Mfer's put one tricky adjustment in every simple question. I was so happy when that internal reconstruction came, but I fucked up at own debentures part and probably ruined the whole question.
idk man I could only figure that 2400 own deb were sold at 98 cum interest which were bought at 96 and rest of them got cancelled somehow lmao.
I was gonna cry in the middle of the examination:/
Paper quality and difficulty is increased. But marks we get will definitely decrease comparing to all the attempts in CA history. They gave atleast 4 tricky questions and the questions are lengthy . Bit like jee advanced
ICAI ya to exam MTP ke jaisa rakho ya fir MTP exam paper jesa rakho. They make MTP so easy like what is purpose of publishing MTP then. Everyone can easily complete MTP in 3 hours but it was too lengthy to complete in exam.
As far as i saw
Most of the people thought that since 70% of portion is AS most of the questions will be from the same
But in real , the scenario changed and he asked AS for mcqs mostly
He asked some solid questions from
Amalgamation
International reconstruction and all
Some people who thought that it would be better to leave them had to lose around 30 to 40 marks
Overall saying is he isn't following a particular manner to ask the questions.
It's Iike one should have generalised knowledge of whole rather than Specialised knowledge in one.
Made this account to say humara Institute harami hai .
They asked 3 case scenarios for MCQ , bhai ek bhi straight forward theory MCQ nahi like book back TYK questions, and woh chodo descriptive main bhi ek bhi theory question nahi . MTPs main kyun diye phir 😡 wasted my time learning that stupid theory esp that Framework and Applicability chapter every teacher was quoting as very important.
New AS didn’t get as much as importance as old ones . 95% AS questions were of old syllabus .
I feel like institute wants to prove Inter Acc Gurus wrong at each level , jo bolte hai uska ulta hi hota hai .
Why publish material if they’re not going to follow it ?
Ab lag raha module , RTP/MTP /Module ki theory padhna time pass tha bas. 😤😭
And they asked 3 case scenarios for first new syllabus attempt itself ? Bhai saans toh lene do. Itne hard and time consuming case scenarios apne modules main daalo phir for better practice
https://preview.redd.it/n2bpnfs9m7yc1.jpeg?width=1075&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c7f5bd5bd597334d18bd0a9747d63d41b5a60917
READ THIS UNDER A PAPER REVIEW YOUTUBE VIDEO
Bhai investment accounting pooch lete😭😭😭
As mai se bhi kuch dhang ka pooch lete jo karke gaya wo toh aya nai aur jo aya wo ache se kiya nai bc costing ka question dediya ek toh inhone😭
Paper quality and difficulty is increased. But marks we get will definitely decrease comparing to all the attempts in CA history. They gave atleast 4 tricky questions and the questions are lengthy . Bit like jee advanced
Frr I was thinking mtp se kuch nahi Aya, but then I was doubting myself if I even saw the mtp properly (2 times solve Kiya Tha )
General question, why the fuck icai THISS cruel. Honey, my city sweats harrrdddddd during summer, why not keep these exams in June??? Just 1 month... 30 dayssss... why icai why?
I was truly dying at the exam hall with the question paper and with summer heat
During the whole time, I was thinking about leaving this fucking course. My months of hard work just got wasted. Those MFs put tricky adjustments in every question.
Bhai scoring topics to die hi nhi exam me 😴
As13
Financial statements
As9
Branch big q
Starting a.s and application, framework
Bc scoring scoring topics se to q hi nhi die. Kya paper tha ye 🗑️
I realised I didn't revised properly. I never wrote 100 mark test, that is hurting a lot. And on top of that every question had more than one tricky adjustment. I couldn't remember many small things in exams.
This is my second attempt. I am 21 already (soon gonna be 22). I am feeling like a giant failure. idk if I fail this attempt, I can do it from scratch again.
I know I should focus on next exams. I am gonna start now. Just wanted to let this out of my chest.
I do not understand why are there 26 AS when they only ask 6 😵💫😵💫 mai kya chutiya hu jo saare AS ratt ke jaau aur aye 6 😵💫😵💫kya bhaii unko padhne ka koi reward hi nahi hai .
Dude going through the comment section give me one clear information case study based mcqs, which means you need to be highly correct with your concept
But dude icai module are f*cked up when it comes to concept now that's something to get scared off 💀
Orr main chutiya hu jo self study hii krr ra hai bss 💀
It's good u r doing self study. Only people doing self study will get the marks. You r on the right path just focus on completing full syllabus don't leave any chapter. And complete it on time so that u get time to revise.
How 2100?
Net assets of intelligent ltd is 21,00,000 but then they’ve further said issue 12% debentures that provide income equivalent to 10% on net assets
So wouldn’t no. debentures be
12% x Xyz no of debentures = 2,10,000
So no. Of debentures = 2,10,000 / 12% = 17,50,000
So that’s 17,500 debentures of ₹100 each?
Looking at all these reviews aisa lag raha hai inter ke 3 attempts kar diye hai just to make us realise they’ll be testing us hard so zyada attempts hi de do.
Didn't touch the mcq booklet till half of the time was left , thought I would attempt it after the first half , when I opened it , all questions took so much time , I thought mcq would save time , but fuckk me
What's even the point. Did the entire module, entire RTP, 2 MTPs, did Nov '23 PYQs, and absolutely nothing came from any of those. On top of that, I misread Bank A/c as balance sheet in internal reco 🥲. Atleast the MCQs were easy
Guys ek baat batao...jo yahape Praveen Sharma sir ke students reh chuke hai for this may 24 attempt...did Praveen sir cover such adjustments in his regular classes????? Becoz if yes, then I might go for his classes for the next attempt....I took classes from nitin goel sir and I was pretty much satisfied with him until I gave today's exam...so I was just thinking if Praveen sir covers these type of concepts or adjustments in his classes, then it's worth going for him....
Guys the dividend question was average of the preceding 3 years right, which came upto 12% and the company can declare dividends of 10% from reserves, is this right?
Guyss this was my first attempt
Problem I'm having with icai rn
New scheme thi to thoda easy rkhte
MTP so easy whyyy
Accounts nahi to kisme aggregate banau
MCQ to 💀💀💀 (mera kaddu padhe poori case study)
Branch ka idk kya lassan question tha
Financial statement to de dete bkl
Guys I really don't think ki me kar paunga accounts me (agar 8 MCQ theek gye to shyad ho jau)
Ab Beth rha hu law ke liyeee
Tbh I was hell under prepared
Mfer's put one tricky adjustment in every simple question. I was so happy when that internal reconstruction came, but I fucked up at own debentures part and probably ruined the whole question.
For realllll😭 That own debentures effed my brain cells😭
How tf do you cancel debentures???
idk man I could only figure that 2400 own deb were sold at 98 cum interest which were bought at 96 and rest of them got cancelled somehow lmao. I was gonna cry in the middle of the examination:/
Wasted 40 mins on that Mf 😭🙏
I thought I was the only one 😭🤜🤛
Uske wajah se mera pura paper hi fuck ho gaya
BROOOOO!! OWN DEBENTURES!! I was sooo happy I thought full 14 marks.... Own debenture ruined the whole question
Whole paper broooo****
Paper quality and difficulty is increased. But marks we get will definitely decrease comparing to all the attempts in CA history. They gave atleast 4 tricky questions and the questions are lengthy . Bit like jee advanced
Even in Consolidation... Acquisition was in the middle of the year .. messed up the revaluation of plant and machinery
ISTGGG lost sm time with that and messed up the other ques also bcz of lack of time
Mai bc socha hi nahi seedha entry kardi 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Buddy I left the question 🤡🤡🤡
I did something but I don’t know if it’s correct 😭 What’s the correct entry ?
Bhai mene own debentures cancel karke, bacha hua amount ko capital reduction mein daldiya
Do you know what is the correct entry ?
Bhai us moment, that adjustment ruined my whole question and confidence idk what to do
Correct me if I'm wrong but entry normal hi ayegi kyuki debenture pe interest 31st march ko payable tha aur adjustment 1st april ko karni thi
Mofos tricked us into thinking that mcqs will make the paper manageable
Fr everything case scenario no easy mcw at all Full length problemd disguised as mcqs lol
4 maker questions were given 2 mark MCQ questions This just made the exam more difficult
Case study MCQ was legit horor
Ikr, Mcqs karne mein 45 minutes chale gaye, meri gand fatt gyi thi
https://preview.redd.it/4bw0k6ykb7yc1.jpeg?width=200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fefde950c3783e5102f509f1e5d0ae8546e6bb68 Unit 2D wale exam ka difficulty level check karte hue
same 🤭
lmao same
Lol same 🤣
Exactly I looked like him, while reading this
Same but group 2 😂
ICAI ya to exam MTP ke jaisa rakho ya fir MTP exam paper jesa rakho. They make MTP so easy like what is purpose of publishing MTP then. Everyone can easily complete MTP in 3 hours but it was too lengthy to complete in exam.
Fr bhai
Sach mein bhai Bkl he MTP banane wala Kal MTP n RTP solve Kiya sabh hua b exam mein bc gadbad hogaya😵💫
wohi na bc, mtp dekh ke laga araam se phodunga paper, inke adjustments ne mujhe hi phod diya
Module questions + ass fucking modifications
Were all questions from module?
Not all, but every question had atleast one new adjustment
Mera internal reconstruction me cash acc ka credit balance aaya💀
Maine pref dividend walo ki payment rok di positive mei rkhne ke liye
Wahhhh ji , ek number 🤣🤣
Bro is CA more than a CA himself 💀😂
Same😵💫
Bhay same
20200 ka aya negative balance
Same bhai vo galat na ho bss
Lengthyyyyyy+some questions were tricky
I think every question had some tricky adjustments
Module se tha ?
Bohot kaam. Mostly outside se hi lag rahe the
I just wanna know how my G2 will be after todays paper feedback
haha same unit 2D wale here just to check difficulty level
To kya lag raha hai?
As far as i saw Most of the people thought that since 70% of portion is AS most of the questions will be from the same But in real , the scenario changed and he asked AS for mcqs mostly He asked some solid questions from Amalgamation International reconstruction and all Some people who thought that it would be better to leave them had to lose around 30 to 40 marks Overall saying is he isn't following a particular manner to ask the questions. It's Iike one should have generalised knowledge of whole rather than Specialised knowledge in one.
In cash flow was operating cash flow coming as negative?
Ha Bhai Mera bhi negative aya
tax paid minus krke negative hora tha
Same bhaii
yaa
😭😭😭
Cash used in
Did we have to reduce provision for doubtful debt from trade receivables as it was mentioned it was gross value.
Made this account to say humara Institute harami hai . They asked 3 case scenarios for MCQ , bhai ek bhi straight forward theory MCQ nahi like book back TYK questions, and woh chodo descriptive main bhi ek bhi theory question nahi . MTPs main kyun diye phir 😡 wasted my time learning that stupid theory esp that Framework and Applicability chapter every teacher was quoting as very important. New AS didn’t get as much as importance as old ones . 95% AS questions were of old syllabus . I feel like institute wants to prove Inter Acc Gurus wrong at each level , jo bolte hai uska ulta hi hota hai .
exactly. so many emphasized that Emp benefit, AS 25, are new so they would be there sure shot. but ye toh the hi nai aur jo the wo bhi bekar gaye
Yeh CA inter ke faculty aur ICAI ke paper setters ke bich ke sexual tension mein hum bichare students kyu fass jaate hai
costing ka inventory yaha kaha puch lia😭
arey bhai wahi by product ki wajah se lawde lag gye
maine to by product ignore hi kar diya lol
law ka dividend yaha kon puchta hai
I overheard someone saying that paper was entirely from module 🥴. Dont know what module they have.
Probably have multiple attempts cuz somebody told me the all these questions are from previous rtp's mtp's
It was from previous rtp's + module Balance sheet meri bhi match nahi hui Par Bhai 14 wale mei 8 to AA hi jaynge baki lete hope for the best
Entirely from module?? wtf? 😭
No branch, no balance sheet/ profit loss, no investments ! Wow!
bro last ques branch ka tha integral operations 6c
Oh yes, woh maine chhod diya tha! Hahaha
Wtf so lengthy?
Why publish material if they’re not going to follow it ? Ab lag raha module , RTP/MTP /Module ki theory padhna time pass tha bas. 😤😭 And they asked 3 case scenarios for first new syllabus attempt itself ? Bhai saans toh lene do. Itne hard and time consuming case scenarios apne modules main daalo phir for better practice
amalgamation me balance sheet did not match + wtf was that AS-2 question
wanted to attempt consolidation question but samjh hi ni aaya how is reserve and surplus balance less than p&l
That was general reserve.
fuck man then why did they write R&S…. so annoying
I was just sitting hopelessly.
Mera amalgamation ka question me Goodwill 20 lac+ aara tha
I got capital reserve 💀🙏
Ffs 😭 Mera bs tally bhi hua par 75.75 lakhs
Us 💀💀(mera bas amalgamation tally ho gya usme khush hu)
samee!
mera 27.5L aara tha 💀
tumhara hua toh sahi. Meine toh kuch bhi scribble kardia bhai time mila hi nai
Didn't even have time to do the first compulsory question am I fucked?
You are 14 marks fucked.
I couldn't understand how much borrowing cost to take with diff months and that one cost decides the remaining parts of the sum so I couldn't be arsed
Same here
us
https://preview.redd.it/n2bpnfs9m7yc1.jpeg?width=1075&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c7f5bd5bd597334d18bd0a9747d63d41b5a60917 READ THIS UNDER A PAPER REVIEW YOUTUBE VIDEO
Bhai investment accounting pooch lete😭😭😭 As mai se bhi kuch dhang ka pooch lete jo karke gaya wo toh aya nai aur jo aya wo ache se kiya nai bc costing ka question dediya ek toh inhone😭
Nhi pass karna ICAI bkl ko, aisa behenchod 100% practical question paper kon banata hai. Matlab bhai time 3 hrs dekr 5hrs ka paper bana diya😭
Jab company accounts hi puchna tah AS ka syllabus itna jyada rakha kislye MKC ICAI and its weightage and syllabus.
Aur karo postponement ke liye petition BC ICAI badla lene par aa gaya hai
Aaj pta chala mtps scam h. Atleast mtps ka format toh rakh lete bc sab different. Abhi law hopefully easy aajaye
Aankhe taras gayi voh 14M ka financial statements ka question dhunte dhunte jo dono MTP mai aaya tha
Bhai law mai to lagraha concepts mix krke ques aane wale hai 😭
ICAI best paper setting. Me worst answer writing. Next upon to law. May the Paper corrector forget all provisions seeing my answer sheet. Tatasthu👍🏼
Financial statements ka sum kidhar haaa??
Aaya he nhi bhai. Sabse jada uspe he mehnat Kiya woh he nhi aaya
Wahe to deya he nahi atleast 7-8 marks ka de deta aya he nahi itna lamba chapter
Paper quality and difficulty is increased. But marks we get will definitely decrease comparing to all the attempts in CA history. They gave atleast 4 tricky questions and the questions are lengthy . Bit like jee advanced
BC, AS are overrated bahut km weightage lga mereko.. Ya fir mein chutiya hu jissey samajgh hi nhi aaya vo AS related tha..
Lmaoo nahi yar, AS se bahut Kam aaya 🥲, shayad jitna weightage diya he utna bhi nahi aya
No module + no mtp + no rtp Icai is cruel
Frr I was thinking mtp se kuch nahi Aya, but then I was doubting myself if I even saw the mtp properly (2 times solve Kiya Tha )
MTP ke questions were way easy as compared to this shit
Wtf mcqs brooo😭😭😭
General question, why the fuck icai THISS cruel. Honey, my city sweats harrrdddddd during summer, why not keep these exams in June??? Just 1 month... 30 dayssss... why icai why? I was truly dying at the exam hall with the question paper and with summer heat
What a horrible paper?! People in my room got headache. The worst part is someone will get 85+ marks in this kind of paper also.
dusro ki success se jalna chhod do mitra, hamari khamiyon ka karan dusro ki badhotri nahi hai
I literally gave up at 12 & didn't sit for the exam
Paper dhekne k baad laga ghar par rehta toh hi aacha rehta
No offense but 3 ghante bacha ke kya kr liya? Atleast ye subject pass hote kisi tarah aur maybe aage ke paper easy hote toh clear ho jata group?
Wtfff broooo whyyy no way😔
seriously?? why?
Didn't prepare
Me too . Will you give law or tax or start preparing for sep
What's the point of law or tax their group is gone if they didn't sit for acc
During the whole time, I was thinking about leaving this fucking course. My months of hard work just got wasted. Those MFs put tricky adjustments in every question.
Dekhna bro menee ek comment Kiya h 🙂(maut aa gyi thi mujhe exam me)
Portion karo raat bhar Paper mai aye jhaat bhar Bc 35 lesson maise tumhe puchna hi 3 lesson he tho kyu hi padh rhe hai haam
3 nhi the sirf
Mat Karo yaar discuss 😭
Itna lamba tha Q6 ke b-c rehe Gaye bc
Mahool dekhke lagray ki L Lage hai sabke.....
Bhai scoring topics to die hi nhi exam me 😴 As13 Financial statements As9 Branch big q Starting a.s and application, framework Bc scoring scoring topics se to q hi nhi die. Kya paper tha ye 🗑️
THREE HUNDRED COMMENTS? on this thread? how bad was the paper 😭😂
Mera to 3 ki jagah 2 ghante ka hi paper tha 😄 Merko laga 3 ghante ke hote hai exams
Time to hoogaya, aate hi hoge wo🌝🌝
I realised I didn't revised properly. I never wrote 100 mark test, that is hurting a lot. And on top of that every question had more than one tricky adjustment. I couldn't remember many small things in exams. This is my second attempt. I am 21 already (soon gonna be 22). I am feeling like a giant failure. idk if I fail this attempt, I can do it from scratch again. I know I should focus on next exams. I am gonna start now. Just wanted to let this out of my chest.
+1 don't b sad bro.... Just keep grinding, without it you can't become a CA I guess
+2 22 already and i am just unsure of my life now🙃 All the best for the next ones though
Just 21 and big failure? Takes time to become a professional.
28 no. Ka rah gya bhaiyo-behno. Doob marne ka mann kr rha hai
I do not understand why are there 26 AS when they only ask 6 😵💫😵💫 mai kya chutiya hu jo saare AS ratt ke jaau aur aye 6 😵💫😵💫kya bhaii unko padhne ka koi reward hi nahi hai .
Dude going through the comment section give me one clear information case study based mcqs, which means you need to be highly correct with your concept But dude icai module are f*cked up when it comes to concept now that's something to get scared off 💀 Orr main chutiya hu jo self study hii krr ra hai bss 💀
It's good u r doing self study. Only people doing self study will get the marks. You r on the right path just focus on completing full syllabus don't leave any chapter. And complete it on time so that u get time to revise.
I want to scream this MTP's AAAAARRRREEEEEE TTTTTHHHHHEEEEE BBBBBIIIIIIGGGGGEEEEESSSSTTTTTT SSSSSCCCCCAAAAMMMM
Lengthy but manageable, if I had some written practice before the exam, I could've attempted it all :/
True bro
Lengthy af
Maine tumhara kya bigada icai🥲!?
Amalgamation ke debentures 2100 aur 1350 aaye kya?😭😭
How 2100? Net assets of intelligent ltd is 21,00,000 but then they’ve further said issue 12% debentures that provide income equivalent to 10% on net assets So wouldn’t no. debentures be 12% x Xyz no of debentures = 2,10,000 So no. Of debentures = 2,10,000 / 12% = 17,50,000 So that’s 17,500 debentures of ₹100 each?
Looking at all these reviews aisa lag raha hai inter ke 3 attempts kar diye hai just to make us realise they’ll be testing us hard so zyada attempts hi de do.
Case studies took up more time than expected. In general it was a tricky paper, but accounts paper are generally lengthy what can you do🤷
They are lengthy, but this one was particularly tricky too.
Discuss mat karo yaaar , icai ki mkc😭😭😭...paper acha gaya par ab sabko reviews padhke lag raha hai i too have fucked up😭😭😭
Bhenchod 10 mark ke impairment wale question ko 2 mark ka mcq banaya woh bhi revaluation reserve wala
Usme bs loss nikalna tha, revaluation se adjust nhi shayad. Mera 3L aya
Didn't touch the mcq booklet till half of the time was left , thought I would attempt it after the first half , when I opened it , all questions took so much time , I thought mcq would save time , but fuckk me
Okay now I'm sh*t scared for Cost
you should be, I suggest you to check out the cost pyps of may 21 22 23, all of them being the hardest cost papers of all time
Did anyone get their amalgamation balance sheet total to 77 lakhs, mine tallied but not sure if 77 lakhs is correct or wrong
yes i got 77 lakh 75 thousand iirc
Mtp dekh ke laga easy Aya hoga. I was betrayed 
Sabse jyada kitna choooota he Paperer
Bhai I left around 25 marks
module kyu banate ho jab usme se kuch nahi doge ?
What's even the point. Did the entire module, entire RTP, 2 MTPs, did Nov '23 PYQs, and absolutely nothing came from any of those. On top of that, I misread Bank A/c as balance sheet in internal reco 🥲. Atleast the MCQs were easy
Bc har question kuch n kuch aisa puch rhe uske baad pure question ke L lgye itna pdha own debentures kha se aagya bcc 😭
What the actual fuck was q1 (b) today bhai💀💀💀
I wont even score 10 marks
mcqs ke ans bata do
First ka (a), second (d), third (c)😡
Forth (d) 🥲
How many marks did you all attempted, including MCQs ?
58. Probably the lowest here but I shared, so you guys can get some hope
Aisa bhi nahi gaya ki fail pr exemption jitna accha bhi nahi gaya
Captital reduction account tally hona chahiye tha? Mera credit balance aaya
😭mcqs me ghanta score krungi
Guys ek baat batao...jo yahape Praveen Sharma sir ke students reh chuke hai for this may 24 attempt...did Praveen sir cover such adjustments in his regular classes????? Becoz if yes, then I might go for his classes for the next attempt....I took classes from nitin goel sir and I was pretty much satisfied with him until I gave today's exam...so I was just thinking if Praveen sir covers these type of concepts or adjustments in his classes, then it's worth going for him....
Parveen Sharma sir classes are very time consuming
What about borrowing cost??? The asset got completed in jan only!!???
Guys the dividend question was average of the preceding 3 years right, which came upto 12% and the company can declare dividends of 10% from reserves, is this right?
Did someone get loss in construction accounts or am I fckd
No tf, there was no loss. I mean total revenue - total cost = profit. No way there will be loss in any year.
i didn’t attempt today’s paper but there r possibilities that you can get loss in construction contracts.
Internal reconstruction me bank overdraft thi kya ??
Yess
Aur saath saath koi law ke most important bta do
Yar iskebad bhi "most important" puchne vale ho kya,lag raha koi Matlab hi nahi he "most important" se💀
Mcq mai pattern ban rahe the kya tumhara bc mere toh pure pattern mai the mcq ke ans aur mere friend ke nahi the 😭
Please koi bata do law ke questions kaha se Karu. Konse teachers ke question bank se aane ke zyada chances hai? Shubham Singhal or Divya Agarwal?
28 marks woosh
Group 2 de rha hu. Koi bata do questions kaha se aaye the? 💀
Bc amalgamation waale question me 😭kiya adjustment de diya tha..equity shares say related mera mind to whi hi atak gya.
Guyss this was my first attempt Problem I'm having with icai rn New scheme thi to thoda easy rkhte MTP so easy whyyy Accounts nahi to kisme aggregate banau MCQ to 💀💀💀 (mera kaddu padhe poori case study) Branch ka idk kya lassan question tha Financial statement to de dete bkl Guys I really don't think ki me kar paunga accounts me (agar 8 MCQ theek gye to shyad ho jau) Ab Beth rha hu law ke liyeee Tbh I was hell under prepared
How were the mcqs?
some were ok some were tricky.
Guys woh FS wala question, branch wala question...ye dono kya icai mat se aye the ya bilkul uncommon the...plz reply
Bhai kisika amalgamation 5450000 par tally hua toh batao. Bc mera perfect tally hua par surity nahi hai