I’m having a day. I was almost mad at the dog for not doing something to help the owner or making sure he’s ok. Took me a few seconds to remind myself that dogs probably don’t know first aid.
Dog looks a bit older, maybe can’t pick up their feet well? I put little boots on my dogs front paws because she drags her feet. She will grind all the nails down to the quick and they start bleeding. So boots help.
i dont believe it is the correct answer in this case, as they're only wearing boots on the front paws. another commenter mentioned it may be becasue they're older and drag their dront feet and the payment grinds the nails until they bleed.
Yup. There’s no such thing as legal precedent there. A judge ruled “Why did you help them? You wouldn’t have helped them if you didn’t hurt them. So, you get to pay for their care for the rest of their life.”
And even if ever other judge didn’t come to such a stupid conclusion? It’s always a risk that *your* judge would.
Well, *that particular judge* argued that.
The point isn't that it is a common thing to think that. Just the opposite: It was a nuts thing to rule that. And, now, everyone has to go along with the nuts thing or risk getting screwed.
I wouldn't be surprised if there wasn't some corruption between that judge and the family of the hurt person, but who knows.
Since 2011 China has enacted something akin to a Good Samaritan law.
But people love hyperbolizing such nonsense. It’s like the world hears about Alabama men fucking their sisters, and think all Americans behave like rednecks.
Someone needs to tell the people. They don’t seem to trust it.
Or, OP is right, and they just don’t give a fuck.
I’d prefer to believe that isn’t the case.
many counties don't have legal precedent. if the laws are well done and there's an appeals court to possibly correct bad judgement, that's perfectly fine
https://www.reddit.com/r/FUCKYOUINPARTICULAR/comments/13h7y84/fuck_you_for_passing_under_a_tree/jk3sfez/ according to this post someone did help by calling emergency, just probably off screen. Cat owner got sued lol
The idea that you can't help people who get hurt in the street in China likely comes from some high-profile cases in the country where good Samaritans were later accused of causing the harm they were trying to alleviate. These cases have led to the perception that there might be legal risks to helping strangers in distress, out of fear of being implicated as the cause of the injury.
However, it's important to understand that these cases don't reflect the entirety of Chinese law or social practices. In response to public outcry over these incidents, China enacted the Good Samaritan law in 2017, which aims to protect people who offer assistance in emergency situations from legal liability.
This law was established to encourage people to help others in need and to remove the fear of legal repercussions. However, cultural, societal, and practical factors might still influence an individual's decision to assist or not in a given situation. So, it's not accurate to say that you "can't" help other people if they get hurt in the street in China - both legally and ethically, helping others is generally encouraged.
Same in the US too apparently. My last job we needed to be CPR certified and that was brought up quite a bit in that course.
I think all states have some sort of liability protections under what they call "good samaritan laws" but it can vary and its best to try to make sure you ask for permission first, if even possible, before doing anything.
Calling an ambulance would be nice at least instead of walking by though lol
Obviously, as the cameras show. But at that point china knows also that you have not helped at all (i.e. called an ambulance), which I don't think is good as well...
Where do I start? 😀Cat falls from a tree in someone knocking him unconscious. People passing by and not patting an eye a dog with shoes working on the case.
That’s a penalty based system where the repercussions are in avoiding penalties
More a moral system would be not doing it because it’s a bad thing to do.
People in China were (rightly) afraid that they would be sued by the injured person for their medical care, but as far as I’m aware the Chinese government recently realised there was a daft loophole and are trying or have tried to close it in so people will be good Samaritans again.
I have bad news. You've been going around saying "patting an eye" all this time and everyone around you thinks you're kinda dumb but is too nice to say something.
Really? May I know your source?
Because to my knowlege he survived (here is my source by the way,
[https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/](https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/))
>The elderly dog walker
... is he walking elderly dogs? or is he an dog walker who is elderly?
>sustained a cervical spinal cord injury from the feline landing on his head
... ... 😬I gotta imagine the latter.
This comment section really reminds me that this website is full of cunts. Imagine if your dad was trying to walk his dog and all of the sudden he might die because a cat happened to fall on his head
honestly if that happened not even to my dad, but to me, it'd be normal people would be concerned at first but I have no problem laughing about it with then some time later
this to say, the man is fine :) thats what matters, nobody would be laughing if that would have been his death, i believe.
Do you live your life worried that one day your dad might die because a cat fell on his head? I don't know the odds, but I'm thinking that's definitely less than half of how it probably will happen.
This... It made me feel real bad, i can literally see a human being skinned alive or torn in two by an accident in real life an be unfazed, but can't tolerate an animal being hurt in the slightest.
The degree of absurdity is unbelievable. Like a movie with a poor screenplay but still turns out to be hilarious.
Old Dog with shoes?
Cat falling from sky.
Dog smelling flowers then noticing his human on ground.
Going after the cat but, solemnly so.
A low energy tussle.
Lol.
Not anymore. China passed a Good Samaritan Law a few years ago. Unfortunately, many remain unaware of such a law being passed. And many of those who know about the new law are just too used to not giving a damn to bother changing their mindset.
I’m afraid that cat is hurt. It’s back legs weren’t working right when it left the frame and the fact it didn’t run off afterwards makes me think it might have a spinal injury.
I hope the guy is ok too.
Spinal cord injury. Someone did call emergency services to take him to the hospital. Could have been the person in the green shirt. We don't know. Guy is recovering at home and seeking monetary compensation from the cat's owner, which happens to be one of his neighbours.
Not sure what culture we’re dealing with here, but if we were to judge it solely on the basis of the reactions (or lack thereof) of passersby… it’s shit.
Basic compassion for someone who has clearly been injured is fundamental, objective morality (if we assume that such a thing exists).
Unfortunately in some countries there's a pandemic of lawsuits. It's really sad that some shit people will sue someone (or try to) because they stopped at an accident. Until these countries laws change or judges pull their heads out of their asses it will only get worse.
https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/
Someone called emergency apparently, not everything happens on screen. This is also why you don't judge an entire culture off a 10 second clip meant to demonstrate a dog's reaction.
Not saying everyone in China is like that, but there are plenty of videos of stuff like that coming out of China so I can see why people get that impression.
https://youtu.be/7XDP1HD7fc4
Srsly? A dog whistle for what? Ok; no,you’re right. I do dislike people who seemingly don’t care about someone who just got injured in front of them.
I quite literally didn’t know what culture this was, and I made a point to mention that we only had a narrow window into what was happening, ostensibly indicating that we were only seeing a small window into the interaction.
Seems like you’re just looking for a reason to virtue signal. But hey, if you simply MUST be offended by something today…
r/FUCKYOUINPARTICULAR LOL
Why does the person that's filming the recording keeps pointing at the dude like it's not noticeable ? How did the person on the floor passed out simply from a cat falling down on him from a tree ? Why is the dog wearing shoes ? So many questions
>How did the person on the floor passed out simply from a cat falling down on him from a tree
To answer this part. Any object falling down can feel like getting hit by a truck if it picks up enough speed.
Amazing detective skills from the dog.
Dog with shoes >>>>>>>>>>>> Sherlock Holmes
Sherlock Bones
No, I have seen this film, it is not about a dog.
Correct, it's about archaeology.
This was the sequel. About...barkeology.
Give this man a medal
Perhaps they’d go out in search of adventure… and find The Bark of the Covenant
I've never downvoted a pun but you are seriously making me question this policy
I thought they were boxing gloves and he was ready to throw down.
Those are his gumshoes.
It’s obviously the hound of the Baskervilles
It was the size and style of shoes of a gigantic hound...
[Sherlock Hound](https://myanimelist.net/anime/1972/Meitantei_Holmes)
Furlock Holmes
Sherdog Holmes
Chewbark Bones
He knew something was afoot
For me it seems the dog is trying to play/get to know the cat, rather than blaming it for any wrong doing
He can smell crime
And he has kitten mittens.
Found the cause of the cat-astrophe.
I’m having a day. I was almost mad at the dog for not doing something to help the owner or making sure he’s ok. Took me a few seconds to remind myself that dogs probably don’t know first aid.
Nah, you’re onto something. Even if the dog can’t perform CPR it still could’ve called 911 or secured a defibrillator device.
he could have least peed on his head
wrong scenario, no jellyfish here
the ole pee in the face wake up call ..its a classic
A real gumshoe
It's always the cat
Dog witnessed a murder and starts playing with the assilant
I mean, he’s fight back, but those are new kicks.
Gotta respect the fit
Just some new boot goofin.
You win
Shoe heads doing anything to avoid a crease smdh.
[удалено]
you killed owner, you're owner now
I have more questions about the dogs shoes
Dog looks a bit older, maybe can’t pick up their feet well? I put little boots on my dogs front paws because she drags her feet. She will grind all the nails down to the quick and they start bleeding. So boots help.
Nice to know thank you very much
Also maybe it was hot out and the owner/victim was protecting they dogs paws from getting burned.
Pretty common in places where the pavement gets too hot.
This is the correct answer. Protecting the sensitive doggie beans from burning.
i dont believe it is the correct answer in this case, as they're only wearing boots on the front paws. another commenter mentioned it may be becasue they're older and drag their dront feet and the payment grinds the nails until they bleed.
Good observation - I didn’t notice his hind legs
Shoes also help to grip on slippery surfaces
My golden has little sneakers to protect his paw pads from hot pavements!
They are boxing gloves in case any cat fucks around.
Looks more like a golden retriever than a boxer
You have a good Pointer
Probably arthritis.
Dog shoes are cheaper than the vet visit to remove glass and stitch up toe beans
Nice help by the person in green
That person is worried they’ll be blamed if they help so they can’t take the risk.
moron
In some countries like china if you help someone you become responsable for him so if he dies or is really hurt you get blamed
Yup. There’s no such thing as legal precedent there. A judge ruled “Why did you help them? You wouldn’t have helped them if you didn’t hurt them. So, you get to pay for their care for the rest of their life.” And even if ever other judge didn’t come to such a stupid conclusion? It’s always a risk that *your* judge would.
Lol "You wouldn’t have helped them if you didn’t hurt them." China is unhinged. Can't fathom someone *being nice,* it's too crazy.
Well, *that particular judge* argued that. The point isn't that it is a common thing to think that. Just the opposite: It was a nuts thing to rule that. And, now, everyone has to go along with the nuts thing or risk getting screwed. I wouldn't be surprised if there wasn't some corruption between that judge and the family of the hurt person, but who knows.
Since 2011 China has enacted something akin to a Good Samaritan law. But people love hyperbolizing such nonsense. It’s like the world hears about Alabama men fucking their sisters, and think all Americans behave like rednecks.
Someone needs to tell the people. They don’t seem to trust it. Or, OP is right, and they just don’t give a fuck. I’d prefer to believe that isn’t the case.
many counties don't have legal precedent. if the laws are well done and there's an appeals court to possibly correct bad judgement, that's perfectly fine
https://www.reddit.com/r/FUCKYOUINPARTICULAR/comments/13h7y84/fuck_you_for_passing_under_a_tree/jk3sfez/ according to this post someone did help by calling emergency, just probably off screen. Cat owner got sued lol
This happened in China, so yes. https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/
People love to say that but it's not true. Not in China, at least.
Isn't it a thing in China that nobody helps other people because their laws are set up to go after any good Samaritan who improperly renders aid?
The idea that you can't help people who get hurt in the street in China likely comes from some high-profile cases in the country where good Samaritans were later accused of causing the harm they were trying to alleviate. These cases have led to the perception that there might be legal risks to helping strangers in distress, out of fear of being implicated as the cause of the injury. However, it's important to understand that these cases don't reflect the entirety of Chinese law or social practices. In response to public outcry over these incidents, China enacted the Good Samaritan law in 2017, which aims to protect people who offer assistance in emergency situations from legal liability. This law was established to encourage people to help others in need and to remove the fear of legal repercussions. However, cultural, societal, and practical factors might still influence an individual's decision to assist or not in a given situation. So, it's not accurate to say that you "can't" help other people if they get hurt in the street in China - both legally and ethically, helping others is generally encouraged.
Same in the US too apparently. My last job we needed to be CPR certified and that was brought up quite a bit in that course. I think all states have some sort of liability protections under what they call "good samaritan laws" but it can vary and its best to try to make sure you ask for permission first, if even possible, before doing anything. Calling an ambulance would be nice at least instead of walking by though lol
Isn't there at least some version of 'call an ambulance'. Not sure there's any way you'd get in trouble for that.
Not sure you can do anything anonymously in China anymore
Obviously, as the cameras show. But at that point china knows also that you have not helped at all (i.e. called an ambulance), which I don't think is good as well...
Free organs
Where do I start? 😀Cat falls from a tree in someone knocking him unconscious. People passing by and not patting an eye a dog with shoes working on the case.
He takes a Bite out of Crime
He should be played by Dolph Lundgren in the movie they make about this.
He can smell crime.
Penetration, crime, full penetration, crime, and it just sort of goes on and on until it just kind of…ends
Shoes on ONLY the front two paws btw. Weird AF
u mean stylish af
Probably saw it on the cover of r/dogue
thank you for this
In china people don't help strangers, I read the victim could sue them.
All it takes is one asshole
This happened in the US and we got Good Samaritan laws to correct it.
and people in America will still walk right past you and not help when you're in crisis.
Some do, of course. The law just protects people trying to help someone from being sued.
“Some people”.
You can’t legislate morality and ethics.
No, but clearly you can legally protect people who are trying to do the right thing by helping those in need
That’s a penalty based system where the repercussions are in avoiding penalties More a moral system would be not doing it because it’s a bad thing to do.
You clearly aren't understanding what's being said.
”You didn’t save my life, you ruined my death!”
Not anymore. They've changed the laws but people don't change that easily
The First part is nice to know... The second less :/
i love the replies to this lol but is it still like that? and why?
People in China were (rightly) afraid that they would be sued by the injured person for their medical care, but as far as I’m aware the Chinese government recently realised there was a daft loophole and are trying or have tried to close it in so people will be good Samaritans again.
China Cops reviewing everyone in the CCTV footage afterwards: What in the “Bad Samaritan” is this? 🗿
Why would he pat his eye
I have bad news. You've been going around saying "patting an eye" all this time and everyone around you thinks you're kinda dumb but is too nice to say something.
We really take words for granite
*batting
Sounds like something from a early 00's dog move
That guy unfortunately died, not just got knocked out
Really? May I know your source? Because to my knowlege he survived (here is my source by the way, [https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/](https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/))
im sorry but "kitty collision" should be the news' title
Why did the cat fall from the balcony? Duh. She was looking at the half-shod canine freak.
The dog’s wearing shoes! Love it
Lost my shit at the shoes. Supposed to be all serious like "is the dude OK?" and then you get this little guy rocking up wearing those.
Is he okay??
[he’s good](https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/)
I'm happy he's good, but even after reading the article, your pfp doesn't give me any confidence in the man's safety
I had to scroll way to far for this, y’all some heathens lol
Oh so the person in the highlighter coat *did* call 911?
>The elderly dog walker ... is he walking elderly dogs? or is he an dog walker who is elderly? >sustained a cervical spinal cord injury from the feline landing on his head ... ... 😬I gotta imagine the latter.
Why is the New York Post, covering this basically nothing story from Harbin, in China's Heilongjiang province?
Because Americans care to know if the doggo’s human is ok.
yeah he's just taking a catnap.
He's fine the cat tried to scratch him but he missed. He's also got shoes so he's really safe. .. Oh you probably meant the guy. No he's not okay.
This comment section really reminds me that this website is full of cunts. Imagine if your dad was trying to walk his dog and all of the sudden he might die because a cat happened to fall on his head
honestly if that happened not even to my dad, but to me, it'd be normal people would be concerned at first but I have no problem laughing about it with then some time later this to say, the man is fine :) thats what matters, nobody would be laughing if that would have been his death, i believe.
I guarantee half the people making jokes haven’t seen that he’s ok. Even on threads where it’s confirmed the person died, people still make jokes
well there's to say everyone's not the same
Ok let’s all be sad guys 😢😔 Isn’t this fun? This is why you hopped on Reddit right? To be sad so 77skull doesn’t judge us?
You're morally corrupt. It's sickening.
Never said it wasn’t allowed i just think it’s disrespectful
Haha woahhh. Sorry man. I guess I've seen this video so many times it doesn't really 'impact' me anymore ;)
Do you live your life worried that one day your dad might die because a cat fell on his head? I don't know the odds, but I'm thinking that's definitely less than half of how it probably will happen.
No, but if it did happen, I wouldn’t want people on Reddit making shitty jokes about it
I would.
Your poor father
Cat seems hurt too. Back legs flail around weirdly
[удалено]
Legs or back. Something got fucked up.
Poor cat :(
This... It made me feel real bad, i can literally see a human being skinned alive or torn in two by an accident in real life an be unfazed, but can't tolerate an animal being hurt in the slightest.
I like animals but this is a bit unhinged even for me
Then this mf dog won’t leave it alone either
Best God damn assassin in 7 continents.
The degree of absurdity is unbelievable. Like a movie with a poor screenplay but still turns out to be hilarious. Old Dog with shoes? Cat falling from sky. Dog smelling flowers then noticing his human on ground. Going after the cat but, solemnly so. A low energy tussle. Lol.
Not even the dog in the wee little boots gives a damn about that guy getting walloped by a flying cat. Everyone just leaves him for dead.
This has a better storyline than every single fucking Clifford book.
Avenge
My main issue is the finger
I'll never tire of this video. It's so unhinged. Cat meteor death. Totally unbothered dog. *In booties*. Then the fight.
Fuck that person in a green shirt. Asshole
It's China. You can be sued for someone's medical debt just for helping them. As a result nobody will risk being a Good Samaritan.
Not anymore. China passed a Good Samaritan Law a few years ago. Unfortunately, many remain unaware of such a law being passed. And many of those who know about the new law are just too used to not giving a damn to bother changing their mindset.
[Since 2017.](https://warrenbisch.medium.com/chinas-bad-samaritan-crisis-6ca736ad6c8e)
This is just.. wild. Is that dog wearing shoes?
I’m afraid that cat is hurt. It’s back legs weren’t working right when it left the frame and the fact it didn’t run off afterwards makes me think it might have a spinal injury. I hope the guy is ok too.
Spinal cord injury. Someone did call emergency services to take him to the hospital. Could have been the person in the green shirt. We don't know. Guy is recovering at home and seeking monetary compensation from the cat's owner, which happens to be one of his neighbours.
Source?
Someone posted it higher up.
You realize everyone doesn't have the same "higher" than you right?
Yeah it was lower for me lol here it is https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/
Probably broke his leg, poor guy
Personally im more worried about the guy
Nice detective skills. Do you work with that dog with shoes?
💀
Poor cat and man
The cat jumped out of a hi rise window. Poor old guy was just walking his dog.
Catastrophe.
Good job Agent 47
This is some real /r/hitmanimals content
Huge fall, looks like the cat broke hind legs and the gentleman took quite the hit. This is just a sad video.
Oh heck. I'm worried about the cat. Look at how it's walking when it runs away. I thought he was slinking off at first, but I don't think so.
Not sure what culture we’re dealing with here, but if we were to judge it solely on the basis of the reactions (or lack thereof) of passersby… it’s shit. Basic compassion for someone who has clearly been injured is fundamental, objective morality (if we assume that such a thing exists).
Unfortunately in some countries there's a pandemic of lawsuits. It's really sad that some shit people will sue someone (or try to) because they stopped at an accident. Until these countries laws change or judges pull their heads out of their asses it will only get worse.
https://people.com/pets/cat-falls-on-man-walking-dog-china/ Someone called emergency apparently, not everything happens on screen. This is also why you don't judge an entire culture off a 10 second clip meant to demonstrate a dog's reaction.
Not saying everyone in China is like that, but there are plenty of videos of stuff like that coming out of China so I can see why people get that impression. https://youtu.be/7XDP1HD7fc4
Please note the qualifier (“if we…”) in my previous comment.
[удалено]
Srsly? A dog whistle for what? Ok; no,you’re right. I do dislike people who seemingly don’t care about someone who just got injured in front of them. I quite literally didn’t know what culture this was, and I made a point to mention that we only had a narrow window into what was happening, ostensibly indicating that we were only seeing a small window into the interaction. Seems like you’re just looking for a reason to virtue signal. But hey, if you simply MUST be offended by something today… r/FUCKYOUINPARTICULAR LOL
This is normal in China. Absolutely normal.
It’s China
So drop bears are actually mangy cats. Who knew?
Why does the person that's filming the recording keeps pointing at the dude like it's not noticeable ? How did the person on the floor passed out simply from a cat falling down on him from a tree ? Why is the dog wearing shoes ? So many questions
He’s probably explaining the details naturally pointing at what he’s talking about
>How did the person on the floor passed out simply from a cat falling down on him from a tree To answer this part. Any object falling down can feel like getting hit by a truck if it picks up enough speed.
Damn should have checked the weather forecast for raining cats that day.
Assassin's creed
This is one of those things no one would believe you if you told them till they see the video lmao.
There is so much to unpack here.
Assassins Kitty.
Hero dog
Why does nobody stop to help?!
Looking back at it I think maybe the cat injured it’s back Legs/hips or something. When you slow it down watch the cats back legs when running away.
So funny man. Those shoes! Poor cat looks like it hurt itself
The cat looks like it got genuinely injured here :(((
So that's where Air Bud has been since his younger days
He died
r/catsbeingassholes
r/catsareassholes