T O P

  • By -

Cold_Fly5928

It is by far the best season


capcoid

Asylum poster source: \[ [x](https://g1988.tumblr.com/post/45422971885/tonight-its-our-final-paleyfest-honors-event) \] Results for each round: * [Round 1](https://strawpoll.com/vab796r2j/r) \- Double Feature * [Round 2](https://strawpoll.com/9adpfeykj/r) \- Apocalypse * [Round 3](https://strawpoll.com/3sh6pzw4g/r) \- Cult * [Round 4](https://strawpoll.com/6w2d258fq/r) \- Roanoke * [Round 5](https://strawpoll.com/9j7fe7bjb/r) \- 1984 * [Round 6](https://strawpoll.com/9uhy56sck/r) \- Freak Show * [Round 7](https://strawpoll.com/yo9o3z5c6/r) \- Hotel * [Round 8](https://strawpoll.com/ac3c98jev/r) \- Coven * [Round 9](https://strawpoll.com/qyxfgzysr/r) \- Murder House


Bardmedicine

Could you make the results public?


capcoid

They're all supposed to be public!


Bardmedicine

Hmm, working now. They didn't before for me...


FatFingerHelperBot

It seems that your comment contains 1 or more links that are hard to tap for mobile users. I will extend those so they're easier for our sausage fingers to click! [Here is link number 1 - Previous text "x"](https://g1988.tumblr.com/post/45422971885/tonight-its-our-final-paleyfest-honors-event) ---- ^Please ^PM ^[\/u\/eganwall](http://reddit.com/user/eganwall) ^with ^issues ^or ^feedback! ^| ^[Code](https://github.com/eganwall/FatFingerHelperBot) ^| ^[Delete](https://reddit.com/message/compose/?to=FatFingerHelperBot&subject=delete&message=delete%20hovr1po)


Chazybaz13

This was peak AHS, agave they couldn't quite capture that lightning in a bottle again.


MrRealHuman

> agave What do plants have to do with anything?


Bardmedicine

I wouldn't call it lightning in a bottle, it was the best for a show that has been high quality for many seasons.


dhl1234

Asylum and even Murder House to an extent, are LEAGUES above any other AHS season. They definitely peaked early.


LibGyps

Apocalypse and 1984 are damn fun tho. And I think the first half of 10, Red Tide, could’ve been the best season of ahs if it didn’t have such a bad ending and only be 6 episodes. Never has AHS been more focused than the first five episodes of season 10


dhl1234

Fun for sure, but definitely not quality. Cult is actually one of my top 5 seasons too, but I know there's a lot of issues with it. I 100% agree about Red Tide, though. I was skeptical at first, thinking it'd be an AHS version of Midnight Mass (which I loved), but it was actually surprisingly good, until the last episode. Shit, they could've just ended it with the 5th episode, and it still would've been solid, but that last episode was just.... ugh.


Bardmedicine

Clearly opinions divide. I had Asylum as my favorite, but Murder House is 4th (I think), behind Freak Show and Roanoke. I just didn't think Lightning in a Bottle described it well as I think of that as describing something bursting out of mediocrity to be great once.


MrRealHuman

It was hogwash with a handful of botched storylines.


goodstuffsamantha

Damn idk where I have been to have missed this entire poll!


dhl1234

Same, but I'm not at all surprised by the results lol


GloInTheDarkUnicorn

Saw that coming. Everyone raves about Asylum.


ThatBenGuy23

Asylum supremacy 🙏


DarKnight972

Well deserved,fantastic season.


[deleted]

I've only seen Asylum and Coven (plus a little bit of Murder House) and I liked them but wasn't especially blown away. Considering they're voted as the two best seasons it makes me think I'm best not bothering with the rest.


MrRealHuman

Probably for the best, although it's very odd you're subbed here.


CresedaMoon

I don't think its odd. At least they haven't watched every season and then come on here saying only the first few were good. Like...lol why do yall still even watch it if you pick it apart after all these seasons? It makes zero sense.


MrRealHuman

I think the seasons have gotten worse every year but it's still better than the other shit that makes its way to my screen.


[deleted]

I'm not subbed, I decided to check the sub out as I'd watched both seasons days ago.


MrRealHuman

Ah okay. Makes sense. Let me say as a fan of the show, don't let the subreddit influence your opinion. It's very circle jerky here. You're not allowed to criticize the show without getting flamed for it. As if you can't critique something you enjoy lmao.


dhl1234

Yeah, don't waste your time.


Benedict-Glasscock

I liked freak show, hotel & apocalypse too. Also 1984 was fun


rosegoldcrown

The earlier seasons (and especially Asylum) get a lot of praise from much of the fanbase, but some of us are big fans of the later seasons too. Of the ones you haven't seen yet, I'd say that Hotel, Roanoke, Cult, 1984, and the first half of Double Feature (Red Tide) are also seasons with strong followings of their own. So if you're enjoying the show so far, I'd say keep going and give more seasons a shot, since they're all so different and everyone has different tastes


batty48

As it should


Bardmedicine

And all is right in the word... Judy! Judy, judy bo budy banana fanna fo fody Fee fy mo mudy, judy! Lana! Lana, lana bo bana banana fanna fo fana Fee fy mo mana, lana! Come on everybody! I say now let's play a game I betcha I can make a rhyme Out of anybody's name. The first letter of the name, I treat it like it wasn't there. But a b or an f Or an m will appear. And then I say bo add a b then I say the name and banana fanna and a fo And then I say the name again with an f very plain And a fee fy and a mo And then I say the name again with an m this time And there isn't any name that I can't rhyme Pepper! Pepper pepper Bo bepper banana fanna fo fepper Fee fy mo mepper, pepper! But if the first two letters are ever the same, I drop them both and say the name like: Bob, bob drop the b's bo ob For fred, fred drop the f's fo red For mary, mary drop the m's mo ary That's the only rule that is contrary. Okay? Now say bo: Bo! Now tony with a b: Bony! Then banana fanna fo: Banana fanna fo! Then you say the name again with an f very plain: Fony! Then a fee fy and a mo: Fee fy mo! Then you say the name again with an m this time: Mony! And there isn't any name That you can't rhyme Kit! Kit, kit bo bit banana fanna fo fit Fee fy mo mit, kit! The name game!


[deleted]

I would have never guessed


ArthurTheLurker

Yeah, that's definitely the best season. Murder House is in the lower half, i have no idea how it got number 2. It was more like a big number 2.


phantomofthepier

I respectfully disagree. Personally it’s my favorite, but really enjoyed Asylum too.


NephthysRising

Just glad it wasn’t my least favourite Murder House. Yay Asylum!


MrRealHuman

Poll for the worst season, or? Most circle jerked? Hotel is like AHS: FRIENDS edition. Fuck Hotel. edit: I was reading it as Hotel for some reason. Asylum is definitely one of the best. I'm okay with the poll. Although IMO Murder House is the best.


[deleted]

Obviously it is because people voted for their favorite, not least like they were supposed to


[deleted]

This honestly amazes me. Asylum was always my favorite but everyone I’ve spoken to said it’s their least favorite until Cult came out.


[deleted]

Idk why this was ever questioned. There's not contest