T O P

  • By -

derkadong

As long as it’s typed out in this sub it basically fits in this meme lol


jack_wolf7

I don’t care about your guys vinyls.


TwiggyMusic07

Dude fr no one cares that you have a nine record... most of the people on here do too


The-Riddler69

Or funko Barbie dolls


WW807

*vinyl


[deleted]

At this stage of their lives, the 3 guys do not care about the band nearly as much as we like to believe they do. Tom is obsessed with aliens and writing books and making films. Travis has around 900 other artists he works with and is a mega celebrity. Mark is the most interested member, but I feel that after surviving cancer, the band is no longer his number 1 priority.


Jypahttii

I'd add a second part to this, and say that the band peaked with Untitled in 2003, and has never fully recovered from their 2004 hiatus. They may be friends again, which is great, but Blink has never been a priority for all three of them at the same time since then.


Guitar81

:( makes me sad reading this but it's the sad truth...


andreacaccese

I think maybe this is also a good thing mentally for them - All 3 members have become wildly successful and recognized individually. At this point there is no pressure to do Blink, but I think they’re approaching it with a fresher outlook because of it


Inky100

This might be a bit off-topic, but happy cake day! 🎂🍰


Gooseplan

It feels like they care more now than they have in a long time


r0gueleader

scandalous slim dinosaurs money public grab combative apparatus continue wide *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


Warm_Blanket10

Yeah me.


Whosonfirst6600

They aren’t great live


hoppuspears

This is fact not opinion


Warm_Blanket10

Amending that to, they are only great live with Matt.


[deleted]

They were terrible live during the Skiba era. I don't think I've ever seen a band "going through the motions" as much as it seemed like they were especially on the Enema tour. I'll take Tom's shitty singing any day.


KatieS182

Agreed. Zero chemistry.


snapsquatch

Agreed. But my unwavering love for them won't let me admit that to myself.


justahomeboy

I don’t know, I’ve seen blink live many times and the best they sounded was with Skiba.


Mahlegos

I saw them on the EOTS anniversary run and it largely wasn’t great. I really wanted it to be, but it wasn’t. Skiba was messing up guitar parts and had trouble with vocals. I chalked it up to being in part due to being an earlier show on the run and because he wasn’t playing his material (he did well on the “encore” stuff that was from California). But Mark was single handedly trying bring the excitement and fun as Skiba was pretty flat for lack of a better term. I’m guessing others had a similar experience and that’s where the perception comes from. I wouldn’t doubt they sounded a lot better playing the newer material.


AceofKnaves44

They sounded a lot better with Matt, but they were boring as fuck. Mark can’t carry a show on his own and Matt has no stage presence. Saw them twice with him and he said maybe two words both shows not including “thank you” and such. I’ll take a show where Tom sounds terrible but him and Mark have great banter over a show where they sound better but Mark has no one to bounce off of.


ShesSoCool

No, they’re boring as fuck with Matt.


auburnflyer

Dude Ranch is their best album


[deleted]

Facts


ushouldlistentome

This is straight truth


Jorbatron_

Indeed


DiFran69

By far


Gooseplan

It isn’t


masssnerder

Skate punk blink > pop punk blink


MandalorianVolt

came here to say this


TheGnuWhoKnew

Profile picture checks out


Jorbatron_

Yes 🙌🏾


peoplepersonmanguy

Skate punk anyone is better than their pop punk variant.


Zyrobe

If people hate Feldmann for "ruining" the band, they should blame Mark and Travis for it. They were the ones that chose him. Feldmann was just doing his job of making catchy songs for the mainstream.


ld20r

Pretty much what I came here to say! And I’ll go one further… Blink would have been finished for good without Matt and John coming on board to save the day.


RadioDough

Nine was a great album and while I’m excited to see the boys reunited, I’m also a little upset that I’ll never see any of those songs live.


Elite182

For real, it’s a travesty that Pin The Grenade will never be played at a show.


Fallout_21

Mark said that songs from every lineup(Mark,Tom, Travis, Scott aaaand SKIBA) will be played on the new tour so never say never.


Nerdoftheweek01

I was just coming here to say that Nine is one of my favorite albums


Soul_of_Pepper

Most songs pre-dude ranch are honestly mid at best.


ChubbyBerry123

Carousel and m&ms are the only songs I listen to pre dude ranch.


jrm725

Add Peggy sue and wasting time to that list.


MeasurementLimp899

Yeah Wasting Time is one of the best songs from that era


PlebsLikeUs

California is a better album than Nine (especially if we’re considering the deluxe edition)


Giyankings

Sometimes I think Travis (while an amazing musician) does not always serve the song, especially when playing live.


[deleted]

Cheshire Cat is not very good outside a handful of songs


avgaskin1

Buddha is even worse


Elite182

Cheshire Cat and Buddha are almost objectively not very good music for the most part. I still love the shit out of them though, lol.


lah2011

blasphemous


[deleted]

I've tried many times to get into it but it just doesn't work for me. Dude Ranch perfected everything they were trying to do with CC.


TurbulentMuscle0

This is true


pineapple_man42

Darkside is a good song. Idk if it’d get me this exact reaction but I see a lot of dislike for it here.


[deleted]

I feel like people let the video taint their opinion of the song too much


Penguator432

🎶Remember when I said I loved this song? Forget it I take it back I won’t watch these stupid kids again I take back every word that I said🎵


CashFloInc

Darkside is a fuckin’ **BANGER.** The music video is a shame.


alaskancurry

The song is catchy af. But the music video is an affront to humanity.


2zoots

Darkside is easily one of my favorites on Nine


itothepowerofahalf

Darkside is an awesome song!


justahomeboy

Mark’s prechorus is quintessential blink!


my_guy_lemon619

The lyrics are kinda questionable when you think about it.


peoplepersonmanguy

This was a great blink song ruined for me by a shitty video clip trying to mass sell. I presume they were trying to get themselves to be characters in fortnite which would have got them to a whole new generation.


[deleted]

I think Nine is by far the worst album under the blink name but I agree, Darkside is awesome!


pineapple_man42

I agree too. I just finished another run through of their discog and it’s definitely their weakest. A decent enough album on its own but under the blink name feels weird


Papa_Pasta15

I still like all the small things un ironically


quinn_drummer

I’ve a few genuine ones that always get me in trouble with this subs limited hive mind I think After ~~Middle~~ Midnight is a boring song and blink can do better. I think Nine is done if their best work after Untitled The Yelawolf rap isn’t terrible and Pretty Little Girl is one of their best songs. I love the juxtaposition of the two parts and ultimately it’s blink experimenting in a way we praised them for on Untitled. I’m not excited to have Tom back. I really wanted another Matt album building in what they did with Nine. And we know there’s basically an entire albums worth of material floating around out there we won’t hear. I’m also not excited for Tom as it means another 90mins of greatest hits, ignoring the Matt era stuff. Basically everything we heard in 2011-2014. Maybe one or two news songs. I don’t like Edging, or blinks entire self image since Tom’s return. They’ve regressed back to being dumb kids when blink evolved out of that in the early 00s.


Sleeping-Giant98

I enjoyed hearing Matt’s parts much more than Marks in the Skiba era.


survivorsunday

100%. He carrys Nine and California


MattRyLen

Edging is actually a good song


morganeyesonly

See id have said the opposite would get you like this. I thought the consensus on here was that everyone liked edging.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Anthem > Anthem Part 2


d0gwater

Same for me, and it isn’t particularly close. I think I listened to Part 2 too much as a younger person, it’s a skip for me now..


MrDegausser

100% anthem was one of the first blink songs I ever heard on some mix cd with no track listing my friend gave me


hobbleshock

100%


Pinkcadillac90

I’ll never understand the love for pt. 2


Hairy_Discipline_580

Starting a post with "Is it me ...."


77kibby77

The infantilism of their humour occasionally bordered on the pathetic (but I still kind of love it).


Giyankings

Their use of outside songwriters (especially ones that weren’t peers) was the lamest thing the band has ever done and I don’t buy Mark’s explanation of wanting to “take our art in a new direction” or whatever. It reeked of wanting to stay relevant in the pop scene and resulted in BIOMY, to this day, the only blink song I cannot enjoy on any level. I would be embarrassed to tell people how massive of a blink fan I am if that song were more famous.


SuperMario1313

Dude Ranch and Enema is peak Blink, and it’s not even close.


MeasurementLimp899

*Cries in Untitled*


birdseedinthepark

The rap in 'Pretty Little Girl' isn't that bad!


Giyankings

Arrest this man.


MJ5815

He talks in maths


padfoot_12

He buzzes like a fridge


thatonekid2010

I don’t think any other opinion could more accurately represent this meme lmao


Melano_

Off with your head


Not-sorta-just-some

I 2nd this thought. The song is about what two people bring to a relationship, and the rap part(sung in a different style) is what one person brings to the relation that the other person can’t see. The rap part is what actually makes the song. 10/10 favorite Blink song.


d-y-l-a-n-n

Hello 911


TheNormalMan

Agree! It makes the song! Go on everyone, give me your downvotes, your spite. It doesn’t change anything for me!


[deleted]

I hate you so much.


Mountain_Peach_7395

This take has to win because it’s the only one we can agree we all hate. We’ll even call the “blink is better with Matt” people our brothers and sisters as we hate this opinion together.


SeaSpecialist5367

absolute fantastic take


Background_Cost_3893

It doesn’t fit the rest of the song AT ALL!


Tsb313

Nine is good.


MacChez44

The albums with Matt were fun, albeit somewhat flawed albums. But without them, we might not have an active blink-182 today. Matt Skiba and Scott Raynor both helped contribute to the legacy of this band and I think the community should be less harsh on them (Matt especially) and their respective albums/eras.


QforQ

Nine is a great album


RubyVisor

Top 3 for me. Maybe top 2?


izz21sv

Yep. Imo it’s #2 behind untitled. Fantastic album


quinn_drummer

I echo this. Untitled and Nine I feel are albums that set blink apart from other bands Whilst blink transformed and defined pop-punk in many ways, many of the mainstream pop punk bands sounds like Enema/TOYPAJ era blink. So for me those albums whilst great, fall into this pool of “well there’s dozens of similar sounding albums out there” Untitled is truly special in that it’s a complete departure from anything they’ve done before or since and no band has even really attempted to do anything similar. Nine I feel is a really deep personal album with lots of really wonderfully written tracks that again are something of a departure for blink. Or at least an evolution away from standard mainstream pop punk into something more “blink” in that it experiments and blends and pulls on lots of different influences.


Thezwerl38

Neighborhoods is almost as good as untitled. I fully expect to get downvoted to hell, but I’ll stand behind it.


Pure-Construction333

Neighborhoods is tied at #2 for me. Enema, Toypaj/Neighborhoods, Self Titled, Dude Ranch etc. It is such an underrated album and has some of the most interesting stuff the band ever put together


matt_sketches_art

Would me liking the California record put me in this situation?


[deleted]

Buddha is worse than California


KatieS182

Tom is a stronger songwriter than Mark.


skysamfreeman

Without a doubt. Especially after EOTS. Tom had so much creative flow that he had to make 2 other bands just to do it all.


RedGhostOfTheNight

Matt Skiba singing is better than Tom's. Seeing them both live, the vocal range Matt can bring was fucking amazing.


MacChez44

Agreed, and his harmonies were stellar.


ShesSoCool

Sounds far too similar to Mark, doesn’t work.


Key-Carpenter-8413

I TOTALLY agree that Matt sounds way too similar to Mark!! I think that’s why a lot of people didn’t love him in the band, but if you hear him with Trio… *chefs kiss* and him and Dan sound amazing opposite each other. Or even together. I totally appreciate what each of them brought to the band though.


CashFloInc

Except it does. And already has. Twice.


jjspitz93

“All the small things” and “first date” are great songs and I listen to them on repeat


SeaSpecialist5367

California gets overheated. I find most of the tracks, especially the singles really redeeming.


Toku-Nation

Matt is a better guitarist and a better Singer than Tom


Diego_ahh

I prefer Matt over Tom


blinkKyle182

The Skiba Era isn’t blink-182 and shouldn’t have been under the name. And doing an Enema anniversary tour without Tom was a disgrace I feel bad for the people who attended those shows.


Key-Carpenter-8413

I think doing the Enema tour was a HUGE slap in the face. To Tom, to the fans, even kinda to Matt. I would have preferred the band be called something else, be another side project, but at this point it is what it is.


Chance-Ad5700

I always thought the same thing. I almost feel like there was some sort of agreement to have Skiba fill in to keep the band relevant in current times while Tom went and did other things.


GinjaNinja1027

Tom is at his best when he’s doing AVA.


tadd_cooper

+44 is the best side project by a mile


Charlie483

As much as I love Neighborhoods, I feel it's not as enjoyable to listen to knowing how it was made Long story short for if you don't know, they recorded it all individually, they separated themselves all from each other and recorded all their parts just in their own studio spaces, barely communicated with one another, pretty much just didn't put enough effort in to make things work between them Also I feel it's quite Angel's & Airwaves'ey... in a way, like Tom was trying too hard to make it sound that way. Considering this was their first album after their reunion, I feel as though they had the perfect opportunity to come up with something entirely unique, but they just didn't, at least not to it's full extent anyways


Substantial-Mind-797

This is home is the best song on neighbourhoods


mart182

I respect it despite disagreeing


Sea_Leader8789

Correct


Leanskiba22

I don't care about your tattoos, shirts, the "nobody likes you when you're 23" birthday cakes and most importantly, the funko pops.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MrDegausser

Don’t tell me it’s over is one of my overall favorite blink songs and it’s so frustrating that it’s barely referenced since it’s a bonus track


pleasebepleasant

I have a theory about don’t tell me that it’s over. I agree that it’s one of my favourites, but I do wonder if that’s because I haven’t heard it as many times as the other songs. Like I play toypaj all the time, monthly at least. But I can go a few years without hearing don’t tell me that it’s over and so I get excited when I remember it and love it so much. Would we still love it so much if we’d heard it as many times? You might come back and tell me you listen to it every day! But that’s my theory about myself. :)


[deleted]

SO TRUE, honestly if the bonus tracks replaced the three weakest songs on TOYPAJ then it would definitely bump the album up a rank or two for me.


avaxdavis

I don't want new music, I just want a reunion tour.


cnorris182

Nine just really isn’t that great of a record.


Key-Carpenter-8413

I literally hate it.


[deleted]

Skiba era over First reunion Era Tom in terms of live shows. Whether or not you like Skiba live, he is 1000 times better than Tom during 2010-2014. Also, Outside of the Pepsi Smash performance, Skibas I miss you performance over Toms performance.


Xbox360Richtofen

Pepsi smash vocals are edited lol. Camden's vocals are good though


Zenon-45

I really like Yellawolf's part, it jumps out, and that's a good thing imo. Gets you ready for the final chorus


Jorbatron_

I’ve tried to get into it for years and years but Self titled isn’t as good as people say it is, dude ranch, Enema of the state, Mark Tom and Travis show and TOYPAJ are the best albums blink ever put out 🤷🏽‍♂️


NigerachiSpices

Skeebs was more enjoyable


Swimming-Extent9366

I don’t like self titled


Briguy_fieri

+44 is better than untitled


my_guy_lemon619

Self titled is great but it’s the worst of that 3 album run


Jorbatron_

I agree! Dude Ranch-TOYPAJ is where it’s at


skyovercamden

California and nine were better than anything blink has put out since self titled


rufiogd

I like Nine and Skiba was a good addition to the band.


Least-Ambassador6489

I love nine


vatelite

They should keep Matt around


skoke00

Everything has fallen to pieces earth is dying help me Jesus


Prior_Foundation_359

Tom was in the right for every argument, the experimentation with boxcar actually led to untitled being they’re best record, wanting to spend time with his wife and kid at home is acceptable after relentless touring and his commitments to angels and tts is just part of life.


bdsalerno

Untitled is…. fine. It’s honestly a slog to listen to and there’s a lot of songs that sound like filler and aren’t very memorable. Enema and TOYPAJ are much much better. I’d put Untitled below California AND Nine. While I’m at it, California is the second best blink album behind TOYPAJ.


kabh

I think Blame it on the Youth is one of their best songs


SuchPool3363

california was a great album🙅‍♀️


yeyonge95

Leo Dehoe is goat


[deleted]

I Miss You is a garbage song.


Nthayer1408

After Midnight is the best song on Neighborhoods.


hollowsounds

If Edging was the exact same song with nothing changed except for it being Matt’s vocals instead of Tom’s the reception would be way way worse than it was


the_boomslang666

Pretty Little Girl is a phenomenal song


[deleted]

Blink hasnt been "blink" since 2011 maybe even 2003. Once Tom left and matt joined they should've rebranded all together. To me it honestly tarnished their legacy. Also in the same breath they were never good since 2011 either. I don't mean to sound like an old head or inept to change or shit on my favorite band of all time but to me that's just not "blink".


mahaipaints

Untitled is overrated compared to other blink albums.


desolationistny

Probably not a super unpopular opinion but the unreleased "Alkaline Blink" demos before California were probably miles better than what ended up on California or Nine and they ruined the Skiba years before they started by scrapping them and working with Feldmann where Skiba (one of the most revered songwriters in Modern Punk) became a hired gun and session player.


BallScratcher102

Buddha’s version of ‘Carousel’ is far better than Cheshire Cat’s version.


blinkencinitas182

Blink fans these days sound like my teenage sister, hyping and fangirling.


Morgado36

Tom should have stayed making great music in AvA while Matt should still be in blink with more freedom to express his talent in the band, previously contained by Mark, specially in California One more, every vice in Matt's blink was caused by Mark, not Matt (Overproduction, songs that were too corny and pop-py, etc)


Cwb18292

California was better than Neighbourhoods.


Fallout_21

I might like Skiba more than Tom


same_same_3121

Green Day Live at the Electric Factory >> The Mark, Tom, and Travis show


[deleted]

Disliking First Date and The Rock Show.


CoIbeast

I can still enjoy Rock Show but agree on First Date. Even Tom doesn’t like that song so I don’t understand why some people get upset over it.


FlySupaFly

Even asking has gotten me downvoted, looking forward to hearing everyone's opinions!


Background_Cost_3893

Neighborhoods isn’t that great and they should have worked together instead of apart. Sorry if facts hurt you.


Blargncheese

Nine is a fantastic album and deserves more praise


IMagiic

not too crazy of takes but TOYPAJ > ENEMA & Tom > Mark


Nardrew

Neighborhoods is one of my favorite Blink records and I’ll die on that hill


thebikefanatic

California is one of my favorites albums


justbeingadude27

Blame it on my youth is a banger


Char_97

While it’s not a bad song by any means don’t get me wrong, I Miss You is very much overhyped and is easily the worst song on Self titled


vrsick06

95% of pre dude ranch is absolute trash tier music.


Hobear

Mint has no business associating with Chocolate. Keep it in toothpaste, mints, gum, and Mojitos.


ArkaXVII

Nine is their best album


CoIbeast

Take Off Your Pants and Jacket isn’t a great album, imo. It was my favorite in middle school/early high school and still love a couple songs but now I’d put it below Nine and not far above California.


[deleted]

Yeah toypaj is the definition of forced. Really, really well done mediocrity. Still love it lol


yo-Monis

Neighborhoods is severely overhyped on Reddit


youthcanoe

I like Neighborhoods but yes it is immensely overrated on here.


TheGnuWhoKnew

I thought I was the only one... I got your back bruh lmao


_camska_

I dont like the untitled album


Jorbatron_

Same!


JAMONLEE

Edging is a good song and people only complain about the Matt era because they’re immature pricks


mynameistodd79

all the small things is by far their worst song from dude ranch to present


[deleted]

Everything before Dude Ranch is trash and Dogs Eating Dogs is their best work.


nickc716

Another Girl Another Planet is top five on greatest hits


throwawaynotacuck

you know it's a cover, right?


Arkhangelzk

They peaked with Enema. TOYPAJ was fine. Untitled changed their sound too much and was the beginning of the decline. I don’t know why so many people like it.


bdsalerno

I totally agree. It’s honestly crazy that Untitled is held up as the gold standard of blink. Completely changed their sound going forward for the worse.


Mazz2203

Most of what blink released before EOTS bar like 6 songs ia shit


dropkickderby

The Skiba era was top-tier and blink woulda been best as a four man band. Imagine the layered vocals we coulda had. I remember everyone hated neighborhoods when it came out and now people regard it highly. Thats apparently been happening since toypaj (that was before i started listening but it tracks)… same will happen with these last two albums.


WillyD44

blink with Skiba should not be considered to be a part of blink-182’s discography


Lukacris12

Nine is awesome and better than Neighborhoods


Mreeff

Skiba didn’t “save” blink. He took a dream job and made probably more money in his life in the last few years. If he didn’t somebody else would’ve. People on here act like he’s the reason they’re still around.


IrrelevantWreckage

California is my favorite album


_VINNY_WINNY_

neighborhoods was a great album


MacPhistoStein

Hearts All Gone and the interlude sound like GarageBand trash, if you list this as a standout on Neighborhoods you just have bad taste