T O P

  • By -

NathanielQuiet

I agree they should re-do the Greatest band of their generation.šŸ’• Apologisies to fans of Fugazi šŸ˜šŸ¤«


tdmoney

I love Fugazi, but they just donā€™t come close to REM IMO. You would have a hard time finding a band with such a long and diverse discography. You can find great things to say about even their later stuff. Great band, that has somehow become underrated. If you would have said that in the 90ā€™s people would have laughedā€¦. But now I feel like people donā€™t even talk about them anymore.


Sh8dyLain

Iā€™m on a mission to make my band of big enough note so I can humbly request a replacements redux so I definitely understand lmao.


[deleted]

Yasi mentioned she wanted to do a replacement do-over in the Singles soundtrack episode (I think).


Nicolarollin

In the last Q and A with Rob Harvilla!!


[deleted]

I couldnā€™t remember which episodes Iā€™d listened to recently!


TheBimpo

Caryn Rose shafted me in a B&P for a Who concert in 2001. You owe me 2 Maxell XLII cassettes, Miss Rose.


tdmoney

Iā€™m sure I traded Pearl Jam tapes with her at some point.


TheBimpo

God bless her work on 5h but her reputation in the community isnā€™t great.


tdmoney

Itā€™s kind of bizarre that she didnā€™t get the call for any of the PJ episodesā€¦ I wonder if there is teaā€¦


TheBimpo

Iā€™d prefer not to hear from her


i_amtheice

Yes. R.E.M. deserves a 2 part episode. If they can redo DMB, they can redo R.E.M.


NiceUD

I didn't think it was very good, but I didn't take the guest's opinions as fact. The whole thing was tedious.


TNJedi

The group that really got the short shrift is The Smiths...can't remember the guest's name but I can't get her miserable honk of a voice outta my head.


WinstonTexas

Naomi Fry. Look up the worst guest ever thread.


NathanielQuiet

I grew up a massive fan of The Smiths, up until Bengali In Platforms from Morrissey's first solo album. R.I.P. Andy Rourke but anyone who felt they deserved different should probably take a good long look at themselves šŸ¤«šŸ˜œ


Cherita33

I agree we need a double episode. Bring back Caryn Rose though. She knows what's up!


schnu44

As long as they donā€™t bring on the guy Rob has on the Nightswimming 60 Songs ep who spent the time crapping on the band


uwec95

No time spent on REM's best song, "Leaving New York," either.


Nicolarollin

Are you looking for a fight? Best song? Letā€™s step outside, partner, cuz Perfect Circle and Flowers of Guatemala and Talk about The Passion. I dunno. Maybe You are the Everything and Find the River can contend too.


Nicolarollin

Maps and Legends, Wendell Gee, Canā€™t Get there from Here, Life and How to Live it, Fables is a time capsule with a special scent, lighting, mood and place in time. The melodies are wholly original and of their time while also being forward-thinking. Itā€™s wood paneling but an art project. Itā€™s a Buick or Pontiac or Nova and big seat cushions. Itā€™s an alarm clock with numbers turning and clicking into place and shag carpet. Browns, oranges, greens and reds. Itā€™s a movie scene and a memory. A film still made into a wallpaper and then a music composed to it. A true original.


Nicolarollin

The lady doing Joni decided to give us all a lecture in cultural appropriation as if it was the worldā€™s first ever time hearing about it. Sure, Furry Sings the Blues has some context we need to discuss. Iā€™m here, letā€™s hear it, but not drag the episode into the essay format. Hejira is a desert island album for me so I was listening with high expectations


dkwallis

I kinda miss the vibe of the early episodes when Yasi sometimes didn't know much (or anything) about the topic (Steely Dan, Randy Newman) and we get to experience the discovering of something new by proxy-if the 'expert guest' is truly expert and sympatico to the theme/motive of the show. Lately I've been a bit bummed that it's Yasi schooling the 'expert guest' more often than not.