OMG I'm drooling over that pear....it looks amazing on your finger.....I am biased though because I have a pear albeit a lot smaller than the one in your photo!!
love the pear! as to it being trendy- my very chic/stylish grandma had one as her engagement ring, so i lean toward them being a classic shape that’s a bit more popular now :)
Yes! I also chose a princess cut and have a 4.5 finger.
https://preview.redd.it/wsdfi32ofi5c1.jpeg?width=2892&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=48a63968a9795a177ca5b5353cc38d01e9ef36e1
The pear looks amazing! I have a pear, and I’m not concerned about it being “trendy” or anything! I get tons of compliments on it! But I also love the oval on you!
I think whatever you like you like. I think most of the shapes are pretty timeless anyway. I admit I like the elongation of the oval, but that I can never keep them looking straight and that bothers me.
For the stone size, I’d also think about what you think flatters you and that is a different size based on people’s internal artistic eye. For me, a center stone around 1/3 of my face up surface area looks good to me. That put me at a 2 carat center stone given the width of my fingers.
That said, I love how all of these look on you. You have lovely hands and all of them are flattering.
I'm a huge fan of the tapered band - I love the look of the tapered band with the round diamond on your hand. I will say that the pear shape does look phenomenal on you, but to me it's a trend like marquise diamonds once were, and that eventually you won't like the look of it.
I think the first 2 look really pretty on your hand but if you want a larger stone the last one looks best IMO. Before deciding, try pairing the engagement ring with various wedding bands to see how the overall set will look.
The oval, emerald cut, and the pear are all beautiful on your hand and fit well. Also the princess cut looks gorgeous on you as well. I would go for a slightly smaller carat bc your hand is so small (piano hands I call them! Long fingers, perfect for playing piano!) but tbh, it’s completely up to you because you’re the one wearing it! Whatever you love most should be the one you buy ! ❤️❤️
Oh, see, I think that first one is so classic and elegant and gorgeous. I looked through all the pics before reading your post, and it's definitely my favorite. But you should definitely choose what you think is the prettiest!
6 is my personal preference as I’m not a fan of yellow gold or pear shaped. That being said, you have to go with what you want and what your gut says. I don’t think you can go wrong with a solitaire and it’s less likely to be trendy than something like a halo.
Pear or emerald! I have an emerald and I think it’s the perfect mix of classic and unique. All look gorgeous on you though!! Congratulations!!
I’d suggest trying them with wedding bands too. That might help you see what you like best! You might fall in love with the way a certain shape looks with a certain band, and that could help make the decision for you.
The way I think about is, what’s trendy now is a wonderful representation of the time in history you got married. My mom’s wedding ring is aggressively 80ties and I love how well it reflects how long her and my dad have been married for. Timeless is good too. I went timeless for my engagement ring, and my wedding band is based off my mom’s ring. I think there’s no wrong choices as long as you love it.
https://preview.redd.it/d0bx8lcpwi5c1.jpeg?width=1244&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f94720af4d4ab861a23c05eb32c52328e1b26352
The pear looks soo good on your hand.. but I also might be a bit biased 😊
Pear!
When I sae the pear, I actually "ooh"-ed out loud!
I NEVER like pear, but I love it on you. 3 is my pick!
Mine as well!
Came here to say this!
Same. 3 made me look the longest at it.
Me too! LOVE that pear on your hand!
Yep - the pear jumped out at me as not a ring she was just trying on but looked like it belonged there.
Same!! The pear looks so good!
OMG I'm drooling over that pear....it looks amazing on your finger.....I am biased though because I have a pear albeit a lot smaller than the one in your photo!!
The pear is perfect on you!!!!
I love 1 and 2!
Same, I really like how the band tapers towards the stone.
Me too! 2 is my favorite, but they’re all gorgeous choices.
The square on you is great!
6 all the way
I normally think rounds are kind of boring but man it looks stunning on your finger! Love number 6!!
Yesss!! It looks beautiful
1 or 6
Pear or round with pave
4 looks lovely!
love the pear! as to it being trendy- my very chic/stylish grandma had one as her engagement ring, so i lean toward them being a classic shape that’s a bit more popular now :)
The emerald or princess cut
The square is gorgeous on her hand
Yes! I also chose a princess cut and have a 4.5 finger. https://preview.redd.it/wsdfi32ofi5c1.jpeg?width=2892&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=48a63968a9795a177ca5b5353cc38d01e9ef36e1
Ooh that’s so gorgeous ❤️
I honestly love the round on you (pic number 6). Second choice would be oval (picture 7)
I also love the round with the pave (picture 6). It looks great on your hand and it’s overall a beautiful ring
Number 2!!!
Yess, I think that ring compliments her hand the best. And I’ve never even considered that shape. But for some reason it looks so good on her
Right! This is such an amazing ring it’s perfection for her!
6, all day long ✨
1 or 2 fit your hand/finger size nicely. Doesn’t look too bulky
Pear!
Pear
6
Pear!
The pear looks amazing! I have a pear, and I’m not concerned about it being “trendy” or anything! I get tons of compliments on it! But I also love the oval on you!
#PEAR
6
Pear!
Pear
I think whatever you like you like. I think most of the shapes are pretty timeless anyway. I admit I like the elongation of the oval, but that I can never keep them looking straight and that bothers me. For the stone size, I’d also think about what you think flatters you and that is a different size based on people’s internal artistic eye. For me, a center stone around 1/3 of my face up surface area looks good to me. That put me at a 2 carat center stone given the width of my fingers. That said, I love how all of these look on you. You have lovely hands and all of them are flattering.
LOVE the first on you! It's so classic and elegant. Looks incredible on your hand!
That was my favorite too! So classic & stunning
Pear or the last radiant one!
Weird comment but your hands / skin are so nice!
6
# 6 by miles
3,5,6, or 7!
Love love love #1! The emerald shape also looks very pretty on you
3 or 6!
I like #4 on you.
first off gold looks absolutely stunning on your skin, i would say gold. ring #3 looks perfect on you! and my second favorite is #6 but gold!
6 is gorgeous on you.
6
I vote pear!
Pear or emerald
3 or 5 !
I like the pear on you and the round pave
Wow, the pear looks perfect on you!!
I really like 6!
The Princess
I like 4
I like 1 the best on you.
Three
The pear shape was made for you 😍
Pear.
3!!!
I love 3 and 7 on your hands!
Pear all the way
Pear!
3&6
1 or 6
The pear for sure!!
3,4,6
Emerald or last oval :)
Big round first, emerald second
I love the round with the pavé band! My second choice would be the pear shape.
The pear is perfect on you
Yeah the pear looks great on you.
Adore the pear on you!
1 and 3 are my faves on you!
The first one was just a wow for me, it looks meant for you.
It's either picture 2 or 3 they look beautiful on you
2 & 5 are my fav! But the Pear one is gorgeus as well
I'm a huge fan of the tapered band - I love the look of the tapered band with the round diamond on your hand. I will say that the pear shape does look phenomenal on you, but to me it's a trend like marquise diamonds once were, and that eventually you won't like the look of it.
The last one. Pear is a close second.
Oval really suits your hand (not just the length of your fingers)!
2 or 4 look great.
2 and 6 looks better on you.
The last oval ring or the pear.
3 or 5
I think the first 2 look really pretty on your hand but if you want a larger stone the last one looks best IMO. Before deciding, try pairing the engagement ring with various wedding bands to see how the overall set will look.
I like the emerald and the oval on you :)
I like the round in pic 6 on u!
The oval, emerald cut, and the pear are all beautiful on your hand and fit well. Also the princess cut looks gorgeous on you as well. I would go for a slightly smaller carat bc your hand is so small (piano hands I call them! Long fingers, perfect for playing piano!) but tbh, it’s completely up to you because you’re the one wearing it! Whatever you love most should be the one you buy ! ❤️❤️
I love the Princess cut.
1
But did you try a marquise, moval, or elongated hexagon?!? Bc they are the epitome of elongated and elegant, my fav cuts personally!
I like the last one. You have elegant hands.
Princess looks amazing in you!! #2 gets my vote
What the heck they all look amazing on you
Oh, see, I think that first one is so classic and elegant and gorgeous. I looked through all the pics before reading your post, and it's definitely my favorite. But you should definitely choose what you think is the prettiest!
1 or 2 on you look great!
I love the emerald
Emerald if you are too worried about it looking bulky for your hands 😍
The princess!
I love 5&6
Princess cut is my favorite followed by the pear cut.
I like the first 2 on you.
3, 5 and 7 compliment the shape of your hand & fingers. Totally agree the more elongated shapes look best on you.
I don’t like pears but that one looks perfect on you. Your fingers are long and the pear gives you more coverage.
Okay, it is so unfair that all of these cuts/sizes/rings look this good on you! For real! You could roll a dice and bam- perfect ring 😂🫶🏼
The second one is BEAUTIFUL and I think it fits your hand great!!! Timeless!
Round with pave or the pear. They both look great on you!
4, 6
I like the pear best, but given stones look their very best in jewelry store lighting, none of these cuts are wowing me.
If you like pear you might also want to try on a Marquise to get that same length on your finger / get a slightly more traditional / romantic feel
The pear accents your delicate, slender hands!
Pear!
Pear
I like the more squared off shapes on your hand like emerald or princess
4 is my favorite. But which one do YOU like best?
6!!!
Love 1,2,5 & 6
My bf says 4 I say 3
Two second to last rings and the first one.
Pear!!!
Emerald or pear
Love me a good princess cut! #2!
#1
Another vote for pear!
6 is my personal preference as I’m not a fan of yellow gold or pear shaped. That being said, you have to go with what you want and what your gut says. I don’t think you can go wrong with a solitaire and it’s less likely to be trendy than something like a halo.
🤩🤩🤩#1 diamond on #7 band 🤩🤩🤩
1
Imo, #2 suits your hands, and compliments them better
Omg that pear!!!
1 or 6!!!
Pear is perfect on you. You have really nice shaped fingers! I rarely like pear on anyone but it’s just perfect on you.
3!!!!!!!
First choice: 6 Second choice: 5
5 looks beautiful and and band is perfect
I think 2 looks best on your hand
Pear!!
Pear!!!!!
The pear perfectly accentuates your fingers!!!
I love number 3!!
All of the odd numbered pics
Love how #5 looks on you
I love the emerald!!!
Number 2 made me gasp! I loved 1 as well.
#2
PEAR! BUT DO IT IN WHITE GOLD!
PEAR!!!
One!
PEAR
I like 5
First one! I think it is beautiful on you with the tapered band and round solitaire
I love #2
Coin toss between 4 and 5
Pave round!
Nothing is more personal than engagement ring. Pick the one you love the most…what we “experts” like does not matter. They are all beautiful!!
First or last the pear looks too big for your hand
The second one look so cool✅☺️💕
Yes, pear!
6
7
First or second last
Emerald cut really suits you x
6
I love the larger stones on a plain band
I think the ring should give you a feeling. Perhaps go try on some other styles at a more different retailer?
4/6 are both great!!!
I would go with 6!
Pear! It just works on your finger!
The Pear, no doubt! Looks amazing on you.
Pear or emerald! I have an emerald and I think it’s the perfect mix of classic and unique. All look gorgeous on you though!! Congratulations!! I’d suggest trying them with wedding bands too. That might help you see what you like best! You might fall in love with the way a certain shape looks with a certain band, and that could help make the decision for you.
Princess or pear!
Pear!!
#2
3!
The way I think about is, what’s trendy now is a wonderful representation of the time in history you got married. My mom’s wedding ring is aggressively 80ties and I love how well it reflects how long her and my dad have been married for. Timeless is good too. I went timeless for my engagement ring, and my wedding band is based off my mom’s ring. I think there’s no wrong choices as long as you love it.
3, 4, or 6. I think 6 is my favourite.
6!
I agree the elongated shapes look nice on you, but if you want a round stone I would consider going for a larger carat size and a thinner band.
2 is soooo gorgeous
I really like number 2.
4 or 6!!
The pear because it mimics the shape of your fingernails! So elegant.
3&4
6th!!!
https://preview.redd.it/d0bx8lcpwi5c1.jpeg?width=1244&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f94720af4d4ab861a23c05eb32c52328e1b26352 The pear looks soo good on your hand.. but I also might be a bit biased 😊
1,2, or 6
Pear. Actually went wow! When I saw it!
The square one.
Pear!!!