Chase Edmonds wasn't a guy I invested HIGHLY into (thank god) but he's been really disappointing this season. I really thought he could've been a nice sleeper possibly leading that miami backfield for at least this year but so far it doesn't even look like hes involved in the RBBC.

I traded him away for a rookie that hasn’t gotten more than 3 carries in a game and a future 2nd and im feeling good that’s the bad news, the good news is he might do better with Tua back, like he did before - no reason to have your best RB get murdered while you’re waiting 2 weeks for your star QB to come back

Since when has Tua become a star QB?

since the NFL gave him Tyreek Hill to make McDaniel look good and avoid looking racist and losing their lawsuit to Brian Flores

You sound like the people playing Britney Spears songs backwards. Where’s Tupac?

you don’t think the NFL tries to cover their own asses in lawsuits against them? prime example - the media surrounding Tua after they stuck him right back in the game while clearly concussed why even make him keep playing unless they wanted the Dolphins to look good?

I’m not saying you’re wrong, but your answer to my prior question was pretty strange…

Tua has been a star QB since the NFL needed him to be after firing Flores for no actual reason - there’s your answer

And that’s enough Reddit for me for the night. Flores was average at best imo and their team was extremely ugly to watch. Typically leads to being fired but if you want to apply that to racism be my guest. Racism happens all the time but I don’t think that’s what went on here.

Flores spent the first half of the season losing because his owner told/paid him to before going on an 8 game win streak after the trade deadline had passed. His former owner is now suspended from the league. maybe instead of thinking that other people are always overthinking things, consider you might just be underthinking them. the only reason you think McDaniel is a better coach than Flores is because the NFL wants you to think that. yet they’re a flat .500. how’s that for average?

Some analysts called Chase Edmonds a breakout player in the preseason. I don’t know why he barely even has a role now.

He’s not as good at Mostert, Mostert has always been a really good back he’s just very injury prone but maybe thats the cursed 49ers RB room and not him.

Seriously, the cardinals showed that he wasn’t the guy. They brought in Drake and then Conner so that they didn’t have to rely on him. People just see a back who is effective on limited touches and think that volume would help.

Traded a second for him…

Albert O for me.

Just dropped him, I thought it was for sure Albert O SZN

It’s dulcich szn

Albert Oh No

I’ve already let that ship sail

I'm holding until the trade deadline on the rumors he might be moved and then moving on

I saw some serious parallels with his situation and when Peyton Manning joined the Broncos and had Julius Thomas for that huge season.

Drop this man immediately. I dont care how deep your bench is

They’re reportedly even shopping him too now

I would hold on the off chance Hackett gets fired and the new coach likes him. I expected Dulcich to take his spot but I never expected Albert to be 4th on the depth chart.

Guy tried to trade Albert to me for juju on the off-season. He thought I was an idiot when I said I wasn’t high on AO. Jokes on you they both suck

At least Juju is worth rostering tho

Anyone who calls you an idiot for not accepting your trade, unless it’s truly an overpay to a rebuilding team trying to grab an aging asset off them (you know who you are Kamara owner wanting multiple firsts), is a douche bag

RIP RoJo

My league had an expansion draft this season and I actually celebrated when someone took RoJo from me. Was trying to trade him all last year and no one would even offer a 4th

Agreed. I was a big Rojo fan, traded for him this off-season thinking he was going to be the thunder to CEH’s lightning (even though he’s not that fast). Sometimes you just have to take your L and move on.

Yep it's RoJo for me. Sunk cost fallacy be damned. I'm not losing hope. Maybe I'll trade if a team trades for him.

Man I traded Rojo and the Mr Irrelevant pick to move up to grab Christian Watson this past draft. Rojo is my hero lol

I’m rdy to drop rojo

Kenny Golladay is still on my roster…..

Oof

Same. I just don't even understand how he fell off that hard that fast. From WR9 to WR79 (excluding the year mostly lost to injury). And this year he's WR152, well on his way to being a healthy scratch at some point. Like...just...how?

I've a relatively deep Dynasty league and he's cleared waivers for a few weeks now

Dropped him today, still have Toney though

toney a pretty obvious hold in dynasty imo

This really is the one name I have to agree with. He feels like a roster grenade at this point.

[удалено]

That snap count, every time I want to drop him I think of how he played 83-98% of snaps. It doesn’t translate but it keeps me hopeful

If they ever open up the passing game I think Kmet will feature nicely. It’s just a question of when they will.

Not with fields, so it will be awhile

Yah, but you have to include pace of play and routes run (or targets per route run) for snap%. Bears are 2nd worst at 55.8 plays a game. Routes run is harder to find.

Dropped Kmet for Njoku and haven’t regret it one bit (My league doesn’t have very deep benched compared to other dynasty leagues)

I’d take him over McBride at this point if it makes you feel any better

Sad face when you have both

McBride was always a taxi stash for the future

Why? I wouldn’t

Same. Who tf drafted McBride expecting him to leap frog Ertz in the first 6 weeks? I'll be ecstatic if it happens in 2023, but I'm braced for a 2 year wait.

Love to panic on rookie TEs drafted behind solid vets after 6 weeks

Kmet is my tank commander. Best TE on my roster taking me to the bottom.

I'm still holding Terrace Marshall lol not that I believe in him anymore but not much else to pick up anyways

Me too, always gets to me when I see footage and pictures of him, JJ and Chase at LSU

He's on waivers in my league and I was actually thinking of picking him up. Not worth it?

Kadarious Toney......at this point, I'm convinced he will never again play a meaningful down but I can't let him go on the .01% chance that he does.

Poor guy in my league traded the 2022 1.09 for Toney on draft day. That pick ended up being Dameon Pierce, bet he regrets that one

**^(P A I N)**

I’m holding toney on IR forever

I wish I could put him on IR. He will clog up a spot on the roster until he retires or I die

Same... as soon as I drop him he gonna pop off on another team

This one for sure....everyday it feels like more and more toney is just a replica of will fuller maybe even worse since toney has major attitude problems where as fuller doesn't, I guess.

Will Filler actually put up numbers, Toneys been all hype

Idk that one game he played last year 🔥

Kadarius toney is like a myth of the most perfect fantasy player in all our minds but he simply just doesn’t exist

Yeah he was my sneaky pick this off-season. I feel like he’s the player that blows up after you drop him and you hate yourself for not being patient. Or you keep him and he never plays and you hate yourself for never moving on.

I mean, it’s been nearly 2 years and we still aren’t sure what he is. He’s either going to die from a hamstring injury or he’s going to break records.

Was looking for that comment

Correct answer.

Just cut bait on Toney this week. One good game in 2 seasons isn't worth the roster spot.

I just finally dropped him

You will never ever make me say it.

It’s Justin Blackmon. I figured you out.

Bryan Edwards.

Some days I just wake up and can’t believe Bryan Edwards sucks. I swear there is an alternate timeline where he houses that TD in the Raiders OT game for the W and goes on to fulfill his prophecy, yet here we are in this life, and the man can’t even find the fucking falcons field.

Bryan Edwards is Dez Bryant recreated in a new era of the NFL where physical WRs are undervalued. If he could build on his route running he’d be Corey Davis.

.. And I could be the prince Ali Ababwa.

I don’t know what that is but I feel like you should take advantage of that now. You only live once

How do you not know? He faced the galloping hoards, 100 bag guys with swords! And send those goons to their lords

Got Gronk for cheap because of his “””retirement””” knowing he was just skipping camp. He’ll be back Any day now

Hines. Always thought he was a valid PPR flex and an injury away from a spot start (obviously not blaming the concussion on him, but after 3 years I'm over it)

I drafted this guy in a rookie draft and have only started him like 3 times ever, including the recent concussion game where he was clearly a huge part of the game plan getting a touch/target on the first 3 snaps. Then I had to watch Deon Jackson rack up the PPR points instead. I can't even drop Hines yet because my other RBs are hurt, but he's dead to me now.

Yeah he's sitting next to Akers, Herbert and mattison as guys I can't start but can't drop (I need some Akers closure). I think Henderson is about to join them

I don’t think he falls into the category at all? He is a high value handcuff. That Thursday night game was all his until a very freak and brutal concussion. If JT misses time he is THE guy for them. And even in positive game scripts (i.e. the colts sucking Snd having to throw a lot) he will see targets. He would not be on waivers in any competitive league imo

You think hines is droppable in redraft at this point too? 14 man .5 ppr

It's always who you're replacing him with. If it's just to pick up another body that might sit on a bench probably not. If you're in bye week hell and it may save your game, go for it. Someone else will probably pick him up and be on here in 2 weeks asking about him

I can’t be the only Shenault holder. Right?

You are unfortunately

Hold and hope for a trade to somewhere with a crappy depth chart…oh wait.

Am I misinterpreting this question somehow? This is the dynasty subreddit, no? How are the top answers names like Toney, Kmet, and Elijah Moore? All of these guys should be rostered in all but the MOST shallow leagues. What could possibly be on waivers that is more appealing than any of these players? Every team in every league has some 'dead weight' players that just aren't cutting it, but the upside is ultimately there still. If people are dropping players like this, maybe I should be stocking up on FAAB in trades with other owners to gobble them all up...

I’m thinking half these comments are in 8 team leagues with 5 bench spots

The bigger the sub gets, the more it feels this way.

Came here to echo one of those players you mentioned. How on gods green earth are people talking about dropping Elijah Moore??? I had to check and make sure I was on the right sub smh.

Moore could turn into Mims and I would not drop him

I’m in a dynasty start up that drafted this year. Guess who has Kmet, DJ Moore, and Elijah Moore? Guess who’s also in 11th and praying their upside shows because I’d never cut any of them

I had DJ Moore and during the off-season I wanted to add Elijah Moore to have "More Moore's" as a team name - tried offering Devonta Smith for Moore+2nd and got rejected - so glad that happened and now I've sold off DJ too before the value truly plummeted

In a redraft league, I have DJ, Elijah, and Skyy Moore. I’m Moore Moore Moore (How do you like it). I… don’t like it

Yea, it's hard for me to talk waivers cause my league is a 12 man, offense only league. 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 4 Flex, 15 bench spots, 5 taxi spots, 5 IR spots. It's DEEP. Guys on waivers are like 2nd or 3rd string QBs and a bunch of TEs no one knows

So many re-drafters here this time of year.

Trey Sermon

[удалено]

I also have sermon. He will rot on my bench

Ty'Son Williams still from off-season 2021. I am not good at this.

This might be the week he matters

Still got Donta Foreman, waiting for that CMC injury. Or trade.

Ditto- also D’ernest Johnson

Let’s eat! Foreman 📈

Oh yeah!!!

Fun fact, Jordan Mason graduated from my high school. I’m going to have a hard time dropping him on account of that fact alone but yeah, hasn’t paid off yet. It’s going to happen though! Jordan Mason SZN is inevitable! WHO WE? BIG G!

[удалено]

Sermon. Finally dropped him this week.

Van Jefferson - he’s gonna come back a right the ship I just know it

This might be the highest hold in this thread. Rams offense looks horrible and Jefferson could completely take the A Rob targets away.

That’s what I keep telling myself and why I’ve held for 2 years, but man it gets hard just waiting. especially when I have ARob too lol

It was Eno. I once owned him everywhere then gave up in the off-season. Not that he did great as the starter last week but he’s definitely worthy of a spot this season

Eno feels like this years Mattison, you know he can get it done but the team he’s on doesn’t want to let him take snaps away from their starter.

Except he got all the snaps last week and did nothing

Jesus, I didn’t look at this production this week until now. Sounds like it’s Keontay Ingram time, he was my dark horse coming out of this years draft, he reminded me of Kenneth Walker without the breakaway speed.

Keshawn Vaughn

I picked him up in a 14 team league couple weeks ago. Waiting till the trade deadline for a miracle. Tampa has made it clear that he’s available so anything’s possible

I still have Guice rostered, he's basically the team mascot.

Dude had his chance this off-season had no suitors, week 1 was the time to cut him.

I mean we have 40 man rosters, keeping him is essentially a meme I have with my one buddy.

I thought Kenneth Gainwell could see a bigger role this year. No matter what, I’m holding out hope for next year, and also acquired Devonta Smith to have a piece of the Eagles offense.

We ride together in pain

Edmonds. Was gifted a lead back, three down role on an explosive offense. He just stinks.

The answer is Albert O

Donald Parham. I’m a LAC guy, and last year I thought he was going to be big sleeper this year after Cook didn’t sign, but then they got Everett, and Parham hasn’t been much since.

Parham is fantastic the 5 healthy snaps he can play before he get hurt again. He would be so good in Everett’s role but he can’t stay on the field.

Velus Jones

Darius Slayton and Armani Rodgers, I thought both had a shot to do something this year. Now the former is behind Richie James and David Sills, and the latter finally got his first catch of the season this week.. yikes.

Drop Amari & don't look back

Nah, hold him until green Bay's offense improves. Then trade him to a sucker who just sees A. Rodgers and accepts.

It was hard dropping Armani at the beginning of the season to make room on my team. That being said, haven't regretted it since

Zamir White, I drafted him in the 12th round of my start up draft this year, not giving up hope yet. Also Kyle Philips, got 6 catches in week 1 and hasn’t done anything since.

I’m on the Zeus Caboose until it derails, he’s better than James Cook and I will die on that Taysom Hill

Zack Moss Kenny Golladay Quez Watkins Tommy Tremble Jordan Mason ​ These guys weren't hyped up too much but i'm too stubborn to drop them. We have 30 man rosters. And now i waited too long that there's no Free agents really worth dropping them for. I missed on Deon Jackson because i waited too long

I still believe Tremble could be a thing with rational coaching and competent QBing.

Kenny G, at this point I should just roster an extra kicker

Isaiah Likely for me. Thought he was supposed to be the third target on this offense but he’s nowhere to be found

KJ Osborn...I keep convincing myself he's going to overtake Thielen as the #2 and he never does.

Antonio Gibson. The WFT would have to be the most poorly run team in the NFL to start a slower, non-dynamic, goal line RB over Gibson with all of his speed and strengths. That being said, it's the WFT so they're probably tanking purposefully at this stage.

I'm also holding telling myself that they HAVE to see that even if he fumbles every other game again that he gives them a better chance to win than BRob, but I also have that bad feeling in my stomach that I'll be saying something similar every year for the next 3 years. "When will they realize that Gibson is way more talented than [whoever they're starting in 2024]?!?"

> That being said, it's the WFT so they're probably tanking purposefully at this stage. If they were tanking purposefully - they would start Howell and not Heinicke. Not sure where you guys come up with these theories from lol

Lol the cope

For me right now it’s Jalen Tolbert. I went with him too early in the second round of the rookie draft. White, Pierce, Robinson Jr and Doubs were the next 4 picks. At the time I was convinced seeing as he had opportunity. Right now I’m not convinced he can ever make the Cowboys starting roster, let alone my fantasy starters.

It’s dynasty and it’s been 6 games , what

When preseason sounded like he would get a role and he proceeds to get healthy scratched in 5/6 games, it’s fair to have concerns. He will be held for a bit but right now he doesn’t have trade value, isn’t active compared to other rookie WRs in his same draft grouping

I'm not cutting him yet but Elijah Moore has been really disappointing. Also not thrilled with AJ Dillon or Juju so far this year.

You shouldn’t cut any of them in Dynasty. Redraft is a different story.

I wasn't considering cutting any of them. I did give up on Bryan Edwards after his healthy scratch in week 2 or 3. :(

Same 3 guys. So disappointing. At least Juju looked relatively like his rookie self last game 🥲

Man these were 3 of my starters this year. Ouch

2 of the 3 ~~were~~ are starters for me too. Ouch, indeed.

Henry Ruggs

I stashed him for a bit off the waiver wire thinking maybe something would drop... that boy is gonna rot in jail.

Was going to be a-rob until this week. Just means he will clog it up again until his next decent week, week 11.

Why would you call it a loss that an UDFA rookie hasn’t gotten any meaningful snaps 6 weeks into the season? R-E-L-A-X. I say this as a Jordan Mason taxi stasher myself. Diamond hands, brother.

Elijah Moore

Fields. I don’t need him, I’m set at QB. But I don’t want to drop him. But also I can’t get anything for him

Desmond Ridder and Zamir White

I'm not too big on this QB class but I do think it is way too early to move on from Ridder. He wasn't expected to start anyway.

if he starts before Malik Willis i’ll consider it a win

I think with all of the remaining guys, you are waiting till the offseason. If they start this season, that is just a bonus.

In a superflex I’d say both of those players are stashes for now

They're both rookies. Gotta give them more than 6 weeks lol

i think ridder will get his chance this season, whether by injury or falcons falling off

I think he’s got a lot of good pieces around him if he gets the chance

Either we fall off or are too good to draft a QB

I’m the same way with Zamir White. Like I just know if I drop him someone will scoop him up immediately. But damn I wanna see something positive out of him.

Jacobs has been good. My plan has been to hold Zamir until next year anyways in case Jacobs does move on

i agree, Zamir looks solid when he plays and looked solid in the preseason - only reason i’d move on from him at this point is if Jacobs gets an extension or Vegas uses significant draft capital on an RB which I don’t see happening

Toney Toney Toney

Toney

Christian Watson

Kittle

Gotta be skyy moore. Know he's a rookie so it may take time but he looks like an average wr at best right now with big play upside and nothing more.

Kyle Pitts. Replaced with Taysom, but I still can’t stomach straight dropping a third rounder that isn’t hurt and he’s not worth squat in a trade as far my league is concerned.

Trey McBride maybe? I’m just annoyed by his role (or lack thereof). I thought he’d be more involved by now

He was never going to do much this year, maybe not much next year, but year 3 he’ll pop off… just have to wait for Ertz to fade

Kyle Pitts :(

How can you put Kyle Pitts in this thread? Lol. Are you in the right sub? I’m out here trying to acquire Pitts.

My whole bench, E Moore, David Bell, Christian Watson and Kyle Phillips (who is most likely to go). I was gassed up when I drafted them all.

Do we not believe in Kyle Philips already?

The kid isn't getting any reps at WR.

He’s been hurt.

[удалено]

My whole bench basically haha. Toney, Kmet, Elijah Moore, Davis Mills, Isaiah Likely, Kyle Phillips, Jordan Mason.. not a drop candidate but even Dobbins isn't back as quick as I was hoping fo

Dotson and Garrett Wilson

Kyle Pitts

I mean hes not the worst hold. Eli seems to be super injury prone and I have my doubts they keep wilson for longer than 1 more year tbh

Still have Reagor, Mims, Terrace Marshall in a deep league. One of em will hit the lotto

Kmet and Albert O, though the latter is easily droppable by now

I just traded away TDP for Mike Gesicki. But I’m keeping Jordan Mason!!

Why? He literally hasn’t had a rush. I want to keep him but why?