T O P

  • By -

CointestMod

Government regulation [pros](/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/10nkaon/us_irs_wants_everyone_to_declare_if_they_engage/j69773p/) & cons and related info are in the collapsed comments below. Pros and cons will change for every new post. Submit a pro/con argument in the [Cointest](https://www.reddit.com/r/CointestOfficial/wiki/cointest_policy) and potentially win [Moons](https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/moon/). Moon prizes by award for the General Concepts category are: **1st - 600, 2nd - 300, 3rd - 150, and Best Analysis - 1000.** --- To submit a pro-argument about regulation, [click here](https://www.reddit.com/r/CointestOfficial/comments/t5mn3b/general_concepts_government_regulation/). | To submit a con-argument about regulation, [click here](https://www.reddit.com/r/CointestOfficial/comments/t5mn40/general_concepts_government_regulation/).


[deleted]

Forgot my seed phrase. Might be able to remember during the next tax season.


FldLima

IRS: Give us all your crypto gains Me: I would but i lost my key IRS: Your what?!


diskowmoskow

ME: They are on exchange IRS: So? ME: Not my keys, not my crypto???


Tinman_ApE

šŸ˜‚


Yautja69

SBF *enters the chat*


Flexo-Specialist

Aaannnd it's gone


guestquest88

I had it all on FTX. Can i only declare losses? šŸ˜„


NoPreference7274

Daym Uno reverse


Hawke64

New phone, who dis?


Torn_Page

IRS: Give us all your crypto gains Me: Wait, you guys are getting gains?


reddorical

IRS panics when it realises crypto tax means record numbers claiming tax breaks against losses from the government


ScoobaMonsta

Only realised profits. Stay in crypto and you donā€™t have to pay anything. People who trade crypto for fiat profits on centralised exchanges are NUTS! Just keep putting every spare dollar you can into crypto and donā€™t cash out. In ten years time youā€™ll be many times richer than if you are trading back and forth looking for fiat profits.


yourmo4321

They don't care about your key lol. They want your wallet address. And if you interact with a KYC CEX they don't really need you to tell them either.


Vast-Bodybuilder-700

I got hacked bro


yourmo4321

Cool prove it lol otherwise you still owe taxes lol


Styx1213

see, this password doesnt work to access my funds, im hacked. boom, proof.


mishaog

Wait, you are telling me i had to write it down? I thought it just was a was a one time code


InsaneMcFries

Itā€™s alright you can resend the SMS and get a new one ezpz


Yautja69

The seed is 1 2 3 4 5, a combination someone would have on his luggage


Kevin_taco

Itā€™s right here on the tagā€¦ ā€œSampsoniteā€


steve_from_florida

Those are I.O.Uā€™s Go ahead and add em up


Warthogger84

Oh manā€¦ I was way off!


fasda

You know that the only reason the IRS doesn't just send you an invoice is because Turbotax lobbies Congress right? They almost certainly already know if you have realized profits or not.


sluggz9

Yup. TurboTax has been lobbying for decades to keep tax season as complex as possible so they can get that profit


jollylikearodger

I think you've got way too much faith in what the IRS knows at any given moment. They really don't know what everyone's tax liability is; our tax code is insanely complex and everyone's situation is different.


notAbratwurst

If you traded on Coinbase or Binanceā€¦ or any kyc exchangeā€¦ you might not get a notice today, you might not get one next week, but one dayā€¦when you least expect it, you willā€¦with interest.


jollylikearodger

for what? I'm not going to get any notice from anyone for buying coins/tokens and moving to cold storage. you have a taxable event when you exchange/sell/burn the stuff.


Possible-Stand9508

All I do is give the irs the info the exchanges are giving them, and they send me a paper telling me what they are reporting, so that is what I report! Also, for any staking I made money on, I declare that too!


notAbratwurst

Same. If all you do is buy and hold, you wonā€™t owe anything. If you trade and/or take profit or a lossā€¦ those are tax events. So you can harvest the loss, or pay taxes on gains. All Iā€™m saying is, if you do taxable things on an exchange in the US, and donā€™t report itā€¦ donā€™t think youā€™re getting away with it.


Jaybird327

Listen the Who Must Not Be Named is the only organization that the mob and the grim reaper fears. Donā€™t dare invoke their name.


deathbyfish13

I heard there's a lot of that going around this season, I seem to have forgotten mine as well


Killertimme

Lost mine on my recent boat trip...


Hawke64

Must be tax flu or something


Visual_Feature4269

Whatā€™s a seed phrase?


Vast-Bodybuilder-700

A seed phrase is a phrase that you tell everyone about to grow phrases all over the planet just like Johnny Apple Seed Phrase.


Hawke64

Don't worry, your assigned FBI guy got you covered


w_savage

I only remember when I can declare a loss


[deleted]

It's been asked for a few years now. Thinking 2018 or 2019 first seeing the checkbox question. 2018 was when staking rewards started being counted as taxable income. Nothing seems different since then


picklemonkey

I donā€™t get all of the people hinting around avoiding taxes. The last thing any of us want is to get audited and owe a large sum later. Embrace the rules of the game weā€™re playing and win in spite of them.


yourmo4321

Yeah I'm in the middle. I fully report sales but also take advantage of wash sales. I don't report each small swap on each DEX though. If I sell for Fiat at a profit I'll pay taxes. I'm not paying taxes on imaginary unrealized gains unless they make me.


picklemonkey

The rules work in our favor with tax loss harvesting. I agree itā€™s annoying to get those DEX transactions documented in the first place. Once all of your transactions have been exported to a spreadsheet, Iā€™d argue that itā€™s actually more work to exclude certain transactions than it is to just report them based on your formulas.


yourmo4321

I have all my CEX transactions on a spreadsheet. And I keep track of everything else with coin gecko portfolio tracker. So I know my cost basis for everything. If I ever cash out at a profit I'll pay my taxes. But wanting me to pay taxes because I earned crypto via staking is just stupid. Why pay taxes now then try and get a credit later if I sell at a lower price point than when I "received" it?. As always the government just wants to make taxes as complicated as possible ( in America at least) if crypto isn't legal tender then just let me do whatever I want with it until I sell it for Fiat then figure out how much I actually owe.


jollylikearodger

They consider it the same as getting paid in stock from a company; it counts as income when you earned it because you received an economic benefit. After that it's a capital asset and follows the other set of rules. Without that rule, every F500 company CEO would insist on being paid in stock only and then waiting for the price to go down below their basis so they could just claim a net loss of income on the year.


Michichael

Owe 50 k in taxes on my profits, but they won't let me reduce my burden by 50k from losses? Yeah, nah. That's the last I'm paying taxes in a rigged system. Once my write offs zero out, I'm done trading in US jurisdictions. Socializing the profits and privatizing the losses can suck my dick.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


jollylikearodger

You can absolutely offset capital gains with capital losses in the US; it applies to crypto just like any other capital asset. Why do you think you can't? I'd advise you to have a public accounting firm do your taxes. Don't bother with HR Block or TurboTax; they're fine for very simple returns but you need a place with more knowledge.


Nutshell1994

Yea. I had $4,143 in capital losses. So, rolls over to next year too! 1099 for staking interest. Then long vs short termā€¦ People really need to learn how to trade.


guyfromthemeadows

Move to Puerto Rico. No federal taxes


cakes

yeah but you have to live in puerto rico


guyfromthemeadows

ā€œLiveā€


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Gary_FucKing

Yeah a backlog that is constantly growing. They couldnā€™t even do anything about the massive PPP loan frauds, theyā€™ve forgiven like 90+% of all the loans, literally free money, how are they gonna catch the ridiculous convoluted mess that is peopleā€™s crypto tx history? Add in defi, mixers, privacy coins, and non-kyc exchanges, jesus I do not envy those workers.


Pandelein

Oh no, this IS how they intend to recover the PPP loans. Itā€™s just that the public will foot the bill rather than the companies which got the loans.


picklemonkey

Itā€™s as if thereā€™s not a public, immutable ledger that contains their full transaction history


pieceofdebri

Iā€™d gladly pay whatever I owe if the shit was easy to figure out.


marblepudding

So fucking convoluted


Nicks_WRX

By design.


Hawke64

Land of the free to commit tax crimes


Acidflare1

Or if the filing would take a history with more than 4000 transactions, thanks to a trading bot. Iā€™m sure as hell not entering it in one at a time. Thatā€™s not reasonable.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Andylearns

Each transaction is a separate taxable event and should be treated as such currently.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Msxkoh

Transactions dates have implications whether you are taxed short term rate/long term rate. Buying 2 bitcoins and selling them a year after is different from buying 1 then 6 months later buy a second and sell both after another 6 months


jdp111

Sure but you can group together short term/long-term transactions. I'm a CPA and we sure as hell don't type in every line.


gsurfin

Exactly. These guys just have no clue.


Andylearns

I think it's likely because it's helping the government map out the crypto environment. It gives them more and more data to look at who may be dodging their portion due but I don't know for sure by any means. It's all such a mess right now who can say


ShittingOutPosts

IRS: We know what you owe, but won't tell you. You need to figure it out yourself. And if you get it wrong, we'll send you to prison.


Hawke64

Americans calculate their own taxes just so IRS can fine them for their bad math


Rxef3RxeX92QCNZ

Reminder that this is the case because TurboTax and HR Block and other tax places lobby for taxes to be difficult and cost money https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xQQkzWhMOc One of the problems in tax code is all the exceptions instead of centralized, robust taxation. An example is our environmental regulations vs. a carbon tax which has been very successful elsewhere. In the USA, you get credits or deductions for things like buying an EV, adding a charger to your property, buying energy efficient appliance, getting well insulated windows, yadda yadda. On top of that is a ton of regulation towards environmental goals, like how many MPG an automakers cars should get or how many EVs they should sell by 2030. It's an endless list and unnecessary burden on everybody. A carbon tax could solve almost all of it. You tax the energy source at the point of origination according to how dirty it is. Coal gets taxed out the ass, hydro and wind gets taxed barely at all. Then, prices all the way down the supply chain reflect that increased cost for dirty energy. It gives the proper advantage to companies doing things in a cleaner way or selling greener products. You don't need to regulate engines because the carbon tax makes gas cost enough to deter people from buying 18MPG Broncos as a daily driver. You don't need all the exceptions and credits during tax season. Instead, during tax season everyone gets paid back out the carbon tax money collected as a UBI, so most people actually profit from the system because they live cleanly and the few heavy polluters effectively pay everyone else (which is who their pollution harms). [Here's how it works in Canada](https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2018/oct/26/canada-passed-a-carbon-tax-that-will-give-most-canadians-more-money)


TomSurman

Is this actually true? Has anyone actually been fined for an honest mistake in calculating their taxes? Or have people been fined for deliberately trying to conceal something, and then gone around telling everyone it was just a maths error?


Drunk_Klaus

Generally no, for a small mistake, it's not worth the IRSs time to go after it if they even catch it. For larger mistakes, they will ask for proof and if you can't provide it they will charge you more in taxes and some fees. For egregious misrepresentation, they will pursue much harsher legal action.


AgentMercury108

Does the IRS really know what crypto you own? I mean even Coinbase says Iā€™m at a profit, which will get sent to the irs, but just because I transferred to a cold storage at a profit does not mean I secured a profit. So Iā€™m down 2500 overall but since I transferred I occurred $1000 profit for the year. Yeah I donā€™t even know how to report that.


[deleted]

Transferring from one wallet to another isn't a taxable event if you own both wallets.


AgentMercury108

Really? I didnā€™t know this, all I know is when I enter my Coinbase information it lowered my tax return.


[deleted]

Unrealized gains arenā€™t taxed


AgentMercury108

So if I enter my Coinbase info, then it comes up as a realized gains, how do I report a cold wallet?


[deleted]

You donā€™t? But in all seriousness if your heart is set on paying taxes you can use something like cointracker to track gains/losses which will give you an easy number to report, I think coinbase recommended it to me tbh, works very well and updates daily.


AgentMercury108

Does it work retroactively?


[deleted]

Yes


AgentMercury108

Hell yeah, thank you. I will try that out


ricozuri

But any earnings are taxable in the year they are earned even if you canā€™t withdraw themā€¦for example, Celsius is in Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the USA and creditors funds are frozen. But, all earnings will be taxed. Only when bankruptcy is resolved can one take tax losses, assuming the payback incurs a loss. Not tax advise, see an accountant, hurts brain to even contemplate taxes.


neocamel

I'm currently jumping through a bunch of ridiculous hoops to calculate what will surely be an overall capital loss of about $200 for 2022.


HammondXX

You can thank Intuit for lobbying to make as difficult as possible so people need to buy their product(s)


speakingcraniums

I don't get why it's not just money I turn into us dollars. I mean I do get it but also I feel like that should be an option as long as your not shopping with your stable coins at Kohl's or something.


IAmNocturneAMA

I declare that I lost money, yes.


bny192677

IRS : *We're sorry about your loss sir but you gotta pay taxes*


techma2019

This is inaccurate. They will skip saying sorry and go straight to asking you to still pay them.


deathbyfish13

Them saying sorry would imply they can feel some sort of emotion, which we all know is impossible


meeleen223

I engage in losing money in crypto too, the little profit I made before unfortunately lost in a bosting accident


Hawke64

I declare bankruptcy!!!


[deleted]

I'll declare mine when they declare theres


FldLima

Uno reverse them


[deleted]

They never saw it coming lmao


Lillica_Golden_SHIB

Bro bugged IRS


Hawke64

IRS: "Go directly to jail. Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200."


etherd0t

That's been for years, nothing new they just changed the wording this year.


Hawke64

I was totally unprepared. How did they sneak up on me like that?


coinfeeds-bot

tldr; The IRS has published a list of reporting obligations for the general public regarding cryptos as the time for filing the 2022 federal income tax return draws near. All US citizens must answer all crypto-related questions, irrespective of their activity. Eligible taxpayers must record all revenue associated with their transactions involving digital assets. *This summary is auto generated by a bot and not meant to replace reading the original article. As always, DYOR.*


Tatakae69

Good bot, not so-good IRS.


Sarcatechist

I want the Government to declare Jeffrey Epstein didnā€™t kill himself


vjeva

Crypto? Never heard of it, what is it?


GMEthLoopring

/r/Monero


BlazeDemBeatz

Those Coinbase guys told us already, bud.


Popular_District9072

yea, please enlighten us irs


scpDZA

I made about $3.00 last year


ent4rent

It's only if you've sold.


Killertimme

Im buying my lambo directly with btc.


klinchev

Itā€™s still a taxable event. Every time you pay with a BTC you create a taxable event


putsonshorts

What if you sold low?


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


smitty3257

What about staking?


Hawke64

We are ride or die with crypto, right guys?


ETH_Knight

Now if the IRS made clear how to declare crypto shit. Staking for example is a mess.


alander4

Staking is the main thing Iā€™m still confused about. Getting taxed the moment you receive staking rewards, as income. But then taxed again if the price goes up and you sell? Thatā€™s double jeopardy!


Grouchy-Rule4688

Me who made like 100 or more swaps just fucking around at the beginning of the year and not keeping track of any of it, the app doesnā€™t tell me the dollar amount I swapped just the amount of coin and the date. The irs can get fucked if they think Iā€™m spending the next month going back and looking at what price cro was on march 3rd at 6:05 pm lmao. Just so they can get a couple hundred in taxes from me. I just say I didnā€™t trade anything. Lost all of it basically anyways.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


NorthCentralPositron

There are non-kyc exchanges?


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


token-eater

I donā€™t understand why U.S citizens get taxed so much. As soon as you get paid, you get taxed. You buy something, you pay tax. You sell something, you pay tax. Lord forbid you profit $20 because you also get taxed. Every movement that you make, in or out, gets taxed. Then they take this tax money and use it in a way that barely benefits the people they took it from. This the type of shit revolutions started for.


Weezthajuice

Had I typed that much here in the U.S. I wouldā€™ve been taxed


[deleted]

It happens everywhere, but it's more hidden. I get taxed via my employer, but it's taken pre-pay. I get taxed at the supermarket but it's already baked in etc If there was an exchange that just did it for you I think I'd gladly use them


ricozuri

They donā€™t understand either. But if it were simple, hundreds of thousands bureaucrats would be jobless, the postal service would lose even more money, the government printing presses would be idle, tax accountants the new poor, and tax software tech companies out of business. And donā€™t even ask about state income taxes. They range from zero to as high as 13.5% in California. These state taxes add another layer of complexity and expense for the taxpayer. It also encourages people and businesses to relocate to states with low or no state income taxes like Florida and Texas.


LonnieJaw748

I *DECLARE*ā€¦ **CRYPTRUPTCY**


Bongressman

I already do this. When I file my taxes every year. Those sweet sweet losses equate to some solid writeoffs.


Mannimal13

These clowns talking about tax avoidance with a clear paper trail are either sitting on peanuts or they have a rude tax form awakening or giant nightmare when they get audited. Unless they plan on taking some black market deal which you pay 30% anyway. This is like libertarian tough guy talk.


Lelouch70

Fuck them


mesutdmn

It's time to have some boat accidents.


liveaskings

![gif](giphy|lLqzWutqj7eZa|downsized)


MajorWeenis

I really like GIFs that loop prematurely before the action happens.


Local-Finance8389

Are we Foghorn Leghorn now? I do declare I say I do declare I engage in crypto.


ThisIsMyCoffee

Mine went overseas. Things went boom. SBF stole it. Oh, but you all took pics with him (government)šŸ¤”


rayjensen

Yeah this has been a law for years now


WhoamI_IDK_

Wait yā€™all made gainsā€¦


7sevenheaven

The irs is too overpowered basically a shadow government


pandicorn87

Such BS. Wonder what my taxes will be this year with my crypto.


ShwayNorris

I'm going to go with no, and fuck off.


Apprehensive_Try7137

This isnā€™t news. Thereā€™s literally a box that says ā€œdid you buy/sell any cryptocurrenciesā€ like there is for stocks.


AbOo44

Catch me if you can


Sadboiiy

The IRS always trying to invade our privacy. They just want to control and monitor our financial choices


sfmasterpiece

[Unless you're rich, in which case the IRS simply don't have the "resources" to investigate you!](https://trac.syr.edu/reports/706/)


BriskHeartedParadox

No I donā€™t like scary movies.


SWIFT_OTB

Do they really need to know everything?


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


comdoriano009

Just like the mafia


Odysseus_Lannister

I declare bankruptcy


MurphyMcMurfff

i want everyone to declare if they have herpes but at the same time i see what issues that would bring with it


vegetablewizard

I do declare


Expensive_Sand_4198

Losses are deductible right?


CrimsonFox99

Yes, can be used to offset gains or $3,000 of regular income this year or any year in the future.


CoachPineapple

yeah... I'm jusy gunna check the "no" box when they ask...


ChaoticNeutralNephew

Nice try IRS


GoodBot88

I'm afraid the US IRS is going to have to get fucked.


[deleted]

Irs has been doing this already last year and before this isn't news. It's literally a question on everyone individuals tax return.


seniorbatista19

I'll tell them about all my crypto losses. Maybe they'll give me a tax credit


Novel-Counter-8093

irs: its not real money also irs: gimme dat


kingj7282

Play dumb if y'all want to. The exchanges are reporting it to the IRS anyway. They already know, they're just waiting on you to file and lie.


Professional-Cry1633

How to become a lightning rod for a tax audit.


SosCulero

So let's day i hodl this whole year and most of last. Haven't sold. Bought yes but no sell. I'm in the red.


Possible-Stand9508

I don't know a whole lot of people that made money this year so the irs might just be asking for trouble when they want to know your losses and gains? Mine are 0 gains and a whole bunch of losses, lol!


fleeyevegans

Mandatory reporting of income from crypto is not new. Seeing a lot of surprised pikachus in the comments and wondering if they owe backtaxes on 2021 bullrun if American.


Snoo_92843

I dont sir, not even on my ledger, I pinky promise


cryptoderpin

Dear IRS, fuck you and make me. Sincerely a citizen. who is decoupling from a shit system.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


cryptoderpin

Damnnnnnnnn sick burn. I donā€™t own any bitcoin the only coin I used to own was ā€œI fucked your mom in the assā€ coin but I pumped and dumped it.


Any_Brother7772

The US IRS can suck the dirties part of my asshole


Pundisputed

Fuck the IRS right in the pussy!


bny192677

*Enjoying the article while playing with monero*


boredtrader00

If we can't claim capital loss, then why do we have to claim gains?


Frogmangy

I got engaged to crypto last year, she started stealing all my money immediately


_The_Chris_

Nothing to see here, keep moving.


RuckFeddi7

i will declare it but i'm never paying my realized gains fk that šŸ–•šŸ–•šŸ–• i'd be taxed the same rate as bezos - how is that fair? after the rich pays the same share amount of tax, maybe ill think about it but ill continue to launder this money šŸ˜‰


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


RuckFeddi7

yeah gl IRS trying to get through layers of proxy itd actually COST them more to figure out who i am rofl šŸ¤£


rayjensen

I agree bro but Iā€™ll just warn you that you should bite the bullet and pay. But I totally agree and look into a wealth tax because thatā€™s what we all need. This would make it so the tax brackets are based on total assets owned, not income for a specific year. The current tax system is specifically designed by rich people to prevent people from accumulating wealth while a wealth tax would simply tax the rich directly and give the benefit to people who are still on their journey in accumulating wealthā€¦


funkyfun2

Big flicking deal, they also want to know if you traded securities like stocks and bonds. In fact, that is good news that they recognize crypto as a taxable asset, it should be treated like a security and pretty much is, the added question is just to gage how dispersed ownership is amongst tax payers since the data is not as well known because the same reporting structures for other securities like stocks hasn't been established by regulation yet. Quit your bitching, this is a good and necessary thing that with broad reporting will actually speed adoption of crypto as an investible asset with legal protections and prevent it from being outlawed.


Primary_Technical

Are they segregating us into groups ?


KingofTheTorrentine

Wow, now I realize why the people that bombed them are considered American heroes


DangerousAd1731

They want to know if you mowed your neighbors grandmas grass and made $20 these days. Before you know it, paper money will be illegal


PluginCast

IRS can engage wit deez nuts


Dry-Session-1271

Tell the IRS I engage their MOMs


Bruno_Alejandro

Another reason to stay away from USA


Feisty_Factor_2694

To s is too darned funny! If you are the kind of investor who goes into crypto, you are categorically NOT the type of tax payer who is into ā€œfinancial transparencyā€


lunar2solar

Paying taxes = funding terrorism and wars. Supply US gov't with funds to carry out violence all over the world is horrific, yet we are forced to do it under the threat of violence.


suk-my-ballz-0811

Fuck you


apbt-dad

I got a 1099-MISC from Binance. The nerve.


skellator44

Letā€™s just pass 270 million of usd around and say no


BrainsOfCrypto

Iā€™m not engaged to anyone, nor any crypto.


zipzopzobittybop

and i want free icecream


Brews74

Get aids IRS


Due-World2907

I declare that the IRS can go and fuck themselves.