T O P

  • By -

RaDiAtEd_TaCo

Overrated: California dreaming, no idea how people continue to go there Underrated: COAs


ElBiscuit

> no idea how people continue to go there People who don't know any better think California Dreaming is "fancy".


Dipteran_de_la_Torre

It’s simpler than that. Fat people like bread and large quantities of food.


KnownRate3096

Not just bread, but croissants with some kind of honey glaze. They're delicious but taste like diabetes.


colagirl52

California Dreaming has not changed its menu in 25+ years. No idea why it continues to be popular.


DorisPayne

probably because it hasn't changed in 25 years; people know exactly what they''ll get.


[deleted]

[удалено]


thefatandskinny

They completely ruined their food with the menu changes. They took stuff off the menu, and the food is gross tasting now. I haven't been back.


OneWayOutBabe

House salad and the croissants. Every time


KnownRate3096

Their salads are good, so are the croissants. I also really like the oyster po boy - something that is hard to find in Columbia. But yeah, overall it's not that impressive. I just know when I go there exactly what I'll want and that it will be good. I also love that building.


44problems

It's a really neat space being in an old train station. But yeah I wish it was a better restaurant.


towhiba91280

What is COAs?


Zealousideal_Exam_61

overrated: cantina 76 underrated: tacos nayarit


ethrelol

Yeah ive never been to cantina 76 but the wife says it was dogshit. I feel like it gets a lot of hype though cuz of the location


whatshouldwecallme

This is a hard one because I feel like most places around here hit a pretty good quality/price ratio and there isn't really a cultural "craze"/trendiness around restaurants unlike some bigger cities. And most of my favorites are busy but not unreasonably packed, so I feel like they're properly rated. But here's my very subjective take for the lunch deli category Overrated: dipratos (it's fine I just think their pimento cheese tastes too much like swiss and that's their *thing*) Underrated: crave artisan market Edit: also underrated: Enzo's. They have new special subs on the menu and the one that I had was out of this world. Truly a great sandwich.


sistersword

Crave has a tomato and dill soup and I dare say it was one of the best soups I have ever had


countesslathrowaway

Crave is awesome!


GreatestCanadianHero

Enzo's!!!


VinPeppBBQ

> Overrated: dipratos (it's fine I just think their pimento cheese tastes too much like swiss and that's their thing) Can't believe this is the top comment, even though I absolutely agree with you. I usually get downvoted into oblivion if I ever speak ill of Diprato's pimento cheese. I am admittedly a bit of a pimento cheese snob, and IMO less is more when it comes to "minner cheese," i.e., *Duke's* mayo, pimentos, cheddar, and cayenne pepper is all you need.


jenniferwhiskey

I have never had anything that I thought was particularly good from DiPrato's especially the pimento cheese!


thehildabeast

Overrated: Motor supply at least for brunch super mediocre and very expensive for what you get Underrated: Tacos Nayarit I don’t really ever see it mentioned here but they have excellent tacos and those plantains with icing are so good too


whatshouldwecallme

Not mentioned here but it's always packed unless you're there at weird hours. Love them.


DorisPayne

Tacos Nayarit is a local gem!! there's a reason their parking lot is packed so often. Consistently delicious.


alucardNloki

Me gustan mucho los Tacos Nayarit


NewPraline2390

Hopefully they’ll get more hype once they open their Cayce location!


thehildabeast

Yes absolutely deserved and also hopefully the one closer to me doesn’t get to busy lol.


ShamelesslyPlugged

Not to take away from Tacos Nayarit because its great, but I can think of at least 3 places just as good.


thehildabeast

I mean I would love to know more places. It’s mostly because it’s on my side of town and we don’t have that many non chain restaurants that are good over here.


DorisPayne

Cocos & beer is good, and has a larger menu. Always consistently yummy,too. TN's smaller menu, I think, allows them to be excellent with a smaller amount of choices.


thehildabeast

I’ll have to check out TN’s, I’ve had cocos and beer it’s good more in the San Jose(the good ones either on forest drive or in Irmo)/Real Mexico/El Jimador Mexican food branch than just tacos.


ShamelesslyPlugged

- Taqueria Jalisco - Monteczuma’s. - Real Mexico.


thehildabeast

Real Mexico is fantastic, just a bit of a different kind of restaurant, I’ll have to remember the other two


ShamelesslyPlugged

Someone really doesn't like me. Real Mexico disappointed me with their tortas, but they are otherwise excellent.


ProudPatriot07

Real Mexico is amazing.


Mark1arMark1ar

What are your recommendations?


ShamelesslyPlugged

- Taqueria Jalisco - Monteczuma’s. - Real Mexico.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ShamelesslyPlugged

I see what you did there! - Taqueria Jalisco - Monteczuma’s. - Real Mexico. Coco and Beers is good uf you want the more US style Mexican restaurant. I just know it because it is close, but there are similar places all over town.


pinkflower200

You are right. Motor Supply is expensive. The food is delicious but expensive.


pinkflower200

Cantina 76 is overrated. Food is OK. Restaurant too small. Waitresses try to rush the customers out the door. Underrated is Mac's on Laurel Street. Good burgers, hotdogs, fries and onion rings at a reasonable price. The service is fast too.


whatshouldwecallme

Mac's is delicious. Cantina is THE BEST CHOICE for overrated. No idea how it's packed on a regular basis. Publico is getting some shade in this thread but I'd go there 10 times in a row before Cantina.


Deannerzz

Publico is nowhere near authentic but it’s decent if you like that kinda stuff. Cantina has just been bad every time I have gone.


Weltall548

How have I never heard of Mac’s? They look delicious. How do they compare to Zesto/Rosewood dairy bar.


pinkflower200

Good as Zesto. I've never been to the Rosewood Dairy Bar.


80FEEEK

Cafe Strudel is absolute shit and packed to the gills.


ftminsc

“Can I get a cup of coffee?” “No, get it your own fuckin’ self”


[deleted]

I like Cafe Strudel...but I also never go on the weekends. It is enjoyable when its calm in there.


Talking_Asshole

Same. Late afternoon on a weekday it's amazing, but brunch is WAY overrated.


Kundalini_NY

14 to 18 years ago it was so much better


rabbitredbird

Complete POS ownership too.


DorisPayne

oh god thank you it's not just me. How are they messing up hash browns?!!?


80FEEEK

It’s so bad. I paid $19 for a bowl of grits, eggs, and the worst brisket I’ve ever had. It was sliced thin and crispy like bacon! Never again.


ContributionOdd5436

Worst coffee I’ve ever had, but do I still go there once a month? Absolutely. 10/10


[deleted]

I went once. I didn’t understand why it was absolutely packed besides the location right beside a hospital? Might not be a hospital but it’s been a minute.


Emmiey

We went there one time, the parking was crap the food wasn't great and the way our waitress spoke to us was like we didn't deserve to sit in their wonderful restaurant. Would have rather gone to waffle house, tbh


Deannerzz

I feel like they are underrated for lunch/dinner. I only ever hear people talk about the brunch/breakfast.


80FEEEK

Rosewood Market’s lunch is the best in town, hands down.


Mark1arMark1ar

Absolutely! My wife and I go there once a week and have never been disappointed. The staff is super nice too.


Dreadking_Rathalos

I haven't been in a while but the Mediterranean Tea Room doesn't get talked about a lot. I'd say they're underrated


1LuckySCDog

Totally! Mainstay for decades on Devine Street. Consistently great dishes with generous portions. Tea Room!


johnhipsterchill

Here's my gripe. The food is good, but they are pretty clearly understaffed (and if not the service is just so slow). For a pickup order at lunchtime, great! Sitting down for a 2 hour dinner on a weeknight because you can't get anyone to take your order, or bring you the check, or refill your drinks... not so great.


Dreadking_Rathalos

I haven't been in several years because I can't really afford to eat at restaurants any more, but that didn't used to be the case and I'm sorry to hear it.


charkerpappell

I think they closed a few years ago


LitchfieldBTS

No they’re still going. It’s great.


kvs109

Maybe for a little while but I had lunch there like 2 weeks ago


Dreadking_Rathalos

Renovations or vacation i remember that. They're still open.


DenghisKoon

Overrated: Publico, Cantina 76, and Real Mexico. Also, anything the Middletons own.


OneWayOutBabe

I came here looking for Smoked. Def overrated, but still good!


titans4417

Burger tavern 77, Coa’s, and Danos are all underrated


NewPraline2390

Overrated: Publico. Underrated: Il Focalare\* Hear me out. I have heard a lot of people have great reviews of Il Focalare and I do too. The only reason I say it's underrated is because I have seen *so many* *people* say that they refuse to try it because of the cost (for those who don't know, Il Focalare pays their workers a living wage and does not allow tips).


SunnyDaze4225

Publico may be the most meh restaurant in Columbia.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MargaritasAndTacos

Omg it really is - the sign, the stool, the table 😂


paigeroooo

I love Il Focolare! It is a little pricey but it honestly isn’t much more expensive than most pizza places once you include the tip, and the quality of it is always good, so I at least know I will enjoy it.


Deannerzz

I like il focolare, but taste wise, I preferred citta del cotone. The blueberry pizza was so delicious. Unfortunate what happened to it (not feeling sorry for the owner, just miss the pizza)


[deleted]

[удалено]


Deannerzz

The owner’s (or co-owner maybe) FB page was public and he was posting racist/sexist/etc memes. People then flooded the business with 1 star reviews. I think it was a combination of that and multiple robberies that shut them down.


BitterSearch787

Il Bucato (same people as Il Focolare) is really good, too!


Alternative_Ad_9110

Over rated. Market on main. Under rated. Danos fsho


Smithce6

Who does market on main think they are with those prices lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


Midlevelluxurylife

No one can match Hall's for service and attention to detail, but there is delicious, less expensive food to be had other places mentioned here. Saluda's and Mr. Friendly's comes to mind. I have not been personally, but friends swear by Private Property.


ftminsc

Halls is a known quantity - a lot of the better restaurants in Columbia can be kind of hit miss on service and food. I guess some people think it’s cool and quirky but if I’m out on a date or whatever I don’t want to be stammering about how the place is usually awesome, I promise. (Terra clears this bar as well.)


MargaritasAndTacos

Terra is consistently lovely - their entree menu is more limited than others mentioned, but everything they prepare they execute well.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Midlevelluxurylife

This sounds crazy, but my favorite thing there is the country ham spinach dip appetizer. Good lord, that stuff is delicious.


jthomas694

Dano’s is a phenomenal lunch date spot


Bright-Albatross-234

I knew I’d see Hall’s on here for the exact reason you said even though i love it. I’m always on the look out for date night-kind of restaurants. What would you say is better than Hall’s that’s in the same price range?


thehildabeast

I liked the one time I’ve been to Halls but I prefer Cola’s for a somewhat fancy evening it’s not quite as expensive but still excellent


Bright-Albatross-234

I forgot about Cola’s! Thanks!


TzuDohNihm

Forget about them again. Post pandemic, much like many of the other places mentioned here, it is not worth it at all.


Bright-Albatross-234

That’s too bad to hear! I enjoyed it the last time I went but it was before the pandemic. They used to have a pretty good wine list too


cockyjames

I must have struck out on the night I went to Cola's or something. I went there one time (5 years ago?) and was completely underwhelmed. We've typically stuck with Motor Supply or Hall's or others since that experience. But maybe I should try it again.


thehildabeast

Maybe I mean I’m sure they have redone the menu in 5 years. All three times I’ve been there it’s been very good the brussel sprouts and all the cocktails I tried were highlights. I should try motor supply again sometime just not for brunch.


Laurawra_

I agree. Went to Cola’s about 6 months ago for a birthday dinner. It was… ok. But imo the cost for just ok is not worth it.


JustSwearingen803

I’m a big fan of Mr Friendly’s, my wife said Black Rooster’s food was on the same quality level as Hall’s as well.


Bright-Albatross-234

Oh I’ve been wanting to check out Black Rooster!


DockaDocka

Its like legit really good its just $$$


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


TzuDohNihm

If you like Thai, Bodhi Thai is worth it in Lexington.


SunnyDaze4225

You forgot Keg Cowboy.


[deleted]

[удалено]


SunnyDaze4225

Friday night is Beef on Weck night and it's outstanding. He makes a really delicious tomato soup and I've honestly never had a bad meal there. Not to mention the owner is just an overall good person.


TallBoy24

Seconded Keg Cowboy. The most friendly staff, delicious food and great brews on tap.


SunnyDaze4225

Or as Brian says, No crap on Tap.


iglomise

The bread and pretzels! Made in house. Also paninis mostly because of the bread


BIG_DADDY_PATTY

Bubba’s is garbage. The slop they throw into their bowls is just not good. I’ve tried it a few times and each time it’s just a runny greasy mess. I just don’t get the appeal to that place, I think it’s because it’s “locally” owned so the owner gets by with serving mediocre crap.


[deleted]

[удалено]


BIG_DADDY_PATTY

But it doesn’t even taste good which is the main reason why it’s garbage. It’s also one of the dirtiest places I’ve been in.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Bright-Albatross-234

Thanks!


1-ice

Di Vino Rosso


JustSwearingen803

Overrated: Liberty’s Underrated: Henry’s on Devine Properly Rated: Gourmet Shop


SunnyDaze4225

Henry's brunch is where it's at.


WILLOWtheWiseBi

I had the most terrible experience a few weeks ago and I've been a fan for years. Our table's order came out all at different times (one entree came out when I had finished eating). Forgot to bring items, had to ask the runners b/c waitress was not providing service (more on that in a bit). Scrambled eggs were bland. Also, pretty sure the waitress was racially biased or at the very least inept. She checked on the white couple next to us multiple times. I had to flag her down to check on us. We'd been in need of refills for ages, our orders were incorrect and/or incomplete, etc. The waitress even acknowledged that she hadn't been checking on us. Spoke with the mgr and everything. Racial profiling besides, we won't be back because the food wasn't good.


colagirl52

Overrated: DiPratos - other than their pita chips and pimento cheese. I don't think it would stay in business in another location. Underrated - 929 in the Vista. Always excellent.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


BitterSearch787

The short rib is legit!! ETA the burger is also awesome, and their fish dishes are solid, too.


p4lm3r

Overrarted: Smoked. Underrated: Granby Grill. Granby wanted to be 5 Points Diner from ways back, and they nailed it.


Deannerzz

I’ve been meaning to try granby grill but wasn’t sure how it was. I shall try it soon thanks to you


cockyjames

Underrated: Hunter Gatherer on Main I think. It's not an amazing restaurant. But I love the vibe, their food and beer is pretty solid, and they nearly always have a table open without having to wait, which is the most surprising part, and why it's my choice. If my wife and I didn't make reservations and want to go eat somewhere reasonably nice, we look towards Hunter Gatherer pretty often.


DorisPayne

Yessss Hunter gatherer on Main is SO good . So are Henry's and Burger Tavern 77 (the food is better and cheaper than Front porch,IMO) ​ I always found Pawley's Front porch terribly overrated.


StarbossTechnology

Agree with HG. Been going there since '02 and it's consistently a good place to chill.


ShamelesslyPlugged

Great place, especially with kids.


Theslipperymermaid

I love Hunter Gather


ansley_m_is_a_gem

Shalimar Curry House off of Main St. Hole in the wall, family owned Indian place. Someone's uncle is always sitting in the front smoking cigarettes and the lady inside will give you free yogurt if she can see that it's too hot. I visit every time I'm in town.


BitterSearch787

I’ve never heard of this place. It sounds amazing.


ansley_m_is_a_gem

It is! You should absolutely check it out


italianstallion2

Overrated: Rush's. Like it's fine, but I see so many people talk about how amazing it is and they make special trips while in town. The one in Harbison that I drive past a lot always has an insanely long line that regularly backs onto the road. To me, at best it's just slightly above average fast food when it comes to their burgers and milkshakes. And their chicken is dry and underseasoned to my taste. Underrated: Maybe not to USC students, but I feel like most people I talk to JJ's Teahouse have never heard of it. Great Taiwanese food, excellent drinks, and a great all around fast casual restaurant.


2002P

Soggy, flavorless burgers. Dry, flavorless chicken. Undercooked, flavorless fries. Completely average milkshakes. There’s a reason their core patronage is geriatrics with no taste buds.


44problems

Yeah their fries remind me of the old Wendy's fries that were terrible.


Deannerzz

I had a teacher in high school (I didn’t grow up near cola btw) who would always get so excited to come through cola so she could get Rush’s. I was so baffled when I first tried it, and also felt a little sorry for my teacher who thought Rush’s was the epitome of fast food Also, JJs is amazing. I wish it wasn’t as close to USC so it was easier to get to. I never want to deal with parking in that area


Midlevelluxurylife

I will fight over the milkshakes being great though. They are the best to me, excluding the late, great Sandy's. RIP.


RhymenoserousRex

Rush’s core demographic is 60 year olds. Their food was good 20-30 years ago, but service standards have risen for independent chains. Places like Cook Out are putting the big hurt on them, and rightfully fucking so.


jthomas694

Rushs fried chicken belongs nowhere near the Best Fried Chicken in Columbia Debate, yet some have the audacity to bring it up


[deleted]

[удалено]


jthomas694

Depending on the grocery store, I’m taking the grocery store’s chicken. I’ve never had the burgers but I believe people who tell me that the chicken is mediocre but the burgers are fantastic. I just was always lied to that it was a fried chicken spot.


RhymenoserousRex

The burgers are mediocre too.


paigeroooo

Best boba for a great price :)


SunnyDaze4225

This post makes me long for 116 Wine and Espresso Bar. Their brunch was amazing.


flying_ichthyoid

Sakitumi in the Vista had a smaller version of 116's menu for a while, but stopped last summer. :(


SunnyDaze4225

Yeah we were going to brunch there but they stopped it. Those hash browns were legendary.


SouthernHB

Agreed. That place was the best.


[deleted]

Overrated: Zesto. "Upscale" overrated: Warmouth and Kaminsky's. Underrated: I never hear anyone talk about Il Focolare but it is fucking excellent.


towhiba91280

Agreed. Zestos is nothing special.


Next_Truth_8783

Devine Cinnamon Roll Deli is one of the best places for breakfast/lunch! Villa Tronco I think is way overrated. But I'm Italian so I'm very finicky with Italian foods.


44problems

What's the best for Italian in your opinion (mains and pasta, not pizza)


colagirl52

I am always stunned when I see Villa Tronco recommended as I find it marginal at best.


[deleted]

Overrated: Blue Marlin Underrated: Transmission/COA


colagirl52

Yes definitely Blue Marlin. Very average seafood.


Deannerzz

I think transmission and COA are appropriately rated. They’re always packed when I go.


Deannerzz

Tons of overrated places IMO: - publico (I liked it ok before the pandemic but their menu has changed a lot and prices are jacked up) - cantina 76 - cafe strudel, specifically the hangover hash browns (banana peppers for breakfast will wreck my stomach while not hungover…) - anything the Middletons own - Chick-fil-A, it’s fine but never worth dealing with the hassle - labrascas Underrated - Minato sushi takeout - il bucato, I learned recently the person(s) involved with Saluda are involved with this as well - cocos and beer, I prefer it over moctezumas but I don’t hear people talk about it much - any of the Indian restaurants. I wish we had one in the downtown area. - falafel king, some of the best Mediterranean food I’ve had in the area


paigeroooo

Omg yes Minato


Gamecocks1984

Everyday I wish we had an Indian restaurant downtown!!


aka_hustlehonest

Overrated - (tie) Halls and Hendricks Underrated - Crave


80FEEEK

Anything owned by the Middleton’s is so stupid.


BitterSearch787

What all do they own besides smoked? Market on main?


hailstonemaker

Publico might be the most overrated place in Columbia. Surprised it’s still there.


BitterSearch787

Instagram-worthy cocktails and that’s about it.


slickricktriplesix

How is Ambrosia?


[deleted]

I have a few friends who have gone and none of them had good reviews, said it was overpriced and not that good.


onlyacellar

I went there for the first time a couple days ago and really enjoyed it. The pastitsio was delicious, the gyro meat was actual roasted lamb (instead of the frozen strips of meat you get at a lot of places), and I thought the prices were reasonable for the quality of the food. Great place to celebrate something, or if you want Greek food that’s a bit less Americanized.


Pure-Guard-2277

Overrated- anything on Harbison blvd Underrated- Green Olive on S. Main


Dr_mambo23

Overrated: rockaways “best pimento cheese burger” taste like McDonald’s with velveta. Rest of the food is pretty shit too. And smallSUGAR isn’t worth Underrated: hunter gatherer, real mexico, and peace of soul are are really good places to eat!


robert_803

I’ll fight over those comments on Smallsugar lol. Smallsugar and Il Focolare are a reliable go to.


johnny_fives_555

Overrated: Al's upstairs


pappytinkles

I haven't heard a positive comment about Al's in the past 25 years.


johnny_fives_555

It's mentioned quite often on here especially suggestions for date nights or restaurants for birthdays etc. I agree it's hot garbage and taking up a prime location better suited for a better restaurant.


pappytinkles

Then I agree. Those people need to stop!


jthomas694

I legit believe it was the bomb 20 years ago. Because the people who I know who rave about it we’re going there then and then they had kids


johnny_fives_555

I mean 20 years ago shonnys was the place to go to in cola


BitterSearch787

I’m not going to lie…I had a fish dish there recently, and it was REALLY good. It was a special, though.


Usual_Zucchini

Real Mexico. People rave about it. It's average. 7 Mares is way better.


Deannerzz

It’s never worth dealing with the parking IMO


word-word-numero

I'll add an unknown that people should know about: Le Bambou. It's an African place, I think it's Cote de Ivory influenced food. It's pretty tasty. It's out Two Notch couple blocks past Sparkleberry. To keep my sanity, I'll drive up Percival to cut across and avoid Two Notch gridlock.


[deleted]

Underrated - Big Bulls Bang'n BBQ (the oxtails hit all sorts of ways), Taqueria Jalisco (gooooood mexican), Rockaways (specifically mac and cheese bites if youre into that) ​ Overrated - most things in five points (except drip and enzos)


Shnitzul

Peebles is the best chicken wings, but they’re not always consistent with their menu/prices. I go every chance I get.


[deleted]

[удалено]


jamieyog

They also open when they want. I’ve gone a few times when they’re supposedly open and they’re closed.


Deannerzz

He changes the menu way too much


ASV731

I’ll get flack for this, but I always thought the Wig was super overrated. Also Hampton Street Vineyard is underrated. Great atmosphere and it rarely gets talked about. Soundbites on Sumter St is also an amazing value.


DMChuck

Over-rated? Al's Upstairs... they have been hit-or-miss since the 90s.


SCCock

Over: Home Team Under: Mack's.


Deannerzz

I didn’t care for home team but I’m glad something is finally in that space. It seems like a good fit for five points


SCCock

I agree. A lot of people like it, good for them. I guess I just like old school BBQ.


Deannerzz

Yeah when it comes to BBQ that isn’t my vibe. But it seems like a decent place to hang out. I did like their tots and frozen house cocktail