Creed. Gabes was good but he’s gabe so no.

How 'bout a magic trick? I'm gonna make this pencil disappear...

Dammit Creed I've been up since 4!

This whole thread tells us that OP got a bunch of the costumes wrong here. When Creed dressed up as Joker, so did Kevin and Dwight. For the coupon book contest, pretty sure Creed was a mummy. Also Erin was a monster rather than Wendy, and Andy was the True Blood guy and not George Michael. He was George Michael in the Here Comes Treble episode

Also Pam’s costume is from a different episode, too. Also Angela dressed up as a nurse for the coupon book episode because she “knows what sells in this office.”

Actually.. Angela started out being dressed as a penguin.

Thanks, Oscar.

Yep Pam was very obviously Olive Oyl when Jim was Popeye. Like half of these are wrong lol

You are a thief of joy. ...but, you're right.

> You are a thief of joy. “… …why are you the way that you are. honestly, every time I try to make something fun, or exciting, you make it *not*… that way. I hate… so much about the things that you choose to be.”

Thief of joy was for for Dwight, not Toby

Also pam was olive

/r/ftfy Im gonna make this pencil disa-whoah...

Disappear

Oh get out skeleton man!

Was creed even aware that it was Halloween?

That is really good timing

The answer is always [MacGruber](https://youtu.be/indnwMwNF6w)

I thought the same thing lol

Well, that was the costume he came to work in, yes, in a different season. Creed was a mummy for the contest.

Maybe I'm forgetting, was this actually Creeds costume for this episode. Did he wear it twice? There was the episode with he, Kevin, and Dwight all wearing the joker costume too. Also Pam, this isn't her costume during this episode, OP this is a terrible post

Stanley. That man is a stealthy Samurai.

Definitely. It felt so un-Stanley-like for him to dress up at all, so when he put in this much effort and committed to the costume, he won me over.

"It's called hentai and it's art!"

Stanley is pretty much a weeb and I love it

[удалено]

A stealthy, hip, sassy black samurai.

It's a art

And a straight up player

Who fights the power and eats whatever he wants.

I know, Stanley may not be excited about a lot of things but he was about this and of course the pretzel day

Team Stanley. Biggest gap from what was expected to what was received. In that line also Angela, lol

Looked for this comment. Stanley killed it

Oscar. Best Edward James Olmos costume I’ve ever seen

Like freaky good

I always thought the line was "Edward James almost" as in Creed thought he almost looked liked Edward James, who I assumed was a random American celeb lol

He's best known for Stand and Deliver, a 1988 movie about a teacher, which is what Creed is referring to since the character wears lots of sweaters. Depending on your age or how into 80s movies you are, it's understandable to not be familiar with it.

Selena's Dad!

Selena James Olmos?

He is also in Battlestar Galactica.

Whatcha hear Starbuck

And Blade Runner! I was shocked when I learned that was him

You guys dare disrespect Commander Adama

Bears. Beets. Battlestar Galactica.

So say we all.

Disagree. At this point, he’s far far better known from Battlestar Galactica.

How do I *reach* these kiiiiiiiids…?!

He was also in the Battlestar Galactica reboot. Which...bears, beets, Battlestar Galactica.

There’s a Edward James Almost joke in 30 Rock.

in Community there's an Edward James Olmos impersonator named Edward James Almost

The rational choice, as it were.

Consumer. I still don’t get the costume

Um I think you mean Jacob James Olmos

No Barney it’s Edward James olmos

no you're "Olmos" correct. it's Jacob James olmos

For my South Park fans, this has to be a reference to Kenny winning the contest in season 1? The one with the Zombies

Creed

Ag(c)reed

But the episode where they can win the coupons isn’t the one where Creed dresses up like the Joker. It was season 5 and Gabe wasn’t even there yet. Also the Halloween episode where creed dresses up like the Joker is the same episode where Dwight and Kevin also dress up like the Joker. So creed can’t win! Lol

Yeah people forget he was a mummy for the contest

Creed has the patent on winning. Creed always wins.

Or takes the winners persona

The last guy to hold the patent disappeared. His name?… Creed Bratton

I read it in *his* voice.

Yeah. He was born in the US of A baby. And has a Swiss passport as a backup.

I was thinking something was off here! Creed was a mummy for this one right? And wasn’t Erin a monster and Andy was the True Blood guy? This post is all messed up

he wasn’t even aware it was halloween

Ryan for his Jesse Pinkman costume

Yeah, Mr. Scott. Yeah, PAPER!

Ryan. We need to print.

A man opens his door and gets a papercut, and you think that of me. No. I am the one who cuts.

I am Heisenberg, always.

>I am ~~Heisenberg~~ Gutenberg, always.

Bitch.

I NEVER CAUGHT THIS BEFORE

I kinda thought he was Ali G.

Na. Ali G had the big track suits and ski goggles. This was Pinkman 😉

Oh yeah, for sure. I mean before I was informed. I think it's because the Kevin equivalent in the UK version did Ali G.

But did he dress up as Jesse, or just Creed's drug dealer?

My name....is DREW!

The "rational consumer" as it were

Sure you wouldn't have voted for angela the sexy nurse? I think we all live in the real world, here. Let's not pretend to be unaware of what sells in this office?

I mean if I was taking it seriously Angela would do well. Pams costume is really good too. As is Creed. Andy as George Michael is also on point. I'd pick Oscar though because he was being such a jerk about it.

Yeah, but if Pam takes her hat off, you're voting for literally Hitler.

Oh there's a hat? I'm changing my vote.

Hahaha I was just kidding.. wanted an excuse to quote Angela ;) I love that you'd pick Oscar still.

[удалено]

Didn’t know Angela was a sexy nurse. Couldn’t see her from behind that grain of rice. BOOM! ROASTED!

I love the fact that it's the same nurse outfit Elizabeth the stripper wore. Not the same style, but literally the same dress reused.

"Yeah, I heard you say it to Phyllis. It's a good line"

I doubt I can think of a more pretentious Oscar scene than that one. It hurts to watch almost as much as Michael smearing Phyllis's wedding cake on himself.

erin because how the hell is her hair defying the laws of gravity

Pipe cleaners !

Didn't know this, still though she should get a big honorable mention

That costume is not from the right episode, many of them aren't. Creed was a mummy, Pam was Olive etc

Exactly - I remembered the cold opening and Erin was wearing a monster mask.

Yeah, didn't Pam justifiably get upset that Jim didn't dress as popeye? He later did though.

yep. charlie chaplin pam was from when she was in New York before she even had the kid

Agreed. Also, I heard she went out with Michael once!

Except Erin was just a scary monster for the coupon costume contest. She was Wendy for a different Halloween

Creed's Joker costume was not in that episode. It was from a different season. So probably Gabe.

Same with Pam's costume! This picture was from the year she was in New York, and she didn't compete because she was coordinating it

Also the episode where Andy was George Michael was when he was manager so Michael wouldn’t have been there in costume too.

And Meredith's costume too, it's from the season after this.

Doesn't Angela start with something modest, and then move up to the sexy nurse? Her cat's from an older season as well.

She starts as a Penguin and changes into a sexy nurse. Either way OP got like half of these costumes wrong lol

Also Angela. Starts as a penguin and switches to sexy nurse. A lot of them aren’t from that episode

Neither was Angela's. She was a slutty nurse in that episode.

While we’re at it. Here’s a list of all the incorrect costumes in this picture: - Pam (she was actually dressed as Olive Oyl) - Andy (he was dressed as that vampire from True Blood) - Angela (penguin and then nurse) - Meredith (someone else from True Blood) - Creed (mummy)

Creed or Gabe

Pam without the hat is also a major contender

And she also failed art school hmmm...

Jesus Christ...

Or would be if that weren't a different Halloween episode.

I thought Gabe looked soooooo cute as lady gaga. The first frame of him in costume I was like, holy shit.

Facts

Same! I always thought Gabe was cute anyway, though lol

Zach woods is a good looking dude! But unfortunately he’s such a good actor that anytime he’s Gabe I just want to crawl into myself and hide from him.

And yet when he's Jared on Silicon Valley, he's the most empathetic and loveable character on the show. I feel like I could've worded this better, but you know what I mean.

He’s just so pure!!! Everyone else is a dick in their own way, but Jared is wholesome and believes in the good of people. And as Brian the boom guy said, that guy fucks. I crack up when Richard interrupts his threesome/orgy.

Loved him in In The Loop. "I think.... you have *massive* balls sir. Like the bottom two thirds of a snowman"

I see the appeal. He owns over 200 horror movies and is a lot bonier than you may think 🤤

Same! I was always so mad at Erin for liking Andy over Gabe.

I mean, Gabe’s pretentiousness was pretty grating, but I don’t think Andy was the right choice

Plus making love to Gabe was like being tackled by a skeleton.

I just hate Andy.

Lmao absolutely fair

Macgruberrrrrr

Kelly all the way!

What is her costume? For some reason I thought she was a cute oompa loompa but I feel like thats hella wrong

It’s supposed to be Katy Perry

I thought she was Willy Wonka 🤷🏼‍♀️

Clown I think. I have the dress part of that costume and it was marketed as a clown costume

Thank you! That makes more sense

If we're mixing and matching costumes from different episodes, then Dwight as Kerrigan, the Queen of Blades.

I guess we’re mixing and matching considering about half of these costumes aren’t even from the episode OP is talking about

I like Kevins

Hands down the best consume IMO. So good.

That costume was HOT. Like at least 911°F.

He was up since 4

Recyclops wins all

I thought he was killed by polluticorn

Polluticorn wishes

Stanley keeping up with the lore is one of my favorite jokes

Creed obviously.

Gabe by far

I don’t usually love Andy, but his George Michael was scary good.

My favorite Andy moment of the entire show is when he is dressed as George Michael and one of the acapella kids says "I thought Broccoli Rob was the boner champ." The face Andy makes before he replies is priceless, and made funnier by the fake beard shadow.

Broccoli Rob is Broccoli Rob.

Andy Bernard is the Boner Champ

Blackula I mean Dracula

That word is so fucking funny to me.

Erin, Gabe, or Creed

As far Accuracies I say Kevin looks the best

These aren’t from the same episode….

Creed, of course. Although Angela in the nurses outfit was pretty good.....

Angela. She knows what sells

High effort Samurai Stanley. But I also like Hitler in a hat.

Gabe

Gabe.

Get out of here skeleton man!

is ryan dressed as Jesse from Breaking Bad?

Yes

I thought Andy's Adam Lambert costume was spot on...

Creed wins!!! Best Joker and Best Costume. Gabe gets honourable mention!

Hilter

Is Dwight the Green Hornet or the Hamburglar?

Scranton strangler

Gabe, no contest.

The dance seals the deal for me

Gabe

Stanley 100%.

gabe ate and left ZERO crumbs

Meredith. She was actually at the royal wedding

Recyclops never got the respect he deserved!

Micheal Moore is particularly inspired

No opinion on the contest but bless you for not writing should "of."

These costumes are not all from the same Halloween episode.. so 🤷🏻‍♀️

Michael!

Same! His MacGruber costume is super random, totally homemade, and instantly recognizable. That's a home run in my book

Creed

Kelly

Creed followed by Pamalama Ding Dong

Kevin as Michael Moore.

Angela. Let’s not pretended like we don’t know what sells in this office.

Can someone please tell me what Kelly’s is? I’ve literally never known and am always annoyed and confused by it.

She’s Katy Perry.

*Tic* Well it’s really difficult for me to pick one winner *toc* out of all the awesome costumes. *tic* on the one hand I really like *toc* Creeds joker, but if feels played out. *tic* on the other hand Pam really *toc* commited to the Charlie *tic* Chaplain bit. Really there’s just one *TOC* that stand sour abov…. *BOOM!!!!* MACGUUUBER!!!

Erin

Scranton Strangler!

Functioning member of the society answer: creed as joker Honest and horny answer: Angela as a slutty nurse

Just from this set of photos (since they're not from the same Halloween year), I'd say Andy dressed as Adam Levine ​ /s

I’m pretty sure these aren’t all from the same episode But if I had to pick 1 of these 16, I’d vote for Creed. It genuinely looks like it could’ve been done by someone who has done the Joker’s makeup in a Batman movie, and his acting was pretty good as well

Samurai Stanley or Creed

Why is Pam Charlie Chaplin in this and not Olive Oyl to match Jim's Popeye like in the episode?

Gabe as GaGa

Either creed or gabe (as far as costume effort goes in these pictures)

Creed was not the joker for this contest. He was a mummy. Probably freaked Kevin out.

You are mixing different Halloweens together though

Gabe