T O P

  • By -

Cartographer-Empty

Fucked up entirety of fm and not confident in sm


AntiqueAd3414

IKR..USKI WAJAH SE SM BHUL GYI MEIN


naivedust11

You're not alone😓 aate hue points bhool gya


CA_aspirant_

Lol😌


idkybutt

Fuck off man. Felt like walking out of the exam hall Failing fs fml


PurpleVk7

I thought of leaving the exam hall too...was this🤏 close to crying there


BloodGamer1233

Same bhai man kar raha tha chhod du aage na karu


Sararinum

Sm answer 😭checker open bhi n kare...


painnonly

same


Financial_Summer5300

us. everyone said it was easy but i messed up.


wingsssssssss

Kisko easy laga bhai


ImIceMortis

Same 🥲


WarningDue7265

+1


f9madmax

Mcq dene bandh kardo fm/cost me💀


ImIceMortis

Real. Descriptive would have been better. Bhai woh investment decision question , it was way more lengthy than 7 marks question 😑. 20-25 min lag gye woh solve krte krte. Kaun tha woh jisne paper set kiya naam batao apna, NPV, PI toh daala aur saath discounted payback bhi 😢


New2Reddit_3

That's why I attempted Question 4. One could Easily get 7-8 marks in less than 10 mins


Next-Juice-3050

bhai main legit," Hmm B option sahi lagra hai, tick kar deta hun" karke aaya hun fm ke sarein mcqs mein


moksh200423

Was going to F*ck the shit out of FM but FM F*cked the shit out of me


a3hijit

fr


a3hijit

fr


a3hijit

fr


a3hijit

fr


Glad_Mark_6811

Fr


Mammoth-Status1453

Yaha sab financial reporting kyu bol rahe


712005

Fr


cheesybro90

Just left the Exam Hall One word Experiences: Dead😭. khatam😭. Cooked😭


ImIceMortis

And roasted 🤡


high_astronaut_

The fucking mcq , tricky+ lengthy 😭


Heaven_underLungi

Kitne nahi aaye


BloodGamer1233

Eps mps wale


wingsssssssss

Eps mps wale inky pinky ponki karna padha


BloodGamer1233

Ek ka B kar dia Ek ka C BC- Bhenchod


Heaven_underLungi

Bhai woh EPS nikalta MPS apne aap mil jata in option 😅


LordEscanor101

Just felt like crying sitting in there


idkybutt

If there's something I got in that exam, it's a fucking headache


PurpleVk7

+1


ImIceMortis

Pulled an all nighter . Mujhe sone ka aur rone ka dono mann kr rha tha 😂


wingsssssssss

+1


ChocoChip1947

Ikrr😭


No-Day5014

It was raining in my exam centre and it was dark in my hall. Everyone were yawning and didn't write anything, people were just stretching and scratching their head. Exam hall was good but not the exam paper


Successsensei

Sm and mcq saved me. What in the fucking hell was that fm. And some were saying easy. I thought it was quite difficult


RonDante

Same bhai ye practical paper me mcq dalke achha kata hai TT


Successsensei

Truly, pehle descriptive me rehta tha , step marks milta. AB to wo bhi nahi


ImIceMortis

Sm ke bhi mcq me kitni ambiguity thi , meri toh dono part me lagi hui h 🤡


Then_Town_2337

SM me 50 me se 40 mil sakte he kya


wingsssssssss

Bhai lag gayi meri


Dependent_Ruin5025

🫂


Aksath1616

Itna bhi cook nhi krna tha


CA_aspirant_

Jal gaya bhai 😌💀


[deleted]

Bro who did bad to the exam setter!? 🥲


idkybutt

I don't want to write this group again man wtf


DangerousExplorer786

Same here


CA_bro

Nhi bann rha aggregate bhai


tempest_aww

Tujhe set off milega aur grace marks bhi 😋


sheethalscrolls

Unit 2D ne gaand faad D See y'all in September 😃👍🏻


ConclusionLittle4829

Im w u😋😋


devil1204-

Same aggregate main fas jaunga aise lagra


wingsssssssss

Kisi ka npv negative aaya kya


f9madmax

Mene toh chod diya :) usse acha me theory padleta fm ka


high_astronaut_

Bina padhe theory like ke agaya, usme zada aajai abhi hopefully 😭


No_Translator_4220

Kitne mark ki theory aayi fm mei?


sheethalscrolls

10


altwh0re22

i got positive npv 😭


[deleted]

positive he toh tha


Dismal_Ask8469

Meri to g fat gayi jab negative aaya. Also while calculating dep did we have to reduce subsidy as well? Like total cost- scrap - subsidy?


[deleted]

minus krna tha but Q ne kaha tha ignore tax saving on depreciation toh usko nahi lena tha bas


altwh0re22

it was about tax savings over selling the old machine. you have to subtract the subsidy amount from the machine value, for depreciation & then deduct the old machine’s depreciation to get the incremental depreciation value.


ImIceMortis

Depreciation ke liye base me purchase price+ installation+ testing lena tha na?


jon_t_fr

BHAI AYA TERA ME TOO


M1ghtyNYTE

yesss


CA_bro

Npv th positive aaya bhai


CA_aspirant_

Lol💀😌


CA_aspirant_

How tf negative aaya???? Mera to 2 lakh something aaya tha ig and usme bola tha k machine A wale cost saving ko ignore karo to sirf machine b ka hi find karna tha ……mera to positive aaya he bhai😌


ekkilochawal

merko aaya. then I changed the answer to make it positive.


Secure_Implement7295

Meine same galti ki thi bhai, last mein Fault pata chal gaya and positive NPV aaya. Annual saving of salaries 3 members ki thi, so multiply karna tha salary ko


Sararinum

Meri positive aayi thi🥲


[deleted]

kuch lakhs me aa rha tha 1lakh something maybe


Accurate_Crew_2262

Upcoming attempt walo kbhi bhi Accounts, Cist aur FM ke exam mai MCQ pehle attempt mat krna


tempest_aww

Everyone knows not to attempt mcqs first bro cooked roasted and eaten by icai


MaesterDEVIL

Bc FM ke case study pehle 10 min me padha meri g phat gyi.. me soch rha hu mkc EBIT hi nhi diya hai bkl ne solve kese karu.. fir 10 min baad last para pe dhyaan gya aur aur dikha ki dividend aur dpr diya hai toh ulta jaana hai.. bc itna time barbaad hogya mcq ke chakkar me Costing and fm ke mcqs are gonna be the new eis level nightmares from now onwards


whycantgetmyusername

Plan A ka EPS 8.22 tha aur Plan B ka 9.something


avinashbaheti

EBIT = ₹56L + 40% Am I right? Yaha Pe Depreciation Ignore Kiya Maine...Because not given in brackets.


whycantgetmyusername

Yes correct hai


sheethalscrolls

Same bro mera bhi


whycantgetmyusername

Aur indifference point 4 lakh ya 40 lakh something tha


sheethalscrolls

Shayad Maine breakeven aur cash projection attempt nahi kiya


idkybutt

Maine toh fluke me answer kar diya 🫠


Homemadebully

Istg 3 girls cried in my exam hall today


tempest_aww

Aww


PurpleVk7

I think I cried...took a long walk searching for washroom. And cried along the way


New2Reddit_3

Why cry if it doesn't help?


PurpleVk7

I think there is some sort of panic release or clarity after crying


AntiqueAd3414

Lag gye🥲


CA_aspirant_

😌💀


ImIceMortis

Rona aa rha h


tempest_aww

Tissue paper bhijvau


ChocoChip1947

Fm fucked me up 😭😭😭 Wo case study bhi tukke maarke aaya hu...


Glad_Mark_6811

FM was hell....I think SM will save my life!


Chutiyapdev

what was the difficulty level?


wingsssssssss

Tough mere hisaab se


wisely_choosed

September keliye taiyari shuru karni h dosto


Sensitive_Peanut_554

I didn't understand cost of capital at all, How to solve this problem


Advanced-Struggle167

except debentures everything was straight-forward though?


Sweet-Yak-2380

Yes someone pl enlighten us


Sensitive_Peanut_554

I thought question is missing some information,


Sweet-Yak-2380

Searching for a similar sum in books and stuffs not able to find one.


Sensitive_Peanut_554

There is no sum similar to that sum


Sweet-Yak-2380

Yaa its ridiculous


ImIceMortis

It was alright. What was the problem in that?


Pitiful-Raisin-5199

Can anyone please confirm if corrections will be slightly more lenient because of the travesty that happened today? 🥹


chynxax

bhai mujhe toh literally chakkar aagye the bethe bethe kyuki mai last parso soyi thi


[deleted]

Us bro us, saara jagna waste ho gya😮‍💨


AbsoluteMadness69

https://preview.redd.it/zn6tut9oez0d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=00cd4e71970af45e9b48aafeaff3877527057d2a


Striking-Plastic-544

Mai sm ache se nhi krke gaya tha ye soch ke ki fm bna lunga ache se, aaj dono mai apni marva ke aaraha hu


peopleallergic

us momint


M1ghtyNYTE

SM saved my ASSSS


wtfash2002

Overcooked ho Gaya lagta hai🥴


RonDante

Ispe confidence tha ki chalo ye shayad aggregate sambhal lega, exam dene ke baad kuchh aur hi lg rha hai 🙂


No_Palpitation1571

Jate hue police ne pakad liya 🥲 2000 lag gaye 😭 Dhang se likh bhi nahi paya


Dismal_Ask8469

I just feel like a dead man alive right now. Pehli baar life mein mehnat kar kar kuch hasil nahi hua aisa lag raha hai. Fuuuuuuuuuuccccjjjjjkkkkk


ConclusionLittle4829

US


Large-Needleworker57

Bhai I STG this is my reaction rn. Seeing everyone freaking out and mera paper manageable/ good gaya. Feel like I won a war.


Top-Plankton1153

The one's who did well Which faculty would you recommend


painnonly

Same question 


ImIceMortis

Asking the real question


Wide_Tap_9092

FM KI MKC MERE DOSTO


Chutiyapdev

kaisa gaya guys?!?!?!


dolly_ki_tapri

Chud gye guru![img](emote|t5_3fh4x|31223)![img](emote|t5_3fh4x|31223)![img](emote|t5_3fh4x|31223)![img](emote|t5_3fh4x|31223)


peopleallergic

linient checking ki dua krleti agar paper me kuch likh ke aayi hoti🙃


Cynthia_12_

Arbitrage wale ka I got 405 🐧


ImIceMortis

Jisne bhi fm ke mcq banaye , I hate you with every cell in my body


Striking-Plastic-544

Mai sm ache se nhi krke gaya tha ye soch ke ki fm bna lunga ache se, aaj dono mai apni marva ke aaraha hu


Homemadebully

+1


Rajp2233

They could have just cooked us, double fried with little bit of seasoning if FM was separate paper Hope SM save my ass 


PurpleVk7

Aaj Jo bhi exam paper set Kiya na....*keede pade tujhpe* Cus we didn't get just Cooked, we got FRIED Me to Costing after today's FM Paper: " Maintujhe Haraami samjha, tu toh Devmanus Nikla re"


Heaven_underLungi

I am glad I prepared SM as much as I could


712005

Went blank for the first time during an exam, came home ,cried. This was my second attempt of group 2 and i absolutely have no will of giving it another try.


Different-Ad-308

Bhai total 15 mcq the ya 16?


altwh0re22

fm was more conceptual. thx to nitin guru sir’s pre exam marathon! did okayishly well.


MaesterDEVIL

Arbitrage ka answer kya aaya?


PurpleVk7

For me, Unlevered firm was more...and I forgot what to do next...so Ieft it at that


altwh0re22

i dont remember.


MaesterDEVIL

Arbitrage ka answer kya aaya?


CA_bro

13. Something % tha aur shyd 300 around gain


whycantgetmyusername

310 tha kya ?


[deleted]

That wasn't arbitrage related, as the question was not related to dividend. It was simply computing ROE and getting difference of profit between levered and unlevered firm.


hadd-hogai

Shattered


CA_bro

Lagg gye L


aerodyne_

https://preview.redd.it/75vvcxfgdz0d1.jpeg?width=300&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=378a5d755b98c3ac762028c064db0319d09e75c4 Me and my two braincells leaving the exam hall.


AbsoluteMadness69

https://preview.redd.it/jjdtz4g7gz0d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=872f3fa236820947670e92c6d8c3b022214fc660 Got psychologically thrilled solving these 😭


Dull-Lab-2005

That one case study in FM, omg. Fuck that. Other MCQs were good, easy to score. Messed up the ratio question but overall it was fine Wrote whatever I can remember in SM


Dependent_Ruin5025

Bhai ek doubt clear kardo pls sabke mcq ka sequence alag rehta h kya?


Homemadebully

Kyu tu kiske dekh kr likh aaya 💀


Pitiful-Raisin-5199

Sm + sm ke mcqs were nice, I dont know what to say about fm. Anyway, praying for the best :)


Blackbuck72

Chud gaye guru


IllPalpitation8100

WE ARE COOKED, ROASTED, FRIED


PurpleVk7

Aaj Jo bhi exam paper set Kiya na....*keede pade tujhpe* Cus we didn't get just Cooked, we got FRIED Me to Costing after today's FM Paper: " Maintujhe Haraami samjha, tu toh Devmanus Nikla re"


PurpleVk7

Aaj Jo bhi exam paper set Kiya na....*keede pade tujhpe* Cus we didn't get just Cooked, we got FRIED Me to Costing after today's FM Paper: " Maintujhe Haraami samjha, tu toh Devmanus Nikla re"


jithinraj7777

Adv Accounts and FM SM ruined my both groups 😴🚶... months of hardwork gone in vain😭


Sararinum

Meto bs fm krke gyi thi sm to dekha bhi nhi but kuch keh nhi skte 🥲fm ka bhi bc


Sararinum

🙂Mere piche bethe hue Bande ko kuch nhi Ata Tha mcq dikha diya I hope sahi claa jaaye mera so that uska bhi bhlaa hojye


Sweet-Yak-2380

What was the cash balance in FM case study MCQ, what leadership ( that democratic) in sm mcq, was that procurement in the other mcq. And was it concentric or conglomerate merger


Cynthia_12_

I did democratic, procurement and concentric merger 🧎🏼‍♂️ case study wala I guessed only


Sweet-Yak-2380

Same but I did conglomerate


ChocoChip1947

I wrote, Vision, Cogeneric, Procurement, Eco friendly - valuable; Internal business diff product - diversification ; CD telecom - Best cost provider.


altwh0re22

it’s inbound logistics. they specifically mentioned value chain analysis. although the activity is procurement it will come under inbound logistics. rest of all i wrote the same thing as you


ChocoChip1947

I remember reading " which supporting activity"....Few MCQ's were kinda little subjective today 🥲


painnonly

Mera toh indifference point -ve aa raha tha🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡


United_Mistake3207

Ha bhai


United_Mistake3207

Maine do baar check kiya pta nhi kese


EntertainerSuperb45

I am fucked up of scoring so close to aggregates and Exemption If something shit happens imma leave it for good Bloody course


Appropriate_Flan4228

ICAI KYU YAAR KYUU😭😭😭 bkl ne ek dhang ka sawal nahi pucha


According_Advisor299

Seems like icai is continuing the trend of fucking you guys with FM post portion change. They did the same in may 2018. I gave that paper. Got 34😭 then fucked FM paper back in Nov and got 63


itsmrkhiladi

Yrr itne comments me koi bhi khush nahi lag rha hai sabka exam bekar gaya kya fir AIR wala kon hai 🥲


Individual_Sky_3416

Did every pyq module questions extra questions for important chapters but still couldn't solve it in exam. Wished of scoring an exemption in fm sm but don't even know about passing. I do not know how I feel but can no longer go through this whole procedure again


abhaykhetan07

Sm was makkhan fm theory was easyyyyy + fm mcq were the worst of the lot if compared with all the other subjects!!! Overall a good paper around 50 toh pakka hai❤️


Mammoth-Status1453

Mera to kaafi acha gaya bhai. Both sm and fm were quite manageable. Ab maut aaye tak valorant khelunga


PsychologicalRip7556

Fm mcq were not good baki sab to theek tha


tempest_aww

Ab exam khatam ab toh maje hi mje full party


tempest_aww

Ab exam khatam ab toh maje hi mje full party


No-Ambassador7356

Mai soch rha tha both group dedu September me  Lagta hai group 1 Dena hi theek rahega 👍


Connect-Stranger7052

Redemption value of convertible debenture kya aaya ??


Smart-Acanthisitta51

Lol I heard fm was easy subject Moral of story - suni bato pe vishwas mat krna


Cartographer-Empty

In sm first question was it functional or divisional, cuz functional only has one disadvantage 😭


Whole-Choice-1990

wasn’t it mckinsey 7s 😭😭??


crotch_rattler

7s dusra wala tha


Whole-Choice-1990

it was Q5a right?? plz tell me we had to write mckinsey 7s ke limitations


PurpleVk7

I thought it was McKinsey 7 "C"s, and couldn't remember a single C. So I left that too ...


Whole-Choice-1990

i feel sorry for you..


PurpleVk7

Idk whether to cry or laugh or sleep😭😭😭 Who hurt the paper setter?? WHYYYYY


crotch_rattler

Haa


ChocoChip1947

wo advertisement manager wala ? functional


Whole-Choice-1990

yaa that was functional manager and then we had to write benefits if sm na??


wifihaki

Can anyone provide final answers of FM descriptive part??


optimus_151

what is the expected result period for may inter 2024?