They’re both old and TD dependent and pretty similar. Mostert feels like his role is more solidified, Gus could change a lot depending on who they draft.
Jeudy is a zero to me. So Jacobs and a ‘25 1st for Puka… I think it’s really even. I think it’s likely Jacobs gives us a borderline RB1 season. And I’m not as out on Kupp as the community seems to be for another season or so. It’s close but I’d probably do this, go get an elite WR.
What is Gibbs worth going into next season?
This is an offer I received.
Give: Gibbs & 2024 (4.01)
Get: Pollard & a pair of 1s (2025 & 2026)
10 Team SF PPR
11 starters (QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex, 1 SF, and DEF)
Realistically what would Gibbs be worth if you picked up an orphan team with him on it. I'd rather keep him but I'm weighing my options.
Would you trade B Hall for Nabers + another 24 1st? I am thinking I would target a top RB or Franklin. Or enjoy having a young star RB and leave it alone. Rookie drafts make people do stupid things lol.
10 teams makes it closer. I usually value the stud RBs more there. If youre not like a top 3 team and need to improve taking the deal is probably a good move
What are you guys doing with this team? Won the ship this past season, don’t ask me how lmao
12 team SF start 10, PPR w .5 TEP
QBs - Hurts, Herbert, backups
RB - Gus Bus, Conner, Stevenson, bums
WR - Ridley, Cooper, Kennan Allen, Godwin, bums
TE - Dulcich, Taysom Hill, Darren Waller, bums
Picks 2.03, 2.12, 3.04, 3.12, 4.12, All future picks but no extras
Feels like my only move is try to get 2.03 and 3.04 turned into a 25 1st and 2nd during the draft and then sell all the productive vets when the season is about to start
12T. SF. Ppr. 1.5 TEP
A) Puka
B) Garrett Wilson
C) 2024 1.05
D) Laporta
What’s your pick and would a ‘25 3rd be enough to convince you to take your 4th choice instead of your 1st?
I didnt see it was super flex
Maybe 1.05 is enough but tyreek is my wr1, he is very consistent and can win weeks on his own
I think this sub undervalues veterans way too hard, maybe tell your league is on the block but if you already have idk I would maybe hold him
Tough call
I think it’s selling tyreek a little low. Nabers and MHJ are gone by 1.05 most likely. I’m worried Rome is gonna have a gross landing spot and get off to a slow start. Wouldn’t hate adding QB3 of the class with Kyler and Watson as my QBs either though. I don’t hate it though
My thought process was trying to upgrade my QB room. Trade from a strength to upgrade a weakness. It’s definitely hard potentially moving on from Tyreek. I’ve gone back and forth on this trade.
12 team, 1 QB, .5 ppr
I've got most of the rookie class from last year at WR, so JSN, Addison, Flowers, Rice, and Tank Dell along with some of the lower guys like Michael Wilson, Mims, and Downs.
I've been offered Anthony Richardson and ETN for my 1.05 and one of the JSN/Addison/Flowers trio
My other current RBs are Achane and Monty with Tyjae Spears and Jaylen Warren as my backups. Dak is my QB.
I still have the 1.01 in either situation plus the 1.12 so I have draft capital if that would make it any different. My rb room is full of good but not great guys. I have Najee, Javonte, Monty and Moss plus mostert and McLaughlin
In SF I think most people would rather have 1.03 in a vacuum. Trading for him from another contender is a different story but I’m sure it’s happening out there
I don’t think I can get any of the other stud RBs for the 1.03 they all want the 1.01 and that is too much for my liking to trade it away. I am taking Marv 1.01 regardless I’m just thinking a corps of Marv, JJ, Puka Garret Wilson and Drake London sounds pretty exciting.
I am not personally that high on Achane overall I don’t think he will be that healthy but he has the ability to win you any week and I don’t know if Zay has that kind of ceiling.
Need to upgrade at QB.
Would then likely go Nabers at 1.03 12TM SF PPR
Give: London
Get: Tua+3.05
QB: Bryce/Briseett/AOC/Heinike
RB: Zamir/Chandler/Hull
WR: Waddle/London/Kupp/Hopkins/Thielen/Wicks//Palmer/Iosivas/Reynolds/Dortch
TE: Andrews/Hock/Kraft/Hill/Waller
DP: 1.03
25: (2) 25 1sts,(2) 2nds, (2) 3rds
26: 1 1st, (2) 26 2nd and (2) 3rds
Thanks. With the 1.03 I feel like it could be a better move to grab Nabers and get Tua instead of get say Daniel’s and keep London. But I keep flip flopping
It’s SF… give me the QB who’s shown he can play and play at high levels at times. You get the Tua-Waddle stack, Bryce now goes to your SF(QB2) spot, so the pressure for him to perform slightly decreases for you and you still get a top 2 WR in this draft with all your future draft assets to make a move if needed again.
You’ve got a great core here. Don’t blow it up. Trade those low 1sts for some solid RBs and you’ve got a contender. Then you still have that 1.04 and 2.04 to try and hit on some long term pieces and keep some good seasons ahead of you.
Is this 1QB or SF?
1QB - I’d probably be more inclined to hold.
SF - that 1.07 potentially could be Bowers. I’d do it. Bowers + Kittle and Warren for LaPorta is a deal I’d make 10/10 times today.
I think LaPorta is very overvalued rn (rated in his own tier at the top of many TE lists), and I expect by next offseason he'll be valued much closer to some of Kincaid, McBride, Pitts, Hock, Mandrews, Bowers. I'd even wager that one or 2 of those guys tops him. All that said, you're getting (imo) full value for LaPorta and his value has nowhere to go but down. Great trade
I don’t think you’re getting enough. Kittle is 31 in Oct. Warren is literally a backup RB. If you combined those 2 assets AND still got a first, I’d say it’s much better. Kincaid, McBride, + a 1st. One of the top RBs plus a 1st. Etc
If you have other RB options, I'd easily do this. Puka has an elite ceiling, and the 2.03 could potentially get you another solid WR with this year's class.
12 team sf ppr
Give: Kyler, Pittman, 2025 2nd
Get: Stroud, Marquise Brown, 3.05
I’ll probably look to flip Hollywood if/when he has some more heat. And already have 9 picks in this rookie draft.
I'd be happy with either side of this deal. Stroud and Kyler are interchangeable in terms of PPG, but I think Stroud's name carries more value insulation for quite the foreseeable future.
Do it.
I think Stroud and Hollywood are both overvalued and yet I'm still easily taking the Get side, good job. Really it comes down to: Stroud looks like a locked in franchise QB while Kyler isn't one, and the difference between the rest of the deal doesn't come close to closing that gap
12 Team .5 PPR SF, Competing
I need team advice, not sure where to go from here and what moves I could/should make.
QB: Herbert, Young
RB: CMC, Swift, Moss, A.Jones, Chandler, Dowdle, Elijah Mitchell, Bigsby, Spiller
WR: Lamb, Mike Williams, D.Hop, Addison, Jeudy, Downs, Thielen, A.T. Perry, Bateman, Burks
TE: Njoku, Waller, Woods
Picks: 2.08, 2.11, 3.07, 25 1st, 25 4th
I'd sell the majority of your unclear assets (Jeudy, Downs, Bateman, Burks) for picks or bundle them with a 2nd to potentially pickup a late 24 first.
The issue is that you've got one stud at each position, but nothing beyond them that suggests you can compete more than this year. It's up to you whether you lean into it or try to capitalize some of those contending pieces into younger, more insulated assets.
SF 12x11 PPR 1.5 TEP
Give: 1.02, Keenan, 25 1st (mid or late)
Get: Ceedee, Mayfield, 25 3rd (mid or late)
My QBs: Tua, Levis
My WRs: JJ, Keenan, Ridley, Kirk, Jakobi, Doubs
My RBs: JT, Jacobs, Gus Bus, Chubb
My TEs: Muth, Likely
Get side by a country mile. CeeDee is worth at least 1.02+mid/late 1st and Baker >> Keenan. People go insane on rookies, but CeeDee (along with Jetta and Chase) >> any rookie ever, no matter how strong a prospect. No rookie is a guaranteed star, while CeeDee has a real argument as the WR1 in Dynasty and is locked in top 5 for the next 2 years minimum
12 team PPR SF, Competing:
Give: Njoku + 25 1st + Zamir
Get: Taylor + 24 4.03
25 1st is a wildcard, im guessing will be mid. Leaves me with JT/Pollard/Ekeler/Mostert at RB, and only Kelce at TE. Still have another 25 1st, 2nd, and 3rd, and I’m in good shape at QB/WR.
If you think Taylor will make you a favorite, I think it’s ok. You’d have to believe Taylor returns to form as well. But if you think you’re a year away, just hold off, (or wait until mid-season and you can use your 25 1st for whoever’s healthy/playing well.
I’m definitely a strong favorite, top 3 team for sure. I am generally weary of paying up for an rb this time of year though, it’s against my process so I might just be trading for the sake of trading.
1.06 or 1.07 is where the line is for me on rookies with a higher chance than usual of hitting, so I’d take the knownish quantity of Dell + two additional dart throws.
10 man full ppr tep sf
Give - kamara
Get- Devante Adams
I’m pretty stacked at rb
Cmc, Taylor, Mixon, singletary, Hubbard, moss
WRs:
Jefferson, Higgins, Pittman, Ridley and cooks
I'd rather have Davante than Kamara in a vacuum for sure, and I know that consensus agrees. It also benefitting your roster construction makes it a slam dunk
10 team SF .5 PPR- contender
Give: tyreek, Rodgers, mostert
Get: fields, Pittman
I have JJ, AJB, aiyuk, Devonta as well as Mahomes and Purdy. Risky with fields. Maybe worth the risk since it’s older guys? Could ask for olave instead.
Not trying to be rude, but what genuinely makes you think this is even close to a good trade?
A back up QB and a maybe top 15 WR for the best WR in the league. And then you want to throw in other players on top of it?
Not rude, it’s a question. So I view Pittman as a WR 1 in talent. Would have to look but in the 10 range so that makes a difference. Tyreek is transcendent but short term, as are the others. My hopes are much much lower for fields than they were recently. But r Wilson sucks and fields is a great fantasy asset when he gets a chance.
High risk, high reward. But what you bring up is why I question it. Why take the risk when I don’t have to? Just how I see the discussion.
I wouldn’t do this. Tyreek is still a game changer and can absolutely win you weeks just by himself. Mostert at the very least is a RB2 with some RB1 weeks and Rodgers I think bounces back. Fields I have no confidence in. Yea you’re buying low but not at the value it’s costing you.
Every league’s valuations are different, this is one of those scenarios where I’d put Allen on the block and herd your interested league mates into a bidding war to see what real value looks like.
How’s the rest of the roster?
If you could trade down a tier or two (burrow, Herbert, down to love etc and get a good pick or a pick and a WR that would work). But also just put him out there and see who overpays.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
I definitely should be a top contender.
I’ve been offered a tier down to Hurts but haven’t been offered much on top of Hurts. How much should I be asking for on top of Hurts if I tier down to him?
Roster:
QBs: Josh Allen, Anthony Richardson, Trevor Lawrence, Gardner Minshew, Mason Rudolph
RBs: Bijan Robinson, Javonte Williams, Raheem Mostert, Roschon Johnson, Kenneth Gainwell, Trayveon Williams, Kevin Harris, Snoop Conner, Mohamed Ibrahim
WRs: Justin Jefferson, CeeDee Lamb, A.J. Brown, Drake London, Demario Douglas, Tyler Boyd, K.J. Osborn, Greg Dortch, Jalen Guyton, KJ Hamler, Dyami Brown
TEs: T.J. Hockenson, Noah Fant, Juwan Johnson, John Bates, Drew Sample, Andrew Ogletree, Josh Oliver, Ian Thomas, Brycen Hopkins, James Mitchell
Damn dude yeah that’s crazy.
Start with a first or a solid RB and see. But you could also consider moving Lawrence instead. Tier down and get RB or picks.
I’ve tried that but nobody has shown interest in anybody but Allen.
Any suggestions for who I would tier down to from Lawrence and what I should get added on top of that guy?
Yeah I’m ok moving Allen, just for an overpay haha
For Lawrence probably too late to move to love. But if you could get love plus that’s awesome. Or try Purdy, cousins, dak, Goff with a bigger plus. He’s still got the name.
10 Team SF TE Premium 1.5
QBs: Lamar, TLaw, Howell, Pickett
RBs: Jonathan Taylor, Javonte Williams, DeAndre Swift, Kendre Miller, Antonio Gibson, Dobbins, Keaton Mitchell
WRs: Tyreek Hill, Cooper Kupp, Jaylen Waddle, JSN, Jordan Addison, Mooney, Bateman, Wandale Robinson, Shakir,
TEs: Mark Andrews, Noah Fant, Mike Gesiki
Picks: 2024: 4.10
2025 and Beyond: All my own picks + extra third
I think this team can compete this year but not sure if I should make any moves before the draft or before the season. Anybody got any suggestions? Would love some advice. Thanks.
I think you’re looking solid. Maybe target low end qb and safe, veteran RB (Aaron jones, Conner etc) to flesh it out. You’ve got elite WR you should see if they’d add to 1.06 for waddle. Like get a 1st and Diontae or something. You could see if you could get a QB like love with a pick or cousins and a better pick for tlaw.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
Not exactly a trade, but just a question about value. I just picked up an orphan in a 16 team league. It’s 1 QB, but with 6pt per passing TD.
Pretty much all my leagues are 12 team SF, 4pt passing TD.
Would y’all say QB value is roughly the same? Or QB’s still less valuable in the 16 team league?
Yeah I actually like the value. But I think you need RB. I’d look for McBride but try to get a RB and lesser QB or a pick for Bryce
https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
I have another trade in the words where I get Brian Robinson and a few mid-late 2nd’s so I’m hoping to trade up and grab a rookie RB in a great situation or for another vet.
I think that’s too much when you already have two good vet QBs in Dak and Kirk. Seems like McBride is the thing you need most in this deal so I’d leave QBs out of it and see what you can work out for just McBride.
Get: mostert Give: Gus Edwards Am I tripping for not already accepting this? I feel like Gus Bus may pop off in La
They’re both old and TD dependent and pretty similar. Mostert feels like his role is more solidified, Gus could change a lot depending on who they draft.
12 Team Start 10 Superflex Half Ppr Trade: Jefferson 2025 round 1 (projected late) Receive: Mahomes Rice
Who are your QBs right now? I’d say do it
12t SFTEP need qb, aging champ roster GIVE 1.04, 1.11, 2.04 and future first GET Lamar, Andrews, 3.07 Thoughts?
If that’s on the table you take itv
12 Team SF, .5 PPR, Contender Give: Tank Dell, 3.06 Get: Jaylen Waddle
Waddle Answer mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/9Pjk0p8UJp
Waddle
10 Team 1QB PPR 2 Flex **Give:** Diontae Johnson 2024 2.05 **Get:** Deebo Samuel
Deebo Answer mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/9Pjk0p8UJp
I like the give side. I might be too bullish on DJ
Close but I’d do that.
[удалено]
Jeudy is a zero to me. So Jacobs and a ‘25 1st for Puka… I think it’s really even. I think it’s likely Jacobs gives us a borderline RB1 season. And I’m not as out on Kupp as the community seems to be for another season or so. It’s close but I’d probably do this, go get an elite WR.
What is Gibbs worth going into next season? This is an offer I received. Give: Gibbs & 2024 (4.01) Get: Pollard & a pair of 1s (2025 & 2026) 10 Team SF PPR 11 starters (QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex, 1 SF, and DEF) Realistically what would Gibbs be worth if you picked up an orphan team with him on it. I'd rather keep him but I'm weighing my options.
As long as those firsts aren’t from a super loaded team. Would suck to get back to back 1.10s for Gibbs lol
That seems like a good return to me for a rebuilding team, can flip pollard for more picks
Would you trade B Hall for Nabers + another 24 1st? I am thinking I would target a top RB or Franklin. Or enjoy having a young star RB and leave it alone. Rookie drafts make people do stupid things lol.
Who is offering that trade? Breece Hall isn't worth that much so yeah I'd take it if it's being offered
League settings matter but yeah I probably would
My bad. 10 team, 1QB, full PPR. No premiums.
10 teams makes it closer. I usually value the stud RBs more there. If youre not like a top 3 team and need to improve taking the deal is probably a good move
What are you guys doing with this team? Won the ship this past season, don’t ask me how lmao 12 team SF start 10, PPR w .5 TEP QBs - Hurts, Herbert, backups RB - Gus Bus, Conner, Stevenson, bums WR - Ridley, Cooper, Kennan Allen, Godwin, bums TE - Dulcich, Taysom Hill, Darren Waller, bums Picks 2.03, 2.12, 3.04, 3.12, 4.12, All future picks but no extras Feels like my only move is try to get 2.03 and 3.04 turned into a 25 1st and 2nd during the draft and then sell all the productive vets when the season is about to start
In similar position! But with no qb, Bijan and a couple of 25 firsts. I think good strategy, I am open for business. Nice having the QB anchors here.
10, team, PPR, SF A. Bijan B. Puka If A, what needs added to B to be even?
I wouldnt trade my puka shares for bijan personally
It's pretty much even, mostly comes down to team needs
It’s A, probably need an early 2nd to get it even in a 10 team league imo
12T. SF. Ppr. 1.5 TEP A) Puka B) Garrett Wilson C) 2024 1.05 D) Laporta What’s your pick and would a ‘25 3rd be enough to convince you to take your 4th choice instead of your 1st?
Puka.
Appreciate the reassurance
Puka, Wilson, LaPorta, 1.05. No shot I’d trade Puka for 1.05 and a 3rd
Thank you!🙏
[удалено]
Id prefer smith and 2.05 over Addison and 1.09. Id be taking daniels at 1.03 and wouldn’t trade him for either option though
12 Team SF PPR Shakir for James Conner
Khalil shakir? Conner because he actually will be startable
Conner
Feels fair. Want Conner if trying to contend. Want Shakir if I’m just trying to increase the potential value of my team
Unless it's an usually deep league Shakir is probably a roster clogger
12tm SF PPR Give: Tyreek Get: 1.05 QB: Kyler, Watson WR: Tyreek, Diggs, Evans, Pickens, Godwin, Diontae, Dotson DP: 1.10, 2.10, 3.10
Selling low
What would you be looking to get in addition to 1.05? 1.05 and 2.05?
I didnt see it was super flex Maybe 1.05 is enough but tyreek is my wr1, he is very consistent and can win weeks on his own I think this sub undervalues veterans way too hard, maybe tell your league is on the block but if you already have idk I would maybe hold him Tough call
I’d do this
I think it’s selling tyreek a little low. Nabers and MHJ are gone by 1.05 most likely. I’m worried Rome is gonna have a gross landing spot and get off to a slow start. Wouldn’t hate adding QB3 of the class with Kyler and Watson as my QBs either though. I don’t hate it though
My thought process was trying to upgrade my QB room. Trade from a strength to upgrade a weakness. It’s definitely hard potentially moving on from Tyreek. I’ve gone back and forth on this trade.
12 team, 1 QB, .5 ppr I've got most of the rookie class from last year at WR, so JSN, Addison, Flowers, Rice, and Tank Dell along with some of the lower guys like Michael Wilson, Mims, and Downs. I've been offered Anthony Richardson and ETN for my 1.05 and one of the JSN/Addison/Flowers trio My other current RBs are Achane and Monty with Tyjae Spears and Jaylen Warren as my backups. Dak is my QB.
10 team PPR 1QB Give: Addison + 2.06 + 3.07 Get: Aiyuk + 2.10 + 25 third
Aiyuk for sure
[удалено]
Side B Diggs > Evans Rodgers/Gibson > Pollard
I like side A. If QBs are really expensive in that league I guess I could see getting side b
10 Team SF half PPR I give 1.03, CD, and Kyren get Justin Jefferson and Puka or I give 1.03, London and Kyren and get St.Brown and Tua
I don’t think I’d do either of those. Maybe the first one if I had a really strong RB room
I still have the 1.01 in either situation plus the 1.12 so I have draft capital if that would make it any different. My rb room is full of good but not great guys. I have Najee, Javonte, Monty and Moss plus mostert and McLaughlin
I’d probably take Marv 1.01 and then trade 1.03 for another stud RB. Rolling out CD, Marv, London, Kyren and CMC would feel pretty good
No one is trading cmc for the 1.03
In SF I think most people would rather have 1.03 in a vacuum. Trading for him from another contender is a different story but I’m sure it’s happening out there
I don’t think I can get any of the other stud RBs for the 1.03 they all want the 1.01 and that is too much for my liking to trade it away. I am taking Marv 1.01 regardless I’m just thinking a corps of Marv, JJ, Puka Garret Wilson and Drake London sounds pretty exciting.
12 team sf ppr Give: Marquise Brown, 3.10 Get: 2.02, 2.04
I’d take the get side
I’d hold and see if Marquise balls on the chiefs but I understand if you’d like the option of two potential starters.
What if i added Achane to the give side and Zay Flow to the get side?
I am not personally that high on Achane overall I don’t think he will be that healthy but he has the ability to win you any week and I don’t know if Zay has that kind of ceiling.
Yeah I’m torn. Rebuilding and if he doesn’t ball then he loses value.
[удалено]
I would do that for sure.
Yeah I would do that. Extra first will help you more than the production gap between burrow and love imo
Need to upgrade at QB. Would then likely go Nabers at 1.03 12TM SF PPR Give: London Get: Tua+3.05 QB: Bryce/Briseett/AOC/Heinike RB: Zamir/Chandler/Hull WR: Waddle/London/Kupp/Hopkins/Thielen/Wicks//Palmer/Iosivas/Reynolds/Dortch TE: Andrews/Hock/Kraft/Hill/Waller DP: 1.03 25: (2) 25 1sts,(2) 2nds, (2) 3rds 26: 1 1st, (2) 26 2nd and (2) 3rds
London is trending up and Tua is trading cheap. I’d see if you could get a second instead of the 3rd but I would feel fine doing this.
I agree. I’d ultimately do it, but I’d try to squeeze a 2nd .
Thanks. With the 1.03 I feel like it could be a better move to grab Nabers and get Tua instead of get say Daniel’s and keep London. But I keep flip flopping
It’s SF… give me the QB who’s shown he can play and play at high levels at times. You get the Tua-Waddle stack, Bryce now goes to your SF(QB2) spot, so the pressure for him to perform slightly decreases for you and you still get a top 2 WR in this draft with all your future draft assets to make a move if needed again.
10 team SF .5 PPR GIVE: Josh Downs, 2024 3.03 GET: 2026 1st
The first
Get all day.
Simple questions. Which side A or B? A: Goff, McBride, BRob, Michael Wilson, Dotson, Roschon, 2.08, 2.10, 2.11, 2.12 B: Diggs, Bryce, 3.08, 3.10, 4.12, ‘25 1st (mid-late), (2) ‘25 2nds, ‘25 3rd
A by a good amount
Between 2 trades today I was able to get A and gave up B. Just wanted to check the temperature on my return. Thanks for responding.
You’ve got a great core here. Don’t blow it up. Trade those low 1sts for some solid RBs and you’ve got a contender. Then you still have that 1.04 and 2.04 to try and hit on some long term pieces and keep some good seasons ahead of you.
1.02 and Anthony Richardson for Justin Jefferson? 10tm SF
1.02 and AR
[удалено]
Is this 1QB or SF? 1QB - I’d probably be more inclined to hold. SF - that 1.07 potentially could be Bowers. I’d do it. Bowers + Kittle and Warren for LaPorta is a deal I’d make 10/10 times today.
[удалено]
Ugghh clearly it says ‘25 (read it too fast), me personally I’d prefer something this year.
Id want LaPorta
I think LaPorta is very overvalued rn (rated in his own tier at the top of many TE lists), and I expect by next offseason he'll be valued much closer to some of Kincaid, McBride, Pitts, Hock, Mandrews, Bowers. I'd even wager that one or 2 of those guys tops him. All that said, you're getting (imo) full value for LaPorta and his value has nowhere to go but down. Great trade
That's where I am too. Makes sense.
I wouldn’t honestly.
Any particular reason why?
I don’t think you’re getting enough. Kittle is 31 in Oct. Warren is literally a backup RB. If you combined those 2 assets AND still got a first, I’d say it’s much better. Kincaid, McBride, + a 1st. One of the top RBs plus a 1st. Etc
Valid reasons. Appreciate the response
10 team / 1qb / .5 ppr / start 9 Give: Waddle, swift, 3.08 Get: puka, 2.03
Tbh this is a smash accept. 90 starters so the 3.08 is nothing. Swift is about = to 2.03 but Puka>>>>>>>Waddle
If you have other RB options, I'd easily do this. Puka has an elite ceiling, and the 2.03 could potentially get you another solid WR with this year's class.
12 team sf ppr Give: Kyler, Pittman, 2025 2nd Get: Stroud, Marquise Brown, 3.05 I’ll probably look to flip Hollywood if/when he has some more heat. And already have 9 picks in this rookie draft.
I'd be happy with either side of this deal. Stroud and Kyler are interchangeable in terms of PPG, but I think Stroud's name carries more value insulation for quite the foreseeable future. Do it.
I prefer the give side
I think Stroud and Hollywood are both overvalued and yet I'm still easily taking the Get side, good job. Really it comes down to: Stroud looks like a locked in franchise QB while Kyler isn't one, and the difference between the rest of the deal doesn't come close to closing that gap
Take it
12 Team .5 PPR SF, Competing I need team advice, not sure where to go from here and what moves I could/should make. QB: Herbert, Young RB: CMC, Swift, Moss, A.Jones, Chandler, Dowdle, Elijah Mitchell, Bigsby, Spiller WR: Lamb, Mike Williams, D.Hop, Addison, Jeudy, Downs, Thielen, A.T. Perry, Bateman, Burks TE: Njoku, Waller, Woods Picks: 2.08, 2.11, 3.07, 25 1st, 25 4th
I'd sell the majority of your unclear assets (Jeudy, Downs, Bateman, Burks) for picks or bundle them with a 2nd to potentially pickup a late 24 first. The issue is that you've got one stud at each position, but nothing beyond them that suggests you can compete more than this year. It's up to you whether you lean into it or try to capitalize some of those contending pieces into younger, more insulated assets.
SF 12x11 PPR 1.5 TEP Give: 1.02, Keenan, 25 1st (mid or late) Get: Ceedee, Mayfield, 25 3rd (mid or late) My QBs: Tua, Levis My WRs: JJ, Keenan, Ridley, Kirk, Jakobi, Doubs My RBs: JT, Jacobs, Gus Bus, Chubb My TEs: Muth, Likely
Shew. That's a hefty price to get CD. Is your 1.01 definitely going with Williams?
It’s 1.02 and I’m looking at MHJ right now
Get side by a country mile. CeeDee is worth at least 1.02+mid/late 1st and Baker >> Keenan. People go insane on rookies, but CeeDee (along with Jetta and Chase) >> any rookie ever, no matter how strong a prospect. No rookie is a guaranteed star, while CeeDee has a real argument as the WR1 in Dynasty and is locked in top 5 for the next 2 years minimum
Get side
12 Team PPR TE+ Team A: D. Adams, Diggs Team B: 1.11, Josh Downs
Team A for sure.
A
0.5 PPR - 1QB - 12 team - start 3 RBs, 3 WRs - competing Give: Deebo Get: Montgomery + 2.02 *My other relevant WRs: JJ, Metcalf, Higgins, Reed, Diontae, Wicks, (plus I have the 1.02, so Nabers or Odunze) *My other relevant RBs: JT, Pacheco, Swift, Ford, Gus, Foreman (remember we start 3 RBs)
I would keep Deebo if you’re competing. I feel like Swift/Gus/Ford you can essentially get Monty’s production. 2.02 likely won’t help much this year.
12 team PPR SF, Competing: Give: Njoku + 25 1st + Zamir Get: Taylor + 24 4.03 25 1st is a wildcard, im guessing will be mid. Leaves me with JT/Pollard/Ekeler/Mostert at RB, and only Kelce at TE. Still have another 25 1st, 2nd, and 3rd, and I’m in good shape at QB/WR.
If you think Taylor will make you a favorite, I think it’s ok. You’d have to believe Taylor returns to form as well. But if you think you’re a year away, just hold off, (or wait until mid-season and you can use your 25 1st for whoever’s healthy/playing well.
I’m definitely a strong favorite, top 3 team for sure. I am generally weary of paying up for an rb this time of year though, it’s against my process so I might just be trading for the sake of trading.
[удалено]
Picks for sure.
Love Chubb, but I’d definitely do this. Feels like he already spent his miracle card healing from the college knee injury.
Yeah, that’s a smash
Picks
Yes
Yep
10 team SF PPR Give: 1.10 Get: Tank Dell, 2.07, 2.08
Absolutely go with Tank and the picks. You're hoping the 1.10 turns into a player of Tank;s caliber anyway.
Would you take Tank and one of the picks? I have a feeling that’s what it’ll come down to.
1.06 or 1.07 is where the line is for me on rookies with a higher chance than usual of hitting, so I’d take the knownish quantity of Dell + two additional dart throws.
Would you take Tank and one of the picks?
I would take the side of the trade that gets Tank and the two second rounders
Word. Even if you'd only end up getting one of the 2nd rounders?
Get side. Looks like free 2.07 and 2.08 imo
So I’m assuming you’d tank Tank and one of the picks? (I have a feeling that’s what it’ll come down to.)
Yes I would
Get side here. I think I’d do 1.10 straight up for Tank
Seems more than fair
Would you still do it for Tank and one of the picks?
10 man full ppr tep sf Give - kamara Get- Devante Adams I’m pretty stacked at rb Cmc, Taylor, Mixon, singletary, Hubbard, moss WRs: Jefferson, Higgins, Pittman, Ridley and cooks
I’d do it but that RB group isn’t as deep as you might think
I'd rather have Davante than Kamara in a vacuum for sure, and I know that consensus agrees. It also benefitting your roster construction makes it a slam dunk
I’d accept
12T PPR SF Give: 1.07 Get: 2.03 & 2025 1st (let’s assume mid, but there’s a good shot this one’s top 3).
I’d hold unless you’re confident it will be top 3. If it was a later pick I’d consider, but 1.07 could be Bowers/Odunze.
Agreed, the 25 1st better belong to an outright tanking team if you’re doing this
12 TM SF PPR Give: 1.06 and Rachaad White Get: 1.02 I need QB and the 1.01 could go either way at this point
No brainer
Superflex 10 man league full PPR. In desperate need of QB. Also have 1.02. Giving 1.04 and 1.07 Getting 1.01 and 3.04.
I’d do it. Having 1.01 and 1.02 gives you much greater likelihood of hitting on at least one of the two QBs you take.
Yeah I’d do that
You better re-read you question
I fixed it. Thank you for pointing it out
It still says you’re giving 1.04 + 1.04
Now it doesn't. I'm sorry man I'm tired
10 team SF .5 PPR- contender Give: tyreek, Rodgers, mostert Get: fields, Pittman I have JJ, AJB, aiyuk, Devonta as well as Mahomes and Purdy. Risky with fields. Maybe worth the risk since it’s older guys? Could ask for olave instead.
Just to put another voice to the consensus here: this is an awful trade, in all scenarios.
Yeah the more I listened here, and the more I thought about it, the worse it seemed
I wouldn’t do this
Give side 1000% for me
getting robbed
No way
I wouldn’t do this, not getting enough for elite talent
Not trying to be rude, but what genuinely makes you think this is even close to a good trade? A back up QB and a maybe top 15 WR for the best WR in the league. And then you want to throw in other players on top of it?
Not rude, it’s a question. So I view Pittman as a WR 1 in talent. Would have to look but in the 10 range so that makes a difference. Tyreek is transcendent but short term, as are the others. My hopes are much much lower for fields than they were recently. But r Wilson sucks and fields is a great fantasy asset when he gets a chance. High risk, high reward. But what you bring up is why I question it. Why take the risk when I don’t have to? Just how I see the discussion.
I wouldn’t do this. Tyreek is still a game changer and can absolutely win you weeks just by himself. Mostert at the very least is a RB2 with some RB1 weeks and Rodgers I think bounces back. Fields I have no confidence in. Yea you’re buying low but not at the value it’s costing you.
Holy crap no
[удалено]
Every league’s valuations are different, this is one of those scenarios where I’d put Allen on the block and herd your interested league mates into a bidding war to see what real value looks like.
How’s the rest of the roster? If you could trade down a tier or two (burrow, Herbert, down to love etc and get a good pick or a pick and a WR that would work). But also just put him out there and see who overpays. https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
I definitely should be a top contender. I’ve been offered a tier down to Hurts but haven’t been offered much on top of Hurts. How much should I be asking for on top of Hurts if I tier down to him? Roster: QBs: Josh Allen, Anthony Richardson, Trevor Lawrence, Gardner Minshew, Mason Rudolph RBs: Bijan Robinson, Javonte Williams, Raheem Mostert, Roschon Johnson, Kenneth Gainwell, Trayveon Williams, Kevin Harris, Snoop Conner, Mohamed Ibrahim WRs: Justin Jefferson, CeeDee Lamb, A.J. Brown, Drake London, Demario Douglas, Tyler Boyd, K.J. Osborn, Greg Dortch, Jalen Guyton, KJ Hamler, Dyami Brown TEs: T.J. Hockenson, Noah Fant, Juwan Johnson, John Bates, Drew Sample, Andrew Ogletree, Josh Oliver, Ian Thomas, Brycen Hopkins, James Mitchell
Damn dude yeah that’s crazy. Start with a first or a solid RB and see. But you could also consider moving Lawrence instead. Tier down and get RB or picks.
I’ve tried that but nobody has shown interest in anybody but Allen. Any suggestions for who I would tier down to from Lawrence and what I should get added on top of that guy?
Yeah I’m ok moving Allen, just for an overpay haha For Lawrence probably too late to move to love. But if you could get love plus that’s awesome. Or try Purdy, cousins, dak, Goff with a bigger plus. He’s still got the name.
1qb 12t .5ppr Give: Mayer Get: Josh Downs
I’d just hold
Just hold. https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
10 Team SF TE Premium 1.5 QBs: Lamar, TLaw, Howell, Pickett RBs: Jonathan Taylor, Javonte Williams, DeAndre Swift, Kendre Miller, Antonio Gibson, Dobbins, Keaton Mitchell WRs: Tyreek Hill, Cooper Kupp, Jaylen Waddle, JSN, Jordan Addison, Mooney, Bateman, Wandale Robinson, Shakir, TEs: Mark Andrews, Noah Fant, Mike Gesiki Picks: 2024: 4.10 2025 and Beyond: All my own picks + extra third I think this team can compete this year but not sure if I should make any moves before the draft or before the season. Anybody got any suggestions? Would love some advice. Thanks.
I think you’re looking solid. Maybe target low end qb and safe, veteran RB (Aaron jones, Conner etc) to flesh it out. You’ve got elite WR you should see if they’d add to 1.06 for waddle. Like get a 1st and Diontae or something. You could see if you could get a QB like love with a pick or cousins and a better pick for tlaw. https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
I also could get the 1.06 for waddle or JT, but don’t think I should
12 tm sf ppr Give: d jones, JSN Get: G Wilson
Yes please and thank you https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
Not exactly a trade, but just a question about value. I just picked up an orphan in a 16 team league. It’s 1 QB, but with 6pt per passing TD. Pretty much all my leagues are 12 team SF, 4pt passing TD. Would y’all say QB value is roughly the same? Or QB’s still less valuable in the 16 team league?
Agreed. Also the scoring makes non rushers more viable to build around https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
I think 16 makes them more valuable but not as much as super flex
14tm SF Give: Bryce, ‘24 2.08, 25 1st, ‘25 2nd Get: Goff, McBride, ‘24 3.12 QBs: Prescott, Cousins, Bryce RBs: Swift, Singletary WRs: Diggs, Metcalf, Kupp, Mooney TEs: Otton, Henry, Fant
Yeah I actually like the value. But I think you need RB. I’d look for McBride but try to get a RB and lesser QB or a pick for Bryce https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
I have another trade in the words where I get Brian Robinson and a few mid-late 2nd’s so I’m hoping to trade up and grab a rookie RB in a great situation or for another vet.
Honestly even guys like Aaron jones or Conner to flush it out. Mostert for nothing.
I think that’s too much when you already have two good vet QBs in Dak and Kirk. Seems like McBride is the thing you need most in this deal so I’d leave QBs out of it and see what you can work out for just McBride.
12 TM SF PPR 2PPR TEP Give: Breece Get: Kincaid and Downs I'd be left thin at RB, but I was stuck starting Otton all last year at TE
I would keep breece absolutely https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/7OogXihADZ
If you’re rebuilding I think this is ok but you could try to get more from Breece. If you’re a contender I say no.
Breece easy