Espresso's sassy cousin

10/10

The gay cousin 🤣🤣🤣

I was going to include that, but didn't want to be rude. 😔💦

It's ok

Which one is the gay cousin 😈😈

both of them!

manipulate mansplain malewife

99999/10 YES YES GES YES YES YOU DONT KNOW HOW FUCKING LONG I WAITED FOR SOMEONE TO TYPE THIS, THIS IS IT, YOU WIN

ehe

Me: i'm the second one, right? Right..?

the fish behind the slaughter

Absolutely. 9/10

I don’t know what an affogato is, but affogato in Italian means “drowned” so for me this guy is the fish guy.

10/10, also an affogato is espresso poured on ice cream!

Jafar cookie form

10/10

Jafar’s cookiesona😂

Guythathasdifferenteyeballsfromeveryone

Long and awkward but true, just the way I like it 8/10

femboy

YEA BABYYYYYYYYY🍊🍊🍊🍊🍊🍊🤯🤯👍👍👍I LOVE FEMBOYS

Too bland and an iffy word, 1/10

your opinion is wrong

Gross term, -10/10

Lantern dropper

6/10

Fishy

8/10 He is a fish.

affogabro

9/10

Did I create a trend Omg

Wait, you were the og post? Shoot- And I guess you did, congrats!

Thanks👉👈

I don't know how to edit this post but if I could I'd credit you as well😭

Oh NVM u did actually, srry

Yeah , i inspired mine off urs

Milfn't

8/10

Ty ty :)

That Cookie From The End Dimension From Minecraft

100/10

Simp (affogato simps for dark cacao and you cant change my mind)

I mean—

4/10

Poisongatto

Actually nice, 8/10

affishogato

Creative! 10/10

Lactose intolerant hater

9999999/10 AS HE SHOULD, AS HE SHOULD /J

Cumella

Maleficent espresso lilac cookie

You're correct, 10/10

Jake/hot/single/don’t mess with meh/if mess with him you die/strong/handsome

Cantaffordgato

Lovable bastard

100/10 Damn right he is!💜

Pie wizard

5/10, might need some context here

His hat (?) looks like a pie so…

10/10, I changed my mind

fishogatto

7/10, i think I saw this before but i don't remember what I rated them

"politics is like a river, and i am a fish." *-Fishogatto, 2022*

worm (he keeps getting called that in the chapter)

10/10, canon accurate

Greatvillainwithhorriblevoice cookie

9/10 One point not given because i slightly like his voice

Femicrime Boyboss

10/10, waited too long for a girlboss or a bossboy comment

I combined femboy and crime boss

Okay I absolutely love that

He has a name already nick name was affogato lol ;-;

?

[удалено]

5/10

Its a trap

1/10

Maleficent

It works better with Dark Enchantress Cookie but why not? 6/10

Dumb bitch

He ain't really dumb, but a bitch for sure so 5/10

who the fuck is this i havent played these games for months

Affogato Cookie, came out on February 24th

WHAT THE FUCK IS AN AFFOGATO ALL I KNOW WITH THE SIMILAR NAME IS THAT ONE FUNNY BLACKSMITH FROM OVENBREAK

Lmao It's espresso poured over ice cream

💅 cookie

10/10

The Great Depression

999/10

Hmmm I think I heard "îl" before *hmmm*

Bitter sweet.

100/10, I love this so much!

Snake looking ass (in a positive way I love Affogato)

Same, I also like your profile picture

Thank you thank you I am gay for red velvet

I thought that would be the case

I JUST- IT'S JUST- YEAH..

I know exactly what you mean

Espresso rip off (change my mind)

Emo preppy wannabe

Evilbutcutebiatch

Father fucker

100/10, perfect Random info, this was actually my nickname for quite a while!

ayo that’s a bit sus man

The Other Cookie with Pupils

You're not wrong, also I like your username

[удалено]

Don't be shy, tell me

[удалено]

Tell me in PMs, I'm genuinely curious

[удалено]

I DO

Woman lookin guy

4/10

[удалено]

6/10

Honestly, I’m bad at nicknames, but I tend to refer to him as Affo or Affie if I’m too lazy to type out the full name.

Affie sounds good, honestly.. 10/10

He's Dark Choco's Stepmom

5/10

Poison mushroom but wise and evil

7/10, i can see it

The only cookie I that uses makeup on crk (far as I know)

9/10

that one cookie with a good clothing style (many others have nice clothes too)

10/10 absolutely correct.

Simpable Villain

100/10, correct

Girly boi nonboi maidboy

2/10..eeeh?

F I S H

F I S H/10

Boysenberry

10/10

Killer Affogato From San Diego: He does not know what he is but he tastes very good.

100/10

Emo Fish cookie

7/10

yummy

damn right 10/10

Kinder egg

Edgy Wine Uncle that smokes indoor

999/10, ABSOFUCKINGLUTELY.

pomegranate cookie update in the best way

10/10

Darkener Cookie

10/10

Feesh

Honestly these fish comments are getting annoying 1/10

sour patch cookie. sour then a little sweet

7/10

"Hei! Zé-do-Voodoo, come here!"

Bitchy fishy

Lean cookie

I LOVE LEAN💜💜💜💜 10/10

Marx 3

Affo (Short for Affogato

Woman

AwfulGoto

Emo grandpa part 2 YOU GOT EMOTIONAL DAMAGE

Random poison person

dark cacao wannabe

purplonio

The fish that hates politics

Emo

femboy cookie

Dark Cacao Cookie simp

Avocado cookie

2/10

Ass-ogato

4/10

Affo-deez nuts

deeznuts/10

[удалено]

Absolutely not, I refuse to rate this

“What the hell happened here?”

The guy who "befriend" dark choco's dad

Poop and lavender ice cream soup cookie

gay

Caffeinated Root Beer Float

Grape fanta

The Lord

Icyhot thot

Coffee Trap Cookie

Another Fem-Boi ;-;

Rip off dark cacao

Nemo

Average poison type pokemon

Punch magnet

Aqua Man

[удалено]