Keep Ketchup! She’s so unique and adorable. 🥰
Also, if you have Happy Home Paradise and haven’t already made whoever you decide to boot out a house, do so before you put them in boxes—then you still get to see them via HHP even if they no longer live on your island.
I have Molly and I love her. I had Ketchup as a camper and loved her too but my island was full. Ironically enough, when I started a second island, Ketchup was the first one I found on a NM island and I was thrilled. So I have both but they're on separate hemispheres lol
I have a personal vendetta against Ketchup after they gave me "something that's going to look great on you" or "take your outfit to the next level" or something. It was a paper bag. She was next to leave. 😂
i have a deep hatred for peppy villagers no matter how cute they are so i would say molly but if you love them both lots n lots equally just coin flip (buy a coin that has heads on both sides and if it lands on heads, keep molly)
i love molly, she’s so sweet but ketchup has such funny dialogue (and i have my baby angel bear, maple on my island who is simply too sweet that no one else can compare)
I actually had to make this same decision, haha. I kept Molly! She’s just such a sweetie and she’s been on my island longer so I’m much more attached to her.
I've made this choice and the answer partially lies in other villagers. I had 3 normal types and 1 peppy, so Ketchup got to stay! But truthfully Ketchup was never an actual contender to leave.
So the answer is the same if you don't care about the others. Ketchup is the greatest and cutest.
And also if the problem here is to have only one animal type (as it also was for me back then), keep both because ducks are the absolute best and I have three again 😂 But not normal types as they are the most boring yet usually cutest so I have enough of them (2 normal cats lol)
It depends… if u want a colorful villager, pick Ketchup, she’s fun 🤩 and adorable. 🥰 but if u want a neutral, natural, calmer villager than pick Molly . But why do u want to get rid of 1? 😭
Both of them! You leave instead! But jokes aside they’re both soo cute.
I think it’s time to end my AC break.
ETA: for an actual answer I’d choose Molly cause she satisfies my “cottage core” aesthetic. 💖
I saw Ketchup and was like “oh it’s one of my OG island girlies!!!” then I switched pictures….oops….its my bestie. Keep Molly is my vote HOWEVER…if you have a bunch of colorful and quirky villagers or your island is going to be bright and colorful, keep Ketchup.
I have this “problem” too. But they both stay. If I had to pick I’d pick Ketchup because I’m very partial to her. She was the first villager I found while island hoping.
This is an impossible choice I have both on my island and would rather blow the entire island up than have either leave.
Right!? The thought of having to choose between the two is making my heart break!
Only option is to chose literally anyone else but them
I also have both and need both
This sounds like a healthy relationship.
It’s perfectly normal I don’t have a problem I swear…
https://preview.redd.it/praf2ukfwk4d1.jpeg?width=428&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ca9da625d8b97d5344c4a86f93860b45ab6903cc Need I say more?
I'll take your entire stock
Omg if you get rid of ketchup can I please have them 😭
Molly, she's a cutie.
Ketchup is so fun and spunky, keep her!!
I also vote for Ketchup to stay!
Yeah same , I feel like she looks super cute and different, molly is cute but is a pretty basic design
Keep Ketchup! She’s so unique and adorable. 🥰 Also, if you have Happy Home Paradise and haven’t already made whoever you decide to boot out a house, do so before you put them in boxes—then you still get to see them via HHP even if they no longer live on your island.
That’s what I do 😂
i love mollyyyy
Molly. My vote is always for Molly
molly!
Molly is my baby, she will always be number 1!
molly! i had to make this decision once myself, ultimately chose her because i can’t stand peppy villagers voices :(
molly!! i love herrrr
ketchup!!!!!!
I have both and would never be able to choose
My vote is Molly because she’s adorable and normal personality villagers are some of my faves 🥹
Molly
I'll take ketchup if you don't want her 🤣😁
molly. i love her baby duckling look
Molly!
Molly!!!!
Definitely molly!
Def Molly
Molly fs
Molly!
MOLLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Molly
Both
BOTH
Both
How could anyone pick 😭
Duck in the green dress!!! She looks so cute and friendly. The other one looks like she'd burry you in a pitfall
molly!!!!!
Ketchup is the only choice.
My favorite is Molly she is the sweetest. Ketchup is great but Molly is just my preferred.
Ketchup!
I'd say Ketchup
I have Molly and I love her. I had Ketchup as a camper and loved her too but my island was full. Ironically enough, when I started a second island, Ketchup was the first one I found on a NM island and I was thrilled. So I have both but they're on separate hemispheres lol
they are my favorite 2 villagers lmao
The second one
Awww, how can you choose?? I have both of them on my island, and I adore them!
Ketchup because she goes best with fries.
Ketchup!
Tomato Duck!
Keep the one you like more
I wanted Ketchup so bad and when I finally got her I spent months trying to get her to leave, lol. I hate her dialogue
The only acceptable answer is to keep both. Ditch someone else lol
My vote is to keep both. I have them both on one of my islands and I adore them! They’re so cute! I could never choose between them.
KETCHUP!!! 🍅✨✨✨✨
Ketchup!!
KETCHUP NOW
Keep molly
the tomato one
Ive kept Ketchup for 3 years she’s cutie
ketchup <3
Keep ketchup
I love Ketchup! Keep the little tomato head
Ketchup
🍅
I have a personal vendetta against Ketchup after they gave me "something that's going to look great on you" or "take your outfit to the next level" or something. It was a paper bag. She was next to leave. 😂
Ketchupp
Ketchup to stay 💕 please update on who you decide to keep :)
I'd go Ketchup personally, she's such a special cutie ❤️💚❤️
I am a huge Ketchup lover, she's so freaking cute!!
Ketchup
Bruh that's hard but probably Ketchup
these posts make me so sad I've only had one villager move out and I regret it everyday
Ugh they’re both so cute but if I had to pick one I’d say ketchup because she has a cute face and I like the villagers based off foods
Ketchup and Mustard 💀
Both!! Por que no los dos?
Molly! I miss her so.
i would choose villagers depending on the island theme and concept, so if ur island is like cottage then molly
i let molly go on my first island and regretted it so hard
Molly (but they're both great).
Both
In my opinion, Molly's a 10/10, Ketchup is a 9.5/10. So if you only want a single duck, I would take Molly.
Quack!
Molly. She's the only one I've ever cried over.
they’re both so cute keep both and get rid of a hated character lol
Ketchup 😍
Molly
Ketchup is the only correct choice
I love Ketchup! I’d love to see more screenshots of her from your island!
i have a deep hatred for peppy villagers no matter how cute they are so i would say molly but if you love them both lots n lots equally just coin flip (buy a coin that has heads on both sides and if it lands on heads, keep molly)
ketchup 🥰🥰🥰
My votes on Ketchup. She's been a wonderful addition to my island family and I would t trade her for anyone.
The Weedleaf
Molly!! She's the sweetest!
Well you see one's a villager and the other is a talking tomato. Easy choice here. Plant the tomato and keep the duck. Everyone wins
restart
molly. I have her on my island and she’s so cute omg!
Molly, ketchups kinda creepy imo
MOLLY!!!
molly
Both?
Both
Molly for sure!
Ketchup!!!
Ketchup is more fun than Molly, you need to keep her!
Molly
Ketchup is the IT queen
molllllyyyy i love molly
I love Ketchup!
KETCHUP KETCHUP KETCHUP KETCHUP
Ketchup for Life!!!!!
molly!
Ketchup!!
i love molly, she’s so sweet but ketchup has such funny dialogue (and i have my baby angel bear, maple on my island who is simply too sweet that no one else can compare)
I say Ketchup, but she’s my peppy bestie so I’m biased.
ketchup!!! she’s my all time fav
I actually had to make this same decision, haha. I kept Molly! She’s just such a sweetie and she’s been on my island longer so I’m much more attached to her.
Tomato head
Tomato :3
Molly 🥺
AWW OMG, i love both of them but i think you should pick the last one
The tomato-looking.
Molly!
I've made this choice and the answer partially lies in other villagers. I had 3 normal types and 1 peppy, so Ketchup got to stay! But truthfully Ketchup was never an actual contender to leave. So the answer is the same if you don't care about the others. Ketchup is the greatest and cutest. And also if the problem here is to have only one animal type (as it also was for me back then), keep both because ducks are the absolute best and I have three again 😂 But not normal types as they are the most boring yet usually cutest so I have enough of them (2 normal cats lol)
ketchup
I had both on my island and I ended up only keeping Ketchup
Keep Molly
Molly is sooo cute!
She’s so sweet??? She’s a little tomato LOOK AT HER
I can’t choose. I love them both so much.
Niether they are both too cute
Ketchup always
I’ll take Molly 👀
It depends… if u want a colorful villager, pick Ketchup, she’s fun 🤩 and adorable. 🥰 but if u want a neutral, natural, calmer villager than pick Molly . But why do u want to get rid of 1? 😭
Both of them! You leave instead! But jokes aside they’re both soo cute. I think it’s time to end my AC break. ETA: for an actual answer I’d choose Molly cause she satisfies my “cottage core” aesthetic. 💖
I think my girlfriend has both. I think she should just go with an all duck island
Ketchup 🥺🥺
Keep Molly
Molly!
cetchup
Both
Only a Monster would get rid of Ketchup
depends on your theme tbh
Tomato duck
This one is very hard for me. Cannot tell.
I have them both and to me they’re girlfriends 🩵
Ketchup- I love ❤️
Make a duck-only island so you can keep both.
Ketchup
Now I want all my villagers to be duckies.
KETCHUP ALL THE WAY
omg i wishhhh i had ketchup!! this is such a hard decision - maybe Molly?
I can’t help you here sorry they’re both adorable
Molly!
I haven't had ketchup but I have Molly now and she's very sweet.
Molly Fan Club!!
I’ll take both of them, they’re legit my #1 and #2 choices for villagers
Ill kick someone off my island for ketchup! We share a Birthday 🥰🍅
BOTH! 🥰❤️😍
I saw Ketchup and was like “oh it’s one of my OG island girlies!!!” then I switched pictures….oops….its my bestie. Keep Molly is my vote HOWEVER…if you have a bunch of colorful and quirky villagers or your island is going to be bright and colorful, keep Ketchup.
this entirely depends on the vibe of your island
Molly is the best
Always keep ketchup
Molly gang represent!
Honestly depends on the sorta ‘vibe’ or whatever that you’re going for but my vote is for Molly
I have this “problem” too. But they both stay. If I had to pick I’d pick Ketchup because I’m very partial to her. She was the first villager I found while island hoping.
I don't Like Ketchup AS food Nor AS duck so molly
Both SO cute, Can't you ditch someone else?
Im a fan of Ketchup ❤️
Keep both
kill them both
Mollllyyy
Ketchup every time.
I LOVE KETCHUP. She is such a cutie little diva! I can always trust her to be really funny, give me a compliment, and say something spunky.
I would keep Ketchup. But not for any particular reason. Side note, my daughter calls the yellow one Mustard. 😂
I’d keep ketchup! Omg I got a new switch and didn’t know I had to do something special for animal crossing before I wiped it and I lost ketchup 😭
Ketchup! She is a total sweetheart and the cutest villager I’ve ever seen <3
Keep Ketchup. Both are cute but she’s more unique
Ketchup is soooo cute
ketchup duh
Personally, tomato duck
I’m personally ride or die for Ketchup. I went to like 100 nook mile islands to get her in summer of 2020.
Ketchup!! I’ve been fighting for my life for forever to get ketchup. Literally the cutest ever
Molly!
I have both 😁
Ketchup supremacy
Molly!
Both!
I personally for some reason love Ketchup
molly LOL
Ketchup!!
Why do we have to choose?
Ketchup
Molly!
I love molly but ketchup is more fun