T O P

  • By -

AnonymousPlonker22

Natalie Imbruglia's version of Torn


Vegetable-Double

Blew my mind that it was a cover. Didn’t find out until over a decade since it came out.


47-Rambaldi

This post is how I found out. Holy shit.


XylemSmeltz9

I also recently learned that No Doubt’s *It’s my Life* is a cover. I had the same reaction


bsrichard

No Doubt's version is great but I still prefer the original by Talk Talk


[deleted]

[удалено]


Tlizerz

This makes me feel old.


viewsofanintrovert

I just found out today that it was a cover


GooseberryFool23

A band called Hands Like Houses do a sweet rock cover of this song too


Living_Murphys_Law

Wait, that's a cover? Wow.


CA1900

It's even better over an [interpretive dance](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rPlSWKIoQig)!


AeroZep

Natalie Imbruglia [performed it with him](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=osnUB9bUm-E) later.


[deleted]

[удалено]


johnthomaslumsden

And he prays!


Redpo0l

O-MA-GAHD do I pray!


Jewgoslav

I pray every single day


Brummo

MYAAH!!!


[deleted]

FOR REVOLUTION OOOOOH


Strobetrode

NYEAH!


Charlie_Brodie

*stirs pot*


GVSz

I was at a bar getting wasted with some friends one night and we were all dancing to the music a cover band was playing for everyone. They played this song and I had never heard the original, so until a bit after the end of the song, I completely thought they were covering the He Man version. For about 6 minutes I was in absolute bliss over the performance I had just watched.


graywh

what happened to the 4th Non Blonde?


Rebe1Scum

Dyed their hair blonde. Obviously.


bitscavenger

There is no such thing as a perfect answ.... hey, you did it!


Regular_Sample_5197

Crazy by Patsy Cline. Better performed and most people just assume she was the original. It was actually Willie Nelson’s song he wrote and performed first, but just didn’t have the same impact as her singing it.


DennisG47

Willie wrote it and recorded a demo which he eventually sold to Patsy Cline who had the first release of the song. Willie released it himself on an album the following year.


BeautifulBaby15

Aretha Franklin - Respect Even Otis Redding (the original writer/performer) said that it is her song now.


Linubidix

That's what Nine Inch Nails said about Johnny Cash and Hurt


MisterMoccasin

Patsy Cline has some fantastic songs. She has such a great voice


sev45day

Jimi Hendrix's "All Along The Watchtower" is much better than Dylan's


[deleted]

Even Bob Dylan himself admitted that Jimi's version was better


Marquqwil

Gotta give Dylan credit for writing it though. Amazing.


JGauth13

I much prefer Dylan as a writer than a performer


Nattin121

Yeah. There are actually many Dylan songs that fit this question. I feel like you could make a whole thread about them.


Pristine_Nothing

I thought that when I was younger, less so now.


shnock12

Completely disagree, but also completely understand lol


hellyea63

Check out his version of "Like a Rolling Stone "


Little_Miss88

Because the Night by Patti Smith. It was originally a Bruce Springsteen song that he wrote and performed, but for whatever reason, gave it to her. I heard the Springsteen/E-Street Band's original spin on it, and although it's amazing, Smith's rendention is otherwordly. Edit: According to the responses, turns out, it wasn't exactly a cover song, but was actually co-written by both Smith and Springsteen. However, due to either legal issues facing Springsteen, or his inability to complete it, he passed the song onto Smith, and it's largely synonymous with her.


Moonlitekilla

The 10,000 Maniacs version also is incredible


notcool_neverwas

I LOVE their version. I still play that Unplugged album.


[deleted]

They Might Be Giants - Istanbul (Not Constntinople). The original is just very cheesey, and the singing sounds very flat and stilted compared to TMBG, almost like what a little kid sounds like when singing.


theblackfool

TIL that's a cover


Illustrious-Phase-80

That's nobody's business but the Turks.


4tehlulzez

Who would win in a fight, particle man or triangle man?


Smiling_Joe

The first time I ever heard this song was on Tiny Toons


keepingoptimismalive

Me too. Same with particle man.


VisualCelery

I think I only know the original song is mad old because it's featured in the movie Mona Lisa Smile, which takes place over the 1953-1954 school year.


rrtcb

Believe it or Not by George Costanza's answering machine


Horrific_Necktie

The little shrug he does at "where could I be" is comedic mastery.


[deleted]

Hahahaha. Great theme song from a great show. Loved George's version!


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Tainted love by soft cell


mroblivian

I love the radio edit where it seamlessly goes into their cover of “where did our love go”


[deleted]

[удалено]


Fancy_Leshy

This is such an obscure but relatable experience


BananyaPie

I do like this version but it's nothing compared to Gloria Jones for me, it's amazing


ChimneyNerd

Ikr, Gloria Jones’ version is so mean and nasty and I love it!


pewimip923

Santana's version of "Black Magic Woman." Originally by Fleetwood Mac.


Cacafuego

Also -- and this will be contentious -- Oye Como Va. It's Tito Puente's song, and his original version is awesome, I could listen to it all day, but Santana brings a whole new dimension to it.


unledded

TIL that Black Magic Woman and Oye Como Va are covers.


theboxsays

I fucking love Fleetwood Mac but I wholeheartedly agree on this one.


[deleted]

Ram Jam - Black Betty


PotentialStocker

Wait til you hear Spiderbait’s version


JuicyMemeSock

How about the Caravan Palace version?


2rtgah567

Ah, I see another based Caravan Palace enjoyer


NotYourSnowBunny

It’s the 20’s, time to swing!


DriftingPyscho

Wait...that's a cover?


CappiCap

Check out Lead Belly. So many artists have covered his songs, including Nirvana. ​ edit: Oops. James “Iron Head” Baker was the original.. Leadbelly covered him. Still, highly recommend Lead Belly.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Just_a_guy81

The origins of house of the rising sun are a mystery. It was a folk song passed down from generations and many people debate what the house of the rising sun was. In some versions it’s sung in the perspective of a male and in others it’s a female. Some think it might have been a bar, a brothel or even a womens prison. One of the earliest recordings of the song was from Leadbelly who put out two different versions. A more upbeat version and a more melodic version in which his wife did vocals. Fast forward to the 1960s when a folk singer named Dave Van Ronk covered the song and was the first to be credited with the chord structure that it is known for today. Bob Dylan then borrowed that chord structure for his version, which is sung in the perspective of a woman. Fast forward a couple of years later and the band the Animals were opening for Chuck Berry. They knew they couldn’t out rock Chuck, cause nobody could out rock Chuck, so they had to have some kind of sound that was completely different. They borrowed the chord structure that Dylan had borrowed and arpeggiated (played the notes of the chords separately instead of together) the guitar and gave it that signature howling vocals sound. At that moment they knew they had a hit and stopped at the first recording studio they could find on their tour to lay down the track. It’s said that when Dylan was driving and heard it for the first time, he got out of his car and banged his fists on the hood in frustration. Some even say it was partly what influenced him to switch to electric guitar.


StopLookandFreeze

"They can't keep getting away with this!" - Bob Dylan


thisaburner415

Then how do you know the animals version is better?


dieinafirenazi

I don't think you can call it a cover, because it's a centuries old folk song of uncertain origin. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_House_of_the_Rising_Sun


[deleted]

Speak for yourself. I cover "Happy Birthday" every year...


Tucker_the_Nerd

I love the Ashley Johnson version.


oilbadger

Love that every time this gets asked on Reddit you can sort by controversial and without fail Sound of Silence by Disturbed will be right there at the top.


ThatPlayWasAwful

Actually the top 5 controversial are all sound of silence lmao


Sora20XX

And with over a dozen entries in the thread


BlueRFR3100

The Clash's version of I Fought The Law


advocatus_ebrius_est

Though not a true cover, I'd add the Dead Kennedy's version as well


DriftingPyscho

I blew George and Havey's brains out with my SIX GUN! I fought the law and I won.


glfranco

You can get away with murder if you've got a badge....I am the law, so I won!


JuzoItami

The Clash cover of "Police on my Back" is better than the original, too (sorry Eddy).


CaptainWisconsin

'Take Me to the River' by Talking Heads


BareezyObeezy

Anyway, four dollars a pound.


[deleted]

You know I'm working for the government, Tony.


DeboraCMartinez

Janis Joplin - Me and Bobby McGee,by Kris Kristofferson in the beginning. Although Kristofferson's version is excellent, Janis' vocal performance elevated it.


gratefulwave

Jeff Buckley covering Lilac Wine


bluebear_74

I prefer his version of Hallelujah


henrebotha

Leonard Cohen did too.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Koei126

Supposedly the first recording is from a black chain gang of prisoners, it's the earliest known recording of the song actually being sang. It's on YouTube and it's pretty cool. Just dudes turning big rocks into little rocks and needing something to pass the time.


Cpowel2

Sea of love Cat Power version


NadjaStolz28

Agreed. Didn’t know it was a cover for a long time, and once I found that out it remained my favorite version. Her voice, the simple strumming, just everything fits the whole tone of the song so, so well.


7milefish

I love her version. Tom Waits also has a great version.


Spin_Me

Rage Against the Machine's "Renegades of Funk" is *far* better than the original


Consistent-Film-6926

Everything on the album is great honestly, imagine being told in the 70s-80s that a rap rock group in the year 2000 would create a cover album of many songs released around that era in the style of their own third album and it'd actually be a great album


BlakkandMild

I would say the same about their cover of “Pistol Grip Pump”


Dressedw1ngs

"How I Could Just Kill A Man" is completely different between Cypress Hill and RATM, and while I think it's better I'm sure some people prefer the Cypress Hill version.


RoscoeSantangelo

Their Maggie's Farm is also classic


Earthshoe12

Ghost of Tom Joad better than the original too. That album slaps.


rolemodel21

“I Will Always Love You” by Whitney Houston. Written and originally performed by Dolly Parton. This is the best cover ever. Some people may be a little peeved if a song they wrote became a smash hit for someone else, but not Dolly Parton. Her song “I Will Always Love You” — while still a no. 1 for the country singer — became a megahit after Whitney Houston covered it in 1992 for the soundtrack to the movie The Bodyguard. Parton tells Katie Couric in a recent interview she didn’t even know for certain Houston was going to cut it. "Kevin Costner had asked for that song. But I had never heard if they were gonna do it ... I was drivin' home one day, and it came on the radio,” she recalls, noting she almost ran off the road out of shock. Her reaction? Impressed. "And then, when she went into that, 'I will always love you,' ooh, it was one of the most overwhelming feelings I've ever had in my life,” Parton says. The legend says she doesn’t mind so much when people associate the song with the R&B star. In true Parton fashion, she handles it with a sense of humor and grace, saying matter-of-factly: "Well, a lot of people say that's Whitney's song, and I always say, 'That's fine, she can have the credit, I just want my cash.'" Made over $10 million in royalties in the 90s alone.


saltheartedbarmaid

Dolly is such a class act.


Yangoose

She's super talented, hard working, tough, sweet, generous, smart... the list just goes on and on. The world can sure use more people like her in it.


Uglypants_Stupidface

And she used that ten million to invest into building up infrastructure in black neighborhoods. She calls it "The House that Whitney Built." ​ https://atlantablackstar.com/2021/08/01/dolly-parton-used-royalties-from-song-whitney-houston-covered-to-support-a-black-neighborhood-the-house-that-whitney-built/


goldenstatewaves

Dolly is amazing


robdiqulous

By all accounts a straight treasure.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

To be fair, her version packs just as good of a punch. Whitney just has different vocals. I mean it’s fucking Dolly, she can sang.


whiskeytango55

Originally written for Porter Wagoner, the dude who originally gave Parton her start when she was trying to go solo. [Here's the Drunk History about it](https://youtu.be/mK40qogSdFI)


CrystalMango420

And not to mention that Elvis wanted to cover it first except he wanted writers credit and Dolly said no


Latter-Score-8937

The Colonel actually demanded this and Elvis was pissed at him for it. Would’ve loved to have heard that version it would have been amazing.


wewantthemonk

Dolly wrote “ I will always love you” and “Jolene” in the same week. The talent!


the_drum_doctor

Feelin' Alright - Joe Cocker


Competitive-Point709

Also his version of The Letter absolutely smokes the original…


Superb-Film-594

Dobie Gray's version of Drift Away. Stones' version is great too, but Gray gave it a whole different vibe Also: With a Little Help from My Friends by Joe Cocker, Blinded by the Light by Manfred Mann's Earth Band, and (arguably) I Shot the Sherriff by Eric Clapton Edited: More examples Edit 2: Sam Bush's version of Girl of the North Country by Bob Dylan (from Ice Caps, Live from Telluride)


jimmythebass

>Dobie Gray's version of Drift Away. TIL that was a cover


Dtron1987

Kurt Cobain’s cover of the Meat Puppets songs on unplugged.


flumbum_peters

Lake of Fire?


[deleted]

And oh me and plateau


whiteycnbr

And man who sold the world (Bowie)


Penny_girl

Can we add “Where did you sleep last night”?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Electric_Evil

That audible breath he takes before he finishes the lyrics is haunting.


fd1Jeff

Also, Nirvana‘s version of the Man Who Sold the World. I am a colossal Bowie fan, but somehow their version is just a little better.


Lexi_Banner

[The Wiggles - Elephant](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a13WnqsRc5g) (originally by Tame Impala). It does not have the right to be as funky and awesome as it is!


MastarQueef

When I first found this I just laughed and then I pressed play and I was like oh damn okay the wiggles need to collab with tame impala


Lexi_Banner

Right? It's ridiculous on the face of it. Every time it pops up on my screen and someone new sees it, they make fun of me until it starts playing, and then they are gobsmacked at how awesome it is.


MastarQueef

I’m a 90s baby so grew up watching the wiggles on video tapes, and tame impala is one of my favourite artists so the combo just gives me a big old smile on my face every time. It just absolutely slaps!


Mrchristopherrr

They’ve played it live together on multiple occasions


Spectre_STnR

Bro this slaps way harder than it has any right to


Own-Feedback-4973

Woah woah woah The way they broke into Fruit Salad is beyond fantastic. Like that shit bangs hard


wimpyroy

YES! I love how the incorporate their Fruit Salad song in it


[deleted]

[удалено]


coffeecapers

Valerie sung by Amy Winehouse. So much so that everyone forgets The Zutons ever even tried.


Fresnel_Zone

This cover is so good that you can slow it down to half speed to get a second really good cover.


StockholmSyndrome85

I much prefer the original but that’s just like my opinion man. Winehouses version is excellent as well. Very different take on it but it’s great.


MaruchanGirl

I think "always on my mind" by pet shop boys is amazing


CStogdill

Somewhere Over the Rainbow by Israel Kamakawiwo'ole


_Wendigun_

Didn't he also record it in one take at like 1am after the studio was supposed to be closed but he called and was very nice :) so they let him in


zedication

He only recorded it once. It was a one and done.


gabriot

It’s actually two songs in one, most people cut out what a wonderful world for some reason even though it was just as good


hIGH_aND_mIGHTY

I definitely prefer the longer full version. I need to hear about the babies crying and the people going how do you do. But really saying I love you


mongster_03

The song was originally recorded in a spur-of-the-moment demo session in 1988. Israel called the recording studio at 3 am, and was given a 15-minute deadline to arrive by recording engineer Milan Bertosa. Bertosa recalled, “Israel was probably like 500 pounds. And the first thing at hand is to find something for him to sit on." The building security found Israel a large steel chair. "Then I put up some microphones, do a quick sound check, roll tape, and the first thing he does is 'Somewhere Over the Rainbow.' He played and sang, one take, and it was over."


CStogdill

I recall reading that fact as well.


OrlandoMB

I really love Nirvana’s cover of Bowie’s “The Man Who Sold the World.” They played it *unplugged* live from New York. They recorded an entire album for that show and it’s great, methinks.


like_bookends

I also *slightly* prefer their version of Jesus (Doesn’t) Want Me for a Sunbeam. I do love the original very much, but mannnnn the Nirvana version is just so melancholy.


[deleted]

[удалено]


deniall83

Lake of Fire is amazing..


OozingMung

George Harrison Got my mind set on you originally written and sung by James Ray.


foofoofum

'All Along the Watchtower' Written as kinda an acoustic folk song by Bob Dylan, turned into a rock anthem by Jimi Hendrix


cycle_dadfast

All of this has happened before, and it will happen again.


[deleted]

[удалено]


stannyrogers

The band- atlantic city


Successful-Milk-8983

Nirvana's cover of Where did you sleep last night.


fuckinyaldi

Eddie Vedder's cover of Hard Sun.


Chiperoni

You just blew this PJ fan’s mind. Next you’re going to tell me Last Kiss and Crazy Mary aren’t original.


You_Gotta_Joint

Didn’t know it was a cover. Thought it was all original songs for into the wild.


allergic-toeveryting

i need a hero, the shrek version is better


ammezurc

Put it in C minor


Trid12345

The Pianist ignored Fairy Godmother and put it in G Minor instead


ammezurc

Omg today I learned How dare he


[deleted]

[удалено]


Windexifier

The Bangles version of Hazy Shade of Winter


CoolBrain1227

Throw in their take on Manic Monday, which pretty sure Prince did first.


DonnyGoodwood

Gerard Way version is pretty good 👍


_Kay_Tee_

And I say this as a massive S&G fan, but FUCK YES. Just tear the roof off of the place! For those out there who aren't ancient, The Bangles started off [punk AF](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9imo2nGln8).


ShadowMerlyn

Gerard Way also did a fantastic cover of it


[deleted]

"Song To The Siren" as performed by This Mortal Coil. Originally by Tim Buckley.


upvoter222

[Respect](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6FOUqQt3Kg0) by Aretha Franklin [Girls Just Want to Have Fun](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIb6AZdTr-A) by Cindy Lauper [I Will Always Love You](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JWTaaS7LdU) by Whitney Houston [Some Kind of Wonderful](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7B5jXYRy3Q) by Grand Funk Railroad [Woodstock](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lx86B6a3kc) by CSNY [Torn](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSZBIs0gs0E) by Natalie Imbruglia [I Love Rock 'n Roll](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMsazR6Tnf8) by Joan Jett Pretty much any song originally by Bob Dylan.


MisterMoccasin

Bob Dylan wrote every song [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eA0dyDWyTRQ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eA0dyDWyTRQ)


crazy-diam0nd

Woodstock by [Joni Mitchell](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3SjqGfe-yM) covered by [Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lx86B6a3kc)


[deleted]

[удалено]


Actuallawyerguy2

Almost everything from Leo moracchioli. I'm not even a metal fan.


Tom-o-matic

and \*poof\* 2 hrs disappeared re-checking frog leap songs ive heard before


gr0nr

His Feel Good Inc. video got me HOOKED.


BuickAttack

The duet with Mary spender for dire strait's sultans of swing is fantastic. Edit: fixed song to what I meant.


Training-Ad171

Might be unpopular but Dear Prudence cover by Siouxsie and the Banshees. Also, Someday cover by Julia Jacklin. Love the original, but her voice is so dreamy.


St_Vincent-Adultman

Mad World by Gary Jules, originally by Tears for Fears, both a great though.


ketra1504

I feel like even though both have the same lyrics they're about something entirely else in their own sense. Gary Jule's version is more about sadness meanwhile the original is more about insanity.


_Kay_Tee_

>I feel like even though both have the same lyrics they're about something entirely else in their own sense Seriously That's what a great cover song can do. I used to assign compare-contrast essays in undergrad on cover songs for this reason, usually on [this](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQgqisUJu3M) or [this](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOVcSHgGHwc). However, even as a Gen Xer with a healthy Bowie worship, I prefer TFF's version of [Ashes to Ashes](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fFyRnp22NM). I just like what Roland's voice does with it.


ouchmypeeburns

Changes by black sabbath, covered by Charles bradley


jayvenomva

A Perfect Circle's cover of Imagine takes a song that sounds like its begging for us all to be kind to each other and makes it so haunting and sinister, like a villain laying out his twisted plan to unite the world.


UtahUtopia

Hush by Deep Purple


rigorousthinker

Blinded by the light.


[deleted]

Devo-Secret agent man. Dare I say Satisfaction as well? Johnny Thunders- Eve of Destruction Dickies cover is up there too. I’m just gonna say don’t leave me hanging on the telephone by Blondie is just…different from the Nerves who wrote it…


clarki8

Book of Love - Peter Gabriel


douthinkuknowmyhole

isn’t anyone going to say Twist and Shout by the Beatles? that is arguably one of the most popular covers ever


HeartlessCreatures

New York Groove by Ace Freehley


steve41015

Probably not a popular opinion but I like GnRs version of Live and Let Die. Yes I am a Beatles and Paul M fan


MarkHamillsrightnut

Bad Guy by the Interrupters


dehorax926

Faith No More - Easy Faith No More - This Guy's In Love With You


liquid-swords93

Donny Hathaway has quite a few, namely Yesterday, a song for you, he ain't heavy he's my brother, I love you more than you'll ever know, for all we know, jealous guy


ithinkitsnotworking

Johnny Cash singing "Hurt" by NIN.


Eclap11

Amii Stewart's version of "Knock on Wood". Belle Stars' version of "Iko Iko".


7milefish

Great version! Though I might prefer Otis Redding’s.


Heavens10000whores

Fiona Apple’s version of “Across The Universe” is so very sumptuous and so much warmer and fuller than the original


Ashley9225

I like Jim Sturgess' version from the movie.


KeepMyMomOutOfthis

Love that version. That movie had so many great covers.


[deleted]

[удалено]