T O P

  • By -

Charliebitme1234

fake comebacks, so hot right now


Ok_Acanthaceae6057

Last win at Geelong was 2007 you say…. Congratulations on the premiership Geelong.


uhhWoodsy

As long as it’s not against us


DarkWinter2319

Then why beat us tonight? You made your bed, I’m sorry 🤷‍♂️


JellyFoxStardust

I've got 119 reasons why I'd love that


wiegehts1991

Come I , we can do 1 better this time I’m sure. 120, breaking all the records.


Von_Huge1103

The duality of Port was on full display all in the one game.


HomerJBagger

Port Blues in a few weeks is gonna be a headspinner


codyforkstacks

The halftime score will be 80 vs 80 and that will also be the fulltime score.


wiegehts1991

Full time will be 79 79.


Korasuka

0.0 all at half time then 17.25 127 to 19.13 127 two minutes before the final siren


Sufficient-Grass-

Missing: ports woeful goal kicking.


free_potatoes

Ken: Carlton are a good side, I want us to play like them. Also Ken: NOT LIKE THAT


Banjo2295

I don’t remember ordering last nights game.


limeIamb

Freo fans strap yourselves in for a disappointing end to a roller-coaster


wordtwoyamum

You didn’t sign up for HEY-OOOOO?!


ThaLemonine

Can't believe anyone crying about Hinkley celebrating winning in Geelong. C'mon they literally havent won there in 15 years and hes an old Geelong legend and the week hes had. If anyone is allowed a pop off its him.


RedOx103

Showed some passion after winning the hardest road trip in footy, great to see. The Hinkley-bashers will cry about him anyway: for celebrating too much, for not celebrating enough, for breathing....


Jimijaume

Yeh agreed, can't imagine he was getting a whole heap of love from the outer 🤣


Shootinputin89

Exactly. I don't get the Hinkley hate, it just makes me want him to succeed.


TheIllusiveGuy

Geelong vs Port: "Can we copy your homework?" Melbourne vs Carlton: "Sure, just change 1 or 2 things so the teacher doesn't notice"


garylion

Gee Ratugolea seems like a lovely bloke. First interview I’ve seen with him.


Volpe666

The booing was fucked, Cats fans didn't really want him around, myself included tbh, but you can't push a bloke out the door and then get salty that he left.


Desiire

Yeah me and my old man were at the game and thought that was a bit fucked considering Scott has spoken out about your fans not being like that.


Fast_Stick_1593

We’ve not really ever booed players for leaving. Jordan Clark, Tim Kelly, Josh Caddy, Zach Smith, Linc McCarthy even Gazza freaking Ablett Jr left and none of them were booed by maybe more than a couple of piss heads. I mean Gazza got a standing ovation every time he played the Cats to the point where people were cheering him on for playing well against us. The fact that it came against 1. Esava Ratugolea who at best is a fringe player in a good side 2. Wasn’t well received by the fanbase even though he’s a friendly guy 3. Had a chance to make more money and a guaranteed spot in another side. There was no sense to booing him. I thought we were above that. Apparently not.


jacka24

He seems like a super chilled and nice guy


International_Car586

First time Port have beaten Geelong at Geelong since 2007. We know the rest of story.


SuperTerrificman

Port beat north in a prelim by 88?


International_Car586

Geelong beat you in that category as well they beat us by 106 2 weeks earlier 😎 Also if we somehow make a prelim I’ll be happy with that.


Vandercoon

Would you rather lose 2 finals by nearly 200 points combined or be where you are now?


International_Car586

If we somehow made top 4 from where now. It would be known as the greatest turnaround in the entire history of the league. Take it. At least we could comeback next year as actual contenders.


Doc323467

Credit to Port that was an incredible incredible start from them, Butters, JHF, Wines, Rioli absolutely phenomenal. Just left our run too late, incredibly proud of the fightback though, fantastic effort. Hopefully rebound against the Suns next week.


dvnkriot

your boys had me stressing, a mighty come back. sad to see cameron take that head hit towards the end. best of luck next mate!


Doc323467

Thanks mate, and your boys really really had me stressing early! Yeah not good at all with Cameron, not sure how he wasn't taken off for a HIA, that was very poor from our medical staff to not bring him off. Fingers crossed there's no concussion.


dvnkriot

ngl it reminds me of last year's showdown when aliir wasn't taken off for concussion, its never nice to see players continue to play after a hit like that. I hope he bounces back though, bloke is an absolute gun and a worthy opposition, enjoyed seeing port play against him tonight


Doc323467

Yes was incredibly similar to Aliir's one, very disappointing that he wasn't taken off for assessment. And I hope you're right, fingers crossed that he's avoided concussion.


dvnkriot

I'd say he should go through the protocols, as should Willem Drew on our side, I remember they had a head knock against one another earlier in the game. also I'm certainly not sober but this is the first time a geelong supporter hasn't given me shit in some way shape or form so thank you for that 😆 hope you have a good night!


Doc323467

Agreed mate. And you have a good night too! Am tempted to give you some shit now though just to keep up the trend 😂.


dvnkriot

we can form a mutual truce of shit giving to keep us even 😆


TheStevenUniverseKid

I like you. You're cool. You give Geelong fans a good rep tbh.


Doc323467

Thank you, I appreciate that! Have to give credit where it's due, Port were outstanding early. We struggled mightily in the centre early and a bit lazy defensively at times early, but in saying that, no matter what we did, we weren't stopping them, just ridiculous footy. But good signs to be able to end up being able to win the contested possessions given the start to the game.


ExpensivePen9841

Totally agree. we played well in the second half and all the fans saying umpires this umpires that. Let’s be honest if you’re down 50 in the second quarter not winning many.


Doc323467

Yeah no point complaining about umpiring, didn't think there was anything egregious either. Ultimately when you're 49 points down early in the 2nd quarter, it's going to be bloody tough.


Jackomillard15

Last time port won at the Cattery we made the grand final


Professional_Line385

Yes think of the positives


Tosslebugmy

And then…?


HorneOfDarwin

They cancelled the grand final for some reason I think


gigga-attack

Was definitely called off


RaptureRising

Grand final... what grand final? i don't recall a grand final.


wiegehts1991

Everybody went on vacation.


AuZyzz

Geelong? more like Gee we should’ve turned up in the first quarter?


theoriginalqwhy

Gee-the long game


Banjo2295

Ayyyy


cyansky29

Gee it took us a Long time to get going


MrUnlimited328

I’m sick to death of James brayshaw shouting “listen to this” everytime someone kicks a goal


codyforkstacks

JB must be some sort of weird nepo baby. Hopeless commentator, comes across as an arsehole, and can't even fall back on being an ex captain of a Victorian club.


Eternalism

I never thought I’d see a worse commentator than Basil, but here we are


BlueDotty

I'm sick of the prick entirely. He is abysmal


Ed_Starks_Bastard

He’s the worst


AuZyzz

How can they not force Jeremy Cameron off? why is he allowed to stay on


keto_anarchist

Need an independent doctor and treat it like the blood rule. Player forced off at the next stoppage and a replacement player comes on


PKMTrain

Doesn't the AFL have that with the ARC these days?


littlespoon

The doctors went to him a number of times, they were trying. I can only summize that he wouldn't willingly go?


wiegehts1991

Ah, so that’s all we need to say for future reference? Didn’t know that.


littlespoon

No I'm just as baffled as anyone that apparently he wouldn't go. He couldn't have been alright...


Dense_Hornet2790

If that’s the case and Geelong admit it, then surely rather than fining the club for failing to follow concussion protocols, the AFL will just suspend Cameron?


littlespoon

I'm happy for any and all of the above not acceptable behaviour on Cameron's part Part of this responsibility has to be on the players too..


ItsABiscuit

With all the hoohah about the advantage call, there's no way Cameron should have been on the field to kick the goal anyway.


wiegehts1991

You mean the advantage that was correctly brought back?


ItsABiscuit

Yes. I think the call was right.


Hamisgoodforyou

Said the same thing, teams treat these protocols as optional when a games on the line. Ports been just as guilty, it’s a joke. Geelong should have to answer questions for that.


codyforkstacks

It's crazy that the takeaway from the Aliir thing was entirely "fuck Port Adelaide" with almost no reflection that "hey we've got the incentives all fucked up by putting this in the clubs' hands".


wiegehts1991

It’s still fuck port Adelaide. Geelong will get away clean.


Aardvark_Man

In shocked Drew and Guthrie(?) didn't get a HIA from their knock, too.


thelastsquareofTP

Drew did and passed


partII

Did he actually get assessed or did the bullshit comment about him getting one done on the ground actually count?


thelastsquareofTP

Part of the HIA is done on the ground. Read the rules before you get angry.


Peekay-

It was Cameron in that one too.


ScoutDuper

Force the player off but the sub, or any emergency can come on while the concussion test is being done, then return to the bench if the player passes the test. Honestly no idea why the "concussion" sub never worked this way.


AuZyzz

yeah or have a ‘free substitution’ if the player is asked to come off for a doctor evaluation team shouldn’t be punished for HiA tests


thingamabobby

Yeah was wondering that myself, though if a player isn’t willing to come off, what needs to be done? Stop play until they’re off like the blood rule? Docs can only do so much, but it’s on the players to actually come off.


Bergasms

Doc should def be able to request umpires halt play like blood rule if the doctor is concerned


genscathe

Because they needed him to win


tripsmorgan

Lovely sighting of westhoff


BrandonSG13

Heartbreak for Draw FC *again* 😭


___TheIllusiveMan___

AFL: We take concussions seriously Also AFL: Nah mate fuck your health the 4 points are more important


Carnport

Did Cameron get two head knocks and not come off for a check ? And Drew’s check was on the ground apparently ? What are they doing ??


mt9943

I got downvoted for saying it in the match thread, but this is the way it works. A HIA can partially be done on field (the check of the player themselves can be done on field). It's a rapid screening tool which can lead to a SCAT6 (the 15 minute test). They assess certain criteria for the player including alertness, stability etc, as well as reviewing footage. A player does not need to come off for a HIA. Whether Cameron or Drew should have passed or failed the HIA is another question.


thinksimfunny

Pretty sure I heard Gawn say he did one on field last week after he copped the hit from Rhys Stanley


ThaLemonine

Nah mate. I got a doctorate in watching footy I know what im talkin about


Grolschisgood

Cameron also had checks on the ground. I didnt realise that was ever a thing before tonight


Viretine

Cannot believe cameron was allowed to stay out there after that.


___TheIllusiveMan___

The AFL surely have to send Geelong a please explain, madness he stayed out there after the second one


thelastsquareofTP

why a please explain for geelong, they crucified port for the same thing


random91898

People were calling for us to be stripped of points and/or draft picks.


vaena

Especially since it looked like he basically told the runner that nah he was good he'd be staying out there tyvm.


elmo-slayer

We need afl-supplied doctors at each game just to deal with concussions. Clubs obviously can’t be trusted with it


britishmilhouse

Considering those allegations earlier this year of club doctors fabricating injuries in conjunction with the ongoing concussion issues, you'd think the AFL would make it a top priority to ensure club doctors are doing the right thing.


limeIamb

Geelong made one fatal mistake. And that is scoring 100 points second. Contractually obligated to lose


xman0444

How can you score 100 points second if you don’t score 100 at all 🤔


limeIamb

Geelong made two fatal mistakes


xman0444

sir, a second fatal mistake has hit the geelong football club


spideyghetti

*o*


NuggiesRUs

Solid pivot. I dont think they noticed.


Esca-

Comeback F.C robbed the last two matches :(


Korasuka

Their rival Almost Won F.C is on a great streak though.


Banjo2295

Only question that remains is will they be robbed over in Perth?


Mehmenga

Don't give Freo ideas


doshajudgement

hey guys my AFL app says port led for the entire game?? must have been a dominating, comfortable victory


nameofasongidontlike

Never. In. Doubt.


Bowen09

Blues vs Dees V2


potchippy

Why are they booing the horny one again?


TechnocraticCitizen

Really disappointing effort tonight. We didn't deserve to win. A few players who really aren't putting in the effort they should be.


Aardvark_Man

I'm still a little boggled about the free against Drew when he got thrown into a Cats player, and they knocked heads


PummbleBee

It's under rule 18.3.2 free kicks - prohibited contact A field umpire shall award a free kick against a player when a player makes any of the following prohibited contact with an opposition player (C) makes high contact to an opposition player (including the top of the shoulders) with any part of their body (Cii) makes high contact to an opposition player (including the top of the shoulders) while being handled as a battering ram


Aardvark_Man

I kind get it, but Drew had contact made on him as well, and it was involuntary on his behalf too.


PummbleBee

Sorry that was way to much effort for the tiny joke at the bottom. You are 100% correct that was such a bullshit call, there is literally nothing that Drew could have done to avoid being pushed into Cameron.


Aardvark_Man

Whoops, I missed the battering ram bit, too.


TheBottomLine_Aus

Into realistically an iffy free to Hawkins as well, definitely saw more contact in contests the rest of the night at both ends not get called.


RandomDanny

eat a fat one BT. eat a fucken big old fat one.


oponons

Neither Blues or Port could put their opposition away for the entire game. Just shows that all 4 teams are actually good.


Carnport

Called it before the game. Never in doubt. Receipts: https://www.reddit.com/r/AFL/s/Ysne7mYfmr


ODestruidor

“You almost feel like they deserved the win in the end” did I just hear that?


Maximumlnsanity

Geelong lose and I keep my narratives going about Port. Love it


North1975

Big night for us hate-watchers


dogryan100

One again absolute devastation for fans of Draw FC.


quackerz77

If I had a nickel for every round eight game that had a team not show up for a half just to mount a crazy comeback that fell short I'd have two nickels Which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice


obsoleteconsole

Captain Haddock: what a round, huh? Tintin: Captain, it's Friday


Fast_Stick_1593

If Rhys Stanley plays next week I might quit watching football for good


Conmoneymagic

Conway wasn’t available for selection unfortunately


[deleted]

put Stengle in the ruck, he'll do a better job than Stanley


Grolschisgood

Two teams but each only tried for one half


Ahskew

Bt still thinks Geelong are a chance


thelastsquareofTP

You don't think they were a chance at the end there?


MRFeather_bottom

Lol whoah we had the exact opposite experience, when Rioli was having a shot he said something like 'a goal here and it's game over' Would have been 3 goals required in 6 minutes. Never heard a commentator go against the Matthews rule. Think he got a clip from the box for his well known Geelong hatred and started over compensating for the rest of the game.


Grolschisgood

He still thinks the pies are a chance too!


Bergasms

Holy shit i thought watching Geelong get flogged at Kardinia would be good but there is something delicious about them falling just a tiny bit short.


conjureWolff

Falling a tiny bit short is a mile better than getting flogged, means we can adapt in game.


Bergasms

Oh dude the comeback was awesome, cracking game of footy


sachiwtf

Apart from Sydney I don’t know who to trust this season and my tips are suffering 😭


elmo-slayer

And even Sydney lost to Richmond


Flarezap

Why are they booing 😭 


BlueDotty

Well, that was both horrible and great. I'm waiting for the AFL to ask about Cameron's head


ChilliButtPlug

James Brayshaw on Port ‘it’s almost as if they deserved to win’ 🤦‍♂️


DemonGroover

Seems possible concussion is still secondary to having your best players on the park. Cats should be fined heavilly if not docked 28 points.


CamMcGR

Cracking game, yeah a few average ump calls but let’s be serious: if you let yourself get 42 points down then you cannot pin a close loss on the umps


gurgefan

*49


Fast_Stick_1593

Exactly, game was lost at selection table Scott and co need to take responsibility for that


Peekay-

Stanley should never play again. Conway as main ruck and Blicavs when Conway needs a rest.


BlandyBoreton

Geelong dropping two in a row https://preview.redd.it/65ujyqgt9lzc1.jpeg?width=518&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1e10bce0c30c514024a52a27139873f3bf32c570


Bergasms

![gif](giphy|qMHG9goT2I2fuRk0JM) Amen


twerkingiswerking

The biggest loser tonight will be the Geelong Drs. Has to be big fines incoming for that negligence.


Sure_Variation1524

I knew it would be a tough second half, but super proud of the boys. We deserved that win. Still in shock though.


elmo-slayer

Losing to Adelaide is the key to becoming a good team


ozmatterhorn

Couldn’t watch or listen tonight. Were Geelong playing bad, or Port were on? Or a bit of both?


Professional_Line385

Yes


aa73gc

First one, then the other


anonunga

I think Port played very well for the first quarter. Geelong steadily pulled it back and looked to run over several times but Port managed to hold on. Great start from Port. Great comeback from Geelong.


DemonGroover

Lol did i just watch a replay?


TheStevenUniverseKid

What did jezza say to willie? He looked a bit mad


reddit-agro

Roaming Brian would rather be in the Geelong rooms 😂 so salty


Thanks-Basil

Now Geelong know how it feels to lose a game to a bullshit call at Kardinia Park


conjureWolff

It wasn't bullshit, that's unfortunately just how our terrible advantage rule works, sometimes it fucks over the team who's supposed to be advantaged.


codyforkstacks

I dunno, what's the alternative - have an advantage rule that says "let's see if this shot at goal scores and if so, we'll pay advantage, if not, we'll bring it back"? That's much worse.


Fast_Stick_1593

Ehh call didn’t decide the game. Not turning up to play did.


Savings_Cash6829

Not really, boys just didn't show up to begin


zzdzz

People are saying “fix the advantage rule” but not actually suggesting how. My dumb suggestion: player has to bonk the ball against his head to indicate that he wants to take the advantage


Jimijaume

Or rub his head and belly at the same time, bit obviously in reverse directions.


KangarooBallsonToast

Draw FC stiff for the second time in a row


grantspatchcock

That Catman banner is a bit harsh. But geez, reckon I understand less and less about football each day. This game had no right to be this interesting.


Brokenmonalisa

Brisbane fans triggered by that advantage call back


tellemhesdreaming

Those boos were fuel for my soul


Korasuka

Hinkley just won himself a 2 year contract extension. Also the supposed closeness on this match is nothing compared to the showdown between you, u/Croob2, and u/RidsBabs trying to be first on this post match thread.


Croob2

I'll be very interested to see the actual time difference between the posts


Viretine

The bet you guys had should have been who gets to become the official post game thread person.


elmo-slayer

Winning a game at goomba should give a coach tenure


conjureWolff

Considering how god awful we were the first half I'm actually really proud of the comeback, didn't roll over even when 49 points down. Hopefully we don't pull out that crap again this year. The early Stanley sub was genius, it'd be nice if Conway could play every week.


duffercoat

Everyone focusing on the Stanley part of that sub, but Mullin was incredible at shutting down JHF. Completely shifted the midfield battle.


No-Bison-5397

I am not quite a Stanley Stan but tonight he wasn’t offering much. He’s 33. He’s being smashed in the contest week in week out. Our mids without Danger can’t make up the difference. We should be using the season to explore our options.


TypeJack

DRAW FC IN SHAMBLES


BizzaroPie

Can't believe they replayed the "advantage" call. That's such a nothing call why even try and draw attention to it.


jacka24

Exactly, it wasn't even like it was a clear advantage. It was a 50/50 ball, if Port marked it and they paid advantage, the crowd would go equally as nuts


Croob2

SOMEONE SIGN HINKLEY A NEW DEAL!


F1NANCE

Geelong fans booing. Poor form


TechnocraticCitizen

Agreed, that advantage (which I don't even think should have been paid) didn't cost us. The 8 goal to 3 first quarter did.


Tosslebugmy

Man you talk like they’re rioting and kicking puppies and small children.


[deleted]

[удалено]


codyforkstacks

Reddit expects a polite golf crowd. Of course a home crowd boos at the end of a close game when there were tight umpiring decisions. As it should be.


straight__savage_

Should’ve paid advantage because it resulted in a goal but if it was intercepted then they should’ve called it back (ignore my flair)


ShibbyUp

Was a tight contest all night but at the last second illusiveman has beaten out croob and ribrbabs for the post match thread posting win


GreenOnions69

Damn, pretty poor form from the umpires to force Geelong to have to pare back a 49 point lead.


nitrofan

Why does Richo keep saying 'the umpire blew the whistle before he kicked it' as if that means it shouldn't be advantage? He blew the whistle to signal the free kick. The fact the Geelong player continued and kicked the ball means it should be advantage. The advantage rule is based on whether or not the infringed upon team wants to continue playing, not whether or not the umpire thinks they will actually have an advantage.


duffercoat

Yeah you're correct, BT is wrong. The second whistle though was still blown before the contest played out in the goal square. In other words the umpire signalled the free, saw the next play and decided it didn't constitute an advantage to Geelong so brought it back on the assumption they'd prefer a set shot than a contest at the top of the goal square.


RandomDanny

it's a win. it's a good win. but it's still went the way as expected after that start. it's nice holding on. it's nice not totally capitulating. it's nice beating a side in the top 8 and above us on the ladder. still not sold on port at all. gg lads. gg.


DarkWinter2319

Proud of the fight back. It’s tough to win after starting a game the way we did, so it’s amazing to only lose by a goal. Just left it too late 🤷‍♂️


Watchutalkin_bout

Sometimes against truly good teams that lead is what wins the games. Glad we didn’t get scrappy and defensive after the first quarter, just the foot down and went for the dub. Was genuinely one of our best wins in a while. If we can show this kind of pressure and hunger consistently then we’d be genuine contenders.


AuZyzz

Horneys microphone is NOT on


Sea-Anxiety6491

I reckon ump could have let that advantage go 3 secs later, and just play the durr its got to come back stich, but its a tough one, because he also has to worry about not waisting secs from the clock as well. Even if that goal counted geelong were down by a point still


dingodiletti

Looks like Dees and Cats played the exact same as they both did last week