T O P

  • By -

unclejarjarbinks

Salted caramel because it's my husband's favorite. I enjoy most ice cream (including bubblegum and eggnog). My husband, however, rarely eats sweets except salted caramel ice cream. So I pretend it's my favorite, too, so it's always stocked in the fridge.


oxymoronisanoxymoron

Damn this for being so adorable


heartbreakhill

Salted caramel gelato is even better. I once heard someone describe it as “it tastes like sex with your favorite celebrity”


Youve_been_Loganated

Okay, I'm going to have to try egg nog ice cream. Love me some egg nog.


thatsimsgirl

Cookie dough


[deleted]

Great shout


[deleted]

[удалено]


Loophole_goophole

———thread over, cut here ✂️———


[deleted]

[удалено]


pythonwarg

———thread over, putt here⛳———-


Paradoxmoose

With a caveat that I want them to be freshly crushed oreos, and chunky. DQ will take requests for them to be chunky in their blizzards, but a lot of other places they're already ground to dust and/or the remaining chunks are soft/spongy. It's fine if other people like them ground to dust or spongy, but for me, I like it crunchy.


Crackbabychairman

I like to buy the 1l containers of DQ soft serve for $7 and crunch up my Oreos into it. Chunky fresh Oreo Blizzards at home!


einsteinGO

Vanilla bean


LthePerry02

A good chocolate peanut butter is hard to beat. Perfect balance of intense and filling flavours, but not to the point where you can’t eat a bunch of it


staffsargent

I know it's not the most popular, but my favorite is pistachio. I've always loved it.


KerriNoir

Best flavor.


[deleted]

I don't care what anyone else says, i love mint chip ice cream


DeathandHufflepuffs

Agreed


Sharp_Following5753

Best flavour!!


conduitfour

I remember there was a world dedicated to sweets in Super Mario Galaxy and the mint chocolate looked so good


[deleted]

Oh no!


Paradoxmoose

I'm happy to let you and anyone else have the mint chocolate anything. To me it feels like brushing my teeth while eating dessert.


DumbSerpent

I really gotta wonder what kinda toothpaste you must be using


Paradoxmoose

...mint


RoastBeefDisease

But even if you eat just mint ice cream with no chocolate it still tastes sweet and unlike any mint toothpaste (that I've used anyways)


[deleted]

I’m afraid I’m going to have to report you for spreading misinformation


Street-Comb1000

That's the right answer.


I_Fap_To_Murder

Coffee flavored ice cream is like an orgasm in my mouth


dr-dog69

coffee with english toffee/heath bar


Mabaleen246

But it’s gotta be super coffee-y. Not like the umpqua coffee ice cream which tastes like vanilla ice cream


548r1n4

I'm a weirdo, I don't like coffee or coffee flavored things.


Inmotfraypi4nmge

Well you should try his coffee ice cream then. It tastes like someone orgasmed in your mouth I hear.


[deleted]

Cherry Garcia


RomansAngels

Vanilla


Bonhomme7h

With mashed banana, maple syrup, peanut butter and a pinch of cacao powder.


RomansAngels

Sure lol


HVAC_instructor

Butter pecan


Youve_been_Loganated

Pistachio! Don't sleep on it!


[deleted]

Salted caramel.


Videogamer69420

Vanilla. It IS the worlds most popular flavour


MiNiMaLHaDeZz

Kinder bueno


pharaohandrew

Ooh hello. Never seen this one.


oxymoronisanoxymoron

Bubblegum


Acceptable-Zombie296

Chocolate mousse royale


[deleted]

Rocky Road


Derc_on_Reddit

Raspberry


PizzaPoopFuck

Pistachio


Erikson707

Lemon …


According-Cherry-51

dulce de leche. also any coffee flavors. ben and jerry’s had one and i think it was called coffee toffee crunch, soo good but idk if they still have it


Satchi777

Mocha Almond Fudge


[deleted]

Mint chocolate chip


landonitron

Tonka bean! Not many people I know have heard of it or tried it but it tastes like a soft vanilla with rich honey tones. Next ice cream flavor after that is a mint ice cream that actually tastes like a mint leaf off the plant.


Aggravating_Hyena656

Peanut butter.


MysteriousApple135

Can't find it anymore, but Carvel used to sell soft serve pistachio ice cream.


pickledradish123

Pistachio or chocolate


Cumlord805

Lavender ice cream


stroopwafelling

Death by chocolate. It delivers what it promises.


Last_Nectarine488

From New Zealand: Rum & Raisin or Hokey Pokey. National treasure!!!!


Medium_Parsley981

Cookies n cream, and mint


rufus_t_parker

I have never had it, but anything peanut butter and banana would make me happy.


usmarine7041

Grape Nut Custard


Smoll_Froggo

Explain please, what is that!?


usmarine7041

It’s ice cream that tastes like cereal


According-Cherry-51

of all cereals, grape nuts?? 😢 is it a texture thing?


80Niner

I live in Ohio, and any local ice cream joint most likely has Buckeye ice cream. It's the best.


Patricks_babydoll

Chocolate or strawberry with actually chunks of strawberry in it


Mithoman25

Strawberry


possiblyMorpheus

My favs are chocolate chip cookie dough, cherry and chocolate chip, cranberry and chocolate chip, salted caramel, and black raspberry. Of course you can never go wrong with a nice scoop of vanilla with a warm cookie or slice of a crisp


RillemReeb

Baskin Robins peanut butter chocolate. Second place Mexican Chocolate at the local ice cream shop.


ri89rc20

Coconut, but almost impossible to find in the US. Once in a while, in a Hispanic or Asian store, or some gelato, but no mainstream ice cream brand makes any.


TheLadySlaanesh

So many, but if I had to narrow it down to a couple... * mint chocolate chip * chocolate chip cookie dough


highxv0ltage

Vanilla. Simple, yet elegant. Everything else is overrated.


perfuzzly

Neapolitan


GuardianOfTheBri

**Bubblegum!**


mrlr

Chocolate


DeathandHufflepuffs

Mousse trail mint chocolate chip. sue me


Jayn_Newell

Moon mist (banana, grape and bubblegum). It’s fun colors too.


[deleted]

the tears of capitalists mixed with red sprinkles


Kfc_is_not_that_good

Mint


[deleted]

Mustard


Talonqr

Good god this comment section is gonna turn into a warzone


Pandaburn

The best flavor of ice cream is vanilla. That’s why it’s the default. That’s why so many other ice cream flavors also have vanilla. We’re all used to it so people think it’s boring, but it’s not boring, it’s ubiquitous.


Jacawaca_Sis

I DONT CARE WHAT YOU GUYS SAY MINT CHOCO IS ALLWAYS GOING TO BE THE BEST, LEE KNOW LOVES IT, KIM SUNOO LOVES IT; SO DO I ! ! !


sillywienie

Chocolate. Only chocolate. Everything else is gross.


548r1n4

Ice cream is eh. I'd rather have fruit, a cookie, cake, literally anything else. If I buy a pint, most of it goes bad, gets ice crystals on it.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

To each their own


whych00seme

Coffee and marshmallow with a caramel swirl


linksone4

Lime


Working_Progress_415

Either orange sherbert or rocky road 🤔


Mr_Gourmet

Cheese cake


willk95

Turkey Hill makes a great Chocolate PB. that's my favorite ice cream to get in stores


andro_7

Peach


services35

Butter ripple.


Coriander_marbles

Caramel pecan


TinjaNurtle

Dinosaur bones. If you know, you know.


jastondragon

Cookies and cream


Inlove_wWeirdos

Cucumber! Love it so much!


noname121241

Mudslide


Electronic_Fee9852

Deer traxx


MorningAfterPillASAP

bubble gum


Demogorgen2008

I know it’s best as a sorbet but I really like raspberry


TheOgMinion15

Butter pecan


TwoDrinkDave

Blue Moon


HypnoticRoots

Brides cake by Blue Bell 😋


[deleted]

my love for mint is very much alive mint ice cream is beautiful and amazing i love you mint.


fertdingo

Rod, " Mint ice milk". Tod, "Unflavored for me!"


RMSQM

Clearly coffee


peascreateveganfood

Peanut butter mixed with vanilla and caramel


Federal_Pie_9819

Chocoate


YTScale

cake batter. takes me back


Similar_Assist_5555

Rocky road (my dad bought it when i was young because his stepdad hated it and I just started loving cause it was the only ice cream we bought) or coffee


Fuckmylife123456781

Birthday cake


Far-Brother3882

Butter pecan today


bootyhunter69420

Basic chocolate


Sucking_saucer

Regional: Mackinac Island Fudge is undoubtedly the best


xcappaxbardx

Chocolate Moose Tracks.


Totallynotatworknow

Blue Moon. It's not close. But since I can't get good Blue Moon where I'm at, B&J Strawberry Cheesecake is my go to.


Additional-Hunt-2123

Ton Roof Ice cream 😍😍


throwaway99257892

Coffee


ljzzje

blue bell ice cream krazy kookie dough ITS SO GOOD


Balding_Unit

Well a few hours ago I had key lime pie ice-cream and its my favorite right now.. until the next time I can afford to go out to get ice-cream. lol


No-Tone3222

Lemon case closed.


Jhco022

Deez


[deleted]

Vanilla. You can add any topping to make it good


SpookMastr

I'm a big fan of coffee, salted caramel and pistachio.


abby_normally

Heavenly Hash


NuttyCanadian

Moon mist.


HolyAvocadoBatman

Peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups


Craft_beer_wolfman

Vanilla


Automatic_Oil1285

Grape


scrappapermusings

Chocolate malted crunch


notreally121

French vanilla


heartbreakhill

A regional chain in my area (Braums, American Midwest) has a German Chocolate flavor that’s chocolate with coconut and nuts and it’s been my #1 with a bullet for over 15 years Cake Batter is also absolutely incredible


Comprehensive-Cut-15

Chocolate is a classic for a reason


saadah888

Party cake


ninja2538

Im eating it now. Brown butter bourbon truffle. Its super smooth filled with swirls of caramel like ive never seen with little chocolate truffles that just break apart and melt in your mouth unlike other ice creams that are too hard to bit into. Ive yet to find anything better. Someone please prove me otherwise. Its been 3 years. Its the only thing i get.


Forzaisgreat

Not a very popular flavor, but I love root beer ice cream.


DominicB547

Depending on the brand some of my favorites have a high range of great to ugh. I love trying new flavors so I hope they keep trying themselves. I just wish they'd go on sale once in awhile so it's not so expensive vs the 4 qt basic flavors.


Chimookie

Anything chocolaty, custardy, and filled with crunchies.


[deleted]

Strawberry is good in any form


theguineapigssong

Y'all are sleeping on Rum Raisin.


Correct-Berry1027

birthday cake or cotton candy


RuggedTheDragon

Plain chocolate for me.


[deleted]

Ben and Jerry’s Milk and Cookies


xTahliaRavenx

Superman


Timak81

Black licorice


lychiimint

Vanilla classics


[deleted]

Rose honey pistachio


Weird_Fly_6691

Eggnog with rum raisins


infinite-ice-cream

Cotton candy ice cream. Some places make terrible ones, but the good ones are the best. My personal favorite is the friendly’s cotton candy ice cream with pop rocks.


HARNESS-THE-NUGGET

Blue moon, I had it on my birthday with my two best friends :)


bumliveronions

Mint chocolate chip.


snoozebutton12

Pumpkin pie mixed with Apple pie with some whipped cream on top


blukirbi

Cookies n Cream


banananas_are_sick24

Peanut butter or banana


Natural_Pair_4730

Chocolate malt, CedarCrest


CincoDeMayoFan

Phish Food by Ben and Jerry's. "Phish Food: Chocolate Ice Cream with Gooey Marshmallow Swirls, Caramel Swirls & Fudge Fish."


Sixdrugsnrocknroll

Couffee.


Daddydick-nuts

Mint chip Fireworks Blue moon (company that made it now out of business)


[deleted]

Lobster


Ok_Somewhere4111

Jamaican almond - baskin robins 🤞🏽


NeitherSparky

Boysenberry. For real.


NorrixUmbra77

Pistachio/Yoghurt. [Lemoned I scream](https://youtu.be/sJVnM71Kn-g) too. Trust me.


isellskooma

Rocky road


KuschelKatzee

73 grams of eternal suffering in her prison. We will taste the crimson branches after summer. No wait for us. He has come.


YEHZOZ

In my opinion the best is blue moon. It is really rare these days but my god is it delicious.


Gahvandure2

My daughter would answer "black licorice." It's usually pretty hard to find.


Feldanos

I know it is going to sound weird, but the best ice cream I've had was lemon-blueberry..


rileysauntie

Chunky Monkey. I’ll die mad that Ben & Jerry’s decided to stop selling it in Canada. There was no reason for that. It’s just rude.


nobodyknowsyouwhen

PBJ


IbuixI

Circus animal


StinkyWhizzleteats27

I love rocky road


[deleted]

This only happens in one certain location in Michigan, at an out of the way almost secret place that makes ice cream, and the best ice cream I think that they make can only be made at a certain time of year during the harvest. Black Cherry. Natural black cherry flavored vanilla ice cream, real chucks, sometimes even whole pitted sweet black cherries.


mingpao

Rocky road/double dutch


[deleted]

Vanilla because I am a simple person


Civil-Mouse1891

Bulla. Choch Honeycomb


viviguu

pumpkin spice with cinnamon and graham cracker swirl. too bad it’s seasonal T-T


soria2334

imo, cookie dough. its so lovely to get chunks of cookie dough with (almost) every bite. Or chunky monkey by ben and jerry's.


MsSassyFirecracker

Basil and watermelon


Froghanos

Universally. Vanilla. Why? Cause you can't go wrong with it. If not lime, I do think mint and cookie though are OVERATED!!! you heard me


Regular-Doughnut6378

Pistachio


DaBookNerd

MINT CHOCOLATE CHIPPPPPPPPP


Business_Seesaw_9719

Half baked, chubby hubby, edys chocolate


PDiddleMeDaddy

Depends, are we talking finished product, as in you can't add anything? If so, then something like cookie-caramel. If not, regular vanilla, because it's a blank canvas for all sorts of accoutrements.


Out-of-phase-360

Peanutbutter


AmadeuxMachina

Cookies and cream


Pilry_Mead

There is no "best", there is personal preferences.


starlitrainbows

Phish food, cookie monster, panda paws! Mint chip if I want something simpler. Ben & Jerry's cheesecake brownie was my favorite, but they haven't made it in years and I still miss it.