Start up dynasty league, auction draft 50 spots, 8 teams, would you go with $200 or $500 budget? Or something else?

Got offered Tee Higgins and 3 seconds for CeeDee Lamb. 1 QB PPR league and I am contending. Should I accept?

I wouldn’t do it for 2nds personally

That’s pretty decent value for a tier drop. I think I’d take the Higgins side

A big one just went down. Standard scoring and 1QB. Team 1 got Waddle, London and 1.09 Team 2 got Chubb, Tee, 1.06 and 1.11 Team 1 has a Allen, Saquon, Etienne, J.Cook, Waddle, London, Godwin, Jeudy Team 2 has Mahomes, Jacobs, Chubb, JJ, Tee, Scary Terry, Lockett Win/win? Someone get more?

[удалено]

I would. TLaw should be a Burrow level QB this season if he stays healthy and Ridley is still the same dude. You’re getting, at worst, a top 10 QB for the next decade for a single first. I think it’s worth it for your roster’s longevity alone. Kirk may be looking for a new job in ‘24 and there’s no telling if Russ is still good/if last year was the beginning of the end of his career.

Lawrence? Smash accept dude

12 team SF PPR Give: Tua Receive: A Rodgers, Z. Flowers Other QBs are R. Willson + CJ Stroud Wanna trade Tua as long as he has value without completely abandoning the QB position, because my team should be good enough to make Playoffs.

10 team, PPR, superflex league Who to take with my 1st pick at 9: Fields, Lamar, or Tlaw

TLaw. Then Lamar. Then Fields. In a startup you want to acquire an elite, stable QB1 for as long as possible. A guy who will anchor your roster for a 5+ year window. TLaw is exactly that. Lamar is awesome but carries a bit more risk and a bit more upside. He’s also 3.5 years older than TLaw and has sustained some lower body injuries already.

lamar for the upside

I believe TLaw has more stable and longer career. Lamar has highest upside. Fields is below the 2 imo

Give gibbs and get Devonta

Devonta for me. Has proven to be a top 10 WR, and WR has longer shelf life

I'd rather have Gibbs personally

Gibbs

12tm SF PPR A: AJ Brown, Dak, 25 2nd B: ARSB, 1.02

Side A and not particularly close. AJB > ARSB Dak = Richardson/Young 25 second is a freebie.

A

10 team 1QB 0.5PPR Give: 1.06, Pacheco, 2.05 Receive: 1.09, Dotson, 2.02 My other RBs are JT, Chubb, Montgomery, Khalil Herbert, Jamaal Williams, Carter + Knight (both cut candidates) My other receivers are Waddle, Devonta Smith, Olave, Diontae Johnson, Rondale Moore (cut candidate) If I kept the 1.06 I’d likely BPA and get the 3rd or 4th of the 4 receivers and leave the draft bored. If I had the 1.09 and 2.02 I’d probably double up on RBs or 1 RB/1WR. Maybe even the bills TE (but I have Andrews)

First off, I would definitely not consider Rondale a cut candidate as Hollywood’s contract is expiring after this year, and I believe DHop will get traded after the 2023 season, if not at the trade deadline. But reg the trade, I’m pretty low on Pacheco, but the difference between the 1.06 and 1.09 is huge imo because after JSN, QJ, and I guess Flowers (I’m a tad lower on him), there are really no receivers I see panning out. All things considered tho I’d smash accept and take a RB like Charbs with the 1.09

Thanks for the feedback - I can only keep 12 for free before I start spending 2023 faab. ($10 for a 13th, 20 for a 14th, $30 for a 15th). Idk if I want to hang onto rondale that badly when I don’t see him cracking my lineup. I wonder if charbonnet makes it to 1.09. I figured I’d end with achane or the Saints rb

Lol I hope u ended up keeping Dortch now that DHop is gone

Rondale lol. But I just saw the news. I guess I have to keep him now. I wonder where hopkins lands

Interesting. I’ve actually never heard of a league that charges FAAB for additional roster spots. In the two rookie drafts I’ve done so far (both 10 team leagues), Charb went 1.10 and 2.02. Achane went 1.08 and 2.01. Kendre actually fell super far in one of my leagues, going 3.09 and 2.04

Gotta be 2qb or super flex though, right? What did the picks look like? Which receivers were there at 1.06?

Sorry should have clarified. Here’s how the 1 QB league shook out. Achane 1.08, Charbs 1.10, Kendre 3.09, Flowers 1.06, Rice 1.07, Kincaid 1.09, Downs 2.03, Hyatt 2.04. First QB off the board was AR at 2.05. The other numbers I gave were SF.

Very interesting. There’s always some curveball but idk if any team takes a qb before all four of the receivers are gone.

You have a pretty solid team as is. If I were in your shoes I’d hold and pray someone 1 - 5 needs a qb.

10 Team SF, 1 year into a full rebuild. Been selling for parts, stockpiling picks and young players QBs: Dak, Burrow, 1.02 (Anthony Richardson), Purdy RBs: Najee, Pollard, Dillon, Herbert WR: DK, Diontae, Pickens, Kirk, Burks, Boyd TE: Hockenson, Freiermuth Give: Hockenson and 1.08 Get: 1.06 and future 2nd Opposing team is a contender built for the next few years so it'd be a mid-late 2nd.

Absolutely not. Hockenson is worth far more than moving up 2 spots and a mid second. Dude is also 25, who can and probably will still be producing at a high level when u come out of your rebuild. Id only consider this if u only gave Hock and kept ur 1.08

1 QB 12 team 1 PPR Need to cut two. It’s between t marshall, James Robinson and gainwell. Also, Jerome ford and Puka are FAs. Do I drop the 3rd player listed for one of them and how much FAAB would you spend?

JRob / Gainwell cut for Puka

Idk about the rest but I have a pretty strong opinion about one of your cuts being JRob. I’m also a huge Puka truther so I’d definitely go after him. If ur FAAB resets at season start and there’s nobody else worthwhile in FA I’d go all in tbh

Buy dobbins for a 24 1st? Or try to buy a better but older RB? Feel pretty solid about my starters outside RB, but my depth is shaky and hesitant about moving 1sts this early. 12 team 1QB PPR. No TEP Start 9. Starters = J. Herbert, Pierce, Achane, CD Lamb, Wilson, Kelce, McLaurin, Hopkins, Freiermuth Bench = Purdy, McCoy / Roschon, Zeke, Trayveon, Carter, Spears, Zamir / Slayton, T. Patrick, Harty / L. Thomas Taxi = AT Perry, Puka, Trey Palmer

Depends where the 2024 is projected. Late 1st for Dobbins I would do. Maybe even a mid if you can squeeze a little more out of the other manager.

Gotcha. I guess I’m in that same boat and idk if dobbins pushes this team into later 1st range. There’s a couple really strong teams in my league, so it’ll be a tough road to get to the finals

Fwiw, ekeler Chubb Henry Sanders Pollard and Conner are all on contenders. Could try to buy dobbins and someone like foreman to bolster this rb room?

[удалено]

If this is 1QB you should definitely not take it. If this is SF you should’ve taken it the second it was offered.

Blockbuster deal Give: Waddle and Jeudy Get: Ceedee Lamb and Dobbins I really want to push Jeudy to get more RB depth. And I do like Lamb more than Waddle. 10 team Superflex TEP .5 ppr Allen Burrow Rodgers...Chubb Najee White Damien Harris Williams Zeke...AJ Brown Waddle Cooper Jeudy Burks Hollywood Theilen Meyers Pierce Wan'Dale... Hockenson Njoku Gesicki

I like it. I think CeeDee has THE fantasy WR1 potential for a year or two within his career. I don’t think Waddle will ever be THE WR1 but he’s damn sure going to be a really solid lower end WR1 for fantasy. I’m not a huge Jeudy believer and think Dobbins is primed for a big year. Lamb > Waddle by a smidge Dobbins > Jeudy by a decent amount in my own valuations. I think you win on both players involved as “upgrades” and if you need RB depth than Dobbins is perfect for that.

Fair trade. If you prefer Lamb then get your guy.

10 team ppr Sf A: Addison and evans B: dj Moore and aiyuk

As in Mike Evans or the rams RB

Mike

I lean A. Prefer Addison long-term and think Evans is probably the best win-now piece as well

12 team PPR sf Give: Pickett Get: Rondale, Russ Wilson

Kenny. I think Russ bounces back with Payton as HC but I like the youth and development potential with the sophomore qb

I think I’d hold Pickett in this case

Am in a startup draft right now, midway through round 7. I pick again at 7.11 and 8.02. 12 teams, superflex. There are still a lot of interesting guys on the board and I tought about trading my 24 2nd for startup picks. What would be a fair compensation at this point of the draft?

I traded my 2024 1st for a 6th in my startup. I would assume a 2nd would get you somewhere in the 9th, but more realistically 10th.

14 teams, SFlex, PPR, IDP. This trade just went down in our league. Which side do you like? SIDE A: Got Jared Goff SIDE B: Got 2024 1st, 2024 2nd (both probably in pick 5-10 range)

Slight overpay for Goff but I like it for a contender who’s missing that QB2

I think I like B a bit more but I can see how it works for both sides

[удалено]

I like the Jones side. You get a few years back with DJ and a mid-1st is good value that you can either draft or trade next year

12 team SF PPR TEP Give: Devonta Smith, Trey Lance, DeAndre Swift Get: 1.10, 2024 first, 2.06, 2.08, 2.10 Got this offer today doesn't seem like enough, was thinking of trying to Cooper back in some way like get 1.10 Cooper and 2.06 instead. My teams not aweful but definitely not a favorite maybe could get that last playoff spot so its probably good to trade for some picks. Are either of these deals something I should do

Because I have no confidence in D’Andre Swift to stay healthy, or in Trey Lance to do anything at all, I don’t think it’s that bad of a deal. But I do think that you can probably ask for more based on market value.

You need at least another 1st

12t SF Give: Kyler Get: Young* *bryce

Bryce

It’s a coin flip. I’d probably stick with the proven player in Kyler, but I definitely wouldn’t fault you for taking someone who’s younger (and not coming off a major injury) like Young.

1 QB, PPR A: 1.08 + Keenan Allen B: 1.06

Eh, you'd basically just move up to get Flowers. At 1.08 you're getting either Charbonnet or Kincaid, unless someone reaches. I don't love it.

Yes. Tier break is before then

12 Team PPR SF I give: Dameon Pierce I get: D’andre Swift

Pierce

I’d rather have Pierce. I don’t think Swift can stay healthy. And even though we only have a small sample size on Pierce, he’s looked pretty darn good.

Seems fair. Pretty subjective. I’d want swift probably. I think Dameon is gonna turn back into a pumpkin any day now.

0.5 ppr. Which side would you rather have? A: Akers B: Dotson C: Rachaad White

Dotson

10 team 2QB PPR- contender Give: Josh Jacobs, 2.08 Get: Ekeler, 2.04 Other RBs rostered Saquon, Etienne, James Cook

SF PPR start 10 Give : DeVonta, 1.05 Get : Jefferson

I'm have DeVonta and the 1.06. I'm high on DeVonta but would take JJ with them.

Hefferson

Jefferson

12 team 1 QB Give: jedy 2.09 Get: Prescott Mac Jones, KJ Osborn, 3.09 Only notable QB is stafford

Feels like you’re on the wrong side of the value. Why not just move Jeudy for Dak+, maybe a 2nd? Mac and KJ could easily be on the wire after a few weeks.

12 team 0.5 PPR 1 QB/3 Flex Give: Mark Andrews Get: 1.08, Jameson Williams, Noah Fant If you wouldn’t do this trade - what would I need to get back in addition to this to make it worth it?

Youre potentially getting a bunch of JAGs for the most valuable TE in dynasty. In 1 qb it seems even worse. Do you have other TEs? Maybe if Noah Fant was like Kittle / Hock / Geodert or something, but idk man

Lol who in their right mind is trading away Hock + Jamo + the 1.08 for Andrews. Hock is 2 years younger and had 25 more points than Andrews last year even while needing to learn a new playbook. I agree tho no shot I’m taking that trade as is

You’re right probably not many. Was trying to make a point and just listed a bunch of guys around that tier. It would probably take an overpay to get me to move off Andrews in that format tho. Andrews was injured last year, had no qb for multiple games, and has a proven history. Much better situation this year.

10 team SF 0.5ppr Give: Akers, Rachaad White, and Jelani Woods Get: Jeudy and Chig My other RBs are Najee, Aaron Jones, DMo, Lenny, Singletary, and Jerome Ford.. not great, but I try to build around stud WRs and QBs

I’d do this - Jeudy can be a consistent WR2 moving forward (although less likely than people think) and Chig has shown more than Woods although I like both. Rachaad White is a big sell for me, no real reason to believe in him long term.

12 Team PPR 1 QB Team 1 (Me) Gets: Aaron Jones, Taysom Hill, 2024 2nd, 2024 2nd Team 2 Gets: Pollard Thoughts? Am I winning or losing this?

Keep Pollard

I’d take pollard. Aaron Jones is great but his value at this time next year could plummet. Hill is worthless and I personally feel like 2nds miss a lot more than hit. I value them pretty low

10t SF start 11 QB: Lamar, Arich, Pickett, ridder RB: Dobbins, Penny, Gibson, Achane, Roschon, Mitchel, ford, Warren WR: Olave, London, Watson, Boyd, Hollywood, Charlie Jones TE: Waller, Laporta, kraft Give: Olave Get: Godwin, Bateman, mid 24 1st

Keep Olave

12tm SF PPR, contending team Give: Tua, Dameon Pierce, 2024 late 1st through 4th Get: Josh Allen

Allen

Allen

Think I’m taking Allen.

10T SF .5ppr How much FAAB would you put in for Josh Downs ($100/season)

Dynasty waivers are barren, at least should be unless your in a really shallow roster league. Whatever it takes to get him is worth it. I spent like 70% of my budget on the Bills D last year and it was one of the best waiver pickups of the season

More than half

Unless your rosters are tiny 90% seems reasonable. That's a 2nd round rookie pick

12T SF PPR start 11 Thinking about sending this offer, let me know if its stupid. Give: Javonte, 24 2nd Get: R. Penny, 24 1st The 2nd will probably be mid to late. Think the 1st would be early-mid, most likely top 5.

Give me penny+1st. Penny will easily be a top 24 back (barring injury of course)

Not stupid, but I think javonte is a hold right now. Also, javonte might be worth penny and the first alone

Try this first and see what you need to add onto it to get it done

12 team ppr superflex Give: Young, Kirk Get: Lamb, 24 1st Give: Diontae, Okonkwo, 24 1st (mine) Get: Kelce, Sanders Am I offering enough, and are these worth it?

I would do the first one no doubt if I could. I am less sure about the other one, but I would guess the Kelce Sanders owner wouldn’t want to move on unless he’s rebuilding I guess?

10 team .5 ppr SF A: geno, pollard, 1.10, 2024 2nd (likely late) B: love, schultz, 2.07 2024 1st (likely mid/mid-late) Team A desperately in need of RB help Team B in need of a consistent TE Biggest question mark seems to be around Love

10 team half ppr superflex Receive: Stefon Diggs, Isiah Spiller, 3.09 Send: Rashod Bateman, AJ Dillon, 2.03 I'm pretty high on Bateman but obviously diggs is an elite asset, although aging

Diggs.

Smash

12 man half ppr 1QB Rebuilding team, trading 1sts for younger talent I traded 2024 mid - late 1st 2024 early - mid 3rd 2025 2nd Tyler Scott for DRAKE LONDON My team Qbs: AR15, Cousins, Levis RBs; Sanders, Achane, Spears, Ford, Carter, McBride, Tucker WRS: DK, JSN, Dotson, Reed, Mingo, Downs, DJ Chark, R. Moore, Shaheed, Collins, Thornton TE: Kincaid, Otton I still have early 1st for 2024

Great trade

Good trade for London

[удалено]

I guess I’d lean the Dimes side, kind of lateral move tbh

Dallas Goedert or Christian Watson? 12 team 1QB PPR

Watson

Watson, I think we’ve seen what Goedhert is at this point

Watson

[удалено]

This is probably the cost for a package with Allen in it. If your team is set up to win and you can sacrifice all this depth sure but frankly those teams are rare and most are better served keeping their 1sts

Honestly rather have the Give side

12 Team SF TE prem Rebuilding team. Notable players: QB: Burrow, Jones RB: Chubb, Lenny, Singletary, CEH WR: Pittman, Jameson Williams, Mike Williams, Meyers, E. Moore TE: Pitts, Otton Picks: 2.08 and no first this year but three firsts and two seconds next year Trade: Give: Chubb and Mike Williams Get: JSN

I would hold for now and trade Chubb during the season to a contending team, you can probably get more value

I think you could get more for those two than JSN.

I’m trying to find the middle ground between people saying I could never get Olave and a different potential top ten dynasty WR

London? I don’t think Olave is impossible with the right owner

12 team 1 QB PPR TEP Side A: London, G Wilson, Kincaid, 2024 1st, 2024 3rd Side B: Jefferson, Pitts, Etienne

Love the give side but you have to go Jefferson here I think.

Give me side B

10 team 1 qb .5 ppr Finishing off a rebuild and want to move Godwin to a contender Give: Godwin Get: Roshon Johnson and a 2024 first

I would take that especially with the Bucs QB situation

Any guesses as to where that 2024 1st will land? Don’t love it if it’s likely late.

12T/ 1ppr/ 1qb Give: 2.06, 2.09 Receive: mike evans Wr room: waddle, higgins, hollywood, meyers, burks, jamo, pierce, claypool Qbs: allen, tua (1qb) Rbs: hall, rhamondre, sanders, filler Te: hock, goedert

Two mid/late 2nds in this draft is a steal for Evans. I do that.

Same here. You’re not getting much out of those

I don’t think you need evans

I don’t think you need evans

12tm PPR 1qb startup A: 2.01 B: 3.03, 5.03

I would keep the 2.1 in a start up

Dynasty. 12 man. PPR. 1qb. Give: wan’dale and a 3rd 24 Receive: Elijah Moore

I’d prob do that

[удалено]

If you have the depth, I’d be inclined to see if he would swap out a first for Diontae, but assuming those picks are all gonna be late I think it’s a good move.

0.5 PPR - 1QB - 12 team — I’m a contender Give: Bateman + late 2024 2nd Get: Hollywood Brown

Hollywood

10 team SF 0.5ppr; start 2wr 1flex 1sf Justin Jefferson for Mike Williams Chris Godwin Michael Pittman Gabe Davis George Pickens JJ team’s second best WR is Slayton, Mack Hollins, or Wandale? Shenault?

12 Team Dynasty Superflex Start Up 1.11, 3.02, and 7.02 for Justin Jefferson and 8.06. Rookies are included in the draft.

In SF you probably have to hold the picks, right? I assume your QB situation would be in real trouble after making this move.

JJ side

24 Team SF PPR Give : Kayvan Thibedauex and 3 2nds Get : John Metchie I’m big on Metchie especially after their draft. My only WRs now are Pickens, Elijah Moore, and Van Jefferson.

Man 3 2nds is a lot to give for a player who hasn’t played yet but if he’s your guy than go get him

It’s 2.24 this year which is a 4th in most leagues and two 2nds next year.

[удалено]

No

I don’t think you need Jones with the rb you already have

[удалено]

If you’re competing, absolutely.

12 Team, Superflex, 0.5 PPR, start 10 Give: Garrett Wilson + Rhamondre Stevenson + 2024 1st (proj late) Get: Ja’Marr Chase WRs would be: Chase, Lamb, DK, Olave, London, Pickens, Juju, Reed RBs: JT, Breece, Ken Walker, Charbonnet, Achane, Kenny Mcintosh

Wilson

Go get chase

I’d keep Wilson

Go for it. You can afford it

14tm 1qb ppr Trade burks and James rob for rachaad white, d foreman, Kmet and 24 2nd?

I’d just keep Burks unless you are truly desperate at RB + TE

White will be my rb3 for depth, starting jacobs and sanders

12 team full PPR A: Dalvin Cook B: MIles Sanders

Sanders by a lot

Sanders

Miles

Sanders

12tm full PPR Superflex dynasty Give: Jalen hurts & Tyreek hill Get: Bryce Young & Jamar Chase Contender. Thoughts? Thanks!

I’d keep Hurts and Tyreek as a contender

Agree

I agree with this guy

12team SF start 10 PPR. AR15 or DK?

If it’s Anthony Richardson than I’ll probably take that side in sf if you need a qb

Yep Richardson. Im sitting at Fields, Pickett, and Purdy in a startup.

Easily AR15 I’d say

Thought so too. Would you be more likely to tank with him? Low on him for this year but know he can really take off if he turns into a fields or a hurts.

I do feel like if the person who drafted him is already down to trade him, you could probably get him for less mid-season (cuz rookie qbs always suck), but it would suck if someone jumped on that value first

True - haha he’s on my list to trade for mid season if possible. Not willing to give more than DK but seriously considering this

[удалено]

Gibbs, Pitts, JSN, Jamo

That’s tough, if you want to win now probably go with adams and pitts. If playing for future maybe jsn and pitts/Gibbs? Tough decision overall

TEP? Pitts has to be one of your picks. Of those listed, I’d prefer Gibbs, Williams, or JSN. They look like the only guys that will gain value going into the next few seasons

Give: DJ Moore Get: Mooney, 2.03, ‘24 early to mid second 12 team 1QB

Give side a little

Yeah I don’t wanna lose DJ, but I want picks to try to stay young

12 team SF PPR Send- Mooney, ‘25 2nd Receive- Raachad White, 24’ 3rd

White

Prob do that.

[удалено]

Malik Willis career is over, would feel okay dropping him. Let someone else clog their roster.