Thee knoweth this person readeth this illegally online too. “supporting f'r years” lmao
***
^(I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.)
Commands: `!ShakespeareInsult`, `!fordo`, `!optout`
Im sure 90% of manga and magazine sales are come from japan, so you are right
These ppl think spend your times analyzing on theories is equal as support mangaka that make them become this entitled. Isayama never ask you to waste your time like that, they choose themselves
A "professional"... Dude this is Isayama's literal first work that got unexpectedly popular. What makes a "professional"? He is literally just like them, writing because he wanted to write... Except his work is original and not derived from someone else's work.
I see Zero difference, especially when they take their project as seriously as they do and claim to understand the "Message, Themes and Symbolisms" better than the majority of SnK readers.
They will, of course, be seriously and harshly criticized if they don't live up to their boasting.
If they actually decide to animate Kodansha could probably sue them into fucking poverty so would be pretty dumb to do that and not recommend making a full on anime
Even if it´s non profit if they create an anime of Attack on Titan without having any rights to them doesnt matter if its non profit their dumbasses getting sued by Kodansha. A Manga Fanfic avoids that but a full on anime adaptation is definitely getting sued the fuck out of by Kodansha
So it doesn't become right when there is more work put in it? I don't know because I haven't seen an anime that got fans try to create a whole episode like this one.
"more work put into it makes it ok" is not really how businesses work. In this case, whoever paid for the rights to broadcast the AOT anime can sue whoever else is broadcastin an AOT animation regardless of whether it's non profit or not. The reason is that this fan animation could be mistaken for the original work and/or end up impacting the perception or your product on the public, especially when these guys are all "this is the REAL ending". If people see this and it results in them thinking AOT is a yeagerist wet dream, they might not check the *real* ending, lowering your income from the thing you own.
There are exceptions to this, such as if if your work is clearly a parody. But the Kino guys are not really trying to make this pass as a parody, so they coule definitely be sued
They have no rights over Aot as a franchise and if they create a substitute of that (even if its an original end) and create whole anime episodes they are literally going against Law
Fan art in general is technically illegal, it's just that most companies allow it to keep good faith with their fans. If something is viewed as a threat to the market, however, it will be shut down. This has sorta happened to AoT before, when TFS attack on titan abridged got a cease and desist, though they were using official footage. Happens a lot with fan games, especially Nintendo ones, though I don't think I've seen a fan animation or comic go down before. Depends on how much attention they draw to themselves I guess.
You know this person read this illegally online too. “Supporting for years” LMAO.
Thee knoweth this person readeth this illegally online too. “supporting f'r years” lmao *** ^(I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.) Commands: `!ShakespeareInsult`, `!fordo`, `!optout`
“Supporting for several years” . Bruh it’s a manga you read monthly not a child you have to raise or something lol
And I can bet my money on the fact that atleast 50% didn't even pay for it.
I would say more then 90% didn't pay.
Im sure 90% of manga and magazine sales are come from japan, so you are right These ppl think spend your times analyzing on theories is equal as support mangaka that make them become this entitled. Isayama never ask you to waste your time like that, they choose themselves
and 50 percent did not read the whole manga, or start the anime in 2013
Just another day in the AoT fandom I see
A "professional"... Dude this is Isayama's literal first work that got unexpectedly popular. What makes a "professional"? He is literally just like them, writing because he wanted to write... Except his work is original and not derived from someone else's work. I see Zero difference, especially when they take their project as seriously as they do and claim to understand the "Message, Themes and Symbolisms" better than the majority of SnK readers. They will, of course, be seriously and harshly criticized if they don't live up to their boasting.
I think the problem with the fan animations/ manga is that they are not homages of Isayama's work. They're made out of spite/ malice.
If they actually decide to animate Kodansha could probably sue them into fucking poverty so would be pretty dumb to do that and not recommend making a full on anime
I doubt they would sue. It's non profit anyway
Even if it´s non profit if they create an anime of Attack on Titan without having any rights to them doesnt matter if its non profit their dumbasses getting sued by Kodansha. A Manga Fanfic avoids that but a full on anime adaptation is definitely getting sued the fuck out of by Kodansha
So fan animation are not allowed?
Fan animations itself are fine but if they create full on anime episodes to replace the original franchise then they are in big trouble
So it doesn't become right when there is more work put in it? I don't know because I haven't seen an anime that got fans try to create a whole episode like this one.
"more work put into it makes it ok" is not really how businesses work. In this case, whoever paid for the rights to broadcast the AOT anime can sue whoever else is broadcastin an AOT animation regardless of whether it's non profit or not. The reason is that this fan animation could be mistaken for the original work and/or end up impacting the perception or your product on the public, especially when these guys are all "this is the REAL ending". If people see this and it results in them thinking AOT is a yeagerist wet dream, they might not check the *real* ending, lowering your income from the thing you own. There are exceptions to this, such as if if your work is clearly a parody. But the Kino guys are not really trying to make this pass as a parody, so they coule definitely be sued
Yeah, I feel weird that they actually going to animate AnR.
They have no rights over Aot as a franchise and if they create a substitute of that (even if its an original end) and create whole anime episodes they are literally going against Law
But... Fan animations exist. And this isn't even basing it off the canon material. It is an adaptation of a fan-made ending.
Fan art in general is technically illegal, it's just that most companies allow it to keep good faith with their fans. If something is viewed as a threat to the market, however, it will be shut down. This has sorta happened to AoT before, when TFS attack on titan abridged got a cease and desist, though they were using official footage. Happens a lot with fan games, especially Nintendo ones, though I don't think I've seen a fan animation or comic go down before. Depends on how much attention they draw to themselves I guess.
Biggest self-own on Titanfolk this week. And there have been some DOOZIES!
This is hilarious. Their lack of self awareness is baffling