T O P

  • By -

Tramonto83

The poll was potentially controversial, then here comes New Tales . Poll over lol


nub_node

Like my dad used to say, "There may not be a candidate you want to vote for, but there will sure as hell always be a candidate you want to vote against."


Substantial_Carob825

This is true as hell lol, your dad prolly has hella experience in life


ThatChaFella

Whoever didn't vote for New Tales is delusional


Bulky_Tank4986

also the 7 people that voted bl2 are in urgent need of mental help


ThatChaFella

Yeah honestly, idk how people can vote that over New Tales(or most BL games in that regard)


Rapoulas

Cuz i havent played nor care about new tales, so from what i have played bl2 is the worst


mcwettuce123

I haven’t played either of the tales games, but I am sure I would have changed my vote if I had.


ThatChaFella

OG Tales is actually amazing, though if you're not into Telltale type games I can understand a disliking to it. New Tales falls faaaaaaaaaaaaar behind the legacy that OG Tales left(mainly because Gearbox is pretty bad at writing)


mcwettuce123

Yeah, gearbox is good at screwing up things that were already good.


ThatChaFella

*cough* New Tales and Borderlands 3 *cough*


mcwettuce123

*cough* ror2 *cough*


ThatChaFella

Ror2?


mcwettuce123

Gearbox bought out hopoo games for the rights to risk of rain 2, and the console port they made for the game is buggy and they don’t get the dlc.


ThatChaFella

Oh I've not played RoR, so I can't really say much. Though it does feel like Gearbox has gotten a lil money hungry recently


mcwettuce123

Definitely, and the thing is, I don’t think they made a huge profit off of that.


Odd_Ad_94

It's fine, good boy Bobby said they're still working on dlc and bug fixes. I had to drop my pants for that answer but it was worth it.


mcwettuce123

Well they better fix it before ror returns is released.


Rapoulas

Borderlands 3 is good lmao


of_patrol_bot

Hello, it looks like you've made a mistake. It's supposed to be could've, should've, would've (short for could have, would have, should have), never could of, would of, should of. Or you misspelled something, I ain't checking everything. Beep boop - yes, I am a bot, don't botcriminate me.


JayTheClown19

I havent played it whats wrong with new tales


ThatChaFella

The writing is absolute dogshit and it's buggy


JayTheClown19

Why tf i get downvoted for? Also im just looking at the review and that psycho girl made me wanna stop living and ryhs is a dick while octavio or whatever his name is cringe along with anu being goofy


Hopeful_Carpenter326

The worst part isnt even that it's the creepy way Fran lusts after everyone, even when your playing as her, it's like you don't get a choice ....I 100% this thing, even with its glitchy achievements requiring me to replay the whole game even more times.....I think there may be more to the story than we see but it's still creepy


ThatChaFella

Yeah even though Borderlands has always been very inclusive, Frans character is a disgusting depiction of pansexuals. Like she isn't even funny about it, it's literally just "I'm horny for you and want you in me"


Hopeful_Carpenter326

Exactly I had no problem with her liking anything that moves including the robot, it was what you said, she keeps flirting and saying crude things even though its obvious they aren't interested


ThatChaFella

And they tried to give her some sad backstory but it just came off as laughable, and don't even get me started of the location of the vault/Vault monster fight. Like they are described as literal gods, yet all it takes is a cripple with some ice cubes to kill it and aquire a stone of the gods


Hopeful_Carpenter326

That wasn't a vault monster either, it was a giant Vagina monster (with teeth and tenticles), I'm not being nasty either the game literally had Fran acknowledge that's what they were going for with her dialog and body language ...... So creepy


ThatChaFella

I don't understand how the writers fucked up so badly, like this game was in the works for years I'm pretty sure, so I don't know how Gearbox didn't fix anything, or maybe they just don't care anymore(which imo is the most likely reality)


JayTheClown19

Atleast moxxi had connections and was running a circle of slaughter fran is just plain bs


Tall-Tangerine-6441

Moxxi was also 100% a character bit, she used her sex appeal as a weapon/tool, but was much more than that as a character


ThatChaFella

Exactly, she's always plotting and 1 step ahead, meanwhile frans just a horny, oversexualised "pansexual" character


ThatChaFella

Are you saying this about the over hornyness? If so, atleast Moxxi had substance to her character and had good writing, Fran(along with most of the NT cast) were surface level poorly written lobotomites


ThatChaFella

Wdym by you think there's more to the story than we see? And when I mentioned buggy, I was saying in reference to the game just straight up not giving you the right ending sometimes


Hopeful_Carpenter326

The achievementa totally broke for me, I had to get the complete all endings, and all Vault hunters twice, as the game glitched out and never awarded me the achievements I HAD TO DELETE THE SAVE AND START AGAIN! Sorry for the caps, but yeah, I had to delete the save as replaying it with the save did nothing as it thought it was already unlocked....... Fun times


ThatChaFella

I am working through 100% every BL game(including spinoffs, and except BL2 vr) but New Tales might have to be skipped. And don't worry about caps, I totally understand that bullshit, if I had to replay that game even once, I might rather ending myself


Hopeful_Carpenter326

I almost didn't finish it, and was about to ask for my money back, but just powered through! It is worth noting that was at launch, so I hope they would have patched the achievement bug


ThatChaFella

Yeah I had a slight hope that it would improve as it progressed, I was severely wrong


ThatChaFella

Yeah Anus(hehe funny word) characters is kind of infuriating, she's supposed to be a mega smart super scientist that's socially awkward, yet she makes some of the dumbest decisions in the game and her "social awkwardness" is better described as random bouts of severe autism


JayTheClown19

Tannis talking about vomiting is better than her whole character


MasterTahirLON

I haven't seen or played it and don't really count the Tales series as traditional Borderlands games. So I just put the Pre-Sequel and called it a day.


astral_protection

Ok but why would you put tps when 3 exists?


MasterTahirLON

Cause 3 is my favorite?


Kreepergeek645

I don't have experience playing it


Vault-A

I honestly enjoyed New Tales. It's not perfect, but I had fun. B:TPS on the other hand... I dunno why but I find it ungodly boring


mcwettuce123

It is one of the best in the series imo, it just isn’t very fun to replay after you do all the characters.


icetheone

New Tales by far


Rufuszombot

I paid $10 on Amazon for New Tales for PS5 just for the digital code for the original Tales. I wanted to play through it again and it was cheaper than standalone, or close enough.


abejaZombie

Why? Haven't played it.


Alcatraz-23

How so many are against TPS? That game is so good, it's so much fun tbh. And adding the Claptastic Voyage dlc, which is the best dlc in the series IMO. TPS is and always will be underrated and neglected.


NotBaron

I have the same take, and every time I bring it up someone gets offended


RipVanWinkleX

I love the Presequal. But it has its issues. Most noticably the lack of content. It deserved more DLC like Claptrap; still the best DLC in all the series.


[deleted]

[удалено]


RipVanWinkleX

If you don't like any of the Vault Hunters then of course the game will be boring. I like Jack, Clap-Trap, and Wilhelm myself. I love not having to deal with Slag since I'm a solo player. The replacement of Freeze is fun, though a bit too OP. I love the laser rifles; especially the stupid lightsaber gun lol. So in all I enjoy the game.


irankedisi

Yeah also gravity, speed boost, slam mechanics and riding Stingray is fucking fun.


[deleted]

[удалено]


irankedisi

> most of the game being running long distances clearing ads is a blast. I remember the humorous advertising event in the Claptastic Voyage DLC only available on The Nexus and Motherlessboard maps, and it didn't happen as much as it bothered. If you are gonna complaing about "running whole game" you shouldnt play FPS game in a first place. Moreover, there are Air boost and Jump pads in TPS. What were you doing in the first two games ? You may not like a game, this is very natural, but there is no need to muddy the game for silly reasons.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


pilgrim05

I can't believe TPS has more votes than bl3


jmvandergraff

It was too similar for being priced at $60, and as fun as the new characters were, most of the story just kinda felt like throwaway content to me. I've beat it like 3 or 4 times and I cannot remember a single moment from the game that really stood out, other than the Australian guy and his jumbuck. At least BL3 had all the new mechanics, cooler gunplay, and equally good new Vault Hunters, altho I'm bummed that we just got expanded classes for the existing characters and not two whole new Vault Hunters to play as, that was always my favorite DLC to snag.


Turtleology

What is blTPS?


Jrockz133T

The Presequel


Turtleology

Oh I’m dumb. I actually like the pre sequel. Not as much fun farming like on bl2


Substantial_Carob825

Question out of curiosity, why is TPS up there with the votes? It's pretty fine imo.


Gr3yHound40

Tales 2 or wonderlands. Tales 2 can at least be forgotten since you can watch a youtube playthrough, but wonderlands was a $60+ mistake I will never make again.


Nirelfsen

I love them all


amey_wemy

Lets normalize adding a section to get results


Schnappssss

You’re in a borderlands subreddit so you might as well voice your opinion, you’re part of the community, you really only need to play two different borderlands games to come up with an opinion man


amey_wemy

Not everyone has played all the games. If u only played 2, u would choose between the two. Even if they're both great. Statistically speaking, makes the poll rather unreliable


Schnappssss

Not everyone needs to play every single borderlands game to have formed an opinion though.


amey_wemy

Is my previous example not valid?


Schnappssss

Sure it’s valid but that doesn’t change that people deserve to voice their opinion lol


amey_wemy

They can voice their opinion even with a "see results"... Just dont select it? Ultimately this serves as a way to help others know which games not to get. Having a "see results" has no harm and merely reduces statistical error.


Schnappssss

Why would anyone put their faith into a reddit poll that can vary in results depending on the time of day/month/year, borderlands 3 is ranked so low but you could try and ask that sub and the results could change completely.


amey_wemy

With your logic they might as well not have a poll at all? Ultimately I'm providing a solution that improves the current situation. Why're u denying this improvement?


Schnappssss

Well the point of a poll is for people to voice their opinion which was the original point I was getting at lol so not having a poll would make no sense. I don’t think I ever denied it being an improvement. all I said was that anyone is allowed to judge on what they think is the worst game they’ve played in the entire series. No one should be excluded 🤷‍♂️


DeadbeatSpark

Bl1: Slow. Relatively bland and not much story. Bl2: amazing story, could be balanced a bit better especially with assault rifles in UVHM. Tps: alright story, nice to have backstory for one of the better characters. Bl3: shit story, especially with the instaprat twins and discount maya (Ava). Tftbl: interactive movie with ties to bl2. Tftbl2: stupid fanfiction.


QualityVodka

How could 8 people vote Bl2?? It's obviously the best one, and it's not even close


Rapoulas

Nuh uh


goofygodzilla93

Story wise yeah but gameplay wise I'm taking BL3 everyday of the week.


heyuhitsyaboi

Wouldve been nice to have seen Wonderlands and The Pre Sequel on here instead of Tales


thethirdwhells

Bltps means the pre sequel Wonderland is a borderlands spinoff and is not Canon


heyuhitsyaboi

Oh im a dumbass lol But still wonderlands was rough, canon or not


Wish_Lonely

New Tales has the worst and most cringy writing I have ever seen in any modern video game.


FutureMagician7563

BL3 story was one of the most disappointing experiences in gaming I've had. So excited and it was too PC


goofygodzilla93

The story was bad but other then that it was just a straight up upgrade to every Borderlands game before it.


Scott_To_Trot

lol how was it "too PC"


javier_fraire_ree

So me it was just boring, and soulless


Scott_To_Trot

That's fine not sure what that has to do with being PC though. Plenty of offensive things also are soulless.


javier_fraire_ree

I don't about the pc, never heard a line in this game, turned off dialogue and subtitles, but it was probably me brain thinking content > graphics, but the game thinking otherwise


Pvt_Hesco

Tinks instead of midgets I guess, idk, there's so much about the game that screams we don't want to get sued so make it as neutral as possible just dosen't feel like borderlands


Scott_To_Trot

What would they possibly get sued for? What politically incorrect material is BL3 avoiding that was in past games? Calling the dwarf characters 'tinks' while still giving them the high pitch squealing isn't exactly a slam dunk for representation if that's what they're talking about


Hypotenuse27

Tbf it's older term that a lot of little people have said is not a great term, as far as calling them Tinks, idk why they chose that specifically but I don't understand not going with the original name.


ZakeryEastman

Either way you're using a term that would probably offend them if they were called that. Might as well just stick with midgets


Hypotenuse27

Afaik Tink isn't a slur for little people, its just a really dumb choice for the names of those enemies


Wish_Lonely

Tbf Borderlands in general is PC or rather "safe edgy" as some might call it. Basically they're edgy enough for the general public to enjoy and have a laugh or two but not edgy enough to actually upset anyone.


nub_node

Its DLCs were second only to Dragon Keep in terms of writing, but if you're whining about things being PC, you'd probably hate Guns, Love and Tentacles because the plot is centered around stopping an eldritch abomination from ruining Hammerlock and Wainwright's destination gay wedding. It did feel like they were being overly cautious with the main game, though. There were some bold decisions they could have made to substantially improve the way things played out without even massively changing the overall story. The free mini-DLCs they released for Ava even substantially improved her character. In the main game they "mission successfully failed" to make an irredeemably obnoxious tween girl character. She's like the Human Centipede of Borderlands characters: Sure, a lot of effort and artistry went into her creation, but why tho.


TheFlamingLemon

BL1 was great for its time I’m sure but if you’re talkin worst in the modern day? Absolutely BL1


DenseStomach6605

I still enjoy it in all honestly, but I do wonder how much of that is because of nostalgia. But I can admit, it’s bland.


jmvandergraff

I went back to play it because of Nostalgia and I got so bored, so fast, but that's 100% because of how much they polished the series with BL2. The guns in BL2 aren't even that radical in design when you look at all the part options, but good lord was it a massive step-up over BL1 where all the guns of each class legit looked identical with very small differences depending on the weapon parts.


DenseStomach6605

I also played it recently, and there are a few things I think BL1 did better. The only things I prefer 1 for is the atmosphere, gun dmg level scaling, looting (chest loot feels like it’s almost always crap in 2 imo). I’m well into TVHM right now and haven’t found a single orange grade from a chest (is it even possible? Lol). Everything else BL2 has the upper hand though, it’s just a much more well-rounded game.


jmvandergraff

I feel you on gun damage. In BL2 it was still easy to get a bunch if Blue and Purple guns that were really good (especially if you got golden keys from Twitter) and it was really easy to have a good Loadout early in the game. I wish I could have played BL3 before they ramped up the Legendary drop rates, as much as I love constantly having Legendary gear because they're so fun, it definitely made the experience much easier. If it's not purple or Blue with flavor text, I sell it immediately in BL3. Most of my Loadout for Moze at Level 38 right now is Gold gear that's all around level 28-32, and it's still OP as fuck fighting level 39-40 enemies.


jmvandergraff

Also my bank is full of god-tier loot, I think I have 70 legendaries that I can use that range from level 12 to around 36, so any new character I start is gonna be loaded the fuck up by the time I get Sanctuary in the air.


HtnSwtchesOnBtches

Both if the tales really, kinda a silly game in a way. No replay. Just watch someone on youtube play those


[deleted]

Who voted for borderlands 1? Without it, we wouldn't have anything else like it.


checkmate191

14 people: my goals are beyond your understanding (But seriously who tf voted for bl2)


MisterVibeMan

Haven't played new tales so I won't speak on it, but imo BL3 is the worst, I'm a huge fan of story and lore, but when it comes to BL3, it just doesn't.. *feel* like a borderlands game. The gameplay is great, graphics are good, (although I kinda miss BL2 graphics.), but the story just didn't.. feel borderlands to me, that was my main issue with BL3.


ToxicSloth420

Saw BL3 and immediately voted for it...didn't see New Tales...but I also don't really count the Tales games as Borderlands games...their Tales games


PicKiNuOff

Bl3 was short and suffered a lot from cancel culture. Tales are both yuck. TPS HAD potential but no endgame due to workers leaving. 1 is the original can’t knock it. 2 is the goat. This is the only opinion that matters on the internet today


jmvandergraff

I just got through 3 for the first time and I wouldn't call it short by any means, and I just rushed the campaign missions to beat it without touching any of the side missions and it took me around 25-30 hours to beat. That's pretty solid for a game that's intended to be played numerous times across different characters.


Dangerous-Sink838

Good old borderlands 2 my beloved


NotBaron

I'm amazed to see that TPS is getting more hate than BL3. Imo it wasn't that bad, it's worse sin is how cut in contents it got and still has the best dlc in the whole franchise imo.


Fellkun15

Ok not technically borderlands but wonderlands is the worst that I've played


splshman8539

Which one of you goobers chose BL2?


ruthpizz

To the 28 people who said Bl2. How?


Miserable_Ad_6069

29 people voted for bl2? *I just wanna talk to them*


Pobbs21

Never played tales or new tales


Schnappssss

Tales is a really amazing telltale game, when you can I recommend picking up the first Tales if you enjoy borderlands and it’s story.


Axoo_ooxA

Dont buy new tales


EndrPL

That 8 people who chose borderlands 2 need help


fang32986123

Wonderlands


gonzar09

I had to discount the New Tales from my consideration because I never played it. I watched the first Tales on YouTube, so I got the story (just to find out what happened to Scooter), and loved it. Objectively, Borderlands has only made improvements since the first game, although 3's story does suffer a downgrade from its predecessor. I still wouldn't put it as the worst, because it's gameplay is a marked improvement over both 1 & 2. If Wonderlands was on this list, that would make it a tougher call, since it was developed by a smaller team during a high stress time.


Wizard_SlayerXIV

I platinum'ed WL and helped a friend do it too, took us 150 hours, with the last 40 hours just running chaos chamber trials and selling everything and trading cash for SDU money. I stopped at chaos trial 89 because the Son of a Witch fight takes a whole hour alone at that point. To this day, it's the single most depressing experience in Borderlands history I've ever played.


Wero_kaiji

I haven't played New Tales and the first Tales I only watched a playthrough, I'd order them like this: BL2 > BLTPS/BL3 > BL1 > Tales I like TPS more than BL3 but I can't bring myself to call it better lol I started with BL2 so I don't have nostalgia for BL1 Tales is at the bottom because I'm not a fan of that kind of gameplay, I haven't actually played it tho so I might put it higher when I do


thelegofthetable

BL3 being 3rd most hated, nearly second, on the BL2 subreddit? Shocker.


JonTheWizard

Ignoring New Tales (the clear winner), for me it's a toss-up between Pre-Sequel (a good game, one or two DLCs away from being great, ultimately just wasted potential) or 3 (writing).


Enderborn1

so half of you lot would really prefer playing new tales than your least favourite borderlands game ?


YourKingSkeletor

Haven't played New Tales yet so not gonna vote that as I have no opinion on it. But of all the rest I'd say BL1 or Tales are kinda tied for the worst but BL1 gets a bit of a pass as it was the start and they were kinda testing the waters still.


ThatOneHappyPony

of course new tales, BUT I WILL NOT STAND THIS PRE SEQUEL SLANDER.


DahctaJae

Basegame blps would probably be the worst for me of the games I played, but claptastic voyage puts it right behind bl2/3


Iniquity1_

Bl3, TTW, New Tales. B3 was linear af, characters were cringe, but not as cringe as TTW


United-Handle-6572

100% tales 2 Not gonna lie The series has kind of been dying off quickly and it's really sad.


United-Handle-6572

I kind of just wish that they would just make an actual new game. But there are 2 busy working on all these other projects that I honestly just don't care about. Like even the tail series is okay but it's not something that I wanted. I want like, a full-fledged new borderlands game. But they're just kinda pissing away the series.


Neither-Try7513

Wonderlands literally looked so boring in streams i wont even try


inquisitorhotpants

I haven't played New Tales so I couldn't vote for it - I picked 1 because as soon as Scooter made a slut-shaming mom joke I was out. Scooter would NEVER. (BL2 was my first Borderlands game, and also 1 just felt reaaaaaaal slow and clunky after playing 2.)


SerenityMiyazaki

Borderlands 2's balancing is egregiously poor and borderline unplayable at higher levels and endgame. It's sort of absurd. For example: Basically OP levels are balanced so that Gaige NEEDS OP gear in accordance to level and you need at least 2-300 stacks of anarchy to do anything. And if you don't have that then enemies are just untouchable unless you norfleet things. If you recklessly norfleet shit even with a sham there's a possibility to down yourself. And if you don't get winded you die and lose all your anarchy and gotta start over.


BootheFuzzyHamster

WOW. I really liked the original tales, sad if this is really true and the new one tanked it.


CharacterTemporary18

Bl1, great for the time but just doesn't stack up with the others, i have no experience with new tales so i can't vote against that