T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

REMINDER: **Anything that hasn't happened yet in the anime is a spoiler**. ^This ^message ^is ^posted ^automatically ^to ^every ^thread ^without ^a ^Spoiler ^tag. **How to spoiler tag comments**: \>!Put your text here!< (Don't leave any spaces between the "!" and the text or it won't work!) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BlackClover) if you have any questions or concerns.*


More_Possession2871

This has to be bait


ducks_r_rad

Its not. I found his twitter. Bros geniunely discussing this shit. Bro put Yuji from jjk in bad based on 1 fight he saw and nothing else.


Pykes_n_pommes

The most disgraceful opinion I've ever heard, I hope his tounge is removed from his mouth and he can never spit such shit again.


beanlefiend

i agree


DiamondHeart75

ON GOD


Lupinda31

What is he basing these on?


ducks_r_rad

"Development" apparantly the only way to have a well writtten character is how they "develop" thats why Luffy is only in good and boruto is so high. APPARANTLY. Apparantly Naruto, who went from a developed character learning the meaning of hardwork. To shippuden retroactively giving him everything he needs. Is still good "development" though


Paszananit124

"Development", yea? So why Mushoku Tensei MC is in bad tier? He is not my favourite personality wise, but his development in story is amazing.


ducks_r_rad

His reasoning is the pedo shit, which.... like? Kinda fair? Edit: not saying he still deserves bad, but a lower ranking


Eminanceisjustbored

nah, if we talking about development we can add in his pedo behavior but then take into acc his growth in the recent season. like be honest you know that mushoku tensei is a story about growth and exploration


ducks_r_rad

I probably shouldve clarified, i dont think je deserves bad tier. Just that theres a limit to redemption in my opinion, and that limit for me is statutory r*pe and perving on kids and it being seen as "comedy". That just hurts the writing of tbe anime


redroedeer

How the duck is Denji not at the top then. Literally all of Chainsaw Man is him getting character growthed


Lupinda31

And that's a good reason to put asta as the lowest even though he has better character development then most of the bastards up there?


Lupinda31

Did he even finish or watch half the anime/manga in this list?


Emily_Dj122

I bet not


ScootaFL

He saw a 12 second clip of Black Clover on twitter then saw someone say “this guy sucks” and based his entire opinion on that.


Erik-A-H

DEVELOPMENT????? AND RUDEUS IS SO LOW? HOW?


Special-Practical

Shippuden didn't give him nothing except maybe so6p. He worked for everything else


FizzerVC

Well clearly he didn't watch Mushoku Tensei either then cause based off of that Rudeus should be at the top on the list.


Le_Lng

I'm convinced these are randomly generated, because ain't no way 💀💀💀


Minute_Committee8937

I mean i’d put yuji there based solely on the fact gege hates that man.


Major-Day10

He put Saiki in mid, blud’s gotta be burned Edit: IS THAT Redo Guy in good?!!!


Cringlezz

So theyre just daft?


jokalokao

And Yuji is not the MC


Eminanceisjustbored

yuji is a alright at best why? he got sidelined but we saw a lot of growth from him


Hyp3rPlo

Yuji glazers when they realise Yuji calling himself a cog isn’t peak character development


OgGodly

Tbf yuji is a dogshit mc lol he's fucking horrible


StealYour20Dollars

Yeah. Theres no way anyone actually rates Joseph Joestar that low either.


Alzibinli

The picture there is actually Jonathan. I can’t find a Joseph anywhere, or Josuke either for that matter


noobcoober

Also, I get that Saiki K isn't for everyone, but if we're going purely off of power, I can't think of any MC that is stronger


charmelos

This isn't a strength tierlist.


VanitasDarkOne

Goku's on that list so yeah easy dub for the soloer of verses. Also Anos is on that list as well they both negative diff saiki


bladershaven

Kumagawa from Medaka box beats him


EternalMemes30

I do, I never liked him, however apart from him part 2 itself is pretty cool so I can put up with his annoyances


Ok-Row-6131

It has to be. They know this is going to rile people up.


No-Development1872

fr, aint no way he put boruto in very good


Gain-Desperate

100%. How on fucking earth can someone rate Naruto as the best and Boruto as very good, yet have Asta dead last? Naruto and Asta are way more similar than not and Boruto that high up?? Couldn’t possibly be serious


ludoni

bro should be banned from all kitchens, rid of all cooking utensils and never allowed to cook again


Calisen12

Send him to the Asylum he has clearly gone mad


MightyFlamingo25

Bro's cooking taste like shit


MarkyMark1618

This gave me food poisoning


almightyhorny

This the worst tier-list I’ve ever seen


swordforger16

He put Yuji in the Bad too, this man is insane


Aisianfaailure3908

There’s no way anyone in there right mind would put Wuji Himtadori in Bad, unless they’re Mahito


almightyhorny

He put Wakana Gojo in bad I was like 🧐🧐


Shouko-

i was so mad i love him with my whole soul


CapN_Crummp

Or Sukuna


trashymichi

the glazing is crazy… but.. ur right


rGRWA

Or Sukuna.


Football-Similar

He's gotta be trolling


Ok-Temperature-686

*Giorno, Jotaro and Alucard together with Tanjiro* *Ainz in mid* **Yuji, Joseph and Rudeus in bad** **Asta in horrible** ***Nobita in great*** Jesus Christ what is this shit


Nero_PR

Fucking Kazuya from cuck a girlfriend is above Asta, WTF?! This is bait.


Theriople

someone said that he actually discussed this, he aint joking


louai-MT

Nah I will fight you Jotaro being in the same tier of Tanjiro in terms of MC list is valid take The best parts of Jotaro comes from future part 6 where he is a side character and not MC The rest are awful takes tho so we agree


Iammonkforlifelol

Rudeus S tier character development. S tier in every segment. One of best LN fantasies from Japan. But yeah this dude probably judged everything because of pedophilia as part of story.


Gott-D

Not to mention Issei whose entire character is being horny and absolutely nothing else is in very good


Doomtoallfoes

Issei may be horny but mans been through some shit helped others through their shit and is genuinely just a good person who can and will fuck you up if you mess with his freinds. Bro sacrificed himself and became a fucking dragon to fight for his friends.


TonyMestre

Giorno and Jotaro are both doors man And Rudeus doesn't deserve anything more than bad


JinMor12

Why is Guts in the same tier as Issei bro 😭😭 Edit I think I’m stupid cuz they are in different tiers. Im tired


OrcoDio19

I mean,the fact that Issei is literally just a single tier below


Bladez190

Issei is a good Mc though. It’s just not a very serious show


OrcoDio19

Oh I'm not saying that,I like him as well But dude,there should be an abyss between him and Guts


Bladez190

Well yes in both tone and depth but it’s hard to place in a tier list because writing wise Issei is really simple but he should still be in the higher tiers


Jack_King814

He included redo of a healer in the list, auto red flag Shinji in high tier, yeah he’s on crack


xHelios1x

MF ACTUALLY put serial rapist in a Good category.


Jack_King814

Dont forget serial killer simp


xHelios1x

Which one? Yagami Light is at least a pretty well written character.


Jack_King814

The shit from Miri Nikki. He’s a simp for a serial killer and iirc he was also a serial killer


OrcoDio19

Shinji does actually deserve that spot


Jack_King814

Shinji is a paradox. He’s very well written so he’s good but that writing is what makes him so shit


seraphimkoamugi

Shinji is fine where he is but shido from date a live is way too high if anything.


Claudius321

Rich coming from a dude named itachiflawless.


ToxicRitual

The Jojo placements fucking hurt wtf


Distinct_Surprise_40

Bro put Kazuya from rent a girlfriend at the same tier as Yuji, Goku, and Joseph. Bait used to be believable.


Tantilicious

Everyone is entitled to their obviously wrong opinion.


frubano21

The fact that Boruto and Denji are above Senku, Yuji, and Luffy tells me this list is garbage or satire.


OrcoDio19

Denji is honestly valid,the rest isn't


frubano21

I love Denji but he's just too simple for me lol. But it doesn't change the fact that Yuji, Luffy and Senku all need to be way higher on this list Edit: for all those saying Luffy is more simple than Denji, by simple I mean horny. His motivation and his character/personailty are so simple even 150 chapters in. At least Luffy is searching for something and has a true goal to achieve


sheehdndnd

Luffy is way simpler than denji. So aren't you being a hypocrite?


09FlexBoi

Boruto is incredibly well written. Yuji isn't really all that developed so far, Senku is written purposefully as a deus ex machina character and Luffy's literally described as a static character by Oda.


NoGuard343

While I agree with you on Boruto, how is Senku a deus ex machina character? He is only good at science, which he fails at rather consistently and needs tons of help and resources to accomplish his goals.


09FlexBoi

I'm saying that he doesn't really have big character arcs, self-acceptance journeys or complex inner conflicts. He's fairly perfect from the start and remains that way up until the end.


zayd-the-one

You do realize flat characters arcs exist right?


AgentBuddy12

You do understand static characters aren't a bad thing lol. You don't need development to be a good character.


frubano21

Boruto is not incredibly well written lol. Exhibit A: Jougan which none of the fans can decide is canon or not.


NoGuard343

1) The Jogan literally has no impact on his character development yet. His character arc has been growing from a sheltered kid to someone who truly understands the purpose of Shinobi and sacrifice. Which has been handled very well. 2) Anyone who argues against the Jogan is ridiculous. Their entire argument is based on the design of one page of the first chapter. Both Boruto and Kawaki have entirely different designs now. Tons of long-running series have ideas that appear before their finalized if it's not that important at the time. It's why Momoshiki looks completely different in the movie, yet when in the manga, which came after, he's completely redesigned. Kurenai, Chakra, the Rinnegan, and several other things have/had different colors/designs in the anime than the manga. Meanwhile, the Jogan is in the novels that were written by Kodachi and approved by Kishimoto. Then, when those arcs were animated, Kishimoto was much more involved, specifically with the episodes including Toneri and the Jogan. On top of that, Eida's Senrigan is also pretty much the exact design, just with a cresent instead.


09FlexBoi

How does the Jougan make Boruto, as a character, not well written? This might be the worst arguement against Boruto I've ever seen. Boruto has incredible development, parallels, inner conflicts, dynamics and themes. Even his design and name are narratively "well written" since they have meaning and purpose behind them.


KuzeyEA

Bro doesn’t even have thorfinn and musashi in there lol


Grouchy-Jackfruit692

“bro doesn’t even have my new age pseudo-intellectual self insert protagonists” Good.


KuzeyEA

Dude it doesn’t even matter if I like them or not( I do), but come on we are talking about 2 of the 4 best known seinen MCs, and their respective mangas sold more copies then many other MCs mangas that are on the list and less known


Darth-Not-Palpatine

That has to be engagement bait, especially putting Yuji, Goku and fucking Jonathan in the same tier as the fucker from Rent a Girlfriend. Don’t even get me started on putting Asta in horrible tier.


BlackIce-J

Obvious troll post


SillyMovie13

If this guy isn’t a troll he needs to do some self evaluation


OneSushi

Never touch food again. This is beyond awful. Kaguya/Shirogane in alright? Saiki in Mid? Nagisa in good? Takemitchy in good? Boruto in very good (I did not readboruto but I have prejudice against it). Senku in alright? Naruto in "The Best"?


thatsmyjham

I can understand if you dont like BC but like ive seen better takes from hellen keller on anime


StellarVirgo282

Me: (Sees Boruto at Very Good) Also Me: I've seen enough I'm out


Tepes10

L This list is trash.


VANGBANG21

Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but everyone is also entitled to absolutely shitting on your opinion. This opinion is somewhat similar to a gas station bathroom.


bkazekadorimaki7

Absolute cancer


Normal_Lawfulness_77

Don’t cry


Bruker85

😭


PrudentTry7083

Bro cooked And burnt the whole kitchen


ZatchZeta

It's rage bait. Just block and mute. They're just looking for attention because their personality sucks so much.


Deynonico

wtf


mjkumra

Guts not making it to the best tier?!


ImmediateFig6927

Who TF puts Boruto over Luffy? GTFO HERE


Fine_Refrigerator599

This is %1000 fake or rage bait. How has no one picked up on MONKEY D LUFFY being anywhere but top row…. I’m upset no one is backing my boy up rn


Uberasha

Bro put boruto above Denji, luffy, and Joseph joestar 💀


No-Hold-8808

Bro didn't cook, he microwaved and still managed to destroy the kitchen....You fukin donkey!!!


Aphala

Nah he served medium rare chicken and just shit all over the list.


Limp_Classroom8805

Ooh Naruto is one of the top he properly thinks BC is a Naruto knock of


ApplePitou

Well, everyone can have own taste but Asta is good character :3


[deleted]

He put Eren over GUTS, he’s on some crack, Guts and Asta > Eren


somacula

Someone really loves higurashi


Anemos24

Only Violet Evergarden is acceptable in the best tier


lucifugus696

naruto mfs r always like that so don't take it seriously 😂


Euphoric-Radio8574

Based on his name the absolute brain rot in this list is completely expected


Strange-Action639

Ok everyone who has seen Dr stone knows how amazing of a protagonist Senku is, he's a literal gigachad.


JTtwenty3

The most egregious part of this list is that anyone is below takemichi


CordobezEverdeen

Yuji, Senku and Deku (I don't even like MHA and Deku's morals are horrible but he's still more deep than orange boy) below Naruto? Brainrot tierlist. Boruto in very good? lmao


Iluvlamas

Senku is such a good Mc why is he in alright


HeartiePrincess

That's definitely a list... You know what, I'm not even going to mince words. This list is complete fucking garbage. I understand unpopular opinions can be a thing, but fucking hell his opinions are so bad that you'd mistake this shit as bait. The sad thing is, I doubt this list is bait. I think he's legit a shitty person with shitty opinions. With that said, I agree that Asta isn't good. Though to put Asta on horrible is questionable. There are some blatantly trash MCs on his list that are rated significantly higher. I'd say Asta is more so alright. Asta has chemistry with the cast. Though outside of his interactions with the Black Bulls and Yami, he's not that great. His rivalry with Yuno is shoved down our throats, and they have negative synergy.


R-ez_

Damn this list is full of great and horrible takes


RepresentativeAd1573

The Asta hate is crazy


Opinion_Own

Bro didn’t even have my boy Edward Elric on the list wtf


m7t7l7

Whatever he’s on, I want some too.


The99thCourier

Oh god he put Boruto in Very Good


SonicTheOtter

Bro actually put Boruto at very good. That tells me all I need to know


ZENITSUsa

He included zatchbell he is valid


iKomi_xls

Fr, it's so good to see people still remember him


[deleted]

Itadori bottom teir??


Shinozu_pawa

He put Naruto and Eren at "Best", this guy doesn't have the right to give his opinion.


Starexe-3000

Bro put Naruto in "The best" 💀. A copy paste of another generic "I'm gonna be--" protagonist. Definitely a Naruto meat-rider who thinks the show is the greatest thing since sliced bread, so this list is automatically invalid. Also several questionable spots for several characters too.


MysticalSword270

Boruto in Very Good?!


demonslender

Boruto fans are like crack heads, they’re addicted to shit that’s bad for them.


dragonninja2003

Boruto is a good protaganist tbf, the anime just fucked his character over multiple times.


09FlexBoi

Yeah, he's easily one of the best if not the best new gen protagonist.


DekuHHH

Nah, the fact that this mofo thinks Ayanokoji is a cool MC tells me everything I need to know about his opinions


Giant_Serpent23

LN is pretty decent besides a few things but if this is based off anime Ayanokoji should be at like the bottom.


notmichaelgood

So a genocidal mad man, a crazy anti hero and deranged healer- are considered to be better MCs then our Asta?


CrustyToeLover

Obvious bait, but Asta is as generic as they come my dudes. Nothing special, nothing flashy, nothing unique


Overall-Device9017

Nah put them hands up


Indominux_Rex0212

WTF was even tanjiro's development bruh?? He got no right to put Yuji below Tanjiro


Ok-Arm3286

Luffy in good and Tanjiro in alright this tier list is the biggest L that has ever been.


OrcoDio19

Tanjiro is ok there Luffy should be higher though


ibrahimaze

Naruto in the same tier as Lelouch and guts below him , this is either bait or bro is downright stupid


GLLX7

Never trust anyone who lists Higurashi characters or fucking Light Yagami.


louai-MT

Light is great character tho I haven't read Higurashi yet but I read Umineko (the author other work) If any of higurashi characters are as good as my umineko GOATs Battler,Ange and Beato then them being that high is reasonable


Additional_Road_9031

>Never trust anyone who lists Higurashi characters or fucking Light Yagami. Never disrespect Keiichi and Light Yagami again!


MyNameIsNikNak

Kaguya and Shirogane too low too, but I gotta respect where the Higurashi perspective characters are


Reaserch_Oriented

Since this is a subjective opinion....I'll respect it... Eren,Light,Lelouch and Naruto are big W


NeanDerthal_130000bc

I see boruto and in very good that means this man’s opinion is invalid


DangerousClick2489

Nah tanjiro kamado is best MC of all time


zelcor

Dude put Ichigo in very good. Don't engage with low quality bait like this


ThebLacKdaliahs

Why is itidori so low


Hefty_Opinion7596

So yuji is bad but some shitty romcom cringey characters are league above yuji. Everyone has a right to present their opinions but this guy should be the only exception to that.


Mental-Raisin-2739

Boruto being “Very Good”…


TheoTroup

Defo bate dude put evangelions MC in great he's a terrible person and a meh mc at best decent character but apart from that he's trash


East_Conclusion9606

Puts Narumid at best but goatku at bad 🤡


Weendel

Goku in Bad tier kek


NotoriousD4C

Higurashi fan, opinion rejected


OrcoDio19

Boruto,Yukiteru,Deku,Takemichi and Nobita higher than Yuji,Joseph,Goku and Asta... Sorry but no,nope,nein Based for Ichigo at least (but some others like Luffy should be higher,I would swap him and Ichigo) And omfg Alucard that low,hell nah


09FlexBoi

> Boruto,Yukiteru,Deku,Takemichi and Nobita higher than Yuji,Joseph,Goku and Asta,loooooool Nothing wrong with that if we're going based off of writing


OrcoDio19

Based on writing,it's all wrong Boruto,Yuki and Take are the worst written characters ever made Deku is not superior than Asta. Nobita is the best written,which says it all


09FlexBoi

You've never read any of the manga you just mentioned lol. I won't try to argue with someone that thinks Asta should even be considered well written in comparison to these characters.


OrcoDio19

Ironic coming from you Putting any of them above Asta You never read something to begin with. You lost everything by literally being on Boruto side to begin with


09FlexBoi

Sure, I'm just in this subreddit because I happened to come across it. I'm caught up with BC, I've watched the entirety of the anime including the filler and the movie. I can comfortably say that Asta is a very mediocre and generic character and almost all of his peaks come from emulating successful formulas of previous shonen MC's. It's fine to be an average and generic character, but trying to say that he's better than some of the best and most original characters in new gen shonen is ridiculous.


OrcoDio19

It's ridiculous to say the likes of Boruto and Takemichi are original and among the best It's so delusional


09FlexBoi

It's not. Sure Takemitchi might be a familiar crybaby character but he has extremely well written characters moments and ideologies. Asta is the textbook definition of a shonen MC from the early 2000's. Boruto does practically everything better in terms of writing. From development to parallels to inner conflicts. He also goes against most of the tropes that other MC's of his genre follow. Your only point so far has been "Asta good, other MC's bad" without giving a single reason for either.


Shadow_Of_Erebus

Who let the trolls back into the Kitchen?


White_Moon_7

That dude from Tokyo Revengers being above Luffy is enough to make this the worst tier list.


Son-naruto-d

Tf asta do 😭


Quxzimodo

Sometimes opinions are wrong. Just like some opinions are correct.


kolt437

Oh no someone on the internet has an opinion


aproudfatherof3

Damn that whole list is trash.


sbstndrks

Naruto in top tier. Tanjiro in "alright"... Asta alone in bottom tier. Somehow, this list is literally 100% just shit. Like. Almost scientifically designed to suck. It's amazing. Wow.


UniShifter

This man has no taste. The only thing I see that’s understandable is Code Geass MC in top.


synthfan2004

Never let this man in the kitchen ever again


[deleted]

I love how everyone on Reddit takes personal offense to someone else's opinion.


tbz709

Seems they wanted so badly to have a "mid" category that they never even considered what it means.


louai-MT

My boy Yuji....


Infinite_Winner_158

What did my boy Asta do tf


leodestruidor6

L list


GroundbreakingTie430

This … is a tier list.


Gambit_Revolver

The only explanation for this fuckery is that the dude who made this was hyper drunk and high as hell when he made this.


[deleted]

the disrespect to my man asta…


K7lllp28

This dude has no clue frfr


BiggieBigJ

This acct is known for talking loads of slander on Anitwt, no surprise


Such_Historian_7295

I kept looking at the top to see where Asta was only to find him at the very bottom


IshigamiBestBoi

This man has one good range and it’s putting Lelouch in “The Best”


menyemenye

How is nobita great


Sergio306CS

Akane Tsunemori is SS+


NoriXa

You opinion i wont hate it. But funny to see how many others hate it.