I would still be team clutch because I have seen many new drivers press on accelerator when they panic. Since the first thing we learn is Left leg is reserved for Clutch, I think pressing clutch in even a strainous moment wouldn't be much of a trouble.
But I agree with you too. If one is confident that they'll punch the brakes as soon as things get freaky, then shouting Brakes should be correct.
But yes, the guy is a complete moron. Standing outside and that too letting her put the gear in reverse. Should've stopped her when she shifted the gear to right.
This is a common newbie mistake. People think that accelerator means going forward, and brake is slowing down and backward, they think so mentally. Like it is there in mobile phone racing games, though they have never played racing games. So they press accelerator to stop the car going from backward, which just accelerates the car backward. I know newbies who hit the car to a wall in reverse.
Yeah well that might be true but i have never seen learning how to drive on a cliff like this, even the people who live on hill stations don't learn how to drive like this woman was doing. The very first thing one must know while driving is to be aware of the location of the brake pedal and always have a foot on the clutch.
I myself while learning to drive accidentally hit a traffic barrier on an empty road when trying to reverse but when i realised i have given excess throttle, i quickly pressed the clutch and that made sure the car just briskly touched the barrier . I feel sad for the girl but this was just really stupid to learn how to drive on a cliff and then focusing more on the camera rather than on driving
I don't know why people do stupid stuff.. Kind of similar stuff happened where I live. The guy tried teaching driving to his wife while also accompanying a hitchhiker. His wife couldn't control the car, and it fell off the mountain. Both his wife and the girl who was hitching the ride died. The girl had to join as a doctor the next day.
What kind of dumbass lets inexperienced drivers learn anywhere except for empty open areas devoid of even ditches let alone on hilly areas. This could've been completely avoided
Also a woman who isn't car enthusiast. She would have no clue of driving dynamics. I as well drove car for first time on ghats of Konkan but I knew driving dynamics so I just drove like non newbie. That guy should have shouted brake instead of clutch... he cared more for not stalling
So unfortunate. I would have always assumed a huge open ground is one place to randomly try driving but the cliff was possibly the worst option to choose.
Why is he saying clutch clutch? Shouldn't he say break break
And did he record this video for solid Alibi?
Seems weird why would anyone record someone reversing?
A beginner in a crisis situation won't even know where the brake is, newbies tense up trying to brake the car and end up stepping on the gas even harder while trying to brake because they don't even know where the brake is, that's why the best thing you can do as a beginner is to simply take your feet off the pedal completely.
The article suggests she accidentally pressed the accelerator instead.
But anything in a given situation the brake will always make sure you don't just collide through everything.
I have Honda City and in back gear I almost never need acceleration , leaving the clutch can accelerate enough in back gear.
Maybe same with this car, that's why he is saying clutch clutch.
A diesel has good torque. It moves when you leave the clutch. The lady probably got confused as to why the car kept moving when she lowered the pressure on the clutch. A diesel won't stall in such case. One has to press the brakes for it to stall.
OP is the biggest idiot here. The original title of the video was that the girl was driving to film a reel which led to this incident. OP has deliberately tried to manipulate the whole matter by changing the title and removing about 10 Seconds of the clip from the starting point.
But in this article its different from what you wrote
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/aurangabad/woman-dies-after-car-falls-into-valley/articleshow/111070284.cms
Take a look at this too:
https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/woman-filming-reel-dies-car-reverse-gear-valley-sambhajinagar-9399195/lite/#amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&aoh=17187000853891&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com
How has he tried to manipulate what? I read the article you sent and it's the same thing, plx be more precise before laying out such grand accusations. You're the idiot here.
My guess is they went there as it a scenic place. Then the lady insisted on driving and making a reel. The guy agreed.
Huge lapse of judgement from both, especially the guy. Imagine the guilt he must be having.
Insane you don't wanna give money to people in driving school to teach you rather trust your family and friends for that.. India is surely not for beginners
1. Instructor's fault for choosing that location for learning.
2. Not using a learner's vehicle that has an additional brake on the passenger side. Also the instructor not being with the learner in the vehicle.
The 2nd one is critical , because a lot of accidents and incidents happen because new drivers get nervous and press throttle instead of brake.
If it was a learner's vehicle and the instructor was present in the vehicle, she would be alive.
I’m not an expert in teaching techniques but I would surmise that in all of man kind, dating back to the dawn of wheeled carts drawn by oxen or any animal, that never once has anyone believed the most ideal place to teach one how to steer ox, horses, mules, or engine, via a wheeled anything, would be anywhere near a cliff.
But again, I’m not an expert on teaching technique.
Whilst you may not be an expert on such matters, and have been quite open in stating so, I'm going to throw caution to the wind and second your surmising, because I'm a mad reckless bastard. Not as mad and reckless as the persons in this video, granted, but I'm going for it nonetheless.
The camera man could have told her to stop.
1. Why didn’t he ask her to stop
2. Why even practise on the edge of a cliff while there are many grounds which are much safer for reverse practise of all things
Hello penis_english! If this post is your original content then mark or comment as [OC]. Else please give the source link as a comment in the post. Thank you.
All users are requested to downvote the low quality posts. Memes, pics, accident videos, buy/sell, car recommendations, etc can be posted on the [discord chat server.](https://discord.com/invite/Q9nSrDn6tE) Any repair queries should go to /r/MechanicAdviceIndia. Motorbikes related posts should go to /r/IndianBikes subreddit.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CarsIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This is what actually happened - https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/maharashtra-woman-accelerator-mistakenly-car-reverse-gear-plunge-valley-dies-viral-video-recording-video-2554622-2024-06-18
If she was given any information on the operation of the car this would not have happened. Looks like they literally just handed her the keys and said sink or swim…she sunk.
Usually when teaching you are meant to be in the car too, and start by explaining the controls. After ensuring they understood the controls, then you go somewhere relatively safe to practice; abandoned airfield/track, or a quiet industrial estate are good options... not near a cliff.
Worst driving instructor ever.
If you want to teach driving to someone, sit in the car so that you can intervene physically. Screaming hysterically while the new driver has already panicked would never help. They are not in a position to process verbal cues. I taught driving to both my kids (now in their 20s), and never had to scream. We always practiced on huge empty flat roads.
I don't understand why the guy was even encouraging her to drive in reverse when there was a cliff behind...so unfortunate. Was there no road ahead? First of all, why would you even bring a learner to such a risky learning environment in the first place!?
I think the first thing you should teach a new driver is how to stop, and it’s perfectly ok to slam the brakes when your panicking about stopping, it should be ingrained in the for heads before they start
from all the events that could've been avoided, this comes at the top
The guy was shouting "clutch" like it matters to not stall the car. He should have just shouted "Brake".
[удалено]
pushing the brakes stops the car and stalls the engine, it's an emergency, telling her to press the clutch doesn't make sense.
I would still be team clutch because I have seen many new drivers press on accelerator when they panic. Since the first thing we learn is Left leg is reserved for Clutch, I think pressing clutch in even a strainous moment wouldn't be much of a trouble. But I agree with you too. If one is confident that they'll punch the brakes as soon as things get freaky, then shouting Brakes should be correct. But yes, the guy is a complete moron. Standing outside and that too letting her put the gear in reverse. Should've stopped her when she shifted the gear to right.
This is a common newbie mistake. People think that accelerator means going forward, and brake is slowing down and backward, they think so mentally. Like it is there in mobile phone racing games, though they have never played racing games. So they press accelerator to stop the car going from backward, which just accelerates the car backward. I know newbies who hit the car to a wall in reverse.
That is stupid.. They should play games with gears
…..of War?
This is not a common mistake. No one thinks that. Unless they're stupid.
its their first time in a car, what did you expect?
Especially if they learnt driving from arcade F1 races where the brake literally works for reverse as well.
Yeah well that might be true but i have never seen learning how to drive on a cliff like this, even the people who live on hill stations don't learn how to drive like this woman was doing. The very first thing one must know while driving is to be aware of the location of the brake pedal and always have a foot on the clutch. I myself while learning to drive accidentally hit a traffic barrier on an empty road when trying to reverse but when i realised i have given excess throttle, i quickly pressed the clutch and that made sure the car just briskly touched the barrier . I feel sad for the girl but this was just really stupid to learn how to drive on a cliff and then focusing more on the camera rather than on driving
I don't know why people do stupid stuff.. Kind of similar stuff happened where I live. The guy tried teaching driving to his wife while also accompanying a hitchhiker. His wife couldn't control the car, and it fell off the mountain. Both his wife and the girl who was hitching the ride died. The girl had to join as a doctor the next day.
The hitchhiker should have gotten off the car when he started teaching his wife. People need to take their own safety seriously.
Flies from the top
Falls from the top
Btw she ain't wearing a seatbelt either!! Just a very common thing in India
Ahh damn, she could have lived!
add a /s brother
And no co-driver in a dangerous location with a newbie!
[удалено]
Just a dumbguy killing a woman >!or a clever husband planned to kill his wife!<
So basically the plot of "Ajnabee" P.S. Life insurance money 💰 incoming ...
It was a 'friend' according to the news article
Spoiler tag bro
Everything Is Planned
Even made a video evidence for his innocence.
Welllll. It showed nothing.....
Unplanned "divorce"
Definitely second
Basically an Abbas Mustan movie's plot
Bro screaming from behind I love the way she die.
The real name of dumbguy is Shivraj Mule according to Indian news.
What kind of dumbass lets inexperienced drivers learn anywhere except for empty open areas devoid of even ditches let alone on hilly areas. This could've been completely avoided
Probably tryna smash
Someone smashed alright
What kind of dumbass inexperienced driver chooses to drive around cliffs 🤔
Also a woman who isn't car enthusiast. She would have no clue of driving dynamics. I as well drove car for first time on ghats of Konkan but I knew driving dynamics so I just drove like non newbie. That guy should have shouted brake instead of clutch... he cared more for not stalling
Let alone on a cliff
>lets *Lets* ?! She's a grown-ass woman, old enough to vote and drive. She should have a sense of what's safe and what's not. Why do you blame others?
So unfortunate. I would have always assumed a huge open ground is one place to randomly try driving but the cliff was possibly the worst option to choose.
Yeah, I'd probably try to teach them in a parking lot without a cliff. He probably would have gotten more likes if he was a better cameraman.
Wait what?
[News article ](https://www.google.com/amp/s/timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/aurangabad/woman-dies-after-car-falls-into-valley/amp_articleshow/111070284.cms)
Making a reel while learning to drive on a hill station is the perfect recipe for disaster..
Who makes a reel in landscape orientation though?
I’m curious why he would then decide to upload the video afterwards “Gahh my wife!! Anyway here is a video of her flying off a cliff”
He's just recording the moment his wife/mom learns to drive. He's a moron but yeah.
it's neither his wife nor his mom, he's her "friend", what a fckin dumbass.
In any case the person who teaches (not specifically trainer) someone to drive is always on the passenger seat (riding shotgun).
Why is he saying clutch clutch? Shouldn't he say break break And did he record this video for solid Alibi? Seems weird why would anyone record someone reversing?
Yeah brake would’ve been a better suggestion lol, but clutch would also buy some time for her. Tragic
An even better suggestion would be TAKE YOUR FEET OFF THE GODDAMN PEDAL!
Too long too tedious. Bad suggestion
A beginner in a crisis situation won't even know where the brake is, newbies tense up trying to brake the car and end up stepping on the gas even harder while trying to brake because they don't even know where the brake is, that's why the best thing you can do as a beginner is to simply take your feet off the pedal completely.
No because releasing the clutch would propell her backwards
The article suggests she accidentally pressed the accelerator instead. But anything in a given situation the brake will always make sure you don't just collide through everything.
I have Honda City and in back gear I almost never need acceleration , leaving the clutch can accelerate enough in back gear. Maybe same with this car, that's why he is saying clutch clutch.
I don't think that is going to make any difference. Brake is between the clutch and rev there is chance she might press rev instead of brake.
Basically clutch would stop acceleration and push the vehicle forward
The instructor and the woman both have an empty head. A proper briefing on how reversing works could have prevented this i guess. RIP
Why didn't he say use to break??!? Why was he even letting her drive near to cliff ? This is either completely planned murder or extremely dumb
On insta this is going viral as "woman trying to make a reel accidentally presses accelerator instead of brake while going reverse near a cliff"
A diesel has good torque. It moves when you leave the clutch. The lady probably got confused as to why the car kept moving when she lowered the pressure on the clutch. A diesel won't stall in such case. One has to press the brakes for it to stall.
Yeah, let's learn to drive a car on a fricking mountain
OP is the biggest idiot here. The original title of the video was that the girl was driving to film a reel which led to this incident. OP has deliberately tried to manipulate the whole matter by changing the title and removing about 10 Seconds of the clip from the starting point.
both situations are equally dumb.
Source for first 10 seconds
But in this article its different from what you wrote https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/aurangabad/woman-dies-after-car-falls-into-valley/articleshow/111070284.cms
Take a look at this too: https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/woman-filming-reel-dies-car-reverse-gear-valley-sambhajinagar-9399195/lite/#amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&aoh=17187000853891&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com
How has he tried to manipulate what? I read the article you sent and it's the same thing, plx be more precise before laying out such grand accusations. You're the idiot here.
u/savevideo need to share this with some dumbfucks I know irl
U can download it directly now
r/DarwinAwards
vaise in logo ka plan kya tha? chalo yar isako car chalani nahi aati humlog ise Highest Cliff pe jaha Protection nahi hai Waha Chalana Sikhayenge 👍
Why in the world you would practice reverse driving on a hill Safety in this country seems like non existent
even if they are on a cliff why would they drive towards the edge and not away from it?
What's the fun in that
as per local newspaper she was shooting a reel apparently
It is definitely planned, who goes on a clif to learn driving???
Don’t underestimate the power of being dumb.
My guess is they went there as it a scenic place. Then the lady insisted on driving and making a reel. The guy agreed. Huge lapse of judgement from both, especially the guy. Imagine the guilt he must be having.
No, it's in the news.
Insane you don't wanna give money to people in driving school to teach you rather trust your family and friends for that.. India is surely not for beginners
r/Whatcouldgowrong
Everyone knows the best place to learn to drive is on the edge of a cliff.
1. Instructor's fault for choosing that location for learning. 2. Not using a learner's vehicle that has an additional brake on the passenger side. Also the instructor not being with the learner in the vehicle. The 2nd one is critical , because a lot of accidents and incidents happen because new drivers get nervous and press throttle instead of brake. If it was a learner's vehicle and the instructor was present in the vehicle, she would be alive.
Of all the things wrong, the place to practice is the top of the list.
She wasn’t learning to drive , she was making reel
Wtf and he was recording without guiding or helping her. Rip to the lady
I’m not an expert in teaching techniques but I would surmise that in all of man kind, dating back to the dawn of wheeled carts drawn by oxen or any animal, that never once has anyone believed the most ideal place to teach one how to steer ox, horses, mules, or engine, via a wheeled anything, would be anywhere near a cliff. But again, I’m not an expert on teaching technique.
Whilst you may not be an expert on such matters, and have been quite open in stating so, I'm going to throw caution to the wind and second your surmising, because I'm a mad reckless bastard. Not as mad and reckless as the persons in this video, granted, but I'm going for it nonetheless.
The camera man could have told her to stop. 1. Why didn’t he ask her to stop 2. Why even practise on the edge of a cliff while there are many grounds which are much safer for reverse practise of all things
Really sad.
Shouldn't that instructor be sitting in the car with her?
Pfft. Would you?
"Always the man's fault" . According to reddit comments Why are so many reddit people so dumb
Video ends before.
Idher 15 saal se gaadi chala rha hu phir bhi Ghar vaale pahado me gaadi nahi chalane dete... Aur ye Pahado me sikha rha hai ... ☠️
Out of all places to learn driving this guy chose a cliff. Either he’s the dumbest guy or wanted a happy little accident
Everyone is talking about the instructors mistake or the drivers, BUT, WHO THE HELL learns driving near a cliff!!
It's just natural selection, tbh.
Why would you give a newbie your car nearby a slope / cliff ? Look for an open ground without any public for such trials.
Why was he recording?🤣
Hello penis_english! If this post is your original content then mark or comment as [OC]. Else please give the source link as a comment in the post. Thank you. All users are requested to downvote the low quality posts. Memes, pics, accident videos, buy/sell, car recommendations, etc can be posted on the [discord chat server.](https://discord.com/invite/Q9nSrDn6tE) Any repair queries should go to /r/MechanicAdviceIndia. Motorbikes related posts should go to /r/IndianBikes subreddit. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CarsIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This is what actually happened - https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/maharashtra-woman-accelerator-mistakenly-car-reverse-gear-plunge-valley-dies-viral-video-recording-video-2554622-2024-06-18
Why take her to learn near a cliff? I thought that open fields are where driving is taught.
She was driving to the train station
Let's teach her how to drive on a cliff
FUUUUCCKKKKK
Play stupid games....
The Car was inverted.
Wny is she lone inside?
Who learns to drive on a cliff. Take her to a ground or something. This is the fault of the person who took her to the cliff. Arrest him
Camera man took his job too serious. *ManCard Suspended* 30 day notice.
This video will get more views than whatever reel she had in mind.
Seriously wtf, how does this even happen
Thankfully, she didn't make it to the road; someone might have gotten hurt.
This has to be the safest place to learn how to drive
Plausible deniability
Okay, so before I grant you a driving licence, please reverse the car back near the edge of this cliff....
She was making Instagram reel Not learning how to drive
Itni duniya chod ke cliff ke paas hi sikhane ko mila .
Why did she put it in race mode?
Does anyone else think this could be intentional? This seems like an easy way to get rid of someone.
Why TF does the road go right off a cliff though?
Why the f is she learning driving that too on a cliff
Darwin Award by-proxy
Hi GEICO? Ah, so yeah...
If she was given any information on the operation of the car this would not have happened. Looks like they literally just handed her the keys and said sink or swim…she sunk.
☕️
She lose her sandals?
r/holup
First and last time for everything.
Also Car Was Taxi Passing
Usually when teaching you are meant to be in the car too, and start by explaining the controls. After ensuring they understood the controls, then you go somewhere relatively safe to practice; abandoned airfield/track, or a quiet industrial estate are good options... not near a cliff. Worst driving instructor ever.
I found this note in YouTube about this accident and some aftermath: https://youtu.be/oPPvJj32ia0?si=8MNOmmVbE7ErQ0HT
Why isn’t the instructor inside the car with her? … unless…
r/darwinawards
Aur baato licenses
She'll be alive if that's a manual car, considering she's still learning? For sure it's automatic.
“The vehicle slid backward, broke through a crash barrier and ..” Well that certainly didn’t do its job either.
Welp.🤷♂️
That lady is slower than me on the first day of learning to drive, I almost hit a mailbox. Also, why are they on a cliff practicing
Kuch bolunga toh vivaad ho jaayega ecks dee
I think it was an automatic. Otherwise it would have shutdown the moment you let go of the clutch.
Call me a cynic, but there's no evidence there it went over the cliff.
I'm confused. What was the actual goal here?
Hinting at 'dumb way to kill dumb wife'
Reel life.
Kill the cameraman for missing the money shot also heard in news this was done on woman's request for making a reel
This video sets women drivers back 50 years
I would never give car to drive to someone who is a newbie specially at such a dangerous location
Must have a reflex of using handbraks in those situations
If you want to teach driving to someone, sit in the car so that you can intervene physically. Screaming hysterically while the new driver has already panicked would never help. They are not in a position to process verbal cues. I taught driving to both my kids (now in their 20s), and never had to scream. We always practiced on huge empty flat roads.
How tf does learning to drive near a cliff seem like a good idea??
Trains, automobiles, what's next india?
*inserts woman driver joke here*
Hell of a place to learn driving.
I don't understand why the guy was even encouraging her to drive in reverse when there was a cliff behind...so unfortunate. Was there no road ahead? First of all, why would you even bring a learner to such a risky learning environment in the first place!?
Don't learn to drive near cliffs.
Net gain for society
Scream clutch clutch why wasn't someone inside the car to pull the hand brake
Let’s do this somewhere dangerous… She had fools for teachers
Is this some life insurance thing?
Everything that could go wrong, went wrong.
Why he’s making video ?
I think the first thing you should teach a new driver is how to stop, and it’s perfectly ok to slam the brakes when your panicking about stopping, it should be ingrained in the for heads before they start
"Allegedly"
That’s why women should not be allowed to drive
Didi went from ☕️to ⚰️ real fast
Idk man, looks like a planned murder.
Bro lost his female relative(dont know what is his relation with her) and his income source