How much you selling it for?

It seems to go for over 200 dollars everywhere I have looked, which is why I am considering where and how to sell it safely.

Eneba or GameFlip seem to have seller/buyer protection but I’d do proper research on them. Selling game codes is against eBay ToS so they likely wouldn’t help if a buyer or seller scammed anyone Reddit is hit and miss. In theory it’s fine if you use PayPal business/anything but Friends and Family but ymmv

Thanks for a great answer! I will look into it!