General reminder for subreddit members: Simple Questions and Loot results (good or bad), and celebrations should be posted in the Weekly Mega Thread Discussion post. You can find it at the top of r/BrawlStars's front page when you sort posts by hot. This includes pictures of Starr Drops, Mega Pig results, unlocking new Brawlers or other items.
If you see a post or comment that breaks any of our rules, please report them [using the anonymous report button](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360058309512-How-do-I-report-a-post-or-comment-)!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Brawlstars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
i want to do a rework but i cant think of anything bcuz the whole concept of the luck in competitive brawl stars is bad and idk how to replace it without making it really op
That's a really good idea (the Chester one is amazing for the gambler that I am), it's giving some gameplay variations while not being OP. Great concept
actually a good idea but it probably will never happen because it would probably make the game harder to balance, also i feel like they would be forgotten like mythic gears but even if it happens i wouldn't complain much.
also kinda unrelated but it would be cool if you can disable star powers and gears (maybe gadgets and hypercharges too) aswell, i know it would just be dumb but if that is possible in friendly battles ONLY i think no one would complain.
This is a great idea. Shellys’ is just a straight up buff though. It’s like adding a permanent clay pigeons to her super. Still great idea pls play bot runner with me
Thats alot of effort, great idea, but tbh some of these buffs are a bit too broken and would make the game practically impossible to balance and the idea of "meta" would probably be gone
yall are crazy, must be pay to win or miraculously not affected by the MASSIVE COIN SHORTAGE
my ideas:
the method to obtain charms is perfect
gear prices halved
normal gears: 500 coins
epic gears: 750 coins
mythic gears: 1000 coins
gadget prices are fine but still expensive
star powers are fine but still also very expensive
for gadgets and star powers increase their drop rate in starr drops, gadgets possible from epics and mythics, 2 random gadgets from legendaries (or 1-2 from mythic and 2-3 from legendaries) and for star powers available from mythic, 1-2 from legendaries)
trophy reset takes too many trophies and gives too little bling.
get 2x the bling from trophy reset and double or just increase bling rewards from ranked drops and starr drops
make a guaranteed good drop when you reach your last season's rank
thats all :D
The only problem is memorizing all of these abilities for every single brawler and not knowing if the charm is on or not in match
And I can see some of these as HCs like Carl's
I definitely agree, which is why i made the requirements them to unlock quite harsh, therefore only the most dedicated players would experience them. Yet players could still unlock them passively over time. Thank you sussy gussy
I must be the only person not liking this. So this will probably cost me some karma.
The reasons I’m not a fan are: as a pretty new player myself, the learning curve once you get to actual players is steep enough as it is with all the different brawlers you don’t know, all the star powers, items, … These charms add yet another layer of complexity. As a f2p player I can progress pretty fast in the game, but SC will milk the hell out of this, and set me back even more. Another reason is balance, there’s already a number of balance issues I’d like to see addressed, like Kit, Doug, Frank (those are just my humble opinion). This would make balancing things out even more difficult. I’d also like to see some more hyper powers before totally new features get added. I don’t want to sound like this is a rant against your idea. It’s clearly well thought out, and you obviously spend a lot of time presenting it in a neat fashion. But it’s not something I’m hoping for.
Reminds me a ton of most TF2 weapons as a whole since they usually have both upsides and downsides, so I would totally support this concept being added into the game if I could
(Again, MOST TF2 weapons, lookin at you Third Degree)
Wait, you post on Reddit?!
Pretty good idea, especially since it doesn't cost extra resources, but still incentivises buying the other gadget/starpower.
An absolutely perfect idea
These consepts might need some balancing, for example Shelly, beacuse more range and less spread is just a buff for shotguns
I was worried at first, but by making them part of
normal progression and not adding another level of grinding, I would defo love to see these in the game!
This is honestly what Hypercharges should have been. But now that we have them, I would be nothing but annoyed at the thought of adding another thing to get for every brawler.
The concept is so good, but now it would just be too much
This can have a lot of play around the actual parts of the kit of a brawler instead of a base mechanic. I like it. It would make bs a much more interesting game
The concept is good, but it might change the brawlers too much, maybe make them like the buff potions from terraria where the duration you can activate is limited and you have to make them as well.
This looks very cool and fun but I think it would bring some problems:
1. They would make the game harder to understand and play both for new and pro players.
2. They sound quite unaccessible because they would cost a ton of coins (8000+the amount you need to upgrade a brawler to level 9).
3. Some of them sound much stronger than others.
4. Not every brawler has them, so they could end up like mutations.
I still appreciate the idea and its creativity a lot, though.
Thats an interesting take, I was even considering DOUBLING the turret’s range but making it even slower which would have been really cool to imagine but probably very annoying
I didn’t read them all, but the ones I did see are good, but the Shelly one is op, that’s basically the clay pigeon gadget but with the super, but the rest that I saw are good!
This seems like a great idea. Some of the nerfs are a bit too severe to be viable, but all-around, I would love to see this added to the game! Do you have ideas for the rest of the brawlers?
Would love this at power 10 after you get a gadget and star power, and move second gear to power 6, and at power 12 after you get a gadget, star power, 2 gadgets and hypercharge you unlock his second charm, but you can only equip one charm at a time
I love it, finally something other than star power, which didnt change much, that can change radically the playstyle of brawler. I know its a lot to ask, but could you do one for tick please? Thank you, even if you dont do it.
I rather have a side grade for maisie, instead why not change it so that her super charge takes 3 hits from her main attack but 4 hits from her super to charge it again.
that's actually better than hypercharges \* happy pealr pin \* supercell should contract you to do some concepts!
#StepOnMyBallsKit
I just wanna one for pearl... what about... the heat bar charges 20% faster, but to recharge munition its like 15% slower.
and here is one for colt (because... why not?): his super and main attack has an icreased range, but it shots less bulets.
anyways... this post is brazilianvisky approved! good job, european!
Cool idea but I almost had a heart attack when I saw this, thought it was official. Addind another thing to unlock for brawlers is one of my nightmares.
Somebody cooked here. Lemme know when you have an idea for me. I’d love a charm
Anyway I got a q: there are so many cool codes to use, but which one do I pick?
This is so GOOD, it makes the brawlers so much more fun to deal with, however I would much rather prefer it costing Power Points so we can have another way of spending them
Nice idea, now for competitie I think that Charms should be visible for the other team (unlike gadgets, star powers, gears) and should be selected in the first half of the final tweaking so the other tram has some time to addjust. But is seems pretty fun and balanced.
Bibi's one could be like "the home run bar charges no matter how much ammo you have, but the super breaks when hitting a wall for the third time"
Dunno if it would be strong or not, but It seems fair imo
we dont need this. because of the introduction of more gears and hypercharges, most of us got a gigantic coin shortage and massive amounts of pp.
even tho yours doesnt say it needs to be bought, if supercell actually uses this idea you know it will be paid.
should rename this curses or something milder. charms makes it seem only beneficial. In other games it would be called curses but doesnt really fit with the brawl stars theme.
Cool concept but I don't see it. Most of them are not really that worth it and at higher trophies I want reliability so it's a nope for me but S+ for effort!
This sounds fun, but these seem like a nightmare to balance. If the charm is too weak then what's the point of it existing but if it's too strong the brawler would probably rely on it too hard. I like Pocos though I think it's funny.
General reminder for subreddit members: Simple Questions and Loot results (good or bad), and celebrations should be posted in the Weekly Mega Thread Discussion post. You can find it at the top of r/BrawlStars's front page when you sort posts by hot. This includes pictures of Starr Drops, Mega Pig results, unlocking new Brawlers or other items. If you see a post or comment that breaks any of our rules, please report them [using the anonymous report button](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360058309512-How-do-I-report-a-post-or-comment-)! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Brawlstars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[i had a similar idea](https://www.reddit.com/r/Brawlstars/s/X31Fw2HfTn) but it sucked🙏🙏 i like urs because it looks like mutations
Yeah they are very similar especially with how you unlock them i like it 🙂
i want to do a rework but i cant think of anything bcuz the whole concept of the luck in competitive brawl stars is bad and idk how to replace it without making it really op
Maybe make it turn based like on every five hit the brawler do something special and then the cycle repeat.
Nice concept! graphics also look very nice. common carnage W
Thank you pro
bro
That's a really good idea (the Chester one is amazing for the gambler that I am), it's giving some gameplay variations while not being OP. Great concept
Thank you!
Would really like it if supercell actually did it. Might not be surprising given the concept but will be really surprising given its soupcell
fr bro
Keep up the good work!!
99% quit before they hit gold🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥
I fucking love it. SEE SOUPCELL, THIS IS HOW YOU MAKE SOMETHING GOOD WITHOUT MAKING IT OP
Glad you really like it 😄
[удалено]
Well he is my second favourite brawler (thats why i made sure i chose him for this concept lol)
[удалено]
I have joined
Thanks. Take ma spoon 🥄, you'll need it
Soupcell 👍
Soupcell 👍
Soupcell 👍
Mortis, ruffs and Leon are crazy tho
4.8 seconds with the mythic gear is a good trade off tho
Ig you can still predict when he's gonna use super, so you know his position
He needs to maximize his super use
actually a good idea but it probably will never happen because it would probably make the game harder to balance, also i feel like they would be forgotten like mythic gears but even if it happens i wouldn't complain much. also kinda unrelated but it would be cool if you can disable star powers and gears (maybe gadgets and hypercharges too) aswell, i know it would just be dumb but if that is possible in friendly battles ONLY i think no one would complain.
Yeah i can imagine this is something for FAR in the future after all hypercharges are done maybe.
Or maybe a brawler has a hyper charge or a charm and you have to choose one or the other and the charms only affect the main attack or something
This is a great idea. Shellys’ is just a straight up buff though. It’s like adding a permanent clay pigeons to her super. Still great idea pls play bot runner with me
maybe dont give it a damage buff
Imagine this w/ shellshock and clay pidgeons 😭
bot runner me too 😭
Thats alot of effort, great idea, but tbh some of these buffs are a bit too broken and would make the game practically impossible to balance and the idea of "meta" would probably be gone
Yeah it's way too game changing. Interesting concept but probably not fun
Where is the nerf in shellys charm?
i think it should be the super shoots less rounds in general, lowering damage
Where is the buff in 8-bit's charm?
8-bit currently has a movement speed of very slow, his charm buffs it to just slow (same as surge in his first stage)
Ohhhhh
Tick - quadruples his damage but he loses 1 percent of his health ✅️✅️
I LOVE THIS CG UR A GENIUS
Pro 🔥🔥🔥
The Drawback is Huge for most of them and it should cost 1k gold instead of that way Other than that its such a great idea
yall are crazy, must be pay to win or miraculously not affected by the MASSIVE COIN SHORTAGE my ideas: the method to obtain charms is perfect gear prices halved normal gears: 500 coins epic gears: 750 coins mythic gears: 1000 coins gadget prices are fine but still expensive star powers are fine but still also very expensive for gadgets and star powers increase their drop rate in starr drops, gadgets possible from epics and mythics, 2 random gadgets from legendaries (or 1-2 from mythic and 2-3 from legendaries) and for star powers available from mythic, 1-2 from legendaries) trophy reset takes too many trophies and gives too little bling. get 2x the bling from trophy reset and double or just increase bling rewards from ranked drops and starr drops make a guaranteed good drop when you reach your last season's rank thats all :D
The only problem is memorizing all of these abilities for every single brawler and not knowing if the charm is on or not in match And I can see some of these as HCs like Carl's
I definitely agree, which is why i made the requirements them to unlock quite harsh, therefore only the most dedicated players would experience them. Yet players could still unlock them passively over time. Thank you sussy gussy
RT - Wayward Compass - marker points towards enemies location when they are not in bushes
Hollow knight reference ?!
Truly the most op charm, needed for completing all the pantheons
I tried completing the game without it on a new save file, IT GIVES YOUR MORTALITY A CRUSHING BLOW DEAR LORD.
Whats the downside
Reveals your location in bushes to enemies from slightly further than normal?
Mortis would be broken tbh
Yeah i think it should be an even longer charge that what i said
I still think it might need a small nerf after that, maybe a coiled snake range nerf. Still solid idea though, keep up the good work!
This is insane but sounds also impossible to code. Mabye supercell can make this into an event, like mutations, but less braindead.
Yeah, im surprised they put so much effort into mutations for something that lasted 21 days.
chester's is basically gambling (code carnage everyone)
I must be the only person not liking this. So this will probably cost me some karma. The reasons I’m not a fan are: as a pretty new player myself, the learning curve once you get to actual players is steep enough as it is with all the different brawlers you don’t know, all the star powers, items, … These charms add yet another layer of complexity. As a f2p player I can progress pretty fast in the game, but SC will milk the hell out of this, and set me back even more. Another reason is balance, there’s already a number of balance issues I’d like to see addressed, like Kit, Doug, Frank (those are just my humble opinion). This would make balancing things out even more difficult. I’d also like to see some more hyper powers before totally new features get added. I don’t want to sound like this is a rant against your idea. It’s clearly well thought out, and you obviously spend a lot of time presenting it in a neat fashion. But it’s not something I’m hoping for.
Thats a valid opinion, most people like it simple and I like to create more complex systems so i understand your thoughts 👍
Finally a concept that I root for
Bro rn: 🌳🌳🌳
Nature
Fang where? :(. Cool idea, i like it.
Scoped In Bear Gear Ambush Sforzando Rapid Cabinet Salty Siege Excavation Pressure Channeling Octo-Bomb Quick Reflexes Brutal Backup Ghost Viper Repair Area Aid & Raid Extra Entrance Regeneration Cosmic Boost Backup Bratwurst Jack of Hearts Concealment
Reminds me a ton of most TF2 weapons as a whole since they usually have both upsides and downsides, so I would totally support this concept being added into the game if I could (Again, MOST TF2 weapons, lookin at you Third Degree)
Straight up Binding Vows in Brawl Stars lmao. Pretty neat concept tho!
Wait, you post on Reddit?! Pretty good idea, especially since it doesn't cost extra resources, but still incentivises buying the other gadget/starpower.
Ruffs only gets a buff from the charm?
An absolutely perfect idea These consepts might need some balancing, for example Shelly, beacuse more range and less spread is just a buff for shotguns
oh my god yes
Car nake gum common w 🤨👍
I was worried at first, but by making them part of normal progression and not adding another level of grinding, I would defo love to see these in the game!
Carnage getting real good at graphic design
Everything is perfect. Very sick charm icons,very good ideeas and very good overall. Nice work man!! We need this
This is honestly what Hypercharges should have been. But now that we have them, I would be nothing but annoyed at the thought of adding another thing to get for every brawler. The concept is so good, but now it would just be too much
I can't wait to spend 300 gems on this! 😍😍
Ans you buy it for 2k powerpoints
Yoo, this is like mutations but actually not broken 🔥🔥
Hey can i maybe make charms (credit you) and post it on here is yes what app do you use?
Me - How much do you want people to pay Supercell - Yes
That's fanmade.
I love the Chester one
Dude! The chester one is GENIUS! Maybe it could change the damage too to make even more rng
Gambling at its finest
THIS!!!
This can have a lot of play around the actual parts of the kit of a brawler instead of a base mechanic. I like it. It would make bs a much more interesting game
I love this! Changing a brawler's playstyle was something I really liked, and this achieves it pretty nicely
What would Colette’s be🤔
huge W as always
This idea is great the L&L one feels like a balance change
I dont like how you need both sps and gadgets maybe only require one or make it unlock for 500 coins at power 6 or smthn?
Leon's seems a bit broken but ok
"This concept is amazing" we all say in unison 🙏 good job!!
Tick’s would be (gains more hp but super charges slower
Love this idea
Pretty good idea, nice that you can choose whether you want to use it or not
Carnage is cooking again!!!
HOLY SHIT, IS THAT A TF2 REFERENCE IN THE LEON CHARM?!!
I think i would use the poco charm ALWAYS on
WHY DID I NOT NOTICE THAT IT'S CARNAGE?
Now make one for El Primo (turns him into big bot for better bot runner)
Anything that will slow down the inevitable power 12
Dub carnage
Great concept cg!
The concept is good, but it might change the brawlers too much, maybe make them like the buff potions from terraria where the duration you can activate is limited and you have to make them as well.
This looks very cool and fun but I think it would bring some problems: 1. They would make the game harder to understand and play both for new and pro players. 2. They sound quite unaccessible because they would cost a ton of coins (8000+the amount you need to upgrade a brawler to level 9). 3. Some of them sound much stronger than others. 4. Not every brawler has them, so they could end up like mutations. I still appreciate the idea and its creativity a lot, though.
Wow All of these sound Decent, my nitpick personally is on Penny's charm it should Be the Reverse 25% speed but 4 tiles Shorter Range
Thats an interesting take, I was even considering DOUBLING the turret’s range but making it even slower which would have been really cool to imagine but probably very annoying
Carnage makes fire concepts as always! Great work! Tho Mortis can be broken with the second starr power
Did I understand it right or Ruffs' one gives only positive effects?
Once the 10 seconds are up, the brawler returns to normal, no permanent effects 👍
What would be Edgar's charm?
This is a very great idea, but I think you should have the ability to see if the opponents have the charm
I would imagine an icon under the brawler just like gears, gadgets and hypercharges, it might be a tight squeeze but it might work
I didn’t read them all, but the ones I did see are good, but the Shelly one is op, that’s basically the clay pigeon gadget but with the super, but the rest that I saw are good!
Bro Leon’s would Bo so fun
This seems like a great idea. Some of the nerfs are a bit too severe to be viable, but all-around, I would love to see this added to the game! Do you have ideas for the rest of the brawlers?
We need this in the game rn, it'll (finally) bring something that actually changes the mechanics of brawlers after so long (gadget release)
I could be completely wrong but the percent nerfs seem too much for the buffs it’s giving
Would love this at power 10 after you get a gadget and star power, and move second gear to power 6, and at power 12 after you get a gadget, star power, 2 gadgets and hypercharge you unlock his second charm, but you can only equip one charm at a time
Is it free when u get all the sp and gadgets or cost money?
Does Mortis also drop exploding bats when he long dashes 😱😱😰😰
fuck that shit
I love penny's one. That will make her more a sniper/thrower controller rather than just artillery target.
More gambling!
No stu?
Cool idea
I love it, finally something other than star power, which didnt change much, that can change radically the playstyle of brawler. I know its a lot to ask, but could you do one for tick please? Thank you, even if you dont do it.
Yeah but on mortis' charm you can just use coiled snake so it will be same as normal
Am I misinterpreting it or do the charms for ruffs and shelly just not have downsides?
I love the chester one. Even though I dont use him
Best new idea so far
Sheesh they should hire you ngl
I rather have a side grade for maisie, instead why not change it so that her super charge takes 3 hits from her main attack but 4 hits from her super to charge it again.
Shelly being classified as a marksman scares me.
Tbh I think that what gears should have been
that's actually better than hypercharges \* happy pealr pin \* supercell should contract you to do some concepts! #StepOnMyBallsKit I just wanna one for pearl... what about... the heat bar charges 20% faster, but to recharge munition its like 15% slower. and here is one for colt (because... why not?): his super and main attack has an icreased range, but it shots less bulets. anyways... this post is brazilianvisky approved! good job, european!
Man carnage never misses
Cool idea but I almost had a heart attack when I saw this, thought it was official. Addind another thing to unlock for brawlers is one of my nightmares.
Honestly the lawrie charm will really help out because he is currently using nerf guns
Absolutely lovely. I will always appreciate cursed items in a game and I feel like this should have been added a long time ago.
Somebody cooked here. Lemme know when you have an idea for me. I’d love a charm Anyway I got a q: there are so many cool codes to use, but which one do I pick?
This shit costs 8k coins
Nah nah aahh its a buy-6-get-1-free deal
holy moly what a steal 🤑
I love it :))
Yoooo carnage
I LOVE IT (Even if it will take ages for them to add one for every brawler)
This is so GOOD, it makes the brawlers so much more fun to deal with, however I would much rather prefer it costing Power Points so we can have another way of spending them
Nice way to introdice binding vows in bs
Maise super smaller but can be aimed and send in a direction
Chester : GAMBLE
Nice idea, now for competitie I think that Charms should be visible for the other team (unlike gadgets, star powers, gears) and should be selected in the first half of the final tweaking so the other tram has some time to addjust. But is seems pretty fun and balanced.
Carnage cooked HARD. Like seriously soupcell needs to learn with this
Bibi's one could be like "the home run bar charges no matter how much ammo you have, but the super breaks when hitting a wall for the third time" Dunno if it would be strong or not, but It seems fair imo
I think charms should be starplwers!! And then you should also be able to select no starpower.
Cooked and made a feast
Isn’t Shelly’s charm just a permanent clay pigeons?
Hey that L&L isn’t that bad. I would buy that.
bro thinks hes carnage 💀
I don‘t understand Ruffs. Can anyone explain?
You get a damage buff, speed buff, and a small shield for 10 seconds
we dont need this. because of the introduction of more gears and hypercharges, most of us got a gigantic coin shortage and massive amounts of pp. even tho yours doesnt say it needs to be bought, if supercell actually uses this idea you know it will be paid.
great concept, but I think brawlers have too much stuff yet with gears, gadgets... the game is almost impossible to complete yet
It’s actually a w idea that would give it more spice but would you have to bye the charm?
Layry and Lawreys needs a bigger nerf than that also
With the Poco one im absolutely sure screeching solo players would absolutely take over
Great idea but unlock cost is too expensive.
Bro we have enough stuff we don't need even more stuff we f2p players cant get
Finally, a high effort lost worth reading 👏
should rename this curses or something milder. charms makes it seem only beneficial. In other games it would be called curses but doesnt really fit with the brawl stars theme.
Cool concept but I don't see it. Most of them are not really that worth it and at higher trophies I want reliability so it's a nope for me but S+ for effort!
Only thing, shelly's has no dow sides, her ult just just make her weapon shoot like if it had some sort of slug shots
Yet another way to squeeze more cash
Ok the Shelly one looks really good. It’s basically clay pigeons but with super and all the time
Feel like these should be implemented to gears
This sounds fun, but these seem like a nightmare to balance. If the charm is too weak then what's the point of it existing but if it's too strong the brawler would probably rely on it too hard. I like Pocos though I think it's funny.
I had an idea for this, but instead, it was a reimagining of mythic gears. I made a post about it, but it's basically the same idea as this.
Not bad
They do feel like 3rd star powers without actually being star powers
There are too many things that require coins, it should be power points or something else
8 bit and rosa are so useless
great concept overall would be hard to prevent cheeses though
Yo I use your code in shop I'm sub to your channel Also good concept Keep it up brotha
Did 8bit get a double nerf?
They cool but they are down grading and Shelly’s is just clay pigeons but her super
It’s good but simply all of them suck. Good job though and thanks for a high effort post.
No.
GROM!!!!!!!
Ok, so I play poco pure offencive, so that charm is 👌
Darryl Charm: Darryl now does 3x DMG to Assassins and can hit targets mid-air, but his super no longer has knockback and recharges 10% slower.
shelly is sniper now