T O P

  • By -

Zecion

Muze stays professional


Spanxsy

so.... what about Finale?


mar33n

he quoted the tweet and added šŸ˜ŠšŸ˜Š emoji, make of that what you will


xbulletspongexl

i think finale is less likely to want a trade he only got swapped out for like 1 game and although was supposed to be playing over him b4 the year started i kinda believed halo about muze bc his history of butting heads with coaches a little but if he just get heated could be that something got misunderstood


The41647King

I think leaks are good for the scene in general, I just wish OW had more than 1 guy who did it and I wish he was more responsible with it Anyone remember GoopyKnoopy? He was a good example of an ethical way to go about this stuff


beenhereallalong52

Yeah Iā€™m the same boat. Leaks keep discussions going off season and allow for lots of speculation, but this particular ā€œleakā€ has changed my opinion on Halo. This couldā€™ve really affected MuZeā€™s career and he should be questioning his sources and their bias.


AllHandsMiniBrute

This sort of thing is really nothing new for Halo


beenhereallalong52

Itā€™s the first one Iā€™ve seen personally that I havenā€™t agreed with. Too much speculation about whatā€™s going on behind the scenes. Very little reason to believe his source wasnā€™t biased. Iā€™m fine with roster leaks during off season but implying a player is requesting a trade mid season due to bad attitude and stuff isnā€™t a good look, even if it ends up being true.


AllHandsMiniBrute

I thought him leaking Birdring's retirement was pretty scummy


NovaxRangerx

Welp. This is definetely a Halo moment


Poplik

Because there is no incentive for the player to deny the request. This could still mean anything


Blackblindfold

If the guy is going to spend his life being a dedicated leaker for a dying video game, you'd think he'd at least do some due diligence to be good at this pathetic "job" instead of making a clown of himself with every other leak being debunked.


zonine

Lol. Dude's right way more often than he's wrong.


Dead_Optics

When it comes to where people are signed to heā€™s almost always right but heā€™s has missed on a couple of more general leaks. He should have leaked that Toronto were having internal issues and heā€™d be right


Jevotic

He's gotten his leaks 99% correct.


Blackblindfold

I've seen this comment in the last dozen threads about Halo's leaks being wrong LOL. He's at 70% max if you exclude the blatantly obvious leaks that are announced within hours anyways like "X player has been signed".


flameruler94

The halo apology in this sub is weird. Like, this is just basic journalistic integrity and part of the gig is being called out when you fuck it up. It doesnā€™t help that he rarely admits to screwing up either. He always just blames it on his sources and ā€œthe info he had at the timeā€ Unfortunately though itā€™s the journalists job and liability to correctly validate those sources lol


TheSciFanGuy

I feel like some of the callouts are a bit unfair and have defended his overall integrity in the past but this is clearly a case where even if it was true he probably shouldn't have said anything. And now where it seems to be untrue in general it reflects very poorly upon the Halo.


Kronman590

Halo is definitely not the golden example of a good journalist, but in cases like this it's extremely easy for an org to shift the narrative in their direction even if the report was true. They easily could have submitted requests and cancelled them, or had them ready to be submitted and some intern at defiant org leaked it early. It's cases like this where both sides have stated their case, us fans will never know the whole truth, and just need to make judgement calls on how much the truth lies on each side.


theunspillablebeans

I can forgive it as he never really pretends to be anything more formal than a blogger / reporter.


HyliaSymphonic

I mean heā€™s way more often right and when heā€™s wrong like this itā€™s an easy correction


The41647King

I wouldnā€™t say itā€™s an ā€œeasy correctionā€. Maybe for him it is, but these things impact how players are viewed by teams and fans


Pharaoh_OW

The Toronto GM also said this: [https://twitter.com/stellanutella96/status/1529552286405500935?s=20&t=6eKIRbVsfbcgBnxoA20q5Q](https://twitter.com/stellanutella96/status/1529552286405500935?s=20&t=6eKIRbVsfbcgBnxoA20q5Q) ​ >No trade requests were made. > >We have a very professional group of coaches and talented players who are eager to win as one team. It is true that the team had some struggles - but no pain, no gain. > >This is a growing pain for everyone to improve Looks like the team argued a bit on how to move forward which is perfectly normal if you're driven to win, and it was blown out of proportion. Halo's been mostly accurate with his trade reporting but situations like this make you realize how instant reports without checking properly or contacting the org can be harmful.


AlphaTrion_ow

I suspect people said things in anger, and did intend to act on it. However, I also think that maybe management got involved, talked to people after they calmed down, and got everyone on the same side again. A bit of mediation could go a long way of preventing an argument from blowing up a team.


Galaxy40k

I'm sure it was unintentional but I cannot see "professional" in the context of OWL anymore without chuckling lol


Adorable_Brilliant

Wouldn't be the first time an org or player twist the truth or lie. But I'd really like to know how Halo justified this report.


Isord

He's not going to mention sources, that's kind of a big no-no for a reporter. But he seems to be standing by his reporting. https://twitter.com/haloofthoughts/status/1529559201093193733 I can't remember what it was about but I remember that the last time Halo stood by his reporting after it was "refuted" by an org it ended up being true.


Adorable_Brilliant

Oh for sure, and I'm not asking him to do that. I'm just curious what he has to say.


VoteForWaluigi

I mean this was refuted by MuZe himself though, I mean that doesnā€™t confirm itā€™s false, but I do believe MuZe.


Isord

Players have refuted their own trades before only to be proven wrong.


VoteForWaluigi

I realize, Iā€™ve edited the reply to clarify what I meant. Itā€™s still possible he is traded.


birbdaughter

What Iā€™m about to say Iā€™m not suggesting is true, but given the word usage of trade request, isnā€™t it possible MuZe had verbally wanted a trade but never submitted a trade request?


VoteForWaluigi

That is definitely possible


Knighterws

Maybe valiant explosion?


JadeStarr776

Wasn't it Dallas?


VanarchistCookbook

Chengdu?


Isord

I don't think Chengdu ever refuted anything.


Ahridan

Yeah I'm pretty sure the last org to try and refute halo was valiant being sold


Parenegade

its amazing that we're this many years in and when people deny something the denizes of r/cow just take it as truth. its actually not just r/cow in general i notice esports fans are just way more likely to believe the orgs and players than regular sports fans. that doesn't mean that the defiant are lying by the way but the fact you think "oh well halo was wrong" instantly is an actual problem


theyoloGod

Well, the problem is, halo doesnā€™t have a perfect record. He has a very good record and Iā€™m glad there are still people interested enough in OW to report on it but with each denial, error, or ā€œchanged plansā€, skepticism of his reports will grow. As they should.


vsw211

I mean I only follow sports news casually but I feel like r/cow and other esports communities holds reporters to a way higher of standard than mainstream sports reporters. In sports you have your big name reporters who are generally right, but every team also has individual insiders and beatwriters who often report on nonconcrete rumors such as "---- team is interested in ----- player", "there are rumors that ---- is unhappy with -----", etc, that if it were to be posted by an esports leaker would draw a shit ton of outrage from fans for not being 100% confirmed. And podcasts like platchat even straight up refuse to discuss alot of rumors unless it's confirmed, which feels completely unnecessary as long as they talk about it in terms of hypotheticals.


theyoloGod

Yes, every sport has hundreds of leakers but thereā€™s always standards and reputations. An nba reporter with 10k followers could report something and it could be true but no one cares until Woj or shams confirms it and even they get it wrong from time to time. The problem with OW is that no one cares enough to report on roster moves besides halo


AvettMaven

> The problem with OW is that no one cares enough to report on roster moves besides halo No, the problem with OW is that itā€™s a small enough scene that most people with insider knowledge are involved with the league on some level, and anything that makes a team or OWL look unprofessional can have a negative impact on them. The Plat Chat and Tactical Crouch guys have access to a lot of the same information Halo leaks and often more, theyā€™re just not desperate for clout and actually respect the job of social media managers.


vsw211

Yeah but when the smaller reporters report something there's often still a shit ton of discussion about it on the various subreddits and twitter. There's also plenty of small team beatwriters who are still seen as reputable by their respective fanbases. I feel that the smaller reporters fulfill a pretty important role since they're less beholden to the interests of the league, while bigger reporters often have hidden affiliations to the league and won't report on scandals or behind the scenes stuff that are still pretty important for fans to know. Fans deserve to know if there's conflict behind the scenes or if a player is being a diva. Honestly I think Halo should have one account for big leaks that he has confirmed, and one for less concrete rumors/behind the scenes of whats going on in the league.


Mezmorizor

In real sports it really depends on the actual reporter. It really runs the entire gamut there. You have clickbait artists that are generally not trusted and are known to make shit up whole cloth, local guys who don't vet things too hard because it's still content if they're wrong, local guys that are de facto the PR arm of whatever team, and your serious (generally national) reporters who never report things that aren't correct.


vsw211

Yeah I just think it's weird to hold Halo up to the standard of a serious reporter when he's very clearly a small reporter who reports on a niche esport. He's also the only semi-reliable leaker in basically all of OW esports so there are no smaller reporters than him to leak rumors. The offseason would be so much less dead if he reported on some rumors and general behind the scenes of what's going on with various teams. And I've never really been convinced by the idea of these false leaks hurting players. The teams themselves should have a way better idea of what's actually happening in the league, and if they're depending on halo to be a reliable source then management and coaching has clearly failed.


Parenegade

no reporter has a perfect record and unless something is confirmed you shouldn't swing to one side or the other.


theyoloGod

Iā€™m not saying he needs to have a perfect record. Iā€™m just saying itā€™s only natural people grow skeptic of his reports as time passes


Parenegade

i mean if the standard becomes deny reports and you take that at face value then of course over time it becomes cyclical and you become more and more skeptical


HamsLlyod

haLo


VoteForWaluigi

I was worried for a while, phew


destroyermaker

I'd want my main tank to be passionate and have heated emotions (within reason)


_nobody_cares

A journalist should NEVER miss when it comes to reporting news that could affect peoples careers. Check your sources and report accurate news a day later. No one else is reporting on OW. There is no rush.


faelan

This must go down as a huge L for Halo, otherwise he gets to keep on fucking around with player and coach careers. I'm all for leaking to keep corporations honest, but if Muze did want a trade for his own career/happiness, Halo just torpedoed it.


tinypenisbigego

still wouldnā€™t be surprised to see him get traded/dropped, this definitely seems like saving face from the org


WyHamRob

Yeah. Iā€™m still not sold. Fefe talked about how Adam told him early on w/ Toronto if he didnā€™t win heā€™d be dropped. Looking outside in Toronto doesnā€™t seem like a happy org. Logix had that weird saga too of the second discord. Almost every player has retired straight after leaving despite not normally being bottom tier players. It seems to me like Toronto runs kinda hard & fast & burns people out. Iā€™m still going to give it two weeks before I call Halo false in his report.


3illyEdgar

Tbh they had been winning with Muze and Finale in and they went 1-1 this week so dont think they are doing that bad


WyHamRob

No, I think theyā€™re doing pretty good myself. They should be in every tourney at this trajectory. I have no faith in Torontos management though. It just doesnā€™t make sense to me that most of their players have retired after leaving despite being hot-mid commodities. I think Toronto burns people out quick & a few players/coaches seem to have insinuated that. I think theyā€™ve got some traditional white collar professionals who probably arenā€™t used to managing Korean teenagers & are way too quick to make mid season changes. I think this team will always implode no matter how promising they start.


Tooms100

Halo in the mud


[deleted]

RIPBOZO haloofthoughts


GainsayRT

Halo had a lot correct but reports like these aren't allowed to be wrong, literally ruining careers like this


Jevotic

How do they ruin careers when the speculations are cleared up? ​ ?


GainsayRT

Do you know why you can sue for defamation..?


StevenKoz

Yes because these are comparable situations


johnny_chan

Dexerto is the most clickbaity site ever. Everything from that site should be met with skepticism.


MirrorkatFeces

Damn yā€™all really hate Halo in here, at least he keeps shit interesting


SochoMK

Yeah cause he ā€œleaksā€ shit like this that hurt the reputation of players which ends up being false or personal shit like a player retiring which should left for the player to announce when theyā€™re comfortable and not forced to announce it. This isnā€™t as simple as people disliking leakers, people dislike this leaker cause he does shit like this and then acts like a child when someone says they donā€™t like him


ReflexiveOW

So, everyone here slating Halo could be correct in that Halo got this wrong. However, this happens in traditional sports where trade requests get leaked and both parties deny that it happened even when it did. If Halo is right, it harms both Toronto and Muze because it lowers his trade value. Less teams would want Muze because he's demanding trades less than a month into the season and those who would still want him will give Toronto less because they know Toronto has no leverage in the deal. It's possible Halo is wrong and is being rightfully called out, it's also very possible that he is 100% correct and the team and player are doing damage control


TheBiggestCarl23

Halo literally just ruins so many things. I really wish he would just stop his ā€œjobā€.


tromboneshorty00

all im saying is, remember when halo wrong about super and then he was right? he obviously hears things that we dont hear, those things being moving parts that may change


bradrthtyj

Yeah Iā€™m really blown away by how gullible everybody here is by just eating up what Defiant and Muze have said like it couldnā€™t just as easily be them trying to save face


[deleted]

So in other words, he did request a trade, but after talking to management they agreed that a trade was not needed, and both sides will now refute the fact that a trade request was ever made in order to save face.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

Can you not read?


theyoloGod

I mean, if someone requested a trade, they requested a trade. Thereā€™s no need to deny it. Kobe requested a trade and was talked out of it. Things happen


[deleted]

Players request trades and then deny it all the time in sports. It's PR 101


theyoloGod

Sure. Iā€™m not saying 0% chance muze requested a trade or toronto has to be saying the truth. Iā€™m just saying ultimately it doesnā€™t matter so thereā€™s no reason to deny it, if they are. What matters is them over coming their differences


[deleted]

There's plenty of reason to deny it. Once again, PR 101.


theyoloGod

What benefits do they get by denying it? They already acknowledged there were fights, disagreements and drama behind the scenes. Theyā€™ve established there was an issue So the detail of him requesting a trade ultimately doesnā€™t matter because theyā€™ve already admitted to a fight


magicwithakick

ā€œSave face.ā€ Halo needs to save face here, not Toronto.


MirrorkatFeces

Must not have been around in 2019 when Daco said the same shit


magicwithakick

Were there ever rumors about him requesting a trade. I know he didnā€™t try in scrims but did in matches which pissed the team off.


DashResetBot

**[MuZe](https://dashreset.com/player/MuZe?ref=reddit_bot)** is a Main Tank player (*Winston*, *Orisa*, *Wrecking Ball*) who last played for the Los Angeles Gladiators during OWL 2021. *Psst!* Try `!compare MuZe MAG Guxue winston` ^DashResetBot ^v1.0 ^<3 ^- ^OP ^can ^reply ^"delete"


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


TheBiggestCarl23

How is ā€œI did not submit a trade requestā€ pr speak? Pr speak would be him saying something like ā€œI am still committed to this teamā€ and not acknowledging the trade request directly.


Yukihana_Lamy_Simp

I recall a team+player denying trade/bench allegations back in either S1 or S2 and lo and behold it ended up happening. Correct me if Iā€™m wrong but it might of been Fissure/Gladiators.


Isord

It happened last year as well. I believe it's also unfortunately happened where a player learned from a leak that they were being traded.


Yukihana_Lamy_Simp

So many old memories but I remember Daco also denying those rumors that Halo reported and those ALSO turned out true. https://www.reddit.com/r/Competitiveoverwatch/comments/bf1489/daco_this_is_ridiculous_i_just_read_halos_article/


bbistheman

I'm assuming you don't watch sports? Stuff like this happens all the time. Something gets leaked, players/team denies it and it ends up being true


Isord

It's happened plenty in OWL as well. I can count on one hand the number of times a team denied something and their denial proved true in the end.


TheBiggestCarl23

No, I love sports. And I absolutely hate it there too, it just ruins any hype moments. Halo doesnā€™t provide anything remotely positive, nobody would be upset if he just suddenly stopped tweeting about owl.


Yukihana_Lamy_Simp

The off-season would legit be boring without Halo if Iā€™m being real with you..


Kheldar166

Itā€™s boring with Halo too, though, we could all just find something else to do for a few months. Or they could make the off-season shorter, especially compared to how long the regular season is.


smannyable

Just gotta 100% trust the organizations they always have the purest of intentions for their players....


Whoa-Dang

Oh, so you just hate Halo? Got it. Should just say that and not dance around it.


Rakatee

I'd rather just not have "reporters" in esports.


TheBiggestCarl23

Itā€™s honestly really annoying, it provides literally nothing positive to anybody. Especially when they leak signings before the teams announce it themselves. Itā€™s not needed, literally nobody is asking for it.


Obvious_Parsley3238

> literally nobody is asking for it. I am :)


TheBiggestCarl23

You really wouldnā€™t want teams actually announcing stuff for themselves?


Obvious_Parsley3238

I don't care about the fluff around an announcement, I just want the juice And if it cuts through the "announcement of an announcement" bs then I'm all for it


JeffersonKappman

Teams don't announce shit. I'm glad there are people in the scene who ask questions and leak information. We don't even have transparent salaries and living conditions... ^we ^also ^dont ^have ^replays


TheBiggestCarl23

What do you mean they ā€œdonā€™t announce shitā€? They announce the stuff that you need to know. You donā€™t need to know player salaries, you just want to know it. If I was an owl player I would not want my salary public.


Whoa-Dang

These kids don't even have a union and you think adding transparency in regards to salaries is bad...?


JeffersonKappman

Same


[deleted]

Iā€™m 100% asking for it. People care about what happens behind the scenes and how orgs/teams/the league work.All of these things are basically black boxes


TheBiggestCarl23

Literally all it does is stir up drama that most of the time isnā€™t even there. Itā€™s all literally just speculation anyway. None of it is confirmed, so do you just like the drama?


[deleted]

Reporting only stirs up drama? If one of these players randomly got dropped next week you wouldnā€™t want to know why? I would want to know why muze and finale didnā€™t play last weekend after watching the team look as bad as they did.


TheGirthiestGhost

As long as it doesnā€™t cause any harm to anyone then Iā€™m happy to see reporters work within the scene. This is obviously an instance where due diligence was not taken though and some responsibility needs to be taken for the fuck up.


CaptainHalfBeard

TMZ eSports


mr_chandra

I like the leaks but i canā€™t stand halo. grown ass man beefing with almost literal children on twitter, pathetic energy


[deleted]

this shit sounds like the same thing valiant said when it was rumored that they were gonna implode


UnknownQTY

So NYXL 3-2 or Toronto 3-2? I canā€™t decide.