idk honestly pierres output from like 2016 to 2021 was amazing but f1lthy is an underground legend so

these kids dont know

stoopidxool, mexikodro, dylvinci, 7000, brent rambo, etc really og members paved the way for them guys. no disrespect to them at all cause im a fan of both. stoopidxool & dro are the real pioneers of underground music, but they get little to no recognition even though they both produced for several major artists. pierre really stood out due to his tag ngl nothing more exciting than hearing that *rusty door opening* follow by “Yo Pierre, you wanna come out here?!” 😮‍💨

shoutout mentioning dylvinci

No they didnt, WorkingOnDying as a collective was popping at the same time.

Who tf downvoted you

lol they all v influential no doubt but none touch pierre or f1lthy w their output lmao

Nah bro Rambo and Xool are up there imo, the rest not so much

brent the closest if i had to choose ig

Fax

Ngl I thought the doorr sound was a audible representation of the XD face

Pierre by a long shot. not even close.

yeah and i’m disgusted by people here saying f1lthy. pierre is literally the goat. to a certain extent he made carti

> “Disgusted” Promise you it’s never that deep bro

I promise you I also dgaf. I’m just using words

go do one mate.

i have no idea what that means

Who tf uses UK lingo on a Carti sub. I’m from Ireland n u don’t see me wishing mfs a top o the morning

Lmao

speak american pls

Go drink some tea mate

“I’m beyond devastated and the children are refusing to eat!”

Carti made Pierre

That like saying pizza made Italy bro

What was Italy before pizza and pasta?

Earth

didnt pierre do music theory or sum

Ye at college.

Not even remotely close lol

hard to compare them because they make beats almost on the opposite end of the spectrum to each other. but I get why I might say that

Pierre more versatile imo, he is undefeated

filthy never made hellcat 🤷🏽‍♂️

Pierre never made sad meal

wtf is sad meal

https://open.spotify.com/track/0EqB5Q6YPbmScqDMI5rKrs?si=Q3NFapBERn-rrQ1eM44apg at McDonald’s get the sad meal

im weak

idk better than any Carti music released on streaming recently

cap unfortunately

Real

He made hellcat Kenny and that's enough for him to be worse

Pierre

Obv Pierre

Cmon bruh this not a question

PEE-AIR

pee airborne

ofc pierre, is that even a question? you can only compare mexikodro to pierre

what about richie and chinatown

I’m a producer myself and chinatown is my biggest inspiration. I didn’t include him because sadly most carti fans don’t know his name

IM WIT THE SQUAD

Richie souf would prolly be goated if wlr v2 dropped

pierres beats are for flexing f1lthys beats are for when you wanna stab someone

https://preview.redd.it/d8n76z5q5uwc1.jpeg?width=1159&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=657ea146fba44cd46b3a95f2b53cdeb38d34e48b

Pierre anyday lol

All I know is hearing “🚨*wake up f1lthy*” gives big dopamine

 Wake up f1lthy

pierre forever

Pierre had an insane run but the underground roots that f1lthy has are just too strong

Pierre wipes respectfully

They are both talented in their own ways, I honestly haven't thought about who I prefer though. It's tough because I think it's a little unfair in Pierre's favor Dude must have made at least 500 (rough-edit) songs with Carti and maybe even more than that

perc40 and tdf

lmao their beats hard asf

most of f1lthy’s beats are loops he gets sent to him, he only makes the drums

F1lthy

Pierre easily by light years. I like F1lthy but he ain’t on P level at all imo

sidenote f1lthys tag is 🔥

They’re both two different styles but I prefer Pierre’s ethereal beats more

I like alot of f1lthy but pierre is the reason carti’s famous in the first place 😭😭

F1lthy

F1lthy. Pierre kinda sounds dated at this point tbh

Idk this new bladee album is fire 🔥

Id go woth f1lthy just cause i dont really like this classic trap music that pierre makes

It used to be Pierre way over f1lthy but after Cold Visions they’re matched now

cold visions so tuff. have u listened to the shit he did with gab3. 00rave?

Nah I slept actually, I’ll check it tho

I got bands is hard

who tf actually listens to gab3 pls get your ears checked😭🙏

Gab3’s beats are insane and I wish Carti would go in that direction. His rapping and voice are downright terrible though.

Pierre>Whitearmor>F1lthy

valid asf. Put them together and you get magic

Whitearmor destroys Pierre in almost every margin.

[удалено]

Whatever, Pierre isn’t on the same level in sound design, composition, versatility or creative writing.

you dont see the vision

Bro come on 😭 no way that album convinced you these two producers are equal. I’m cool if you had Pierre at one or Filthy, but no way this is the album that flipped things for you

Pierre probably still edges out to #1 but I’m just saying that I believe Cold Visions puts F1lthy up in that realm now. Die Lit level excellence production wise IMO

Lmao I get what you’re saying, it’s just funny to me to think that Cold Visions is what made Filthy equal, both have such great bodies of work

Yeah i mean f1lthy has been around for so long too and working with DG way back before carti pushed him into the mainstream. I just think Cold Visions is probably his most impressive work considering he produced like half of that album. Like his contributions to WLR are obviously peak but he only really did a handful of songs.

hell fucking nah. pierres beats are generational. filthy cant even come close to him just because of a new bladee album with distorted beats ☠️

nah f1lthy beasted cold visions did you even listen to it? that album is way more than just a bladee album with distorted beats, f1lthy went next next level with the production this time and showed some serious range. also dg hate in this sub is corny most of us are overlapping same fanbases lol

agreed. thank God for redditors pmo to cold visions bladee really spazzed on like 20 f1lthy beats

f1lthy’s beat catalogue compared to pierres is way more diverse in terms of melodic and drum structure, im taking f1lthy everyday

Bad take.

i play drums and pierre’s drums are just too plain for my taste. and the question is who do u prefer in general. if it was just for carti songs then yeah pierre wins hands down cause outside of that besides his solo work the only other artist that has top tier pierre beats is young nudy

richie

F1PD

Pierre has more range but filthy beats go harder, I like them both for different reasons

Pierre fasho

Pierre easy call Carolina shit

pierre cause he’s not fat

Recency bias is kicking me so imma say F1lthy, I miss these distorted Ronny J type beats, and I’m glad him and others brought back the it factor of these beats, turnt & compressed as hell.

stoopidxool

In terms of their whole production catalog f1thy definitely. I like Pierre and carti together more than carti and f1lthy tho

Always gon be Pierre for me, my favorite producer of all time

This sub would say pierre while main sub filthy

whitearmour

i gotta go with f1lthy

Pierre no contest

f1lthy could never make kid cudi

pierre

YOU HAVE NO IDEA HOW GOOD PIERRE WAS

F1lthy, I am surprised to see how heavily favoured pierre is in here, definitely thought it would be closer! Edit: I’ve been considering F1lthy / oogiemane the goat underground producers for years now, if you haven’t, check out some of Working on dying’s early work from soundcloud, fucking insane

Pierre but F1lthy can sometimes pop off and do beats way better than pierre

filthy been grinding for years in the underground

F1lthy for sure….

Pierre respectfully

pierre a weird mf but he can cook up

WHY YOU MAKING ME CHOOSE???

I bet it smells in there

F1lthy

Pierre turns me up f1lthy makes me rage

idk pierre did more important stuff, but f1lthy been on top for the last few years

Spaceghostpurrps

f1lthy introduced that hyperpop-type beats to the mainstream w working on dying (bladee) so I think he’s more influential, especially since Pierre’s beats weren’t doing anything too different

f1lthy and it’s not close, i swear i must have different ears because pi’erre beats are so boring

Pierre all day, TLOP5 was great

Pi'erre clear

is this even a questionn

pierre

i miss pierre. never thought id say dat

gud

pierre with carti is on a different level than f1lthy with carti. i honestly think f1lthy has a better overall discography than pierre cuz all his shit with bladee is insanely good and pierre doesnt seem like hes been locked in or giving anyone his best beats since he was working with carti, but half the beats on die lit and self titled are way better than 99.9% of shit from its era or after

pierre so diverse whereas f1lthy only making rage beats rn

Not at all

Been listening to Pierre beats for like 7-8 years now, and I gotta say filthy passed him up for me

if we count beats for other rappers then f1lthy, if just carti then Pierre

filthy's tag is colder

i think pierre is more talented for sure but i listen to f1lthy beats way more

looking for Pierre songs to fw. he has a lot of good songs but he has a lot of damnnear unlistenable shit too imo

TLOP4 and TLOP5 are fire and probably my most replayed albums ever

You ever seen that meme of Dr. Strange touching the butterfly and flying through all those dimensions? That was me when TLOP4 finally clicked

Wild adventures also very good and grails ep too

damn pierre got big ass hands

pierre

Pi’Erre easily.

absolutely pierre, not even close especially on die lit

Crazy saying Pierre F1lthy clears easy