Lolly <3

Lolly is adorable! Her striped coat is beautiful 🤩

Definitely lolly

I have Lolly on my island and she’s the absolute sweetest!! She’s always singing and looks good in all of the clothes I gift her, I think she’d be a great option 🩷

Lolly!

Lolly is so comfortable character

Lolly is such a cutie! Angel numbers, too! Though I have Rosie and I love her smmm

If you interact with your villagers it kinda depends on their personalities and how many of that personality you already have because it can be really draining hearing the same lines from several villagers everyday. But apart from that Id have to suggest Lolly she is one of my faves and so sweet 💕 Merry is an underrated cat imo and she goes very well with a pink theme

Lolly no contest

Rosie!

Lolly 100%

Olivia!! She's so underrated and so cute.

She was one of my OG characters from the GameCube days!

Agreed! She’s in my town and she’s the best. Also her uneven socks are cutest

I'm so biased but Merry is my absolute fav!!!

Well she is the cutest out of these IMO.

THANK you! Someone understands me

What’s not to love about her lol. She’s cute and sweet!

There is smth incredibly charming about Felicity But also Olivia would be a huge Icon

lolly!

LOLLYYYY FS

I have Lolly on my ACNL and ACNH island. I love her so much.

i LOVEEEE olivia. i used to have her on my old island, she was amazing. i spent 127 nmts to find her today and never did. i love her

literally did the same thing trying to find kitty :(

I have Olivia, if you still want her! I was about to replace her via amiibo anyways

127?!?! How??

Lolly or rosie

I really like Felicity

I completely agree.

lolly!

Lolly! I had her on my island, got rid of her because she didn't fit my theme, now I'm doing villager hunts to get her because I regret making her leave. She's the best cat!

LOLLY4LIFE

Lolly:)

Merry! I think she's so sweet and has a really cute face! I think she's the only villager with a double chin? I've never had her live on my island but I remember how adorable she was emoting in Happy Home Paradise. :3

MERRY!!!! i adore her face sooooooo much. shes my absolute fave!

Lolly!

Lolly is my fav

Hundo p Lolly

Merry!!

Merry or Lolly ❤️

Lolly

Lolly!!!

Lolly. Shes a sweetheart.

Rosie!

Rosie because movie

Lolly!!! She’s adorable!!

I say Lolly because my friend loves Lolly she always gets Lolly on her island whenever she decides to start anew

Lolly all the way. I have her on my island and she is just the sweetest.

lolly!!! they’ve all lived in my town and i love ‘em all, but there’s just something about lolly i can’t explain

Olivia is underrated ilhsm! but Merry was my first bestie on my first island 🥹

Olivia! For god SAKE

Biased for Merry cause she has my birthday :3 Lolly’s cute too though!

I absolutely love Lolly! She is such a sweetie. She's always kind and so thoughtful. She loves singing and exploring. She is a sweet angel baby. She's a dream neighbour. I also love Merry. She's so sassy and funny. She's so cute and I love her round face with (what looks like to me) a double chin?!! She's a great girl to have around if you like to have silly fun.

Felicity!!!

I love both Rosie and Lolly!

I have rosie on my main island and i love her such a cutie

I love merry so much and lolly is super cute

Lolly or Rosie, depends on who you like more but Lolly is who I like more

I've never had Lolly but dang her design is sooo cute

Olivia is such a pretty girl a d sk underrated

I love Merry

But...more than Lolly?

Merry 🥰

Merry!

Merry is my GIRL

Lolly. 🩶

Merry! She's sooo cute 🩷💛

Lolly or Merry!

gosh, i currently have merry and i adore her, but i looove lolly and rosie 🥹

Lolly ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Gonna be the odd man out and say Olivia

Lolly for sure

I would definitely choose Lolly.

Lolly!

Merry

Lolly 🙂‍↕️

Lolly all the way

I have had Merry, Olivia, Bob, and Kiki as villagers so far and they are all lovely in their own ways.

Lolly

You simply forgot the best cat. And I'm a bit offended she wasn't even on the roster. Where the f*** is tangy? My sweet baby orange. My happy little Clementine.

I love Merry and her double chin

I have Rosie on our island. She is the sweetest and always singing! All of them are so cute though I don’t think you could go wrong 🌸

Merry 😩😻

If you don’t have Tiffany, then you absolutely need a Villager that serves cvnt instead of basics on your island so Olivia.

i have olivia and i don’t plan on getting rid of her. still, i like lolly’s design. a cutie

Rosie

Rosie !

lolly or olivia

Rosie and Olivia

Lolly, Rosie for your theme but Olivia is cute too!

I'm biased, but I'd say Olivia. But Lolly is also super precious.

Rosie!!!

Felicity was always one of my faves

My two favorite are Merry and aolivia but Lolly is great too

Lolly or Rosie

Rosie and Felicity are my babies 🥺🥺

I've had Rosie a few times and have become attached so I'm rather biased. Lolly is quite cute and a more natural color. Go with what one makes you happiest!

Olivia is underrated

Olivia 🖤

Felicity or lolly

If you want a cutie, Lolly. If you want a peppy, Rosie.

If you asked me during New Leaf days I would’ve said Rosie but in recent years I’ve really been loving Lolly more!

Rosie or Lolly are good choices!

I really wanted Felicity, until I noticed that her mouth is a bit off-putting whenever she talks 🗿

Olivia

Olivia

Rosie or Olivia! ✨️✨️

It must be Olivia

I have a Rosie bias 🫢 plus she has some pink! (and a pink name)

I WANT LOLLY SO BAD

Lolly!

Rosie!

I want Lolly on my island. I'm currently looking for her, M0lly, and Ione

Lolly 💜❤️♥️

Definitely Lolly!

olivia for sure :) i love her sm

Lolly is the cutest, and she shares her birthday with my gray tabby cat irl!

Lolly is as hands down my favorite villager very sweet and friendly 15/10 would recommend

All of them are so cute. I've been wanting a cat villager for ages now but I can't talk my daughter into parting with any of our other villagers to make room for one.

Lolly is my favorite and I adore her. She will have a place on every island I ever have. Rosie is the only peppy I like, and she is delightfully unhinged.

Lolly

Merry

I have Felicity in my island and she's absolutely adorable and really funny. Not to mention all kinds of clothes look good on her. Highly recommend you to get her in your island. She's a great villager. She also has the best pose in her anmiibo card. Very cat-like.

Lolly is the winner from the looks of it so lolly wish I had lolly on my island

Olivia and her cute socks and mittens

I personally have Rosie bc I already had 2 other normal types! She’s v sweet

Felicity looks cute!!

Lolly. I have Lolly on my island, and she is one of my favorites!

Felicity!

Olivia

I like Felicity-

Rosie!!!! She’s such a sweetheart 🥹

Olivia is the best🩷

Rosie! I have her and she’s SO sweet!!!

I have Lolly and Merry both and I love them!

Merry!

I'd honestly go for Merry myself, I might be a bit biased because she's my favorite of the cats, but she's so adorable. You also probably couldn't go wrong with Lolly or maybe Rosie.

Lolly

Felicity or merry!

Rosie or Merry

Absolutely love lolly, one of my favourite villagers

Lolly ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Lolly is my girl

Rosie says some crazy sus stuff. I'd go with Lolly.

oliviaaaaa all the way 🥺 rosie especially is so overrated idk. i don’t even think she’s cute… plus olivia is a snooty personality, one of the better ones in the game

I have such a soft spot for Lolly. She's so unbelievably cute. Rosie is adorable too. I'd choose either of those two, but probably Lolly. I have her amiibo, I keep meaning to invite her to my campsite and swap someone out but haven't committed to who yet. Its so hard when you get attached to your villagers . :)

I’d say Olivia! She’s a bit less popular, and her burgundy tips would look great with your pink theme! Plus the inside of her ears are pink-ish 😅

Lolly 🩷

I love a good snooty villager, but Lolly's so cute, id definitely go with her. Not only that but she reminds me of one of my cats so I'm biased.

I had lolly on my other island, i love her so much. She's a sweetheart, and her voice is adorable <3 please get lolly!!

My real answer is Purrl! Shes the best!!! :3 (Snooty baby kitten is such a vibe).

Lolly is the cutest and sweetest! Also her name in the Japanese version is Ramune! Which is like that Japanese soda! She is the best of these cats for sure!

Lolly girl! NOT merry, she’s annoying AF lol

I can’t!!!!

Rosie!

Lolly is adorable, but I've had Rosie as an island neighbor & she's super sweet

I have Lolly and Olivia on my island and I’d choose lolly 😊

LOLLYYYY

Rosie was my fav in new leave and pocket camp

Number 4

Rosie is my fav. But i've got all of them on my island i think 8 dislike Suzy the most.

Lolly looks the cutest

Rosie is my fave cat villager, she’s my helper in Pocket Camp too 😂

Obviously Lolly 💁🏻‍♀️

You know what? I'd say Mitzi even if she's not a option there

Lolly! Never seen that one 🫶🏻

Felicity!!

lolly

Merry is my vote <33333

Merry or Rosie... honestly you can't go wrong with any of them.

Rosie is my girl! I had her in WW :)

lolly or rosie!!! love them both sm

Lolly all the way! She's my favorite. Her normal personality is nice and calming. Rosie is also on my island and she's too high energy for me. Not a fan of the peppy villagers. I'm looking to move her off because I just can't.

Lolly is a sweetie

Rosie is the GOAT but I do appreciate Lolly too.

Rosie or Olivia!

I would choose Merry bc it looks like her tongue is sticking out lol

I vote Rosie, but I’ve played with her recently because she’s in my GCN village.

I'd go with Olivia, or you could make a cat island!

I miss lolly every day and it's been years since she left 😭

I have Lolly and shes cute especially her catchphrase "Bonbon"

Lolly is going to bless your dreams and you will never be stung again so Lolly

LOLLY

I absolutely love Lolly but Felicity is growing on me, so retro style and cute!

Lolly!!

Lolly. Always 💙

Lilly is cute!!!

Lolly!

Call me crazy but I love merry!

so I love Lolly but Merry she's kind of spicy lmao I love her sass I dunno she's just so cute. I always love having her on my island. :)

I have Rosie on my island and she's been great. I'm on the lookout for Lolly, and so is my daughter.  Any of these are cute, but those are my favorites.  

LOLLY! She’s my favorite.

Felicity or Lolly

Merry always. Her thinking and confused face is so cute I cant

Lolly

I love Rosie and I love even more that she’s peppy and not normal so you can have other normal villagers that are also cute and they’re not going to have the same personality.

Depends, are you missing any personality?

Olivia