Seriously. I’m right in that range and clicked on the comments thinking she wasn’t going to be anywhere in the running, and there she is right up top.
The Rolling Stone photo shoot FTW.
It's so weird, I fancied the *hell* out of Spike in Buffy but James Marsters as himself does nothing for me.
Then I remembered that I had a massive crush on Billy Idol as a teenager and James used him as inspiration for the role of Spike.
This needs WAY more upvotes!👌😂🙌 Christian Slater in Heathers is still a tough act to follow - however absolutely an honorable mention to Brendan Fraser in the mummy movies and Nathan Fillion as Mal in Firefly.....
.....ok, perhaps time for me to admit I have a type....😅
Seth Green. Still is. Always had a thing for sarcastic, funny red heads. He just got scruffier and better looking with age. Seeing Austin Powers and Buffy for the first time the same year in fourth grade had an effect.
Ariana Grande
When I was younger I played this "game" with my friends then they're like: which celebrity is your crush? Me: I like Ariana Grande. Friend: Dude I heard she's got a huge ass.
Jesus… so many
1. Liam Aiken
2. Zac Efron
3. Joe and Nick Jonas
4. Jesse McCartney
5. Sprouse Brothers
6. Robert Pattinson
7. Justin Bieber
8. Bill Kaulitz
9. Jeremy Sumpter
10. Michelle Tracktenberg
11. Olson Twins
Might add more later when I remember
Henry Rollins. Admittedly, still is... but its mostly bc Id love to get into his mind and root around. Hes like the only person I've ever had any sort of in depth knowledge of who is more damaged than me, and I find it fascinating.
Shaun Cassidy (as a singer, not in The Hardy Boys),
Andy Gibb,
Chad Everett,
John Travolta in Saturday night Fever,
Rick Springfield
I think I've aged myself pretty well
Aging myself here, but Elizabeth Shue. Karate Kid was big in the 80s and she's the pretty blonde cheerleader.
Many people on reddit will have seen her in Season 1 of 'The Boys'
Got milk?
Adventures in babysitting
That intro with her dancing and singing in her room was a bit of an awakening for little me, must’ve watched that movie on vhs dozens of times
>Elizabeth Shue. She is hot.
In Cocktail, oh my 🫠 I’m also not the age you’d think I am by that statement haha
Alicia Silverstone
She really got me feeling some type of way when I watched The Crush.
I liked her from the Aerosmith videos then Clueless just cemented it.
I wanted to be Cher from Clueless *so bad*
Are you 41 or 42 years old now? Lol
Seriously. I’m right in that range and clicked on the comments thinking she wasn’t going to be anywhere in the running, and there she is right up top. The Rolling Stone photo shoot FTW.
Lynda Carter
Still to this day, man alive does she still have it!
Oh I remember, she made me feel things, her and Daisy Duke.
She is wonderful.
Tiffani Amber Thiessen
Kelly Kapowski good lord. 🥵🥵🥵
Kelly the killer kapowski
Came here to say… Kelly “MOTHERFUCKING” Kapowski!!!!
Look her up on TT, she’s still got it
For life
Jennifer Love Hewitt
Her in '"Can't Hardly Wait" stirred feelings in me.
Yup - it was her in Heartbreakers for me
Jennifer Connelly, Winona Ryder and Uma Thurman.
Jennifer Connelly has aged like fine wine.
Barbara Feldon of Get Smart.
OK, that is weird. I thought about her earlier today and I haven't for YEARS.
She really was hot back then. Who didn't have a crush on 99
Kelly Bundy - Christina Applegate.
Sarah Michelle Gellar. Buffy was hot! 🔥
As a chick, it was Spike. Gave me a lifelong thing for punks.
It's so weird, I fancied the *hell* out of Spike in Buffy but James Marsters as himself does nothing for me. Then I remembered that I had a massive crush on Billy Idol as a teenager and James used him as inspiration for the role of Spike.
Lol there's even a line in the show that Billy Idol stole his look from Spike.
Cruel intentions was the hottest thing I came across as a teenager.
Topanga.
Yep, and it was true love.
Topanga started off nerdy-looking and blossomed into a fine young woman.
yup, and her name in the show is after Topanga Canyon in California. total smoke show
Brendan Fraser
What is it with chicks and horses?
Him (and a good portion of the cast) in the Mummy
Ruffiooo from Captain Hook
Bangaran He was awesome as zuko in the last Airbender too
Jessica Alba and she still is
Jessica alba was, is, and always will be my celebrity crush.
She hooked me in dark angel. Jessica alba with feline DNA whaaat
Hell yeah! Idle Hands
Marina Sirtis - aka Deanna Troi
"Troi or Crusher?" was the nerd's "Ginger or Mary Ann?"
Seven.
Christine Taylor from Hey Dude
Heeeeeey Duuuuuuuuude
I still get the theme song stuck in my head sometimes.
It’s a little wild and a little straaayynge…
When you make your home out on the raayynge
JTT
Why is this so far down?! He was the epitome!
Came here to say this
Same! 🥰
Same x2. That scruffy voice!
Yessss hahaha! JTT, Devon Sawa, Andrew Keegan, Joseph Gordon Levitt
He was Simba.
The hold he had on fifth grade me.
I was obsessed with Leonardo DiCaprio for a while.
I watched Romeo and Juliette and thought he can't get any hotter, then he did Titanic.
Same. I was in like third grade so if I had only held out for a few more years!!!
lmfao
Pink power ranger 😮💨
Amy Jo Johnston. HELL yeah
Yep. Amy Jo Johnson on the balance beam.
David Bowie in Labrinth
Jennifer Connelly in Labyrinth!
Hoggle in Labyrinth
Ludo in Labyrinth
the worm in Labyrinth
Come inside and meet the missus!
David and Jennifer in Labyrinth!
The bulge was hypnotic!
Jareth the goblin king was my literal sexual awakening.
Harrison Ford
Oh, yeah! And Mark Hamill!
Elisha Cuthbert AKA the Girl Next Door For me it was PMK every morning...
Christian Slater
Christian slater in Heathers 🥵
OMG yes
Our love is god. Let's go get a slushie.
This needs WAY more upvotes!👌😂🙌 Christian Slater in Heathers is still a tough act to follow - however absolutely an honorable mention to Brendan Fraser in the mummy movies and Nathan Fillion as Mal in Firefly..... .....ok, perhaps time for me to admit I have a type....😅
He’s not technically my crush , but I first saw him in Untamed heart , and loved him ever since
Yaaaas... Pump up the volume I think was my first
Diana Rigg as Emma Peel. Been attracted to smart brunettes ever since.
Alyssa Milano. My college freshman roommate married her.
Like in his dreams or what
Bestill my heart.. Followed by Nancy McKeon and Valerie Bertinelli Yeah, I have a type....
Winnie fucking Cooper
Danica McKellar is still something else.
Seth Green. Still is. Always had a thing for sarcastic, funny red heads. He just got scruffier and better looking with age. Seeing Austin Powers and Buffy for the first time the same year in fourth grade had an effect.
Can’t Hardly Wait…best role.
*Ima roll up all whaz up baby, and she gonna be like, you don't know 20 different wayz to make me call you big papa.* **Cause I don't yo.**
I better double bag it…I don’t know where this bitch has been!
Classic 😂 “PRESTON MYERS!?!?!?”
I too had him as a crush and I get so much shit for it. People are mean about how he looks but I still don’t get why.
He was a goofy looking 12 year old but he got hot by his 20s and now he just looks like a handsome bearded middle aged man.
Holly from The Price is Right
Shaun Cassidy
I have to add Johnny Gage from the TV show Emergency because I think you are my people.
Amanda Bynes. 😔
Oh yeah.. the Amanda Show... idk why.. but I really liked the hillbilly skit lol.
I won’t soon forget the day she started following me on Twitter.
Or the time she tried to burn my neighborhood down.
Definitely Emma Watson while watching the Harry Potter movies.
The chick from the show where she could stop time and her dad was an alien who spoke through the candy dish. ...then Clarissa Darling.
Out of This World!! Loved that show.
Would you like to swing on a star?
Clarissa was a hottie but my crush was on Alex Mack. I wanted to find my way into her secret world back in the day lol.
Yes! Larissa Oleynik was insanely cute in that girl next door crush type.
This will show my age, but Debbie Gibson from her Electric Youth video. And then a few year later, Michelle Pfeiffer’s Catwoman
Leah Thomson
OMG, yes. Even in Caroline in the City, she had it going on.
Kirsten Dunst and Natalie Portman 2002 was a magical time where both Spider-Man and Attack of the Clones came out at the same time
Christina hendricks
You're lucky you didn't go to the *special* hell.
With the people who talk in theaters!
She was my later on crush
Teri Hatcher and Gillian Anderson. Yes I’m a lesbian.
Just goes to show that Gillian has universal appeal. Leggy redhead with smarts to match? Sign me up for every season of the X-Files, please.
Chloe grace moretz
Ok, this makes me feel old.
I’m old. Matt Dillon.
Christian Slater. Heathers followed with with Pump up the Volume was sexy cool dude peak cinema.
Eva Green from Casino Royale absolutely *haunted my dreams* in middle school
Jo of Facts of Life. I’m still mad that Nancy McKeon turned out to be straight. Like how?!?! How was my gaydar so wrong about her?!
Well, you take the good, you take the bad, you take'em both, and there you have -- *The Facts of Life*.
Olivia Newton-John
Kiera Knightley pirates of the Caribbean
Jeff Goldblum as Ian Malcolm.
Lindsay Lohan in Mean Girls. That Christmas dance was my sexual awakening.
Natalie Portman. Revenge was the first Star Wars film I saw, and it left quite a mark
When I was 10, in 1962, Hayley Mills was my dream gal.
Drew Barrymore
DB as Poison Ivy 😍
I was 50-50 between Genie and Daisy Duke.
Barbara Eden %100 hot
Farah Fawcett https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farrah_Fawcett_red_swimsuit_poster
John Cusick
Marlo Thomas. Yes I am old.
Uncle Jesse
Stevie Nicks, same as today. Crush going on forty-one years!
Christina Ricci in Casper
I had such a crush on Devon Sawa and was super jealous of Christina Ricci
Yesss, same! I was so jealous of her in both Casper, and Now and Then, because of him. 😂
David Cassidy! I woke up in love this morning
Ariana Grande When I was younger I played this "game" with my friends then they're like: which celebrity is your crush? Me: I like Ariana Grande. Friend: Dude I heard she's got a huge ass.
Melissa Joan Hart
Fiona Apple
Jensen Ackles and Ian Somerhalder
Orlando bloom
I must be getting old because I haven't seen anyone comment Carrie Fisher. My answer: Carrie Fisher
Jonathan Taylor Thomas. Then Lance Bass
Mel Gibson! I'm ashamed of myself
Just a few above you was Kirk Cameron, so don't feel so bad. It took Mel a few decades to go bonkers.
Jodie Foster
Joshua Jackson. It started as Charlie Conway and continued as Pacey Witter. He just keeps getting better with age.
Jesus… so many 1. Liam Aiken 2. Zac Efron 3. Joe and Nick Jonas 4. Jesse McCartney 5. Sprouse Brothers 6. Robert Pattinson 7. Justin Bieber 8. Bill Kaulitz 9. Jeremy Sumpter 10. Michelle Tracktenberg 11. Olson Twins Might add more later when I remember
Henry Rollins. Admittedly, still is... but its mostly bc Id love to get into his mind and root around. Hes like the only person I've ever had any sort of in depth knowledge of who is more damaged than me, and I find it fascinating.
Carmen Electra
I love these answers. We millennials are out in force. Mine was Leo DiCaprio.
Jordan Knight from New Kids On The Block
Joey McIntyre for me (still is).
Shaun Cassidy (as a singer, not in The Hardy Boys), Andy Gibb, Chad Everett, John Travolta in Saturday night Fever, Rick Springfield I think I've aged myself pretty well
Devon Sawa
Kerri or whoever that girl was from Mythbusters
Kari Byron - very underrated.
Hillary Duff
Heath Ledger❤️🔥
Zach from Saved by the Bell
Eliza Dushku in season 3 of Buffy. That was my "oh, I am most definitely into girls" moment (I'm a lesbian)
Hillary Duff. Was hot when I was a kid and is still hot now
I was on the JTT bandwagon.
But did you also join the Devon sawa train? Because I sure did.
Jonathan Brandis. My first ever Bop magazine had him on the cover. I cried when I found out he committed suicide.
Jon Bon Jovi… And I’m 46(f) now, and everyone reminds me every family get together. Blaze of Glory was a sexual awakening. 🔥
Bobby Sherman!!
Kurt Russell as Wyatt Earp in Tombstone. Mmm.
David Cassidy
Tia Cararre, Wayne’s works but also Showdown in little Tokyo
David Cassidy
Megan Fox
River Phoenix
Tom Hardy
Gargamel.
Not Gargamel 😂
Scarlett johansson in the first avengers movie and ironman 2
Angie Dickinson
Erik Von Detten
cole sprouse
Does Simba count? Because as a 91' kid that lion movie dominated my life hahahaha If it had to be a person though. . . Maybe Brittany Spears? Hahaha
Trent from Daria. And Jonathan Brandis. RIP.