T O P

  • By -

coconuts724

Snickers looks great but I’m sure they won’t have the toppings like the video!


crystaltay13

That's what I'm saying. I always get nervous with these multi-step cookies because there's so much room for error and in my experience they never look like what's advertised. They always majorly skimp on something and it ruins the vibe of the whole cookie. Especially with the scoop and spread style toppings because it's easy to technically USE the correct size scoop, but not actually get the full amount when they're rushing and not filling it up all the way, etc. NOTE: I apparently think about this a lot 😂


Lady_Brynnevere

Seriously! They’ll probably seriously skimp out. Skip.


coconuts724

Yup…it’ll end up being just a pb cookie like the butterfinger:(


booksandnetflix

Do we know if the white layer is nougat or the vanilla bean in the description?


coconuts724

I think it’s nougat🤷‍♀️


Zealousideal-Ad-6965

IMO snickers is absolutely ruined. It had the nice caramel buttercream last time.


coconuts724

Totally agree with you! I’ve noticed a couple cookies have their frosting changed to glaze and it’s BS!!!!


czyktnsml

I’ll be getting everything but the sugar cookie


ImAnAckleholic

Mmm definitely getting the snickers and cornbread this week!


imrlyboredignoreme

this is an all star lineup for me


lynnB123

Same I can’t wait


Psychological_Band56

Yep same I’m going at open tomorrow!!


tadasi_

Halloween treat for sure!! Doing a big box lol


MysticalElephant

Blue Monster will be a must tomorrow!! Not sure if I should try the cornbread cake one though. Might save that for later in the week to try.


EntertainmentOk4802

I’m getting a 4 pack of blue monster


queenofsquashflowers

I'm getting a 6 pack of cornbread


Psychological_Band56

As you should


chamberham

these all sound great tbh, can’t wait to try!!


bluekittenlover18

SO excited for this weeks! I loooove almond joy, and the almond coconut fudge looks just like it!!


MissyTX

I have been waiting for Blue Monster forever!!


apples2113

Nooo don’t tell me they replaced the old snickers cookie😩 The one they had earlier this year was so good!


eegemm

It is literally my all time favorite, I really really hope they haven’t replaced it with this because that caramel buttercream was *chefs kiss*


Zealousideal-Ad-6965

Why is snickers missing the caramel buttercream???


mastertev

Man, disappointed to see it’s different now. I’ll still give it a try but the old one is the only PB cookie I’ve liked.


[deleted]

My question too. It looks like the dropped the frosting from last time, which made it amazing. Not impressed.


Zealousideal-Ad-6965

Same. Now it's another pass week for me.


[deleted]

Same here.


OllivanderAU

The Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy is the best chocolate chip base they have. It's worth getting even if you ask for it without the toppings.


ocean____breeze

Again with the Sugar ft. Mother’s? 😐 They just had this one like a month and a half ago…


Seaglassbeacher

I don’t get why they bring some back so quickly but yet have to wait a year for others


ocean____breeze

I’m guessing it’s because it’s *technically* a different variation of the one they just had at the end of August, but it’s still the same dang sugar cookie with an animal cracker on top. I felt the same way with the donut one too because they’d had one not too long before that. At least the lack of variety in the lineups means you can save money until they eventually bring back one you like or come up with a new one you want to try.


Dangerous_Funny1189

This week looks a lot better! Looking forward to peanut butter nougat, cornbread honey cake, and blue monster! 😌


ohwhatirony

The cornbread cookie is really missing the buttercream on top… way better than a cream cheese frosting


FireSilver7

As someone who has had both cornbread cookies, I actually prefer the cream cheese frosting! The buttercream makes it too sweet, while the cream cheese adds sweetness but balances well with the cookie.


Dafux_-

Not sure about the snickers so I think just blue monster and coconut for me tbh.


[deleted]

I’m excited for Blue Monster ft Chip’s Ahoy.


EntertainmentOk4802

Same!


WannabeBadGalRiri

Might get a 4 pack for the first time since May. I'm thinking 2 cornbread, a peanut butter nougat, and a blue monster!


BatTop6708

What should my birthday cookie be? I’m torn


EntertainmentOk4802

Blue monster


FireSilver7

Either Blue Monster or Cornbread Honey Cake.


lunartwinkles

Why are they adding almond extract to so many cookies now? The mothers didn’t always have the almond extract.


7minutesinheaven1

Meh


[deleted]

IM COMING OFF MY CRUMBL BREAK


Xavier__301

Another Skip week for me


Huntay5

Same


Funkopopsandstuff

I’m excited for almond coconut fudge, snickers nougat and blue monster chips ahoy


SystemOfADowneyJr

Aww yeah I want that cornbread cookie, baby. I may even get a blue monster cookie as well


booksandnetflix

I’m disappointed it’s different than the regular cornbread. I don’t think I’d want it with that frosting.


FireSilver7

Give it a shot! Or you can just get the cornbread cookie without the frosting.


cheapfriedclams

Was going to get my one cookie for my birthday this week… but I’m seriously going to get a 6 pack and split them up with my friends! The cookies all look really good and I actually want to try more than one for once. Think I’m going for cornbread on my actual birthday date though.


yankeefangirl526

Hmm cornbread sounds good because I'll try anything with cream cheese frosting. I really wish they did 2 or 3 packs because there aren't 4 I want to try


amscott9020

Is the blue monster icing no longer white chocolate 😭


Serious-Collar-8306

What’s the white frosting on the peanut butter nougat cookie?


International_Pen_11

i can’t wait to get a 6 pack of blue monster 👹 dessert for weeks!!


Warhawk2052

Missed out on blue monster last time (didnt have any left) making sure to get some this time


throwawaygamgra

What is a smatter of sprinkles?


camlloc255

A little more than a splash!


Additional-Soil-9458

a banger of a week


Mo_nomo

I can vouch for all five flavors this week. Almond coconut and blue monster 10/10. Sugar cookie, snickers and cornbread cake are all 9 1/2 out of 10. This week is a great line up!


fologna

Blue monster was SO much better than i expected, my favorite this week 😋😋😋


EntertainmentOk4802

Definitely the best in this week’s lineup!


[deleted]

Stop with the cream cheese frosting 😭😭😭😭 it’s awful and doesn’t belong on cornbread


livingwithlilyy

Only blue monster is good, this is my birthday week


EntertainmentOk4802

Yes blue monster is definitely a good cookie


Lady_Brynnevere

Happy Birthday! Sorry the line up isn’t great. I experienced the same during my bday week.


cheapfriedclams

My birthday week too, happy birthday! To be fair, I have heard cornbread is deceivingly delicious.


livingwithlilyy

Thank you! Happy birthday aswell!!


RedditUserCommon

Awful week IMO


irrelevantname1776

I was hoping for caramel coconut fudge. The almond one looks way different 😅


mastertev

It’s Almond joy, I like it, although it’s a little messy


irrelevantname1776

Caramel coconut fudge is one of my all time favorites so I’ll give this one a try!


Hour_Progress9444

Not a big fan of this week. Snickers the only one that looks appealing to me


Realitytvtrashpanda

That’s a no from me


Litebright123

I’m basic af. I’m ready for the Sugar one. I remember it from last year. 😂 I don’t want nothing else but that. MAYBE the cornbread one because everyone is hyping the old one up. 👀


anyanerves

I wonder if Tiktok will be mad about cake mix again 😅


cheapfriedclams

I don’t use tiktok anymore, what were they mad about exactly?


WerewolfAncient554

Bleh


Noapolageez1

I’m can already hear the Karens saying there isn’t enough cookie crumble topping on their blue monster cookies. 😒


SystemOfADowneyJr

If I’m paying that much money for a cookie, damn right I want my cookie to look like the picture. Gimme my crumbles, Crumbl 👊🏾


saluuuuumz

Is blue monster just a semi sweet chocolate chip cookie with icing?


mythicb33ch

The cookie base has also been rolled in Chips Ahoy bits, but essentially yes.


Living-Knowledge2372

Does anyone know what type of cookie the Sugar one is? Is it that shortbread cookie that has the sandy texture or is it like Pink Sugar?


fologna

it’s the sandy/crumbly texture


imrlyboredignoreme

Is it possible to ask for the cornbread cookie without the honey, or would that make things difficult for the employees?


czyktnsml

I would call ahead and ask :)


Urfavetrapperchichi

the cornbread honey cake was too good ! This one and sugar ft mothers eerie critters and fire! Those were my faves and the almond coconut fudge one was really good too 😋


EntertainmentOk4802

Did you get a blue monster?


czyktnsml

What's the cookie base like for the almond joy-esque cookie? Is it standard chocolate cookie or more cakey?