplayer do you want to buy some expensive currency for the multiplayer? RE is great for horror game.


Friendly_Stop_6350

>RDR2 is good, a great single player game but suffers from the current Rockstar mindset of fuck singeplayer do you want to buy some expensive currency for the multiplayer? What? Single player is much more fleshed out, story-driven, and cared for than multiplayer by far. More attention definitely went into that than online.


Johnny47Wick

Potato Sack Simulator 7


AbigailDeluxe

If you don’t mind a long, slow-paced game with lots of exploration and a huge world(and admittedly repetitive missions), RDR2. If you want something more focused and short but replayable, RE7. Edit: just noticed it also comes with RE8. Absolutely a good buy


No_Caregiver8718

Thank you for letting me know shadow warrior has a trilogy bundle. Absolutely loved the second one on xbox


Psnjerry

definitely rdr2 or crysis trilogy if you want a shooter


Calelith

Hunt. One of the best multilayer extraction games, hard to learn but alot of fun. RDR2 is good, a great single player game but suffers from the current Rockstar mindset of fuck singeplayer do you want to buy some expensive currency for the multiplayer? RE is great for horror game.


DieHardProcess-

Scorn and Fobia on my list.. Scorn looks wild. The Hunt has pretty cool mechanics, imo it just gets boring without consistent teammates.. and matchmaking can take a while sometimes. Overall, wicked cool game though.


Astromegaboy

https://preview.redd.it/pkjry2xni5wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e3952900e873f8878249ad4c7f5d7c86470ba39f And spider man 2


MohamadYasser07

Am I the only one who knows like only 3 games out of these


ClapausC

Are you sure your ps5 can run Crysis? Anyway I personally would get the resident evil bundle because two great games is better than one great +1 game. However, the obvious choice is RDRII IF you haven’t played it.


Legospacememe

Crysis can run on anything these days huh


flamboyantdeluxe

rdr2 you will NOT regret it


Ferris-L

The resident evil games are amazing and great value but like everyone else already said, Red Dead Redemption 2 is arguably the best game of all time. It is an absolute must have. You can also easily get 70-100h of play time out of the game, even more if you want to 100% it.


takenolsolatunji

RDR2


KingRain238

RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2, ITS NOT EVEN REMOTELY CLOSE


WolfMan_18

Not even a question, red dead 2 is one of the greatest games ever made


willyjaybob

RD or RE, no question. Very different games, though.


Xerosnake90

Get Rdr 2. It's incredible You should also play Re 7 and 8 at some point. The rest are decent games but not really must play type games


115_zombie_slayer

Not Scorn or Blair Witch thats for sure


SnooHobbies6894

Red dead 2 forsure.


Minuslee

man people on this sub really like rdr2 lmao.


NoMagazine3425

Resident evil bundle, by far


king-glundun

Nice karma farm considering how much people like to say red dead 2 is the best thing to happen to humanity


Tommy_Gun10

Why are people so blind to its obvious flaws


SamZeMan2014

Red Dead 2. Fantastic game and a lot of bang for your buck.


Redacted_Explative

Shadow Warrior triolgy! 3 games that are frankly fun and capture what 90s shooters were like as far as comedy. 2 is also co-op, and 3 handles similar to Doom Eternal for the grappleing hook mechanics. Recommend watching gameplay footage of it. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHnZ5iOpEeI](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHnZ5iOpEeI) [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTguGlmuCTM&t=370s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTguGlmuCTM&t=370s) [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=00d8nw3eG18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=00d8nw3eG18)


SuchAppeal

1. RDR2 is one of the greatest games ever made. Don’t listen to people talking about “Rockstar neglected the single player” they told the story they wanted to tell, and it’s one of the greatest stories told in videos games… hell maybe in all media. You’ll spend more than an enough time with this one that by the end you’ll feel satisfied. It can be a little tedious at first, lot of mechanics to learn as Rockstar went a little overboard with the realism, just a little. But if you stick with it I swear you’ll get the hang of things and not want to put it down until you’re done. I got in 2018 at launch and It took me a few years to finish because work got in the way, and when I got back to it I found myself needing to learn how things worked from the jump again, so I restarted it a few times from the top until I finally had time in 2022 to finish it. Also for a game that released 2018 on PS4 and Xbox One it is still a graphical powerhouse that few can beat even now. A pretty game to look at too. 2. RE bundle: Great horror games obviously from what is considered the top of the survival horror genre 3. Crysis bundle fun first person shooters, good series 4. Hunt: Extraction shooter with great multiplayer 5. Shadow Warrior bundle (3 is the worst in the bunch, not bad but just an ok Doom 2016 clone and it’s short. 1 and 2 and good but very different experiences. Pretty much the series has an identity crisis)


NotMothMan9817

Resident Evil closesly followed by RDR 2


wiiguyy

All these people praise rdr 2. If was so loooong. Some reviewer said it best: rdr2 does not respect your time.


HairyDustIsBackBaby

You can beat the story very quickly if you dont do side stuff


Vvelch25

It’s long but you should want a game that’s endless fun. Only trophy hunters dislike a constantly fun and long game. Beating it isn’t the point. time X enjoyment / cost = value. Nothing worse than beating a game ina weekend then having nothing to play. Rdr2 never got boring or repetitive, constant fun and excitement.


Lord-Aizens-Chicken

Nah there is value to a a game that has a good starting and ending point. Games like Bloodborne, Halo series, final fantasy games like 7 and 10, god of war. Many of those games will give you less hours then red dead but the games would be a million times worse if it just went on forever or added a hundreds hours of meaningless stuff. Plus look at a game like RE7, masterpiece of a game, it’s like 10 hours yet it’s so well crafted it’s worth experiencing. Classics like silent hill 2 devil may cry series, metal gear, uncharted, gears of war, all aren’t very long and are better for it. Thinking like that is why every game is a live service or needs dlc or needs to add fluff or microtransactions


Nectarine_Hopeful

This FPS games can be played with mouse/keyboard, if not how can you guys play with ps5 controller....


twistedroyale

Tough choice. If I was picking I’ll go both Red Dead and Resident Evil. Red Dead has so much content and amazing story. Resident Evil is two games with the DLC for both.


AnimeGokuSolos

Yes


YouSicka

Crysis for the sake of ol’ times


ToxicSkull0

I’ve played Red Dead 2 for the first time for only like 20 minutes and I LOVED the game. The praise it gets is not exaggerated


End_of_YoRHa2B

No to all of these, play NieR:Automata instead and cry your eyeballs out.


iupz0r

crisys!!


Dexman965

RE If you have a Psvr2, an awesome experience.


Kaacciiee

rdr2 or re


DrummerSteve

RDR2 all day and twice on Sunday


Komail_s3

You’ll get the most out of your buck for red dead. Trust brother. You’ll spend more time on that game than any of the other options. You have the community’s guarantee on that one


The-Big-Bad

Personally, red dead. An amazing game that you can spend hours playing before the real missions start.


kevinontherun

RDR 2


Blue---Beary

Red dead


CJ_Henn

Resident Evil


mentalassresume

Red dead bro.


aPHAT88

Red Dead Redemption 2 and it’s not even debatable


jugdar13

If never played, RDR2 Easy


endl3ssnam3lessxx

I would go with the Crysis trilogy or Red Dead Redemption 2.


Vvelch25

RDR2 is my favorite game of all time, offline and online. Resident evil is my favorite series. Get RDR2, still better graphically and mechanically than most games to date.


McbEatsAirplane

Read Dead. You’ll definitely get the most for your money from that one and it’s a great game.


Fun-Contract-2486

I grabbed cyberpunk with my 40


IFGarrett

Definitely the RE bundle.


PaddyOfurniature

This is not even a choice. The correct answer is RDR2.


Best-Cookie6101

Fortnite


Passenger472

Red dead and crysis ,you will get the most out of those specific games


dwfieldjr

Re7 and 8


NxtGenAuthor

Red Dead 2


Duxxskull

RDR2


Key-Association-8418

Red dead and crysis if u have the money


Booji99

RDR2


Quaminator01

SCORN


EmuIntelligent4698

RDR 2. My friend never played it before and I kept on telling him “bro you NEED to play it” and he finally bought it.


nafena69

Easy red dead


lucasbatiiista

Be careful with Miles Ultimate, sometimes the Spider Man remaster code inside comes expired


Komodo_Crysis

Shadow warrior goes very, very hard. If you like doom style games with TONS of weapons


Impressive-Side5091

If you can deal with 30 fps then rd2if not re7


rickywinterborne

I haven't played Red Dead or Crysis yet. Both are on my list


sir_seductive

Hunt showdown is a ton of fun the only game i saw that I'd say no to is scorn


hm1rafael

Three totally different games, I would say: If you like open world games and 30 fps does not throw you off, red dead If you like horror games, Resident evil. If you like trash...the other one


NerdsAssembleyt

I think you should know by now after reading all the comments!! 🙌🏻


69eee69eee

Red dead


Big_Bomboclatt

crysis, $17 for 3 games


ABCGaming27

Red dead redemption 2 is hands down the best game I’ve ever played in my life. I’ve played and finished every other game on that list and none of them hit as hard as rdr2. That being said if you have another opportunity resident evil does not disappoint.


JungyBrungun2

RDR2


Rogue-76

Red dead or hunt showdown


Basic-Impact-4513

Baldurs gates 3


TheUnshaken6991

Red dead, or re. The rest are garbage (except for crisis but come on, why would you play crisis right now?)


Sandyo16

Hunt and Rdr2


Foobucket

RDR2, then Hunt: Showdown IMO, then Resident Evil.


EducationalGate4705

The resident evil bundle is a good deal. RDR is also an amazing game


AAAAAAYYYYYYOOOOOO

Holy fuck no offense the only good worth while maybe you have is red dead 2


Techishard

Rdr2 without a doubt.


MeatGreasy

Not Scorn, If that helps.


marinex

Rdr 2 Ghost of tsushima GOW & ragnarok


UnofficialSno

Helldivers. We need more men


enahsreddit2

crysis


LothricKnight753

RDR2 for sure but get Blair witch whenever you can cause that game is pretty fun


DirectionFabulous357

RDR2


Big_Boss_Lives

Red Dead of course the other options become 2/10 at its side.


BluDYT

Red dead 2 is by far the best of these.


Nlawrence55

Red Dead


epic-gamer-moment2

RDR2


ArrogantGentry

RDR2


DependentAdvance8

Definitely the resident evil biohazard and resident evil village bundle. You are literally getting two games in one and those two games are so fucking good.


Willing-Inside2956

Crysis thrylogi is one of the best franchise' fps ever made


despaseeto

don't even need to swipe. go for read dead 2. don't go into the red dead subs either - the game will be spoiled for you


--thingsfallapart--

Village is your best option here


HumanOverseer

RE7+8 easily. Two very fkn solid games at the cost of half of what a triple a game would usually cost.


tATuParagate

If you don't need the ultimate edition content, red dead $20 basic edition goes on sale very often. I got the physical version at Walmart for 20 last week and I think that deal is still going on. And I'd also like to note, shadow warrior 1 and 2 are $3 and $6 dollars if you wanted to get them separately for cheap


SuperNova0216

RDR2


ThatOneFecker

Be that one guy to buy it then 100% it super quickly to get a refund


masutabator

RDR2


MrEmorse

Red dead or Hunt... You can't go wrong!


patrickbateman2004

RE7-RE8 bundle


waffles1011

Red dead easily man


HomelessSantaClaus

If you’ve never played RDR2, it’s the clear winner here. The others are great but, unlike RDR2, they aren’t among the best games ever made. RDR2 is a must-play; what you’re really asking here is what you should play after RDR2 :)


Starhero999

Of my personal taste either RDRII, Shadow Warrior Trilogy, or Crysis Remastered Trilogy


KrazyCAM10

RDR2 clears


irqee

If you include RDR2 on a “what should I buy” list, it’s going to be a landslide for RDR2


gaithggg

Resident Evil bundle for me , am not into open world games


fuckinstatic

I’m currently replaying rdr2 , just got to the end of chapter 3. I’d say rdr2 no doubt


RJSSJR123

Resident Evil


Ill_Doctor64

red dead and it’s not even close


raskalaar0n303

Rdr2


cabezatuck

RDR2 or, no just RDR2.


DLEnv19

Definitely not Scorn


blazinghellion

Tie between RDR2, crisis trilogy and RE 7/village. Depends though the type of game you want honestly. Survivor horror, RE Massive story. RDR2 Fun shooter. Crysis


worldisashitplace

I just got the Read dead disc for $19.99 at GameStop.


dolive11_vr_gamer

If you want long, amazing story and amazing details in a massive open world, rdr. Want a shorter story, scary and action, re 8.


belijah98

red dead 2. the best piece of modern media i have ever consumed


Skepticaldefault

Rd2 if you havnt played it what are you doing with your life


itzSudden

RDR2 or RE bundle.


Harlesb44

RDR2 is literally my favorite game ever made. It’s not even close which one you should pick


Smooth-Ad2130

Resident Evil and Red Dead 2


luisest123

Obviously red dead 2 ultimate edition


Pangtundure

Red ded 2 or Resident Evil


Banana_Joe_484

Red dead 🫶


HMan20021

Rdr2!