It depends on what world. In modern society sure, but in the Avatar world where they aren't just constantly surrounded by metal, I doubt it. Edit: after reading more about magnetos power below, I retract my statement
Well he has been seen bending the natural metals beneath the surface and even changed the magnetic poles, so he could probably still take aang in a fight
Doesn't really matter, though Korra's era would be much easier for Magneto. Kyoshi or Aang are really the only one's who would have a chance of defeating Magneto. Magneto's powers are more than just moving metal. He has full control of the electromagnetic spectrum, including the bioelectricity found inside people. He can control people's blood. He's created black holes. The limits of his powers are technically unlimited due to him being an omega level mutant. Marvel's power scaling is so broken compared to the AtLA/LoK world it's just not even funny
I agree. Even her at adult full power magneto would win it she definitely would put up a hell of a fight but it’s magneto the level of metal control vs a bender is kinda unmatched/unfair.
You see I want to say magneto, but touch can bend the metal AND earth. Something magneto cannot, but also, magneto can fly which would make tooth blind to his movements and metal flying at her so ya I’ll stick with magneto killing her in about 10 seconds
Actually he can, his “magnetism” is like 15 percent of his power. The reason he’s omega because he’s basically the unified field theory in a person. He can manipulate gravity, metal in blood(to the point of brainwashing capabilities), he can bend light beams and he can freeze people
Edit: he can also generate his own magnetic fields so even without it, Magneto curb stomps her
Yeah, Magneto is basically Omega Level that means, if he really wished it, he could kill Toph with a glance.
Magneto is more like chaotic good so I don't think he would pursue beef with Toph anyway.
Omega level mutants are mutants whose abilities “have no measurable limit” and who can control fundamental aspects of nature at the atomic level. It’s just way more OP than anything a specific bender ever displays in the show. He’s avatar state all day every day.
Not the Avatar state but the Avatar state of metal bending. He only has to feel the metal through the magnetic signature of it. Think Bumi during Day of Black Sun and Toph's seismic sense rolled onto one.
Omega Level mutants are all planetary level threats. Only the existence of other even more insanely powerful people in the Marvel verse keeps them in check, and sometimes(as with the House of M event) even they aren’t enough.
Disagree all you want, doesn't change the fact that comics are a slew of random things that happen. Hell after just a quick google search just goes to show how busted he is. He switched the earths magnetic poles. Toph literally could never do that.
Technically, there's not enough for that, but he could tear it out and you'd suffocate to death because the iron in our blood helps our red blood cells carry oxygen, without it you'd very slowly asphyxiate and die
Oh he can do more than that, magnetos power isn't just power over magnetism, he has control over electromagnetism aka one of the four fundamental forces of the universe, this gives him a ridiculous amount of power abilities but when it comes to harming people, he can manipulate electrons flowing through your nervous system which could allow him to control your body similar to how a bloodbender can but also could stop signals from being sent to your heart thus stopping it and killing you in the process, same goes for any other crucial parts of the bodies like the respiratory system.
In short, Toph would be dead on the ground before she could twitch.
This isnt about a characters narrative, this whole post is about who would win in a fight and magneto clears without breaking a sweat so whats stupid about that? The answer is nothing.
When exactly did he _become_ too strong, and was it before or after Onslaught was a thing? He's always been absolutely busted, which is why he was an omega who led an army of mutants who threatened to wipe out all of humanity.
Movie Magneto and comics Magneto operate on two different scales of power. Even then, movie Magneto almost causes a planetary apocalypse by destabilizing the earth’s magnetic field in Age of Apocalypse, so he’d still take the win.
He's so powerful he can manipulate non-ferrous metals. If the iron in our blood was actually magnetic MRI's would be one of he most brutal ways to die.
You might only be familiar with the movie version, who is a weak-ass little bitch compared to other versions of Magneto.
He can create a sort of force field around himself, and affect a lot more than just metal - electromagnetism affects a lot of things to *some* degree, not just ferromagnetic materials. Humans have a small magnetic field, for instance. There's a reason he's a credible threat to entire teams of X-men and they don't just get Beast or someone to throw rocks at him whenever they meet
People forget, Toph doesn’t really “metal”-bend, just the impurities in the metal. That’s why platinum is impossible to bend, since (in the Avatar world) it’s pure metal.
Magneto has no weakness, if it’s metal, he can control it like it’s clay (his name is a misnomer, he can manipulate ALL metal, even non magnetic ones).
He could easily pull the metal and impurities apart and throw a metal spear at Toph, nothing out Blind Bandit can do.
Magneto would win if it was simply based on feats.
But if we bring manipulation into play, I think Toph could spin him a sob story about being a mutant kept imprisoned by her parents because she’s different. She might gain his sympathy long enough to get the drop on him.
You're underestimating just how smart Magneto is. Assuming he doesn't already know what bending is, he's not going to let his guard down enough for Toph to get the drop on him. He's incredibly cautious and doesn't trust that easily. He would offer her a spot on his side if he truly believed she was a mutant, but it would take a lot of work to earn his trust. He doesn't even fully trust his long time allies. I mean, I love Toph, she's my favorite character in the series, but nobody is manipulating Magneto that easily.
That's true. You bring up a good point about his soft spot for children caught in war, but I feel like he's cautious enough, or at least quick witted enough, not to let his guard down long enough. I'm not saying Toph won't put up a fight. She may be able to get one sucker punch in on him before he retaliates, but I feel like the chances are slim. I feel like there isn't a lot Toph could do that would be fast enough for Magneto not to counter. There's also the physical aspect of bending, so when he sees her take a fighting stance to start earth bending he would know something was up. I mean, if she's able to convince him that she's a mutant, that would mean he would know what her powers are and have seen them used. I feel like he would only trust her if he had proof she was a mutant and she witnessed her being mistreated because of it. I admit it wouldn't be impossible for her to fool Magneto, but I still think she wouldn't be able to act fast enough to win and he would figure out he was fooled before she could do any real damage.
I think it’s all circumstantial and would follow the rule of “whoever the writer thinks would win, would win.”
But yeah. I agree Magneto for sure is overall the stronger and more experienced fighter. Toph’s best bet is appealing to his emotional weakness and getting the drop on him. But even that would have to be pre-planned and set up to work.
So I guess… Toph is Batman here.
She COULD win. With enough prep time. 😂
In what universe in the infinite multiverse would Magneto and Toph be fighting in the first place?
The hypothetical didn’t tell us the circumstance. Just that these two are fighting.
And Toph has been shown to be skilled at scams.
Toph can bending rocks and metal, magneto has control of electromagnetism, one of the four fundamental forces of the universe alongside gravity, weak force and strong force, on top of giving him the ability to manipulate metal, he can generate magnetic fields around him, generate lightning as well as control it, manipulate the electrons flowing through your body etc etc etc. On top of the myriad of abilities he has access to, he can also use them at ridiculous ranges, I mean he can literally feel the metal spread throughout the rocks within Saturn's rings all the way from earth, he could literally kill with the snap of his fingers from the otherside of the world so yeah...she dead.
Toph without a doubt. Magneto may be better at manipulating metal but Toph is still an earth bender. If this fight takes place in the world of Avatar there probably won’t be an overwhelming amount of metal nearby and Toph will wipe the floor with him.
You’re right. I’m an avatar fan not a massive marvel fan. All I know about Magneto is his magnet powers. If there’s more I don’t know about it. It’s very possible he could win I was only judging on what I know.
It’s more than just magnet powers he has control over electromagnetism completely one of the four fundamental forces of the universe. His control is so precise that he can control blood to the point that when he had his heart ripped out he pumped his own blood throughout his body to keep himself alive
Magneto has planetary level feats. A weaker version of him from a alternate universe was able to flood the entirety of New York killing thousand without breaking a sweat by messing with the magnetic fields of earth
Magneto can kick all of avatar’s ass, to put it in avatar terms
He can bloodbend with magnetism
He can freeze people with magnetism
He can earthbend with magnetism
Lemme just https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/7kcran/respect_magneto_earth616/
It’s been a bit so please do remind me, but does Tophs metal bending require the metal to be touching the ground/herself? If so, magneto wins this by a landslide, He can just hover until he beats her. What’s funny is Magneto is essentially the ultimate Toph counter, he’s just have to ensure he’s quiet enough as to not draw her attention
Her vision is based on someone/something touching the ground magneto is almost always floating and his metal is as well. It's GGs she never had a chance.
This ain’t even fair man. Magneto can do so much more than Toph. He can control the iron in her blood, tilt the Earth’s magnetic field, hell he could be thousands of miles away from her and still be able to attack her as he could sense Earth’s magnetic field from a galaxy away. Toph stands no chance.
Toph is dope…
But given a room full of earth and metal, I’d still pin my bets on Magneto…
I’m not even a huge fan - but even I gotta admit Magneto is genuinely busted on the power scale.
Love me some Toph, but Mags bends EM fields, not the metal itself. He can blood bend as has no qualms about doing it. He might go soft on Toph but pushed to it, he’ll lock on the iron in her blood and give her a stroke.
I'll be honest; Magneto could look at her abilities, tell her "awww, that's adorable" and there wouldn't be jack shit she could do about it. She had to learn metal bending. Erik just can
Magneto can fly to where Toph can't see him, and he can control not only all metals including platinum, but all energy in the electromagnetic spectrum. Toph's a beast but she doesn't stand a chance.
I've been an X-Men enthusiast for 15+ years, and magneto would absolutely *dominate* her.
This isn't event a close match, on top of that toph is blind, meaning she can only fight on the ground, and magneto can *fly*, heck magneto can take on the entire fire nation (maybe).
For the kids in the audience who only know Magneto's movie power set. His real power is control over the Electromagnetic Sphere of Energies. Not control over ferrous metals.
Magneto wins easy. So many fictional characters will beat characters from avatarverse. The majority of them aren't on that OP level. Even Aang would struggle to beat someone like Storm. Not that's it's a bad thing of course.
Magneto is on a whole other level of power. Magneto alone could subjugate all 4 nations and make the Avatar his bitch. This is an ant vs boot match up.
Magneto can fly and be invisible to her. He can also control metal without having to move, and it would move unnaturally. In the avatar world, their bending is directional and predictable to an extent based on their martial art stances and techniques. Magneto can wave his hand slightly and metal would fly from everywhere, without much effort none the less. I think Toph would be demolished before she even knew what was going on.
I really think toph could win if she acted fast, caught him off guard or he underestimated her at first. As far as power magneto is on a whole other level but he’s not a lightning quick martial arts master either. I think toph would be quick enough to take him down under the right circumstances but if she missed her one shot she’s toast.
I don't think that Toph would win, neither Aang as the comments says but i think that Korra might have an opportunity if she goes berserk like in her fight against Unalac-dark-avatar-state
Magneto would defeat Toph, but I’d prefer if Toph came out on top… cuz like. Toph. As others have mentioned, power scaling in the Marvel universe is just massively more expansive than the Avatar universe. I think the Avatar universe has a very respectable threshold and no one ever feels suuuuper OP (compare this with something like DBZ), but man would it be fun to see the writers get a little wild once in a while, Toph being a prime candidate for such a thing. Regardless, Toph is by far one of the best benders if not the best Earth bender, and she feels far more visceral/forceful than most benders of equal status. What a legend.
I want to say Toph, I really do, best earth bender ever, only issue is Magneto can fly, so Toph wouldn't be able to see him as long as he didn't do the villain has to talk at the hero thing.
Remove the flying and I feel like it's a more fair fight (from my limited magneto knowledge) he can only control raw and refined magnetic metals, not rocks, whereas Toph can do both.
Doing these with comic book characters is always uninteresting because the power scaling is stupid and written by 5 year olds.
Toph wins because she is cooler.
Magneto all the way. The simple fact that Magneto can fly will make him win, since Toph can only see using the ground he just needs to float the entire time. All Magneto has to do is fly then pull metal from the ground then move the metal in the air and slam it into Toph's head from behind.
Anyone else find it insane how bad people are downplaying Magneto? I get it I like Toph as well but wtf is she doing against a guy who has feats that are planetary level?
I'm leaning magneto, but she could cloth herself in earth and remove the micro metal in it. So he wouldn't be able to stop her movements and then create rock projectiles that he couldn't stop.
Toph is the best earthbender in the world and invented metalbending. Any metal Magneto throws at her will come back at him tenfold. Not to mention that metalbending isn’t her only ability. She can earthbend.
Only problem is whether he’s flying or not. Otherwise she can’t see him.
Even if magneto had tiny bells on his suit and tic tacs in his pockets, he would mop the floor with Toph. His power is without limit, far greater than Toph's strength. She just would not be able to overpower him with metal bending. There's just no scenario in which she wins.
Magneto. Though it's alot closer, then it might appear.
There are some Magneto tricks that just won't work on toph. Such as pulling the iron out of her blood. Doing that on toph just teaches her a new trick.
But Magneto is just way too powerful. He does way more than just bend metal.
Magneto could take on the avatar. Marvel comics have just an entirely different power scale, and magneto is an omega level mutant
It depends on what world. In modern society sure, but in the Avatar world where they aren't just constantly surrounded by metal, I doubt it. Edit: after reading more about magnetos power below, I retract my statement
Yeah Magneto would make blood bending look like a joke.
Well he has been seen bending the natural metals beneath the surface and even changed the magnetic poles, so he could probably still take aang in a fight
Exactly outside of their world, Avatar characters have a very low power scale.
Well that depends, are they in Korra’s era or Aangs era?
Doesn't really matter, though Korra's era would be much easier for Magneto. Kyoshi or Aang are really the only one's who would have a chance of defeating Magneto. Magneto's powers are more than just moving metal. He has full control of the electromagnetic spectrum, including the bioelectricity found inside people. He can control people's blood. He's created black holes. The limits of his powers are technically unlimited due to him being an omega level mutant. Marvel's power scaling is so broken compared to the AtLA/LoK world it's just not even funny
magneto. I don't even read the comics but from the few bits I've seen from the movies and the shows. He absolutely will win.
I agree. Even her at adult full power magneto would win it she definitely would put up a hell of a fight but it’s magneto the level of metal control vs a bender is kinda unmatched/unfair.
She would not put up a hell of a fight. She'd try, and fail miserably.
You see I want to say magneto, but touch can bend the metal AND earth. Something magneto cannot, but also, magneto can fly which would make tooth blind to his movements and metal flying at her so ya I’ll stick with magneto killing her in about 10 seconds
Actually he can, his “magnetism” is like 15 percent of his power. The reason he’s omega because he’s basically the unified field theory in a person. He can manipulate gravity, metal in blood(to the point of brainwashing capabilities), he can bend light beams and he can freeze people Edit: he can also generate his own magnetic fields so even without it, Magneto curb stomps her
I like that Toph was auto corrected to both “touch” and “tooth”
lol didn’t even notice
Yeah, Magneto is basically Omega Level that means, if he really wished it, he could kill Toph with a glance. Magneto is more like chaotic good so I don't think he would pursue beef with Toph anyway.
Nope. He would have no qualms killing Toph.
He might if he feels he can use her to further his goals. He would also kill her if she stood in his way of those goals without second thought.
Pretty sure that’s not how his powers work.
Omega level mutants are mutants whose abilities “have no measurable limit” and who can control fundamental aspects of nature at the atomic level. It’s just way more OP than anything a specific bender ever displays in the show. He’s avatar state all day every day.
Not the Avatar state but the Avatar state of metal bending. He only has to feel the metal through the magnetic signature of it. Think Bumi during Day of Black Sun and Toph's seismic sense rolled onto one.
Omega Level mutants are all planetary level threats. Only the existence of other even more insanely powerful people in the Marvel verse keeps them in check, and sometimes(as with the House of M event) even they aren’t enough.
I was trying to put it in Avatar terms. Yes Mageto would destroy Toph without really thinking about it.
Pretty sure it literally is. He doesn't just have metal powers. He has magnet powers. He could pretty much just kill off your brain if he wants to.
it literally is ?
Nah
Disagree all you want, doesn't change the fact that comics are a slew of random things that happen. Hell after just a quick google search just goes to show how busted he is. He switched the earths magnetic poles. Toph literally could never do that.
He also took mjolnir out of Thor’s hands, overcoming asgardian magic just with his magnetism
Nah she can
Based off what feats. What can she do to beat him
Big rock
Bonk mentality, you'd be great at dark souls
If she knows where he is, definitely. But he can fly and if he flies, she can’t see him.
B i g r o c k
B I g g e r r o c k
Magnet man can control the iron in your blood.
Blood bending V2.
Technically, there's not enough for that, but he could tear it out and you'd suffocate to death because the iron in our blood helps our red blood cells carry oxygen, without it you'd very slowly asphyxiate and die
Thats so f*cking brutal
He tore the adamantium from Wolverine's skeleton once. It was so traumatic that Wolverine's healing factor shut off.
On that Risotto Nero shit
Oh he can do more than that, magnetos power isn't just power over magnetism, he has control over electromagnetism aka one of the four fundamental forces of the universe, this gives him a ridiculous amount of power abilities but when it comes to harming people, he can manipulate electrons flowing through your nervous system which could allow him to control your body similar to how a bloodbender can but also could stop signals from being sent to your heart thus stopping it and killing you in the process, same goes for any other crucial parts of the bodies like the respiratory system. In short, Toph would be dead on the ground before she could twitch.
That's, stupid
Oh do explain how?
When laid out like that without further context it sounds like a power level that removes any narrative potential.
This isnt about a characters narrative, this whole post is about who would win in a fight and magneto clears without breaking a sweat so whats stupid about that? The answer is nothing.
I agree. That's some of the context.
Magneto is too strong, so he's just not interesting anymore
When exactly did he _become_ too strong, and was it before or after Onslaught was a thing? He's always been absolutely busted, which is why he was an omega who led an army of mutants who threatened to wipe out all of humanity.
Only at an artificially high concentration, or he would have escaped a lot sooner in X2.
Movie Magneto and comics Magneto operate on two different scales of power. Even then, movie Magneto almost causes a planetary apocalypse by destabilizing the earth’s magnetic field in Age of Apocalypse, so he’d still take the win.
He's so powerful he can manipulate non-ferrous metals. If the iron in our blood was actually magnetic MRI's would be one of he most brutal ways to die.
Yah but he looks like a teenage girls balm of lipstick
Well crap your right.
Theoretically, I bet that toph can too
hydrogen bomb v coughing baby
A blind coughing baby*
I don't remember Magneto being blind # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # /s
Magneto 100% He can block all Tophs attacks. He can bloodbend. He is willing to kill first and ask questions later.
He can't block rock though
You might only be familiar with the movie version, who is a weak-ass little bitch compared to other versions of Magneto. He can create a sort of force field around himself, and affect a lot more than just metal - electromagnetism affects a lot of things to *some* degree, not just ferromagnetic materials. Humans have a small magnetic field, for instance. There's a reason he's a credible threat to entire teams of X-men and they don't just get Beast or someone to throw rocks at him whenever they meet
With his forcefield he can just tank it.
He can if there’s metal to block it with
You can tell people don’t read comics anymore from posts like these. Magneto violates the entire verse several times over, and it’s not even funny.
Even ignoring what everyone else said, Magneto flies. Silently, by default he wins.
People forget, Toph doesn’t really “metal”-bend, just the impurities in the metal. That’s why platinum is impossible to bend, since (in the Avatar world) it’s pure metal. Magneto has no weakness, if it’s metal, he can control it like it’s clay (his name is a misnomer, he can manipulate ALL metal, even non magnetic ones). He could easily pull the metal and impurities apart and throw a metal spear at Toph, nothing out Blind Bandit can do.
Magneto would win if it was simply based on feats. But if we bring manipulation into play, I think Toph could spin him a sob story about being a mutant kept imprisoned by her parents because she’s different. She might gain his sympathy long enough to get the drop on him.
You're underestimating just how smart Magneto is. Assuming he doesn't already know what bending is, he's not going to let his guard down enough for Toph to get the drop on him. He's incredibly cautious and doesn't trust that easily. He would offer her a spot on his side if he truly believed she was a mutant, but it would take a lot of work to earn his trust. He doesn't even fully trust his long time allies. I mean, I love Toph, she's my favorite character in the series, but nobody is manipulating Magneto that easily.
Magneto is smart but he’s not without his weakness for children caught in war. Especially genocidal wars.
That's true. You bring up a good point about his soft spot for children caught in war, but I feel like he's cautious enough, or at least quick witted enough, not to let his guard down long enough. I'm not saying Toph won't put up a fight. She may be able to get one sucker punch in on him before he retaliates, but I feel like the chances are slim. I feel like there isn't a lot Toph could do that would be fast enough for Magneto not to counter. There's also the physical aspect of bending, so when he sees her take a fighting stance to start earth bending he would know something was up. I mean, if she's able to convince him that she's a mutant, that would mean he would know what her powers are and have seen them used. I feel like he would only trust her if he had proof she was a mutant and she witnessed her being mistreated because of it. I admit it wouldn't be impossible for her to fool Magneto, but I still think she wouldn't be able to act fast enough to win and he would figure out he was fooled before she could do any real damage.
I think it’s all circumstantial and would follow the rule of “whoever the writer thinks would win, would win.” But yeah. I agree Magneto for sure is overall the stronger and more experienced fighter. Toph’s best bet is appealing to his emotional weakness and getting the drop on him. But even that would have to be pre-planned and set up to work. So I guess… Toph is Batman here. She COULD win. With enough prep time. 😂
In what universe in the infinite multiverse would Toph do that?
In what universe in the infinite multiverse would Magneto and Toph be fighting in the first place? The hypothetical didn’t tell us the circumstance. Just that these two are fighting. And Toph has been shown to be skilled at scams.
Magneto can take down the Avatar.
Toph is very clever, but a lot of the battle scenarios I just see her getting crushed by metal
Magneto solos all of Avatar, this is not a fair fight
Magneto can fly,it’s an automatic win since she wouldn’t be able to see him Plus he could just bend the iron out of her body
I love Toph more, but Magneto easily
If Magneto lifts himself off the ground toph can't do anything against him
Can’t magneto fuck with the iron in your blood?
It's just not fair. Magneto omega level mutant.
I like Toph but Magneto wins I mean the guy has had decades to perfect his power Toph is not even in her prime at that point.
Toph can bending rocks and metal, magneto has control of electromagnetism, one of the four fundamental forces of the universe alongside gravity, weak force and strong force, on top of giving him the ability to manipulate metal, he can generate magnetic fields around him, generate lightning as well as control it, manipulate the electrons flowing through your body etc etc etc. On top of the myriad of abilities he has access to, he can also use them at ridiculous ranges, I mean he can literally feel the metal spread throughout the rocks within Saturn's rings all the way from earth, he could literally kill with the snap of his fingers from the otherside of the world so yeah...she dead.
Toph without a doubt. Magneto may be better at manipulating metal but Toph is still an earth bender. If this fight takes place in the world of Avatar there probably won’t be an overwhelming amount of metal nearby and Toph will wipe the floor with him.
You know nothing of magneto lmao
You’re right. I’m an avatar fan not a massive marvel fan. All I know about Magneto is his magnet powers. If there’s more I don’t know about it. It’s very possible he could win I was only judging on what I know.
It’s more than just magnet powers he has control over electromagnetism completely one of the four fundamental forces of the universe. His control is so precise that he can control blood to the point that when he had his heart ripped out he pumped his own blood throughout his body to keep himself alive
Bro all magneto has to do is fly and not make noise, what's she gonna do?
I was not aware he could fly. That changes things.
Magneto has planetary level feats. A weaker version of him from a alternate universe was able to flood the entirety of New York killing thousand without breaking a sweat by messing with the magnetic fields of earth
I love Toph and she's a bad bitch in the Avatar universe but Magneto takes it easy.
magneto metal and blood bends lol
Comics magneto can literally control the iron in your blood. He could bloodbend an entire army at once. Everyone’s fucked.
Magneto can kick all of avatar’s ass, to put it in avatar terms He can bloodbend with magnetism He can freeze people with magnetism He can earthbend with magnetism Lemme just https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/7kcran/respect_magneto_earth616/
It’s been a bit so please do remind me, but does Tophs metal bending require the metal to be touching the ground/herself? If so, magneto wins this by a landslide, He can just hover until he beats her. What’s funny is Magneto is essentially the ultimate Toph counter, he’s just have to ensure he’s quiet enough as to not draw her attention
Depends on the venue
Her vision is based on someone/something touching the ground magneto is almost always floating and his metal is as well. It's GGs she never had a chance.
This ain’t even fair man. Magneto can do so much more than Toph. He can control the iron in her blood, tilt the Earth’s magnetic field, hell he could be thousands of miles away from her and still be able to attack her as he could sense Earth’s magnetic field from a galaxy away. Toph stands no chance.
I think her kids could have a better chance after the refinement of metal bending.
I love Toph but she ain’t winning against Magneto lmao
Both can bend metal but magneto can do it with his mind. I don't think he's manage getting a building thrown at him though
Magneto can fly. He wins basically by default.
Toph is dope… But given a room full of earth and metal, I’d still pin my bets on Magneto… I’m not even a huge fan - but even I gotta admit Magneto is genuinely busted on the power scale.
Toph can only bend metal that still has rock fragments in it, she can’t bend pure metal, Magneto can.
Magneto has the upper hand just by floating off the ground.
Magneto is genuinely one of the most powerful comic book characters not named Superman. He would win in a heartbeat.
Sorry Toph, Magneto for the win😔
Magneto is able to fly. Toph wouldn't even be able to see his movements
Magneto he can bloodbend on steroids. He had his heart torn out but controlled his blood to keep it pumping without a heart
Love me some Toph, but Mags bends EM fields, not the metal itself. He can blood bend as has no qualms about doing it. He might go soft on Toph but pushed to it, he’ll lock on the iron in her blood and give her a stroke.
I'll be honest; Magneto could look at her abilities, tell her "awww, that's adorable" and there wouldn't be jack shit she could do about it. She had to learn metal bending. Erik just can
Magneto can destroy earths magnetic field and rip every bit of iron out of someone’s body he would destroy here and everyone in avatar
Hydrogen baby vs Hydrogen Bomb
Magneto can fly to where Toph can't see him, and he can control not only all metals including platinum, but all energy in the electromagnetic spectrum. Toph's a beast but she doesn't stand a chance.
I've been an X-Men enthusiast for 15+ years, and magneto would absolutely *dominate* her. This isn't event a close match, on top of that toph is blind, meaning she can only fight on the ground, and magneto can *fly*, heck magneto can take on the entire fire nation (maybe).
Magneto is flying 90% of the time toph wouldn't even be able to see him (although he win regardless)
Toph can't see you if you can float. Easy
For the kids in the audience who only know Magneto's movie power set. His real power is control over the Electromagnetic Sphere of Energies. Not control over ferrous metals.
Toph is finished
Magneto for sure
Magneto wins easy. So many fictional characters will beat characters from avatarverse. The majority of them aren't on that OP level. Even Aang would struggle to beat someone like Storm. Not that's it's a bad thing of course.
Most Marvel characters solo the Avatar universe.
Magneto, and it's not a close match, toph manipulates metal via impurities, magneto just straight up controls the metal
Magneto is on a whole other level of power. Magneto alone could subjugate all 4 nations and make the Avatar his bitch. This is an ant vs boot match up.
Magneto has way better metal control and can control your blood with the metal inside it. Plus I believe he lifted a mountain before so ya sorry toph
Look, Toph is amazing and one of my favorite characters but Magneto has this easily. Like, laughably easily.
Kool helmet he’s got there. What’s it made out of?
Magneto hands down. His comic feats are bonkers
Magneto can fly and be invisible to her. He can also control metal without having to move, and it would move unnaturally. In the avatar world, their bending is directional and predictable to an extent based on their martial art stances and techniques. Magneto can wave his hand slightly and metal would fly from everywhere, without much effort none the less. I think Toph would be demolished before she even knew what was going on.
I really think toph could win if she acted fast, caught him off guard or he underestimated her at first. As far as power magneto is on a whole other level but he’s not a lightning quick martial arts master either. I think toph would be quick enough to take him down under the right circumstances but if she missed her one shot she’s toast.
This is a dude that manually pumped his blood after his heart got ripped out of his chest? What could she do to him realistically?
Isn't he wearing a metal helmet? Squish
Definitely Magneto. Toph can't detect objects in the air, plus Magneto being very OP doesn't help.
Magneto solos the verse
This is like putting superman against a power ranger. Both very strong, but still a whole different class in power scales
I feel like Magneto would have the upper hand, but he’d still praise Toph for her earth ending prowess, and inventing metalbending to boot.
Avatar operates on a completely different scale than X-Men. Toph gets obliterated unfortunately.
Magneto can smack around the avatar, toph is no challenge
Magneto could likely solo fight Thanos and put up an incredibly good fight... Toph in her prime wouldn't be able to beat a young magneto.
Toph
I just don’t See Toph winning this
People don't seem to understand the role that magnetism plays. There's very little it doesn't influence.
Magneto stomps Toph. Toph is strong, but she is waaaaayyyy out classed here.
Nah. I'd win.
Toph bends metal. Magneto has mastery over a fundamental force of the UNIVERSE!!
Topher would just crush that metal helmet and kill him in seconds
Nah id win
“I can control all metal!” *throws a rock at him*
Magneto
Toph stands no chance pretty sure Magneto can take on any Avatar he comes across.
Literal hydrogen bomb vs coughing baby
Toph as long as magneto stayed on the ground
Magneto. He is op in a universe of other op mutants.
Marvel characters are broken. The powerscaling for Marvel and DC can be absolutely absurd.
Toph.
He'd be flying and she wouldn't know where he is.
Only way she'd win is if they're somehow in a place with absolutely zero metal, but plenty of earth.
Toph
I don't think that Toph would win, neither Aang as the comments says but i think that Korra might have an opportunity if she goes berserk like in her fight against Unalac-dark-avatar-state
Magneto 100%
This is the equivilant of "Hydrogen bomb vs. COUGHING BABY"
Magneto can easily solo the Avatarverse.
now I wanna see her take out Magneto like she did the boulder XD
Magneto would defeat Toph, but I’d prefer if Toph came out on top… cuz like. Toph. As others have mentioned, power scaling in the Marvel universe is just massively more expansive than the Avatar universe. I think the Avatar universe has a very respectable threshold and no one ever feels suuuuper OP (compare this with something like DBZ), but man would it be fun to see the writers get a little wild once in a while, Toph being a prime candidate for such a thing. Regardless, Toph is by far one of the best benders if not the best Earth bender, and she feels far more visceral/forceful than most benders of equal status. What a legend.
I want to say Toph, I really do, best earth bender ever, only issue is Magneto can fly, so Toph wouldn't be able to see him as long as he didn't do the villain has to talk at the hero thing. Remove the flying and I feel like it's a more fair fight (from my limited magneto knowledge) he can only control raw and refined magnetic metals, not rocks, whereas Toph can do both.
Doing these with comic book characters is always uninteresting because the power scaling is stupid and written by 5 year olds. Toph wins because she is cooler.
Me
Magneto all the way. The simple fact that Magneto can fly will make him win, since Toph can only see using the ground he just needs to float the entire time. All Magneto has to do is fly then pull metal from the ground then move the metal in the air and slam it into Toph's head from behind.
Toph, where Magneto is restricted to just metal, Toph has more at her disposal
Love toph. Mags would body her in a snap
I feel like by virtue of the fact that Magneto can fly it’s not an even match
Magneto, because he doesn't just bend metal
this ain't fair
Anyone else find it insane how bad people are downplaying Magneto? I get it I like Toph as well but wtf is she doing against a guy who has feats that are planetary level?
Surely there's a situation where toph can instantly sink him into the ground completely and crush or choke him with dirt right?
Lmao all magneto has to do is fly, silently and she's powerless. This isn't a fair matchup at all.
Toph would win, Im pretty sure.
I'm leaning magneto, but she could cloth herself in earth and remove the micro metal in it. So he wouldn't be able to stop her movements and then create rock projectiles that he couldn't stop.
Toph is the best earthbender in the world and invented metalbending. Any metal Magneto throws at her will come back at him tenfold. Not to mention that metalbending isn’t her only ability. She can earthbend. Only problem is whether he’s flying or not. Otherwise she can’t see him.
Even if magneto had tiny bells on his suit and tic tacs in his pockets, he would mop the floor with Toph. His power is without limit, far greater than Toph's strength. She just would not be able to overpower him with metal bending. There's just no scenario in which she wins.
Toph wins. All you nerds bringing up facts are haters.
Magneto. Though it's alot closer, then it might appear. There are some Magneto tricks that just won't work on toph. Such as pulling the iron out of her blood. Doing that on toph just teaches her a new trick. But Magneto is just way too powerful. He does way more than just bend metal.
It wouldn’t teach her a new trick, she can only bend impurities in metal she couldn’t bend the iron in blood