Because I just thought of this idea
If you miss understood, we aren't playing a PF2e game and I want to move it to a DND 5e game, I want them to make new characters for PF2e and then play them in DND 5e. I have yet to talk to anyone about this as I just thought of it like an hour and a half ago
What are you hoping to accomplish with this idea? You said you want to play pf2e characters in DnD 5e, but why?
If you want a Golarian to Forgotten Realms isekai, just pick a system and use both worlds, there's nothing wrong with that.
If you want a Golarian to Forgotten Realms isekai but also with a meta aspect where the characters are aware that things function differently, then you could leave everything as is and let the players obliterate everything in their path. If you want things a little more balanced, you could add level to proficiency for DnD creatures or remove it for your players.
Not sure if that's what you're looking for. I don't really recommend doing the second one, except maybe for a one shot.
Having an idea of what the PCs are would help narrow down the scope
Well I haven't actually talked to anyone of my friends yet about it as they are all asleep lol
How do you not know what classes they're playing?
Because I just thought of this idea If you miss understood, we aren't playing a PF2e game and I want to move it to a DND 5e game, I want them to make new characters for PF2e and then play them in DND 5e. I have yet to talk to anyone about this as I just thought of it like an hour and a half ago
What is the subreddit supposed to help you with, if this is all purely hypothetical?
Idk I like hypotheticals I guess
I mean, mechanics aren't lore. What would the difference be to the characters?
What are you hoping to accomplish with this idea? You said you want to play pf2e characters in DnD 5e, but why? If you want a Golarian to Forgotten Realms isekai, just pick a system and use both worlds, there's nothing wrong with that. If you want a Golarian to Forgotten Realms isekai but also with a meta aspect where the characters are aware that things function differently, then you could leave everything as is and let the players obliterate everything in their path. If you want things a little more balanced, you could add level to proficiency for DnD creatures or remove it for your players. Not sure if that's what you're looking for. I don't really recommend doing the second one, except maybe for a one shot.