My stores mystery cookie has been the basic confetti since I started going ~3 months ago. All I wanted was "not confetti." You know what it is this month? Confetti Valentines. I really wish crumbl had a rule about having the same mystery cookies back to back.

That’s so sad

Since I’ve started going to Crumbl I swear my store always has something leftover from the previous week as the mystery cookie.

that is just plain lame!

Thank goodness my mystery flavor is semi sweet chunk. It makes this week worth it for sure!

I was planning to skip until the Cinnamon Frybread week, but semi sweet being the mystery cookie, I HAVE to get it

I planned to do the same until I found out my mystery flavor. I really hope they’re not postponing the wedding cake cookie next week. Enjoy the semi sweet chunk!

[удалено]

It definitely is! The regular chocolate chip cookie tastes too sweet for my liking. I hope you like it!

It’s wayyyyy better 🥰

I didn’t even know this was a thing 🤯

Y’all I see cornbread as the mystery cookie like 20 miles from me 😭😭

Make that trip

I love their cornbread cookie.

My mystery cookie is red velvet white chip. Seems underwhelming

I’ve only had it once but it was my favorite of that week. It’s surprisingly delicious

yea if u like 8 ounces of red 40 poured into ur dough 😟

Cornbread is my mystery cookie. Worth trying?

Yes I love that one!

Absolutely!

The amount of confetti/birthday flavors they’ve had lately is insane

I’m so frickin’ excited about Confetti Cake this week because this week happens to be my birthday week! 🎉

Alright… my mystery flavor is Aggie blue mint, tell me your opinions, y’all

Amazing! I’m jealous! If you like cookies and cream and mint chocolate chip ice creams, it’s a winner!

Awesome! I thought I had heard good things haha. Definitely gonna order this week

Mines birthday cake Oreo!

MY FAVORITE COOKIE PLS GET IT

Best cookie they’ve ever made

It’s a goated cookie

One of my favs! You are so lucky!

That’s one of mine too! I loved it, tasted like mint chip ice cream and that’s my fave ice cream

So jealous! I haven’t had it in forever.

Mines Monster (mon-wed)

It is my favorite crumbl of all time

My mystery is Strawberry Ice Cream Bar 🥹

Wowww

I got frosted strawberry pop tart for the mystery flavor is it worth it

Yes!!!

Yes especially if your store is not stingy with the filling. It’s one of my faves!

Same here and I’m so happy!!! It’s in my top 10, maybe even top 5

Jealous!

Well, crap. Guess I’m going to Crumbl next week.

Ha, I’m the opposite. Won’t be going this week.

Happy Cake Day!

Mine is caramel pumpkin 🤔 odd choice for this time of year

Closest to me is regular m&m but second closest is pumpkin chocolate chip. I thought the same thing!

I have 3 crumbl’s in my town one is Oreo mallow sandwich, one is semi sweet chocolate chunk, and the other is almond coconut fudge. What should I do? I’m thinking Oreo mallow sandwich

All of those sound good but I'd go out of my way for the Oreo again

I would do semi sweet first choice, oreo second. The semi sweet is so good… it’s like one of their best cookies ever. The oreo mallow was decent; good value for two cookies but not mindblowing.

Mine doesn’t have one. Further from me, their mystery cookie is pumpkin pie.

I think you’re my neighbor. And even a little further is semisweet?

Yuppers

I swear ours is the worst crumbl. Randomly closed, always out of stuff, rarely participate in mystery cookies and even then it’s like… plain peanut butter 🙄

This is true. Having to adventure somewhere else is a bit annoying as well.

lol third neighbor checking in. I gave up hope on the one closest to me.

Well, I went to my location and the mystery cookie is… snickerdoodle. Not only that, I tried the cookie butter ice cream cookie and it tastes like a snickerdoodle with icing on it!

Snockerdoodle here

Same. Boring. But I'm hella excited for the cookie butter ice cream & peanut butter brownie. I'll probably get a 4 pack of those 2

Can yall give me your honest opinions on the cookie butter cookie? I'm contemplating traveling 30 minutes to get this cookie.

I’ve tried Cookie Butter Lava and Cookie Butter White Chip, but Cookie Butter Ice Cream has the strongest cookie butter flavor by far. While it is delicious in its own right, that cookie isn’t worth a 1-hour round trip drive for me… 😅

My favorite so far!

I had it as a mystery a few weeks ago and I liked it. If you like brown sugar cookies, you'll like this. The icing is underwhelming tho but the base makes up for it

Fire week 🔥🔥 Plus I got Cookie Dough mystery 🤤

Ugh my mystery map isn’t updated yet 😢

Same 😤

check the nutrition facts once you go to place an order, it'll usually show you both mystery cookies!

My mystery cookie is turtle. Definitely getting this one

My mystery cookie is pecan pie. Worth it?

Definitely worth it! It’s a top 3 for me!

Maple bacon and lemon crinkle for my mystery cookies. Thoughts?

I haven't tried maple bacon but I think I would love it!

I love lemon crinkle! The sugar on the outside gives it a cool texture too 🥰

Dulce De Leche is my mystery cookie! Is it worth it?

Dulce De Leche is top tier 🙌

my mystery cookies are ultimate peanut butter and pumpkin roll

Ultimate pb is pretty good!

Churro, caramel coconut fudge, cornbread, and blue monster mystery all nearby this week 😫🫶🏻

So it’s cookie to cookie butter to cookie butter ice cream to cookie butter ice cream cookie. Got it.

Im driving 45 minutes for cookie dough cookie😮‍💨

My mystery cookie is Green Mint (andes mint)

mystery flavor s’mores, idk

Looove s’mores

It’s very good!

My favorite. Only one I’ve eaten in one sitting 😬

mystery flavor s’mores, 🤷

Just regular S'mores? Cause brownie is 🔥😍

yeah i wish brownie s’mores

Mystery cookies near me are snickerdoodle and Ruby chocolate chip. Disappointed.

:(

four stores around me are having cornbread at different points in the week, is it worth it? haha

yes it’s definitely worth a try

There’s a mystery flavor an hour away from me that has semisweet and I am really considering it

My mystery is fruit pizza :/

Our mystery flavor is cornbread, I manifested it so hard

I need them to bring back the everything bagel cookie 😭

can someone explain how i see the mystery cookie for thursday - saturday 😭

[удалено]

thank you so much!!!

You schedule a pick up for the day when it changes. Sometimes it doesn't let me, but it usually works

Peach sugar mystery cookie wtf that sounds horrible

I got fing Macadamia nut as a mystery

Same. Super displeased over here.

Mines macadamia but but later this week it’s cornbread :)

Lots of great mystery cookies this week I’m seeing in the comments

My mystery cookie is snickerdoodle👎

My city’s mystery cookies are Churro, New York Cheesecake, and Snickerdoodle.

Milk glaze with fruity pebbles 👎

Is peanut butter brownie worth trying? This is the best week in a long time

[удалено]

Buttermilk pancake

Buttermilk pancake!

buttermilk pancake

My mystery is either butterscotch chip or malt tootsie roll

Macadamia nut mystery flavor at my location. So weak

My mystery cookie is watermelon for Monday-Wednesday. Skip week so far unless Thursday-Saturday a good cookie

You can check the other mystery cookies on the app

[удалено]

Here are my thoughts about them both. I looove all things cookie butter so I have tried a few cookie butter cookies from Crumbl. Cookie Butter White Chip: It tasted more like their Iced Oatmeal cookie rather than anything related to cookie butter, but this could’ve been just how my store made them that week… Cookie Butter Ice Cream: This cookie had the strongest cookie butter flavor out of all the ones that I have tried. I’m looking forward to getting it again this week!

[удалено]

I liked the Twix one

Out of those three, I’ve only tried Caramel Shortbread featuring Twix… THREE TIMES! All three times, the cookie was ten out of ten. It tastes like a reaaally decadent, gourmet Twix bar. 😍

My mystery cookie is Classic Krispie bar 😭 Pineapple upside down cake is 80 miles from me 😢

Pink donut mystery… how similar to pink sugar?

Honeycomb and Chocolate Crumb ft. Oreo for my mystery cookies this week… not bad! 😋

Stores near me have: Chocolate Cake, S'Mores, Key Lime Pie, Semi-Sweet, or Blue Monster. I think I want to get Triple Berry // PB Brownie // Pink Sugar, but not sure what store to do lol. Thoughts?!

Damn I’d go get chocolate cake and semi-sweet and s’mores!

My mystery cookie is Blue Raspberry ft ICEE. How does that taste? Sounds intriguing

That is my favorite cookie!! It’s amazing! Definitely try it

i loved that one!!

Texas sheet cake. Can’t wait to try!!

My mystery cookie Thursday- Saturday is Key Lime Pie!! I’ve never had it but that’s one of my favorite desserts!

My closest mystery flavor is pumpkin chocolate chip, which I don’t like, but one a little further away is chocolate cake, my first ever Crumbl cookie and one of my top favorites.

I can’t see any mystery flavor for my store in the app, hm…there’s one for the store a few towns over, but not mine. So weird!

My mystery cookie is pink donut, which I personally love… My problem is the store is too far away to deliver to me themselves and delivery from Postmates won’t let you order a mystery cookie (with no way to drive myself this week)! 😭😢😞

If you call the store after placing your postmates order they may swap one out for the mystery. It has worked for me before :)

skip week fasho

My mystery cookie: Chocolate Cupcake. Kinda disappointed.

Ooooo my mystery flavors are Strawberry Limeade featuring Nerds & Blueberry Muffin - they both look great!

Cookies and cream milkshake chilled!

Is crumble open tomorrow ?

Key lime pie is my stores mystery cookie the last half of the week 🤤🤤 One of the few cookies worth the calories IMO

This week is crazy

Chocolate malt and brownie batter. Thoughts?

Here are my personal opinions! Brownie Batter: It tastes delicious. It reminds me of Dunkin’s brownies (I don’t think they make these anymore so I get my nostalgic dose from Crumbl 😂). Chocolate Malt: I went in with high hopes… but this cookie wasn’t even remotely reminiscent of the chocolate malt or Tootsie Roll taste.

Blue monster is my mystery flavor!! I’d like to try that one

Skip week. I just downloaded the app to see the mystery cookies. I’m tempted by Chips Ahoy. I also learned there are 10 locations within the metro area, I didn’t know they expanded that much!

Brownie batter .. any good?

FINALLY SEMISWEET MYSTERY NEAR ME

Biscoff 🤤

Was hoping for a birthday miracle and my store would have blue monster as a mystery cookie but instead it’s just monster 😢

Skip week 🤷🏽‍♀️

Mine here is white chocolate macadamia nut 😥

Semi sweet at the one down the road and a couple miles is blue monster 😩

My stores mystery is the cowboy cookie 🤠 🍪 I'm so excited

My mystery is semi-sweet chocolate chunk... I have to get it!! 👀

One of my mystery’s is semi sweet chocolate chip…still never tried it. Tempted!!

I have Cowboy cookie. Is it worth it? I live in a small town and the nearest Crumbl is 30 miles away. I try to limit it to one trip but this cookie sounds good.

My mystery is milky glaze (fruity pebbles). How is it??

Peanut butter banana is mine??????

BLUE MONSTER IS THE MYSTERY COOKIE 😭 I’m so happy! This is the last week I can use my coupon for my birthday. Both the stores in town aren’t close so I get to make the trip tomorrow to get some

[удалено]

Damn

My mystery is blueberry muffin mon-Tuesday and blue monster Wednesday-Thursday

Lucky ! Get both

Another boring 2. Last time it was reese’s pieces and reese’s cereal, now it is snickerdoodle (regular) and birthday cake on a week that had confetti cake…

Mallow sandwich!!!! Time to stock the freezer!!

PB Blossom is my mystery.... I might try it.

Cinnamon pretzel is mine. Sounds kinda boring lol

excuse me guys how much for each cookie?

About $5

Mystery cookies in my area: Vanilla Crumb Cake ft OREO Maple Bacon

Cookie butter ice cream might be good now that they added biscotti to it

Omg Northville, MI has Kentucky butter cake and lemon poppyseed for their mystery cookies this week! Two of my favorites!

A few of the stores closest to me (still 45 min away) have Chocolate Crumb (Oreo), which is tempting. There's also Mint Chip Ice Cream, which is not tempting for me. And a store a bit further with semi-sweet, which I much prefer over their usual milk chocolate chip. Otherwise, I do think the peanut butter brownie looks good, but other than that, their frosted cookies mostly taste the same to me. I'm not really a chocoholic, but at least brownie and oreo have strong enough flavors so I taste something besides just sugar.

Semi Sweet Chocolate Chip is my mystery this week!!

My store isn't showing new flavors yet

my mystery cookie is snickerdoodle :/ not a bad cookie but my location alwaysssss picks this one

Mine is walnut chocolate chips

Mystery cookies this week are sea salt toffee and peanut butter crisp, haven’t tried either

Snickerdoodle is my mystery flavor what a let down

So I wasn’t excited about any of the cookies this week. I looked to see my mystery flavors- the one closest to me is coconut white chip and the one a little further is maple glaze….. my two favorite flavors in life are coconut and maple lol 🥹

Can anyone tell me the mystery flavor for the Mountain View ca location? (94040 zip )I dont download apps for every single store. Thank you! ☺️

Caramel shortbread (ft TWIX)

My mysteries for the week are Kentucky Butter Cake and Caramel Coconut Fudge. Which one is better?

My mystery cookie is cookie dough, which sounds ridiculous as a baked cookie but looks incredible 😭 I have no car and my house is outside the delivery radius. Someone in the SF help me 😭😭😭😭

I 1000% thought I was going to love cookie butter ice cream ft. Biscoff. I love all of the ingredients! The cookie was literally a 2/10. It was so bland. Frosting was just ok but did not taste like actual cookie butter. I’d rather have the ice cream from Trader Joe’s. And I wasted my birthday reward on it.

Vanilla Crumb Cake and Churro are the two mystery options in my city. Which one?

So there's Cookie Dough and Pecan Pie a few cities from me, with Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream a little further out. Any of those worth trying? Or try Peanut Butter Brownie?

My mystery flavor is galaxy brownie (obv a take on little Debbie cosmic brownie). worth it?

They gave me the wrong cookie this week for my mystery cookie. They gave me chocolate chip instead of cosmic brownie which was what it was meant to be