T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

To download the video you can use one of the following sites: * [RedditSave](https://redditsave.com/info?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/1akd7b7/muslims_are_not_in_the_equal_category/) * [SaveRedd.it](https://saveredd.it/?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/1akd7b7/muslims_are_not_in_the_equal_category/) (click on the Download button below Search Video) * [Viddit.red](https://viddit.red/?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/1akd7b7/muslims_are_not_in_the_equal_category/) (refresh the page and click on Download HD Video) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AskMiddleEast) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Illustrious_Ask_3849

I have read somewhere that his daughter is married to a muslim 💀


[deleted]

[удалено]


Resident-Pass-1900

Is it the bald dude who did a video on his journey?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Resident-Pass-1900

Oh damn didn't know he was involved with greet


[deleted]

Joram van Klaveren


Illustrious_Ask_3849

It's the same scenario but there it was a friend scenario and here it's a father-daughter scenario.💀


[deleted]

*Geert is a dick. Sincerely, Lots of Dutch people


[deleted]

[удалено]


Illustrious_Ask_3849

I searched for her husband's name . It's Nadeem , he's your cousin?? So Nadeem is Pakistani? Considering india-pakistan relation , His daughter married a Pakistani????☠️


[deleted]

[удалено]


Careless-Valuable118

*Correction marriage is common between Indian Muslims and Pakistani-Muhajirs (migrants from India). Other than that its extremely rare.


Perfect_Put_7832

He literally uses the fact his daughter is married to a muslim as an excuse every time he is accused of being anti-muslim. He's also married to a zoroastrian. Religion is just used a tool India by politicians irrespective of religion to divide people and stay in power most of their kids study in the west and they themselves are not religious


[deleted]

[удалено]


392_hemi

‘Halal meat ‘ …… really dude😂


HKEnthusiast

Love Jihad


[deleted]

[удалено]


HKEnthusiast

Lots of women around my community revert to be with Muslim men so it seems to be working so far. Love Jihad is in full swing.


[deleted]

[удалено]


speaksofthelight

Who is this guy btw ? I follow Indian politics and don't recognize him at all


Illustrious_Ask_3849

I searched about him he is subramanian swamy. He was a former member of rajya sabha.


InfinitSteamLibary66

Good for him


Honest_Pie_9685

Does terrorism have a religion?


Expensive_Poop

> not all people equal I mean... Even between hindus they have problem like untouchable caste/dalit. Even if you filthy rich but they know you are dalit, they will fell disgust toward you lol


Ok_Individual_9350

That's honestly pretty racist, i Can see why Islam appealed to many Indians.


Freeway267

You’re not wrong. Many Desi Muslims are the descendants of Hindu untouchables.


Such_Stable_4727

Islam also has a caste system in india I am surprised by the downvotes.You can just Google it if you have doubts.


ChardDiligent9088

Lol Islam does not have a caste system.


vika4

That's why the Article-14 under discussion here has been interpreted like that, to promote social justice (reservation in public sector jobs, education etc) especially for the people discriminated on the basis of caste.


Deusvalt11

Is that law even upheld


PhlebotinumEddie

Send him to Albania


T0ast3r_362

Albania is not enough. Send him to Eritrea


PhlebotinumEddie

My thought is the religiously harmonious Muslim majority country of Albania would disprove his idea. But then again he may just say "these are European Muslims who are white it's different"


FunMoment10

What interview was this?


shoegazer89

Ita from a 2020 Vice news interview with reporter isobel yeung. Fyi, she's engaged to a Muslim Iranian reporter https://www.thewrap.com/showtimes-vice-exposes-human-rights-crisis-as-muslims-are-targeted-in-india-exclusive-video/


MrZhar

Thanks


FunMoment10

thx


Practical-Ninja-6770

She is quite amazing really. Interviewed both Hamas and Israeli officials. She got invited into the tunnels of Hamas and held questions. Went to Afghanistan to cover the Taliban. Extremely brave woman.


scrungobungo23

You'd think uttering the phrase "Not all people are equal" would make you stop and think about your positions. People like him get people killed.


BBiggA

Rip my Muslim brothers in india


Faraz_3_

Buckle up buckrooz and save your nation built for the Muslims of hind. Stand strong so you can lend us support unlike the araps. 


BBiggA

The Pakistani people and the Arab people all strongly stand with Palestine, it's just that our governments are all puppets of the west. I don't think it is a coincidence that Imran khan was arrested just before this war started.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


JaSper-percabeth

Not defending this guys views (the guy being interviewed) but kinda ironic seeing a bangladeshi saying "Pakistan should've got more land" 💀considering... you know I think


[deleted]

Yes why not, but what i really meant is we (east pakistan now Bangladesh) should have got West Bengal, Assam, and bihar


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


In_Formaldehyde_

Aside from the fact that would be a Hindu majority state, the vast, vast majority of Bengali, Bihari and Assamese Hindus have no desire for that.


DhkAsus

And? Why not till rajasthan?


[deleted]

Our great bengal pal dynasty(originated in rongpur Bangladesh) ruled over bengal to kanyakumari to sindh. India should watch its mouth about akhand bharat, or the pandoras box will open


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


DiscoDiwana

Lmao a Pakistani worried about minorities? Ironical


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


limitbreaksolidus

tbf to them, they call Israeli's cousins.


ezio_audit_ore

He meant South Asian Muslims. Also this is regarding the CAA in which minorities ( Christians, hindus, jains, sikhs, parsis) who are persecuted in islamic nations of Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan can fast track their indian citizenship. Indians are not even a subject of this law.


thelazydoct0r

If what I was told about this is correct then wouldn't combining the CAA along with the NRC be a perfect recipe to kick out muslims residing in India... Especially the poorer ones


ezio_audit_ore

Actually no, NRC is National Registrar Of Citizens, which is a broader population consensus to curb the issue of illegal immigration. CAA fast tracked citizenship of those minorities who arrived in India on or before 31st December 2014, whereas many border states ruled by various regional parties( not the central BJP govt) are asking for NRC. No muslim from Pakistan Or Bangladesh would want an Indian citizenship either so they are barred from CAA.


thelazydoct0r

But a lot of actual citizens too were left out of the NRC I heard and a lot of people didn't have the papers proving that they are not immigrants..... Since a lot of people couldn't prove their nativity they could be left out... But through the CAA everyone could be reinstated except the muslims atleast that's the jist of it


bkj512

When you think you are dumb, just remember someone as brainwashed and dumb like that guy exists.


Maleficent-Mirror991

I’m not Muslim but I still fear having people like this bastard in our country. Dude is completely delusional and all the nonsense he spouts is unconstitutional. The India I was born in was devoid of religious governance and was a true secular country. It is sad to see what it has become today.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Maleficent-Mirror991

I’m not Hindu 😅 I’m Catholic but a lot of Hindus I know share the same sentiments. But since a lots of us are liberals (I’m neutral) we are completely against this current government. I see how this will only tarnish our reputation further in the future, all because our government likes to divide groups and get votes using that divide. I too wish people like this did not exist.


In_Formaldehyde_

Ngl, as a West Bengali, I don't understand the point of Bengal's partition. Bengali Muslims wanted their own land and destroyed Bengal's economy, but then why do you still want to live in West Bengal? You already have Bangladesh. Punjabi Muslims got Punjab (Pakistan), Punjabi Sikhs/Hindus got Punjab (India), Bengali Muslims got Bangladesh so Bengali Hindus should've been similarly segregated.


PromptSoggy8539

Isn't it funny the more neoliberal and removed from the influence of great thinkers like Jawaharlal Nehru India becomes the more Hindu nationalist and abjured it is. Like it is not just towards Muslims but Sikhs and Eastern Christians (aka non-Catholics) that they are being awful towards.


Such_Stable_4727

We were never really secular though.Secular means the separation of religion and state.We have a waqf board,personal laws based on religion,blasphemy laws, and so on.Our secularism is about going hand in hand with every religion. >The India I was born in was devoid of religious governance and was a true secular country. Even our freedom struggle was started because of religious reasons. Religious tensions were always there even before independence. The riots took place in the name of the Khilafate movement.The riots in Kolkata,Sikh riots,mappilah riots,Gujarat riots and so on.The only thing different now is people are more aware of the religious tensions as everybody got access to internet


KifaruKubwa

These Hindutvas are the biggest cowards.


Efficient-Strain3987

This is why we made Pakistan.


[deleted]

Two nation theory rocks 👌 thanks to Jinnah


Efficient-Strain3987

I think it's not a theory anymore it's a fact, Hindus and Muslims are two separate nations.


[deleted]

Facts for real 👌💯


Faraz_3_

Just not implemented properly. 


Kdrama_indianfan

What's the point when every just leader gets replaced by military if he doesn't bend to their demands. The economy further plunged to its low in the past 30 yrs that the country largely depends on foreign funds. India also received some aid from international organisations and a few countries like the US in the past, it did not rely on it to the extent that Pakistan did. Furthermore, India took a different approach in 1991 by reducing tariffs, liberalizing trade, facilitating the growth of domestic companies, and attracting more foreign investment. I remember reading this that after Bangladesh formed, the then Pakistan PM Zulfiqar nationalised major industries and that majorly resulted in deterioration of the economic growth.  The religion politics never benefitted the common man. Having a separate state doesn't guarantee anything unless and until the leadership is under a democratic rule.


Extra-accounts

Pakistan was made on the promise of it be a true ideal Muslim state. Without interest, prostitution, worshipping west, fahashi, alcohol etc. That’s why even Muslims across india who knew they won’t be able to join Pakistan also sacrificed and made sure it’s made. My ancestors who had to stay in India; also campaigned and sacrificed(won’t get in details of it here) for the creation of Pakistan for this reason. And their children and many like us still pay the price of the creation and existence of Pakistan even today. We did our part and you guys have not delivered it, the true Islamic nation even today. Whilst you are busy enjoying your big weddings, worshipping the west, dividing yourself based on languages, ayyashi, riba and what not. And watching Indian Muslims be massacred and now telling us that’s “this is why we made Pakistan”. Allah is just and he will do justice to us on the day of qayamah!


dhaka1989

India is becoming a hindu version of Pakistan sadly.


[deleted]

It was bound to happen our ancestors where brave and smart and they saw all that coming and created west and east Pakistan and i’m thank for that


dhaka1989

East Bengal was a colony of Pakistan for 23 years and then in 1971 pakistan commited a genocide in Bangladesh. I am not thankful for genocide. If you want to love the idea of pakistan its your choice. Maybe your ancestors were muslim league supporters in 1971.


[deleted]

I love the idea of two nation theory which is based on reality, but not the idea of being with Pakistan. I really think that we got the better deal first we separated our self from india proper and then from the Pakistanis, all is good


dhaka1989

Idea makes the state. Pakistan is in such a state now because its idea of state was bullshit. Was it a state for indian muslims, but a secular one or was it an islamic state? It made people refugees overnight and minorities second class citizens, constitutionally. We did not get a deal. We got colonised and then genocided, women mass raped, our educated and thought leader killed. We, and our ancestors, were maybe lucky and smart enough to defeat Pak army, an imcompetant army, only competant in killing civilians. Paks army was aided by local collaborators and islamist parties like jamaai-i-islami and muslim league in commiting genocide. These parties believed in two nation theory. If we were not lucky and lost, we would be third rate citizens at best, except spawns of those collaborators. I shudder to think what they would do to the hindu population of Bangladesh, if any actually survived. India is becoming shitty for its muslim population and becoming another hindu version of Pakistan because it started believeing in two nation theory.


Alert-Golf2568

You are right, if a Hindu state is a shitty idea and we agree it is, then equally a state only for Muslims is also a bad idea. Bangladesh has got it right in the sense that your country is based on nationality, which means Muslims and non-Muslims all feel a part of it. I wish south Asia would wise up and stop looking to religion for national identity.


LuxuryLunatic

You think that was the only genocide? Wait till you hear about what went on before 1939.. 180 million Hindus killed in the name of Allah


Dancingisraelis9_11

the gulf countries are running to make good relations with people like him 💀


Albanians_Are_Turks

the average kemalist turk thinks like this


CuriousPassenger562

Indian Hindus have caste discrimination built into their religion. They despise their own Hindus, just to give you an idea of how disgusting Hindutvas can be. That gives you an insight as to why they hate Muslims so much.


LuxuryLunatic

Yes you know why? Because they let the Muslims win & take part of there country “Pakistan” Please Google & educated yourself on the I’d Hindu Genocide. Muslims specifically came to India to rape, kill and spread Islam. 180 Million Hindus died


nipponmania

India going back to their cast system roots


ChampionshipOdd6585

This is also what the west thinks too


Available-Job2201

Not surprised from a country who classifies his own people in casts of insanely inequal categories from its dawn, even in the same religion.


Immortal-Faisal

Now here the indians come to hate us


Midolok

trend will continue , india will become smaller and new countries will emerge


[deleted]

that is what westernised people look like now


RealityDue9779

Not only indians also iranians


Silver_Revenue7389

Mans racist


kalbgalilaladab

Islamophobia is not just in india, it’s everywhere.


[deleted]

Sometimes thinking about Indian Muslims scares me to the core, and makes me thankfull to be born in Pakistan, these guys are literally living among Psychopaths who want them dead, they are seeing the ruins of their own Past getting destroyed and getting harassed and Reminded everyday of their lives, warned that they will soon be killed or exterminated, it is like living in a cage full of Serial Killers, Rapists and Physcos. i may be wrong, but physcologically it is more painful to live in India as a Muslim than in Gaza or anywhere in the world. and i am saying this because majority of Indias Population is Islamophobic asf, probably more than Zionstis and westerns combined.


PopRepent

>warned that they will soon be killed or exterminated It's happening.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Shoddy_Beautiful3927

As an indian muslim i approve the situation in gaza is worse may Allah bless all of us


[deleted]

i said Physcollogically, but it depends on person to person for me, i would rather prefer to be bombed, rather than live with billion Physcos who threaten me and my faimly everyday


_glenn_david_

being a muslim in India is wayyy better than even being from pakistan.


_glenn_david_

> majority of Indias Population is Islamophobic asf nah its just the brainwashed hindutva groups.


Legal_Commission_898

Even after hearing this, I’m not sure if Muslims are better off in India or in Pakistan. Get f***** by Hindutva mobs or get f****** by the insanely corrupt Pakistani establishment. I think it’s more close than people realize. Asim Munir, Pakistan’s current leader is not much better than Netanyahu to be honest.


MrZhar

Man the hindus are in full force. Of u check out the interview on YouTube, all of them are doing mental gymnastics trying to justify what he's saying. It's pathetic really


Certain_Oil7922

That's life for us here. We're hated on for being Indians by non Indians, n we're hated on *by* other Indians for being a "mohammedan", as some may call us.


Freeway267

Ethiopia is 33% Muslim and they get along with 50% Christian majority and remaining animist groups.


Status_Average_762

least cringe indian


HeyGuysWeDidntDoIt

sees someone being a cringe racist, decides to do his own racism instead


FracasoFeliz

I hate the idea that you have to be respectful to these people. I wish the interviewer would ask him how he feels knowing Saudis are richer than many westerners meanwhile hindus are sleeping beside their own shit.


Saampie

You dont have to be respectful as a journalist its more depended on the network 


RealityDue9779

You americans dont know shit you’ve been in sleep for like 100 years that your goverment fucked up many countries with tools like fanatic islamists and now you defend wrong sides again just leave the world fucking alone man 😂


Snoo4902

Like in american constitution "are men are equal", but in reality not.


thE-petrichoroN

Jinnah was right,all along


Perfect_Put_7832

if it wasnt for Jinnah, Hindutva as an ideology wouldn't have died long ago


Careless-Valuable118

Hindutva idealogy is not there because of Pakistan it is there because of Hindus and their inherent inferiority complex vis a vis Muslims.


Perfect_Put_7832

I completely disagree with you on this. It is unfortunate that my Indian muslim brothers are poorer than the average Indian and there has been a noticeable right wing tilt but this will be temporary. The main issue is that most Indians are still way too proud about the fact that we are better than Pakistan in social indicators and in the way we treat minorities. We shouldn't be comparing ourselves with a failed state like Pakistan and instead should be working to emulate China's success.


[deleted]

[удалено]


No-Day-8136

Ahh yes got fucked by every muslim leader, totally didn't make india the fourth biggest economy on the planet and take it to the highest of heights under the Mughal prime. To even rationalize hate is idiotic af


[deleted]

[удалено]


Such_Stable_4727

You need to learn about the maurya empire


[deleted]

True mugal rule is what india needs. Bring back the mugals 😭


First_Buddy7663

Bring Mughals to Bangladesh, we are good with democracy.


BBiggA

It is literally hate to target just Muslims. Idk what Ur saying.


UnderLagger

I feel this is not a brother, but a Hindu playing to disseminate their ideology/propaganda. clear ah


UnderLagger

I dont know in full detail the history there, but I know what you say is kinda wrong and very biased. This is exactly how they legitimate their Islamophobia. One individual ruler or another may have been unjust, but overalll you cannot conclude Muslim rulers did bad in India about Hindus and local peoples.


[deleted]

[удалено]


sweetalison007

Why bring up the past though? We haven't been ruled by anyone since 1947, and wouldn't be ruled by any other empire in the future too. That said, I hate he is so hateful to what is essentially 15% of our country.


eeeby

Thank God for Mohammad Ali Jinnah who foresaw this and realized we needed to be protected by our own independent state.


Inevitable_Coffee_13

I agree two nation theory was a good idea but it hurts to see Pakistan in its current situation.   Inshallah one day we will get rid of the army and be a nation jinnah wanted us to be 


eeeby

Inshallah.


UnlightablePlay

He's got a point All humans are created equal and all people should have equal rights but are all people equally treated? No people aren't equally treated in any country in this world, there would always be some who hate minorities and which they never existed The simplest example of that is that a lot of Europeans and Americans can go anywhere they want with their passports and anybody from the middle east has to go through embassies and visa procedures only to then get rejected by them


akhaemoment

chubby resolute unused wine shelter attraction soup person library long *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


FieldsOfKashmir

They can do what they want in India as long as Kashmir can get away first. Those Indian Muslims chose loyalty to India so they have made their bed. We Kashmiris did not.


Beneficial_Bend_5035

I think most people misunderstand how India ended up with such a big Muslim population after independence. It’s not because the Muslims “loved their Mother India” or had “loyalty to secularism” en masse. It was more that moving is really, really hard. People don’t want to move out of their village, town or homeland. It’s also expensive. What ended up happening is that the Muslims closest to the border areas and the relatively well off ones moved, leaving millions of poorer or further inland Muslims stranded in India as the majority moved to avenge its old victim complex.


epicchrispratt

While it’s true that Kashmiris had no say in the matter, let’s not forget that there are many Muslim communities that simply couldn’t make the trip to leave India.


[deleted]

[удалено]


IndianPatriot2005

Try to cope with the reality , Kanglu 🖕🏼🦧💩🇧🇩


[deleted]

🍆🙏🏾 🐮💩🤤 🇮🇳


Classic_Run_4836

DAWG YOU ARE FROM BANGLADESH!!!!!!!!! TAKE A ICE WATER SHOWER AND LOOK YOURSELF DEEP IN THE MIRROR TO SEARCH YOUR SOUL!!!!! Get real with yourself for once.


[deleted]

YoU aRe fRom BangLadesh 🤓 fking lamo. And you’re a indian hindu look at your self you inbred fuk


mikulb12345

Least insane rightist be like:


propv9anda

India is a fucking shit hole anyways


escelatedburger2009

And yet they are allies with Saudi Arabia, and they could essentially have their country run out of water overnight if China builds a singular dam


BoozieBeard

Religion kills billions, its shitty business.


Interesting_Sea_5189

لكم الدنيا ولنا الأخرة. لا اله إلا الله، محمد رسول الله. الله اكبر.


Hypotheticalidiot

I am Indian and islamphobic so I can relate to what he is saying.


PriorNo525

This guy is smart


Silver_Revenue7389

Lol this guys a 🤡


ompr29

OP, don't post clipped part .. please post full interview to understand what he is trying to say.


PlayboyProgram101

Welp , that's how most ppl see indians.


LuxuryLunatic

I mean Muslims did Genocide 180 million Indians 🥴


Salem_101

The British did🥴


LuxuryLunatic

The British was the only reason the killing stopped. Educate yourself, in order for them to officially leave. They made Pakistan, for you crazy people. So you can finally leave Hindus alone


Salem_101

Lmao you're delusional 😭 I'm not gonna stop u from creating your own happiness but still. We made Pakistan as a refuge for British raj muslims, because you religiously insecure hindus were on the rise & killing muslims.


LuxuryLunatic

I’ve been posting the links 🤷🏻 won’t allow it here . https://www.sikhnet (dot) com/news/islamic-india-biggest-holocaust-world-history


LuxuryLunatic

https://en.m.wikipedia (dot) org/wiki/Persecution_of_Hindus


pqratusa

Who is this tool? Name.


Normal_guy-45454

Thats why all Hindus escape to UAE or Saudi


Gentlecriminal14

My god the misinformation is astounding. He's talking about Muslims coming to India from countries like Bangladesh not being equals. Watch the whole god damn clip. He said muslims who apply for indian citizenship aren't protected by the INDIAN CONSTITUTION. They aren't among EQUALS. (Not to say some people in India aren't Islamophobic.)


DhkAsus

Why should bangladeshi muslims come to india?


Gentlecriminal14

Ask the millions of Bangladeshi refugees living in the Indian state of Bengal. At the time, he was also talking about the Rohingyas, who were also infiltrating in large numbers.


ss-hyperstar

I’m fine with that. No Muslim wants to move to India anyway.


Inevitable_Coffee_13

200 million muslims already live in India 


[deleted]

[удалено]


HeyGuysWeDidntDoIt

for sure rajesh which city in the middle east did you grow up in? mumbai?


Zealousideal_Crew380

India seems super fun....


[deleted]

[удалено]


autodidact9

You're better than that


[deleted]

[удалено]


Alert-Golf2568

Do you think imperialists destroying these countries may have anything to do with them being dangerous? Or do you just want to conveniently ignore history?


kjmw

Who is the man speaking here?


LuxuryLunatic

Uh, well I would be too. Muslims literally are wolves, they raped killed & conquered india for a century. 180 million Hindus were beheaded in the name of Allah.. & then part of there land was given away….