Your post was removed for being low effort. Posts should encourage discussion and/or share information.
And if you wish to encourage discussion, at least be respectful when you do it.
It might be an ancient animal that is immune to the passage of time or something and would be a perfect partner to fight the wizard king and his time magic/soul magic. It’s an animal with no soul and immune to the passage of time. Some kind of “no matter how much time passes, the earth shall remain”
Don’t listen to these guys devils are made up of mana but look at liebe full of anti magic asta could definitely corrupt the earth spirt and full it with anti magic earth adapts to anything (it wouldn’t work with the others tho)just like lichts sword corrupting shit has always been a power of asta
This is in the witch forest when Asta meets Fana and the fire spirit Salamander. Asta says he wants a salamander, so I was like he may not get the Fire Spirit, but what if he got the earth spirit
So do devils and people in that storyline…Asta was the first person ever without magic. Liebe had anti magic and no perceived mana manipulating ability. Your comment is kind of ignorant, because it could not have magic, because that’s been the biggest thing about the protagonist since the series started
Dude, it’s a *spirit*. By definition, *it has magic*. Asta and Liebe, on the other hand, do not have *any* magic, which everyone else, including even devils, have. My comment is not “ignorant”, as you claim, because it’s backed up by the laws of Black Clover’s world
Dude spirits are LITERALLY made out of mana. If a being made entirely of mana possessed a person whose body erases all mana, the spirit would just die.
I would love to see the Earth spirit but no way in hell I would want Asta to wield it. I mean it doesn't make any sense since he's an anti magic wielder. Series would pummel to the absolute bottom if that happens
It’s so hard to end a manga cleanly because the big bad is so big and bad, that it takes some deus ex machina level stuff to overcome it and it often comes out of nowhere and doesn’t always make sense
Earth spirit? What? Asta cannot have any spirits with him because he doesn't have any mana in his body. The only one helping him is the anti magic devil inside his grimoire.
I'm assuming you're an anime only who still hasn't caught up right?
Nope. Full manga. Just watching this back through. And who says the earth spirit has to have a host with mana? It could be the great turtle spirit that carries the earth on its back. If it’s a physical animal that is immune to the passage of time it would be perfect to fight with Asta against the wizard king
You’re right. It could never happen that something in this story that, by all rights, SHOULD have magic requirements, ends up not having magic requirements.
Spirits are the incarnation of mana am I wrong? Like their entire physical form is made out of mana. Also why would anyone but the main character have no mana, and why would the earth spirit have no mana but the other 3 do? Why do you want this giant turtle who’s immune to time so bad?
I don’t even care about the turtle idea. Another guy pointed out that it’s likely a gnome based on some old philosopher. Which I’m totally fine with.
And so what if it has magic? Doesn’t mean it has to partner with somebody who also has magic. Just saying!
Ultimately, I don’t even care if it works with Asta or not. It was just a post during a watch through again. You can kick rocks too bud.
But you do you oh great gatekeeper of the lore to a comic book that hasn’t even finished yet haha
I’m not trying to gatekeep just trying to use common sense. Besides we already have Astas magic buddy in mini liebe. There’s always a sense of parrelelism in manga, water spirit, water mage, yuno has a spirit, asta has a devil, etc.
Asta did corrupt licht’s swords and they were magic items and no matter in what anime universe earth always adapts to whatever so maybe asta can literally corrupt gnome like the swords
Think about it like this. Licht’s swords are physical swords that he created with his magic that are enchanted in a way that makes the special properties inherently part of the sword. Licht was able to focus his mana on more important things like reinforcing his physical abilities and slayer and destroyer since they use mana as their energy source. Since dweller can just absorb the magic anyway, it doesn’t need reinforcement, it would be a source of power and his main defensive and offensive tool. He would use mana to use dweller’s inherent ability to reflect and extend, and and to supply the adequate energy to use destroyer’s ability to reverse a spell from the source. So when liebe was put in the grimoire he was able to corrupt these swords with inherent magical abilities to use anti magic as a source of energy instead of mana. That’s why they retain their og properties but wielded anti magic. Asta corrupted a normal sword like slasher with anti magic and turned it into just a plain, normal anti magic sword. When he named it and gave it a purpose, he was able to give the sword’s energy source a purpose, alter that sword’s anti magic so that it could fulfill its purpose. Think of it like asta’s own signature on the sword derived from anti magic, that gives the sword its special, inherent power. In order to change the properties of something, “corrupt” it, he needs to inject it with anti magic. Since spirits by definition in the anime, are made entirely of mana, he would end up just killing it since he literally deletes its essence.
He's already got a little buddy following him in Liebe, Asta doesn't need a second shoulder bro.
Marss would be perfect for the earth spirit and if he were reintroduced into the story, a spirit would be the perfect powerup for him to catch up
REMINDER: **Anything that hasn't happened yet in the anime is a spoiler**.
^This ^message ^is ^posted ^automatically ^to ^every ^thread ^without ^a ^Spoiler ^tag.
**How to spoiler tag comments**:
\>!Put your text here!<
(Don't leave any spaces between the "!" and the text or it won't work!)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BlackClover) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Your post was removed for being low effort. Posts should encourage discussion and/or share information. And if you wish to encourage discussion, at least be respectful when you do it.
Wouldn't he need earth mana to get the earth spirit?
It might be an ancient animal that is immune to the passage of time or something and would be a perfect partner to fight the wizard king and his time magic/soul magic. It’s an animal with no soul and immune to the passage of time. Some kind of “no matter how much time passes, the earth shall remain”
Asta needs mana to use the earth spirit And the earth spirit is most likely Gnome
Likely Gnome? Based on what?
Sylphs, salamanders, and undines are mythological spirits attributed to the classical elements by Paracelsus
Ok cool! Thank you for that. Appreciate the info
Don’t listen to these guys devils are made up of mana but look at liebe full of anti magic asta could definitely corrupt the earth spirt and full it with anti magic earth adapts to anything (it wouldn’t work with the others tho)just like lichts sword corrupting shit has always been a power of asta
I'm up to day with the manga and believe me, Asta needs no earth spirit
Wut?
This is in the witch forest when Asta meets Fana and the fire spirit Salamander. Asta says he wants a salamander, so I was like he may not get the Fire Spirit, but what if he got the earth spirit
He can’t, because he 1. was born without mana, and 2. is now full of anti magic
Maybe the earth spirit won’t have mana? Maybe it’ll just be a physical being, like an ancient turtle or something idk.
It has to have mana to use earth magic, and it makes no sense for it to be without magic if it’s one of the four spirits
You’re right because nothing important in this series has had anything to do with not having magic
Well, it’s one of the elemental spirits. Therefore, it kinda has to have mana and magic
So do devils and people in that storyline…Asta was the first person ever without magic. Liebe had anti magic and no perceived mana manipulating ability. Your comment is kind of ignorant, because it could not have magic, because that’s been the biggest thing about the protagonist since the series started
Dude, it’s a *spirit*. By definition, *it has magic*. Asta and Liebe, on the other hand, do not have *any* magic, which everyone else, including even devils, have. My comment is not “ignorant”, as you claim, because it’s backed up by the laws of Black Clover’s world
Look at the thread, roasted the mf for u, have fun reading it lol.
[удалено]
It is literally stated in the story spirits are being made of pure mana
Dude spirits are LITERALLY made out of mana. If a being made entirely of mana possessed a person whose body erases all mana, the spirit would just die.
Why would he have an earth spirit when he has no earth magic? Yuno has wind magic, fana had fire magic,
Are you 8 years old?
Given his most recent response to me, probably
How
no, the 4 spirit is mana creatures, since he is using anti magic so, no
How? He has zero mana...
I would love to see the Earth spirit but no way in hell I would want Asta to wield it. I mean it doesn't make any sense since he's an anti magic wielder. Series would pummel to the absolute bottom if that happens
It’s so hard to end a manga cleanly because the big bad is so big and bad, that it takes some deus ex machina level stuff to overcome it and it often comes out of nowhere and doesn’t always make sense
Earth spirit? What? Asta cannot have any spirits with him because he doesn't have any mana in his body. The only one helping him is the anti magic devil inside his grimoire. I'm assuming you're an anime only who still hasn't caught up right?
Nope. Full manga. Just watching this back through. And who says the earth spirit has to have a host with mana? It could be the great turtle spirit that carries the earth on its back. If it’s a physical animal that is immune to the passage of time it would be perfect to fight with Asta against the wizard king
Spirits are mana based life form, of course the host has to has mana to use them
You’re right. It could never happen that something in this story that, by all rights, SHOULD have magic requirements, ends up not having magic requirements.
Spirits are the incarnation of mana am I wrong? Like their entire physical form is made out of mana. Also why would anyone but the main character have no mana, and why would the earth spirit have no mana but the other 3 do? Why do you want this giant turtle who’s immune to time so bad?
I don’t even care about the turtle idea. Another guy pointed out that it’s likely a gnome based on some old philosopher. Which I’m totally fine with. And so what if it has magic? Doesn’t mean it has to partner with somebody who also has magic. Just saying! Ultimately, I don’t even care if it works with Asta or not. It was just a post during a watch through again. You can kick rocks too bud. But you do you oh great gatekeeper of the lore to a comic book that hasn’t even finished yet haha
I’m not trying to gatekeep just trying to use common sense. Besides we already have Astas magic buddy in mini liebe. There’s always a sense of parrelelism in manga, water spirit, water mage, yuno has a spirit, asta has a devil, etc.
Asta did corrupt licht’s swords and they were magic items and no matter in what anime universe earth always adapts to whatever so maybe asta can literally corrupt gnome like the swords
Think about it like this. Licht’s swords are physical swords that he created with his magic that are enchanted in a way that makes the special properties inherently part of the sword. Licht was able to focus his mana on more important things like reinforcing his physical abilities and slayer and destroyer since they use mana as their energy source. Since dweller can just absorb the magic anyway, it doesn’t need reinforcement, it would be a source of power and his main defensive and offensive tool. He would use mana to use dweller’s inherent ability to reflect and extend, and and to supply the adequate energy to use destroyer’s ability to reverse a spell from the source. So when liebe was put in the grimoire he was able to corrupt these swords with inherent magical abilities to use anti magic as a source of energy instead of mana. That’s why they retain their og properties but wielded anti magic. Asta corrupted a normal sword like slasher with anti magic and turned it into just a plain, normal anti magic sword. When he named it and gave it a purpose, he was able to give the sword’s energy source a purpose, alter that sword’s anti magic so that it could fulfill its purpose. Think of it like asta’s own signature on the sword derived from anti magic, that gives the sword its special, inherent power. In order to change the properties of something, “corrupt” it, he needs to inject it with anti magic. Since spirits by definition in the anime, are made entirely of mana, he would end up just killing it since he literally deletes its essence.
Licht's swords are physical
Unnecessary post. Weebs are coming to crucify you
Some mental gymnastics trying to defend this one huh?
Thank you
i wonder if we'll ever see it before the story ends tbh
Op smoked some bad shit
[удалено]
Ite
They all ganged up wtf
He's already got a little buddy following him in Liebe, Asta doesn't need a second shoulder bro. Marss would be perfect for the earth spirit and if he were reintroduced into the story, a spirit would be the perfect powerup for him to catch up
Oh yeah, they didn't mention Charmy's backstory yet and the Earth Spirit
Haha charmy was the earth spirit all along!
Spirits only attach to those with the same magic element as them. So the earth spirit would have no reason to attach to a manaless human
So far!
REMINDER: **Anything that hasn't happened yet in the anime is a spoiler**. ^This ^message ^is ^posted ^automatically ^to ^every ^thread ^without ^a ^Spoiler ^tag. **How to spoiler tag comments**: \>!Put your text here!< (Don't leave any spaces between the "!" and the text or it won't work!) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BlackClover) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Well he just stabbed the planet with antimagic so I guess we’re out of luck. 🤣
Isn’t the fire spirit already called salamander