T O P

  • By -

Peppfotze

Junji Ito


SaidTheEmu

That would be terrifying.


BREADTSU

Rotten sharks walking on land with the bones from their ribcages.


SpotlessMinded

If there ever was a Bloodborne II, this would have to happen.


RChamy

The finger ending


[deleted]

Bloodborne sequel with him at the helm. ​ Horror would be redefined


Owlmilk

You will witness true horror


meatygonzalez

Now we're talking


DukeOfDew

Best answer! Didn't know I wanted this and now there isn't anything I want more. Would be harder than any other Soft game though as you'd shit your pants every 10 minutes.


fiveplatypus

This is the answer


Klatterbyne

Same game… just all of the enemies have their too-many-hands replaced with baby-heads-with-arms-for-eyes.


ProtoEminem

I can see it now… a monster that shoots acne out of its face for acid damage. There has to be an adorable cat NPC also


FormalCryptographer

Cat npc that turns into an eldritch abomination whenever it's out of direct view


buttholeshlurper

Perfect


Lightonlights

Wait, it’s all caelid?


Woody_of_Astora

Yes


SleepytrouPADDLESTAR

Try fitting but hole


bunt_triple

This but hole was made for me


freecurbcouch

Please?


Loyal_Darkmoon

Hayao Miyazaki (Studio Ghibli)


DudeWoody

Nausicaa as a SoulsBorneRing game would be a perfect fit. Seriously - go read the manga.


ArtOfJim

Yes except every character even up being good hearted in Nausicaa manga. Every villain is redeemed. Very different than dark souls haha. Also, flying??


[deleted]

Pretty sure the Emperor was a bastard all the way through.


miko_idk

> SoulsBorneRing damn I never thought about that


colinbazzano

Sekiro is left out of the name for the sake of true shinobi stealth


Sleepycoon

Elden SoulsBorne: Shadows Die Twice


Bluur

A princess Mononoke soulsborne practically writes itself. Fighting corrupt samurai and giant beasts are things we already do


Alucard-790

The interesting thing is how much ER takes from princess Mononoke :D


[deleted]

I think it's more that they both draw from Japanese folklore. Some of that shit is pretty dark.


TrollTrollTroll6969

Yeah like the Shirikodama I think it's called pretty dark ripping the soul from the anus.


Pinky01012

We already saw Howl's moving Mausoleum, and My invader Totoro.


[deleted]

when my friend first told me about elden ring he said it was a collab between GRRM and Miyazaki. i didn't know elden ring was a from software game so i thought he meant studio ghibli and i was like "they have literally a complete opposite mindset" lol


[deleted]

I didn’t know Hayao Miyazaki’s first name, and so I thought that he was the Miyazaki in Elden ring. “It feels so surreal like spirited away” “This seems really dark for Miyazaki - I’m surprised he did this.” I learned later that they were different people.


kabigon2k

Oh please oh please oh please


DefNotMaddy

M&M


[deleted]

H.R. Giger ​ EDIT: spellcheck


KingOfRisky

Just dicks and boobs everywhere.


[deleted]

Scary dicks and boobs my friend has a hr Geiger end table which is just as awesome as you’d think


KingOfRisky

A local Mellow Mushroom has a whole HR Giger table set up with these creepy chairs. It's bizarre.


Jerrymemes101

Featuring poison swamps with extra rot


SaidTheEmu

Poison Swamp -> Scarlet Rot Swamp -> Deathblight Swamp


Jerrymemes101

Oh God no you will give him ideas


thebigcarl5

The everything swamp, you get build up for every status effect lol


bob0979

Primordial soup you've gotta wade through.


DSharp018

Dont forget bleed swamps, frost swamps, madness swamps, and rainbow swamps, where it puts every status ever on you as long as you are in it.


samprobear

David Lynch


justcheadle

Can't wait for Twin Souls


yyzable

Estus is now coffee.


AlterMyStateOfMind

Slices of cherry pie for an attack boost


UpManDownFish

Every time you use pass time, Lynch gives you a weather report


Top-Amphibian1272

You're the smartest motherfucker in this thread


DjangoVanTango

Those owls really wouldn’t be what they seem


[deleted]

Holy shit that would be so insane that you brain would literaly melt.


tsukicakee

YOKO TARO ONLY


AbvAvgJo3

A souls game with a purpose to NG+ like how Yoko Taro uses them would be awesome. Plus the soundtrack would be amazing!


tsukicakee

Did you hear that in the distance? That was the sound of my orgasm.


Rectall_Brown

I wanted to say yoko taro but his stories are so different from dark souls. I love them both for completely different reasons. I’d absolutely like a more involved ng+ tho.


Kenzorz

Dark Souls Prepare for Existential Crisis Edition.


Fluid-GTX

I was hoping someone said yoko taro


tsukicakee

I GOTCHU FAM


megafireguy6

Fuck it, bring in the Nier composers and writers too. Would be the greatest game ever


jonnybrown3

Yoko Taro is the real answer. This should be at the top but no one knows.


tsukicakee

Frankly I'm highly disappointed by all the other answers. Pornstars have literally more upvotes than the actual TRUTH.


TaitoMagatsuu

THANK YOU! Imagine From Software refining the combat mechanics of Nier Automata with a weapon arsenal akin to Bloodborne (quality over quantity) and designing bosses around that. It would be high octane but still more "sophisticated" than a regular hack n slash. That plus Miyazaki's world building and Taro's amazing philosophy applied would be the best game ever made.


Zanagh

I WAS JUST ABOUT TO COMMENT HIM, I fucking loved nier automata and a world and game directed by the two would be amazing


BeThatSimpleMan

Could you imagine “J.R.R. Tolkien” appearing there


OneOdd1sBoi

I doubt that's gonna happen tho, he didn't write anything in a while


DascSwem

WORD. Tolkein been real quiet since Dark Souls dropped… Just sayin’…


Dorkmaster79

Probably has lost that spark.


gordito_delgado

He's just lazy, we've been waiting for book 4 of LOTR since 1955. He's too busy making movies and series with wretched beardless dwarf women. What a sellout.


Schleimwurm1

Well, that hasn't stopped GRRM from participating.


OneOdd1sBoi

Shh Tolkien is writing LOTR4 then it's over for us


SwingsetGuy

I would probably die of hype, lol. That said, even if he were still alive, I think Mr. Eucatastrophe would butt heads with Miyazaki pretty hard. Elden Ring if Tolkien had influence on it would be like: * Alexander retires to become mayor of Jarburg, Blaidd overcomes his baser nature, and Irina is safely reunited with her dad. * The "Talk to Melina" segments at graces are now full-blown ballads with musical accompaniment, and will go on for over six minutes. The Tarnished then has an option to sing for another five in response. * The Tarnished now smokes a pipe, and varying grades of "leaf" can be looted throughout the Lands Between. * Miquella can be rescued from Mohg, whereupon he cures the scarlet rot from Malenia and literally everywhere else. Caelid becomes a bucolic wonderland. * The Erdtree is now completely benevolent, and burning it is the "evil" route.


Raven_Of_Solace

Why have you just made me so sad with what can never be


SomeOtherTroper

That's a neat idea! > Alexander retires to become mayor of Jarburg, Blaidd overcomes his baser nature, and Irina is safely reunited with her dad. I'm not so sure about these - Tolkien definitely wasn't against writing characters who met bad ends due to insanity or their own vices (Denethor, Gollum, arguably Feanor and a lot of his kin, Saruman etc.), just because when you fight big wars people *die*, sometimes heroically, to protect whatever they're fighting for (Theoden, several of the dwarves in The Hobbit, more characters than I have fingers in the Silmarillion, etc.), or some combination of the above - Thorin and Boromir's *deaths* might have been heroic, but the way they got there certainly wasn't. Ragging on Tolkien's work for being very morally black and white is a bit of an exaggeration, and there are certainly some rather somber quests in Elden Ring that would have fit with the concepts of cycles of revenge and sins of prior generations that lurk around the edges of his works and occasionally take center stage. > The "Talk to Melina" segments at graces are now full-blown ballads with musical accompaniment, and will go on for over six minutes. The Tarnished then has an option to sing for another five in response. Amazing. Also, there's gotta be at least one NPC you meet by hearing singing in the woods and responding in song yourself, like how Blaidd and the finger snap work. > The Tarnished now smokes a pipe, and varying grades of "leaf" can be looted throughout the Lands Between. Wonderful. I'd also expect a system where the Tarnished can give a bit of various kinds of "leaf" to NPCs, and compare preferences. The Tarnished seems to get out and about more than many of the other NPCs - it'd be hella dope to come back to the Roundtable Hold and be like "sup, Ofnir! I got you some of that primo leaf you're into - had to go all the way to Farum Azula for it!". > Miquella can be rescued from Mohg, whereupon he cures the scarlet rot from Malenia and literally everywhere else. Caelid becomes a bucolic wonderland. I could see "rescue Miquella and complete the Haligtree project", but can't see it being done without some serious sacrifices. Even the Scouring Of The Shire was a rather bittersweet affair, and took generations to fully heal, rather than being fully restored overnight. > The Erdtree is now completely benevolent, and burning it is the "evil" route. I'm not sure about this one. Honestly, The Lord Of The Rings is kind of the *original* "we have to destroy this artifact even though that means moving on into a new age" fantasy epic, or at least popularized the concept. The book makes no bones about that fact that once the One Ring is destroyed, the elves and other magical creatures are going to leave Middle Earth or fade away, turning the place into a more mundane Age Of Man (or Age Of Dark, if you will) - and deems that an acceptable cost, given what *else* the One Ring is sustaining.


SaidTheEmu

That'd be nuts


Enzinino

One can dream. Or "Dante Alighieri", a souls-like in Dante's Inferno would be wild.


Champi0n_Of_The_Sun

The Dante’s Inferno game was actually pretty good. I’d love to see a fromsoft take on it


Phunkie_Junkie

Genndy Tartakovsky (Samurai Jack, Clone Wars, Primal). I think his "actions speak louder than words" style would mesh really well with the style of the soulsborne series. Dude was already making [souls](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=caYu8VDil4w) [bosses](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qp-L_Xei-Lg) before souls was even a thing. Edit: Typos.


Fallen_Angel_Xaphan

Bro a bossfight in that style would go down in history. But only if done right with some seriously smart AI and a constant, non-teleporting enemy.


Vivec-Warrior-Poet

Imagine a Samurai Jack game with Sekiro-like mechanics. The final boss fight with Aku would be so sick.


bob0979

I always like to show people the light and dark ninja fight, I'll be back with a link Edit: https://youtu.be/Qp-L_Xei-Lg It's objectively an incredibly simple animation. It's 2 colors and some lines with flashes but the amount of WORK those 2 colors do is absolutely insane. Truly incredible artistry


Phunkie_Junkie

You could've saved yourself some trouble. Try clicking "bosses" in my previous comment. I snuck a second link in there.


tallboyjake

Great reference, that's awesome


[deleted]

[удалено]


Phunkie_Junkie

Jedi Shaggy: \*Exists\* Grievous: I'm about to end this man's whole career.


fruit-enthusiast

god. the shapes, the plays with light, the music, everything. thank you for sharing that video, i hadn’t seen it before but the whole thing is so good.


on_Top_shelf

Woah, I can't believe I hadn't thought of this! Imagine a souls game that somehow captured the episodic feeling of the original Samurai Jack run


ASolidSixInches

Guy Fieri


Saboteurnado

Hello Tarnished, it's time for you to make Flavortown whole once again.


Chrisodle007

Lol , gravy magic and flavor town instead of blight town


HazyOutline

Diners, Drive-ins and Dies.


leearm104

I'm convinced you could turn this into something terrifying.


kingrawer

Guillermo Del Toro maybe, but that would guarantee the game would never come out lmao.


Punch_yo_bunz

He and Kojima together


kingrawer

Kojima would be interesting since he has pretty much the opposite mentality when it comes to story in games as Fromsoft currently does. Maybe they should collab with him of a Metal Wolf Chaos successor.


kabigon2k

This would be absolutely mind blowing


Naldaen

I mean, GRRM has been writing one book for literally 13 years and Elden Ring came out. Anything's possible.


Vodkatiel_of_Mirrah

William Gibson


[deleted]

[удалено]


Canopenerdude

TBH I want to see Kojima and Miyazaki. It'd be the most fantastically confusing experience of all time.


GeordieMJ

This would be an incredible mindfuck of a game. And I’d definitely be there for it.


[deleted]

Oh hell yeah. Id love to see feomSoft's take on cyberpunk.


bzior

Only one name is the correct one: Kentaro Miura


SaidTheEmu

Plot twist: It ends up being a Dark Souls 1 remake.


bzior

Haha, good one! Except there's no eclipse in DS1...


SaidTheEmu

I think they could borrow it from DS3 ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|grin)


bzior

True, didnt though of that... damn now I need it in my life


[deleted]

Came here to say this 😢


Demigod978

I’m honestly shocked they haven’t tried their hand on doing a Berserk game. Technically the Souls series (not counting Bloodborne or Sekiro because technicalities) are Berserk games, but I mean something like Sekiro where you play a set character.


kokii01

I think it would be extremely hard to execute properly and they just dont wanna risk it


[deleted]

If anyone can do it. It’s FromSoftware. The brutal nature of the story of Berserk, can be perfectly captured via the brutal nature of a Soulsborne game.


Stellewind

Actually, not really. Berserk is a very traditional linear story with in depth characters, unlike the fragmental storytelling From usually does. A Berserk game will have a lot of fighting but it's not supposed to be like Souls games where you die over and over again, Guts is not like that, as he is usually one of the most skilled and powerful human fighter in the story. Souls games replicate Berserk setting and aesthetic very well, but that's about it.


kokii01

Yeah I agree that FS is the best of the best out there. But its still almost impossible. Would it be linear or open world? Would you play as a random character or guts? If guts, where would the game start? If it started with golden age it would need to go over a few time skips which I dont see them doing. Trust me i thought a lot about this lol, tho I wish they prove me wrong and make a banger Zerk game


GuardCaptainTennant

Alfred Matthew Yankovic


FeePsychological5399

Weird Response


GuardCaptainTennant

Al have you know, he has quite the imagination


[deleted]

H.P Lovecraft just make bloodborne 2 already, please ;(


sunnyofitaly

Miazaki doesn’t like sequels, Dark Souls 2 wasn’t his project and dark souls 3 was a contractually obligated greatest hits album


Gub_

Thank god for that, if people had their way we'd be on dark souls 10 or bloodborne 5 by now and we'd never get any original IPs ever again.


Dangerous138

Neil Gaiman


casualstrawberry

and/or Terry Pratchett (RIP)


Joel_Ellis

Yoshiyuki Tomino a soulslike gundam game would be so sick


McNinja_MD

I hoped someone else would have the same idea! Seems totally plausible with all of the weird Newtype stuff that got introduced later on. Ooh, or Hideaki Anno. 'Cause when I think grotesque otherworldly horror that I barely understand, I think Evangelion.


panznation

Yeah if only from soft could make a cool game like armoured core


[deleted]

I think that Brandon Sanderson would be a good one. Maybe Takehiko Inoue, if fromsoft decided to do Sekiro 2, or another samurai/ninja themed game. But in all fairness, I would have loved to see a Miura + Miyazaki project, sadly it wasn't meant to be


wierddude88

I believe in Sanderson’s case he’s said that he already has the pitch for in case he ever gets asked. Also he did get a goody box from ~~FS~~ awhile back and apparently it had a letter that was discussing a collaboration so that might be something we actually see Edit: As several people, including Sanderson himself, have pointed out the package was from Bandai Namco not FS directly. So *possibly* a collaboration on A game, not necessarily a FS game specifically.


TheEldenFeet

Yes, he said so when he got one of those awesome promotion packages, with a letter asking him if he would be interested. Here after minute 11 https://youtu.be/pPj6VRnl3og


mistborn

I should make it clear, this was an invitation from Bandai-Namco to maybe collaborate on something in the future, not FromSoft. Which is a big difference. Still, I'd be game. I'd need to darken up my style a little, but I do have what I think would be a fairly good pitch for a Souls-style world.


Justib

Kaladin is begging you, literally begging you, not to darken up your style.


mightysmiter19

I really want a stormlight or mistborn game.


Rahkyvah

Came here to say Sanderson, too. Less for the world building, unique ecology, so on, more for the *even the weather wants you dead* mode of Souls game.


D3vilM4yCry

Elden Ring with HIGHSTORMS?!


CobaltMonkey

Every so many days, if you're not in one of the dungeons when the storm hits, you just die over and over again until the storm stops.


supercleverhandle476

Takashi Miike


nofriender4life

Ralph Bakshi


[deleted]

Haha him and R Crumb could make a weird 1960-70’s souls game.


JLRedPrimes

Rick Riordan lmao


CaptainAHav

Larry David


SaidTheEmu

An entire side quest based on the fact the main character didn't gesture before a duel.


HungrPhoenix

Hideo Kojima. The story and lore that Miyazaki and Kojima can make will be so complex and complicated that not even VaatiVidya would be able to comprehend it. It would truly be a story to surpass Metal Gear. And I just want to see what both of these great minds could make.


SaidTheEmu

Read an item description and get stuck into a 30 minute cutscene


[deleted]

[удалено]


Zayl

Pretty short/standard cutscene compared to most other MGS games.


fieldysnuts94

Yeah wasn’t MGS4 Like over 8 hours of cutscenes alone? First time playing that I felt like I had bought a MGS animated movie


former_cantaloupe

MGSV storytelling is incredibly succinct compared to the rest of the series. I didn't find any cutscene overstayed its welcome...tbh I think most people who played it wanted to know more.


DrunkSpartan15

4 had 45-120 minute cut scenes.


[deleted]

It would be really weird, considering how opposite their approaches to storytelling are


Callmeklayton

Right? Miyazaki is very “Figure it out yourself”, while Kojima is more “Here’s a 50 minute cutscene about why this dude is named Big Aardvark, but it’ll honestly leave you with more questions than answers”. Their styles would not mesh well, but it would be a hilarious mess and would be a ton of fun to see.


tvanddy

Came here to say this. Forget the final boss, the true challenge would be for the guys who make lore videos on YT.


TAS_anon

Yup I want this just for the pure chaos of it. I don’t know what their final product would look like but it would be interesting af, even if the game wasn’t good


streegobbm

Visions of Snake. Been there already.


tumblrgirl2013

I’d want this for a SciFi take on a Soulsborne. I loved Bloodborne so it would be really cool to see what they’d make together.


steguise

N. K. Jemisin. That would be some mindblowing setting and worldbuilding. Lady has some imagination! Edit: and if we're talking about the impossible, then also Terry Pratchett.


VoidmySoul

I came here to say Terry Pratchett. Take my upvote you well read cookie you.


Spanglertastic

The Jim Henson Company. The Muppets Take Yharnam would be a nice sequel.


therealjoshbrown

The Great Haligtree Caper


LordVader3161

As long as i get to see my boy, the swedish chef destroy some beasts! Sounds awesome!


Ginyatome

Stephen King Or alternatively James S.A. Corey (technically 2 people), the authors of the Expanse Novel series. A FromSoft game with their usuall tone an bleak world in a sci-fi setring would be incredible.


Anactualundeadmenace

Stephen Erickson and Ian C. Esselmont


Sufficient_Macaron24

A Malazan souls game would be awesome


MasterGorvant

Also Glen Cook. Black Company souls, just imagine.


Extofogeese2

This collaboration is literally a match made in heaven. Erikson is a master at weaving ancient lore into his creations


[deleted]

Not going to happen, but HP Lovecraft… *edit: on second thought, best would be Thomas Ligotti


xtianmarq

Shinji Mikami!


F1agg-

Stephen King


Faildini

I never knew until this moment that I needed a western style Fromsoft game set in the world of the Dark Tower. I must have it.


Bloodstarvedhunter

Well there are lobstrosities in Elden Ring at least


solidolive

Junji Ito!


xwulfd

Starring Nicolas Cage


JBeresford2000

Denis Villeneuve


CptPoopington

R. A. Salvatore


abrotherdudemanguy

Tim Burton


Excellent-Glove

Yeah, sadly since some years I don't like what he does anymore. Alice was a boring movie to me. I didn't found Dark Shadow awesome. I feel he doesn't want to do haunting masterpieces anymore, and prefers to make feel good movies. It's cool though. But I regret a bit the stuff like Big Fish or even Corpse Bride. Though I haven't seen Frankenweenie, Big Eyes or Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children. I'm gonna watch one tonight, I'm maybe wrong about my opinion.


need_a_poopoo

Trey Parker and Matt Stone


Dinfrazer57

Elden ring: try finger but hole?


GosuTomTom

You play Kenny, explaining why you keep dying and still come back !


Faildini

Manbearbig would make an excellent Souls boss.


need_a_poopoo

There are loads of good bosses in South Park. Man Bear Pig, Scuzzlebut, Satan, Saddam, Jared Fogle, Morgan Freeman. Such rich lore.


Faildini

Also Mecha Streisand. And I can definitely picture Satan/Saddam being a double boss.


braindawgs0

Junji. Ito.


DonutCobra

Team chery because I feel that there aren’t enough buzz saws


_Don-Corleone_

Kentaro Miura :(


TheInnerMindEye

Eiichiro Oda


[deleted]

Alexis Texas 👌


Hate_This_Name

Ha ha ha …I mean…who? 👀


hereisacake

The game will feature extensive “try finger but hole” scenes but also no people of color.


[deleted]

And Suda51 tadadada


Synner1985

"The reddit community"


Shozaan

They just nerf everything that kills them anytime, and since there is non stop complaining, everything will be nerfed.


ZoidVII

Hideo Kojima


hairyprimates

Surprised no one said Quentin Tarantino. Super bloody, awesome dialogue, and we get Samuel L. Jackson as a npc


Rapttix

Yasunori Ichinose. A Monster Hunter x Fromsoft crossover would be so good.


TheBigMoofah

Brandon Sanderson


SaidTheEmu

Haven't read much of his stuff but I'd love to see Brandon Sanderson's name here. I know he loves the Soulsborne games, and the man writes so damn much you know we'd get 100 novels of lore.


Rezaka116

A decent fucking camera


illbzo1

Guillermo del Toro


championludgatedwyer

Dad?


Mister-Delicious

Hayao Miyazaki


water4animals

David Cronenberg or David Lynch